There were hard copy CE request forms at every one of our conferences and people would have to write in or fill in the circle like an SAT, a Scantron, and then have a WEF staff member initial or stamp each session. And then we'd have to manually enter that information into spreadsheets and then physically mail out certificates and transcripts to each one of the attendees. You're listening to Tap Talk, the drinking water in rural America podcast. We believe everyone has a role to play in protecting public health. And together, we're connecting water and health professionals with ideas to extend and enhance our work. Whether you operate, educate, or regulate, this show is for you. Welcome to episode 50.
In this episode, we're chatting with Matt Jones, manager of the Continuing Education Credit Program for the Water Environment Federation. Our conversation highlights some of the unique challenges of delivering continuing education training to two different professional sectors, online and in person and across the U.S. and Canada. So today, we have Matt Jones from WEF with us. Matt, thanks for joining us. You have a very interesting job, and we're really excited to talk to you. I think we'll just get started. And so first of all, let's find out where you work, what's your role, what do you do in your job there at WEF? So I work with Water Environment Federation. I'm currently managing the Continuing Education Credits program at WEF. The goal of the program is to obtain continuing education credit approvals for our in-person conferences and online training. Then we track that participation, we distribute CE documentation to attendees, we report those credits to state boards, and we maintain all of the related files.
usually for about seven years, which is in keeping with the ISET guidelines. Yuck. Yeah, it's a lot. Yuck, Steve, we do this too. I know we do. You don't do the work of it. To hear it, it's like, oh my gosh, it blew my mind. Matt, what do you love about the work that you do? Okay, this is one question I have answered before, and I always feel like I'm answering in a very cliche kind of way, but I enjoy working for an organization whose main goal is to improve the world we live in. So our job is to help the men and women on the front lines of public health to do their jobs effectively, to make their lives easier. And the people I work with at WEF are exceptional.
And every one of them will tell you that the professionals that make up this industry are amazing, selfless and dedicated. That's enough for me. That's enough to keep me around. That's a great answer. And it's not cliche. I think both of us feel the exact same way. We're really making a difference, really helping make the world better. And I think there's no better reason to be in a job. So that's awesome. It's not for the money. No, I hear that too. We've had that same conversation. The consulting world's where it's at for that, right? Oh, what a deal. So we always ask everyone about a personal fact.
Fun fact about you, something that maybe the world doesn't know or even maybe some of your colleagues don't know that you want to share with everyone just who you are and things that you like and all that stuff. I mean, I like a lot of things. I'm kind of an outdoorsy kind of guy. But me and my partner just recently obtained our sailing licenses for vessels up to 22 feet in length. So we've been sailing a lot over the past few months. I mean, that's pretty new. So that would be a fact that a lot of my coworkers don't even know. That's cool. We have in Illinois, we're landlocked. We've got a small sailing club out of Clinton Lake, which you can look that up later. Yeah, I don't know how big it is, but it's not that big.
Sailing is an interesting thing. That's really cool. Good for you. I know it's a lot of work. We also like to ask our guests about their water hero. So someone who's worked past or present in water or public health that you've admired. So this is a tough one because there are a lot of people, a lot of candidates in my mind. But I would say that Jeanette Brown is one of the coolest, most intelligent, hardest working people I've ever met. And she makes it look easy. She's involved in a lot of things. And everyone that knows her just loves her. I know she was executive director at Stanford Water Pollution Control Authority for a number of years. I believe she's professor of environmental engineering at Manhattan College. She's heavily involved with WEF. She's just amazing. Awesome.
Very cool. We'll make sure to link her up in the show notes for the episode. Today, the reason we have you on is obviously because of the work you do for continuing education credit and really to talk about the challenges of doing that, especially on a national scale. I think the folks that train in a given state don't realize how difficult it would be to expand that, for one, and some of those things. So I guess if you can start, I know you already mentioned it, but could you share a little bit about WEF and in particular how WEF approaches this? Because WEF actually does a great job providing continuing education opportunities. And so I'll let you speak to that. Well, we really try.
Don't always feel like we're that successful, but I guess our successes do outweigh our failures. So WEF is an international not-for-profit member association that serves the water industry through publications, conferences, and networking opportunities. The major goal is improving water quality around the world. Our approach to offering continuing education opportunities is kind of simple. We offer training events and online courses as a core part of what we do. Those just happen to be, mostly the content happens to be relevant for continuing education credits. We just take the events that we are already going to offer and the courses we already have online, and we try to get them approved at the state level nationally. It's a simple approach, but not a simple process.
