Skip to content
Ulrik Haagerup Talks About Constructive Journalism episode artwork

Mar 12, 2020 33 min

Ulrik Haagerup Talks About Constructive Journalism

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

This week we have a special interview with Ulrik Haagerup, the Founder and CEO of Constructive Institute, about what our media is getting wrong and how constructive journalism could be the answer.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Ulrik Haagerup Talks About Constructive Journalism

0:00 33:35
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome to your listening to 4th Estate, the show where we talk journalism. Coming to you from 2SER in Sydney on the Gadigal lands of the Eora nation, right across Australia on the community radio network and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. I'm Mike Atard. This edition we have a special guest, Ulrich Hugarup, who is the founder and CEO of the Constructive Journalism Institute.

He is also the former executive director of DR News and Editor-in-Chief in that's in Denmark. So OK, loyal 4th Estate listener, let me ask you a couple of questions. Do you find the news depressing? With coronavirus about to go out and control around the world, stock markets crashing and a US president almost denying that his nation even faces any threat from his virus, is your anxiety going through the roof?

And let me ask you an even harder question. Do your news sources help you to be an informed and empowered member of society? Well, those questions gave you a moment of pause. This edition of 4th Estate may be the good news story that you've been looking for because the Constructive Journalism Institute is at the forefront of a new movement called Constructive Journalism.

So what's that? And to tell us what our journals have been doing wrong, I'm pleased to say that Ulrich Hugarup is welcome to 4th Estate. Thank you for inviting me. Now, you've been here for a couple of days in Australia, and I'm assuming that you've had a little bit of time to look at our news media.

What are your initial thoughts before we delve deeper? I think you have a great country. I don't always think that that is reflected in the news here. I think even in so-called quality serious news media, there's a tendency to use tabloid storytelling techniques in order to grab the attention of people and actually I see that a bit more here than I see elsewhere.

And what do you put that down to? You mean why? Yeah. I think the competition for attention here is very high.

I think the media intention is very high. I think there's a huge conflict culture in your political environment. And I think it's not necessarily good for addressing the real issues maybe. So as far as your concern, it's more a factor of available audience rather than anything inherent in our media?

I think you experience the same thing as everywhere else in the digital media world, where it's so easy to measure everything. And there's a truth, I think, in the fact that if you cannot measure what is really important, which might be glued to the country together, make sure that you enlighten people and they know more about not only themselves, but other people who do not like themselves, how they place in the world, give it the facts right. If you can't really measure that because how do you do that, then what you can measure will be important and what can we measure easily? How many click on this?

How many view it? Does it convert into something? How many share it on social media? And if we don't take care and I don't think we have to enough degree, that will be what is important for us.

And have you observed in your time here the proliferation and exacerbation of... That was very, very nice words. Danish guy would not understand what that means. Have you observed in your time here the increased number of reports that seem to be more opinion based, advocacy journalism?

Is that something that you noticed? Yeah. Is that more pronounced here than Denmark? Yeah, a little, but not much more than in Britain, but in Britain they have the best of the worst journalism in the world anyway.

I think there's a lot of news which is actually just of use. So you see the United States where I'm there quite often, I love America, but I get so depressed when I'm there because I now see families who can't speak together before. Again, because they have completely different views about reality depending on which media they're supplied. It would kind of truth the surprise.

So it's right. Whether they get the information from Fox News and their likes or they get it from CNN, which almost do the opposite of Fox. Do you think that would be any different if Donald Trump were not the president? I don't think it's a matter of Donald Trump.

I think Donald Trump was a product of that. I think that Donald Trump better than maybe any politician in the world really understood how to play media, angling all his stories on drama and conflict crooks and victims. And he was being overexposed because he knew about that and he was created a freak show and he was being overexposed. Actually numbers say he got exposure for free, which is what you normally don't do in United States.

Yes, that's right. You're spending money on advertising, right? But he didn't have to spend a dime in the presidential election because we did the jump for him. Yes.

1.9 billion US dollars. He got free exposure for because why? Because he talked into a new square area. He created drama.

He created conflict. But do you see that as a failure of journalism or just the uncanny, very, very smart workings of a mind like Donald Trump's of a salesman like Donald Trump? We see it a lot of places. We've seen it in Great Britain with Brexit, which was not a result of a really nuanced debate in the media and the public about the pros and cons of Britain being in or outside EU, but was a fight of slogans and perceptions give us our country back.

