Skip to content
TT020 - Community-centered Infrastructure Planning episode artwork

Apr 21, 2022 47 min

TT020 - Community-centered Infrastructure Planning

from Tap Talk Hosted by Illinois State Water Survey

How do we solve the most difficult water infrastructure problems? It requires a more nuanced approach to trust-building and a proactive perspective on the challenges still to come. In this episode we're chatting with CAPT David Harvey about what we can all learn about problem solving in rural communities from the Indian Health Service. Visit drinkingwaterpodcast.org to learn more and find the full show notes for this episode!

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

TT020 - Community-centered Infrastructure Planning

0:00 47:13
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

The model of the Indian Health Service has in kind of putting technical assistance in the communities that they're tending to support is a model that should be closely examined when trying to figure out how to identify the magnitude of the water access gap and what the solutions are to close it. You're listening to Tap Talk, the Drinking Water in Rural America podcast. We believe everyone has a role to play in protecting public health. And together, we're connecting water and health professionals with ideas to extend and enhance our work. Whether you operate, educate, or regulate, this show is for you. Welcome to Episode 20.

In this episode, we're chatting with Captain David Harvey about what we can all learn about problem solving in rural communities from the Indian Health Service. We discuss how solving the most difficult water infrastructure problems requires a more nuanced approach to trust building and a proactive perspective on the challenges still to come. Please note that Captain Harvey's words are his own and do not constitute official statements from the U.S. Public Health Service or the Indian Health Service. Dave, thanks for being with us. We have Dave Harvey with Indian Health Service with us today, and we really appreciate you being here. You work a lot with tribal infrastructure, I understand. And so I guess, really, if you just want to give us a brief overview of kind of what your role is and the work you do.

Yeah, hey, Steve and Jennifer, I want to thank you for inviting me here to your podcast. I've been a fan since it started, so I'm real excited to be joining you here today. Yeah, my name is David Harvey, and I work in water, and I've worked in the federal government for about, I'd say about 20 years or so, both within the Indian Health Service and at the EPA, where I met Jennifer early on in her career, in the mid part of my career. Um, I've also worked in water in the private sector, um, both in engineering consulting and, uh, with equipment manufacturers in water. So you can say that I've, uh, I've been a part of, uh, pretty much every, I'm going to say every aspect of the water industry. Um, and so, you know, I think it, as you get further on in my career, I find myself relying more upon the experiences that I've learned earlier in my career to help to guide my, my, uh, my work going forward. But, uh, yeah, that's where I come from. And that's, uh, you know, what I've been doing. What do you love about working in water? Like what's kept you in it for 20 years?

Well, you know, water is an essential need. We can't live without it. And I've always kind of felt a need to be able to use my skills to help people to improve their livelihoods and their living conditions. And so kind of being that altruistic kind of high-minded kind of professional, you know, I found myself moving from private sector into public sector, feeling that I was going to be able to achieve more of those goals. So I think being able to impact people's lives through water is an important thing for me. And that's kind of what's kept me driving and pushing forward.

It's awesome. I think we emphasize to you for sure on that particular issue. So before we get started, we always ask a couple kind of different questions. And one of them is tell us one personal fun fact about you that no one's going to know or very few people know. Well, you know, I played the trumpet quite a long time from like the middle school right on through to like the University of Maine marching band and also in the University of Connecticut marching band. And, you know, I didn't ever thought I would really find those skills being helpful in any other part of my career. But I still haven't.

One thing that most people don't know about me is that I was the 2018 champion of the conch shell blowing contest down in Key West. I was the most musical at the Schooner Wharf Bar and Grill. And if you Google Dave Harvey Key West, you'll see a picture of me in the winning conch shell and with my daughter there as well. So that's a fun fact. Not included on my CV. Maybe I should. It'll show a little bit more breadth and diversity. And it could be maybe a benefit in my future.

