Skip to content
TT038 - Operator Training: It Takes Skill episode artwork

Mar 14, 2024 40 min

TT038 - Operator Training: It Takes Skill

from Tap Talk

The methods with which we teach and train water operators have evolved as the world changes around us, but one thing hasn't changed: It takes skill and effort on the parts of both the teacher and learner to ensure the most effective possible training. In this episode, we chat with Ramzi Mahmood of the Office of Water Programs at California State University, Sacramento, about what he's learned from his years of teaching and the future of operator training. Visit drinkingwaterpodcast.org to learn more and find the full show notes for this episode!

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

TT038 - Operator Training: It Takes Skill

0:00 40:01
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

If you decide to run a marathon and you know that next month there's this marathon in your hometown, there's no way you can say, okay, I'll run a marathon next month. It takes effort. Same thing with learning. It's not different. You're listening to Tap Talk, the drinking water in rural America podcast. We believe everyone has a role to play in protecting public health. And together, we're connecting water and health professionals with ideas to extend and enhance our work. Whether you operate, educate, or regulate, this show is for you. Welcome to episode 38. In this episode, we're chatting about operator training best practices with Ramzi Mahmoud.

from Sacramento State's Office of Water Programs. So today we have Ramsey Mahut with us from Sacramento State. He's the director of water programs there. Many of you in the water and wastewater industry are familiar with the Sacramento State manuals. And so we're so grateful to have you on today. You know, we were just at WPI together and I always enjoy your perspective on training because you spent so much time in that world. And so I guess as we start out, do you want to describe a little more about where you work and what's your role and how that goes? Good, thank you. First, thank you, Jennifer and Steve for inviting me here.

I'm the director of Office of Water Programs at Sac State, and also I'm professor of civil engineering. So I've been in the teaching business for almost three decades. I started in 97 as a director. At that time, there were 11 of us. And now there are about 70 of us, 50 full time and 11 students. The training part that we develop training materials is a small part still compared to the rest of it. We do a lot of funded work for Cal EPA, the state agencies, basically.

We also do some work for EPA, US EPA, through the finance center. We're one of the finance centers for region. We are for region nine. So that's basically what we do here at OWP. Of course, the training manuals are, I call it our bread and butter because we've been in existence for over 50 years. That's awesome. Wow. Yeah, it's incredible. It's definitely something that I heard of within the first couple months when I was originally at EPA. So it's always been a fixture in our industry.

What do you love about your job and the work that you do? You know, when I think about it, it really boils down to that I am part of making a difference in the lives of many people. And I'm talking about operators. They get into a professional position and they make a difference in protecting public health and the environment. I mean, it's really what a nice mission for them. And then every day I wake up, I know I'm making a difference for everything that I change or think about how we can adjust so it makes it easier for operators to get the idea, get the concept.

It feels great. Yeah, I was just going to say that. Doesn't it feel great and make you want to go to your job every day? Because we were just talking about the same issue. We're very fortunate to be in a situation where we do get to help people every day. And yeah, it means a lot more than it does. It makes it fun to come to work. So tell us one personal fun fact about you that the audience here would not know.

Oh, wow. I don't know if it's fun, but it's fun for me. I love soccer, you know, otherwise known football in the rest of the world. And especially, you know, I watch English Premier League and I wake up early in the morning on weekends just to watch the games. My favorite team is Arsenal. And I have other favorite teams, which goes in contradiction with people who are really crazy about soccer. And I thought about it. I said, what makes me like other teams? And it boils down to what they call as manager, we call here head coach.

And really the common theme with the head coaches that I like, and I like their team accordingly, is they are good teachers. To me, you know, they appear to be great teachers. So here we go again. Comes right around. Yeah. So I assume you've seen Ted Lasso. Oh, yes. Oh, yeah. I knew nothing about soccer before that. I mean, I knew a little, but, you know, what a great feel-good show. And same thing. It is. It's an amazing show. Yes. Yeah. Yeah. And then that's what he knows how to make people feel their self-worth. And, you know, and yeah, it's awesome. Yep. Yep.

