Right then, guys. Hello, everyone. Hello. Hello. Hello. For those who don't know me, my name's Jamie. Hello. Welcome to our third session on learning research. And today we're going to be looking at good clinical practice and ethics, and having a look at why that's so important when it comes to clinical research. Spoiler alert, there's going to be quite a bit of Nazis and syphilis. These are our learning outcomes for today. So we're going to explain what ethics are and why they're important to medical research. We're going to know what GCP is, why it's important, and how we get certified. And then we're going to outline how to apply for ethical research.
So if we just refresh our memory to go back into some of our previous sessions. In our first session, we were looking very much at the research method, and having a look at a literature review, working out what holes are in the literature, looking at what our outcome is going to be, and we talked about how that might guide our method. Last session, we had a look at PICO. Do you remember what PICO stands for? C stands for? Population problem. I stands for intervention. C stands for control or comparison. And O is outcome. Who invented the clinical method? Research.
James Lennon, what year is it? 1747. 1747. He essentially invented the... And we used this example to talk about Pico. This is how we formulate a clinical question. You have a population and a problem. His population was... We're on a disabled list with scurvy. He had an intervention in mind. He thought that acids cured scurvy. He thought scurvy was due to a lack of acid. He thought citric acid would be a really good cure. So he thought, let's give it a citrus root. He had some comparisons. He has sulfuric acid, vinegar, sea water, and a spicy paste with barley.
And at that time, you'd hope they'd be fighting fit and they'd be able to go off and fight French. And he invented the method. So that's our first two sessions that we've had so far. Please remember, as with all of our previous sessions, that this is a friendly environment. It's nice and open. If any of you have a question or a point to make, please feel free to get involved. So building on that, we've got our first bit of group work today. What I'd like you to do is have a look at it. Formulate the PICO for that. What was the PICO? But then also, as we're in an ethical session, some things may alarm you as you're reading it. So I'd like you to then have a chat about what the actual issues are in that study. But you guys here at the front.
Your study was, your abstract says, syphilis is an important section of the disease with multiple stages. Little is known about the right time to begin treatment for syphilis and at which stage of progression and with which dose. It's been theorised that syphilis affects different ethnic groups. We observed 625 poor African-American sharecroppers. 431 had syphilis at the time of enrolment. They were given free medical care, meals and burial insurance for participating. They were informed that the study would last six months but continued for 40 years.
After a decade of the study beginning, it was shown that henicillin could be a treatment for syphilis, but no participant was treated with henicillin, and the observation continued. No participant was informed they had syphilis. By the end of the study, 28 died of syphilis, 100 were dead of related complications, 40 of their wives had been infected, and 19 of their children had congenital. So guys, what can you come up with then for ECO and for your evidence? For 40 years, until 1972, it's interesting that people do...
behind this study actually felt that they were doing good because these were four people who in america would not have had any access to free medical care so actually by being enrolled in this study they felt that while we're not treating syphilis if anything else comes along we can treat that and we're actually doing good that was their argument even worse is that during the time of this study there was a second reward and men in this study were called up to fight army doctors said people are syphilis and the people behind the study did all they could to stop the army doctors from treating them but interestingly the gentleman behind your study is also behind your study which is the second group So, your one was also involving step for syphilis, and involved the recruitment of 1,038 Guatemalans from the army, prisons and mental institutions. Participants were unknowingly infected with syphilis, either through inoculation or through exposure with prostitutes. 52% of them received a form of treatment, which was either penicillin, which is a new word, placebo or traditional treatment. The age range of the treated patients was anything from 10 to 72, and overall 82 participants. So what was your pico and what was your effort? Well, knowingly. Yep, very into his syphilis.
vulnerable groups, as we've already discovered. That trial is known as the Guatemalan Syphilis Experiment, on from 46 to 48. It was only stopped when there was some gossip going around amongst public health circles, and it was also stopped because they ran out of money. It was the only reason it really stopped. And we only found out about it in 2005, when somebody was researching Tuskegee. So, doctors behind this, where are all from? So finally, a group there at the back, you've got a child that doesn't involve symptoms. Unfortunately, there's only so much syphilis as one through Google.
There is limited knowledge regarding the treatment of prostate cancer, or the training for rectal exams. It has proven hard to recruit patients to trials due to concerns over pain and other adverse effects. We recruited homeless men in lower Manhattan, showing signs and symptoms of urinary obstruction. Little was known of their background, although many had alcohol or mental health problems. Patients underwent a physical exam, as well as blood and radiological investigations, and had biopsies of their prostate taken. If cancer was confirmed, a prostatectomy and orchidectomy, such as their prostate and their testicles removed, was performed, and they had hormone treatment in this. Patients found to have cancer, received a bed, three meals a day, and had three medical treatment.
To ensure improvement, we did not inform the patients having adverse effects on the biopsy. 24 patients reported adverse events. Of 686 patients tested, the mortality rate of patients with negative biopsies was 20%, while it was 30% of patients losing positive biopsies. Yeah, brilliant. Intervention. And to know what sort of adverse events they would be getting after having a biopsy. So yeah, infection, rectal percoration, incotent, it's a good adverse event. What did you think about ethics? Yeah, to start, yeah. It's what's known as the Skid Row Cancer Center.
called Skid Row, and it was the street he recruited these guys from was called Skid Row. It was actually called Skid Row. This is Dr. Harry Hudson, who was a New York urologist, who used to practice medicine, and I believe might still be alive. And he thought this was a great, brilliantly designed study. And he said, well, of course it's great, but I haven't paid them, there's no coercion, they're homeless people, they're homeless people, otherwise, this is a great study. And he began publishing his research, and that's how people started pointing out to me. He didn't have a control of heriton, that's what stopped him doing. So, what is the definition of ethics? What does it mean to you? It comes between right and wrong, yeah?