I'm disappointed that I did not know this before because we just went to Key West and we could have gone to the bar and looked for the picture. You could have gone to the bar and the stage is still set up there. I don't think they have the picture in the bar. They have the picture on their website. But, you know, it is a factor. It's indexed in Google. So hence, it therefore exists. That is awesome. We also want to ask our guests about their influences in terms of professionals who have guided their work personally or someone they've just admired from afar. So who is your water hero?

Well, you know, early on in my career, I worked in the Candybunk Port Wells Water District. And I was like the, I painted the fire hydrants and chipped off the lead paint, probably. I don't know if it was lead paint at the time. And then painted the hydrants. And I got introduced to the water through that world. We did hydrant flow testing and kind of like understanding hydraulics at an early age. And Norm Labby, who is the current.

You know, I guess superintendent of the Kennebunk Water District to this day is kind of like a, you know, my early mentor. I didn't really view him as that, but he's an early mentor. And then later on in my career, I have Anna Navas-Asien, who is my advisor from John Hopkins when I was doing my master of public health. She's now at Columbia. She helped me to kind of really understand, you know, how engineering impacts public health and how public health.

can be, how engineers can add to public health and be kind of really an important contributor to that field. And so, and she's a medical doctor, but she saw value in the work that I've done and I see value in the work that she's done. I think it's been great to have guidance from her and help me to kind of see the broader impact of the work that I'm doing. That's awesome. I think that just makes you underscores that you're a great guest for this podcast because that's exactly what we're trying to do here is to make sure that those worlds and those communities are connected and can continue to understand those benefits and how we can support one another.

Yeah, that's great. I mean, public health and engineering are one and the same, and I would have never thought that initially studying engineering and going into engineering, that wasn't even close to being on my radar screen. Yeah, it is now. Well, and that's really what we're going to talk about today. And, you know, as a lot of engineers obviously aren't in the public health sector or don't realize that they are as much in the public health sector as they are. So I'm sure you've run across professionals who really understand the engineering side, but really aren't as versed with public health. What advantages do you see for engineers that have public health experience and why should we all have those skills? Yeah, so I want to state, you know, first off, you know, engineering education is important and problem solving and engineering are important and they've moved society and technology and society forward. I think what kind of like makes...

public health important for engineers, especially if you want to be in a leadership role in a public health organization is that you would need to have some training in public health and view kind of a problem-solving paradigm that's kind of a little bit different than the engineering problem-solving paradigm. And, you know, in engineering, you kind of define the problem, you kind of list some solutions, and you evaluate those possible solutions, and then you kind of develop a plan to kind of deal with one of those solutions, and then you kind of check out on your plan. But it doesn't really – it can be done by one person in and of itself or a group of people.

But in problem health solving paradigm, it's a little bit more, it's broader. And it looks across, it tries to kind of determine, you know, what is the problem? How big is that problem? What are the, how does that problem exist within the world that we live? Like, you know, it's both biological and demographics and social and cultural aspects and political aspects. And so, you know, without kind of examining, trying to consider and examine some of those issues on the determinants of the problem, the solutions may be incorrect for these.

for the problem and they may not be adopted. And so, you know, this is what I've been saying more recently than not, but sort of working with some of the more disadvantaged communities is that the solutions that are kind of been proposed or have been proposed maybe are not fully accepted by the population. Maybe people haven't been asked if, you know, is this going to work or is that not going to work? Or why wouldn't this work? Or why would you use this in this way if it were provided to you? And so those kinds of questions appear to have not been asked in some situations. And as a result, you know, we...

