Skip to content
Unorthodox Presents Sivan Says episode artwork

May 30, 2024 26 min

Unorthodox Presents Sivan Says

from Tablet Studios Hosted by Tablet Magazine

Unorthodox is off this week, but today we’re sharing an episode of the Tablet podcast Sivan Says: Taking the Torah Personally, featuring Sivan Rahav-Meir and our own Liel Leibovitz. Parshat Bechukotai’s got a lot of blessings, and a lot of curses. Follow God’s commandments, you’re in the clear. Don’t follow them, some gnarly stuff can happen. Persecution. Exile. A divine wrath. But could it be that it’s all a blessing, even the curses? That the worst sin isn’t some particular action, but apathy towards our connection to God? Tune in to find out. Sivan Rahav-Meir is a leading Israeli journalist, media personality, and Torah scholar. You can sign up for her The Daily Thought WhatsApp group, where Sivan sends small insights about Judaism and current affairs. Learn more about becoming a Tablet member at tabletm.ag/uomember. Find out about our upcoming events at tabletmag.com/unorthodoxlive Write to us at [email protected], or leave a voicemail on our listener line: (914) 570-4869. Unorthodox is produced by Tablet Studios. Check out all of our podcasts at tabletmag.com/podcasts. SPONSORS: Brandeis University offers an online master’s certificate in Jewish Professional Leadership, training creative and compassionate Jewish leaders on a flexible schedule. Learn more at brandeis.edu/hornstein. Emanu-El Downtown’s Religious School Lab opens this fall in Manhattan for kids in kindergarten through sixth grade, offering a welcoming community, pick-up from local schools, and one-to-one virtual Hebrew instruction. Visit EmanuelDowntown.org for more. Since October 7, Meir Panim has provided over 2.5 million meals, essential items, and care packages to IDF soldiers and displaced families, as well as organizing events and daily support for thousands. Donate at meirpanim.org/unorthodox.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Unorthodox Presents Sivan Says

0:00 26:43
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello, J. Crew. Welcome to Unorthodox, the universe's leading Jewish podcast. I am your co-host, Leah Leibowitz. And yeah, you're hearing right. It is not a regular episode. Usually you hear Stephanie, you hear Joshua Melina, you hear a lot of jokes, you hear news of the Jews, you hear guests, you hear interviews. But this week, record scratch. We're stopping it all to bring you something truly, wonderfully special. Today, we want to share with you an episode of our brand new podcast. Sivan says, taking the Torah personally. Here's the thing. If you don't know her, Sivan Rav Meir is exactly...

the teacher, the guru, the inspiration, the light that you need in your life right now. She's an Israeli journalist, author, thinker, but more importantly, Torah teacher. And she has this amazing way of reading the Torah, one parashah, one portion of Torah a week, and making it feel not like, you know, oh, well, it's something that you just need to learn. Oh, that's the thing that the rabbi used to talk about. She makes it feel really like it's incredibly relevant, incredibly personal, incredibly timely, incredibly urgent, because it is, we don't have any better engine for our spiritual.

yearnings than the Torah. So here's what I want you to do. I want you to find a time and a place where you could really kind of listen to this when you're completely at peace. Maybe it's when you're taking a walk with a dog in the afternoon. Maybe it's 10 at night after everyone else has gone to bed and really kind of let Sivan walk you through this week's Torah portion, which is really a doozy. I think you're going to love this new podcast and I hope you will subscribe to it. Check the show notes and here without further ado is Sivan Says, taking the Torah personally.

Hey there, and welcome back to Sivan Says, Taking the Torah Personally. If you are new to this podcast, here is what you need to know. My name is Leah Leibowitz, and that doesn't matter at all. The only thing that matters is that you are about to hear Sivan Rahav Meir, an Israeli author, journalist, reporter, news anchor, but most importantly, Torah teacher who magically has the ability to take the ancient and eternal words of the Torah and show all of us why they are just as relevant and urgent and inspiring now as they have ever been. We hope you like it. And now, live from Jerusalem.