Who stole it? But it's a matter of people make decisions based on perceptions and other facts. And journalists tend to talk in slogans too and they tend to repeat things that have been already published so there's a kind of automatic transfer of information that's often unquestioned. Is it the same where you come from?

Yeah, to some degree. But I mean, I'm also really an optimist. But in all the different optimists, you also have to be a realist first and then you have to also see where the hopes are. And I do see hope and Denmark.

I saw the election with just that last summer, our summer in June. It was much better media coverage, much more responsible coverage than we had in the previous ... And why was that? I think we have been successful among editors, journalists, having a better discussion about what are we actually doing?

Are we doing something wrong here? Are we giving free airtime to lunis, to something extreme? Do we have to use words from warfare each time we have a new program, Crossfire, Hot Talk, duels, all that? Can we have other political debates than the debates with the blue corner, red corner, where we do split screens so it seems for people that they stand nose to nose and shouted each other?

But why the change? I mean, was that demanded by the public? Yes, but normally we don't care because we know best and they're just stupid. But I think people could ...

People, and when I talk about people, I mean media people have realized in our country that you could see the numbers. I mean, people hate programs where politicians yell at each other, which was a shame because that was all we did. So maybe we should find new concepts where we ... Maybe we should find new ways of ...

I mean, basically change the incentive structures for politicians. So they don't only get into the news if they hammer on someone else, criticize somebody, shout or extreme. Maybe we should find program formats where we encourage doubt, people who shut up and listen, who behave well, who are authentic, who have ideas. It's a very critical question to ask a politician.

I've got the question, who's to blame for this? And then they will always say to somebody else. But say, that was not what I asked. I said, do you have an idea how to solve the problem?

And if you don't have an idea, listen here. We have been to our living country and they have the same problem too. You look what they did. They actually solved it.

Do you like that idea? If you don't, do you have another idea? So do you think that our media here in Australia does that to a sufficient extent in the limited time that you've been here and been able to observe? No, I don't think so, to be honest.

But I have experienced, to my extreme joy, a very big self recognition from both editors and journalists saying, we realized something's wrong. We just didn't know how to get out of it. Is that another way? And if you explain, there's another way.

We call it constructive journalism. So tell us what that is. Just give us an exact name. They are very curious and they really want to do it.

Just came from ABC and talked to them. I was at AAP the other day. We had a, I was in Canberra and talking to a lot of regional reporters the other day. And it's really fascinating.

A lot of bright people with it. And all of them went into journalism because they wanted to do good for societies. And they know to something. And maybe we don't, if we only paint a black picture of everything.

Can I put to you though, I do want you to define constructive journalism for us. But we first met at a conference the other day that was hosted by the Judith Nielsen Institute for Journalism and Ideas. And you sat on a panel there and you sat on a panel with the editor of the City Morning Herald, the essentially the editor in chief of the ABC, Gavin Morris, who's head of news and current affairs with the editorial chief essentially of News Limited and Lenore Tade of McGurley. And what I heard from I think almost all of them was, do this all sound great but we're already doing it.

Were you surprised by the, did you hear that same message? Yeah, yeah. They said that to some degree until some of them which was Gavin from ABC said, we always say this as conferences. Oh, we do well because we're always being attacked by somebody and then we feel we have to defend ourselves.

But there were also self-recognition there. There are things we need to do better. We need to be more curious. We have a tendency in our profession also in Australia that we as journalists, we have the story in our minds before we go out of the building.

We know which folks we want. We have the storyboard ready before we leave, which is not really been curious because reality might turn out to be different. So I think that was also on this top level of people, a recognition of, oh yeah, there's things we could change. But isn't that just bad journalism when you set out to cover a story and you've already got the storyboard in your mind and you're just looking for the quotes to slot into a story.

I mean, that's just plain bad journalism. If you had good journalism, where does constructive journalism make that better? Constructive journalism is basically trying to answer the questions that none of us learned in journalism school, which is now what and how. Most of journalism is focused on two other things, which is who's to blame, which is investigative journalism or what has happened and how much does it cost and where was it, which is the breaking news part.

I know people want to know, isn't that all that people want to know? Yeah, so constructive journalism is not trying to replace that. It's trying to build on that. It's finishing the circle of breaking and investigative news because I don't know if you have that, but I spend a lot of my time digging up problems, figuring out who's to blame for it.

