So if we don't recognize that level of service, which is that public health protection and that quality of life, if we don't recognize that as what we're doing, we get off on these tangents and we're so much more worried about the physical stuff than we are the purpose of what we're trying to do. You're listening to Tap Talk, the Drinking Water in Rural America podcast. We believe everyone has a role to play in protecting public health. And together, we're connecting water and health professionals with ideas to extend and enhance our work. Whether you operate, educate, or regulate, this show is for you. Welcome to episode 24.
In this episode, the final episode of Season 2, we're chatting with Heather Himmelberger, a professional engineer and director of the Southwest Environmental Finance Center. Our conversation features the role of the EFC network, why water systems shouldn't be intimidated by asset management, and her mixed feelings about infrastructure spending. Heather, it's great to have you on our podcast. Thanks for joining us today. And I guess we'll start out with really where you work and what's your role. And I know we've known each other for a long time. Well, thanks for having me here today. And I work at the Southwest Environmental Finance Center, and we're located at the University of New Mexico.
And we're within the School of Engineering. There are lots of EFCs around located in all different kinds of parts of universities, but ours is located in the engineering school. But we have lots of people that work in, you know, lots of other kinds of professions and majors. So it's a pretty diverse group of people that way. And I am the director of the center and I've had that role since 1996. So it's been a long-term gig for me. So what do you love about the job? What has kept you in that position for so long? What has kept me there is just the freedom to really be able to help people the way they need to be helped. I don't feel like there's any boundaries put on what we're allowed to do and how we're allowed to do it. So when we don't have any profit motive type things where, you know, I used to be a private consultant and you had to think about what we're going to make money for the company and we don't have to do that. We can go out and do what we feel is necessary to help people. And sometimes it's those really tiny.
projects that end up being the most rewarding, the ones that only are bringing in a couple thousand dollars, but they're so rewarding because you've been able to help somebody, help them meet a need they have or solve a problem they have or better serve their customers. And so it's really those interactions with the people and the ability to help and try to improve things for the water utilities, wastewater utilities, stormwater utilities, or their customers. So just helping make communities better. And I just really love doing that. It's very, very rewarding. I totally agree. I tell people all the time, we run our programs like a nonprofit.
You know, really. And we don't care. We don't really get any money back from anyone. But when you get calls from well owners or from small utilities and you know you're getting them on the right path, it's pretty rewarding. That's cool. So we always ask everyone, we've got a wide range of answers, too, for this, which have been really cool. So what's one personal fun fact about you that we don't know? Well, I don't know if you know it or not, but one fun fact about me is that I've been to all 50 states multiple times each. So it's been at least four times each for almost every state.
Two exceptions, Nebraska and North Dakota, which I've only done twice. But every other state, it's been at least four or five times each. I've been to all the territories, most of them multiple times each too. And I've been to the tiniest of tiny places and the biggest of the biggest cities and all those places. And just to be able to see the country and see what an amazing place it is. And I've loved every place I've been. I mean, there are really special people and special places all over the country. And so it gives me hope that we can eventually unite again as a country, but I really just love seeing the country and meeting people and seeing new places.
And even old places. So it's really fun just being out and about. I have two left, Hawaii and Alaska. I have one left, Idaho. Idaho, okay. Yeah, I've actually been to Idaho many times. So it's one of those states and I've driven like the long way through Idaho. So I feel like I really earned that one. So we also like to ask our guests to share their water hero, someone past or present whose work you've admired.
So I will share someone, Dr. Abel Woolman. He is sort of the father or father, grandfather, whatever term you want to use of chlorination. So back in the early 1900s, he was working on how we come up with the dosage of chlorine and his advances working with his colleagues and his advances in chlorination is what really helped us to disinfect water and make it safe to drink and really improve life expectancy. One of the reasons I picked him is when I went to grad school with Johns Hopkins, he was there as a professor emeritus and he was in his nineties and he was still showing up every day, just about, if he wasn't on the lecture circuit, which he did a lot, he was of course in demand for speaking engagements, which he was still doing. He would show up on campus and he would be walking up the stairwell and I would run into him in the stairwell. And he literally was the most humble person you would ever want to meet. He would stop and talk to anybody. If you didn't know who he was, you would never have known that he was such a prominent, important figure. And we had a couple of events on campus that I got to go to with him and talk to him. I mean, you know, like.
All the students were there, but he was there and he would just talk to the students and he was so interested in what we were doing and what we were learning. And just the fact that you could be so important and so prominent in the field, but yet be so humble, so willing to, you know, share and learn from others. I just thought that was amazing. And I took that to heart is just like always be humble. Like it's so important and listening and learning that way is so important. So I've always found him to be one of my big heroes in environmental engineering is just because of what he did and who he was. I thought he was a really special person.
That's awesome. What an amazing story. Yeah, that's really awesome. Really cool guy. I can still picture him. He was a really tiny man. He was not very big and he would just be walking up the stairs and, hi, how are you? Kind of have a chit chat with him on stairwell because he usually likes to sit on the landing for, you know, stand on the landing for a little while before he kept going. You could have a little conversation with him. He's just an amazing person. Awesome.