Sivan Rav Meir, how are you? Thank you. I'm exhausted when you exaggerate, you know, when you start the show with so many compliments. But Baruch Hashem, Shalom everyone from Yerushalayim. And basically, you know, I was supposed to bring, I don't know, a cake or something to drink L'chaim. This is the last parasha of the third book of Vayikra, Leviticus, the 10th and last parasha. You know, in many shuls, they're going to say, declare, chazak, chazak, v'nit chazak, meaning we're strong and we want to be stronger. Great thing to say in those challenging days. So in a way, yeah, we're about to start the new book of Bamidbar.

A lot to celebrate. First of all, Leviticus, what a book. So many incredible insights, so many incredible rules. But this one, this last parasha, this last portion, it's kind of amazing. I mean, right? It's amazing because even when you read it in Shul on Shabbos, you read it in kind of a different way because it has a lot of blessings and a lot of curses that you read in this kind of low tone. So as always on the show, before we begin doing anything else, we would like to trouble you for a very brief summary. What is Parashat B'Chukotai about? No problem. In a nutshell. And as you said, it's really, it's when you read it, it's just, you know, basically I think we all think about ourselves, about what we do in this world because the parasha is very simple.

if you follow my laws, you know, my statutes, and you faithfully observe my commandments, then things will be great. God promises that the people of Israel, if they will keep his commandments, they, we, if we will keep his commandments, so we will enjoy material prosperity. We will dwell securely in our homeland. But there's also, after promising so many really vivid descriptions of rewards for observing, you know, everything, it's like great things are going to happen from the rain to the security, from the incredible blessings of peace and elimination of wild animals or incredible military success, you know? After that, there is what we call in Hebrew rebuke, meaning there's warning, harsh warning of exile, persecution, other evils, awful things, really devastating versus if we will abandon our covenant with God. So it's not such an optimistic parasha. I'm about to, you know, we will elaborate and zoom into it. We'll see. I believe it is extremely positive and uplifting. But in a nutshell, it's not such a, you know, people usually do not want to sometimes be the one that reads from the Torah. And there are certain customs, the way you read it, even the sound or the...

The way you treat this, I would say, challenging text of Bechukotai, it's different in every shul. But yeah, in a nutshell, that's the equation here. You know, do good and it will be good. And if, God forbid, you'll choose the opposite, so things are going to get worse. Look, I know this very well because a few years back, a very good friend said, hey, you know, we really want you to come and read this thing in shul. We have a simcha and please come and read it in shul. I said, well, what an honor. I would love to lane it. And then they said, okay, I asked, oh, what parasha is this? Oh, it's Bechukatayin. We're giving you the bit with all the rebukes. That is A, like 7,000 verse long. What did you do? I went into a spiritual gym and I practiced for like five weeks and, you know, I sweated bullets for this. But okay, so here we are. We have these amazing blessings that, as you said, pertain to every...

cornered facet of life from normal wild animals to you'll have rain and great grains to a bunch of rebukes that are very, very scary. But in this show, as always, once we finish kind of surveying the landscape, you take us deeper. You take us into the real heart, the real insight that we could take from this week's Parsha. So let's dive right in. I think our commentators, the way they look deeply into the text, they see that it's all a bracha. It's all a blessing. Meaning if we're in touch with God, if we have a certain relationship, it means we're there and we're important and he's important and we have this special connection. It can be through.

the brachot, you know, at the beginning of the Parsha, the peace in the land and the no wild animals and no, you know, five of you will chase away a hundred and a hundred of you will chase away 10,000. You know, today in Israel, I wish the IDF, you know, will see such an incredible military success in Gaza. So many descriptions of great things that can happen. But then, you know, the severe, terrifying punishments if Jews will reject God's commandments. So disease and famine and occupation, and as we said, exile. So, but if you look deeper into that, both sides of the Parsha, you see that it all says we care and we see God's hand. We're looking, we're asking questions about what's going on.

And maybe the worst sin, the worst, I would say, scenario is feeling indifference, feeling it means nothing. You know, in a way, all sins, they derive from the sin of insignificance. When a person basically ceases to be sensitive to the importance which God attaches to his life. What do I care about any of this? Exactly. When you don't care, that's the worst sin. You know, I don't really matter. That's the worst curse because it's not like humility. It's no, it's I don't really matter or I can do what I want. It really means it's nothing. And the most terrible of punishments really is if you feel God says, all right, have it your way. I don't care.

