Skip to content
Uneasy about fishing episode artwork

Jun 25, 2026 50 min

Uneasy about fishing

from Urban Wildlife Podcast Hosted by Urban Wildlife Podcast

Billy and Tony are back with their first episode in almost two years. After some updates they talk about their uneasy relationship with fishing and how to connect urbanites with aquatic biodiversity. Here’s that Meateater article Billy mentioned.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Uneasy about fishing

0:00 50:15
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

This episode is brought to you by rad dudes who love nature. Welcome back to another episode of the Urban Wildlife Podcast, Tony. It's been a while. It's been a while. Yeah. So, I don't know. It's been about a year and a half, right? It's been about a year and a half, at least. I'm not even going to look because it'll make me feel bad to think about the hiatus. But urban wildlife is still happening. Yeah, indeed. Absolutely. And you're writing about urban wildlife. Yeah. I guess, like, I can absolutely say I wrote a book. Now, it's not going to be out for about two years because it's going to be about a year of revisions.

and like, you know, layout and everything. And then it's apparently, I don't know, about a year, but at least six to eight months probably of like back and forth layout and revisions and everything. And then... apparently it's a 14-month turnaround time from when you send it to the publisher. When the publisher sends it to the printer. Yeah, kind of love academic publishers. But they did tell me I could say. Oh, yeah, yeah. Yeah, so I don't know if we said last time because I forget if it had... We talked a little... I think we talked a little bit about it. I forget if it had said who it was because I signed a contract and everything. Okay. So like, yeah, so I am the author of the forthcoming Field Guide to Backyard and Urban Wildlife of the Eastern and Central United States and Canada.

And I'm sure that the title might get a little bit complicated, you know, but that's the working title right now. And Cornell or Comstock, you know, which is imprint of Cornell University Press is publishing it. And I'm stoked. And Timbal Kano is the artist who did my band's album cover, but he's also, he's an incredible wildlife artist, but he also does, his bear and butter is, he lives in the United States now, but I met him when my band played in Indonesian Borneo. And he ran a nature center in Balakpapan. He found it and ran a nature center, you know, in a sun bear rescue in the city of Balakpapan. Sun bear rescue? Yeah, sun bear. Because sun bears are like adorable.

did a small spare and people take him as pets. And the problem is, is... I mean, it's not like running a rescue for birds where you just need a little cage for... Right. So they have a big six-acre enclosure or whatever for them. Yeah. Or maybe six-acre or I forget. It's big, yeah. Yeah. And you can't release these bears into the wild because if there's habitat left for them, there's already a sun bear there and it'll come out. And so he had an American zoologist, Allie, volunteered there and met Timble and they got married. And now she runs a marine science center in Port Townsend, Washington, and she's in charge of the aquarium part of that. Wow. And so he lives here and they have a son and a...

so yeah but he you know he has all these wildlife financials as you can hear but he loves to do his main thing is he does album covers for like death metal bands and some you know bands so like yeah i mean he's incredible so i i saw i was looking through instagram a few years ago and i saw his art for a compilation of like bands from like calamantan like and it was always like boarding wildlife and i was like this is art's incredible oh my god it's artist and then i saw it was my friend and i was like and i don't even remember the band my band rambo had even how serious we were talking about making a new album at that stage but i was like man if rambo ever does an album cover it has to be him he's our friend already he's perfect so he did our album cover it came out like two years ago whatever you know, defy extinction. And it's all, you know, wildlife, mostly wildlife on the U.S.-Mexico border. But then we also have, like, all different authoritarian, like... It was wildlife going after public officials. Right. And also, like, a militia guy. But we even had Biden on there, like, it was a big kind of... I mean, because the status quo is not good for the environment. So, like, we would want to be like, well, like, Democrats are the best. I mean, anarchists aren't exactly pro-Democrats. Right. You know? And it's also silly, you know? The funny thing is, one militia guy, he had a patch, like, on his leg.

gear that had like the flag of texas with like a silhouette of era 15 and like someone comments and you know from where i was posted online like relapse records did the record and someone was like oh of course you're gonna make fun of texas and it's like it was really taken from like something but also like my wife is from texas you know what i mean like yeah like and so i go to texas all the time like i love texas like i'm not i don't want to put up with texans being defensive texans are so aggressive with their with their like identity that like come on like we're allowed to make fun of texas yeah yeah and it was like you know it was a I mean, it's the biggest border of U.S. and Mexico is Texas. Totally, yeah. You know, so, yeah. But I mean, it's just, I mean, literally, so many things attacking him are like, oh, what's the fritillary? There's a South Texas, like, localized butterfly. Yeah. Of all things, like, come on, it's ridiculous. Yeah, no, if you're getting attacked by a butterfly, it's hard to take that seriously as something threatening. Yeah.