There may be infrastructure credit that is being given for solutions that have been put out there that actually aren't solving the problem. And so being able to kind of know you have to ask those questions, ask those questions, and then really hear the responses to those questions and integrate them into an approach to try to solve the problem is very iterative and not as directive as many engineers would like. And hence, I believe some kind of like shy away from that. But if public health practitioners don't do that, then they run the risk of kind of arriving at a solution that meets their view of the problem and not the actual. view of the community. It really should be about the community. So this is kind of an offshoot. It wasn't, it's not on our list of questions, but I'm curious for those engineers who aren't going to be able to go back to school and get their MPH on top of their degree and their experience. What, what advice do you have for improving those collaborations and being able to see things a little bit differently? Yeah, right. You know, don't all of us have time to go back and do that. And I appreciate that, but you know, being open maybe to different ways of examining problems and kind of being open to maybe criticisms and critiques of solutions that.

maybe you or your group has put out there as a potential option, asking the hard questions like, does this make sense to you? And will this approach work for what your needs are? And being ready to kind of hear no or being ready to hear no answer, which I would interpret as being almost the equivalent of no. Because if you get no answer, that means you really haven't built the trust that you need with the community that you're reaching out to. And so hence, you really need to get down at that level of a trust building kind of relationship. So kind of understanding a little bit more of the...

Human dynamics associated with communication is what is important. And those are... you know, sometimes difficult traits to learn for engineers. You know, the old joke is like, you know, two engineers looking at their shoes and, you know, trying to introduce themselves. I don't remember it totally correctly because I'm not, I don't attribute that to myself, but the sense is that. And so, you know, being, I guess my short advice is like, be ready to be uncomfortable about the solutions that you're proposing and know that being uncomfortable about those solutions is okay. And that's just kind of a, that's kind of the essence of trying to arrive at a better solution.

And so if you're open to being uncomfortable about what you're proposing and being challenged, not on the technical merits, perhaps, but on the kind of like the bigger picture, why are you doing this or why are you doing this way? Then, you know, that could lead to better outcomes. So engineers are just analytical in a lot of cases. And there's a lot more to working with communities, especially. Is this where I get to remind everyone that I'm a geologist? Yes, that would be what you do now. We try not to let that bother us too much. So it's really clear that it's not just the technical issues and trust is such an important part of protecting public health and dealing with communities. You work particularly with tribes. What other skills are important when you're working with tribes?

Well, humility is one. It's like the key. I think it's a key point that, you know, you need to, and I don't know all the answers. I don't have all the answers for their community. And I can't come to a discussion knowing that. And especially I can't come to the discussion during the past two years when we've all been living in our basements, so to speak, you know, broadcasting these things. I mean, the work that I've been involved with over the last, since 2020 on the Navajo Nation associated with increasing water access through.

some connections to increasing the number of connections to pipe water systems that, that hauled water can be taken from has been developed primarily while I've been sitting in Rockville, Maryland with, with a group of, of professionals, tribal navigation, government leaders, federal government leaders, universities, nonprofits, that kind of has been able to kind of facilitate a collaboration that I would never have thought possible. But if we went in and said, we know the solution to this, hence let's, let's roll forward with it. Then that group would have never taken off. And. the project wouldn't have been as successful as it would have been. So, you know, being humble, being able to listen, and being able to develop consensus and collaboration around issues are really the key things that are kind of needed for really any public health intervention. But, you know, and in this case, the ones that I've done worked on water interventions.

You know, we tell people the same thing related to trying to work with private well owners. And honestly, is if you can include them and make them part of the discussion and make sure that, you know, they have a say, you have a lot better chance of reaching folks. And it sounds like that's a very similar message. So, yeah, so you do a lot with supporting tribal water and wastewater systems. You know, our water operator at work program really supports that as well. How does, you know, quote, being from the government slow things down or how's that a detriment? I mean, you talk about trust building. I'm sure that's makes things more difficult in some of those cases.