Now you have a lot of different types of individuals as members. Are these continuing education opportunities just for water and wastewater operators? Are we also talking about other licenses like engineers? Oh yeah, we absolutely handle two major professions within the water industry. So I don't know the exact number, but it's probably something like 60, 40, 60% engineers are members and 40% operators. So we are offering continuing education credits for both water and wastewater operators and professional engineers. For most of our events, it's both. For a few of our events, it's just for engineers because the topics of discussion are directed just for engineers and engineers are the only ones that attend those events. There's not many of those.
We'll get more into some of the technical things, but how, if we're talking, I mean, 50 states plus tribes, territories, and all that, how many of those are within the same organization, the professional licensing, and how many are different parts of the state? So I think we did the count a few years ago. We're working with 112 licensing boards because we're working with 50 state licensing boards for wastewater. I believe there are or were 12 states that had a separate water licensing board from their wastewater department, and then we have to answer to 50 state engineering boards. So it's around 112 licensing agencies that we work with.
For the most part, we don't have to do too much work on pre-approval for events for engineers because most of the engineering boards will accept web credits as they should. But there are some states like New York and Florida where we have to go through pretty lengthy processes to do a triennial and biannual re-approval of our ability to offer credits or training credit approval, provider approval. The real work is for operators, wastewater and water operators to get events approved for them. And in fact, and it surprises a lot of people, it's more difficult to get approval for water and wastewater operators than it is for engineers. Well, and I think we'll get to this question of, you know, next steps. I wonder if there's things that we can learn from the engineering side. Good point.
What is the history there and what is the history on the operator side and what crossover could be shared? I'm not sure why they're more lenient. It used to be when I first took this over about 15 years ago, it was more lenient to get approval from states for water and wastewater operators too. I'm starting to see a trend where engineering boards are discussing having an approval process where they didn't have one before. And they contact us fairly frequently and ask us our opinion. And our opinion is usually, I don't do that. Just keep it the way it is. But that's a selfish answer.
No, it is. But it's interesting that it's going that direction. I'm also not surprised that, you know, particularly as we have more technical capabilities to do all of this oversight, there's often interest in doing it to make sure that everyone's doing what they're supposed to be. Even with those boards, you can develop a relationship. I know when we put on our first virtual conference last February, and one of the states made us go through this lengthy process, even though they were RCAP speakers. And they said, well, you know, the RCAP region would have applied. We fast track them because we know that, you know, that they're providing a training. And hopefully that happens as well with WAF, I would think, given your history.
I have noticed that in the past, sometimes when we've been dealing with someone for a number of years and they've gotten to know us and then they leave the licensing board, we have to deal with somebody new, which is great. But a lot of times they are dotting every I and crossing every T and holding us accountable as if they don't know who we are. And they don't, I guess. Yeah. And I guess one of the things I wanted to bring out was, you know, the difference between what WEF does versus a lot of the approval folks do. A lot of the trainers, you know, we work with like 900 trainers, you know, on wateroperator.org, our website, we go out to 900 websites to pull training information.
But 99% of those, or at least 97% probably, are training in one state, I guess. And so, you know, the unique challenges you have there, and if you want to go into a little more detail about that, are really what's different. And not only you already touched on it, but also that it's more than just the United States. Right. Oh, do you do this outside of the country, too, in terms of? Canadian member associations. That's right. Just, I mean, we've done it a little bit in the past, but in the past year, year and a half, we're really focusing on making sure that, at least for our larger events and online training, that we are also applying for approval in Canadian provinces. They've asked us to do this.
Mostly people we've met at the WPI conference from Canada have asked us to apply for approval. We're happy to help. It's just more work. Their systems are pretty robust, fairly strict, like a lot of the more strict states. But that's a good thing. I'm not exactly sure if this still applies, but there was a time where if you got approval in one of the major provinces, it applied to most of the other provinces. And that's something that we could learn from Canada. A couple of states that do that on the water side, I think. There are a few states that have just recently started doing that on the wastewater side as well. It's mostly like a regional thing where a neighboring state that maybe doesn't have this.
as much or many resources is using their neighboring state's more robust system. So if that state approves something that WEF is applied for, they'll accept that approval. So it's kind of a training reciprocity in a sense. And we would love to see more of that. Just a few years ago, we thought that that would never happen. And so we're starting to see that in two areas of the United States. And we're hoping that things go that way more often. For those who don't know what this process really looks like, we know because we're both doing things at the same scale. But for our audience out there, which includes those in drinking water, as well as those in wastewater, private wells, public health, we have quite a broad audience. Can you tell us more about what the process looks like?
And I think also kind of a volume number would be helpful here because even Weftech alone is how many different presentations then are you getting approval for? So we go through the same process as any other training provider. We've got to fill out applications when states have applications. We've got to compile all of our event content. That includes everything from detailed agendas and session descriptions to full bios for all of our speakers. And then samples of all our documentation, CE documentation and our SOP for selecting sessions through subcommittees and things like that. So for Weftech alone.
