Skip to content
TT074 – Mitigating Legionella Risks in Water Systems: Lessons from a Microbiologist episode artwork

Apr 23, 2026 41 min

TT074 – Mitigating Legionella Risks in Water Systems: Lessons from a Microbiologist

from Tap Talk

Today, we welcome Katie Maegli of Water Quality Investigations to Tap Talk! WQI is a private water testing lab in southern Wisconsin, where Katie serves as the lab's microbiologist with specializations in buildings' water systems and Legionella management. This conversation dives deep into Legionella; from where the bacteria is commonly found, the regulatory guidelines that help reduce Legionella risk, the actions individuals can take to avoid legionella growth in their wells, health impacts from Pontiac fever and Legionnaires' disease, and the complexities of accurate testing of Legionella. Visit drinkingwaterpodcast.org to learn more and find the full show notes for this episode.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

TT074 – Mitigating Legionella Risks in Water Systems: Lessons from a Microbiologist

0:00 41:36
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

For Legionella to be a concern in a water system, two things need to be true. First, we need to have the environment in the water system that will promote Legionella and allow it to establish and proliferate. And the second thing you need for Legionella to be concerned is for there to be a mode of transmission for Legionella to reach the consumers using the water system. You're listening to Tap Talk, the Drinking Water in Rural America podcast. We believe everyone has a role to play in protecting public health. And together, we're connecting water and health professionals with ideas to extend and enhance our work. Whether you operate, educate, or regulate, this show is for you. Welcome to Episode 74.

In this episode, we're chatting with Katie Megley, a microbiologist with Water Quality Investigations. Our conversation focuses on Legionella and building water systems, served by private wells, as well as public water supplies. So today we have Katie Magley from WQI. Thanks for being here. It's going to be an interesting talk today. I think the work you do is really important for groundwater and wells and water systems. And so first of all, why don't you tell us where you work and what's your role there? Yeah, well, I first want to start off by thanking you for having me, Steve. This is a great opportunity and great podcast that you have. I work at Water Quality Investigations, also known as WQI. It's a small private water testing lab based out of Monthorab, Wisconsin. And I'm the resident microbiologist and I specialize in building water systems and Legionella management. Very cool. What do you love about the work that you do?

I really love the team that we have here. We have a lot of variety and backgrounds and expertise. And so it's really neat to collaborate with everyone on the variety of projects. And the other part that I really love is the variety of projects that we have. There's always something new coming in through the door, whether it's a well sample or a plumbing sample. Sometimes we get aquaculture samples. And it's always really neat to just look at water quality in different aspects and help people solve their problems. It's always something new. And we even have, we like to call it the wall of shame, where we have some of our special corroded pipes or dirty media scales and other trinkets from water systems that we've helped. We have that on display at our office here.

We work a lot with WQI on those sorts of issues. And I will say, I totally agree. You guys have a great team. Everyone's great to work with there. That's awesome. One of the things we do before we get started is we ask everyone for a personal fun fact about you that maybe we or your colleagues may not even know. Totally up to you. I have to mention this because as somebody in the water industry, you think I test water. It's what I do. But actually, I enjoy water most in its solid state as ice because I am a hockey player and I've been playing for over 25 years now. It's crazy. I was going back and counting the years and I was like, wow, it's been over 25 since I started, but still play and I play on a local hockey team and it's a lot of fun.

Wow, that's cool. Yeah. You know, we never had hockey where I grew up. Small town, but several guys here play at the U of I's Ice Arena and they really love it. Everyone says it's great. I can't skate to save my life. So it's just the way it is. So we also like to ask our guests about their water hero. So someone who's worked past or present has inspired your career. So my water hero, we're going to have to go back a couple hundred years-ish. My water hero is actually Jon Snow and not the Game of Thrones character. He's actually an English physician and he's known as the father of modern epidemiology for his work in solving an infamous 1854 Broad Street cholera outbreak in London.