And so you're still running an environmental center. Yeah. So I run an nature center for, I don't care anymore, Philadelphia Parks and Recreation. Yeah. Who I mostly love. And even the people that drive me crazy there that are being in my existence and getting worked on, I still think they're some of the best people in the world. Yeah. They just have different priorities. And you get to turn urban folks on to nature and wildlife. Yeah. Yeah. Because I've still got a book out. So if you're like hungering for Tony's book, but you want to get another book in the meantime, you could get Exploring Philly Nature, a guide for all four seasons.

I have continued writing for Grid Magazine in Philadelphia, although you can subscribe to it from anywhere, but it's a Philadelphia-focused environmental print magazine. I'm the senior editor there now. And I wear another hat, a very part-time hat, where I'm running a little nonprofit in northern Chester County. So it's about an hour outside of Philadelphia, depending on the traffic. It's called the Great Marsh Institute. And so Great Marsh Institute does programming at the Great Marsh, which is a really big, really big spring-fed freshwater marsh. Basically, if you're trying to think where that is in the geography of PA,

in the headwaters, basically the headwaters of Marsh Creek for folks who know their Pennsylvania geology and geography. But it's a cool spot. Check out greatmarshinstitute.org and you can learn more about what events are taking place and come check it out. Follow us on Instagram too. And it's interesting about the Great Marsh is often we have discussions about what constitutes urban wildlife and that we're very biased by how dense Philadelphia is. Yeah. And I remember the book, you know, originally I was trying to do a book called like Urban Wildlife of the World. And I just think it's viable to have a book.

that you could take with you around the world and step off a plane in any city and still see, you know, and have a guide to most of what you would see, terrestrial vertebrates, but that ended up more localized, right? But when I was researching the book, the city that I thought was just going to be North America, I said I was looking at the West, you know, and I was looking, you know, and I thought the whole thing about swift foxes, right? And it was urban swift fox research and like what they're considering urban. like, the area they're looking at, like, would absolutely, in that area of California, would absolutely correspond with, like, Tester County. All right. You know what I mean? So, like, you know, it's in, like, the Philadelphia metro area in, like, you know. Yeah. But it's, you know, it's approaching where it kind of becomes rural, but, like. It's ex-urban adjacent. Yeah. So, it's interesting, you know. Yeah. It's still kind of, you know. And then I can't, I'm sort of a compulsive nature writer, so I have a substack called Where the Brown Snakes Roam. And I'm playing around with a substack, another one about billionaires called Billionaire of the Week. But I'll see if that one has legs. If people like it, I'll keep writing it. If not, I'll just focus all on the nature stuff again.

I started self-stack too. I think I have three followers and I do it like, I think I made like three posts like months apart, but I'm trying to make it work regularly. So I think you just find it by my name, Tony Crosedale, C-R-O-A-S-E-D-A-L-E. There you go. And yeah. All right. So I'm probably going to do one for this podcast slash book. So, so we're, so now we're, we're, we're going to try to.

do podcast episodes more regularly. I have to say, I am not a fan of a lot of artificial intelligence. As someone who's a writer and editor for most of my living, I feel like there's crosshairs on my chest when it comes to AI. I'm what they talk about replacing. And so there's that. I have lots of other big concerns about society and AI. But one thing I do like about AI is helping out with audio editing. So I think with the help of maybe some AI tools, it'll be easier to put these episodes together and get them out. And so hopefully we can get these going once a month or so going forward. Yeah, absolutely.

in defense of ai a bit like i don't know my book would happen without ai because of like helping with copy editing editing you know like like especially you know like what's interesting you know i use grammarly a lot for you know editing and what i found was after a while i kept like refreshing a screen or whatever and like thinking that like i'm like oh it must not be working must not be detecting because i make any suggestions and then i realized oh i've taught myself grammar you know what i mean you know so like internalized it right so you know i uh and i think there's a place for people who are more content experts and ideas and they're deficient in like grammar like people are good at grammar and whatnot or like it's almost like those skills are maybe like a gatekeeper for a lot of people who have really good ideas and really good you know knowledge and like having you know to be able to like write your ideas down and not have to like outsource to a human the cost of like editing it you know and also it kind of just shows you like what for instance with a field guide like i write full sentences but a field guide you gotta condense it and like it's hard it's hard to like figure out how to like condense it yeah can you condense this and then like and i can just pick and choose what i want and rewrite it like you know like because like i

I mean, I can just write, write, write, write, write, write on my brain, but, like, you know, and then, like, but it's hard to write not complete sentences. Like, that's how to find it intuitive. So, like, it's nice to at least see, like, a suggestion. You know what I mean? Yeah, yeah. We were talking before the episode. What do we talk about for our first time back after a little while? And we just sort of went with the topic that...

happened to be something I've been thinking about a lot. And so I put this in a category, in a sort of a category of how you deal with compulsions for personal vices, as well as maybe a topic that can then bridge into certainly animal welfare questions, animal rights questions, and even conservation questions. And so maybe I'll start the story as asking Tony, when's the first time you think you remember going fishing? I'm almost certain. My dad used to be a lot more into fishing. I wonder when the last time my father went fishing. It's funny because he walked to the river from his house. I don't know when he goes, but I, they moved to Jersey.