Could I get them fired? I was a great journalist. I went prices. I got quotes and then I jumped on to another problem and another problem and another problem.

And in that process, and it was never fake, it was never lies. We don't lie. But I was sometimes maybe not so much interested in whether I gave a true picture, whether that I got my story. And so I got my appraisal for my colleagues and my boss and from other journalists and other media that should quote it.

So there are things that constructive journalism is a way of talking about quality and how can you do it better? By adding to the equation, journalism can also be about tomorrow. It can also be inspirational. It can also ask the question now what and how.

Do you think that social media has made it slightly worse in the sense that- Much worse. Okay. We'll tell you how do you think it's made it worse? I mean, I think it's a very nuanced discussion.

But for the first 10 years of the life of social media, we all thought this is fantastic. This is democratic, democratic, democratic, and it is fantastic. I mean, we were gatekeepers of information to people. People have to be nice to journalists in order to get journalists to do their stories, so they could get some kind of version of that truth out to people.

Now everybody has access to tell their own story to everybody all the time from everywhere. And that sounds great. And it is great. But, and there's a bot.

And it's only for the last one, two, three years we have started realizing, Jesus Christ, how do these people make their money? If it's free, maybe we're the product. Maybe they collect so much information about us that do we really want that? And maybe it was not a good idea for traditional news media just to give our content for free.

So these tech giants in the hope that they would, they would somewhat, people would find us. Maybe that, maybe we have done something strategically very, very, very wrong. Do you think as well, or social media has permitted journalists to turn themselves into brands? And so if they don't go along with the way the herd thinks, if they don't go along with the way, you know, a certain tribe of thinkers think, then they lose their followers.

They lose their retweets. Yeah, but you see so many newsrooms now, especially in these breaking news environments online. They never leave the newsroom. They sit under social media and see what gains attraction and they try that.

And so this beautiful video, which in the beginning, it must be representative of what's going on all over Australia because you exposed it so much in any media here about these women who started fighting a little piece of toilet paper. And I thought, wow, it is happening everywhere since they put so much emphasis on that. But was it really so? Was it just three women who misunderstood something, maybe stupid or I don't know what it was, but does it happen in Perth and in kind?

Well, as it turns out, indeed. And it's spread to the United States, it's spread to the UK, it's spread to Japan, it's a bit deficit everywhere now. Yeah, but we don't fist fight over it, do you? I mean, people that might be a shortage and there are a lot of good explanations, but it was just an example that I was just talking to the ABC people.

They spent eight minutes about that single episode and not putting perspective into it, but just talking about this as if people were fighting all over Australia. And the perspective would be what? The big story is the coronavirus crisis is really exposing the consequences of globalization about the short supply chains we're having. What happens if we depend, we don't have stocks of things, we have to wait, we produce stuff when it's being ordered, all that, it's been shipped from China, from a factory in the other end of Australia and all that.

And that works fine until a point when people start thinking, lose confidence in that, you can actually get this. So there are a lot of things that the coronavirus will tell us and maybe that we could also learn from. Yeah. So can I ask you then, on the day that the World Health Organization has declared a pandemic, it's pretty alarming news and stock markets have fallen all around the world and it's pretty dramatic.

And people are now genuinely and probably understandably very worried. Do you think that they want to hear about supply chains today? No. What do they want to hear?

Now they want to hear directly, get an overview. I think they want to know how many people are affected, but also how many people are getting well. I think they want to get a nuanced picture. I want to get the facts right.

They don't want to be lied to. They don't want us to think that their authorities or people don't tell them the truth. But I think there's also lessons to be learned on the long run. I mean, this will take a long time and it will have massive effects.

But a story that I thought is interesting. Now we have to figure out how is it to work remotely on your laptop? How's that going? What can we learn from this?

How much CO2 emissions do we actually save by this? How much consumer goods do we actually not need? How can we be closer to our families? How can we and what can we learn from this crisis, which is really a crisis?

So when you look back on the week that you've been here and observing media and you see the news media reporting every new single case of coronavirus or COVID-19 being diagnosed, so it were headline news and a case of Ebola, what have you thought? But it's difficult because it is a global crisis. There are people dying from this and we haven't seen anything since the plague spread so rapidly. And in globalized worlds, it's traveled so fast.

