What I'm getting at is that they might sell you a technology, pipe it into your septic system, and unbeknownst to you, you're ruining it. So that's, again, where hopefully the services of our cap and others like ourselves can really help you understand the further implications of what you've installed. For good reason, hopefully, to have good water quality, but there are other implications to your septic system that need to be considered. You're listening to Tap Talk, the Drinking Water in Rural America podcast. We believe everyone has a role to play in protecting public health, and together we're connecting water and health professionals with ideas to extend and enhance our work. Whether you operate, educate, or regulate, this show is for you. Welcome to Episode 61.
In this episode, we're chatting with Andrew Evans and Jim Starbird about on-site wastewater challenges, including their anecdotes as technical assistance providers with RCAP Solutions. Our conversation includes helpful best practices as well as potential pitfalls for the future. Welcome. Today, we have Jim Starbird and Andrew Evans both with RCAP Solutions here with us today. This is a special episode really to talk about on-site wastewater system challenges. SepticSmart Week is coming up. And so welcome, you guys. Thanks for participating today. I guess we usually start out just by asking a little more about you. So Jim, why don't you start? Where do you work and what's your role?
Thanks, Steve. Good morning. I'm Jim Saban. I'm the regional director of RCAP Solutions for the Southern New England region, which is Connecticut, Rhode Island, and Massachusetts. And my role is really just overseeing all the staff and contracts and deliverables we have in those regions. We work in drinking water, wastewater, onsite wastewater, septic systems, and private wells. So quite a variety of work. Andrew?
Yeah, I work for Jim in his division. My title is a community specialist and a technical assistance provider. So I undertake most of the work that Jim manages under our contract. So I'm really getting in there with the folks on the ground to try and manage their system, help them figure out troubleshooting or funding that they might need and what might be in their water or wastewater to help them out. Continuing with you, Andrew, what do you love about your job? I like how diverse it is and that I get to meet with the folks in the community one-on-one. I used to be an operator and sometimes I felt that there was a disconnect between myself and the community. I was out there doing a lot of work, but they didn't necessarily know what we were doing.
And so this has been a great opportunity to sort of get a larger reach in the community about water and wastewater projects. It really does affect their quality of life. And I like to think that by getting out there and working with our cap solutions, we can hopefully make better and more sound decisions moving forward. Yeah, it's a huge value for sure. Jim, what about you?
Well, I also like the diversity, but I also really enjoy the fact that we're really helping people without any other agenda being federally funded, mostly in some state funding. We don't charge the communities or the homeowners we work with. We have no agenda to sell more or anything like that. So we really can provide an unbiased and trusted assistance to the community because they know we don't have some sort of agenda behind it. You know, we're just giving them the best we can. That's well said, because I think that's the way Jennifer and I feel, too, with what we are doing since we're funded federally and through you guys. It's very rewarding work in that respect. I think people are always surprised that we don't charge for what we do.
Yeah, that's for sure. Sometimes. I would say a lot of people think, you know, like for the private well side of it, you know, a lot of people expect, you know, after we do the water test, we'll be trying to sell them a filter. And they actually get surprised when they're like, well, no, we can't even recommend who the filter company to go to. We recommend going to a number of them and see how we give them guidance in general, what kind of filter they should look for, but not the brand name of the company that's going to install it. So I think at that point, they really know that we don't have any, any reason why to guide them astray.
Oh, yeah, it really is the best guidepost because you get to offer an unfiltered perspective of what's really happening. There can be, especially on the private side, you know, there is there's a reason to try and sell something, a product and try to tether it to a certain problem, whether it fits best or not. So it really is from a professional standpoint, very rewarding, like Jim said, to be able to offer that to people and really just provide as much clarity as possible without having to filter it through some other channel. I think people deserve that. Well, especially when trust is in such short supply these days, I think everyone's skeptical, no matter who you are. And so I think having that makes us an even more valuable resource. So especially you guys on the ground.
Yeah, and I've never heard so many ads on the radio about water treatment or lab or people offering basically what we do as a fee. It certainly has come up from the way it used to be, which really nobody really talked too much about it. So it's a good thing in some ways that it's up front and center, but you're right in that what is said and how is very important and people need to understand what's really at stake. Well, and that's part of our job is to make sure that folks understand and know that folks like you are out there. All right, so we always ask everyone just kind of as an icebreaker, if you will. So Jim, what's one personal fun fact about you that we might not know? I'm a plant nerd.
You know, everything about plants, you know, everything from gardening to flower boxes to, you know, perennial gardens. Yep. And just like you. He's showing all his plants in the background. Yeah. Yeah. It's just, you know, it's really my hobby and the passion out of work, if you will. How I got to wind down after the day, you know, go and water the flowers in the summertime. So yeah, another fun fact for me. That's awesome. I love that. I didn't know that.