We usually have around 20 full-day workshops, around 130 technical sessions, six or seven off-site facility tours, and three days' worth of exhibit hall time that are available for credits in some states. So people can track their time by scanning their badge when they enter the exhibit hall and when they leave the hall. So a lot of different things that they're scanning for. Yeah, I didn't know that. Just for example, we had over 3,000 people scan at WebTech 2024 recently. And each one of them, well, the average was about 10 scans per person. So there were over 60,000 scans that our system had to process for just WebTech. And that's, you know, what, 15% or 20% of the attendees?
It's actually closer to 30%. There's two different numbers. There's the number of total attendees, and then there's the number of people that pay for full conference to attend tech sessions and workshops. It's about 30% of that number. But yeah, it's a little bit less when you add in the full number. Yeah, no doubt. But a lot of those people aren't people that would be licensed professionals. Sure. But I would say that the biggest difference I've noticed between WEF and most of other training providers is that our in-person events are large, multi-day conferences. It makes it more difficult to complete applications or report those credits, especially using online systems, because most of the systems weren't designed with these types of events in mind.
We've talked with several state representatives that have implemented the online systems. And they told us that when they developed their system, they weren't thinking of three to five day conferences that had this many types of sessions and where partial credit could be given for sessions and things like that. So we've had to work around these systems a lot. And fortunately, the states have been very willing to work with us for the most part. But it does make it tough. I bet it's a lot of extra work. It is. Yeah, because you mentioned seven years. You know, it's just it's just it's a it's quite an animal in the end.
So, again, going back to our first experience last year with the virtual conference we held, I think we ended up with 42 states, maybe, Jennifer, is that right? Who we had credit from, we didn't get all 50. And so hopefully we've learned from that and we're doing more this year earlier to get ready for next February. But how, I mean, do you typically have credit in all 50 states? Well, that's an impressive number, I have to tell you, that you got that many. Yeah, we typically get 47 is our average. We shoot for 50, of course. This year we got 47 and British Columbia. Okay. So it's a lot of work. Yeah, there's a lot of...
There are a few states that don't really have an approval process in place. I think Alabama and Virginia don't require a pre-approval. Oh, sure. Yeah. That number includes the states that where they either said on their website or directly to us that the certificate would be acceptable there. I think it just has to meet, the content has to meet their guidelines. And I'm sure yours does. Ours typically does as well. Well, we had 12 talks. So that's for over three days. So I don't envy what you have to do. That's for sure.
Well, and we've had quite a journey with this because we started trying to get pre-approval for a self-paced class a number of years ago, pre-pandemic. And of course, everything was different then, and it was self-paced. So it was just almost a different animal completely. Just to your point, I was going to say that pre-pandemic, there were states that wouldn't accept online courses for continuing education credits. And that has changed across the board, obviously. And now there's so much content available online that I'm sure the states are inundated.
with approvals for online courses at this point, which might be why a lot of them are looking for online systems to kind of push the work back onto the training provider or more of the work onto the training provider and weed out some of the less applicable courses that are out there. Just a thought. When the pandemic started, we had vendors, some of the companies that usually have salespeople who go out and do meet with folks and stuff, contact us and say, we're going to do a webinar. Why aren't you putting us on your website? I'm like, well, we don't put webinars that are just for a company who is making a profit all this. Unless they go get CEUs. Yeah, so it's got to be CEUs. And I bet I talked to 12 or 15 different companies and said, if you go even get credit in one state.
we'll list it for that state. Only one did it. And he contacted back, you know, four months later and said, well, we went through this in this state. And so we listed it because, you know, our job is to support water and wastewater operators, not a company that's making money off of the community to do that. Our event is free. And then you've got some of the states who want us to pay for all that, which, you know, not usually a huge amount, but if there were 130 sessions, that would add up, I imagine. That's right.
That's right. I think there was a state that used to not have a fee, but they did have an application. I'm not going to throw any states under the bus. They began charging a $1,000 a year fee to be approved for the year, which I'm sure sounds great to some people. But if we do that math, if every state followed that, we'd be paying $50,000 a year to be approved just for each year. And that would not work for us. And to your point about the companies coming to you and asking to help you get something approved or to put something on your site, we often get exhibitors at our events, especially WebTech.
ask why they can't give continuing education credits for people that stop by their booth. And they think that they can piggyback on WEF's approval for WEFTEC. And we get that request a lot and we have to explain to them. So even people that are deep in the industry don't understand how that kind of thing works, which is surprising to me a little bit. Well, I think as we mentioned that online training wasn't even often approved pre-pandemic. Things have continued to change. Even last year and this year, we're seeing different requirements. So even those who maybe were more informed at certain points, their information may not be valid anymore.
