Skip to content
TT047 — Hands-On Training: How to Develop the Water Workforce episode artwork

May 16, 2024 47 min

TT047 — Hands-On Training: How to Develop the Water Workforce

from Tap Talk

The latest episode of Tap Talk delves back into the topic of how to develop and train the newest generation of the water workforce. Jennifer and Steve talk with Matt Maas, the director of the Environmental Resources Training Center at Southern Illinois University Edwardsville. The ERTC is a one-of-a-kind facility with working pilot plants and laboratories that allow students to experience hands-on training throughout the entire certification program. Visit drinkingwaterpodcast.org to learn more and find the full show notes for this episode!

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

TT047 — Hands-On Training: How to Develop the Water Workforce

0:00 47:33
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

is really what sets us apart. The fact that we have a working-scale pilot plant and working laboratories where we're able to just constantly provide this hands-on training to students in a controlled environment. You're listening to Tap Talk, the drinking water in rural America podcast. We believe everyone has a role to play in protecting public health, and together we're connecting water and health professionals with ideas to extend and enhance our work. Whether you operate, educate, or regulate, this show is for you. Welcome to episode 47. In this episode, we're chatting about developing the water workforce through hands-on training with Matt Moss, Director of the Environmental Resources Training Center.

Well, today we have Matt Moss with us from ERTC, which to a lot of people, they're like, what's ERTC? So we'll let Matt share that. But it's a great workforce development program that many people probably haven't heard of unless you're in the water or wastewater business. And so you want to talk a little bit about more where you work and what's your role? Sure, sure. So my name is Matt Moss. I'm the director of the Environmental Resources Training Center. So essentially, I'm responsible for managing all center operations, managing staff, managing curriculum. In addition to that, I teach the mathematics and the water quality science portion, along with the communications portion of our program. The ERTC in general, essentially our goal is to prepare people for entry-level positions into the water and wastewater industry. And that's on the pre-service side, but we've also taken on a role on the in-service side as well. So our pre-service program is essentially a one-year program, a combination of hands-on training and classroom training. So we'll teach them the theory of drinking water and wastewater in the classroom. And then we also have three full-scale training pilot plants at 30,000 gallons per day. So small scale, but they'll be able to see.

all of the items that are needed with respect to different treatment plays, different chemical dosages, things along those lines. We also have two laboratories, one being a drinking water laboratory, the other being a wastewater laboratory. So our program ends up being about 50-50 with respect to the classroom learning and the hands-on portion of it. And that'll go through one year and then proceed on to internships. And so we'll arrange for internships both on the drinking water side and wastewater side. Additionally, throughout this entire process, we're training them for certification. So they'll be certified in drinking water and wastewater in both the states of Illinois and Missouri, and then try to push them out into the workforce. Generally speaking, we try to set up internships where the students can roll into a position afterwards if at all possible. On the in-service side, kind of the way that one works is

Those are the individuals that are already in the industry. So they may be looking for either continuing education credits to maintain their certifications, or they may be looking for some sort of training to upgrade those certifications. And so we'll assist on that side of the fence as well. So Matt, what do you love about your job and the work you do? Probably the biggest aspect is just, and I think pretty much anybody that's involved with education will give the same answer. And it's just helping is really, really the key.

And so whether we're talking about, for example, on our pre-service side, a lot of times we'll have individuals that will be right out of high school, don't really have a plan for the future, not really sure what they want to do. Sometimes we'll have students in their mid-20s that maybe they graduated high school, they didn't go to college immediately. They've been kind of bouncing job to job for five, six, seven, eight years, not really found a career path yet. And being able to assist them in getting certified, getting training, and getting into an industry where they're going to see a very competitive salary. They're going to see fantastic benefits. They're going to see about the best job stability that you can have in any industry. Those aspects are probably what I like the best on the pre-service side. And then on the in-service side, it's kind of the same thing, but in a different realm, right?

It's finding ways to help and assist operators that already have their certifications, but maybe they want upgrades and certifications. Maybe there'll be some sort of merit races associated to those upgrades and certifications or new job opportunities down the line from those upgrades. And so just in general, finding some way to help and assist people just so that they have a better professional situation. That's awesome. Yeah, it's a really unique place that I'll say, you know, from what we do, as far as listing all the different places that do on the pre-service side, train folks to become operators. So we always ask everyone we have on just for one personal fun fact about you that, you know, the rest of us would not know. We've gotten everything under the sun. So it's a wide open thing here. So to those that know me, this won't come as a surprise at all. But for those that don't, I'm kind of, I guess I'm a little bit of a basketball junkie. And so it doesn't really matter whether it's playing, watching, all things associated to basketball. If it's little kids shooting around at a court, I'm willing to watch. If it's the NBA, I'm willing to watch.

exception of water and wastewater, I spend the vast majority of the rest of my time either watching or playing basketball. That's awesome. I obviously follow Illinois. And we're in such a unique... We could talk basketball all day, probably. But right now, Illinois has two players on scholarship. I'm going to pretend to snore now because... I'm like, how do you do that when you're just an elite 18? But yeah, I'll figure it out. Yeah, the beauty of the transfer portal, right? No doubt. It has quite changed the game a lot, for sure. So Matt, we also like to ask our guests about their water hero. So someone who's worked past or present has influenced you or have been someone that you admired.