He basically connected the cholera cases that were affecting the community to a water pump that was drawn contaminated water from the River Thames, and that work improved the scientific community's understanding of water hygiene and public health. I actually visited the location of the pump a couple years ago now, and they have a plaque commemorating the abandoned pump and even a replica pump for nerds like myself to take pictures with. That's awesome. I remember now that you went there, I forgot about that. It's very cool. Yeah. Well, you mentioned water hygiene. Legionella and water hygiene is kind of our topic today. Can you share a bit about your background and how you came to focus on, you know, you mentioned building water systems and water hygiene is the main focus of what you do.

Yeah, sure I can. So I actually earned my bachelor's degree in microbiology from the University of Wisconsin-Madison back in 2018 alongside a certificate in global health. During my time at UW-Madison, I completed undergraduate research in the human microbiome and foodborne pathogens. And that was where my interest in that interplay between public and environmental health and the microbiome and biofilm began. When I began working at WQI, that allowed me to delve deeper into that passion, especially when it comes to protecting public health and plumbing systems. I like to make the connection of just like the microbiome in your gut, water systems contain a natural microbiome like biofilm, and that can arise to issues if...

pathogens find a way into that environment. It's a neat connection between my history and present. Yeah, for sure. Can you give us the definition of water hygiene? I don't think that's even a phrase that I had heard before. I mean, how does it fit into the broader water safety landscape?

Sure. So water hygiene refers to the cleanliness of plumbing, encompassing all activities that help maintain water quality in a water system and prevent a variety of water-related issues. It's kind of like personal hygiene, where water hygiene is maintained through a series of tasks that may change depending on the unique needs of a water system. It's applicable to all steps of a water system, from wells to water treatment plants to distribution systems and all the way to premise plumbing systems and the tap where you get your water. As far as its application to the broader scope of water safety and the water industry, water hygiene includes a lot of those activities that are actually recommended within current regulations.

guidelines, such as ASHRAE guideline 12, ASHRAE standard 188, and ASHRAE standard 514. That's a recent one. However, water hygiene is not just limited to the activities outlined in those documents, and if prioritized, can enhance water quality beyond the scope of Legionella and waterborne pathogens. I'm going to skip ahead to a later question because I want to know the answer now of compliance. How do those correlate? Is compliance a quantitative measure of water hygiene? Are they equal? Can you talk a little bit more about that? Sure. So I think that a lot of the current standards, they have certain compliance standards in which basically if you don't have Legionella in your system,

you are doing a great job at maintaining your water system and preventing Legionella as a risk. However, that is not necessarily the case. Oftentimes, you might have that safe sample, that negative Legionella in your water sample, but that does not necessarily indicate that there's no problems occurring or that there aren't problems lurking. So that's the gap between compliance and safety. You can have a safe water sample, but you can still have a risk. We often see that gap highlighted when a system or a system operator sees that they are getting Legionella positives or repeat exceedances of their control measures. This is repeat Legionella positives. And basically, in some cases, responding to

to a legionella positive, according to a standard, might reduce legionella numbers or lead to a negative result in the short term, but it may not address the underlying cause of those legionella positives in the system, which leads to a lack of reliability and persistence of risk. For example, if you do a chemical treatment to comply with your water management plan, when you receive a Legionella positive, you do a chemical treatment, that could result in a lower Legionella count or even a negative the next time you test. But it's not necessarily addressing the conditions that led to the establishment of biofilm and Legionella growth in the first place, which are often upstream of where you might be applying that treatment. And so these solutions that are complying with standards might really just be kicking the can down the street until another positive occurs months or years later, and then you end up having to treat again or do a different kind of remediation.

So it'd be the same as disinfecting a well that's poorly constructed or very old and there's still vulnerabilities to contamination. You might get a safe sample in the short term. Yeah, there's two things there. One is we had an instance recently sampling a private well where they had Legionella and they added UV, but they added it where it came in the house, not understanding that the Legionella was in the biofilms that were in their premise falling. So they had a Legionella positive a year later and they were really upset by that. I think that's what you're getting at. The other thing that you said, you went right into Legionella. What's the gap in compliance because we only sample for coliform?

You assume coliform is so ubiquitous that if anything's there, it's going to be there first. And so no one's looking at anything else when they maybe should be. A lot of folks don't even test for the genealogy, but everyone tests for coliform. And yet not understanding that compliance versus safety there seems like a really big animal. And that's actually something I wanted to touch on is, you know, a lot of homeowners, when they think about their water, they might not even think about their quality of water until they have an issue, until they see brown water or if they receive a positive coliform result. These kind of buzz terms, coliforms, E. coli, iron, nitrate, those are things that homeowners can grab onto and understand, but those aren't the only problems.