Have you had difficulty with states not approving certain topics that maybe, like, they felt? So, you know, you have this agenda. You said 130 sessions. Well, these states will approve 126, and these will do 130. Happens all the time. Actually, it happens all the time. So for states like that, what we do is we provide them a spreadsheet that has all of the session detail in it. And what they'll do is they'll go through our spreadsheet because it makes it easier for them and just kind of mark the ones that are approved.
Tracking system doesn't allow us to not give people credit for specific sessions for a specific state. We kind of have to have one system that fits all state needs. When it comes to reporting, it gets complicated because if somebody attended sessions that weren't approved in their state, we kind of have to try and weed out. If we're reporting to that state, we have to weed out the things that weren't approved by them. A lot of that is some DE&I topics are often not approved in a lot of states. Some states don't approve management type training or financial based sessions.
Some states have it listed in their application that they'll only approve technically-based sessions that are directly related to the daily operation or design of a facility. So anything outside of that, they would consider not worthy of CE credits in that state. How do you handle that on the participant side? I guess when I go to WEF every year, I usually attend a couple of sessions, but most of the time I'm there on the exhibit hall. I've not noticed that, is there a tag on a given session that says it's not available in whatever state? Or is there a disclaimer in the big booklet that comes out that says somewhere in there? I'm sure it does, I guess, but... It actually doesn't.
It actually doesn't because there are 50 states and each one of them is going to have their own set of sessions that is approved, whether it's all of them or a few are missing from their approval list. What we do is on the website, on the webtech.org site, we try to put, we have like a list of states and if you click on your state, it'll pull up the doc, if it's been approved in that state, it'll pull up the documentation that's either directly from the state if it's a scanned approval letter or if it's like the list I told you about, the session listing that details which sessions are approved or not. So if somebody wants to know what sessions are approved, we make it available to them, but it's not really in their face. They have to go looking for it. They have to open up the website. It's a lot of work, but we do our best to inform them. But outside of that, I mean, you've been to website, there's signage everywhere. There's so much to read. People miss things that are right in front of them all the time. So you're still doing diligence in my opinion there though. Yeah, that's the intent. Yeah. I think anything related to this and printed materials is kind of incompatible because things are so fluid. You know, we got approval for one state for our February 2024 conference last month. And we're like, this is, it's been eight months.
And then other states also ghosted us completely. And, you know, we paid and never, they never did anything. So, but it's been, I can see why web-based information would be the best way to communicate. Yeah, it really is. It's probably not ideal to some people because they'd want to know right then and there on the spot. But it would really be impossible for us to have that level of information at every session or in every area that it would apply. It would just be too much to read. People would walk right by it.
Oh, sure. Yeah, no, yeah, that's my bad. When I'm looking for presentations, I might want to tend to or when the small systems group is meeting or whatever. But I can, you know, there's ways to get that out, too. I mean, I'm thinking about us. We could put in our September newsletter, you know, just a blog post about how to find out which CEs are available, blah, blah, blah. I'll make sure and write that down because we will certainly support WEF in that effort. But the more information people have, the better. Oh, that would be a big help. Yeah, sometimes getting people to the right place to get the information that exists is half the battle. Just to click on the right website. Yeah, that's right. To this same point or to this topic.
There are a lot of states that do not approve the exhibit hall time for credits. In fact, most states do not. But surprisingly, some of the bigger states that have very strict approval policies, they actually do accept those credits. And it still to this day surprises me who accepts them and who doesn't. It really varies from state to state. So like everything else. So outside of Weftec, are you seeking free approval for operator CEUs for every single event? Is there like a scale which you just only issue certificates?
We issue certificates for every event, even if we've only gotten approval in one state. A lot of the times, not a lot of the times, but sometimes states will allow or accept our credits. If we haven't gotten approval in that state, they'll allow operators to submit after the fact if they've got documentation from us. And sometimes they'll end up approving an event that's already been delivered. The other thing is we've got both operators and engineers attending. And since most states accept our credits for engineers, we don't know necessarily if our attendees are engineers or operators when they attend. Some of them are both. Some of them are licensed in multiple states in both professions. We just have to give them documentation and hope that they're able to submit it to their state and have it accepted. We do have kind of a scale that we used to try and get approval for all of our special or smaller specialty conferences. It ended up being way too much work and it didn't actually make much sense from a practical standpoint because there weren't always people attending from every state. So what we do is a couple of months out, we take a look at the registration list.
And we try to get approval based on who's already registered for each event. So in those states. That's a great idea. So just spoke about how much work this is. How many staff work on this? For the longest time, it's just been me. Oh, my. I do have some backup from my department, but my department mostly handles the delivery of these events. But they've been great. Whenever they have time, they back me up. But about a year and a half ago, we hired somebody to kind of help with what I'm doing for the in-person events. And Stephen Massa, who's taken over our online training portal to assist him with the same thing. So continuing education credits for both. And she's been a blessing to us all.