Yeah, actually, I've got a few. If I was going to pick one, probably Captain Mike Curry. He operates out of Nashville, Illinois right now through Curry & Associates. And probably the reasoning for that is both, it'd be a combination of his passion for the industry along with his longevity. So he was actually back in the mid-70s when everything first started rolling out with respect to certifications in the individual states. He was out in California, met with groups to kind of build and kind of create a path for state certification. He assisted IEPA in setting up these operator programs when the decision was made to build the Environmental Resources Training Center. He was integral with respect to the setup, with respect to the career.

for our programs. He wrote some of our textbooks on the math and the science side. Additionally to that, he was giving enough that he created a Patrick's Kirk Curry scholarship for students going through our program. And then even fast forwarding to modern day, he's been at it for a really long time. He still assists us with drinking water operations at ERTC. Anytime we have questions, he's willing to help. He still assists a lot of small systems with respect to planning, renovations, regulatory changes they need to adhere to. And then he still is constantly working with IEPA anytime they have updates with comment. So Captain Mike Curry from Korean Associates would be probably the person that I most admire currently. That's awesome.

And, you know, being in Illinois my whole life and being involved with this for as long as I have, I don't know, Mike, where I haven't heard that story. So, no, that is great. Yeah, folks like that are so important and really speak a lot about our industry, I think, and the type of people that are involved. Yeah, absolutely. And Steve, probably the reason for that would be he probably tailors more towards the drinking water side with respect to his work. And it's amazing. And I'm still amazed how you can have two items with respect to drinking water and wastewater that are so common, but so often so segregated with respect to the individuals themselves. So, yeah, yeah. Excellent. Excellent person.

So I knew that name sounded familiar. And we had a previous guest on episode five who also selected Captain Curry, which is Dave McMillan. Oh, yeah. Oh, sure. And the funny thing is, if I was going to select, if you gave me a list of five, I probably would have put Dave McMillan as one of my five. I've worked with him a lot through IEPA, actually, just the past two days. Got back from training with both Dave McMillan, Steve Vance, and Mary Reed from previous IEPA. We were training for IRWA. Yeah. Yeah.

Dave and I go way back, but I had forgotten that he mentioned Captain Curry. So, all right, well, interesting. So, today, we want to talk about workforce issues related to water and wastewater operators. You know, our audience is a broad audience. It's both private well and water and wastewater systems, you know, focusing on smaller systems. So, can you start really just by talking a bit about how someone becomes a certified water and wastewater operator?

Sure. So that one will, semi-loaded question in the sense that it will vary from state to state, right? So everybody has, each state, the second that they're delivered primacy from federal EPA, then they basically are responsible for creating their own operator certification programs. I guess I can speak a little bit to Illinois and Missouri, and we can kind of view it as just similar, I guess, throughout other states. Yeah, it's just, there's different specifics, like number of years or whatever, but it's really...

It's really about, you know, the fact that, you know, the license and some of those things. Sure, sure. As a general rule of thumb, kind of like the key points that you'll have to hit will be, there'll be some sort of education and experience requirement working within the industry. And then there'll be some sort of certification examination that will need to be passed in order to get into the industry. And that varies depending on what the student or the individual is interested in getting into. So, for example, almost in all cases in every single state, they'll have different levels of certification. A lot of times those levels kind of coincide with either types of treatment or just general operational aspects. And so as a general rule of thumb, if I was just going to use Illinois, for example, pretty easy to walk into on the drinking water side, a class D.

certification. And that class D certification really would just be essentially for a distribution system. So the hours are pretty minimal on that one. You're only looking at about 890 total hours of work needed for the experience portion of it and then passing of that class D certification exam. So once those two criteria are met, you'll become fully certified. Now, one thing that a lot of states will do, and in my personal opinion, this is fantastic, is in years past, a lot of times you had to meet the education and experience requirements before you took that certification exam. Now, a lot of these states have gone a route of what they would say more or less an OIT, an operator in training. And so an individual can move forward and take the certification exams prior to getting the education.

experience. True that they won't become a fully certified operator until they check all the boxes. But for anybody doing hiring, I can speak as a past operations manager. I'm kind of looking, will they show up? Will they do a good job? Will they get along with everybody? And will they be able to pass certification exams? And if by getting that certification exam passed as an OIT, they've already checked one of my three questions. That's one item I won't have to worry about. I won't have to worry about hiring somebody, them going through and getting the experience, but then failure to pass the certification exam and then they can't become a certified operator. So the fact that that OIT exists is something that's both very beneficial to the municipality or the business, but also really beneficial to the individual because they've already shown the aptitude that, hey,

I have the knowledge to pass the certification exam. I have the knowledge to become an operator. I just need the experience and that more working knowledge associated aspect. Once you're certified in one state, obviously it can vary from other states. A lot of times, especially if you're dealing with adjacent states or states that fall into a similar EPA region, you'll run into situations where they'll have some sort of reciprocity. So you can just complete an application. A lot of times it'll just be license for license. For example, I had a class A license in Missouri, applied for reciprocity when I came to Illinois. And based off of my experience and background, they basically just gave me a class A. I didn't have to do any additional testing or anything along those lines. That being said, when I bounced out to California, completely different. They acknowledged my education and experience, but I still had to take a couple additional classes and then their own individual certification exams.