It's interesting to think about how many people he connected with over the years. It had to be just an unbelievable number. His son ran the department. I was in the Department of Geography and Environmental Engineering. And so he had worked at the school for a long time. He, of course, had all this long career. All those students. I mean, it would have just been...
you know, just unbelievable numbers of people that he touched directly. And then indirectly, it'd be like all of us, because a lot of what he developed back in the day is still what we're doing today. So it's, you know, millions and millions and millions of people have disinfected safe water because of, you know, his work and the work of his colleagues. That's awesome. Very cool. Well, so, you know, today, obviously, with the Environmental Finance Centers, our topic is really about asset management and the work that they do. And so first off, could you tell us a little bit about the Environmental Finance Centers and really how they came to be and where they're at today? Sure. So the first Environmental Finance Center was actually at the University of New Mexico. So we were the...
Very first, back in 1992, I came in 94. So I missed the very, very beginning origins. And I always say that we must be successful because there's about six different origin stories of exactly how we came to be. And I figure that's because if we weren't successful, nobody would have said they had anything to do with it. But because they perceived us as successful, there's several different versions of the story of exactly how it came to be. But in general, it was an idea that EPA had. And there used to be a group called the Environmental Finance Team. And they were focused more on the money part, you know, the how to pay part.
And there had been a lot of, you know, in the early 90s, there was a lot of complaints from states that they were getting these unfunded mandates and EPA was telling them to do stuff, but they weren't giving them any money. So this environmental finance team was sort of tasked with, you know, how do you get the money in there so the states can do what they need to do and the systems can do what they need to do. So somewhere, you know, again, depending on whose origin story you believe, they came up with this idea of, hey, we could create these groups that could help the states, help systems and focus really on the finance side of all of this environmental stuff that we have to do. So environmental compliance, environmental infrastructure. So they decided to try it. And New Mexico was selected because there was an individual who was working in D.C. but had New Mexico connections. And they thought, OK, well, this is a way to start it. And they needed to put it somewhere that it was neutral. So the university idea kind of came to mind. And universities have lots of resources available to them. So they plopped this gentleman in the University of New Mexico. He was on a detail from EPA and decided to see what would happen. And the original EFC at UNM was working on public-private partnerships and a lot of border-related work.
And then they decided, well, that worked out pretty well. Let's do some more. So then they started to pop up in other universities. I think Maryland and Syracuse are the next two. And then they started getting the idea of, well, we should have one in every region. It took a little while to get there.
That was many years before they finally got one in every region. And then we kind of, as EFCs, decided in 2000 that we wanted to create the Environmental Finance Center Network. So the network of centers is kind of our creation. And we created bylaws and a memorandum of understanding between us that we all wanted to have a certain way to work together. We wanted to share and be able to be collaborative as opposed to being competitive with each other. So we try to avoid any situations where we're actually competing head to head with each other, but rather we're working collaboratively and performing teams. And so now we have a really long history of working together.
twos, threes, fours, fives, and even, you know, all of us together on projects. So it's a great collaboration, and I really love working with the folks at the other universities. And we intentionally decided we didn't want to be 10 of exactly the same things, so that you just put 10 similar centers across the country, because then you're kind of limiting the reach of the centers. So if we were all slightly different, then that gives you more ability to team up and say, well, I can bring this to the table, you bring that to the table, and then together we can do more. So each center, you know, has a slightly different skill set and project base.
expertise. So there's overlap in that we all kind of have this finance bent, but there's a lot of you know, dissimilarities so that we can team up and be stronger together. So we always say the whole is much greater than the sum of the parts because we do have those, you know, differing expertise. Well, I'm sure that helps kind of reduce the feeling of competition against each other since we're in the situation of constantly evolving funding. Yes. And it's just great because if there are things that one of us wants to do, like let's say way back in the day, Maryland had done a lot of work in stormwater, but not so much in asset management. So we kind of get together and like, okay, let's, I'll bring my asset management. You bring your stormwater. We'll create some stormwater asset management stuff. And then they can go off and run.
So now they're doing quite a bit in the stormwater asset management arena. So it's just ways of sort of bringing us together to, you know, share different expertise. Like, you know, we worked with Wichita State Center to do this CANCAP manual where it's a manual and a training program for capacity development. So we had pieces of that and wrote the manual. They did the videos and developed the training. So we were able to work together to create, you know, this really cool product. So just those opportunities to kind of work together and bring, you know, each person's strength to the table is a really good, you know, really good program. It works very, very well. Sounds like it.
When you're particularly known for your expertise in asset management, and that's how we first became acquainted, particularly the conversation around infrastructure development for compliance with the arsenic rule. And this particular show we're doing today has quite a diverse audience. We have both environmental health professionals as well as the drinking water community listening. So could you maybe go back to a little bit of basics and share what asset management is and why it's important? Sure. And this is, I'll kind of go back to why I was even interested in it as like the first step. And this would have been the early 2000s.
water and wastewater utilities were having a lot of issues of just trying to do the basics of the maintenance and, you know, how to keep the systems running and particularly in the small systems, but not exclusively. I mean, even bigger utilities were having trouble trying to keep the budgets for maintenance there. Because if you want to cut a budget, what's the easiest budget to cut? Maintenance. Because it seems like it doesn't matter. And for a short time, it doesn't. But then you start to have problems because assets are failing. And now how do we get them replaced? And how can we be smarter and not so reactive? Because so many utilities just reacted to every problem and they're not getting ahead of.