So this is a new environment for everybody. I think that a situation like that also demands fast thinking at the same time reflections. I mean, maybe we should try not to do it. I saw the interview the other day really thought, wow, why are they doing that?

I spent eight minutes on giving the microphone to some opposition person who either attacked the government for doing too little or too much or too much. It was so easy to use the same narrative we criticized. And of course, we should have it abated about it. But the debate should be about what are the facts and what do we do about it?

How do we live here? And the media's role here is giving people trusted information, give them an overview. Don't scare them if it's not necessary. But tell them where it is.

Just like when you cover the bushfire. It was important to keep people informed but just as important to tell people where there was no risk anymore because the fire was out. But how easy is the question? Is that for journalists to do?

Given we are so entrenched in the way we report, in the way we conduct ourselves as journalists and the journalists and we produce, it sounds like a pretty big U-turn because at the end of the day what we're used to doing is saying they'll add it, if it bleeds, it leaves. If it's a big story, then that's what we're going to go with and the more negative and the better the news, the bigger the story. It's a pretty big mind shift that you're talking about. But I think it's a needed mind shift.

If you listen to what people say, that's two groups of people who say it very, very specifically. It's young people. They hate the narrative of us 50 something fat white men. And women.

But it's a very male way of presenting the world really. And women, they don't really like. Young women, we have lost them. They don't like this kind.

So it's not because young people don't care about the world. They just, and we have been used in media talking to people and we have used every new technology to find a new way to talk to people faster or louder or whatever. But maybe we should use these kind of technologies to find ways in which we talk with people, engage people, ask them. What do you think we should ask?

What do you want to know? How are you doing? People want to be engaged, especially young people. They want to be part.

So do you think that's why young people have kind of turned off mainstream media? And is it same in Denmark? Yeah. It is.

Where do they get the news in Denmark? Same places you do. Social media, social media, news. And sometimes they don't know where you have that from.

I'm from Google. What do you mean Google? I mean, they do produce anything. But so we have to, we have a giant mission also as parents to tell future generations.

It is important who you let you, who you let filtering. The world for you. Who is doing that? And why do they do it?

Is it because they, is it because they want to make money on you? Is it because they want to persuade you to think that they, like they do? Or do they do it because they want to do public good? There's a huge difference.

And we need, just because it's on Google or Facebook, it doesn't mean it's, you can trust it. It could be. But that depends where does it come from? Who is written it?

So in Australia as mainstream media, particularly ABC, bleeds, young audiences, they don't, you know, they've got a real demographic crisis that they are trying to deal with. They seem to believe that the answer is to kind of have a broadcast organisation that caters for two audiences. They're an established older audience and then a younger audience. It's taking what the ABC produces.

It's journalism onto platforms that young people use. No, no, no, but I'm not sure that's exactly what ABC News is trying to do, but it's right that a lot of news organizations struggle with the same thing. Take the same story and as we have done, newspapers saying, okay, these internet, how can we use that? Either as a marketing platform to attract people to our print product or we just use the journalism we produced for the paper and put it online.

We did that for many years and that didn't work in order to attract new customers. I think we need to listen just as much as we talk. So I'll come back to the question that I asked you earlier. How easy or how difficult it will be to get journalists to think in the way that you propose at your institute?

If you help journalists remember why they chose not to become lawyers or investment bankers, but they decided to spend their life in journalism, why was that? And they remember it was because they wanted to tell important stories to people in order to do good and then have them reflect on do good every day and the way you feel the world. Do they know? Sometimes they produce something they don't even want to read or watch when they have a day off.

So how can you think that other people want to do that? If you're a storyteller and you're not really passionate about what you tell, who will listen to it? And that might be a part of the problem. I feel and that's really, I'm leaving Australia tomorrow with high hopes because there's a lot of goodwill.

There are a lot of great people who really want to do good, who just need help with new ways of thinking, a little broader mindset, new tools, new concepts of making a debate which is not blue corner, red corner and who won, but how can we, where's the compromise? What can we do to solve this question? Now what and how? People get that.

I'm speaking to these editors who have been open to your suggestions. Where do they tell you that they've gone wrong? And do they admit any blame? Yeah, yeah, they do.

I mean, we all do and I'm not, I am most likely the person who had done most wrong because and that was what I, you have to admit that. I mean, I use the picture. If you come home from holiday as a man and you don't dare to go if you're close in the bathroom behind closed doors and look in the mirror and take the consequence of you. So you keep eating ice cream and you keep drinking too much beer and so if you can't see that you have, you have gained, you just continue and you'll end up being fluffy and then you end up dying, right?