But you grew up in one of the neighborhoods in Philadelphia close to the Delaware River. Right. Yeah. Yeah. Absolutely. In fact, when I was, when I, when I was old enough to like ride my, well, in his day, early 80s. So we've ranged freer then. Also too, when you live in Philly. We live in dense row house neighborhoods. Like where I lived, like I'm not by any means saying I lived in like open air drug markets and stuff, but like.

there's certainly, I didn't have to go, I mean, there's certainly some of that. I mean, you're putting certain risks in context. People definitely, I had my windows, we had like, someone kind of like messed up and shot everybody's window with a BB gun. Like, so it was, I seen like swap teams, like raid a house. Like I'm not, I didn't grow up like, you know, it's weird. My point is, is that, well, you can ride your bike and go to the river. Yeah. And the point is that we're free ranging. It's like, like, you know, when your neighborhood, when your block, it's probably as dangerous as, my block was more dangerous than going to the river.

yeah right so anyway so yeah i could go yeah and then when i moved to mayfair a little bit further than the river but still probably a mile from the river like you know i would go down and fish sometimes like you know on my own or the penny pack park and fish right and and so yeah so but i i'm first fishing i don't remember i have photos of me standing next to my dad fishing when i was little yeah when i could just start walking what kind of stuff would you fish for so trout but like we'd go to like every year we'd go opening to boiling springs and like near harrisburg for opening day because my aunt lived in harrisburg okay but like in and you know but also you know you know for our listeners you know that's our philadelphia is not exactly landlocked we're we're close to the you know we're on an estuary you know and we're you can cross new jersey in like you know an hour and a half no i mean that hour i've gone with my friends at night to like like see you get boardwalk fries and it's like 50 minutes each way you know there's no traffic like you can get to salt you know you get the salt water from philly 45 minutes right so like i've gone flounder fishing and you know so like yeah and like when we go crabbing you know, so like, you know, so I go charter boats, it's something that has a boat. My dad, I feel like he remembers, he had a fishing club across, and just north of Philly, where the huge dump is, you know, Pet Water Club. Yeah. So I did a lot, you know, but mostly like, you know, you know, and like, I used to love using little like MEPs, like spoons, like lures for like catching little sunnies. I love these ultra light tackle, catching little sunfish. Yeah. You know, so like, you know, and getting little baby strippers on a Delaware, you know, like, you know, catching, you know, yeah. So, you know, obviously like they stock trout in the creeks here, but it would go where they're.

or natural pork trout, you know, over the mountains, you know? Oh, yeah. You know? But yeah, so I mean, lots of fishing growing up. It was a big part of my... It was, for me, it was, I have early memories of, I think, I grew up in the Midwest, and I remember, I think the first time I was going fishing, there were calls with my dad. My dad's a pediatrician, retired, but he was a pediatrician, and so would sometimes get, when me or siblings would have, like, go to sleepaway camps, they like to have, like, it's kind of a nice deal, like a parent of one of the kids could be a camp doctor for, like, a week or two, and they might, like, have a few of them come through. So I was one of those, and we were fishing on the lake, and I think I caught, like, a sunfish. And then my grandfather, or my dad,

when we visited our family in Philadelphia, would sometimes drive across New Jersey and take a charter boat out and go fishing. And my grandfather, my grandparents also were snowbirds in the winter. They were down in Florida, Pompano Beach. And we would do that sometimes. And then I got, I don't know, it must've been like 10 or nine or 10-ish. I got into just like light tackle fishing, although I guess mostly for bass. And so I'd do that when I visited my grandparents. So they would have like these canals and golf course lakes and stuff. I'd just throw lures in there. I had a great time. I don't know. I can't think of why I stopped fishing.

I'm sort of sitting here thinking about it. I mean, clearly in my adulthood, herping took the place of fishing. Like it was a thing I would do to get out and catch stuff, which was a lot of fun. But like at some point, I mean, becoming vegetarian, I wasn't gonna eat the fish. And I was doing other things that I had more fun doing outside.

with the herping and i don't know it sort of left me some space to think more about fishing and started thinking about like maybe this is really not that nice to the fish and then what it would get me also was like thinking the times i would use fish as bait for fish yeah you know and like there's things like you would never intentionally go out and the term is foul hook like a fish like to hook it through like its back or something and drag it to shore but then there's no problem taking a juvenile version of a fish or like a flathead minnow or something like that and putting a hook through its back and tossing it out there to catch a crappie or something else or a little bluegill like you could you could catch a bluegill to catch a bluegill You could also catch a bluegill, put a hook through its face, and throw it out there to catch a flathead catfish. And like, there's, that sort of got to me. And if you use lures, you know, artificial bait, like, you can get away from that, but then you're still like, it's not like hunting more.