We work with WPI on those very issues and have been for eight or 10 years. And it's, you know, some states are fairly frustrating, to be honest. And that's a whole other issue, I guess. That would be a whole episode for sure. It really would be, yeah. Well, we probably, we had WPI's executive director on already, and I'm sure we covered a lot of that then. For sure. Matt, you've already shared a bit about what ERTC is doing today, but can, and even some of the history with Mike Curry, but can you tell us a bit about how the program came to be? So anybody that's listening to this and is familiar with...

wastewater or drinking water. We're going to go back to 1972 Clean Water Act and 1974 Safe Drinking Water Act. And you had those two laws, those two laws came into place. And once that was done, Illinois knew, the state of Illinois knew that they needed some sort of training hub to just, I guess, exhibit competence in operators, right? To show that we did have competent operators. And so the decision was made that we're going to create some sort of training center. If you were to kind of look at the general geography of Illinois and decide where to put a training center, the answer probably wouldn't be Metro East or Metro St. Louis area, right? Like it makes more sense to have a hub near Chicago where your high population is, maybe a hub in Springfield where it's more centrally located, but the rationale and their decision-making.

process on this one was, first and foremost, they wanted to work with a major university. But secondly, they wanted a university that had their own wastewater treatment plant. And the rationale for that was they were going to intercept water from that wastewater treatment plant and bring it up to our pilot plants for training purposes. Having a university as one entity and a separate sanitary district that they had to work with simultaneously, they just figured that would be too difficult. The selection of Southern Illinois University Edwardsville kind of made it a one-stop shop. And so they only had to deal with one entity and thus made it a little bit easier. And it is very, very easy to work with the university and to make this work, since we are technically part of the university through the School of Engineering. So once that decision was made, as far as the location, 1975, so they operated very, very quickly.

was very proactive with respect to all of these aspects initially. And what they ended up doing was issuing a grant. That grant was for the creation of our building itself, as well as the pilot plant and the laboratories. From 1975 to about 1981, the vast majority of time was spent just getting everything built, getting everything squared away, and then developing the initial curriculum for our one-year program. First class would have been in 1981 with the graduating class of 1982. And then probably the other key point in our history would have been in 1984.

Through an Illinois EPA interagency agreement, we became responsible for the training of plumbers on backflow protection. So we performed all the training throughout the state of Illinois for cross-connection control device inspectors and the initial certification exams and renewals. What's unique is that you have an actual plant. We list probably 80 or 90 programs around the country that offer basically prep for exams. And most of them are junior colleges and most of them are just classroom. And I know you've been asked this question a dozen times, but I don't think there are any other places like ERTC where you have two wet labs. You guys do confined space training and you do everything operationally to prepare an operator to go in and work in a plant. And yeah, I don't know if just something to really point out. I didn't know if you knew of anything else out there like that, but there needs to be.

I mean, complete agreement with that statement. We definitely need more of them because even at full capacity, I can do 30 or 35 a year. And we obviously are going to need an infinite more amount of operators than those 30 or 35. With respect to other things that are similar, places have built, or I shouldn't say built, but have programs where I guess it's just not a one-stop shop would be the way that they've done it, right? They'll do the classroom training. And then generally speaking, what they do is they'll do some sort of partnership, some sort of apprenticeship, internship, whatever you want to call it. And the student will pick up time working at a water plant or wastewater plant. And that'll be the hands-on portion. And that's all good. It's very good. Where we kind of stand apart is when somebody's going through an apprenticeship or an internship,

The issues that may occur throughout a treatment process, they don't encounter those until they actually occur. And so you're having to try to learn while simultaneously dealing with problems in real time. With ours, what makes it so much better with respect to having this pilot plant where the water just returns back to the headworks of our wastewater treatment plant down the hill. So none of that water is discharged to the environment. None of that water is consumed by anybody out of our drinking water plant. So our students, we can allow them to make mistakes. So we can create scenarios where they might not figure it out or might not be able to get it right the first time. But after they run into some of these scenarios later on, they are prepared for them. And so hopefully our goal is kind of a sense of if there are going to be issues on the drinking water side or on the wastewater side, hopefully we can expose students to those and they can have some sort of idea.

as to how to correct those situations before it's really on the line and they're having to do it at all time. Yeah, no, I was actually, that was going to be the next thing, you know, the next question was about how your program is innovative or unique. And I know I hired a young man who hadn't found a job yet after he graduated from ERTC. It's probably been eight or 10 years ago, at least. And he was telling me some of the stuff you guys do, like the old go in and basically, quote, mess up the plant. So when they come in on a Monday morning, they got to figure out what's going on and why it's not putting out water that's potable or whatever it might be.