They're just like every day they're running around like, you know, chicken without their head because, you know, there's this new problem. Something else has failed. Something else has happened. And it just wasn't rational to just, you know, every day your day is kind of disrupted by all these, you know, events that are happening and you're not planning. And there's a lot of just, you know, lots of problems. So EPA had started some asset management trainings, you know, in the early 2000s, they brought some folks over from Australia to help train. And I went to one of those very early trainings and was sitting there listening and it was.
kind of a little bit like drinking off a fire hose. They were just throwing so many things out. But then this man from Australia said, hey, what this really is, is just thinking. And here's why this is important. And the more he talked, the more he was like, yes, this is what we need. We need a way to think about our assets. And at its core, it's just a different way to think and to ask yourself questions and try to think a little bit differently about what you're doing. So it really alerted me to like, hey, there is a different way. There is a better way to get this done.
And that better way is to really just get to the basics of what assets do you own? Because how do you manage anything if you don't know what those assets are? And so many systems, even today, don't know how many and what type of stuff they have. So how many pieces of pipe are in the ground and what size are they and what type are they? Where are your water meters? Where are all your valves? Where's each tank? What kind of pumps do you have? So just fundamentally knowing what assets you have allows you to better.
address those assets and manage those assets. So the first part of asset management is really just about learning what assets you have, just the basics, a little bit of information about them, what condition they're in, how much longer they're going to last. And that gives you a base of information to work from. And then the next part is really knowing what you want those assets to do. Because how do you, again, manage your assets if you don't know what you want them to do? And many, many utilities don't really think about that. Don't think about, well, what is it I'm actually trying to do? What are my goals with my system? How am I managing those assets to achieve those goals? And if I don't achieve them, what do I do about it?
And then we have to look at criticality, because if we don't think about our assets and which ones are critical and those assets fail, really bad things can happen. So criticality is all about looking at your assets and saying which ones are most likely to fail. And if they do fail, how bad is it? So those assets that are really likely to fail and it's really bad if they do, we better be thinking about them and addressing them in some way, because if the failure occurs, some really horrendous thing is going to happen. And then the next step is really looking at how are we going to operate, maintain, repair, replace our assets over time? So we have to think about these assets are going to be around most of them for a very long period of time. How do we make sure that we're doing the maintenance, we're doing it the right way at the right time to keep those assets in place? And then what are we doing about rehabilitating and replacing them over time? With the final part being the money, how are we going to have the money to run all of this, pay for all of this that we want to do? So it's really at its core, just a thought process. That's all it is. It's not anything more. You can do all kinds of fancy schmancy things.
But really at its core, it's just that thought process of what assets do I own? What do I want them to do? Which ones are most critical to doing that? How am I going to maintain them and operate, replace them over their entire life? And how am I going to pay for them? So if we can use that thinking process and not get so bogged down into, you know, what are the fancy computer tools you're going to use, but rather how are we going to keep the thinking going? That's the way more important part is the thought process of, you know, what is the best way to do this? And, you know, if we have this situation occurring over and over again, is there a way to prevent it rather than keep?
fixing something over and over again, can you improve it? Is there a different design you could use, a different asset you could use? So it's really just questioning yourself, why am I doing what I'm doing? Why am I doing it this way? Could I do it in a better way? That I think is the fundamental power of asset management is it gives you those tools and just kind of uses what you already know about your system, harnesses that to give you what you need to make a better future for yourself. Well, I think one of the things that you've imparted on me is the importance of level of service and really thinking about what you want your assets to do. Why is it so important to keep coming back to that aspect?
And I think the level of service is so important because we often forget that we're not in the business of managing assets. We are in the business of providing a service to the public. We are trying to protect public health. We're trying to give them water so they can live their lives. But we're not in the business of managing assets. If we could manage assets, if we could do it some other way, like if we could, you know, you just had to snap your fingers and water comes out of somewhere, we wouldn't even need pipes. Like we only do pipes because that's the way we figured out how to get water to somebody's house. So the fundamental thing we're doing.
is providing public health protection and providing a service so that your life can be better. It's way easier if you can flush your toilet in your house, if you can turn on the tap and water's coming out and you can drink it, you can cook with it, you can put clothes in the washing machine, you can take a shower, that type of stuff, we're making your life better. So the fundamental thing that a water utility is doing or a wastewater utility who's taking water away from your house, they're providing that public health protection, environmental protection, and quality of life. So everything else you do is meant to make sure that's happening. So if we don't recognize that level of service, which is that public health protection and that quality of life, if we don't recognize that as what we're doing, we get off on these tangents and we're so much more worried about the physical stuff than we are the purpose of what we're trying to do. So level of service is a way to focus you back on the purpose of what you're trying to do and really thinking through like, what do I want to give my customers? So we hope fundamentally you want to meet all the regulations that you have to meet. So that's like a key thing. But beyond that, what else do you want to do? So what kind of customer service do you want to have?