hopefully you just put the animal down instantly, right? Like, that's your attention. And you try as best you can to put the animal down immediately. And it's obviously a possibility. So what you should do, most likely, that's what's going to happen with fishing. Like, the animal is in distress and pain for minutes, if not, you know. And the whole objective is to have an animal in distress and pain. Like, it's not how you think of it. You're not saying, oh, I want to go torture a fish today. But you're like,

if you're saying, oh, that fish really puts up a great fight. Right. But circle back to Urban Wildlife Podcast. We're talking about this because it comes up like as, as a, we haven't done urban fishing before. It's, you know, and like a microfisher guy and whatnot. And like- Well, Leo Shang. Yeah. And I don't want to knock these folks. Leo is, you see him take great care to release fish in good shape, you know? I think the reason why we're talking about the, we're not passing judgment on other people who fish. We're talking about like, I think Billy, I think Billy and I both enjoy fishing. And, but-

or why don't we basically come to the i think both of us feel like we also have less other hobbies to take away but we're like kind of like this fishing we enjoy it and but we don't do it now why this is why not like the whole point of this is not to say we're guys fishing we like fishing we like to do it now but we want to talk about fishing because it comes up a lot as like a a way to engage people in nature like a gateway to nature and and so like well i'll say it's the only way you can interact with fish like short of i don't know how else you interact with wild fish i mean like i snorkel with fish i guess yeah so sometimes you know if i have work you know if i have a if i remember to do it early enough and like i could put out traps to catch like one of the my favorite things that we did when we were working at the nature center together was like the fish trap yeah and like seining you know and you know just show people you know and i have a native fish tank at work and basically borrow fish for a while and return them so there's that but like yeah i mean it's it's a great engagement tool but i think it opens up like a whole discussion about like I mean, there's a little bit of hunting. Hunting gets in there, too. But, you know, obviously hunting in... Well, you can... There's a lot of urban hunting, especially in a bigger context of, you know, like suburban areas or, like, green spaces, you know, state parks or whatever, state game lands or whatever, within a metropolitan area you can hunt. But fishing, you know, you can... You know, literally in New York City, you can just, like, throw a line from the base of a skyscraper. It's a lot easier to get a lot more people engaged by catching bluegills than by trying to go hunt white-tailed deer. Yeah. Yeah. I think it's... And so I've had, for the past few years, this bit of a conflict where I'm like...

you know we're sort of celebrating an engagement with nature or a mode of engaging with nature especially an area of nature that i wish more people felt engaged with but then we're doing it in a way that i feel uneasy about you know right there's you know the another impetus for the or not impetus but like something kind of pushed me over the edge talking about it more was honestly like listening to hunting media folks discuss fishing in in terms of like Yeah, we get fish, you know, you read about this or hear about this in the meat eater world. They have a good article on their website, an interesting article on their website talking about the conundrum of catch and release fishing. But the logic that, okay, if you're catching a fish to eat it and getting a hook through its mouth and yanking it to shore is the most efficient way you can think of, or that we commonly catch fish to eat them. In a way, you're reflecting some pain, but it's for the goal of feeding yourself.

Whereas with catch and release fishing, you're inflicting some pain for the goal of your own sort of recreational enjoyment. And so it's in a different moral category than catching a fish to feed yourself or your family or other people. I will say, you know, Bill and I are the same age and we, we just referenced this to a TV show Portlandia and they had the whole thing about the dream of the nineties. And so I don't, people do Portlandia dream of the nineties, but like one of the things when I was coming up and talking, like it's kind of like punk adjacent a bit, like it was like the people who would like. hang weights off of piercings and stuff. You know, so I'm like thinking like, well, maybe, you know, some people do take pleasure in like putting like a hook in their body and whatnot. A certain subset. Yeah, I don't think people still do that. Like your room circus, whatever was that? I forget what. I mean, it was all that like, you know, like Lollapalooza state, you know, the side stage people. No, I'm imagining people now. Doing hang center blocks off their like nipple piercings and stuff. Sideshow kind of stuff. Yeah. But the other countries I'll point out like have also wrestled with this. In Germany, apparently catch and release fishing is illegal. Apparently widely practiced and sort of people ignore the law. But they sort of came to that same conclusion that like, look, if you're just playing a fish and then letting it go.

that's not a good enough reason to inflict pain on it. And so it's, you know, in American fishing culture, you look at that and be like, what the hell are they doing over there? You think of the whole, in American fishing culture, catch and release is like the ideal in a lot of circumstances. You're trying to release a fish unharmed in the end. Someone else can catch that fish. Now, there's a lot of research into the actual survival rates of fish once they're caught and released.