troubleshooting is just, you just said it, you just answered my question, but which I think is just really cool and certainly good life experience for someone who's an operator. But yeah, are there other ways that you would like to mention as far as how your program might be innovative or unique? Sure. So that is kind of on the unique side of the fence. That is really what sets us apart. The fact that we have a working scale pilot plant and working laboratories where we're able to just constantly provide this hands-on training to students in a controlled environment. As far as innovating, we kind of just ebb and flow with the industry, if I'm going to be honest. So it's interesting in that, I guess, for example, if I was teaching calculus, calculus has kind of been the same since forever, right? There's not a huge, I mean, if I were to grab a calculus book from the 1960s, it's not going to be too different from our day, right? Whereas if I were to grab a drinking water manual from the 1970s and then look at it versus today, it's going to be completely different. And so we have this constant change in the industry, for better, I would say, right? The smarter we get, we should be making advances.

in this industry and should be protecting the public and protecting the environment in more advanced ways when we notice problems. And so that's kind of our innovation standpoint is basically just trying to stay ahead of a lot of this. When we're trying to provide support to current drinking water and current wastewater operators, we are fully aware that they have their job to do. And a lot of times they don't have time to keep up with all of the modifications to regulations or new laws that roll out. And so we feel that it's kind of our duty to stay on top of that stuff and have collaborative trainings like I just had with IRWA or host our own trainings here locally or via Zoom and provide those trainings and keep them up to date with all of these changes. So I'd say that's probably the best way we innovate.

and wastewater, generally speaking, is kind of an old school industry. Because of the pandemic, we did kind of have to flip everything on our head a little bit. And so prior to that, we had no online offerings. Now, if we're looking at the drinking water side, it's all online offerings for our workshops and for our evening courses and things along those lines. That's a path that I think a lot of people went, but I think it's a path that was definitely the right path because in years past, all of the people that attended our courses, it was location dependent. So they either had to be near there or they had to take time off work in order to come there. The beauty of the Zoom is it doesn't matter if it's Illinois, Missouri. I've got a student that has a certification in Montana, Ohio. They'll still attend some of our Zoom courses because they'll get that Illinois credit so that they can maintain their Illinois certifications.

just being able to have those offerings and not having it location-dependent and just available to everybody, I think, has been huge for the industry and something that really didn't exist a lot prior to the pandemic. Things like Zoom, like what we're working with right now, kind of just fast-forwarded and fast-tracked everything and fast-tracked everything for the better. We just need all the certification stuff to catch up. Because, you know, the guy in Montana, we tell folks, you know, they can go on our website and find training in every state that's worth seeing using that state, but it might be on Zoom or another platform. We recommend that they contact the host, get their slide deck and see if the state's going to improve in advance if that's how that state works. Because, you know, they may be really interested in a particular topic, but they also want credit for it just because their time is so short in a lot of times. So, yeah, what a deal.

So part of the program is an internship, and I'm sure that's an important part because of the hands-on experience that you need working with others and actually being in the field. How does ERTC work with utilities to make sure that it's a valuable and effective experience for your students? It's kind of a combination. It's a combination of not just working with the utility. I guess the first step.

in our internship process is initially working with a student. And the main rationale for that is, for example, the student that I kind of just mentioned that's currently living in Montana, I need to know exactly where the student wants to be in order to provide them an internship that hopefully could potentially roll into a job for him. So my first step within this internship process is kind of day one when our students come in, I just speak with all of them and say, hey, if you're interested in staying close to home or you're interested in staying where you live, that's not difficult for me at all. I'll be able to make that work. But if you're interested in going somewhere else, please let me know. And we can kind of start that internship process right away. And so in his particular example, he came and told me, hey, I always travel to Montana for vacation. I love Montana. I want to live in Montana. And so right out of the gate, we started trying to

to set that internship up. We were able to get him an internship in Montana that rolled directly into a job. In speaking with the regulatory agencies there, they put me in contact with somebody that had a retirement that was upcoming. And so he basically just went through his 10-week internship and immediately rolled into a position. He's currently working as a foreman there now. So kind of that first step is just seeing where the students want to be and arranging it accordingly. With respect to the actual internship providers and the value that they provide for our students with respect to the hands-on, first check marks would be on the drinking water side, we want to make sure that we don't have a class D rated system. So we want to make sure that we have our students at a system where there's actual treatment being performed, not just a distribution system, just so that they can gain that additional experience.