And so it's difficult to work against that lack of understanding because there's a lot that can cause water quality issues and that people are just not aware of. And even on the public water side, public water systems have to disinfect, but there's still dead ends, places where the disinfection doesn't make it all the way to the end. How often does that cause problems that you guys see? Yeah, we've actually done work with utilities where they've seen corrosion in service lines and we can connect that it's a complex problem. There are multiple layers to everything, but we can connect it to usage in portions of systems and how that usage differs. If you have a manufacturing facility on the end of a water main and they use a lot of water, that water coming into that manufacturing facility, that main leading up to that facility would receive a lot of hopefully higher velocities, not be as stagnant in any plumbing systems that are attached to that. Ideally, receive better water quality than, say, a loop in the water main at a different part in the system where it's just residential water systems. They might even be like vacation homes or something where you'd see just lower usage in general in that portion. And so you'd see a disparity in those homes between the water quality they're receiving.

receiving at their service line and in one part of the system versus another, which a lot of people, they think I open up my tap, I get good water quality, but there are a lot of steps along the way that could influence that. It's such a tough problem because how do you deal with those two situations separately as a water system? That's where we need to head, it seems like, is understanding. I mean, I know there's talk of water age and some of those things, which I don't know anything about really, other than it just means it's been in there longer, but I don't know how utility is going to manage some of those things. Maybe let's go back to basics a little bit for those who wouldn't be listening in or looking for a little bit more of a foundation. So where do we find Legionella and why is it a concern?

Legionella is a bacteria often found in freshwater and soil, but it can also establish within drinking water systems, which is where we see all these health issues. It can be present from wells to the endpoint tap used by a consumer. And Legionella prefer stagnant, warm environments, which can be abundant in plumbing systems, especially in hot water systems that maybe don't see as much use. It's a concern for water systems because it has the potential to cause human illness. The illness can manifest as two types of illnesses. The first one is Pontiac fever, which is a fever that has extremely low case fatality rates, generally presents as a flu-like illness. Another illness that can be caused by Legionella.

Legionella is Legionnaire's disease, which is a very serious pneumonia, can cause severe health issues, and has approximately a 10% fatality rate. That percentage is actually higher in immunocompromised individuals who have hospital-acquired infections, in which they're already in a vulnerable situation and health situation, and they get exposed to this pathogen. A majority of Legionella cases have been linked to Legionella pneumophila, which is why a lot of our testing is geared towards detecting that species in particular. For Legionella to be a concern in a water system, two things need to be true. First, we need to have the environment in the water system that will promote Legionella and allow it to establish and proliferate. The environments that support Legionella include warm stagnant conditions and alongside biofilm and nutrients present in the plumbing system, which unfortunately, those are all very common in plumbing systems. And the second thing you need for Legionella to be concerned is for there to be a mode of transmission for Legionella to reach the consumers using the water system. It's often in the form of aerosolization. When water is aerosolized in tiny water droplets, the water droplets that contain Legionella can be inhaled into the lungs and can cause illness.

They can also be transmitted via aspiration of water. When you drink and water goes down the wrong pipe, that can cause an illness. And so aerosolization and aspiration, those aspects are why a lot of current standards and guidelines emphasize specific components in Legionella control, such as cooling towers, decorative fountains, showerheads, hot tubs. Those are modes of transmission. I've not heard of the aspiration side of this because when someone asked me about Legionella and the work we've done, I was like, well, it's not a drinking water hazard. It's a inhalation hazard. But I'd never thought about the fact that, yeah, it could be from your cold water line in the end.

Wow. Yes. Yeah. If your cold water system is warming, you know, if it's stagnant and it's getting warm and people drink that, another component in a public water system that people are concerned about as far as water management is ice machines. And that's because if you contaminate the ice, use your hands, get it dirty with bacteria, that ice melts into the water and that can cause an issue too. So they really try to cover all the aspects in which Legionella can get into your lungs. Legionella is not a drinking water issue. Like drinking the water that has Legionella is not an issue, but if you were to accidentally inhale any of that water, then that would be the issue.