I didn't know that either about Jim. I knew you liked plants, but I didn't know it was quite such a passion. Yeah, I've been working for Jim for almost five years now. So yeah, that's a wonderful thing to learn. I am not so botanically inclined. I have a lot of plants and they are living in my house, but it's not my passion. I'm actually more about what's dead out there in the world. I like rocks and sand and geology in general. Myself and another colleague are very much into that sort of thing. I'm hoping to get my soil evaluators license here in the state of Massachusetts soon.
But aside from geology being a passion, another thing that I've been getting into recently, tying flies. I've been fly fishing a little bit more lately. And I've seen that as more of an artistic kind of going about things or whatever you want to call it. It's nice to tie flies from an artistic perspective. It provides some peace, I suppose, at the end of the day. And then hopefully I catch a fish with it if I'm lucky. So that's a new hobby of mine.
We, unfortunately, in Illinois, really don't have many places to catch fish with flies. Oh, no. Go down to Arkansas or Missouri, you know, down southern Missouri in Boothill. That was the last time I used a fly. I can remember. It's been a number of years ago. But I certainly love to fish. It's just, yeah, that's a painstaking art form. It takes a lot of time to make it and almost no time at all to lose it in a tree. I can assure you of that, Steve. I've seen. I've been there. Yeah, I've been there. That's awesome. Yeah, Steve likes the fish and the plants, and I like the dead things, too. I like, or rather not the dead things. I like the non-living things. I like the rocks. She's a geologist, though. Try not to hold that against her.
So we also like to ask our guests about their water hero, someone whose work past or present has inspired you or motivated you in your career in water. Well, I thought about this one. Me from Massachusetts, I'm going to have to go with Paul Revere. A lot of people don't realize, well, everyone knows about Paul Revere's night job, but they didn't realize he had a day job. He was actually the first health agent ever in America, the first health department ever in America, Boston Health Department. And it was formed to fight a cholera outbreak in Boston at the time. And coming from the former board health agent, you know, just fits, if you will. Wow. I learned something today. Yeah. That's awesome.
Yeah, it's a cool historical fact, too. It is, yeah. Multifaceted guy. I have a feeling Steve's going to be taking that one for some of his podcasts there, or some of his webinars there, Steve. I don't know if this is proprietary or not, but that's a good one. I didn't know that either. It is. It's a good, yeah, it's a good way to tie that into things. So, Andrew, what about you?
Mine's a bit more contemporary. John West was my first boss in the wastewater industry, kind of fresh out of college with a geology and environmental science degree, and really showed me what's possible in the industry and had a lot of excitement around it. And for someone that's young to meet someone, a veteran in the field like that that still has a lot of spunk, wants to get into the new technologies, and the rest was really illuminating. And it's kind of been... He's still very prominent in my professional career, even though he's retired. And also kind of, again, with that outreach, he was always very concerned with how we were presenting ourselves and how it impacted people in the industry as well. He was always meeting with our governor at the time, Jim Douglas, to really be a proponent for what we do. To see that and to sort of see someone taking it on front and center was really and still is motivating to me. That's awesome. So was John a random water treatment plant or wastewater treatment plant?
That's what was so amazing about him. He had like 40 systems that he was operating on the private side. He also operated a couple of public systems, water and wastewater. And, you know, he had that page run all the time. He would answer any phone call, any question from any. He just he did for 40 years. It was all about the water industry. And it wasn't just about the money for him. Him and his wife really took it on as a passion. You know, seeing that again from someone as a veteran, because you don't always see that. Right.
It was, it was really impactful to me, especially as a younger person and not knowing anything about this stuff. I think a lot of people can relate that we all drink water. We all use wastewater services, but a very few amount of people really know the details about how it all functions, right? Seinfeld episode, different pipes, different places, you know, no, that's not really the case. So yeah, it's just, it's, it's very, um, it's good to have people in your life that do that. And of course there are people before and after that continue on, but as I look back, he certainly was the most impactful. Awesome. Yeah. Thanks for sharing.
Okay, so yeah, the topic today where you get into that now is about on-site wastewater systems, septic systems or advanced systems, I guess. And there's a lot of challenges. There's a lack of awareness. We run into people all the time who say, I don't even know where my septic tank is, things like that. I'm sure you guys have both seen many of those. So we're coming up on SepticSmart Week. It's September 15th through the 19th. And so I guess, first of all, just to kind of frame that, what do you see as the important messages that we all should be sharing with the owners of those systems?
I think the big message is, and believe it or not, there's still homeowners out there who believe this, is pump your system pretty regularly based on the size of your house and how many people are currently living there, really. Two years of it's a full house, if you will. We could probably back it up to three, five years if it's two people in a three-bedroom house. I meet so many homeowners that think they can just put additives into there and that relieves the pumping. And 16, 18 years later, I'm advising them that they should really pump their septic tank. So I think that'd be the number one thing is regularly pump it based on how full your house is, if you will.