What happens to you is of no significance. You know, I don't really care. You don't care what happens to you. It's your business. And a believing Jew looks at everything that happens in this world and in his or her personal life and immediately, you know, undertakes that. But nothing is by chance. OK, nothing is random in this world. And things are sometimes frustrating and challenging. It can be in New York, London or here in Israel right now. Sometimes, you know, things seem pointless. And you understand it's not the right way to look at the world. OK, there is a reason to everything here. There is a plan. There is a creator now.

It's not just a religious solution, you know. It's a basic attitude. And if you read the Parsha and you always think about, okay, how can I be better? How can I improve things? Your perspective, it's part of the bracha. It's part of the blessing because you're connected. You understand the importance of everything you do, you know. And it's so practical. You can start right now, you know, when things are upside down and when everything is, you know, looks awful. No, you're able to maintain peace and calm because, you know, you understand it's bigger than you. And it's not just, you know, bad karma. You know, someone's looking to make your life miserable. It's not bad luck. No, there's someone who...

Who cares? And it's not just madness. It's healing, you know, to know, especially I'm speaking as an Israeli in the middle of a war, of a crisis. And I see so many families of wounded soldiers, bereaved families. You know, I just met a mother. Her daughter was buried last week after so many days of uncertain and so many rumors. She was kidnapped from the festival and they found her body. And the ability to rise above the situation and to understand that there is a bigger plan here, you know, to take a deep breath, to remember that someone is in control and that it helps us to be in control. And, you know, in a way, you just have to pass the test, you know.

And, you know, I look at brave people and when they hear the brachot, but also when they hear the klalot, the curses, they still believe God is here and he's in touch. As long as he's in touch with us, we're on the right side of the, we understand the concept. If we're not part of the story, that's the real klala, that's the real punishment. And we're not there. I think millions of Jews are now asking themselves really deep questions. Why? How come? It means you're, you know, it's part of the mutual bracha.

See, that's an amazing, amazing insight because I think for so many people listening right now, if you'd asked them, you know, 20 minutes ago, they'd say, well, you know, being religious means that God kind of is in command of everything and we're all just whatever pawns in his game. What you're saying right now is actually being a believing Jew means that God made each and every single one of us for a purpose, for a reason, that we matter so, so, so, so much that God bothered, you know, to put us here on this earth to do the thing that only we could do. And so if we abandon hope, not just, or faith, not just in God, but in ourselves, if we say, oh, I don't matter, what does it matter, what do I do? That's the real curse. That's a very beautiful way of looking at it.

Exactly, exactly. I think, you know, our mutual enemy is not Hamas. Hamas is a tool in God's hand. It's a physical enemy, but the real enemy is indifference. The real enemy is apathy. If the Jews, you know, if we don't care about our future and mutual goals, that's the real enemy. So I think that's, yeah, the Parsha really teaches us how to remember we're here and we're in touch with him. And that's the most important thing. And in our generation, I think we can see at the end of the Parsha, and if you read it in the past in Shul, I'm sure you remember that after a long list, long series of curses and punishments, there are two beautiful, beautiful verses. And it's not a bracha, but it is a promise, a haftacha, what we call in Hebrew.

Even if they are in the land of their enemies. Just like I said, he's still in touch with us. I do not reject them. I will not violate my covenant. I will remain. I will always be their God. I will remember in their favor, the covenant, you know, with their ancestors. It's a bigger story. You know, I freed them from the land of Egypt. Okay. To be there in order to be their God. Meaning he also remembers, even though sometimes it looks like.

It's his indifference, his apathy. No, never. And in our generation, we see new ways of the brachot, of coming back to the land of Israel, establishing something new. I'll give you just two examples I saw this week, you know, after the Holocaust. By the way, there's a famous, beautiful story about the Kloisenburger Rebbe, Rabbi Yekutiel Yehuda Halberstam, originally from Romania. After the Holocaust, he came to Israel, established a big neighborhood in the city of Netanya and a medical center called Lani Ado Center, a hospital. And he lost 11 children in the Holocaust, you know, and his wife.