I hadn't thought about that. It makes perfect sense. Legionella, it's highly adaptable, or that's how it's described. They talk about VBNC and all those other things. How does that make it harder to detect and manage as well as, now you mentioned Umafila, and there's also other species, and it seems like the industry doesn't view them all the same way. What are your thoughts there? What makes it so hard? Yeah, so one of my favorite quotes comes from Jurassic Park, and it's, life finds a way. Legionella finds a way. All microorganisms do, and we just have to be prepared for them.

In Legionella, this actually looks like a parasitic association with amoeba hosts. A lot of people think of just the bacteria, but they can actually use amoebas as a Trojan horse to move through a water system and utilize that protection that the amoeba hosts provide from disinfection and high heat. And this makes detection of Legionella more challenging because you would need to treat a water sample to basically release Legionella from their hosts prior to culturing in order to get an accurate estimate of the Legionella presence. This is why a lot of assays will implement heat treatment or acid treatment in their preparatory steps to try to break up any amoeba that are present. to release any Legionella that are within those amoeba.

But if you acetate or heat treat a sample, you run the risk of actually killing off Legionella that might be free-floating in the water sample itself. And so you might actually inadvertently reduce the amount of Legionella you end up detecting. Talking about the Trojan horse and the protective adaptability of Legionella, once Legionella makes it into a water system, whether they're in an amoeba or if they are free-floating, they will actually embed themselves into biofilm for a similar purpose of protection. And if they're safely embedded in biofilm, they're less likely to be detected in a water sample. And that sample, which would likely be negative, would imply that current actions and water management is sufficient despite the actual presence of Legionella.

in biofilm in the system. And so this can allow Legionella to multiply and present a hazard if biofilm is ever disrupted. No one's ever explained to me the heat and acid part of that that way. And my first thought is you almost need to do it both ways. If it's actually the goal is to get it out of the amoeba, if you will, I did not know that's what the purpose of that was. It's really interesting. I wonder if anyone's looked at that. Yeah, I believe those treatments are also used for samples that are expected to have high occurrence of other bacteria because it's been assumed that Legionella can survive those treatment steps better than other bacteria. So if you have a non-potable sample.

you might want to treat to get rid of the non-targets. Because it seems pretty clear that water systems that aren't disinfected have a lot of bacteria in them. Yeah. So are we seeing more Legionella in building water systems or are we just doing a better job of detecting it and know where to look and what to look for? So my first instinct is to say that we're getting better at testing, but there actually has been research on why we're seeing more Legionella. And there's an article I was reading recently, and it discussed, they're comparing the testing methods, the testing occurrence, and whether the fact that we're testing more or testing better is leading to higher Legionella results. And they actually found a similar rate before and after advancements in testing of Legionella. It's just that I think there are other factors contributing to it that are not related to the testing. Those could be changes in climate, changes in plumbing design and water efficiency, and a variety of socioeconomic factors, whether people are living closer to cooling towers, that kind of thing.

the things we can control as people in the water industry, I think ambient temperatures in building systems or around water system pipes, those are very important. And we tend to be seeing that warmer days are getting warmer and cold days are getting colder. And that directly affects those ambient temperatures within homes and buildings and allows cold water pipes to warm and hot water pipes to cool despite our best efforts in insulation. And as we know, Legionella survives and thrives in warm water. The next factor that I might want to mention is the changes in plumbing design and implementation of water-efficient fixtures. We might be using water-efficient fixtures in new construction or retrofitting those onto older plumbing systems, but that might significantly reduce water usage volume and flow rates. This reduction in water increases the potential for accumulation of debris in the service line, if applicable, and the downstream plumbing, which increases the rates of a variety of water quality issues. You can have microbial-influenced corrosion, reduced water quality, increased Legionella presence.

And I think that those differences in our design and our water efficiency is having an inadvertent impact on water quality. And I won't bog you down with the talk of codes, but there are gaps between water efficiency and plumbing design and pipe sizing. And we're working with people in the industry to actually make those improvements. I was wondering if anybody has looked at whether LEED-certified buildings have a greater incidence of Legionella. And maybe eventually they'll be incorporating that into their standards of, yes, efficiency is good, but we also have to make sure things are safe.