People really fight that too. You know, we get almost hate mail email about additives, especially. It's almost a source of pride to say, I haven't pumped it an extra minute. Is it not right? And it's, you may not, are you proud about not changing your oil for 50,000 miles and that your car still runs? Maybe I wouldn't be, but everyone has their own take on it. Right. So anything else to add there, Andrew?
I would echo that sentiment for sure, to be mindful of not only pumping it, but what you're doing in the sense of additives, in the sense of non-flushable wipes, in the sense of perhaps rental properties. We're seeing a lot more Airbnbs, people seeing these as opportunities for income, but there may be unintended consequences, especially there's a lot of people in your house doing a lot of flushing of things that you don't have control over. Garbage disposals are another one. If you have one, I highly recommend you don't use it because it's putting a lot of extra burden on your system that's really unnecessary. Certainly, or they need to pump a lot more often.
So as a follow-up, obviously the recommendation would be to not flush wipes, but for someone who is, would they be needing to pump a lot more frequently? Is that an annual thing then? They would be. And even it's possible that they can get surcharged. We're seeing a lot of things develop. I just saw an update from New Hampshire. They're increasing the fee from 350 to 450 for your permit. Same thing goes for wastewater treatment facilities. If they see a load from a septic tank that's full of rags or full of grease or both, they can surcharge for that sort of thing and it will cost you extra money. So I think there are new designations coming out and we're certainly a proponent for that. Not just the flushable white, but that it will actually break down like toilet paper in a tank or in the collection system of a municipal system. So hopefully that comes about, but that's something that folks should certainly look for on the horizon.
Well, and we should also point out here that you folks are from Massachusetts, which has some of the best, if you will, rules and regulations in the country compared to some states that maybe aren't as proactive. And so when you talk about surcharges and all the things that can be done, some states don't even have those kind of rules. So it really does fall on the homeowner to be the proactive one and understand what they should and shouldn't be doing. Absolutely. Or it goes down to the local level too. So if the state doesn't provide a...
legal framework as a backdrop, sometimes pressure comes at the local level to do something about it, which can add even more nuance and difficulty when trying to explain them because it can vary from town to town. There's nothing in one town and then 57 pages of regulations in another. And we don't have that in Illinois. That's the other interesting thing you have. I tell people all the time, you know, Massachusetts is one fifth the size of Illinois. We have about 85 health districts of county health departments or multi-county health departments. You have 350 boards of health that all have their own regulations. I mean, you're home rule state. We're not. So it's a wild west here compared to.
Well, that's the Wild West, too, in some ways, I guess. Nationwide, it's certainly, you need to understand what's going on in your area and what kind of authority, because our counties don't have the authority your boards of health have. Yeah, absolutely. And as I've said, things are changing. New Hampshire just updated their rules. It's effective July 1st, 2025. Vermont promulgated new rules in 2023. So a lot of things that people historically thought of as, you know, in my backyard, not a problem of the government, things have certainly changed. There's a hyper focus on, maybe not a hyper focus, but there is a renewed focus in a lot of states to look at this more closely. Sure.
So can you talk a little bit more about that, Andrew, and how this complexity that's entering the domain, how has that impacted the average homeowner with these new rules and regulations? To give you an indication of complexity, I was just looking at it before our podcast here today. Definitions. For Vermont's regulation, last 15 pages. That's just the definitions for the regulation. I think for Massachusetts, it's 12 or 13 pages of just definitions before you even get into the meat of all the other important information and whose authorities there are and how that all works out. It's a very complex thing because it's a complex problem and it is case dependent, especially when you're talking about septic systems. The soil itself can vary. The water quality can vary. Proximity can vary. All these different things have to be sorted out. If a state wants to look at it from a regulatory standpoint, sure enough, before you know it, you can't just build out a one page article and put it out there.
regulation it has to be a lot more involved and typically requires again a layered approach from the local level up to the state it also requires some sort of licensing that's involved either for installers or inspectors boards of health all of that sort of gets wrapped up into it Part of that question really is about how systems themselves have become more advanced. You know, I ran into some in New York that were right along the lake where it's rock at the surface. You know, there's no way to even discharge anything and not have it affect the groundwater supply. And so you've got advanced systems where they're actually treating it like you would for a public wastewater system. You know, Jim, are you seeing more of that? Much, much more now. Actually, in Massachusetts, Cape Cod, they just updated the Title V regulations to make them much more stringent down there. So basically, every home in certain areas of the Cape and a large swath of the Cape.
been affected by just algae blooms in the kettle ponds and other kinds of environmental issues. It's really, it's basically, there's no bedrock out there. It's just a big sandbar, Cape Cod is. So right now, basically every house down there is really going to have to either connect into a city sewer, which is going to have treatment, or put in an advanced denitrification treatment systems on every home. You know, under Title V, usually we get these during real estate transactions when Title V inspections required. Either the system's failed, needs to put a new one in, or they find it's in an area that needs further treatment or more what they call evaluation by the Board of Health, which can put more regulations on that homeowner to pass that Title V inspection. But this is a...