Yeah, well, I mean, I've not, personally, I've really never experienced, you know, are you really from the government and you're here to help? Because I've never really experienced that type of reaction to me personally when I've been involved in any kind of discussions with tribes or other communities on deployment. I've kind of been, you know, again, I try to go in there with the humility of understanding the issues and kind of like to try to bring, you know, offer the... Whoever I'm dealing with, my best advice that I have for them to be able to succeed. And I provide them with what I see as the problem, try to listen to them about what they see as the problem, offer them a solution that I feel is the best outcome for them. And sometimes that's not viewed for them as the best outcome. Let me take for an example. Working in Nevada, when I was working with the tribe out there, there was arsenic issues that were kind of extremely problematic. I mean, there were levels of arsenic that were 10 times the current MCL and such that there was a real urgency to get.

address this situation. The solution that was the best technical solution was probably interconnection with the larger community water system. It wasn't a tribal enterprise. It was the county system. That wasn't what the tribe wanted to do. They didn't feel that there was a lot of sovereignty issues associated with that decision, that approach. And it was not kind of in the cards. Now, I was not the one kind of within the organization to kind of decide that it was okay for the federal government to build an additional treatment plant to kind of deal with this issue. But that's what happened. But understanding, there had to be some understanding within my organization, at the time it was Indian Health Service, that that consideration had merits and values. And hence that that...

That was the approach that was going to be moved forward with. And that's the approach that was moved forward with. And the treatment plant has been online and is removing arsenic and protecting public health today. Now, you know, some people would say, hey, look, federal government wasted money by building another treatment plant over there when they could have connected in. So from a purely kind of economics discussion, yes, that's probably the correct statement. But from the kind of...

Probably the cultural place that the tribe is coming from, the desire for a more sovereign approach to dealing with problems themselves, that wasn't the correct place to go. So sometimes the advice that you did, and that then reframed my focus in on when you're trying to provide advice, that there are other considerations here rather than the cost-benefit analysis associated with the solution. So you said that you've never had that personal reaction to you, and I know others who have. So I'm curious if you think there's a different kind of relationship between IHS and the government and tribes because it is a government-to-government relationship versus state and federal entities and public water system. Yeah, I would say that the Indian Health Service is a great organization to work in if you want to try to impact public health at a local level. We have the organizations, the staff that are within the Indian Health Service, within the program that I work in, live.

in the communities that they're serving in nearby. And so they're, you know, de facto community members in there. We are kind of a local establishment within the community. They know where we are. We know we exist. And for the most part, we employ tribal members within our organization. And so we're viewed as kind of, I would say, part of the community. And so, you know, while there's some, you know, all these political issues associated with some decisions that may upset the, you know, kind of political leadership between tribes in the Indian Health Service.

At the base level, because of the field presence associated with the engineers and the diversity of the geographic locations, the agency has been able to build trust with tribal entities. And as a result, when we go and meet the tribes, it's not that we just go and meet them to present them with a solution after we've heard about the problem on the phone. We've actually been out there and collected the data in the field, collected it maybe in conjunction with the tribes, analyzed it in conjunction with the tribes, and then come together with a solution for them at the same time. So that's the way I carried out myself in working when I was in the field in the way that... I suggest that others, now I'm kind of in a leadership role now and I can't actually do anything, but I can suggest what I think is best, suggest how the work should be done. It seems like there's a lot to learn from that model elsewhere just because of building those trusted partnerships. Yeah, for sure. And there's a lot of tension in the country now about closing water access gaps in disadvantaged communities. And I've said to many of those parties who are kind of partitioned to that is that really the model of the Indian Health Service has in kind of putting technical assistance in the communities that they're tending to support.

is a model that should be closely examined when trying to figure out how to identify the magnitude of the water access gap and what the solutions are to close it. That's awesome. That's a great way to look at it, and it makes a lot of sense. Well, I know that a lot of this major investment infrastructure will be trying to wrap our brains around that challenge and how do we move forward. What do you see as some of the challenges in the next three to five years as we're facing unprecedented levels of money and change? Yeah, so the funding that's been provided to improve and close the water access gap on tribes is historical. And the Indian Health Service has never seen this level of project funding in the history of the agency.