And after the Holocaust, there's a famous story of Shabbat, the rebuke was written. And suddenly the Rebbe shouted, you know, someone, not you, many years ago, but someone was reading, was leaning. And when he, when it came to the part of the curses, the reader, you know, just lowered his voice. It's a well-known custom to just lower the tone, softer tone. But suddenly the Rebbe shouted, in Yiddish, he shouted, hecher, meaning louder, louder, hecher, kol ram. The reader was confused, you know, he was simply following the tradition of generations, you know, reading it quietly. But no, the Rebbe said, hecher, and he explained, let God hear what is being read.

All the curses have already been fulfilled. Now there must be only one blessing for our people, Mashiach, redemption. It's a famous story, you know, because in a way we saw in our generation, physically, so many of the curses, you know, maybe we should read it hecher, louder. God, please, this chapter is finished. Now let's move forward only to the brachot. And now I want to give two beautiful examples I saw here in Israel, this Shabbat. We spent this Shabbat in Ranaana, just like Ramat Bet Shemesh or Yerushalayim or Modi'in. Many English speakers, you know, olim, make aliyah, and they immigrate, they come to Ranaana. And I was invited as a scholar in residence to a...

Shul called Shivtei. The official name is Shivtei Israel, the tribes of Israel. But, you know, the common name is Shivtei. And I was shocked because I'm familiar with the communities out there in the States or in Europe. And suddenly you see a community here, but it's like a piece of chutzlah. It's a piece of South African, South African olim. They all came. And in a way, they don't want to be suburbs. You know, they don't think we must become Israelis, copy-paste, become exactly like the native Israelis, what they do in their shuls. They built their own community, their own synagogue. With their tradition, they brought so many beautiful things with them.

even some pieces of wood from South Africa. And everything is done in English. Everything from the, you know, announcements at the end of the prayer and the prayer for the kids. And, you know, the shulah is built in a certain way. I felt outside of Israel, but it was so exciting to see, no, you're in Ranaana. And I think it's a very mature approach. You know, when you come and we expect millions to join in the future, you don't have to, you can bring, you know, we're not perfect. Israelis are imperfect. Although sometimes, you know, we're not so humble. And you can bring your own treasures and your own style or even your own nuances, you know.

It's hard for you to, even the announcements, the mazel tov at the end of the prayer when you, or the shiurim, they asked me to speak in English. It's weird standing on Har Sinai street of Ranaana speaking in English. No, it's weird to take the new olim and force them to become Israelis. And it's the first time, out of my experience, I hope we'll have more chances to meet and see growing communities like this, this mixture of, you know, their kids, they go to Israeli school, they understand Hebrew, but I liked it. I mean, it's the first time I saw like a piece of chutzlaretz in Israel. And I think it's part of the blessing we see in our generation. Beautiful. And the next example, and a very, I would say, touching one.

On Motzai Shabbat, we went to pay a shiva call in Ranana at the house of the Amsalem family. Eliyahu Amsalem, a brave soldier, fell in Gaza. The parents also made Aliyah from France, and lots of French community members were there. And I saw something. I don't think in any Jewish generation could you see such a precious treasure. Eliyahu was, in a way, kind of a chassid, really connected to the Chabad movement of chassidut. And he was learning the daily chitas, abbreviation of chumash tehili mentania. Every day, every day, he took it with him to the army.

free booklet called Dvar Malchut. And in it, you have the daily routine of learning the Chumash, the daily portion of the weekly Parsha, the Tehillim, saying just a few chapters every day, and the Tanya, the basic Hasidic book, and just a paragraph every day. And Elia was so devoted, so connected to this booklet of Dvar Malchut, he took it everywhere with him. And after, unfortunately, he was killed in the battlefield, the family got the last edition of Dvar Malchut back. And you see, physically, you see the bullet hole in it. You see the wounded Dvar Malchut, the wounded booklet of Jewish learning, the daily Torah learning.

of this precious soul, Eliyahu, Amsalem, all the way from France to Ranana, to Gaza, directly to heaven. And I looked, I thought about it, you know, and the parents are not so, you know, he became much more, I would say, observant and much more connected to Judaism. And in a way, you think about it, you know, this commitment, it teaches us so much. If you will follow and learn my Torah, how can we not be more connected after, you know, he gave us such a beautiful example, he can do it in Gaza. How can I not do it in Yerushalayim or in LA? And I started learning the daily chitas a few years ago. And I was really, you know, excited to see someone's doing it in Gaza.

