Unpacking the Real-World Challenges of Litigating Against Pro Se Litigants

In this episode of Creditors Corner Legal Talk, Smith Debnam attorneys Rachel Rogers and Emily Murphy join moderator Melissa Tulis Smith to unpack the real-world challenges of litigating against pro se (self-represented) parties. Drawing on their experiences in creditors’ rights and family law, they explore common misconceptions about pro se opponents, how judges actually treat self-represented litigants, and why these cases are often more complex—not less—than those with counsel on both sides.The conversation covers practical strategies for maintaining ethical boundaries, communicating clearly without giving legal advice, and adapting advocacy in the courtroom when the playing field is uneven. Rachel and Emily also discuss the growing impact of generative AI on pro se litigation, from improved access to justice to new procedural headaches. Whether you’re a new litigator or a seasoned practitioner, this episode offers candid “war stories” and concrete tips to help you navigate cases involving pro se parties with professionalism, empathy, and strategic clarity.