Kind of the first time it's going through just basically anyone in this part of the Cape needs to upgrade or tighten the sewer. So we're seeing it more and more there. But then as homes get sold or new systems need to go in and older homes, like you said, lakeside or you name it, they allow them to not meet the current total fiber regulation. But with the advanced treatment, you're putting affluent water in the ground. It's much more treated than a typical gravity system. So I've seen one system that brings the nitrate down to about a third of the drinking water standard going into the ground. It's awesome. So a lot of these systems are very good. You know, they're expensive to put in. A lot of them are energy hogs, too. A lot of them have big blowers and, you know.
a lot of electrical needs to make them work, if you will. So it's going to require a lot more of a homeowner, even in being able to know when there's a problem or when something's not working or how to deal with an alarm. And most of the homeowners have to have, you know, basically contracts, wastewater operator firms and have wastewater operator come by once a year or as an emergency comes. And some of the larger systems require monthly visits to make sure the system is running. So they're basically really small wastewater treatment plants for all intents and purposes, you know, package plan, if you will.
Well, I didn't think about this in advance, but this leads me to, are you seeing also then more cluster systems where it's like a whole neighborhood and they get it pumped? So it's like a mini sewer system just to one cluster on-site treatment system. I know we see that in Tennessee. They're even putting those in on purpose and new subdivisions, but is that happening in your area? Not many of the subdivisions that I've seen. Have you seen them, Adam?
Yeah, it's easier when you're considering a new system, right, or a new subdivision. You can look at the landscape, chart your course, where the homes are going to be, where the field's going to be, what you know you can calculate, right, because you're building the houses, you're the developer. You can build in the cost for each unit to pay for the wastewater that you're going to build, whether it's an advanced system or not. But as you probably are aware of in Illinois as well, we have an old housing stock, and a lot of these houses were built early in our evolution of water and wastewater treatment, right? So it wasn't as though, okay, it went from surface to subsurface, well, it's a gravel, trench, and pipe, right, and maybe a septic tank. Or it goes straight to a field tile.
Or field tile. Yeah, we have all farm ground. Yeah, we run into those all the time. And as time goes by, we learn about water quality and where wells are located and the rest. These regulations start to happen. And before you know it, a home might be a really tight spot, right, about whether or not you can even feasibly fit an AI system or anything else. So that's typically where we see cluster systems arising in situations where full of neighborhoods are having a hard time managing their wastewater or really don't have any options other than to find a collective area to treat and dispose of their wastewater.
So that kind of leads into, you know, one of the things you all shared with us is about a small community in Massachusetts that was a sewer working with a factory, I believe, and using their system. And now that factory is closed, I think. Right. So I guess if you would, what's going on there and what's the situation today, I guess, and where they've come from. And it sounds like it's a real problem.
Well, it's a problem certainly for the folks living in their houses who have a lot of uncertainty about what's going on and what can happen with their wastewater. The landscape there is very confined. There isn't a whole lot of space available. You can imagine a factory area along a river might have some groundwater contamination over the years, oil spills, things of that nature. So on top of the topography, that's really been very difficult to find a place to locate a subsurface treatment. And again, these, all these regulations in Massachusetts play a part in that. So it does create a problem where we went from basically a subsidized treatment because of a big factory providing so much volume of flow that they didn't really.
have to worry about the residential flow. But now here we are in a situation where that's all that's left, and it's a very small system of just 26 houses and a chapel. What do we do now? And it is a bit of an issue. It is a confluence of a lot of different factors from a political standpoint, because on the one hand, you have very strict rules, as there should be, to protect water quality and public health. There's also an initiative in Massachusetts to increase our housing stock and to maintain what we already have and not lose any more of it. So how do we meet those goals?
hopefully find an affordable solution. It's been a bit of a quandary, but that's where it stands now. And the Board of Health is playing a vital role in that because they really have to look at all of this and make sure that it fits within all the rules and regulations that are out there. So I guess, Jim, if they can't find a solution that works, and this reminds me, but I mean, these folks, it'll be more expensive, clearly, to do something without the factory. What will happen if you can't solve this as far as finding an equitable, I guess, solution that the folks there can afford?
Well, I mean, individual systems aren't really plausible because of the land they're on, how close they are and all that. And under the housing code in Massachusetts, if they don't have adequate sewage, then the housing could be condemned basically by the local health department. And all those people would be homeless. So it's kind of the stakes we're looking at. You know, it's an unfortunate situation that really needs a remedy. But without sewage going in, I mean, going out, it's a place to get rid of it. That's kind of what they're looking at. You know, the houses really would be condemned and now they'd all be homeless. Currently, it's going into basically a settling tank, which is turning into a tight tank, which is then now pumped and brought to a neighboring.
plant to be treated. They had some state funding that they received from a local legislator put them in for it. But sooner or later, that funding is going to run out. It's quite an expensive endeavor, as you can imagine, to pump a large septic tank once, twice a week, sometimes paying on the rainfall, and then trucking it to a neighboring system and paying them for the treatment of that. It adds up quite quickly.