So before we get into our main conversation today, we also like to ask our guests about their water hero. So do you have someone, past or present, whose work in water or public health you've admired or has influenced you? Yeah, I mean, that's for me, it's very easy to say. First of all, there are so many people that influence me, you know, I mean, going through graduate school and, and working in this field and so on. But then I was fortunate to work about 20 years with Ken Carey. I mean, Ken Carey started this program. And boy, what an amazing thing. And I really got into the program after working with him briefly. And I was, you know, working on small sections, updating manuals and so on. And, and in 97, he decided to retire. And it just happened, you know, naturally that I became the director.

And I continue to work with him. So he is on top of the list for sure. Yeah, I'm sure a lot of folks who might listen to this are jealous that you had the opportunity to even work with Ken Gary because he certainly, you know, WPI has an award named after him. I mean, he certainly is a father in a lot of ways of many things related to operators for sure. Yeah. So that's awesome.

Today, that's what we want to talk about today is operator training, how we learn some of the things. I mentioned earlier, we were both at WPI, Water Professionals International meeting in January. And when all these topics come up, your perspective is always well-received. And it's interesting because people are willing, a lot of times folks are trying to just get to the end. And don't think about the work that needs to go in in the middle to really create great training and great trainers. And so that's why we really we asked you on today is to get into some of the heart of those things. So before we start, we mentioned Ken Carey and Sac State and the manuals we provide. Could you give us a little more of a background? As Jennifer mentioned, it's kind of the first thing you learn and about the manuals, past, present, future, just to give everyone a perspective that may not be aware of those things. Yeah. You know, I mean, as I mentioned earlier, we've been in existence over 40, 50 years.

And the way it started, you know, a long time ago, Kangari was asked to really write some manual for operators so that we can train operators and so on. So at that time, probably a lot of the audience may not know, these manuals were typed on an IBM Selectric. I mean, that was, of course, revolution in technology because it had these balls that has the, you know, the letters on it and you can exchange the balls with different fonts. And that was revolution at the time. So anyway, that was then. That's crazy.

Yeah. And then we moved along and then, you know, the books were updated and so on. So by the time I started, we still published the books ourselves. We did everything. The nice thing about it, there were a lot of operators slash engineers that involved in developing the books. And it made one of the key success for these manuals. Really, everybody paid attention to the language. So we, from that day, we had.

People, technical editors that paid attention to the language and not to write a book for engineers with a lot of complicated things without really having the ability to communicate with the audience. And I'll come to this theme about audience, you know, that's the key. So time moves forward. And we had, by that time, 19 books. And we still do in different topics, you know, wastewater, water treatment, collection system, distribution system, industrial and so on. In 2015.

I started this project to update the books. And one of the key elements, we said, okay, what are the important things to focus on? And then it goes back to how to make the books easy to follow and also use key strategies in terms of effective learning for operators. So the books were redesigned in terms of the layout, redesigned in terms of how we put certain elements. To give you an example, we used to have the key terms, which is important for anybody that gets into this field.

And then we have it within the book and it's bolded. So if they see this key term, they have to go back and look up what it means and so on. Within your design, we have this two-third, one-third design and immediately it's in the margin defines it. So which makes connection much easier because you have the context, you have the connection to it and so on. And we also introduced that to check your understanding, meaning each section when we finish is really to ask questions.

and I don't want to bore people because I've been talking about it for over a decade, is really learning strategies. Retrieval, meaning, you know, you ask questions, that's how you consolidate learning. You know, that's one of the key elements. And we try to use that throughout the books and so on. So, you know, I'm happy to say we finished 16, three to go, which it's really, they are underway. And also we have e-learning strategies. We have been incorporating the same concepts of how people learn more effectively and what are the key elements to put them in.

When this e-learning started some time ago, people were basically putting PowerPoint slides together, which I call, at best, you can call them super duper PowerPoint slides. And you go through it and people thought, oh, okay, this is how you teach people or this is how people learn. And now it's getting better because we're learning about these things and we want to incorporate better concepts, way to engage the audience and so on so that it's really useful for operators to learn. So that gives you some overview of what we have and we're planning. Just in my view, there's a next generation training manuals. And currently it's really building the strategy. What do we do? What's next after updating all these books? Sounds like quite an undertaking. Yeah. And years in, yeah. So from all your experience, both within the program and as a professor yourself, what are some of the problems you see in delivering training to water and wastewater professionals?