So I would say now we have two people dedicated to this at WEF. It still doesn't seem like enough. I'm surprised, in all honesty. How long have you been doing this position? I'm in, I believe, my 15th year doing this. I've been with WEF for 21 years now, but I started doing other things, like I started on an EPA grant for BSAT training years ago. But that's how I was exposed to the CE credit side, because I had to get the workshops that we were doing approved in every state. It was a little simpler when you had the EPA stamp on everything to get approval. And then when the grant commenced, they asked me if I'd stay around for this position. So yeah, I've been doing this for about 15 years.
That's awesome. I'm assuming that the technology that you've used to support the Endeavor has evolved in that time. You mean from WEF standpoint or? Yeah, in terms of tracking everything. I mean, were you even scanning badges 15 years ago? Yes? Just starting? I think we might have just started for like WEF tech maybe 10 years ago. It was all hard copy when I first came on. So there were hard copy CE request forms at every one of our conferences and people would have to write in or fill in the circle like an SAT, a Scantron, and then have a WEF staff member or room monitor initial or stamp each session.
And then we'd have to manually enter that information into spreadsheets, mail merge, and then physically mail out certificates and transcripts to each one of the attendees. Yeah, I can't even imagine going back to that. It's all badge scanning now for our conferences. So when people arrive at the conference, they show ID, they've usually paid already, or they register on site, they get a badge, and then they scan that badge when they enter and exit each session. And that's how we track. Wow. Yeah, the good old days, right? Yeah. We still have, because of the seven-year thing, we still have some of the hard copy forms on file for our specialty conferences.
Because we started with Weftec and then we started adding the larger specialty conferences and then into the smaller events. But now it's everything that gets scanned. Is it accurate to say the work has transferred from the back end to the front end? Because there's all the pre-approval effort now that maybe wasn't a thing then versus the alpha manual labor afterwards to deal with those requests? I guess it has. It was kind of just coincidental that states started to get more strict with their policies or enforcing their policies. At the same time, the technology kind of arrived. So it was just kind of an even switch for the workload distribution, I guess.
So Steve led into this earlier about attendance if you didn't provide CEUs and didn't go to this effort. It sounds like maybe your engineers would still come, but maybe not the operators. How do you think that it would affect attendance at Weftech and other events, including online events, if you didn't go to this effort? So we have talked about this in the past. We can't really be sure how it would affect attendance. I think the number I gave earlier was about 30% of our attendees actively seek continuing education credits for Weftech.
So if we assume that they wouldn't attend without receiving continuing education credits, that would be a big negative impact to our attendance overall. That number is actually larger for our specialty conferences. It's about 40% of our attendance or our attendees ask for CE credits. So they actively seek them, which means they're intentionally scanning their badge in and out of sessions because they don't have to to enter, but they have to get the CE credits. So that would be a huge impact. We don't know if this is a deal breaker. Like we don't know what that number would be, like how that would affect percentages as a deal breaker for people. For online courses, everyone who completes a course gets a certificate of completion, like a CE credit certificate. So we assume that when they're shopping.
for courses that they're looking for that as well. But we don't really have any numbers or surveys on that at the moment. That sounds like a great idea to do a survey. Yeah, that is a good idea, actually. I'm writing that down. I just did. Yeah, actually. That'd be really interesting. So really, it comes down to, because you're doing this on a national scale, you're doing 50 times the worker and plus with engineers, many more than some local trainer or even a state, you know, RCAP group or Royal Water Association who are only training in their state. So that's kind of what makes it.
more difficult. We've already discussed that. So could you talk a little bit more about like some details on the range of requirements and guidance that states have? Like, you know, some states require the seven years and others, you know, may require just a bio or some may require something different or whatever, you know, both good and bad. I mean, shout out to states that are doing things that make it easier for everybody too. Agreed. I mean, just an email is always nice, but I would say that's few and far between at this point. That's right. I mean, it used to be a lot more like that, kind of the handshake approval, a phone call or an email.
The biggest issue is obviously that there are no national standards for approval or a singular process for obtaining credit approvals for the water professionals. Working with 50 individual states, multi-professions, multiple credit types is another issue. There's a whole list of things that are essentially a CEU, but states want to call it something else for whatever reason. Well, even like distribution versus, you know, some states go to that detail. Oh, and even like, you know, the individual will come back and say, well, I want to apply four of these hours to my treatment license and the other six to my distribution license. And so I need to have that set on the certificate. I need two certificates.
And we don't really have a system that is able to distribute that level of detail. So we leave blank spaces on certificates for people to handwrite things in because we don't have another way of doing it. There is programming available for that level of tracking and issuing credits, but it costs a lot of money to do that. And we always joke that we don't have NASA money. If we did, we might be able to do that. I don't know. So one of the big things that we run into is that states, a lot of states want the information, the application and all of the backup materials 30 days in advance of an event, some 45.