Without the grant, they'd be bankrupt within six weeks with the amount of revenue they currently have. It's a district, you know, and they do billing and all this, but they also have a water system and they all have to pay that bill too. They have a water and sewer bill. And if they have to manage that tight tank, I don't think they'll be able, I know they won't be able to afford it. And it's a bit of a situation too, because the state determined that the town owns the collection system, which is kind of an odd situation unto itself as well.
So it gets complicated very quickly. Let's just put it that way. It's not a sustainable way of going about it. And then furthermore, the Board of Health won't permit a tight tank for more than a couple of years. You know, it just, it doesn't, from a public health perspective in the state of Massachusetts, a tight tank is not, it's not a long-term solution to solve a public health problem, which is wastewater, right? It's very tenuous to have a tight tank. If there's an overflow, it's completely untreated wastewater at the surface. Can you explain what a tight tank is? Yeah, a tight tank is a vessel which takes the wastewater and does nothing else other than hold it until somebody pumps it out.
It's a big holding tank. It's just a big holding tank with an alarm that says high level, and you better pump it at that point or before. Typically, we see, I think the longest permit I've seen is only three years. And if at that point you still don't get anything in there and the Board of Health feels compelled, they can evict you. Oh, I hope that works out, yeah. Yeah, we've walked with some Lakeshore communities that you touched on that, again, they were managing this because a tight tank is very expensive, but if it's just a seasonal home, it's a whole lot less expensive than an AI system. AI system, excuse me, innovative alternative system.
So it's hard to get people to come up and put the money forward and that sort of thing. But again, a tight tank, it's just, it's so risky to have. And because it's one of those things too, where all these folks have said, well, I'll just put in my own tight tank. Again, it doesn't work that way. And I know that the board of health won't approve that. So it also adds, you know, when you touch upon what's really at stake and the housing stock and all the rest, I look at it also as a matter of gentrification, because if it boils down to that situation, you might have some homeowners will say, well, I'll just buy that other person out, tear it down and build my system here. So it becomes a situation where the people who have enough money.
can get rid of the people that don't so that they are taken care of. And I don't want to see that happen. Yeah, I'm sure there's going to be some hard decisions there. I'm curious if this is because of the density you have in Massachusetts, what's the likelihood that this is happening in another community and you just you haven't become aware of it yet? I think it's going to happen not just in Massachusetts, but elsewhere. We live in, again, going back to our housing stock. Well, the same thing goes for our factories. There was recently a paper mill in Putney, Vermont that closed that was treating a lot of the wastewater, too. Now, luckily, there were some agreements in place. There's a little bit stronger state law about abandoning these properties and transfers, that sort of thing. But I think that.
As these things happen, and as Jim alluded to, the funding that it took to kind of shore this thing up in the meantime, I think it will illuminate some of this down the road to say, hey, we really need to think about how these companies are operating, what type of wastewater they're taking on, and what sort of contingencies we can put in place. Because let's just face it, manufacturing in this part of the world is not as easy as it once was. And they're kind of going away, unfortunately, which can sometimes leave the local population at a disadvantage. Seems like a unique situation. I don't know that we have areas in Illinois like that where a number of homes are tied to a business for their sewer or septic. And so every place is a little different in how they evolve, I guess, and what the laws do. It'd be really interesting to look at the data nationwide to see how many situations are like that and what's the risk of the problems increasing because of changes in the economy. I would say home rural states are probably more likely. And like where you have this local control, all the northeastern states especially, that's probably pretty common.
Yeah, it is. And again, we go back to the evolution of a factory that needs workers, builds housing. They don't want to build a separate treatment system or extra piping unnecessarily. So they just pipe it into the factory. And that's that. It provides housing. It may provide additional treatment. And there you go. Again, things change, though. So here we go.
So, Jim, you mentioned Title V earlier. Can you explain a little bit about that and as far as how that limits some of these things and why, like, I know one of you already said that it's not possible to use separate septic systems here because of the terrain and the soil and all that stuff. But I think Title V is looked at as an example of what every state should probably do. And maybe just a few words about how that is and how that's evolved in Massachusetts. Sure. Well, Title V, it really came in effect after a major rewrite in 1996. And that's kind of when it really brought it to where it is now. It's the septic code for Massachusetts. It's basically minimum standards for on-site septic systems. Now, like you mentioned before, local boards of health have the authority to be more stringent than state law, but not less stringent. So a lot of local boards of health will add different regulations on top of that for their own community and some based on where they are. Like a lot of systems down the Cape will, a lot of boards of health down the Cape will...
require more separation to groundwater than the four feet that Title V has. The reason being is sandy soils. They want more soil or sand treatment before it gets to where the groundwater is. But it really specifies construction, the inspection, the licensure, everything having to do with septic systems. So everything from when you're putting a brand new one in, setbacks to have the groundwater, how big the leach field has to be, how big the septic system has to, the septic tank has to be. So when you say you're selling your property, you have to have it inspected by a licensed Title V inspector.