So let me start with this idea that, you know, obviously to have a competent teacher, you need the experience and knowledge that's given, right? But having the experience and knowledge does not translate into effective teaching. In my mind, that's the key element that's missing. So if you take a model in universities, let's say, typically professors finish their PhD and go on and they are expected to teach. I mean, they are competent, definitely. They have been, you know. Probably have six years of research. Yeah. Yeah. So, but.

really none of us was prepared to be effective teachers you know and that's really the key so you can translate this into when we deal with operators we think if someone is experienced and knowledgeable we say okay can you can you train And I've seen some trainers, you know, I mean, really, they have a PowerPoint slide that they prepare and they go through them. At best, they may ask questions here and there, and they think this is an effective and a good teaching. So in my mind, you know, step number one is analyze the audience. So in this case, what we're focusing on is operators. So if we take an operator, he or she has a family, has work commitment, of course. And then there's this so-called certification, right? You know, because you have to be competent.

to be able to work as an operator to protect the public health and the environment. So on top of it, we expect them to learn effectively and so on. So if you look at their time, they are not full-time students, for sure. And their time is very limited. So now we have to figure out what's the best way to approach this. And in my mind, you know, they have sort of two big options. One, to take distance learning. Our books is an example. There are many other books and training materials and so on. Or do some kind of online training. But both of these options, they need to incorporate some effective learning strategies because time management becomes important. And of course, I always tell my number one slide when I talk about learning and so on.

I say, don't let anybody fool you that learning is easy because there's no shortcut. And my best example is if you decide to run a marathon and you know that next month there's this marathon in your hometown, there's no way you can say, okay, I'll run a marathon next month. It takes effort and it takes a schedule that you develop, what you do day in, day out to get to that point. Same thing with learning. It's not different. You need to organize your time and schedule. So there's this responsibility on the operator side, but also responsibility on us to make it effective.

Meaning, you know, you have strategies that help operators to learn. So that's really how I think about it. And when you think about any training, audience come first and learning strategies. All the time we run into cases where someone is a great athlete or they were great at a sport and they're expected to go coach a team and they have no coaching skills and it does not translate in any way. We're running into that right now with a certain situation. And why folks think, well, I was good at this sport. I shouldn't be.

coach it. It's not about knowing the sport. That's just a prerequisite, like you mentioned. And so that's, you know, it's so true in life and so many things. Yep. That's all I wanted to say. But go ahead, Jennifer. That connects well to my question. Just following on this one, what are your suggestions for those of us who are listening to this podcast or peers in the industry who are doing training in terms of developing those skills without going back to school and getting a degree in instructional design? Yeah. Yeah. I mean, so to me, really, what it boils down to is understanding learning.

strategies and effective learning to me. And that's not very hard to do, but it takes time for designing any training session, any training hour or book or anything you do. It just takes time. So to give you an example, we talked about retrieval. Retrieval is the mechanism where, you know, if you understand the concept, you sort of embrace it. It's sitting in your brain somewhere. And if you don't use that information, it's gone, right? It's just gone. The best way to sort of.

what's called consolidation, is to ask questions. So you learn this, and if there's a question related to it, now all of a sudden you go and say, okay, what did I learn about this, and how can I retrieve this? And that retrieval process is what consolidates learning, and that's when learning happens. So now this is a simple thing, questions. So in my mind, if I'm giving a lecture, what I will start with is a set of questions. What it does, actually, it makes you think as a learner in terms of, first of all, what they call inventory of knowledge.

So you say, well, wait a minute, I have no idea what this is. Or you can say, well, I heard something related to it. But that process makes your brain just, you know, function immediately. Yes, engaged. And then now I'll start the lecture. So I had a set of questions that I triggered in everybody's mind what kinds of things that they need to know. And then I start my lecture. And as I develop each concept, I pepper it with all kinds of questions and activities and pause, you know, let them retrieve this. If I continue talking about something, it's just, it's not.