When I started doing it, different circumstances, I was a reporter covering the Supreme Court in Israel, a different battlefield. And when I started learning that this daily dose of learning, it was because I covered the prime minister's trial. Ehud Olmert was the prime minister. And every day I was there, every morning, covering his trial, testimonies, witnesses, investigations. And, you know, it was really so I felt it wasn't so spiritual, you know, seeing your prime minister. Unfortunately, he ended up in jail. And I remember when I added this piece of learning into my life, I felt like every morning I meet King David in Tehillim. I meet.

Abraham Avinu or Saraymenu, our ancestors, you know, when you learned the Parsha. And I meet Bala Tanya, the founder of Chabad, when I learned the Tanya. And then I meet Eudolmert, you know, that's the right, every day before I go and meet the judge and the lawyers and everyone, I have a meeting with really Torah giants. It puts things in a very different perspective. Yeah, exactly. I remember the feeling you, after you have this meeting every morning, every person you meet, the perspective is different. And I thought about it when I saw the booklet of Eliyahu, the same Dvar Malchut, you know, we were both subscribed, I think, the same publisher. And he met, every day he met King David and he met.

Now, Moses, Moshe Rabbeinu, and he met them every morning. And then, unfortunately, he met Hamas terrorists. He met the ultimate evil. But he came from, really, from such a wholly different perspective. So when I see the communities of Rehanan, and when I also see the soldiers with spiritual bravery, not just physical bravery, I believe we will, be Ezrat Hashem, see all the blessings fulfilled really, really soon. You will all see peace in the land, and you will have, really, the truly fulfillment of all the good words that we read this week.

Amen, amen, amen. But Sivan, we are not letting you go before you do what we do here on the show every week before we say Shalom and Shavua Tov and Shabbat Shalom, which is for you to give all of us some spiritual homework, something to do in the week to come to really kind of embody the message of Parashat Chokotai of this week's tour portion. What can we do? Let's do it. It's really tachless and simple. We're not in Gaza, in battlefields. We're not making Aliyah this week. Maybe some of you, we're not brave heroes. We're simple Jews. Let's take God into our life. Let's be in touch. Let's look at the things around us right now, the things we see as a bracha or as a klala, as a blessing or as a cursing, as a challenge. And let's...

Bring him into the picture. It's not random, okay? It's not just something that happens. You're not just miserable. Breathe and remember someone's in control. Find him and talk to him. Make him involved. Bring him into your life, into the situation. And in a way, you will have the ability to rise above the situation. You will be much more, I think, connected and mature. And that's the right way to also solve the problem you have in your personal life. You know, we discussed Jewish history, destiny, thousands of years. Let's take it into our personal life this week.

That is probably the greatest piece of homework I have ever received. As always, Sivan Rav Meil, thank you very much for being our teacher and our guide through this week's portion. Thank you very much. And Shabbat Shalom from Israel. You've been listening to Sivan Says, taking the tour personally. If you enjoyed the show, then please rate and review us on Apple Podcasts or wherever you listen to podcasts. We're a brand new show and every single star helps. I promise. Sivan Says is a Tablet Studios production. The show is hosted by me, Lea Leibowitz, with the wonderful and insightful Sivan Rav Meir. It's produced and edited by Ellie Blyer and Josh Cross. Our team also includes Cordy Hazlett, Roberts Caramuccia, Quinn Waller, Stephanie Butnik, and Tanya Singer. For more information, go to tabletmag.com slash Sivan Says. We will see you here next week. Until then, lehit rot. Goodbye.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Tablet Studios?

This episode is 26 minutes long.

When was this Tablet Studios episode published?

This episode was published on May 30, 2024.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Tablet Studios episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.