It institutes what the inspector has to look at and what are the criteria for failure and other issues like that. It also specified the licensure required via Title V inspector, a soil evaluator, which is used to evaluate a site before you design a septic system, who can design a septic system, who can pump, you know, license pumpers, license installers. So it really set forth the whole criteria for anything, any kind of on-site wastewater disposal, if you will. It also has a system that's over 10,000 gallons per day. That goes up to the MassDEP. It's out of the local board of health jurisdiction at that point. And that's where we see a lot of the...
larger scale package cluster system come in. We see a lot of that get affected with the manufactured housing communities. A lot of them are much older, you know, older builds from the 50s, 40s. But once their flow gets over 10,000 gallons, it really, they need what's called a groundwater discharge permit from SDP. And that comes with, you know, requirements, which a lot of the requirements usually lead to either tying into a sewage or sewage available or basically centralizing the wastewater within the park into one centralized treatment system that puts it into the ground, which, you know, we dealt with a few of these and these are multimillion dollar systems where, you know, communities really can't afford it.
So, yeah, there's a lot of pros and cons. You know, it does protect the environment quite a lot, but it does create financial hurdles sometimes as well. Oh, I bet. Yeah. Well, it's interesting. You know, I'm more on the private well side, but we have two states that don't have well construction code, for instance. And one thing we haven't looked at is the variability in all the rules on the septic side or on the on-site side. Probably interesting to do. The regulation in Massachusetts does implicate wells and does a lot to protect wells because you sat back. Oh, sure. Yeah.
To sort of put a pin on it, the Title V regulation is 103 pages long. So to say that it's comprehensive would almost be an understatement. And Jim sort of highlighted a lot of the things that it goes over. There really is no stone left unturned. However...
Because of its detail, it does provide certain limitations, such as a 10,000 gallon marker. You know, you find yourself by calculation a gallon over that. Well, you're in a whole different ballgame and a whole different set of rules. And it also is a bit cumbersome in the way the approval process goes for emerging technologies. You know, some systems are approved for over 10,000, but not less than 10,000. And all those are sort of broken down into other subsets of the rule.
again, kind of goes back to having a legal and engineering help when you're trying to go through all of this. No, and I think, Andrew, that's the point, is that it is complicated. There's a lot there, but it does a lot as well. And there are states where they don't have any of those kinds of rules, right? And so that was my point, is it's really, there's areas where, well, they're not as dense either, probably, as Massachusetts is, as far as population and some of those things. It's a lot older area and all that.
It is. But it's also a tale of two circumstances, I would argue, because Massachusetts has very rural areas that have also been implicated in a lot of these rules that may not necessarily fit so well. But then there's very densely populated areas, as you as you suggest. So it tries to find the best balance it possibly can. So zooming out here and taking the context you have, particularly for this community we've been talking about, are there areas where homes should not be built, but maybe they are trying to be built because of some of these issues?
Yeah, I haven't really seen new homes in places that can't be built between, you know, the zoning regulations each town has, the septic regulations. We have a strong local conservation commission. Each town has one of those that sets setbacks with wetlands and other things like that. New homes, we don't see a lot going in like that. The big problem is the pre-existing homes that all of a sudden need to upgrade. That's where we kind of find it. You know, the home's already there. The people are already there. You know, we need to find a solution. You know, do they meet the new regulations to the team? No. Well, how can we make a variance or make them have some sort of...
technology that can fit that footprint in um in the septic system world then that's you know we have the different approvals and all these are done by the principal health um department they have a soil testing site on the cape and they kind of do all the research for these technologies at that facility and then they assigned um you know different criteria that it can meet you know some technologies will give you um lower the space you need to the groundwater from four feet to two feet because you're treating it before you put it in. Or if you're in a zone two of wells, a nitrogen reduction area, you have to put a nitrogen reducing technology onto the system when you do the repair to bring that into compliance, if you will. So that's why we see it more is on the repairs of the older homes that were there long before Title V was even a thought. Trying to maintain the best we can with, you know, what you have. And so, you know, being so old.
You know, some of these communities, I've actually been to a Board of Health being in a small community that's kind of in the middle of the Metro West area near Boston. It's a rarity there. They're all in wells and they're all in septics with one of those small towns that never put any kind of public utility in. And I saw one home that they were looking at a $100,000 plus septic system repair because of the size of the home and where it was located and what they had to do on this little lot to make it work. Yeah, that's kind of a daunting thing for almost anyone these days. Yeah.