Yeah, that's a simple strategy. There are a lot of things that, you know, a lot of other things that you can do is teach learners how to develop their own flashcards. I mean, that's another retrieval process. And I always tell people, hey, don't take shortcuts where you see this. Say, I think I know it. You look at the answer right away. Don't do that. Think, try to come up with a way to answer that. Then look, you know, that time is important. Another concept is we tend to.

An example, if I show some graph or some graphics, right away it pops up. I'm not allowing people to absorb information, you know, as opposed to if I do it gradually, meaning I, you know, draw graphics and axes if needed. So anybody that's watching can see this and I'm giving them time. And then I gradually describe what this is and how it works. So I call it absorption time. You know, really you're receiving information as opposed to something flashes in your face and you say, oh, what was that? Just, you know, simple things that may take you a lot of time to prepare.

But then it is really effective. You know, that's why, you know, as I mentioned, I taught for almost three decades. I know the subject matter, no question about it. I taught some of these courses for a long time. And every time before I go to the lecture, I take about 45 minutes, just sit down and think through that lecture. When do I pause? What do I do? How do I plan to get to the students? I call teaching part of it to be effective. It's really a performance. So it's as if you're going to a stage and you're performing.

So you need to sort of rehearse in your mind what you're doing and how you do it. And then when you go, it looks seamless. You're not reading anything. You're not doing anything. High-level athletes, which I'm not, of course, they talk about they are in the zone. And to me, teaching is the same thing. When you are in the zone, you just don't need anything. You know exactly where you're going. You know exactly what you're doing. And just it happens naturally. So to me, this gets back on how do you prepare people into that? It's really hammer on learning strategies.

And each one of us developed a way to do this. But learning strategy is the important thing. So in what you just said in answering Jennifer's question, there's two things that really come out for me. One is you're focused on the learner. And I say that because I would just imagine that a lot of professors that I've had in college, which was also a long time ago, if they heard you say, I spend 45 minutes before my hour lecture preparing for that, they're all cringing and going, are you crazy? For one. And the other thing is you really have to be intentional. And you want to support your learner. You want to be prepared.

Um, it's, it's not something just, you can't say, Hey, I'm an expert at this. So I'm going to be a good teacher. Um, you have to be intentional at wanting to deliver it in the right way. That's really, yeah, it's interesting. And, uh, giving dad Jennifer, cause he really led into the next question. So the next question was really, um, you know, when you spoke at the WPI meeting in January, um, it was part of, it was about learning and the things that keeps coming up is people learn in different ways. And I know someone said that in the audience then. And, um, and there are, there are, you know, I consider myself a face person, not a name person, you know, there's.

And you just alluded to that. You talked about flashcards for, you know, how do we deal with that? Do you, I mean, it sounds like what you've incorporated are a number of strategies so that you're going to reach all those folks in different ways. But, you know, that's always been an issue as far as visual versus readers or whatever. So I guess my question, yeah, is really how do we deal with that side of things? Yeah, I mean, it's, if we focus on the idea of a trainer and what kinds of things we need to do and to prepare the trainers.

You know, it goes back to the idea you focus on your audience. So we establish that. And then what kinds of techniques or strategies a trainer can use? You know, to me, it goes back. We mentioned earlier about certifying trainers. In all honesty, it's OK to to do that. But then you tend to focus on certain elements and you forget that teaching requires requires this practice, this passion. And how do you develop this?

You almost need some kind of academy to say, let me prepare someone. And it doesn't need to be a degree or certificate or anything. It's just some way to do that. I can give you an example, actually, to exist now for civil engineers. And the training was developed by West Point. And it's called EXCEED, which is Excellence in Civil Engineering Education. That's the EXCEED. They developed it in West Point. The way they approached it, they went into details of how you develop.

down to a lecture in terms of mechanics. You know, everything you do, how do you do this? How do you write your notes? You develop your board. I mean, it's really detailed and it's one of the probably best programs I've ever seen. What happened, American Society of Civil Engineers noticed that and they adopted that program and they started sponsoring this program to be given to all civil engineering faculty that they, you know, the new ones that start teaching in civil engineering.