And so we need to be the mirror and we need to not laugh at people but with people about what we do and help them understand that we could, we could change, we could do better without violating any of the principles of trustworthy, independent, critical reporting that we all cherish. Do you think that in this era where there is such competition for eyeballs for people to read stories and consume news media when the business models have completely broken down you'd have to say that, you know, producing that kind of journalism is what is going to get people to click on? I mean, the interesting thing is that the news organization we've been working with, when they start looking at the numbers which is mainly about engagement and trust level but also the fact that they find that people actually read news stories that deals with hope, ways out and what we call potential solutions to the problem. People read those stories much more than traditional news stories about a suicide bomb in Sudan where it is.

And to finish that, it's proven they also spend longer time on it. The truth is that a lot of people, they never read a new story until the end. They don't, but they don't spend time on it. They scroll, they find a new thing.

There must be more something interesting, especially on the mobile phone. But here they spend more time on it and they share these constructive stories more on social media than other stories. Can I ask you though, does that apply to stories where the story does not impact the person reading? So for example, I would be more inclined today to read to the end a story about the pandemic because it feels very real to me.

It's about to get me. So I'm concerned and I'm worried. And I can understand why people read to the end of the story in that social stance. When people don't read to the end about a suicide bombing in Yemen or wherever, it doesn't impact them.

It's not touching them personally. Is that the critical difference? Yeah, of course, journalism that deals with real issue that affects people is of course what interest us. But we also have to do stories on a broader level that's not only about you, but it is about us.

But when people read them? Not everybody. But a lot of people are not so selfish as we think. A lot of people, if we're able to frame it, you can do a story about on the coronavirus and now it's implemented in Australia the other day, it wasn't.

An idea from South Korea. How do you test people fast enough? Use what we have learned from the fast food business when Donald's drive in. So you just stick your arm out the window.

Somebody takes the block test, you get it and have some mess with it, you're positive and negative later. I mean, that's an idea because we need to test millions of people now. So we need stories like that. Does that affect me?

Maybe. But it's a damn good idea. And we can learn from that. And I think a lot of people like these kinds of stories.

But again, I think that's not a great example because you would expect to be concerned about coronavirus because somehow, in some way, even if broadly speaking and at a distance, it does impact you. But does bombing in Syria affect you in the same way? And would you read to the end just because at the end of the story or is it a part of the story, the journalist wrote about possible diplomatic solutions to the crisis in Syria? Yeah, but don't make it too complicated.

But if one example I used today, high school students in Denmark, they smoked more than they did 10 years ago. It's a complete failure of a strategy for several governments. We wanted the first smoke free generation. We didn't.

We messed it up. Something went wrong. So we can do that. And we could have thought of the guy who did something wrong and we maybe we can have him why, but that's not important.

The important thing is how do we fix it? If smoking is really bad for people, also young people, especially young people. So the constructive is looking to Norway. And despite the fact, none of my children smokes.

Despite the fact I don't smoke. I'm really curious about what did they do in Oslo that their numbers for high school students is not 18% as in Denmark, but it's 0.2 or 1.2, I can't remember. And you can actually, what did they do? They did something different.

They tripled the cost of buying cigarettes and they made a campaign, they get uncooled to smoke and Norway, we can show it. And that's inspirational. And that doesn't affect me. Do I care about it?

Yes I do. Do other people care about it? Damn, well they do. And that was Ulrich Hager, the founder and CEO of the constructive journalism institute.

He's also the former executive director of the DR News in Denmark. And thank you for listening to the Fourth Estate. This decision was recorded at the studios of TOSER and heard across the country on the community radio network. Fourth Estate is produced with the assistance of the Community Broadcasting Foundation and we thank them for their continued support.

Make sure you're subscribed to Fourth Estate on your favourite podcast app so you can hear us talk media, politics and a few things in between. Also can we ask you to tell your friends about Fourth Estate so we can share this unique insight into our media and body politic. We'll be back with more next week but in the meantime you can stay in touch with us on Twitter. Our handle there is Fourth Estate by you.

And thanks as always to my producer Anthony Docklum. My name's Monica Atard. Thank you for listening.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 33 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on March 12, 2020.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.