What type of response do you want to have when something goes wrong? So if a pipe break occurs, what is your response rate to that? If you're in a wastewater system and there are odor complaints, how do you deal with that? What do you do with backup? So it's really thinking through all the things you do. How do you want your service to the customers to be? And sometimes a utility has to acknowledge they can't do 24-7, 365 water. We have some very small utilities who have problems with droughts, and they can't do that. So it's even recognizing having that conversation with customers. If you can't do...
you know, best of class service all the time, what can you do? What is it that you're going to be able to provide your customers so that you can have a conversation around? This is what we're able to do with the money we have. So again, it also ties that money in because as you're increasing your levels of service, that can increase your cost. So if somebody wants, say, an aesthetic thing fix. So personally, I live in an area where the water does not taste very good. It's extremely salty. So I would love to pay a little bit more and have them take the salt out. But that's like a conversation you have to have with your customers. So we could remove the salt. There would be extra treatment that would have to take place. But now your customer, you know, you will have to pay $2 a month extra or something like that. So it's also a way to have conversations with customers around.
the level of service you're providing now and what would it take if you want to change that level of service, what would that take? Or are there some level of service goals you can back off a little bit because you need to put money somewhere else? So it's really about recognizing the customers as the most important part, focusing everything you do on that. So all of my actions are to make sure that I'm meeting what the customers want. And then when you have level of service goals, you have to make them measurable. And when you make them measurable, that sets up a conversation of what do I do if I don't meet them?
So now we can have a conversation around what is the reason that I'm not meeting that level of service goal? Do I need more staff? Do I need more equipment? Do I need training? Do I need resources? Is there something that's missing or is that goal not attainable? And we need to have a conversation around that. Like, okay, maybe that goal needs to be backed off on because maybe it's not an attainable goal. So maybe we have to think about, you know, what do we do differently? If we can't meet that goal, what should the goal be? So it's really, I think, fundamental. It's probably the most hated part of asset management in the United States.
Bar none. People don't like it. People are afraid of it. But I think it's super, super important because, again, it changes the focus to we are doing this for the customers. We manage assets only to meet what the customers need. And it's not the other way around. Oh, we're managing infrastructure. And by the way, customers will get service. No, customers get service. We manage assets to make sure that that happens.
I like how this process just adds specificity to the conversation. It's no longer just everything stinks and we don't have enough money. We can actually be really specific about what we need so that we can then communicate that to our boards, our customers, our funding opportunities, so that then we can be more effective with those funds and make better decisions. I was just going to say, that's actually why I liked it better because I sort of came out of the capacity development days, you know, in 96, EPA put capacity development into the Safe Drinking Water Act. And there were lots of attempts to build internal capacity, which is super, super important. I'm not knocking that at all. But it felt to me like the amoeba problem. Capacity was so big and so amorphous that you never really knew if you were...
making progress or not, because it was hard to measure. It wasn't specific enough. So you could work on one area, but maybe they still had capacity issues somewhere else. And it was a lot less defined, whereas asset management is a much more defined program. It's easier to tell if you're making progress or not. You can see tangible things that you can do. So I picture capacity being bigger than asset management. Asset management doesn't cover the entire realm of capacity, but it hits a lot of capacity development related things. And I think just that structure, that ability to say there is an actual program, there is something you can.
check. There are things you can look at. You can measure improvements that for me made it a little bit easier to work with utilities when you had something that was more defined as opposed to just kind of. again, doing the Amoeba thing where you need this and you need this and you need this. It just felt like a little bit too disjointed and a little bit harder to work with communities in that realm. So I feel like asset management gives you more structure and that sort of thing to work with people. It also, you know, by listening to your customers and making that the focus, you know, we always complain. We've always tried to find ways to help the public be more knowledgeable about water. And a lot of people have no idea. And we run into that all the time. And this is a really good way to, I don't want to say force you, but on both sides, your customers and.
the operators and everybody else to actually have a conversation and get more engaged. And it's an opportunity, I would say, to really educate your customers, which really has to happen. You know, we've all these big programs we've had over the years trying to help people understand water and what it takes and what it costs and why. And really, if it could be done at the utility level, it'd be so much more effective, I think. Yeah, I think it's like a triangle to me. So there's three points of the triangle. And one point is the leadership of the utility, whatever that leadership might be. Another point is all of the staff.
whether those are volunteers or paid staff. And the third part of that triangle is the customers. And it takes all three parts of the triangle to make it work because everybody needs everybody else. So you can't have leadership without anybody, you know, to lead. And if you're not doing it for your customers, why would you have leaders? You know, the staff needs the leaders to tell, you know, to give them the direction and make decisions, but they also need the customers to pay the bills and give them the money they need. They're also there to serve the customers. And, you know, of course, the customers need everybody in the water utility to get the public health protection and the service. So it's like so important that all three work together.
and you know it's kind of crazy how if water's not there right away, people are going to be complaining like, you know, a couple of hours of a water outage and, you know, people are up in arms about, Oh, you know, I can't take my shower. I can't cook. I can't do whatever, but yet we still have such a low value. You know, we'll pay so much more for, you know, like here's my cell phone and what I pay for my cell phone is so much more than what I pay for water. But I could live without my cell phone as much as, you know, I might try to pretend I couldn't, you know, if you took my cell phone away, I could actually live, you know, I would miss the water a whole lot more than I would miss my cell phone. But for some reason, we just don't have that.
