Understanding Insurance Fairness: Navigating High-Risk Area Policies
from Insurance Hour Hosted by Karl Susman
Understanding Insurance Fairness: Why Living in a High-Risk Area Costs More — and Why That's Reasonable When it comes to insurance, few topics spark as much debate as fairness. Homeowners living in wildfire zones, earthquake-prone regions, or rural communities often feel penalized by higher premiums and limited options — while their urban counterparts pay far less. But is it unfair that riskier areas cost more to insure, or simply reasonable? In a recent Insurance Hour discussion, host Karl Susman and Assemblyman Tom Lackey — a former California Highway Patrol officer turned state legislator — tackled this very question. Their conversation peeled back the emotion and politics surrounding the issue and explored what "fair" really means in the context of insurance. As Lackey put it: "Instead of using the word fair, what we really need to talk about is what's reasonable." This shift from fairness to reasonableness is more than semantic — it's central to understanding how modern insurance pricing works and why Californians in high-risk areas are paying what they are. Defining Fairness vs. Reasonableness When homeowners in wildfire-prone or rural areas open their renewal notices and see double-digit premium hikes, their first reaction is often anger. It feels unfair — especially if they've never filed a claim. But as Lackey explained, "fair" is subjective. What's fair to one person might feel unjust to another. "Reasonable," however, can be explained, measured, and justified with data. "If insurers can explain the reason why these rates are where they are," Lackey said, "then that meets the definition of reasonable. Because it's hard to argue that any rate is truly fair." Insurance rates are calculated using actuarial science — a process that evaluates risk factors, loss history, exposure, and the cost of potential claims. When risk increases, so must the premium. Wildfire-prone rural regions, for example, face far greater exposure than urban neighborhoods surrounded by concrete and hydrants. The same applies to properties near fault lines or floodplains. In that sense, charging higher premiums for higher risk isn't discrimination — it's math. The Rural Reality: Paying More, Getting Less Assemblyman Lackey, who represents a largely rural district in California, acknowledged that many of his constituents are feeling squeezed. "Right now, the rates for some of these rural areas, in my opinion, are not reasonable," he said. "Are they fair? Depends who you talk to. But reasonableness has to do with the ability to pay it." That phrase — ability to pay ...
Embed this episode
What this episode covers
Understanding Insurance Fairness: Why Living in a High-Risk Area Costs More — and Why That's Reasonable When it comes to insurance, few topics spark as much debate as fairness. Homeowners living in wildfire zones, earthquake-prone regions, or rural communities often feel penalized by higher premiums and limited options — while their urban counterparts pay far less. But is it unfair that riskier areas cost more to insure, or simply reasonable? In a recent Insurance Hour discussion, host Karl Susman and Assemblyman Tom Lackey — a former California Highway Patrol officer turned state legislator — tackled this very question. Their conversation peeled back the emotion and politics surrounding the issue and explored what "fair" really means in the context of insurance. As Lackey put it: "Instead of using the word fair, what we really need to talk about is what's reasonable." This shift from fairness to reasonableness is more than semantic — it's central to understanding how modern insurance pricing works and why Californians in high-risk areas are paying what they are. Defining Fairness vs. Reasonableness When homeowners in wildfire-prone or rural areas open their renewal notices and see double-digit premium hikes, their first reaction is often anger. It feels unfair — especially if they've never filed a claim. But as Lackey explained, "fair" is subjective. What's fair to one person might feel unjust to another. "Reasonable," however, can be explained, measured, and justified with data. "If insurers can explain the reason why these rates are where they are," Lackey said, "then that meets the definition of reasonable. Because it's hard to argue that any rate is truly fair." Insurance rates are calculated using actuarial science — a process that evaluates risk factors, loss history, exposure, and the cost of potential claims. When risk increases, so must the premium. Wildfire-prone rural regions, for example, face far greater exposure than urban neighborhoods surrounded by concrete and hydrants. The same applies to properties near fault lines or floodplains. In that sense, charging higher premiums for higher risk isn't discrimination — it's math. The Rural Reality: Paying More, Getting Less Assemblyman Lackey, who represents a largely rural district in California, acknowledged that many of his constituents are feeling squeezed. "Right now, the rates for some of these rural areas, in my opinion, are not reasonable," he said. "Are they fair? Depends who you talk to. But reasonableness has to do with the ability to pay it." That phrase — ability to pay — gets to the heart of the issue. When rates climb beyond what residents can afford, even "reasonable" premiums become unsustainable. Lackey argued that while disparities between urban and rural areas are inevitable, regulators and insurers alike need to find a balance. "We've got to get there," he said. "Because the public deserves that, and the institution deserves it." Entitlement or Expectation? Susman asked an uncomfortable but important question: "Do you think people in higher-risk areas feel there should be a way for them not to pay more just because of where they live?" He shared an anecdote about a woman from Big Bear, who argued that her higher premiums were unfair because city dwellers benefit from her community's tourism economy. "I live in Big Bear," she told him. "You come here to vacation. So, in a way, I'm subsidizing you when you visit — just like you subsidize me when I come to the city." Lackey sympathized but stressed that insurance isn't about shared experiences — it's about individual risk. "I don't know how you get away from not doing that," he said. "These are realities that exist." In other words, while society may share certain costs collectively — like taxes or infrastructure — insurance is fundamentally a risk pool, not a social subsidy. If one property is far more likely to burn or flood, that risk must be priced accordingly, or else the en ...
No transcript yet.