And then on the wastewater side, we're kind of flexible with respect to that can be anywhere from a class one to a class four and still be all right. Generally speaking, I guess I can start by saying that our program's pretty intense throughout the fall and the spring semester. It's not really like typical college. Our students are here Tuesday through Friday from about eight o'clock till four o'clock. A lot of times that makes it difficult for students to have any type of consistent employment during our program. And so another thing that I try to do almost immediately is if possible, I try to get them paid internships. I know that they've gone probably in a lot of cases, nine or 10 months without any decent employment. And so we'll try to get them paid internships and we'll try to get them internships where there may be a position waiting for them afterwards. So when I first got on here,

A lot of the internships were more localized with some of the smaller municipalities. That's one thing that we've tried to modify a little bit in the sense that try to get students at some of these larger places where there's going to be more job opportunity. And there's also a little bit more specialization too. So in our entire goal with respect to those internships, what we're hoping for is a student to land in a position, whether it's smaller municipality or large scale, where they're going to be exposed to a bunch of different aspects of the industry. So if you go on a drinking water internship, you're not just going to sit with a drinking water operator the entire time. You might sit with a drinking water operator for a portion of it. You might go out in your distribution system. You might sit with a laboratory. You might work with mechanical maintenance. So we try to find places that are willing to.

all of them are, buying places that are willing to give our students a well-rounded internship. That gives them a little bit of an opportunity. If they haven't decided what realm they favor up to that point, they can maybe see, okay, in my head, I thought I wanted to be in the laboratory, but now I've just, I don't really like the laboratory. I really like working outside. I think maybe I would like to go a distribution system route. And so just having a combination of pay, potential positions on the hind end, and then a lot of flexibility and variability in their internship are kind of like the key points that we have with these internships. Awesome. And you just mentioned one, but...

How long have you been the director? And you just mentioned one of the changes you made. Are there any other changes you made since you've taken over the helm, so to speak? Yeah, so I guess my previous life was with American Water, and so I began working with American Water in 2002 and did that for about 15 years. And then various places, St. Louis County, Joplin, and then I was out in Sacramento, California for a while with California American Water before I came here. I came here in 2017, so I'm just finishing up our seventh class. As far as changes that have been made, modifications to the program, I think the internship is one aspect. We have kind of adjusted the way we do that a little bit. Some modification to the curriculum has been performed, most notably in the communications class that I teach. I quickly realized that we do a fantastic job of training water and wastewater operators, but we weren't doing a very good job on soft skill type stuff, so they were great water and wastewater operators.

Maybe their cover letters or resumes weren't adequate, and so they weren't initially getting an interview. Or if they were getting an interview, maybe they were bombing their phone interview or their in-person interview. So really having a focus where just in one semester, we're helping them with cover letters and resumes. I work directly with the Career Development Center. We come over, we do in-person mock interviews with the students. So hopefully if they've got a bad interview in them, it's with me and not when a job's on the line. So that was an aspect in the curriculum that was changed. And then I think probably the other pushes that I've really made are modifications to kind of the hard assets here, really going after grants, really going after donations for just improvements in our pilot plant and in our laboratories. The industry sometimes can get...

as I mentioned, can get a little old school. So I wanted to make sure that whether it's our pumps, whether it's our continuous analyzers, whether it's our laboratory equipment, getting that turned over to where we're using more updated technology, the technology that students are actually going to see when they get out into the real world and start working with the company. That was another huge, huge push. And then I guess probably the last thing that I've really pushed is advancements in scholarships. So just trying to work with, whether it be individual donors, whether it be with some of the larger businesses or municipalities in the area, finding some way to kind of lessen that burden on our students. Everybody knows higher education has gotten extremely expensive, kind of across the board, vocational trade schools.

included and to find some way to lessen that burden, especially if it's a program like mine where it's difficult to have a job as you're going through. What was one of my key points and probably a point that I'm really going to push hard here in the future as well? On that note, are there other challenges that you think lay ahead for the water workforce that you're preparing your students for? There's probably two main ones. The first one would be more...

I guess it's common throughout almost all industry with retiring of baby boomers. It's more common in our industry because with the start and the advent of our industry, which kind of happened late 70s into the mid, early mid 80s, that's essentially when all or a lot of water and wastewater operators were hired. So if you fast forward, let's say we're hiring people in their mid 20s, you fast forward to 40 years later, we're at a point where almost everybody that was hired initially into the industry will be retiring all at the same time, right? One larger business that we work with, one of their statistics is at this exact point in time, 60% of their operators are eligible for retirement. So at any given time, if something were to change, 60% of their operators could all just walk out the door immediately. And where that one gets so difficult in our industry is it isn't just a situation of we lost an operator, so we hire a new operator off the street and we're good. In a lot of situations, there almost has to be four to five to six years in advanced planning being performed. Because for example, if you are a class one rated facility on the wastewater side in the state of Illinois, you need to have six years of experience in order to obtain a class one license. So if you were to immediately lose a class one operator and

hire somebody off the street, you're looking at finding some way over that six-year period to get somebody that'll be willing to sign off on all of your MPDS permits before your person is eligible for that. So it's not just like a quick replacement process. And that's one area where I think we're going to get in a little bit of trouble here. I hope I'm wrong. I really do. But I could see a situation where we lose a lot of individuals, we lose a lot of knowledge, and those individuals are replaced. And not only is the knowledge lost, but we also have this little gap that exists where we might not have enough people around that could be the responsible operator in charge for individual districts.