that ability to get, you know, people to understand the value of water. I think because we've done such a good job of being in the background, you know, as a whole industry of water and wastewater, you know, on the one hand, I think, man, what a great, great job it has been for all those unsung heroes out there working in water and wastewater, where it's such a, in the background thing. Like you just know that if you turn the water on, the water is going to come out, you know, it's just so taken for granted that we don't have to value it higher because we've done such a good job of providing service. And for the most part, with some rare exceptions, you know, public health. is protected you know in most places we still have a little bit to go but you know you can feel pretty good as i travel the country i mentioned i travel over i don't think about it you know if i go to a hotel and i'm using the water at the hotel i don't think twice about it it's like i know it'll be okay and just that ability to um you know not have to worry about it has been great but on the other hand because we've been so behind the scenes and so kind of um you know left out of the the forefront I think it's also made it harder for people to see the value and the reason that they have to pay and you know why they get a water bill and you know why are you raising my rates and that sort of thing I think that's been harder for people to understand even though they'll pay so much more for water that you stick in a bottle you know they'll value that water but we haven't been great at valuing the water that comes out of the tap and I joke sometimes that if we could put like each drop of water in a little tiny plastic bottle and send it out the sink like maybe people would pay but you know just that idea of
You know, how do we get customers to understand the value of water so that they appreciate the service that they're getting? We still have some work to do in that area. And I think, you know, as you started that conversation with level service, that is a way to help improve that. And I have seen it firsthand in New Zealand where they've done some amazing work with trying to. to, as a whole country, trying to get customers to understand the value of the services they receive. And they have a very, very robust customer engagement process. It's not lip service. It is really, really a robust process. And they go through it every three years. They have to go through it with getting together with all their customers to talk about transportation needs and parks and libraries and municipal services and water and wastewater. And their customers really get engaged.
And as part of that process, they've been able to value their services a little bit higher because now customers understand these direct relationships between what they're paying and what they're getting. So I think we can get there. I just think it's going to be a... you know, long, slow process, but you know, it is very important. I've always joked that we should just have a national turn off the pumps day and every utility shut off their water for a day and we'll see how much people value their water then. Definitely. I thought of that too. It's like, wouldn't it be great if you could just say, do you miss me now? Yeah. I'm going to pay your bill now. No doubt. Like, you know, even if you could say, well, you're only paying me enough to have water like 20 days out of the month instead of 30. So the last 10 days, we're going to shut off the water because you're only really giving us enough money to cover, you know, 20 days.
People just don't understand that, you know, all the complexity that goes on behind the scenes. And we even talk to leaders sometimes. We ask them, you know, have you ever seen your facility? Like, have you ever gone to the wastewater plant? Do you get a tour of the water plant? And how many of them have never seen it? And you just wonder, like, how can you make a decision about, you know, some project either to do it or not to do it when you have no idea?
of what you're actually talking about and what these facilities are. It's almost like saying, would you buy a house without like ever setting foot in it? You're going to like, well, I'm going to renovate my kitchen, even though I've never seen the kitchen. I don't know what's in the kitchen, but I'm going to renovate it anyway. I mean, it just, sometimes it just seems crazy to me that, you know, the people have, you know, leaders who make those decisions don't have.
you know, the time to come down and like talk to the operators and talk to the managers and tour the facilities and really see, you know, what they're about. So I applaud anybody who has done that. There's certainly leaders who do, but for anybody who hasn't, if you're a leader of a water system, go out, see your facilities, talk to your operators, find out what's involved. I even think it'd be great if they would spend the day with an operator and see what an operator does. You can sometimes make decisions that totally affect the water system and, you know, they have no idea or even understand that the operator is a responsible person for that utility legally. It's nuts sometimes.
Yeah, so I think that connection between leadership and the operations needs to be stronger so that they understand how their decisions are affecting not just the customers, but the employees as well. And actually, that's something we always try to talk to water utilities about is asset management is not just for the customers. It's also for the employees. And it's as important for employees as it is for the customers. So yes, we want to do everything to serve the customers, but we also want to use asset management to make their lives better. So we often start a conversation with what are the things that are really hard for you?
so that we can design at least part of this asset management program to address those things. Because asset management can do lots of different things. Now, where do we want to start? So where are your pain points and how can we use asset management to help you with those? You mentioned as a joke, basically, if you only gave people water 20 days out of the month or whatever, one of my colleagues who's an atmospheric scientist, I can't remember if it was Jordan, somewhere in the Middle East to do some consulting. And that was how the town was ran. You had water three or four days a week and they didn't have enough water. So some parts of town got it some days.
And some got others. And so the hotel she was in, they actually had you fill up your bathtub. Wow. And so it was really eye-opening. I figured that's something else everyone should experience. Because those people in that community lived that way their entire lives. You had to plan for not having water for three or four days. And it just, it's, yeah, people don't appreciate what we have, that's for sure. Yeah, again, it's a sort of idea of it's kind of in the background. And, you know, we take it so for granted. And we were just recently in the South on vacation.
Charleston and Savannah we were touring this house in Savannah which apparently was the first supposedly the first house in the nation with indoor plumbing so this guy had this whole series of cisterns like five different cisterns in his house and he created this indoor plumbing system even had a shower and he ran the pipes behind the fireplace so supposedly they even were having hot water showers back in the day and I was thinking of like okay here's kind of that first move to having indoor plumbing and everybody else in town would have had outhouses and would have had you know to make do in other ways so how far we've come from there today. And again, it's not everybody. We still have some work to do to get that last bit of the country that doesn't have indoor plumbing or doesn't have quality water. But we have made huge strides from there until now. And again, sometimes we forget how good we have it. Yes. You mentioned how things have changed. One of our questions we were going to ask you today was really about, since you've been in the asset management game, so to speak, how have things changed from then until now in the last, say, two decades in the landscape? And I mean, we're all in that game. So it's been interesting.