There's one state that has a 90-day before the event submittal timeline. We don't have that information available 90 days out a lot of the times. It's certainly not in a completed format. It would be templates and drafts at best. So that can really complicate things. We're racing to get approvals in the last minute a lot of times. There are a lot of difficulties. Is that something you all have faced? We've tried our best to, you know, the deadline even to submit all of the presentations for our February virtual conference is actually tomorrow because of the few states that want to actually see the content in addition to the bios and the outlines.
as early as we can get things done. We've tried to, but we're also dealing with a different scale for sure. Yeah, we had 533 attendees and I think like 380 wanted CE credit. Oh, wow. And so it's great for a first event, but it's nowhere near the scale. So, I mean, and we're just learning this. You've been dealing with it and all the changes for many years. So I certainly appreciate all that, learning that from you. And so one of the other questions here we discussed was what happens from one year to the next? We've noticed, Jennifer mentioned it earlier, some states already have different procedures this year than they had last year.
We have to deal with, you know, the requirements from last year don't work this time. Do you come across that a lot? We do. And unfortunately, states don't really reach out to let training providers know. I mean, that would be a big job. So we usually find out in real time and then we have to change our whole process or like we're in the middle of doing it this way. Now we have to stop and change things. We have to download their application. We have to learn what they want us to do. A lot of times it's even just the contact. We'll be contacting somebody via email that's no longer there.
We don't find out until it's almost too late that we should be talking to this other person. So we end up having to make a lot of phone calls to find out who the right contact is. I would say that the range of requirements goes from like what you all said, kind of the phone call or email approval to the very complicated application process with a fee supplying all of the background or the backup material, content and everything, bios. And then the requirement that there's post-event reporting. Sometimes that's online and those systems are pretty complicated as well. And if you don't do the post-event reporting, you can lose approval.
We've run into that a few times with a few states where they've said if we didn't get the reporting within 15 days after an event to the state, that we could be looking at trouble. So that gets difficult. We no longer customize our approval process for each state because that would actually be more work. We come up with all of the content and all of the material that would be needed by the most strict state requirements. And we provide that to every state. That's what we've done, too. It seemed like every application we were just adding more and more things. And I'm like, OK, by the end of this past year, we have, OK, this is the maximum that anybody could possibly want. So let's start there now for this year.
That's what happened to us. Easier-ish. It does. But yeah, you kind of learn that on the way. That's exactly what they did. That it's easier to come up with the one model fits all. How have the online submission processes and different various applications that the states are using that may or may not be well integrated with other things, how has that helped or hindered the process? Does it make it easier or is it actually harder than just emailing somebody an application and some attachments? I prefer the just emailing with attachments. That's what I'm accustomed to. But the online system, it's a little bit of both because some of the systems do seem to put more work on the training provider. And then other systems, it does simplify the process a little bit.
It's really dependent on the state and how their system works. Just keeping track of all of the state sites and all of the login credentials that we've got to use to log into these systems, aside from learning how each system works, because they're all different. They're all completely different. And they're not always intuitive or user-friendly. So I would say that has helped. I feel like it has overall created a little bit more work from our perspective as a training provider. Oh, I bet. We talked earlier about most of this is done before the event, but then there's also all the stuff that has to be done after. And you mentioned that a minute ago. With the 15 days. Yeah, that can be. I don't know if you want to speak to that or some of the, I'm sure, really a challenge to try to get everything out.
as soon as possible after the events are over. It can be. So like I mentioned with WebTech 2024, just over 3,000 attendees scanning over 60,000 times in total. There are bugs that need to be worked out to make sure that some of the scanners for maybe a session weren't working properly or the data wasn't collected properly. So we have to make sure all of that is accurate before we distribute the documentation. Sometimes we need a little bit of time for that. We need a week or two. And that puts us really close to the 15 days that some states are requiring that level of reporting. Then we have to take the documentation from the vendor that operates our scanners and...
keeps all this information for us. We have to take that reporting and then make it workable for the states. The states that require just a spreadsheet are a little bit easier, but then there are states that have online systems for reporting. And a lot of times those can be complicated because they don't match up with the way we track. Some states have a system where anything that's approved, they can only offer full credit for it. But our sessions, the way they work is people can get partial credit for attending half of the session when it comes to the technical sessions and workshops. They can get partial credit, but their systems don't allow us to report partial credit. So we have to go around the system and work directly with our contacts there anyway. When you mention a session, a session...