So different fish have different survival rates after being caught and released. Apparently, like if it's a big catfish and it's not gut hooked, in other words, if a fish really swallows a hook and it gets hooked in their digestive tract, the fish is probably dead, even if it swims away. But if it's just hooked in the mouth, let's say a big catfish probably, I guess, apparently does pretty well. Trout do terribly. Something like a quarter of like rainbow trout or cutthroat trout that are released die from the trauma and the stress and everything. And that can really add up, even if it's just like 6% or something.

if it's a really popular fishery, like really popular fish, like stripers or striped bass, I was about to say stripers, everybody knows what that is. Striped bass on the Atlantic, mid-Atlantic, let's say, if like four people are catching the same fish, you know, as it's swimming up and down the coast, then that fish might just take too much of a beating. And also when people pick it up out of the water and they're holding it in the air and it's this big, heavy fish that's not really made to be, it hasn't evolved the ability to be out of the water, then that can also be quite a beating for them. Beyond being sort of an abstract thing that like we talk about, like, well, how do we engage the public with aquatic ecosystems without fishing? Yeah, that's a tough one. And then the other thing is I still really like it. What's sort of rewoken it in me is that...

a kid who, I'll call him like a nephew in the sense of close family friends. Like we'll call their friends like uncles to their, or aunts or uncles to their kids. But he loves fishing. It's a way for me to take him out and do stuff in nature. And I'm like, what can I do? Am I going to just hang out and go birding? I could, while he's fishing. And I'm like, well, I really don't like flathead catfish. And I really don't like snakeheads. These are two invasive species for the Delaware watershed and the flathead catfish in particular. Just like hoover up shad, which are native migratory fish that are in a lot of trouble. Incidentally, when the Partnership for the Delaware Estuary put out a report on status of shad and other anadromous herring.

that swim out the river and catch and release fishing is named as one of the problems for Shad. I don't even realize... You're about to say something. Oh, well, in a minute, yeah. Shad can breed more than once. They don't always breed more than once. But in Delaware, they definitely can. But if they're caught and then released, they're probably not going to breed more than once. They're not going to make that run another year because it'll just be too beat up after that. And so it can have an impact on the population level, possibly. One of the problems with shad is they're not quite sure. Like, there's a whole bunch of things that are affecting them. One of them is flathead catfish, like an exotic predator that they didn't evolve with that sort of, you know, literally takes its toll as they swim past. And then fishing is another one.

But flat catfish, I'm happy to pull out a river, pop them on the head and see what's in their stomachs. Same thing with snakeheads, little frog assassins. Yeah. So I've, I've, I've actually like gone through what for me is a mini buying spree to get like another, get a fishing rod and some lures that might work for these species. But I'm still like, I'm very mixed about it. I'm still quite sure. Yeah.

a little tangent. I'll try to be quick and brief anecdote about Shad just because of where we are. Shad are a big deal here. Yeah. Right. Well, the United States is about to celebrate its 250th year. I'm actually, I will be celebrating my 50th birthday soon. I'm named after Anthony Wayne. My name is Wayne after Revolutionary War General who apparently was a terrible person. But, so, like, I should probably rename myself like I do fish. I like to rename birds whenever ever, you know, better. But anyway, so there's two. Who's an outstanding Anthony in history? So you just be changing your middle name. Yeah. Well, yeah. We'll get back to that. It was about the Shad. So,

One of the famous revolutionary war... events it's interesting because it's almost treated like a battle but it's not a battle was Valley Forge and where we sit right now in my house is northern it's like I'm almost at the northernmost tip of Philadelphia and so I'm very far it's like not very far it's like 10 miles from here is Valley Forge Stark Park and Valley Forge was basically like it's famous for that Washington and his army didn't freeze and starve to death over the winter yeah and but they we just did a or one of the super AI memes we made was we're talking about oh turkeys crossing the river we made it the question is whether turkeys because there's wild turkeys in Philadelphia there's wild turkeys a lot of them in South Jersey urban areas, right? Urban parks in Camden, you can see wild turkeys. I have been at like a public housing development in southwest Philadelphia watching like a turkey across the street from some folks on their porch and they're just like, oh yeah, you're looking at the turkey? Yeah, I don't think turkeys were ever really like a deep, dense forest, interior forest bird. I think they've always been more like an edge and like an oak savanna kind of. So I think like the people like oaks, street trees and like yard trees. So I think like they're... They do okay. So the question was, could one, could they go from Jersey to PA and back and forth? Because we have this really wide river in between. Right. But however, the Delaware like does narrow significantly just north of Philly.

You know, so like maybe it's easier. These are the questions. So we're talking about crossing the Delaware. So of course, I was like, oh, Tony's going to respond with the AI meme of the turkeys crossing Delaware, like Washington crossing Delaware. But I had to take it further. I'd say this is a fun thing for me to do is always try to like throw a softball meme generator question to Tony. So rather than like just do the turkeys on the boat, I was like, well, let's have them one day after they land it and are killing Hessian mercenaries. But anyway, so back to the shad. Washington and his army ate dried shad, right? Because everybody in colonial...