So Steve came up with this question, and I'm wondering if you were maybe thinking about states other than Massachusetts that have a lot less intensive regulations and oversight over this, that you're thinking of other areas of the country. Speaking for myself, I know Jim's worked in Massachusetts almost exclusively. So I've touched on Vermont and New Hampshire. And to your point, there isn't quite as much, or at least not up until recently, there wasn't as cohesive a regulation at the state level. However, it still plays out at the local level because people still are concerned about land use in their communities and the outcomes of different decisions. One example in Vermont is, again, trying to increase or at least maintain the housing stock that we have. That's a statewide initiative. There's a lot of money being put forth to try and bolster that. But sometimes that can mean a farm field is taken up for a new development. And what does that look like for the community?
Well, despite all of the regulations that may or may not be in place, it still is a socio impactful decision making process. regardless of the backdrop of rules that may exist. One example is that we were working with a homeowner in this community we were just talking about, and they were very concerned about the look of a subsurface treatment system in their neighborhood. And it was confusing to me because this person's been staring at a factory building and concrete tanks and rusting towers for decades. But the concern over a subsurface system was very upfront and center. So there was some education that had to be involved about what it really looks like. And we were able to provide some aerial imagery of what fields look like in different places in the area. And it really put them at ease.
But it was a really interesting thing to even have to have that conversation. I didn't even expect that, right? But I think they felt relieved in the end to say, well, we're replacing all this hopeful factory with a nice field, maybe a couple of pipes for venting and that sort of thing. There's more to it than just pipes in the ground, 100%. Well, it highlights the role of folks like RCAP Solutions to provide that education connection for the community to make sure that the decisions are being made effectively and everyone understands why and that in the end, the outcome is a positive one. Yeah, and sometimes it really, you know, that was a very simple situation, you know, about aesthetic.
But it can get complicated really quick if someone else is concerned about, say, an emerging contaminant. They've heard something in the paper about PFAS. And now you're talking about a subsurface system. What does that mean for my well? And, you know, so there's sometimes a lot of buzz around other things, kind of putting the cart ahead of the horse sometimes even, where there's some alarmist situation going on that may be completely separate from the overall impact of just trying to get a place to treat the wastewater and hopefully keep people, in this case, in their homes, for example. It can really cloud the conversation.
I don't want to get into PFAS here. I do want to mention, though, that there was just a paper that came out that suggested toilet paper because it has a lot of PFAS in it. It could be a big culprit in rural areas for why we're seeing it in some private wells where there's really no other source around. Totally different topic. We'll get on that some other day. It's just interesting to me, and it made me think about the connection between septic systems. And several studies have suggested that it's got to be a septic system that's getting PFAS into that part of the world. Yeah, Jim, certainly a little bit more.
aware of all that. Yeah, he's been looking at that more closely than I have. I've been looking at it more from a conjecture standpoint, but a lot of it is conjecture, but you have to understand that we're washing Teflon in our sink. It's happening. This happens in other sectors as well. I've seen it a lot, particularly with wind energy. I think there's often a lot of conflict around that. And you get such a very diverse opinion set out there, right? So you've got the people over there that are saying, I don't pump my tank ever, and they're proud of it. But then you have a whole other side of the spectrum too, which is hyper-focused or whatever. So you have to really balance all of that.
So, Andrew, as we wrap up, any other thoughts, suggestions, best practices? Again, with SepticSmart Week is coming up, a lot of folks are going to be made aware of, you know, that at least they should think about their system this week, if you will, or something that might jog their memory or whatever. So, you know, what would you want folks to know as we head into that on September 15th? So I've probably got a little bit of an odd one, if you will, especially considering the current state of affairs here in the Northeast. We're in a bit of a drought, but I'm actually going to talk about hydraulic overloading. If you're gone for a while, shut off your water.
Make sure there's no leaks going into your system. Make sure there's no unnecessary water getting into your system. I've recently been working with one that has been washing out pretty regularly because there's too much water at one given time entering the system. So be mindful of your water use. Try not to waste any water unnecessarily. You know, try to stagger those loads. If it's a shower, take showers at night, do your laundry in the morning, that sort of thing, and stagger things out. It's really going to help your system in the long run. And Jim, what about you?
