Uncrustables vs Trader Joe's Taste Test | Birmingham News

Who knew a head-to-head taste test between Trader Joe’s and Smucker’s Uncrustables would be so surprisingly close? Despite a recent lawsuit, TJ’s version—square-shaped, grape jelly—held its ground on the shelf, matching the iconic round, strawberry-flavored originals in creamy peanut butter and satisfying texture. The only real difference? A subtle jelly flavor note. And guess what? The shopper couldn’t tell them apart in taste—just enough to make you question whether the extra buck is worth it for that nostalgic sandwich fix. Listen in comfort:Get a discount on a Soli Pillow: http://solipillow.com/discount/dnn. Advertise on DNN:[email protected] This is an automated, high-level news summary based on public reporting.Sources:https://www.al.com/life/2026/09/one-shopper-did-the-work-so-you-dont-have-to-uncrustables-vs-trader-joes-taste-tested-side-by-side.html More coverage & latest updates:https://sources.thednn.ai/5e542444eb763453 Report issues to [email protected].