And when I was department chair, we put in the offer letter that we expect in the first two or three years, I forgot, but something like that for them to participate in XSEED. And it became actually so competitive. They offered two sessions, 24 participants each. And it's one week long. And by the end of it, each one is responsible to start to present a lecture. And then after going through the workshop, to present the same lecture with what they learned.

You know, something like this, I think will be a lot more effective. Then the issue is who covers this, who does that and all that. I mean, and to me, that could be something that EPA can sponsor and put some thinking into it and then allow trainers to participate in this. Because without that knowledge, I mean, we expect people to know how to operate a treatment plant and we put them into training. Why do we not expect that trainers should get some kind of training? And that'll be effective. Yeah.

How do you distinguish between the trainer and the training itself? Because obviously, if both are great, that's the best possible scenario. But one of my concerns about the idea of certifying trainers individually, okay, they're certified, but maybe they're going to end up using somebody else's training materials, which, what's the point then? Yeah, that's an excellent point. You know, a lot of times, you know, people ask me for lecture notes or in different venues. Since 2009 to 2016, I volunteered for UNESCO.

And we were going in the Middle East, in Iraq specifically, to help with the quality of higher education. So we worked with academician and administrators in higher education and engineering specific. And some of them were asking, oh, can you share your notes and so on? And my point in this, really, my notes, I developed them through time by just trial and error because that's how it works. I mean, there's no way I can use anybody's notes because it doesn't make any sense to me. You know, the way I flow the materials, the way I describe it, you know, it may make sense to me and I think it's effective. And then.

Every time I look at it, next time I offer it, I adjust something because I say, wait, last minute, last time I had some questions about this and I'm not sure if I covered it well. So let me tweak here and there. And so that process is connected. You know, the training and the training materials, you may know the topics is generally the same, but the way I do it is different from somebody else's and so on. So, you know, that's such an important point. You know, the two are so connected. Obviously, when you say we need the following information to be.

convey, it will be the same in topics, but the details will be definitely different from person to person. There's a lot of trainers or people who've given talks or whatever who have a light bulb going off right now, because at least for me, I've been on both sides of that. And it's so true because it's not the way I would write it if I'm going to make a statement. We provided materials, complete presentations with all the notes. This is what you should say. By the time somebody else is doing that, and if they're taking their time and doing their due diligence, they're totally changing the wording to match how they talk. And otherwise, it just doesn't come across.

as natural or understanding or any of those things. So I get what you're saying. It's really interesting. I mean, it becomes mechanical. You know, you can imagine you might as well record it and let them listen to it. And we call it a day, right? I mean, to me, that immersion between what you're trying to deliver and how you understand the audience is so important. And there is this evolution. It's not, it just doesn't happen. The first time you do this, it's perfect. There's no such thing. You know, I mean, I taught some courses for over 20 years and I tell you every time I do it, I have something different and adjust something.

How have the shifts in technology, you already mentioned that you are doing e-learning, but how does your perspective on understanding learners and various teaching strategies impact your business decisions? I'm putting that in quotes here in terms of continuing to update and offer the manuals as well as doing online training. Yeah, you know, I thought about these things and I offered some of my courses online on the university side. And this was back more than 15 years ago because through advisory committee, I hear. Online, online, online is important, and especially in the graduate program. So I said, OK, I always talk about it. Let me do it. And I did that twice. At that time, you have to be in a recording studio. And some students elected to come and some students listen to me. And I demanded that they listen to me live, although the lecture was recorded. So my first time I offered that, I had one student that did not show up to any lecture other than he came to the exams and did the exams. And he did very well. So I asked him, I said, I'm curious to hear from you because you are the only one who.

Did not come to any lecture. Some mixed it up. And you did well. What happened? He said, well, he really showed me his notes. He said, look at my notes. These are the best notes I've ever taken in any class. So I said, so what happened? He said, you know, when I attended the lecture, I took some notes. And then I went back and listened to the recording. And I adjusted my notes because I filled in the gaps and did all that. And I said, oh, OK. He's a good learner. He's a good learner. I mean, he's putting time. He's putting effort. So that's why. The next time I offered it, I had a higher percentage. Almost half of the students were online, did not come.