Oh, add to that, because I do private wells quite a lot, is if you have a treatment system on your private well that has a backwash, take a look at it and see if it goes outside into a dry well or just on top of the yard. Or does it go into your septic system? Is it piped into the pipes? That's something to keep an eye on. I've seen some nightmares. It does the hydraulic overload because you get all that flow in there probably every night. However, too, it's backwashed and it's also going into your septic system, changing the pH. It might kill the bacteria that are doing their process. And here in Massachusetts, it's against Title V and it's an automatic failure if you have a home on it. So just take an eye.
to look at it you know it's kind of like a garbage disposal really both of those you don't want going into your septic system so it's against the rules to have a treatment device backwash go into your septic correct other than a um other than just an arrow on your like a point of use arrow they don't mind that you know it's just a little bit just as you're drinking but any of the you know the full health systems definitely yeah they don't want to see that backwash going to the septic but it can ruin the ph i've seen the concrete be compromised because of it too it's not the septic tank will actually start breaking down if you will corroding it so to speak yeah oh that's interesting all right well any other thoughts I should point out that, as I said before, you know, you got all these companies with these new treatment systems out there, you know, and doing water testing on their own that may or may not be at labs that are accredited. What I'm getting at is that they might sell you a technology, pipe it into your septic system, and unbeknownst to you, you're ruining it. And so that's, again, where hopefully the services of RCAP and others like ourselves can really help you understand perhaps the further implications of what you've installed for good reason, hopefully to have good water quality. But there are other implications to your septic system that need to be considered. Hey, Steve, is that on our assessment tool of whether or not your backwash goes to your septic tank? It is not.
That might be something interesting to add. Yeah, and relevant for sure. Honestly, it's even, you know, we're adding a less than 11 to our private well class that's just on septic, our on-site systems. And because of that, we're redoing some of the pages in our private well class lessons that need updated anyway for a number of reasons. But I just wrote that down because that is something to make people aware of. Whether it's against the law or not, it's a bad practice, right? Because in most states, that is not on anybody's radar as a illegal thing to do like Title V has. I mean, if it's a whole house RO.
You don't even want that. I guess it's the volume would be small enough for a point of use RO, but still, you know, it's four times the water goes to discharge as goes through the membrane. So you're still talking about. Yeah. So if it's one or two people in the house, I'm not so concerned. But as an example, I was at one last year, Jim, where they had a point of use, but she had like five dogs and eight cats and she's filling up all their water from that point of use. It's a lot more volume, you know? So there's some, again, there's really some minutia there or some sort of unpacking of what's really happening on the ground.
No, it's a really good point, though. Just the whole idea that it's something I certainly have not thought of as an issue, but it certainly would be. You know, some of them are common. You know, you don't flush things that aren't supposed to go down your toilet or, you know, whether that's a chemical or, you know, we always use the example in our webinar about when your kids had amoxicillin because they had an infection, you don't take the extra pills and flush them down the toilet. It kills bacteria, right? So things like that are common, but, you know, it's really interesting.
Another thing to be mindful of is, and this is a really, really sad situation, but if you run into cancer treatments, some of these treatments that force their way through the body also kill all the bacteria in your septic system as well. I think you pointed that perhaps out in one of your webinars, in fact, Steve, and that was very illuminating to me. I didn't know that. No, there's a lot of things that can certainly affect in the groundwater world, you know, through like the National Groundwater Association, there's a Darcy lecturer. And one year, the Darcy lecturer was a professor who did a lot of work looking at pharmaceuticals and personal care products. He sampled rural high school, the groundwater around that, and their treatment system, it was 300 or 400 kids, I think, but they found...
methylphenidate and you name it, depression, antidepressant drugs, all those sort of stuff was all getting in the groundwater there. And it was coming through these kids' bodies, right? It's just, they discharge some of it and it leaves. And yeah, so there's a lot to think about depending on what the area may be providing. I did my thesis in college about pharmaceutical waste byproducts in groundwater 20 years ago. And here we are still talking. Well, this Darcy lecture was probably close to that because it was a big deal when they first realized that it's a problem and there's no treatment for a lot of those things. They're getting through conventional treatment. They're going out in wastewater discharge, all that.
We've made headway in the pharmaceutical collection, right? So if there's medications you're not using, I think the education's gotten out there really good to not just dump that bottle of Tylenol. Right. Take it to a PlayStation or a library. Yeah, but it's the bodily processing is still occurring that we're working on, right? Yeah, this has been really interesting. If there's any other follow-up, let us know. We will. Are either of you on social media in a professional capacity where our listeners might be invited to follow you? For example, LinkedIn. Speaking for myself, and I'm pretty sure Jim's the same, we are not so social media inclined so much. R-CAP Solutions probably is, yeah. Yes, R-CAP Solutions, I made a little list here.
The communications team does a great job of making sure we're on social media, even though we're not officially on social media. Our Cap Solutions maintains a Facebook, an X, Instagram, LinkedIn, and YouTube pages. Okay, great. We will link those up in the show notes for the episode. You can see plenty of myself and Andrew on those, I'm sure. All right. Well, hey, thank you very much. And yeah, it was a great conversation. It's been wonderful. It's great working with you guys. It really is. Yeah. All right. Thanks for spending time with us. Anytime.
Tap Talk is a collaboration between the Rural Community Assistance Partnership and the University of Illinois with funding from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. The show is hosted by Steve and Jennifer Wilson of the Illinois State Water Survey. You can visit drinkingwaterpodcast.org to find the full show notes for this episode.