It's sort of my the glasses half empty, the glasses half full scenario. So there are times when I look backwards and I say the glasses half full. And when I look forward, sometimes I say the glasses half empty. So when I think back to where we were a couple of decades ago, when I started pushing asset management, I was a huge promoter and I thought anybody could do it. But when it first came over, it was really being kept for the biggest of the big systems. And EPA's original idea was that only those systems that were about 100,000 and above really needed it or would even be able to do it. So their initial intent was, we're just going to take that.
you know, what is that couple of percent of systems? Cause there's like 97% or so that are below that. So we're just going to take these couple of systems up top. We're going to have them do asset management and it's not going to be a program for anybody else. And I kept arguing, well, that doesn't make any sense. This is just a way of thinking. Anybody can think. And you're just changing the level of complexity at which you do it.
So maybe, you know, a small system is using a really simple computer program or even paper because we've had some do some phenomenal things just on paper. And some big utility is using this multimillion dollar computer program. But the thought process is the same and you don't need anything to think. You just need your brain. So I kept pushing the idea that small systems could do it. Anybody could do it. And EPA was kind of like knock your socks off because we don't agree. And so I got yelled at a ton. You had to grow a pretty thick skin. I was in a lot of meetings. I literally was yelled at, screamed at. You're crazy. This is stupid. Why are you doing this?
Very, very negative. And at one point they said, you know, show us it actually can be done in small systems. And that's when we put together our AM can't work guide, where we went out and filmed a bunch of small utilities and we proved there are a lot of utilities doing it, not having any trouble, like really teeny tiny ones, 25 customers. And it started to change the conversation to, yes, we can do it. It is possible. There's no reason they can't. So I think we've made huge strides where now I don't believe there's a lot of those conversations that it's not a good idea or it doesn't have a lot of merit. So I think we've come to the realization that it's still, you know, that is good and anybody can do it. So that's a huge improvement where we still have work to be done is.
there's still this idea that it's like this extra thing. So I have my day job and then you want me to do asset management. And I always say, no, that's not how this works. Your day job is asset management. It's not like day job puts something on top. It's like, we're changing your day job. And we want to change your day job in a way that's easier for you. So you're not running around putting out fires all day. You're doing something that makes more sense and is more efficient and more effective.
So we're trying to change that part of the attitude because there's still a real sense that we're just asking you to do something more, something additional, and I don't have time for it. And that is not what asset management is intended to do. So I feel like we have a lot more work to go in implementing it. I was involved with AWWA in studying the current state of practice in asset management. We studied in 2015 and 2020. And at first, we were all really discouraged because we saw a really tiny uptick in practice between 2015 and 2020. So our initial thoughts were like, oh, man, it really didn't get that much better.
But then we kind of took a beat and said, well, it didn't get worse. And so that's a good thing. And it did get a little better. So maybe we should take heart in the fact that we're moving in the right direction. We are seeing improvements and we didn't see any backsliding. And we had about the same demographics of responses. We don't know if they were any of the same responses because we are not privy to who actually filled it out because it's an anonymous thing. But we had about the same number of respondents. The demographics were about the same in terms of size ranges and things of that nature between the two studies. So we feel like that was.
a way to say there was a little bit better practice. There was not backlighting. So we do definitely have work to do to really get it, you know, the practice more embedded, more, you know, more robust, but I think we are making progress. And as long as we keep that steady progress, you know, that's going to be a good thing. Yeah. I mean, you mentioned there's still certainly a lot of systems that are struggling, but I mean, are the problems the same? Are they different? Is it just the same where a small utility doesn't see the value? Probably some of all the above.
I think some of all the above. I mean, I think we still have the same workforce issues. That has not changed. So we've had workforce issues for quite a while now. And obviously that ties into asset management because if you don't have the workforce at all, it's really hard. You know, asset management is going to fix that. So if you don't have an operator, you can do asset management all day long. It's not going to help. But where it can help is when you're trying to address the operator who is retiring after so many years and bringing in a new operator. That's where asset management can really, really help us in the workforce area. And we've had, you know, good examples of that.
Doing the inventory work, developing an asset management program really helps transition the one operator into retirement and bring the other operator on. So that knowledge transfer part of asset management is super, super important. And we do feel like that is something that can be helped in the workforce, but the lack of a workforce, asset management isn't going to fix that. We need other programs to fix that. And I think the other area that's really big is maintenance. We still have to improve our maintenance practices. The idea you have to do maintenance and that you should be looking at what...
what cycle to do maintenance on. Like too many times maintenance is just, we've always done it this way. Or yeah, I think Joe told me to do it once a month, you know, but there's no thought process about like, is once a month the right amount of time, you know, does that make the asset last longer or. or is it that I should be doing it once a week? Like there's no thought process of people just to take that step back and say, well, why am I doing this? It's exactly the right thing. I was just going to say that. They need to understand why they're doing what they're doing and ask those questions. And I think when they take that time, you know, just to give an example, there's this one utility we worked with and they're having to clean out one piece of sewer over and over again. So every month they have to go and clean it out because there's a flaw in the sewer. And if they don't, they're going to get a backup. So once a month they go and it's this big, horrendously awful job to do to, you know, get the clog out of the sewer and nobody wants to do it.