Towards about, I would say, before mid-semester, I canceled online because I noticed a bunch of these students are falling behind and they are not really keeping up with the lectures. They are not doing their homework correctly and all that. So I called it off and some of them were mad. And I told them, I said, it's not working. I'm sorry. And it turns out they weren't even looking at the recording. They were thinking, oh, I have time. I'll do it next time and so on. So my lesson from these two events is really, if you are engaged, it is effective.

If you're not engaged, it's gone. And that's true for any mode, right? It's true in general. Actually, the research shows that because a lot of the online courses that had high percentage of failure and the main reason is lack of engagement. So what I came to believe is you need to figure out ways to engage students, especially when it's online. So how do you do that? You do it by, I call it, you know, stopping points where they cannot proceed if there's no an action on their part, meaning answering a question, doing something, doing an activity.

So that's one. The other thing I think, for the most part, the online is useful as a value added. Some people may think, OK, you're old style. You're still thinking that way. It's fine. I think you still need something physical to write on, especially when we talk about some technical areas, technical details and so on. You need something to write on. So our approach in the e-learning that we're designing and should be released soon this semester is really we expect them to do the reading on a topic and come do the activities online. That's how we're designing it.

Now, some people may say, well, that's useless. But in my mind, we tried in the old model where we have a bunch of text on the screen and then we give them activities. You know, I don't think that's an effective way to just look at the screen and read, as opposed to the technology is useful because we can do a whole bunch of activities using technology that we cannot do in a print form or anything. And that consolidates the concepts and gives them an opportunity to practice. So that's how we are approaching it. Now, I know some people have a different way to do it.

And that's fine. That's what the beauty of it is. We have diverse ways to look at it. Our focus is always on learning. So we'll see. So would you classify that as kind of a hybrid model in terms of combining the benefits of tactile interaction with materials with what you can do online? Yeah, that's a good way to put that. You know, we refer to our books in terms of sections to read or, you know, detail. There's no point in putting them on the screen again. And then they come back and then they do problems. They test their knowledge.

And they proceed. And then if there's a math application, they do the math part and so on, and they continue to proceed and see the progress. Great. That sounds wonderful. Yeah. Yeah, well, definitely, when that releases, we will do a blog post on it on our website. Blogoperator.org. Yeah.

Steve, did you have any more follow-up questions? This has been so fascinating. To be honest, I have not met you, so I didn't know what you did. But as someone who helps to design training experiences, I'm glad we got to have this conversation. Oh, thank you. That's very nice of you. Thank you. You know, we're going to bring up a few more things. We've gone pretty long. I'm sure you wouldn't mind if we had you back on to talk about the stuff that I brought up about maybe creating a certification for trainers. And I think we have a lot more we could talk about. And so as that moves forward here, yeah, let's plan on doing that.

Fascinating topic. It's so important, not only for water operators and wastewater operators, but in so many things we do in the world. Let's go there. My pleasure. All right. Well, thank you. Yeah, it's great to see you. And I appreciate your time. And congratulations on all your success with your programs and your department. And thanks for being on today. Thank you. Nice meeting you, Jennifer. Nice meeting you, too. I got more to say about what you're going to put on the web or on the page for the podcast, some of those things.

So we'll just conclude with asking you where our listeners can find you online, if you're on social media in a professional capacity or just your program's website. Yeah, the website is easy and we have a LinkedIn account and I don't know what's the address to it. We can link it up for you, yeah. It's owp.csus for California State University Sacramento.edu. Great. Yeah. Awesome. Yeah, again, thanks for spending time with us. Yeah, thank you. Nice meeting you.

Tap Talk is a collaboration between the Rural Community Assistance Partnership and the University of Illinois with funding from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. The show is hosted by Steve and Jennifer Wilson of the Illinois State Water Survey. You can visit drinkingwaterpodcast.org to find the full show notes for this episode.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Tap Talk?

This episode is 40 minutes long.

When was this Tap Talk episode published?

This episode was published on March 14, 2024.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Tap Talk episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.