I think we can have both. There has to be compromise. You can't have completely efficient fixtures with the same retrofitted old plumbing systems because those are oversized often for the use in that water efficient fixture. And so if we don't have the volume of water moving through the system that we used to, or the velocities to get biofilm or debris disrupted in the plumbing system, then we're going to just contribute to the issues that we see. And isn't part of it, you talk about debris, I assume that means biofilm. So it means things on the sides of the pipe, right? I just want an explanation of that. And the idea would be to have higher velocity from the beginning so that they can't form in the first place.

Yeah. And when I say biofilm and debris, the debris is mostly non-organic material that minerals or pieces of scale or metals that might accumulate in a water system. It could even be considered if you have dirt or sand or something like that. But that debris is important to mention because the debris can actually end up being a nutrient source or even like a surface that biofilm can establish on. And so it is a contributing factor to water quality issues. Things we keep learning that we didn't know. So many people associate Legionella with public water. That's what's in the news, outbreaks, all that stuff. So where do you see it show up? I mean, where else?

Yeah, we mostly focus on plumbing systems. So that's where we've seen it for the most part. Now, we've seen it in pharmaceutical manufacturing facilities. We've seen it in hotels. We've seen it in private residential plumbing systems. And I think the key factor to think about there is why all of these systems? And I think it is the fact that there are plumbing systems and the fact that despite water quality entering those buildings.

The usage of that system varies depending on what that system is being used for. You know, if it is a pharmaceutical facility that only uses the water for super sterile processing water, or if it is private residents where they have empty nesters and they have much lower usage than they used to. It's a plumbing-related issue, and our usage of the plumbing systems is what dictates the ultimate risk, and how we maintain those systems is very crucial to that. You mentioned empty nesters. How many people have a second or third bathroom that today maybe they're not using maybe every week when they go upstairs to clean a room? And so that's really the problem. Yeah, I mean...

Just thinking about my parents' house, they never go upstairs. And, you know, there's that one bathroom that hasn't been used in probably a decade. This is a side question. I'm not sure if either of you know more about it, but about the liability of Legionella when we're talking about potentially larger facilities, apartment complexes, hospitals, places where other people are responsible for the people that are getting sick. How is that playing out?

Yeah, that's a good question. So we have the ASHRAE guidelines, which are in place for specific types of water systems. Those are high-rise buildings, hospitals, healthcare facilities, places in which we have multi-residents, apartment complexes, things like that. Those are in place to basically control the risk for Legionella. As I mentioned, all those types of facilities that are covered under that, there are plenty of plumbing systems that are not covered under those umbrellas of those types of water systems. And so we have those guidelines in place as far as liability.

If a water system or a water operator is implementing a water management plan according to those ASHRAE guidelines and standards, they are ideally controlling Legionella. We know sometimes it's not necessarily true. Compliance might not equal safety, as we mentioned. So even though you're checking off boxes, you might not actually be addressing the underlying concern. But sometimes we can see that it acts as a way for systems to prove that they are doing something, even though it might not actually be as effective as they need it to be.

So for all of us in drinking water, we're used to the ANSI NSF standards for drinking water treatment, all that stuff. I had to Google ASHRAE. I just did a second ago. American Society of Heating, Refrigerating, and Air Conditioning Engineers. So basically, they're the NSF ANSI standards for plumbing, piping, all that sort of stuff. Is that fair to say? Yeah. And those standards that they've outlined are actually adopted by the Center of Medicare and Medicaid Services to apply to hospitals or healthcare facilities that are receiving CMS funding. So if you are a CMS facility, you would need to be implementing a water management plan for the control of Legionella. Very interesting.