The second one, I would say, would be more probably infrastructure related, I guess, would be the second item that I would state that's going to be difficult for our workforce going forward. And that's just kind of been a general problem with utilities. It's not really glamorous. I mean, I understand that if I'm a politician and I have $200,000, it makes a lot more sense for me to beautify our parks than to install a replacement water main. Like, I get that. But unfortunately, we've been going down that road for so long that we have this horribly aged infrastructure. We're going to start having some major issues. It looks like Congress is starting to realize, at least, you know, with some of these infrastructure bills and stuff, we're headed down the right path. I don't think it's nearly enough. I think we're going to have to get a lot.

more proactive with the way that it's done at the municipality and the business level. And I think that's something that's going to be extremely difficult for people going into the industry right now, because the industry can be difficult enough with just managing treatment change based off of water quality characteristics. If you're having to make modifications based off of issues with infrastructure, it's just that much more difficult. So I'd say both hiring and infrastructure are going to be the two things that are going to be the biggest challenges going forward. You mentioned hiring people off the street. One of the things, you know, our program, wateroperator.org, is really based on helping support smaller systems, those under 10,000 people, more likely better compliance, all those issues. We certainly see a lot of also when, you know, St. Louis needs an operator, they may hire somebody who comes from one of the smaller towns because at least they've got some experience. And, you know, you can't blame any of the small town operators. They get better benefits, better pay, all that stuff. But it's really just shifting the problem to the next town. And when you get down low enough to the really small communities, they're the ones that really struggle. Yeah, and I don't know that there's a solution to that.

I've always, when I was on the small systems division for AWA, I always said, you know, we need towns like St. Louis to work with, you know, 20 small towns around them and provide young operators to those towns so they can learn and then they can move in and move up and bring new people in. And eventually, you know, if there's a problem with that small utility, you not only have that operator, but you have all St. Louis' experience behind it, kind of a major league and minor league type of system. It'd be interesting to see. I was at a meeting at St. Louis University with one of the lead people at Water System for St. Louis.

And I asked him, I think he said they had about 60 operators, maybe. Does that seem right? And he said probably half came from smaller towns. And I wanted to do a survey to figure that out because I really believe there's a way there to have the St. Louis's of the world make it better for all the folks in the smaller communities. Anyway, sorry, I got off track there a little bit.

No, I actually think that's a good track to go down because I would be in complete agreement. It ends up being a huge financial impact on the smallers in the sense that they're basically providing all the initial training and passing on the finished product to, you know, the larger municipalities or the larger businesses. So they get stuck in this endless cycle of training and passing on training and passing on training, passing on, never really get anywhere. And then you have the businesses and the municipalities that are larger that are benefiting from. They don't have to do a lot of initial training because a lot of times the person will have a couple of years of experience already when they move on. It is a huge issue. And I don't know the right answer to it. What ends up happening a lot of times is the only true answer would be.

some sort of increase in pay, some sort of increase in benefits to try to get people to stick around. A lot of times the municipalities can't do that. You get this perfect storm of they have problems hiring and they don't have money available for infrastructure. And that's where you start rolling into this realm of a lot of the larger businesses, say, you know, the American waters of the world, something along those lines, taking over some of these smaller areas. Right. And so I don't know the right answer to that one. And unfortunately, I don't I don't know if there is. I think unless you had some sort of uniform pay and uniform benefits, everybody's always going to be going on to the greener pastures and you can't you can't fault them for going that route at all. Yeah, we'll just have to see.

Well, and, you know, like here, we're in Champaign, Urbana. We're also Illinois American Water. And they have taken over and started running some of the smaller systems around us. What I noticed as a customer, to me, it's a unique and it's a great approach. Everybody pays the same amount for their water, whether they're in Champaign proper or whether in Tolono or St. Joe or wherever. Some people would probably be like, well, it should be cheaper in Champaign. And maybe so. But by spreading that out that way, it does make it equitable and it allows them to provide equal service to everyone. And so I think, you know, for a small town, that's certainly not a bad solution that way other than.

so many small towns don't want to lose their autonomy. And they see not having their own, you know, being part of American water would be, we're giving up our autonomy to, you know, whatever. And, you know, that's always been an age old problem. And people just need to get over that too, I think. Yeah. I mean, I kind of understand like both sides of the fence, right? I worked with American water and did some due diligence. So I totally understand what's happening here. And I would agree with you that the beauty of being part of an American water system is just that ability to spread that cost. And so if you have five different small places, and let's say all of a sudden one place now has a PFAS problem and they have to install $5 million of treatment, and then that's going to be a recurring cost of $200,000. And you have to find some way to spread.

that over 80 to 100 residents, right? That's something that's very, very difficult to do. But if you can take that one area and have that incorporated in with a much larger customer rate base, it makes it a lot easier to spread that cost out. So yeah, would people in other areas be paying for that smaller area in part? Yeah, they would. But the beauty of it was they would pay for some of your stuff when you need to have something done, right? Like it all sort of balances out in the end. And you don't have these huge swings with respect to the rates that individuals are paying because you have that large rate base. You can keep a kind of, people will know and be able to expect what their water and their wastewater bills are going to be. Yeah, I think it's a decent model. Okay.

One other thing I guess we wanted to ask about was, you know, you said you can handle about 30 students a year. I mean, how do you attract students? Is there an issue there? Are you overflowing? How's business? I guess the question there.