And it's a real opportunity to try to get a head start on trying to close the water access gap as they exist in tribal communities. Now, there are challenges associated with that. The funding that's been provided kind of meets the total need that was reported a couple of years ago. Things still continue to age and to kind of degrade. And so there's going to be more need that's going to come on board.

Tribal communities continue to grow. And of course, as we understand more about the health effects of water contaminants, the regulations will probably be added in the future to mitigate those risks. So at the end of the road here, the need will still exist, but this will put a good down payment in it. Now, a little bit more nuts and bolts with ramping up, going from zero to 60 in the government from $200 million to $700 million a year. We're more like, I want to describe it like the Titanic. We're more like a big ship that's hopefully not going to crash, but it's going to be hard to turn the wheels as quickly. We're doing the best we can to try to increase the number of staff and change the way we increase the contracting opportunities that we have. So we're going forward with that. At the end of the day, one of the remaining challenges that will be is that the facilities that are going to be built are going to be transferred to the tribe. And the tribe is going to be responsible for operating and maintaining these facilities. And there are some challenges there with that model.

because of the socioeconomic conditions with many of these communities are solved, not just in tribal communities, but really many rural communities and also communities in urban areas where the model of rates and payments like that are problematic to ensure that the full public health benefits associated with the infrastructure that's being provided to deliver them are available. And so kind of having a better understanding of what those costs are and kind of what actions the federal government has in supporting them, I think is... going to be a challenge and going to be what the focus needs to be on moving forward. I mean, that's, you know, you and I talked years ago even about building. That's great. But O&M is where there's where the rubber meets the road, if you will, just because if you don't know how to manage it or there's not funding to operate it.

you know, what do you do? And so do you have any suggestions on any success stories there? Success stories. We love about success stories. I don't want to name names here. You asked me to name names. Well, listen, I mean, if you, the EPA has led the Tribal Infrastructure Task Force for a while, since I think the time when Jennifer and I were both back there at the agency, mid-2000s. And, you know, there have been...

If you go and look on their website, the EPA, the infrastructure task force there, there is a document about successes in kind of operation and maintenance activities. And it cites, you know, tribes that have the ability to, or any, in this case it's tribes, but I would say really any kind of, or any small community that has the ability to kind of leverage the cost of their water operations with other things, like, you know, selling natural gas, selling telephone service, or selling electricity, kind of bundling utilities in a way that you have those utilities that can be the revenue generating ones, so to speak, and those that can be the loss. the ones that are going to lose. So, you know, that's kind of one aspect of that that kind of came through under that discussion. I forgot about that document. Yeah, right. And then, you know, we also tried to, you know, basically, and you guys at the University of Illinois have helped us with this as well, the kind of connecting of technical assistance providers. So, like, you know, making sure that each technical assistance provider that's been kind of provided funding to support disadvantaged communities knows what each other are doing and tries to kind of, you know, facilitate communication between them.

who has the best skills in their toolbox to be able to support these communities and who doesn't. And so if you're kind of like in there, you know, like a doctor, if you're in there and, you know, you're like an orthopedic surgeon, you hear the guy's got the, you know, got a heart problem. You don't like try to like operate, you know, take care of the heart. You like refer that guy to an orthopedic, right? So kind of like that, being able to kind of know who the providers are and to kind of provide advice across, you know, to the community about, you know, where to go. If it's not you, it's them. And here's what it is. And then to be, you know, circle back and kind of make sure that everyone, you know, that your colleagues know that you're doing this, right? And that they kind of support that you're doing this. And so.