It's four talks, three talks, right? Right. I just make sure it's clear to everybody. Oh, right. That it's not an individual presentation somebody's getting up and walking out of. It's that they're interested in two talks, but they want to go to another session and listen to the other two talks there. And so they're not staying in one place. And so I can't imagine how you work that out along with some folks who are in states where they only approve some sessions. It's always complicated. And we're very often dealing with individual customers on a case-by-case basis based on what their state needs are. So yeah, never ending the workload here. So I guess that's job security, right? Well, that's for sure.
So I'm assuming if your experience is like ours, that you have some states where you have a course ID for WebTech 2024 and then other states where you have a course ID down to every single one hour block of time or even a four hour session. Yes, there are states that require that we have a different approval number for each session and workshop at WebTech. So absolutely adds another level of complexity to reporting out to those states or creating documentation that will work that we just can't because somebody has attended 22 events or 22 sessions within one of our conferences. That certificate would be four pages long. Yes, yes. She's smiling because she's feeling your pain.
No, I get it. And I also don't quite feel that pain because we're not operating on that scale. So I'm actually impressed that you said that you loved your job at the beginning just because you must have just a great attention to detail and a love of perseverance. I mean, if it wasn't for the states really being willing to work with us, we wouldn't be able to do this at all because they, admittedly, some of their systems just aren't designed for the types of events that we offer. And AWWA as well, we've heard it from them, that it just, they're looking at one or two day in-state workshops for the most part. When they were developing their systems, they weren't looking at organizations that would need national level approval for a multi-day event with that many sessions related to the delivery. So yeah, if they weren't willing to work with us, I don't know what we would do. I guess we wouldn't be offering credit in some states.
Yeah. So with that in mind, what is needed for national organizations like WEF to create a better way of obtaining CEU approval? Maybe there's the, what is realistic? And then what is Matt's dream? I definitely have a dream, but I don't think that that one's ever going to happen. So this is probably the toughest question that always gets asked in the CE credit realm. I'm not sure there is an answer for it. So, okay, we joke around a lot at WEF, at least in our little department, that the more questions you ask, the more questions you get. There are rarely answers.
But that being said, if organizations like WEF and WPI could help states develop a single standard for approval that could apply nationally, that would be a huge win for the industry, I think, as a whole. I'm not sure if that's ever going to happen. But like I said earlier, there are some regions that have had continuing education credit reciprocity, for lack of a better term, and that seems to be working well for those states. Some states just don't have the resources to review that other states do. So if a state has a really robust system that seems to be working, it would make sense to me that they would just rely on that state's system to also offer approval for that event.
It's happened regionally a little bit in two regions. There's only a handful of states that have allowed for this, but I would really like to see it go that way. Maybe that could lead us to eventually to a national standard, but it would definitely take the assistance. It would take time and the assistance of groups like WEF and WPI to kind of see that through. We see a few examples. You know, there's, you know, the New England section of AWBA, New EPIC. They train in multiple states regularly. They've developed those relationships. So that's, again, and I think some is even in statute, maybe. So it's, you know, that's, we find that, or I find that as one of the big hurdles is some states have specific rules in their legislation that make it difficult for them to change anything. It would take that kind of thing. It would take legislation to change a lot of states' policies in this regard. And I don't think that, I don't think groups like the EPA ever want to get involved in kind of mandating anything like that because they don't want to.
mess with states' rights, and rightfully so. But it would be fantastic if the state boards could just get together. I know it's not that simple. It's easy to say. I wish they could all get together and just agree on maybe the strictest standards compiled. It would be easier to get approval using these strictest standards, even more strict than we're using now, or the most strict state in terms of requirements. It would be easier to do that one time, even if they upped the ante on that, than it is to get approval in 50 different states, even if those states were easy to get approval in.
Does that make sense? It does. It does. Like you're putting together something once and then saying, I think even if an entity were to create something like that, that is as strict as the strictest or stricter, if we could get states to say, yeah, we'll take that super hard one or you can do whatever our normal thing is. Because if you've already done the hard one, you've done the work. And I'd love to just be able to submit that to you. Absolutely. I would do the extra work gladly if they upped the ante on how strict the requirements were.
WPI actually did something like this for online training a few years back. They were approving online courses. I think they became a certifying agency and were approving courses for online. And their goal was to get states to buy into that. And they got quite a few states to buy into that. So if you got approval through ABC at the time, WPI now, then it was approved for an online course. Then it was approved in all of the states that had bought into that. I think that program has gone away. Yes. I would love to see that come back and maybe even apply to in-person events, but that's my dream.
Yeah, I mean, we use that model to, we use their requirements to start our applications for our online course, because we knew that was perhaps the strictest standards that were out there for online self-paced at the time. And by the time we were ready to submit it to them to get that, you know, additional approval in other states or, you know, by acceptance reciprocity, they weren't doing it anymore. I think the pandemic shook things up in there too, so. You know, and WPI has done a lot of work looking at reciprocity for states for certified operators, but this is really the same thing. You know, I know they're doing a little more work looking at trainers per se, but it's the approval.