So since pandemic, we've actually been down a little bit. And I think a lot of that was just because we weren't able to get out and really promote like we should. Where we're sitting right now is the vast majority of the promotion that I do will be, we've been getting, it has had been flowed. Previously, a lot of our students would come from, if the economy's bad, we'll get a lot of students that are coming from, say, like a WIOA program or something along those lines. We'll end up with a displaced worker from a different industry. A lot of times it'll be something that's comparative to our industry, maybe the oil and gas sector, maybe the steel sector, something along those lines. And they'll roll through our programs. More recently, it's been a lot of high school students that we've been getting. So a lot of people, if not directly out of high school, maybe only a year or two.

moved. And so a lot of my focus anymore has been going to those high schools. So I'll hit a lot of high schools here in our area. And we've done better in the sense that before I was attending the same type of college fairs as other four years. So there wasn't anything specific for vocational and trade. Here in the St. Louis area, they've done a fantastic job with basically like a technical career showcase. So it's a combination of North Technical High School, South Technical High School, and Eureka High School out of Missouri. And they hold three individual sessions. And it all is just primarily geared towards vocational and trades type positions. And where that works out so much better is when I'm sitting at a normal career fair, at least 50 different times, I have to explain how I'm a vocational.

vocational trade school at Southern Illinois University Edwardsville and not the School of Engineering at Southern Illinois University Edwardsville, right? Whereas when I'm at a vocational trade school, I don't have to make that explanation. The students that are going there know specifically what it is that they want to get into. A lot of times they won't want to go the four-year route. They're looking at a quicker path into the workforce. And so I'm getting a product or I'm getting students that are actually looking for my product versus having to try to sell my product. So in that aspect, it works really, really well. Additionally, like I mentioned, WIOA, I'll work with a lot of the job centers throughout Illinois and Missouri in trying to get WIOA funding for students. So if you have anybody displaced, they've got the opportunity to go through our program. A lot of times that charge is covered through the WIOA program. And then I'll go to...

water and wastewater conferences to promote our program to current water and wastewater operators, as well as these little sidebars of traveling with Illinois Rural Water Association or something along those lines, hitting some of the more rural parts of the state where we had some of the problems, you know, Steve, that you just mentioned with difficulties finding people and showing them that there is an avenue where if they can have a little bit of foresight and know that something's coming, maybe they pick a student and send them in our direction. And then they've got a student that's potentially trained and certified that's available for them within a year. So that's kind of like a key point that we've been hitting up. And in that case, they care about their hometown. Exactly. That's certainly what you see with most small town operators. A lot of them have lived there their whole life.

That's a great idea, actually. Yeah, but it's also a difficult one in the sense that for the infrastructure reasons and everything else, a lot of times they don't have the budget to send a student down here and have that overlap too, right? But it is one, if you could advise anybody with any water or wastewater operator that has an upcoming retirement, if you can find some sort of succession plan and preferably a succession plan before the actual retirement, right, to get that ball rolling, even if it's just a few months ahead of time, it can make a world of difference. I'm just curious, you mentioned this is your seventh class. How many of your students have been female in that time?

Yeah. And that's a great question. And it has trended up. So I would say early on, we were looking at 10 to 15%. Most recently, we've been around 25% of our students have been females. I would love it if the stigma kind of disappeared a little bit and we had more females in the workforce. They've performed extremely well. Almost all of them pass their certs. Almost all of them get hired almost immediately. So there is a strong, strong demand for kind of all levels in our workforce.

I wish we could find a way to attract more. We work with MSD and MSD actually has a specific, it's basically like a diversity scholarship. So that scholarship is specific to either females or minorities getting them into the water and wastewater industry. So that helps a lot with what we're able to bring in. And then we're able to, usually if with respect to the females in the industry, a lot of times it's either through that scholarship program or it's because they already know somebody in the industry and become familiar with the industry. So finding some way to further promote the industry, not just to females, but to everybody, I think would be huge.

As utilities, generally speaking, we're going to have to enter a different realm of promotion. In years past, we wanted to go under the radar, right? Because generally speaking, if someone hears about a utility, it's because something's going wrong. In my time as an ops manager, no one ever called me and said, thanks for the drinking water. It's awesome. It was always, you know, there's a main break. We don't have water or something along those lines. So no news was always good news in the utility industry. And we kind of operated under the radar. We're now with the infrastructure issues, with the promotion, with all of that, I think we're going to have to start making a little bit more of a push and making more people aware of what's going on. And I think that feeds right into attracting new candidates in our program as well with just that increased visibility in the industry itself.

It's so crazy that when you talk to anyone who is in the industry and, you know, where they started, whether they, you know, especially smaller towns, well, I never even intended to be in this industry, but here I am. Then they all talk about how much they love it and what it means and what the responsibility means as far as, you know, they're helping people, all those things. We certainly need a way to get that out there. And, you know, AVA's tried, WEF has tried, there's been all these programs and we still do a poor job of marketing ourselves and what we do. You know, we've tried. It's a crazy thing.