It's all about trying to develop a community to support the community. Sure. When we still maintain that contact manager, we contact everybody that's listed from all 14 different organizations and agencies once a year to find out if there's new staff or any of those things. So it's still available. I still continue to point people towards it as a tool to figure out who's doing what where. We will link that in the show notes for this episode as well as the case study document that you mentioned. One thing that's standing out to me is this is going to be the ultimate test of

has all this work that we've been doing on sustainability, both like the theoretical thought work and the education and the collaborations we've been setting up at all different levels. When there is finally funding, we've been complaining, yes, we have all these great things, but there's not enough money. Now that there's money, did we do enough to be ready for it? Well, there's money to build things, okay? That's what I'm saying. There's money to build things. There is not money to operate things. And I think there are reports out there that are kind of highlighting this need now. I think as the infrastructure dollars are spent, I think that this is going to become a clearer and clearer that it's just...

not the funding of pipes and putting in the ground that kind of makes sure that they can deliver the water that's needed. And so, you know, it's just going to have to hopefully, you know, become part of the national conversation with water. You know, the need for water is like, you know, oh, the ASE ranks our water at E minus. I don't know what is it, D plus or whatever. But it's so really what we need to have is a scorecard of the operation and maintenance capacities associated with the nation's water systems, for example. You know, the operation maintenance capacity of, you know, I would say.

In many, the communities that I've worked in, and they don't just include tribal, you know, it's not, it would rival the score that the ASEE has given the physical infrastructure. Well, that's a perfect circle back to what we talked about at the beginning, just that building the relationships and trust and asking the right questions, even if you're not going to like the answers, and it's going to be part of it. And that's, I would say, one of the things that we're going to need to be doing in the next three to five years is making sure that those, that little bit of slowness, that pause to ask the questions is going to need to happen. Yeah. Are you going to be able to afford this? And is this going to, you know, and this is going to fit within, you know, what you can do. And so, and that's hard for utilities to answer, right? Because they're in the point of like, well, we know this is what it's going to cost. And, you know, then, you know, what do we do? I mean, we have to now go to the council or the board and say, hey, time for this. And they're going to say, hey, no way or something. So, you know, what we need to do is it's really a broader conversation about the value of water and the value of water from public utilities supplying that to meet.

And that's, you know, the bottled water industry has a lot of money and a lot of marketing clout. And so, you know, trying to take that on, you know, to kind of convince consumers, you know, consumers that have disposable income to be able to kind of put some of that towards them. And then creating programs to ensure, help to ensure the gaps where needed to support kind of longer term operating maintenance for communities that can't afford it is kind of the balancing public policy act that will have to come about now. But that all starts with data, right? And I would say that the best, you know, the EPA does its needs assessment annually, or not annually, every four years, is it, I guess, maybe, where they update the drinking water needs assessment. And, you know, operation maintenance hasn't really been part of that picture, so to speak, you know, hasn't been. So, you know, maybe there needs to be a focus in on that. And to discuss, because if you don't know, all you just knew is anecdotally, oh, you can't afford it over here, you can't afford it over there. But does that add up to real numbers yet? I don't know.

And without definitive numbers, you can't get to the kind of historic investments that we've received in funding for pipes. So those numbers are based upon the industry's kind of... compilation of infrastructure needs. And we need a similar paradigm around the operation and maintenance aspect of things. You're going to try to capture data over time that shows kind of the needs. And it's through a methodology that's trusted and supported by many stakeholders, not just advocacy groups that are trying to solve the problem, but maybe not with the most rigorous of data. Well, there's certainly going to be some people that only look at the cost-benefit analysis. And there's going to be people who say, well, five years ago, we funded this giant infrastructure bill. And now we have people saying they can't run their systems. Why not? Well, that means we...

didn't frame the problem correctly to start with yes that's my exactly my point yes right and so the same thing happens uh well yeah i mean it's um You know, on one side, we're talking about disadvantaged communities where we start talking about percentages no more than three or 5% of your income and some of those things. Well, there are systems that just can't exist at that level. They don't have enough folks and all the incomes and the folks living there are too low to actually, it has to be 10 or 15% of their income. And so, you know, that's the hard solution that we still haven't. That would be Alaska to a T. Alaska. The challenges are most acute with costs, both for infrastructure and operation and maintenance in Alaska. Oh, I bet. Yeah.

permafrost and all that. I'm kind of bummed out now because I feel like we've been kind of asking the wrong question and counting the wrong things for a couple decades or so or more. Well, no, I don't think it's that. It can't be bummed out. I'm not bummed out. I am thrilled to be working within an agency right now that's going to be hoping to really buy down a problem that's been longstanding within the nation. And it's a real...