So, you know, we started asking them, like, how often have you been doing this? Or how long have you been doing? Oh, about maybe about 10 years we've been doing this. And then we said, well, what would be a way to change it so you wouldn't have to do it anymore? Well, we could put in a new piece of sewer. Okay, well, how long of a piece of sewer would you need? So we got that information. And we sat down with them and really looked at, well, what are the costs of you once a month going and cleaning out the sewer? What's the cost of replacing the pipe? They have already spent more in the 10 years than the cost of that pipe. And there's no end in sight because right now the program is just keep going every month. And it's looked at, well, if we keep going every month, there won't be a backup. Well, that's true. But if you put a new piece of pipe in, there wouldn't be a backup either. And taking the...
step of putting in that infrastructure so you don't have to go do this horrendous job. That's where I think the tie can really work between how this affects customers, the leaders, and the utility workers. So if you just did that, now you've bought the utility workers. There's actually four guys that are needed six hours a day at the clog plus two guys at the little treatment plant so that it doesn't cause a problem there. So you actually need six people.
And so the number of hours you just got back. So it's almost like, okay, now I'm going to give you this many hours. What do you want to do with those instead? So you don't have to do this anymore. What can we do with those hours? And then you start to have really interesting conversations about, well, I never get to do X. Okay, well, now you can. I just gave you the time to go do X. So I think that's where asset management can really help the small utilities is let's look at individual things you do, like down to that level of what are some individual things you do over and over again that maybe could be done differently. Now we bought you time to go do something that you can't do.
So hopefully we can keep pushing the practice in that direction and making their lives better. Cool. It seems like it's so much of a matter of just slowing down and taking that pause to think, as you've been saying, and then how do we create more of a culture that it's okay to do that? Because so much of this work is, okay, we have to get this done. We're unlimited time. You know, we all want to go home at the end of the day, but how do we slow down just enough to make better decisions? I think that's really, really true. It's just taking that pause and empowering the workers too. So I was trying to do that too. Like you are, you need to be empowered to talk to your upper management, like whoever that is, like whoever's above you.
You need to be willing to go to them with ideas. And we always say, be careful how you go to them. Like you don't want to just be screaming like, you know, you make me do this every month. This is terrible. Like that's not going to get you anywhere. But if you go with an actual documented data to say like, okay, we do this every month. It takes this many hours. It takes this many trucks. You know, here's what it costs you. And you can go with some actual information and present it in a very like matter of fact way. Now we can make things, you know, now we can have a really good conversation and we can.
you know, make improvements. A lot of times it's just changing the way the conversations are even had because the operators, I find many of them have really good ideas, but they kind of just don't know how to talk to each other. It's sort of like, you know, they're talking past each other or they don't feel empowered to even bring it up or they don't maybe take the time themselves to think, well, what could be done different? It's like, oh yeah, we just got to do this every month. And until somebody asks them the question of, well, what would fix that? You know, like, how could you fix that issue? And then they think a minute and like, well, we could do this or we could do that.
then I think if you take that beat and you say, okay, well, maybe we can all work together to have a better outcome, you can make real progress. I mean, there's real gains to be made, real benefits, if we can have that time in those conversations. Sure. How are you seeing the new infrastructure funding changing the conversation, particularly as it pertains to small systems and how we're going to do these things better? I'll say I have real mixed feelings. So on the one hand...
I'm really thrilled that there is an idea of trying to get money to small systems and systems that maybe have been left out of some of that funding in the past. On the other hand, it's not strictly an infrastructure problem. So there is so much more to the issue than just infrastructure. And throwing money only at the infrastructure part of this will not get us where we need to go. So I think there is a little bit of a...
It's a concern on my part, I guess, that we don't want to look at this if we just go out and put brand new infrastructure in all these little towns that suddenly the world is going to be better because that's not true. We need to be thinking much more holistically. Okay, well, if we did put new infrastructure in, who's going to run it? Who's going to manage that infrastructure? Do we have the workforce? Are they certified at the right level? If we give them a more complicated treatment plant, water or wastewater, can they get the higher certification that they need? Can we pay them what we need to pay them? Then are we going to be able to do the maintenance?
So if you put infrastructure in, it has to be maintained. What is the plan there? Will they be able to get the spare parts? Will they be able to do the types of activities and maintenance activities that you need to do? Do they have a plan in place to do it? So I am really, really worried that we're going to have this huge uptick in infrastructure spending. And then fast forward 10 or 20 years when nobody's done the maintenance and all that infrastructure is falling apart. Now what? Then do we infuse another ginormous chunk of money to rehabilitate all that infrastructure? I don't know. I just think that it's...
taking the problem and making it too narrow. I mean, it's a problem like this, but we're solving it with a solution that's narrow. So I'm hoping that... EPA and the states and others will broaden the solution out a little bit and say like, okay, let's put the infrastructure money in as a broader solution. And let's be really smart about how we spend that money and not just throw the money out the door as fast as we can, but really be smart about what are we going to spend it on? Where are we going to spend it? How will we best meet the needs of the utilities? Because I think, on the one hand, it's a great gift we have this money, but we need to make sure that we use that gift wisely, that we're smart about how we employ it. And we don't get narrowly focused on just, this is not just an infrastructure problem. It's much, much bigger than that. And our solution has to be bigger than that.