We've talked about some of these workforce workshop issues about the need for reciprocity so operators can move from state to state easier, blah, blah, blah. But it's really the same. It's the same argument. But starting small with a few regions today, that's great to hear, actually. If the workforce really takes more of a lead in our industry as far as trying to preserve and bring more people in.
You know, maybe there'll be a way to try to get another state added here or there. And eventually, you know, you have five or six different places you need to submit. I see problems, you know, like if I think Ohio has one of the hardest drinking water application processes. And I think I mentioned at WPI last year, but if all the states around them would accept Ohio's for us, that sounds great. But if I'm, if I'm Great Lakes RCAP or I'm Ohio or I'm Indiana Rural Water, they're applying then in Ohio. I see, you know, there's the other, it'd be a lot to work out, but it's, it's certainly something that needs to be dealt with, especially as people become more mobile and states resources get pinched. I think they might start being more interested.
in developing a regional model for states. Necessity is usually what drives that kind of thing. Like the pandemic drove continuing education credit approval for online courses in a lot of states. Well, and we haven't even mentioned the person who's been at the state agency for the last 25 or 30 years who isn't going to budge no matter what. They've got their process, they like it, and it's really going to be when there's turnover that states there's an opportunity for the industry to reach out and try to change things. Well, and I think I was a little, when Steve said he wanted to have this conversation, I'm like, who cares besides a small group of us who do training at the national level?
But if our audience that is, you know, many of you are state employees and in these roles that may have a way to plant seeds for the future for when things are changing and there's new conversations, they we might be able to share. There's one challenge that you could solve. Takes a champion and at some point a champion will arise. Very true. I mean.
I agree with that completely with everything you all are saying. There are a lot of people that are doing great work trying to push these issues. I mean, we talk at WPI every year about these same things. So, I mean, it's not going away. People are talking about it. It does seem like a little ground has been made. I don't know if that's because of the discussions that are being had or because necessity has mandated that people look for other resources because they just don't have anything left at the state level or their state level. Another thing that we get asked a lot is, well, why don't you just get ISET approval and that'll solve all of your problems? Well, ISET approval is fantastic, but there's, I mean, I think ISET appears on a few applications at the state level, but.
Even if you mark that box, that ISET checkbox, you still have to submit all the same material and fill out that same application because the states have that level of control over it. And so ISET, for our industry, ISET doesn't really help in terms of getting the approvals at the state level. I'm sure, I mean, it looks good to them. They like to see it, but it doesn't change what training providers have to do to get that approval. So, you know, above all this, you mentioned that you have another person now who does the online stuff. And I wanted to mention that WEF has a lot of their past webinars and other things that they do. I know there's one that's coming up, I think, this week, maybe, that's just freely available to the world.
You know, who is your audience for that? And, you know, what would you tell our audience about what they can find on Wes' website beyond pay training? There's also a lot of other resources and online events or recordings of events. So this would be a really good question for Stephen Massa, who runs our online portal now. Our webcasts, they cover a wide variety of topics, obviously, essential to operations procedures. Those topics are selected and developed by our members of our practice communities. So most are designed to be engaging for operators and engineers at every experience level. There's a sizable library of videos that operators can access as either a professional resource or for continuing education credit needs.
So we encourage everyone to check out the full catalog on the WEF Learn sites, learn.wef.org. It's the WEF Learning Center. It's really helpful. It's really cool. There are a lot. I actually, before we got on this call, I went and looked because it's been a while and it's pages and pages of free webcasts available. So there's a lot in there. Thanks for spending time with us, Matt. Of course, it's always interesting and I'm glad to finally meet you because we've met you many times in the past. Are you on social media in any professional capacity where our listeners would be invited to follow you?
I'm really not. I'm a WEF guy, so I don't have any specific social media sites to promote professionally of my own. But I would invite people to go to WEF.org. There are a number of social media sites related to the different areas that WEF works in, like Operations Challenge, Water Leadership Institute, Circular Water Economy, things like that. There's all kinds of information and links to chat groups and things like that you can get involved with. Great. We'll definitely include those in the show notes for the episode. Yeah, we're really impressed with WEF. They put their members first. It's really clear. They're really a benefit to our industry. So we appreciate all you do, for sure. And thanks for coming on today. It's been really fun to talk about all these things that we've been dealing with.
Well, I really appreciate it. And likewise, to all the work you all are doing, we appreciate you very much. CapTalk is a collaboration between the Rural Community Assistance Partnership and the University of Illinois with funding from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. The show is hosted by Steve and Jennifer Wilson of the Illinois State Water Survey. You can visit drinkingwaterpodcast.org to find the full show notes for this episode.