So you are a guest on the podcast because WQI has been working with Steve and some folks on our team to look at Legionella risk in private well homes. So how are those challenges different from larger or even regulated systems? It's a good question. Private homes and smaller residential systems are more challenging due to, I would say, a lack of awareness of whether or not they should be testing for Legionella or even just Legionella in general. As I mentioned earlier, a lot of homeowners don't think about the quality of their water until they have an issue. And with the multitude of things that a homeowner can be concerned about, it's no wonder that most are unaware of their potential risk for Legionella growth and exposure. And there's no requirement to test for Legionella.

they just might not be aware of it. And they might be potentially leaving themselves at risk without being aware of that risk. Another thing is, I would say, lack of funding and resources. The benefit that most large plumbing systems have is that they have resources and personnel to invest in implementing a water management plan and the testing to validate if their actions are actually improving water quality. And I think that is a pinch point for a lot of private residential homeowners is they have a certain amount of spending money. And if it comes down to testing the water or doing something else, they might choose that other thing. And so it's mostly, I would say, awareness and also resources funding.

And I think there's also the question of if you do find Legionella in your home, what do you do? And I'm not sure if there is information available on the CDC website and such, but it's not as publicly known. When you receive such a scary result, you want answers right away. And sometimes it's not very clear. No, that's a huge problem. The other piece is that at least public water systems are disinfected by law. And as someone who works with a lot of private well owners, no one disinfects, uses UV or chlorine unless they've had an E. coli problem. Typically, that's when it goes in and they can't fix by shock chlorination or some other thing.

Everyone looks at E. coli and coliform, and like we talked about earlier, Legionella is on no one's radar as a private well owner. It's never discussed. It's never really tested for. You know, there's people who don't test their water even for basic things because they're worried they'll find something and then they'll have to pay for treatment because they just don't have those kinds of funds. So everything you said just rings totally true with what we see working with private well owners. Is there anything that a private well owner can do? I know we're actually talking about disinfection. Is there anything practical they could do to maybe reduce their risk besides necessarily adding a chlorinator? Any thoughts there?

Before I get into the things that a homeowner can do to protect themselves or prevent Legionella from colonizing their water system, I do want to mention that a lot of the practical steps that a homeowner can take to have that benefit is not necessarily limited to just Legionella control. Our goal at WQI is to address the underlying conditions that promote establishment and growth of Legionella, which is often related to file formation. By addressing this biofilm, we can improve water quality, reduce the likelihood of pathogens that includes Legionella, total coliform, Z. coli, and we could actually reduce the potential for plumbing fixture corrosion, decrease the likelihood of taste and odor issues and other aesthetic issues like staining. Now, as far as the practical steps that homeowners can take, I would say if we start from source to tap, I would say improve and maintain source water quality. For a private well, that would mean ensuring the well is cleaned or rehabilitated at regular intervals. If they're on a public water system, that means flushing their service line at a high enough velocity to remove accumulated debris and biofilm.

Maintaining water treatment systems is also important. So if you have a softener, if you have a granular activated carbon filter, you should be aware of the treatments or maintenance that is required to maintain that system. Many treatment systems require regular maintenance, backwashing, or cleaning to ensure that they're performing as intended, and that can help maintain water quality going into your water system. As far as the hot water system, don't cut corners with your hot water system. I know we like to try to reduce the temperature in our hot water heater to save on energy and cost, but Legionella can actually thrive in temperatures between 77 degrees Fahrenheit and 113 degrees Fahrenheit. The CDC actually recommends storing water at 140 degrees and delivering it to taps at 120 degrees. Don't try to turn down that dial on your water heater. If you want to protect yourself from Legionella or other pathogens, try to make sure you're keeping that at a decent temperature. If scalding is a concern, you can always consider thermostatic mixing valves to prevent that risk. Also, do not oversize your system if you don't have to.

People often dream of mansions and living in these large homes, but we've seen residential clients with large homes and complex plumbing systems who are experiencing corrosion and experiencing issues with their water quality because they are not actually meeting the velocity needs in that water system. If you have reduced occupancy due to family changes or changes in ownership, changes in whether you're using the home as a permanent residence or a vacation home, that contributes to water age and stagnancy within the plumbing system. And so if your water system is larger than your needs, you may have to implement intentional flushing of the plumbing system to mimic that usage that the system is designed for. And as always, if you have dead ends, get them out. That stagnant environment is perfect for Legionella. That's just a good thing. Just dead ends, just get rid of them. So you just mentioned flushing as a practical step. And this really would apply for a homeowner, whether they're on a public water supply that's disinfected or a private well home. And that's really just every so often turning on as many faucets as you can and really stressing the system. I guess where I run into a problem is, or how to solve this, is there's already established biofilms.