It's a great privilege to be doing that with the people that I've worked with over here. And yeah, but so what we don't want to do is kind of like, you know, think we're done, right? I mean, I think we're done. We need to kind of help to reframe the problem and start thinking about it in a different way. And so that's kind of where, you know, that's what I've been doing, you know, ever since I've been working over at the EPA and over at IHS thinking about this operation of maintenance challenge issues with, you know, tribal communities. But again, saying tribal communities, it's not, it's really many small communities. It's all small communities. The problems in tribal communities and rural communities.

with scale and cost. And these are kind of transcend racial boundaries. You said it earlier, and you've said it more than once, I think. If you look at it like it's a down payment, this is a big down payment. Now, whether we keep paying our bills or not or we get it paid off is really up to us to understand that we still have to do that every, you know, we can't just walk away from it. It's not totally paid off. Do you think the increasing requirements for asset management plans, regardless of how robust those are as a requirement of funding, are at least a baby step in the right direction towards making sure that...

We're thinking holistically. Yeah, yeah, right. I mean, I do. I mean, there are the carrot and stick approaches, right, to funding, you know, in order for you to get this money, you need to do these things. And so I set some of those up within the tribal drinking water guidance when I was over there. And, you know, now, you know, hopefully they've moved the needle a little bit in that direction. But, you know, it's, you know, asset management plans are important. They should be part of every utility's, you know, toolkit. And so you know what you have, know where it is, and know what condition it's in. Because if you don't.

you're kind of flying blind. And so, yes, I think making those requirements for funding is important, but also it's not just a requirement, making sure that people understand that it's not just a requirement. What's the rationale behind it and why do we really want you to do this? It's not just like a paperwork exercise. It's actually something that you should use to do. And that requires, in some communities, that requires training of their boards and of their elected leaders about, well, look, your water system didn't know kind of like how many tanks it has, how many pumps it has, or how old they were. They were only doing repair and replace type of approach. But through these tools,

that we're requiring of you for our grant or the loan that we're going to give you are going to provide you with a leg up for you board to ask questions of your utility to kind of help to move the conversation forward about the understanding of the current conditions and the ability of your systems to deliver water to your citizenry. And so trying to sell it in a way that kind of shows its value rather than just a bureaucratic requirement, those are usually rational and have an intended point. And if no one really understands that, then they do just become a hindrance. And so really it's upon everyone who's in the granting organization to know that, to be able to communicate that, and to be able to communicate that at varying levels within, not just to the utility who's filling out the grant, but to the to the board, to the leadership of the community about, you know, what are the kind of the key aspects of utility management that will improve, you know, the viability of your community, the economic viability and the public health of your community, really. I know USDA RD now requires with their loans that you have to depreciate at least one asset, or this was a couple of years ago. And I thought, wow, what a great idea. And getting back to your point, Jennifer, and the point I made earlier is like, you know, the need survey, the drinking EPA, our need survey could...