You know, we just had an American water truck drive by my window today, and I'm pretty sure it said on there, water is a value. So, I mean, I think that those types of relatively simple activities do make a difference. So, it's happening. Absolutely. You talked a lot about the challenges, the changes you've already made, and why they're important. Are there any other kind of mission statements you have to document your vision for the future of the program? Sure. I guess growth is always an answer. If I'm going to sit here and harp on the fact that we've got so many retiring operators that need to figure out a way to fill that void, growth will be a huge thing. What would it require for you guys to have 10 more students a year?

Yeah, so the issue that you run into with our program has nothing to do with the classroom portion of the program. My auditorium can seat 100 people. So there would be no issue with that portion. The problem is that the way that we establish and do the hands-on training, essentially what we're doing is we're splitting them into four groups. One group is responsible for laboratory and they'll operate in kind of like week-long batches. So for one week, one group will do laboratory. For one week, a group will do drinking water operations. For one week, a group will do wastewater operations. And for one week, a group will do mechanical maintenance. If those class sizes get too big, the students kind of are just falling all over themselves. It's very difficult to have.

if I had 50, to have 12 people standing around trying to rebuild a pump or something along those lines. Things like that just get difficult. If we were to grow, probably what you would end up looking at would be maybe a doubling in staff, and then we have some sort of cycle going where half of the group is doing hands-on training and half of the group is doing classroom training, and then we're just cycling through. In theory, we could accommodate 20 or twice as many students if we went that route. And that's kind of been, if we ever did reach a point where I was getting 40 or 50 applicants, that would probably be something that would be entertained. That's a difficult one, though, because for me to make that pitch, I would have to be under the assumption that's going to be happening consistently going forward in order to make those additional hirings. But in the short term, I could always...

that gap with adjunct lecturers or something along those lines. And we could just kind of build and see where it went. I guess constant renovations and constant innovations to our pilot plans in our laboratories is going to be something that just continues as far as the future. Our future in those aspects kind of just coincide with whatever the future of the industry is. So anytime there's a new laboratory analysis that needs to be performed, anytime that there's new continuous analyzers that are available, anytime there's new treatment that's available and new treatment technology, then we look at adjusting our training program and our pilot plan to incorporate that. And then I guess if I probably a year in...

If you would have asked if I could change one thing about the program, what would it be? I still would have that same answer. And that is just in general, with respect to higher education, it's so difficult for students to be able to pay for it nowadays. To arrange some sort of collaboration of businesses, municipalities, individual donors, organizations, just to create some sort of network where there was enough funding available that if somebody wanted to go through our program, they could go through our program for free and ERTC would still be getting money needed to function. That would probably be the end game. Like if I could check off that box, I'd be stoked when I left here. Right now, we've worked towards it when I first started working.

here. We didn't have any full ride scholarships. MSD will do up to three each year now. I've recently just had an individual donor, an anonymous donor that has given money for the next three years. We're going to have one full ride scholarship for our students. And then depending on whether or not it's successful, we might be looking at an endowment on the hind end that'll provide a scholarship each year going forward. So just finding some sort of bridge and relationship with those businesses and municipalities to create this for our students would probably be the thing that I would envision as what would be most successful for these students. Because a lot of times the students that we're getting, when you're looking at the vocational and trades, a lot of times those won't be higher economic status students, right? A lot of times they will.

need some sort of help. I guess to quote like Steve Galloway from New York University, I think the purpose of higher education isn't just like to bring on remarkable kids and to keep them remarkable, right? Like the whole purpose of higher education is to bring in some that may be less remarkable, but make them remarkable. That's kind of like the key. And so to just provide avenues where the cost of the program wasn't the hurdle that the student had to jump over to be successful, where it was just going through the program and learning material where that was the hurdle. I guess that would be probably the thing that I would really, really push for for the future. That's awesome. Well, it's a great program. We're big fans, obviously. Appreciate it. Yeah, we appreciate your time today.

Where can our listeners learn more about ERTC online? Sure, sure. So our website is siue.edu slash ERTC. If you can't remember that, if you just search SIUE ERTC, where the ERTC stands for Environmental Resources Training Center. So that's one play. And then if you just want to, if you're interested in the program, interested in training, just want to talk water or wastewater, you can always give us a call at 618-650-2030. Sounds good. And we'll make sure that's on the podcast notes.

And I make that available there. We have a page on wateroperator.org that lists all the programs around the country, as I mentioned earlier, that provide prep for certification exams. And your programs are listed there in Illinois and Missouri. Awesome. Thank you so much. Well, thanks for joining us today. Yeah, it was a good conversation for sure. So yeah, thanks again. Yeah, appreciate you spending time with us. Thank you, you too. TAP Talk is a collaboration between the Rural Community Assistance Partnership and the University of Illinois with funding from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. The show is hosted by Steve and Jennifer Wilson of the Illinois State Water Survey. You can visit drinkingwaterpodcast.org to find the full show notes for this episode.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Tap Talk?

This episode is 47 minutes long.

When was this Tap Talk episode published?

This episode was published on May 16, 2024.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Tap Talk episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.