Mid-Atlantic, the Colonial Mid-Atlantic in New England ate dry chow. And the other, so I live in the neighborhood of Philadelphia, Roxborough, and weirdly, Roxborough, like, this side of the creek, the park where I work, is the Wissing Creek and the Wissing Creek divides Northwest Philadelphia in half. And for some strange reason, the one side of the creek, you know, about equal area of Philadelphia, is four neighborhoods, Chestnut Hill, Mount Airy, Germantown, and East Falls. And the corresponding side is essentially just Roxborough on one side. There's Upper Roxborough. Right, but it's all one zip code. All right. What about Maniunk? That's a different neighborhood. Other than Maniunk. And Maniunk's literally like a mile long, mile too long at the most, and like a few blocks wide, and has its own zip code. And it's really weird. It's like, it's this tiny little, it's like...

it's like basically it's the main street and a couple blocks off of it but it has its own zip code and it's like but manny what it was it was his own little was his own community before philadelphia you know became like surrounded it and and uh 1854 i believe yeah and yeah and manny young i it's funny i've been trying to i know about this incident i'm about to talk about and we're struggling back to shad but i don't i haven't been able to find the references so i'm hoping to invent this go ahead what is it apparently so just north of philadelphia outside the city limits just north is a town called contra hawken Yeah, another Schuylkill River town. So there's Maniunk and then Conchahokan, and they're pretty close to each other. They're only a couple miles apart. And apparently, they fought a battle over Shad because Maniunk was putting a net across the Schuylkill River. So Philadelphia has two big rivers, two main rivers. No, you might be onto something. The Delaware River is an enormous river and one of the largest undammed rivers in the United States, I believe. And Schuylkill has dams on it, and it's a lot smaller. And so this is the Schuylkill River, the smaller of the two rivers. And so you could feasibly put a net over the whole, across the whole river. Like Delaware's pretty much, I mean, it's like a mile wide in places. But the, so apparently.

Katsuhaka was mad that Maniak was putting a net across the Schuylkill and they came down to fight him. I'm not sure about that. I'll tell you both, you're onto something though. So there's a book that I just read because I was writing an article about shad, which is why I was thinking about shad so much for Grid Magazine. You can read about it in Grid. Looking at how shad are like in trouble out here, but on the West Coast and the Pacific Northwest, they're going gangbusters. They're like the most, by numbers, the most common migratory fish coming up the Columbia River, for example. They have like massive amounts of shad out there where they were introduced. Wow. And so it was kind of a funny thing how like out here, we're like doing everything we can to rescue the populations. Out there, they're just like swimming in shad. But-

The book, I think it was called America's Fish by McPhee. Hi, listeners. Quick correction. The book is called The Founding Fish by John McPhee and incidentally includes a whole chapter where he wrestles with the ethics of the pain caused to the fish versus everything else that he absolutely is fanatical about and loves about fishing for them. about Shad. Great book, but he talks about these histories of in colonial, the colonial schoolkill. It wasn't Maniunk and Conchhocken that he writes about. It was two other towns, but basically that. On a different river or was it? On the schoolkill. I feel like it was like near Flower Town or something. It was like a little further up the schoolkill. Maybe. But like that, you'd have people netting all the Shad before they could get up to the next town. That was a real thing. People getting pissed about it. Also, what would happen is that people would string nets across for the Shad and then farmers who wanted to like take their boats down the river to sell their flour or something would get caught in the...

And the nets capsize and lose, like, a season's worth of product because this other town downstream was fishing for shad. And so those are real things that happened. I don't know if it was Maniak and Koch-Auken, but you're remembering something real. Oh, my namesake, apparently. Maybe you could put a net over the Delaware further north.

But people would put nets out into the Delaware. Right. You don't have to cross the whole way. Apparently, Anthony Wayne put a... I think what he did was put a chain across the Delaware to prevent British ships from getting up there. There you go. No, if you pick a strategic spot where it's like a channel that the fish would be following, you net that. I mean, it was funny. When I've written articles about sturgeon...

before there was a caviar fishery for sturgeon, sturgeon were known for pissing off the shad fishermen because they'd string these nets out into the Delaware River and then you have this seven-foot beast of a fish go right through your net and destroy it. Also, one of the other names for service berries is shad bush because service berries are a small, either small tree or large shrub, like a multi-stemmed. It's an apple family. The berries are kind of like a blueberry mixed with a cherry and if you actually bite through the... little tiny pit. It gives off a little bit of pepumic acid, like an almond. And I know about this because I went on a whole Servesbury walk with the Philadelphia Botanical Club up at a Poconos. I got to see a coyote cub and it was yelling at us. It was one of the two things I ever saw. But like, apparently the taxonomy of Servesbury is like crazy. It's a ton of species. And it also like, it's like haploid, diploid, and it's like all these weird... But anyway, like, the name Servesbury refers to it would be in flower at the time of year when the ground was thawed enough to, you could dig a grave. Because if you died in the winter, you couldn't, before you had like, you know, excavators, you had to put bodies in a mausoleum or something until... So...