I think as TA providers, we need to look at it in the glass half full way that it's an opportunity to reach out to all those systems and say, you're not going to get another one of these. This is your chance to actually pick up your system if it needs it and learn the right way to run things so that you can be sustainable and blah, blah, blah. And I realize there's not enough funding or TA providers to actually reach everyone. But again, incremental wins are wins. One thing that I think has always been missed in the country, and I've mentioned it many, many times when I get on my soapbox is...
We have systems that are too small to really be sustainable. So we're talking about it's a public water system if it has 15 connections and 25 people. They're facing some of the same regulations as a system that has 2 million people. There is no way that that is financially sustainable over the long term when you have that few of customers. So we have allowed systems to be that small without addressing the fact that there probably needs to be some continued subsidy of some type.
for operation and maintenance if you really want to make it work. And we haven't really had the hard conversation that actually some other countries have had where they have said below this level is not sustainable. We are going to consolidate and you're going to consolidate into like management areas. We're not talking about physically running pipe, but managerially consolidating. We've not ever imposed that type of consolidation.
So I think that that's one of those things that we will have to come to grips with is addressing the fact that we have systems that are probably too small to be financially sustainable, but we don't want to recognize that. So what are we going to do as a country to make them more sustainable, either as small systems, leave it exactly as is, but somehow subsidize some of the running of the system in some way, or say that we need to make bigger entities managerially or some other way partnering to get more of an economy of scale. So we're going to have to eventually wrestle with those issues of how do we help these really, really small systems. continue to be sustainable over the long term. Go ahead, Jennifer. I was just gonna say, one of the things that gives me hope is that we've had this conversation on another episode this season and everyone that I've talked to, and I think Steve as well, who we've been talking about, okay, we have all this money, now what? I think we as a community all are sharing these concerns and hopefully we've done enough work over the past one, two, three decades or more to be ready to have the conversations because there are the tools in place. There are trainings and resources and things that we've been talking about and now there's...
some funding to help move us forward and do it in the right way. Yeah. And I'm trying to be like as optimistic as possible, you know, because I do, I am really excited that there is this recognition that small systems should get, you know, their fair share out of this money where maybe that hasn't been as much the case in the past, or maybe they just haven't known, you know, how to access those funding. It wasn't like they were specifically kept out, but it wasn't also that there was a big outreach to try to get to them. So I'm really, really excited about the fact that we're recognizing the need. Now we just have to make sure that we put.
the right pieces in place to try to really make a difference. And especially in those communities that maybe haven't had compliant water or had any water service, you know, what are we going to do in those areas as well? And I think there's sort of separate conversations going on around those kinds of things is how do we help? areas that maybe have been left out entirely of the conversation of just how to get water. You know, there's still parts of the Navajo Nation, for example, that don't have running water. And how are those types of things addressed? Or people that don't have good sewer systems, you know, there are certainly areas in Alabama and I think Texas where they've had diseases that shouldn't be there, but because there's inadequate, you know, wastewater treatment, they are. So how do we address those too? And I think that's going to be a big part of, you know, I hope a larger conversation of, you know, addressing the systems that are there, but also helping those that maybe don't have that option now of even having a water or wastewater system.
For sure. So Heather, are you on social media in any professional capacity? This has been an awesome conversation. We'd love to help our listeners. I think I'm probably a little too old school. So we do have our Southwest EFC website where we have blog posts and things like that. And then we started something a few years ago called the Environment Focused Learning Academy, EFLA.
That has media sites or, you know, like a Twitter and Instagram. So you can follow the EFLA site. And what we have in mind is that it's like a neutral place to go get information about water and wastewater. It's in its new stages. We're experimenting with different ways of communicating. So we have some art type things. We have some papers. We have some podcasts. We have some videos. So, and we have some animations. So we're experimenting with different ways of communicating with the idea that eventually there'll be content.
that will help customers, elected leaders and water utilities with, you know, sharing information about water, what it means, how it works. Like for example, one of our animations is about how septic tanks work. So lots of people have septic tanks and don't really understand how they work. And here's a chance to see, well, this is just how it works. We have some bottled water things on there where again, we're not trying to hit anybody in the face, but rather just say, here's some differences between the two. You know, they're regulated differently.
And trying to let people know that actually the sources of water are the same because many people think bottled water sources are different than the water that comes out of your tap, which I always find funny is like there's some like special place that bottled water comes from. Like, well, there's this water over here that we put in a bottle and this other water goes through the tap. And like, no, it's all the same water. So the best thing to do would be to, you know, go to our FLIS site or Southwest EFC because I'm a little too old school to be social media myself. We will include those links in the show notes for this episode.
It's great to talk to you. Oh, you guys do. I'm glad we finally got to make it work. I appreciate it. I appreciate the opportunity. No, it's, yeah, it's been an enjoyable conversation for sure, so. Yeah, this is our final episode of the season, and I think it's a fantastic way to end it. You've shared a lot of wisdom with our audience, a lot of food for thought. Well, thank you very much. I appreciate it. Well, you guys have a great day and a really good weekend. TAP Talk is a collaboration between the Rural Community Assistance Partnership and the University of Illinois with funding from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. The show is hosted by Steve and Jennifer Wilson of the Illinois State Water Survey. You can visit drinkingwaterpodcast.org to find the full show notes for this episode.