velocity isn't going to take care of that probably, or it's going to need some kind of chemical treatment to get rid of them. And so how do you know if you have biofilms without spending a lot of money to do certain kinds of tests? Is there just testing for overall bacteria count? HPC, I think it's called. Is that something that a homeowner could do? And I just thought of that on the fly. I'm trying to think of what can we tell people because they already have biofilms, then flushing isn't necessarily going to take care of it.

So to address the first part of that with the flushing and removal of biofilm, if you have an established biofilm that might be like sticky in nature or recalcitrant, you might need to do extra treatment or even, you mentioned chemical treatment, but one thing that we have recommended is actually air scouring. And that involves basically introducing a little bit of air into the system to break up, mechanically break up biofilm or debris that are in the system. Depends on what the system owner can achieve, if that's feasible for them. Now, there are ways to remove biofilm. It's just some are more complicated or some biofilms are more recalcitrant than others. As far as detecting biofilm in the system, I would say looking at the nutrients or even if you're going to go the microbial route, I would say looking at your water system from source to tap. So from the entry point of your building to the treatment system to the water tap that you're using and just looking at seeing how those change, it can give you an idea of...

what you might be having in your system and what issues you might have to be combating. And we at WQI like to take that approach because it helps us determine where the source of the issue is. And if we determine where the source of the issue is, we can actually address the problem from the source instead of just addressing a symptom. Or even having to address the entire system. Yeah. So I've been listening to Steve for the past few years. Tell me slash complain about lab methods used to identify Legionella. It's been really interesting because you just assume that if there's a method, it works and that they all do what they're supposed to do. So what challenges have you seen?

Yeah, so as with any lab method, there are strengths and weaknesses to each method used for Legionella detection. There have been studies performed looking at the success of certain methods in detecting species of Legionella bacteria, and there are various methods. So first, there's the spread plate culture method. Labs use a traditional spread plate culture where they take the sample and they spread it on a plate and they use that to basically see how many colonies of Legionella are growing from that sample. And that is a method that's actually certified by the CDC Environmental Legionella Isolation Techniques Evaluation Program. That's also known as CDC Elite. That method has its limitations in that it detects the entire genus of Legionella, which can be difficult for investigative uses of culturing. So if you're trying to pinpoint an exact species, connecting it to an illness that somebody had, that might be a little bit more difficult. You would have to do some additional typing of that.

the culture. Interpretation can be challenging, especially if the analyst is not as experienced. And there's also a potential for false negatives when Legionella species are actually present. And without trying to get too in the weeds with the description of this method, but when you're analyzing plates, the analyst must use a combination of auger conditions to determine whether the growth on the plates is Legionella or a non-target organism. One of those conditions is an auger plate that does not have the amino acid cysteine. And because Legionella inherently requires cysteine for growth, any growth on that auger that does not have cysteine would indicate that organism present is not Legionella. However,

There are species of Legionella that can grow on the auger without cysteine. And so if you're looking at those plates and you see growth on all the conditions, including that condition without cysteine, you might think, oh, this is just a non-target that made it through. And you would actually end up predicting a false negative in the sample, even though you do have Legionella. One of those species that causes that false negative would be Legionella ochrogensis, which is not Legionella pneumophila, which is what a lot of healthcare facilities are very concerned about. But it's still, that false negative is detrimental to water management and public health.

As far as other methods, there's the LegiAlert. That one detects only Legionella pneumophila. And the reason for that is because Legionella pneumophila, sero group 1, is the Legionella species commonly associated with Legionella infections. That's about 93% of its infections are attributed to that species and sero group. But this ignores other species of Legionella and doesn't give, the Legionella itself doesn't give insight to the sero group of the pneumophila. It also has a risk for false positives. Pseudomonas is one that causes a false positive in the Legionella. And one thing listeners should know is that Pseudomonas is highly ubiquitous, meaning it can be found in a multitude of different environments. So finding Pseudomonas in a water sample is very common.