And I just think that's apocryphal. Oh, really? Yeah. So that's what I heard. That's a great story. You have a service, a funeral service, but you say it's not true? Apparently serviceberry is close enough to, I guess, a French or another term for the, like a French term for the tree. That's like an anglicization that then became a just so story. Wow. Okay. All right, listeners, I double check this and I was wrong. It has nothing to do with a French term. It's that the berries on the serviceberry look similar to those on a European plant in the genus sorbis. So sorbis, service, there you go.

So there's that, and then there's, you know, Juneberry, which is, so flowers in like April, the fruit is in June. Yeah. And then, but shadbush was when it's, is the flower or fruit? Flower. I mean, it's in flower is when coastal is when shad are running up the river. Yeah, that makes a lot of sense. Yeah. No, it's a...

yeah so hopefully if i do any fishing it'll be in the service of shad trying to pull some of the predators out of the river yeah i'm interested you know i love it's interesting with the migratory fish we have out here like i'm always like i was a chief on my shoulder if you're a nature person in like the dusty populated east or whatever yeah where the mountains are biodiverse and long and not tall and pointy people like are like oh you want to do like nature why don't you move out west you know and i'm like no biodiversity i love it you know anyway one of the things i think about is is you know either the savage fishing and what out west and like and but yeah out here like we do i wonder like what the i don't know how you compare it like is there survive the fishing like urban fishing like you know i mean one of the last time i actually went fishing this is my friend in portland we fish on the the columbian calumnet river river and then we went a well i met river right and then we went to a lake in the like a reservoir we were supposed to go on the base mount hood but rain forecast it's how it works out in that part of the country if it's if you're on like if you're

the eastern third of Washington or Oregon in his reign, all you have to do is drive an hour west over the mountains and it's like high desert. So we went to the other side where it was drier and went fishing for like landlocked kokanee, which is like a landlocked little salmon. And you would talk about fish dying to catch and release. We brought the limit out, so we like released a smaller kokanee and it didn't make it. It was a floating really sad. We're like, oh, maybe we should have kept it. And then a bold eagle comes and nails it. And we're all like, yeah. Yeah, but that was really cool because...

It was a neat juxtaposition because you, you know, you wouldn't have had a reservoir at that part of the, it would have been a big lake in that part of the world because it's like high desert or whatever. But again, basically a canyon. So the walls of the canyon, so there were perifalcus nesting on the walls of the canyon and they were like harassing the bald eagle. So it was a neat juxtaposition of like perifalcus. Yeah. And I think if it were, if we were using the fish fauna of, of pre like 1800, I think the Mississippi drainage would have us beat on fish for sure. Yeah. But then what happened is people introduced a lot of Mississippi drainage fish everywhere else in the country.

in their mind to improve the fisheries. So when you fish the schoolkill, people who are fishing recreational schoolkill river fish or anglers, they're going for smallmouth bass, introduced, right? Maybe largemouth, introduced. Channel catfish, introduced. People sometimes fish for carp. Eurasian species also introduced mainly for food, although no one likes to eat them anymore. And even the studies we're talking about, like red-breasted sunfish are definitely native to this drainage, but bluegills are not. So you think of the most common things people would go out and catch these days, even around here, bass, maybe some catfish and bluegills, and they're all exotic introduced for recreational fishing. What we're trying to get to is like, you know, the engagement, you know. Yeah, how do you do it? Because, you know, I work at a nature center on a creek, right? Yeah. And so when the demographic is part of the city is very different from people.

I worked at before. And what I worked at before is I felt more of a you know i like to do an adhd hyper focusing and like you know my brain my motivation gets triggered by like different things right and like much annoys my wife because like you know not that i don't do a whole lot of housework don't be wrong but like certain projects she wish i would invest in this you know like building a pond and you know what i mean and like anyway like sometimes i can get interested in something or feel motivation to do something not so much from my personal interest but like i feel like this is important for other people yeah and so where i am now it's very i hate it in privilege like i think it's overplayed but I don't think it's, I think plenty of people in areas easily accessible to where I am have access to fishing more. Right. Whereas in Cops Creek, that neighborhood, people might not have so much access to fishing. Right. So I felt more of a, you know, I felt more of a motivation to like overcome my discomfort with like, you know, like torturing fish, you know, and also particularly more, maybe more.

and anything else, the annoyance of constantly untangling fishing line. Because if you got like 15 little fishing rods to take kids out fishing, there's no way to get them back without them all getting all tangled up. I know what you mean. But I'll just, maybe we end on this, that like my favorite thing when I worked for a summer with Tony at this nature center we're talking about. I got to be your boss for once. Yeah, exactly. Most overqualified team of staff of all time. But it was best job ever, man. But there's no way I could do it for that pay for much longer. But you had a fish trap you threw out there. Yeah. And then I think that in some ways is maybe slightly better than rod and hook. You know, like, because you,

You pull fish out of the creek. And instantly put them in a small plastic aquarium. You get your little tank set up right there next to where you're pulling the fish out. So they're going right there into the water. Kids can get a real good look at them. You're pulling out, maybe it's like mad toms, like little catfish, red breast sunfish, some other things, little shiners. And you're putting them into little tanks for kids to look at right away. You put them right back. And you're not like, you're not hooking them. You're not dragging them around too much. I'm sure they would prefer not to have been trapped. But I think it's a lot easier on the fish and the kids still get the experience. Yeah, I mean, that's, it's interesting. Like, Cobb's Creek, like.