So essentially, it's the moral considerations that guide your behaviour or an activity. So it can be the personal ethics guiding you, but also an activity, whether it's a research trial, whether it's a clinical operation, etc, etc. The important thing there about ethics, I think something that we've mentioned in all of these groups, is there's a degree of power and control. Has anyone here ever actually been in a hospital with a patient? I think to speak as a doctor, being a patient, I suddenly realise just how much control you hand over when you're a patient. And actually, when you're a doctor and nurse there, how much power you have in that person. And they have to have a lot of trust in us, and they've got their interests apart.
and that if we're giving them demographics, if we're giving them information observations, if we're giving them tissues, we've got to make sure it's being done for the right reasons. To help out that person, there's also a wider community to be there, are people who thought they were doing the right thing, they were fully trained, they were in a democratic country, but it's clearly ethically done for you. Ethics has also been formed throughout the centuries, so the Hippocratic Oath in the 5th century BC, that's probably about the first time we started talking about ethics, and from there we get the phrase freeman non-moshio, you've probably heard that expression, it means first to no harm, and that really is the first principle that guides ethical practice versus no harm.
when we're there with our patient, making sure we've got their best interests at heart. Because ethics can be a personal thing. What you think is right and wrong would be different to me. We all have our own political opinions, we all have our own faith, we have religion, we have experiences that guide us. And those can sometimes be at odds to things that are going on in our community, can be at odds of what we have to do for our patients sometimes. That's why it's important to move away from the person to start thinking about the official. That's why it's very important that there are legislation and there are guides for us to guide our ethical practice. That really is primarily a tale of two cities. Great thought. The first sitting question is Nuremberg, 1947, the Nuremberg post.
what was going on in Nuremberg in 1947. After the Second World War, the fourth horror of what was going on in the Nazi Concentration Council was coming out, the work of Joseph Mengele, horrible studies on twins and considered inferior, and people realised this can't go on. And actually what we need is a guide for ethical practice and research. And they came up with a code of 10 principles, it's all this 10 principles, and it looks at things like something we talked about, informing our patients, making sure that they can consent, making sure that there is a clear reason for our practice, it's not just because we fancy them, and stopping if we start to notice there are adverse events.
Moving on from there, because this is Neurobos Museum. Helsinki in 1964, so the Helsinki Declaration, World Health Organization, they expanded slightly on those 10 principles. They came up with 11 principles. But again, looking at it, enshrining, it's not a legally binding, it's morally binding, the principles that guide our research. And the Helsinki Declaration has moved on and moved on and has been added to over the years. The latest edition is in 2013, and there are now 37 principles that guide us in our practice. It's all the way around. We are setting up a trial. These are principles we expect wherever you are in the world.
So I've had to fill out a whole load of paperwork for my university dissertation, but that involved university students. If you're involving patients and NHS staff, that's when you need to get things up and get their effort. As Phil mentioned, if a trial comes to you like this, that's a large morphine centre trial. We've already had central approval before it comes to us, so we don't have to worry about that.
But if we're setting something up here, that's when we have to. And their website, if you go to their website, you basically get this tool. It basically goes through us asking you questions to see whether or not what you plan to do actually qualifies as research. And you answer it. And it says, yes, you are research. And you need to follow the pathway and fill in your form. You can follow that and go to other pages on there. They have it all spilt out for you exactly what you need to do. These are your forms that you need to fill in. And you need to carry the document if you want to see them before you can be here.
need that for any for involving any staff so for our central for the pump priming studies as well key parts of theirs and it doesn't even say we look favorably if you have involved patients in public in your design to show that you've talked about excellent the general brings us on to good clinical practice so these are the international standards ethical scientific and practical considerations if you are gcp positive that is an international standard that shows that you appreciate all the stuff that we've been talking about it is a requirement of law for the 2005 research government you are going to be doing clinical research. This is the National Health Researcher page, and it basically goes through, do I need it? And if you do need it, how do you go about getting it? There's a range of online e-learning that you can do in your own time, and when you click all the way through and done it, you have your own experience. And it covers things, not just about Nuremberg, not just about Helsinki, but also how to report an adverse event, who is actually responsible during your trial or something that you've played. It's all sorts of things. So here are a little bit wordy as an e-learning package. I've done a medical classes in medical education, so let's have it.
So Lisa Hogg asked for this session on www.taecoordy.com. We'll also put up the links to GCP and we'll put up some links to Nuremberg and Helsinki as well as to the NHRA. Our next session is on the 16th of May. We'll be looking at types of trial. So we've now started looking at the foundations of research and then we'll be actually getting into the new theory of actually what the different types of trial are in the airport.
I hope that I've shown you why we worry so much about ethics. It's not just an annoying hurdle that we need to get over. It's actually there to protect not just our patients and our colleagues, but us ourselves. It's a way to help us to guide our practice and to make sure that we are doing the best to our patients. Ultimately, what I hope I've shown to you is that the only way is ethics.