I guess I don't work for EPA, so I can say you really should include some aspects of these types of questions to try to baseline it and then to kind of like over time where it's going, you know, how old the pipes are in the ground. It's not just like we need pipes. Well, how old are the ones we got out there and what's coming down the path? So it's like it's more, it'll provide a better picture and rather than kind of all of a sudden, oh, stuff's broke, time to fix. This is the direction that we're going within the Indian Health Service is we've devised, we're developing a GIS inventory tool where we have a vision for, digitizing with tribal permission, all of the assets that have been kind of used, developed with Indian Health Service support. And then kind of then using that information to be able to facilitate designs and anticipate needs and also easily identify, more easily identified needs when you go into the field. So these tools that are indispensable really in utility aspects and they're really indispensable in public health programs like ours. And this year we're going to be recognized at the 2022

ESRI User Conference Award with a special assignment award for how great this is. And so we'll be out in San Diego to collect that thing. And that started with a vision paper that myself and a couple of colleagues put together that started moving the needle with the leadership of the program. Here's why we need to do it. Here's why it's important. And here's what we believe are going to add value to this program that's going to support tribes. And those were things that no one could

could say no to it was like yeah you're right you're right you're right and so you know what becomes difficult is the doing right is like how do we incorporate this and make changes to do it just like any utility or any any organization they have to do things differently collect things differently to get there and we're not moving as fast as i would hope because of covid and whatnot but we are moving in that direction and um And it's going to be a brave new world we get there because the Indian hustlers will be able to be proactive in knowing the conditions of the assets that are there, be able to support tribes with knowing where they should look to put investments both from the federal government or from themselves or other entities to support that infrastructure. But it just takes a vision first to begin to think about that.

the kind of putting it on paper to make sure that people understand why we're doing it. They don't forget why we're doing it when we're in the middle of it because you need to point people back when you're doing change. Remember why we did this? Let's go back and look what we signed here. This is why. It's not because it's an edict from the granting agency or it's an edict from headquarters or something. We all had common buy-in and kind of a vision on this. And you kind of remind people of that as you kind of move whatever you're trying to do through. But in this case with the GIS thing. So it's just, yeah, it's hard work. It's not easy, but organizational change or any change never is. That's for sure. Well, it's exciting to think about how technology.

And the ability to access data remotely and all of that has allowed us to start implementing those visions and answering some of the questions that we've had for a long time. And it's only going to get better from here in terms of being able to use data to make smarter choices. It's come a long way since CUPS, man. I think we can amp that thing up. It'd be CUPS like 10.0, right? I think right now, I don't know. But it's like a different, it's because the cost of this technology has been reduced and data collection in the field with the iPhone. We were out there on the Navajo collecting information with...

not even iPhones, phones that we bought at Walmart for like 10 bucks a piece that were out there with the GPS that were in there and we were taking quick pictures and being able to respond to the surveys on these really rudimentary phones to quickly get an indication of where we should put these water points and display it in kind of almost near real time. They're great for emergency response. And if they're great for emergency response, they're really good for just kind of operation your stuff day to day. Awesome. Well, this has included just so many points of wisdom that I think all of our listeners will be able to take away no matter what part of water they're working in. Are you on social media in any professional capacity? Would you like to share that with our listeners? Yeah, I'm in Twitter. I think it's environmental health ENG, environmental health ENG. I'll give you the link to it. That's fine. Yeah, I think that, yeah. So I'm there and that's where you can find me.

tweeting to my 33 users. So anyone can come on please more. All right. No, I have 77, I think it's today. I don't know. Anyway. LinkedIn, any of those things? I do have a LinkedIn profile, but I've not, I guess I, but I've not really like paid attention to it. I don't know if I probably should. It's hard to do all of those things. Right. Because I, so I have one because like people who I know are like coming into my feed and I'm like, I know them, I must have something in there, but I've never really gone back to look at mine. So mine could say like, you know, conch shell blower. That's it. I don't know. Say something else. I'm not sure. But we got the important stuff in there. Yeah. Right. Right.

Tap Talk is a collaboration between the Rural Community Assistance Partnership and the University of Illinois with funding from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. The show is hosted by Steve and Jennifer Wilson of the Illinois State Water Survey. You can visit drinkingwaterpodcast.org to find the full show notes for this episode.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Tap Talk?

This episode is 47 minutes long.

When was this Tap Talk episode published?

This episode was published on April 21, 2022.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Tap Talk episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.