And so that can be an issue for the Leg Alert essay. And then there's also PCR, which detects genetic material. And then in that case, you don't necessarily get an idea of whether the material is from a viable organism or a non-viable or dead organism. And so we spend a lot of time discussing the pitfalls of these tests, but I do think we should consider the information that we are gathering from these tests and what insight that gives us into the overall system's water hygiene. Now, if we're using traditional plate culture, we do not get any legionell positives, but we see a lot of growth of non-target organisms. Are we just going to assume that we're in the clear? I wouldn't look at that and think that we are safe, but we might be safe from Legionella.

But it indicates that there is a condition in the water system that is allowing microorganisms to persist, which can contribute to other water quality issues and can put human health at risk in other ways with other waterborne pathogens. And if the environment supports the growth and persistence of a multitude of microorganisms, it can likely support the growth of unwanted microorganisms too, such as Legionella. Even if we don't get a Legionella positive that one time, if that environment is present, we could get a positive in the future. Yeah, especially the non-target side of that. It's a whole nother issue to identify those. I'm sure it leads you down.

quite a path. But I guess what you just said makes the most sense in that if you have other growth, it's worth understanding why. It means bacteria are able to grow in a water sample that should be disinfected, especially on a public system. But it's very interesting. And there's a lot going on, I realize, related to all these efforts. And we pay attention to literature here and we see stuff all the time on new methods that are being developed. Things like letting a plate go for six months and then something eventually growing. How do you deal with that? It's not practical to keep a plate in an oven for all those things. What you said earlier about the Jurassic Park quote is really sticking with me. The Legionella is a poster child for that.

Is there anything else that you think our listeners need to know about? Either Legionella, water hygiene, any of the issues we've talked about today. It's been fascinating to hear about all this and we appreciate your time. And if there's anything else that you want to add, please do. Sure. I do want to mention quick that Legionella, we have a focus on detecting Legionella. A lot of water management plans are validated by detecting Legionella, but Legionella is often a symptom of an underlying issue. We often attribute that to biofilm.

But these underlying causes of Legionella are unique to each system, and addressing the underlying factors often solves water quality issues in addition to Legionella control and prevention. Those issues that can be improved upon by addressing these factors include corrosion, premature pipe failures, aesthetic issues, taste odor, staining, recurring total coliform and E. coli positives, seeing an increased disinfection demand in the plumbing system, and Legionella is often associated with biofilm. And that biofilm connection is recognized by ASHRAE guideline 12 as being a factor in regional growth and persistence within plumbing systems. And the word biofilm is mentioned in ASHRAE guideline 12 34 times. But in the ASHRAE standard 188, which is the standard that applies the concepts of guideline 12, it isn't mentioned at all. And so there's a gap between our understanding and our action that makes it more challenging to address water quality issues and ultimately leaves the public vulnerable to disease.

I'd like to see a shift in the industry from our current reactive approach to a more preventative approach to detect the conditions that would support Legionella and maybe work towards addressing those conditions before we have a Legionella positive instead of just reacting to a positive and fighting an uphill battle against biofilm that's established in the system. You mentioned earlier, a private homeowner doesn't worry about their well water until somebody gets sick. You're asking humans to fight against their own. But it is true. Proactive is certainly always better. So that's really interesting. Thank you for coming on today. And it's really interesting. Katie, are you on social media in a professional capacity where you'd invite our listeners to follow you?

Yes, I am. I am on LinkedIn at Catherine Magley. That's K-A-T-H-R-Y-N-M-A-E-G-L-I. And our listeners can also follow Water Quality Investigations on Facebook and LinkedIn. Great. And we'll include all those links in the show notes for the episode. Cool. Thank you so much. I appreciate you taking the time today and having this enlightening discussion. TAP Talk is a collaboration between the Rural Community Assistance Partnership and the University of Illinois with funding from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. The show is hosted by Steve and Jennifer Wilson of the Illinois State Water Survey. You can visit drinkingwaterpodcast.org to find the full show notes for this episode.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Tap Talk?

This episode is 41 minutes long.

When was this Tap Talk episode published?

This episode was published on April 23, 2026.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Tap Talk episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.