I used to invest in more fish traps, maybe, like, maybe it was the wrong ones. I had bad luck at the wassaken getting fish. I had better luck just using a hand net and, like, running, basically, like, a one-man scene, like, running, like, towards the bank and getting him in there and then putting him in the crayon. I do, like, staining. Staining can be fun, but you gotta find another person who's, like, willing. So staining nets, like, two poles with a net strung in between them, and you're kind of, yeah. You gotta get someone else who's willing, and, you know, usually, you know, it's hard to, like, even with, like...

basically need chest waders to guarantee you're not going to get wet or just wear a bathing suit and wear water shoes. It's the summer you accept that you get wet. Yeah. And in Philly in the summer, like if you're wearing waders, you're going to get wet for sweat. She might as well get wet for water. But I wouldn't want to do that at Collins Creek because Collins Creek is a combined sewer and my creek is, and the creek market now isn't. So like Collins Creek is a chance if you're basically, you might be getting, you know, You might be real careful about whether there's been a rainstorm. Yeah, you might get raw sewage in the creek, but the creek I'm at now, not so much. But it is really cool to see like, you know.

Black Nose Dace and, like, you know, different shiners and, you know, it is. But, oh, so funny. I took this memory. I forgot about it. I think I once got Tony to make a meme that was Ace of Dace. But one of the craziest things that happened to me was at Cobb's Creek, there was a, all of this happens at Urban Waterways is, I think now they have measures against it. They're a bit more effective. But shopping carts in Creeks? How do they always end up in Creeks? I just think, you know, people, I don't know, I think it's just to ride them. I wondered about that. Why do you always end up with shopping carts? I wonder if, my guess is it's not the same person that stole it.

is the same person threw it in the creek. My guess is that someone took it from the shopping center. It's in the neighborhood. Somebody takes it out. They're just like, let's throw it in the creek. I don't know. So I went and there was a shopping cart in the creek and I went and grabbed it and I didn't have anything on me to capture what I was about to find and remove it. But I pulled the shopping cart out of the creek and there was a big pleco. There was like South American armored catfish in the shopping cart like flopping around. Like it was like about like a foot and a half long. Like it was a significantly good sized pleco. And I assume someone just had an aquarium because they sell them. Like I have lots of fish tanks.

I had one of those when I was a kid and I had a fish tank. I have plecos, but I have like clown plecos and I have bristledose plecos and they only get to about two to three inches long. They're perfectly good size. But the common pleco that you get at like PetSmart or Petco, whatever, you know, you buy when it's like two inches long and then it can be like, they can be like three feet long, I think. They're all over South Florida. Yeah. And they suck on manatees and stuff. They're like, you know, they're like enormous. Big algae eaters. Yeah. Yeah. And so I don't know how this one would persist, you know, like. I think your winter would kill it. Yeah. But you know what? If that thing parks outside of a stormwater outflow. Right. This is one time I found an alligator snapping turtle in the school kill.

that was right by a stormwater, a big, like one of these 15-footers stormwater outflows. It was basically a creek that had been covered over by the neighborhood. And my hypothesis is, well, number one, that species does occur pretty far up in the Mississippi drainage, so maybe you could just handle the winter. But it was also parked somewhere where even in the winter, the air coming out of that sewage stormwater tunnel plus the water coming out of it would have all been relatively warm compared to the freezing depths of winter, right? So that turtle would have a shelter in the mid-50s no matter what and be able to come back out and forage once it got warmer. Any case.

Our time is almost up. And so we'll say the things we should have said at the beginning. If you like the podcast, rate us on your podcast listening app of choice. Give us a thumbs up, whatever it is. Tell your friends about it. And urbanwildlifecast at gmail.com. We're going to start checking that email address again. So if you've got any ideas, let us know. I guess we'll come up with the official name for it sooner than later, but I think I will be ahead of the book and because of the podcast, I think we'll make the, probably the backyard urban wildlife sub stack. There you go. We'll come up with some other ancillary media maybe. And then we'll figure out the Patreon thing again.

We got to get that. Yeah, I think we need to do like at least six months of regular podcast before we can convince people to invest in it. I think that's fair to say. Yeah. No, and we wouldn't be looking to, I mean, God, if we could make money doing this, we really would love that. But at this point, I just want to pay the hosting fees. So we'll figure all that out next month. We'll have something soon. Okay. Awesome, Tony.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Urban Wildlife Podcast?

This episode is 50 minutes long.

When was this Urban Wildlife Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on June 25, 2026.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Urban Wildlife Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.