Hey podcast listeners, we had so much great conversation and so much to pack into this urban birding episode that we split it into two parts. Thanks for downloading part one, we hope you like it, and download part two. To me, birds is a great way of connecting with people. For me, it's a great way of sharing, I know it sounds corny, but sharing love. Welcome back to another episode of the Urban Wildlife Podcast.
This is one of your co-hosts, Billy Brown, with Tony Crowsdale and Keith Russell. We're going to talk about some birding around the world topics. So we got interviews with David Lindo, the urban birder out of England. We had shorter discussions with a couple other birders from elsewhere around the world. Mike Liu out of Manila in the Philippines talking about the Wild Bird Club of the Philippines. And Dr. Joseph Onoja from Lagos in Nigeria talking about the Leckie Bird Club there and their birding challenge. Let's do a quick introduction with Keith. Keith, who are you? My name is Keith Russell and I am...
A member of the staff of the National Audubon Society, I work for the Pennsylvania State Program of National Audubon, which is called Audubon Pennsylvania. And I'm one of three staff that work for Audubon Pennsylvania in the city of Philadelphia. I've been working for Audubon Pennsylvania about 10 years. Could you briefly explain to people how there's National Audubon and there's... And they have state chapters, but there's also separate Audubons. I think a lot of people don't realize that, that there's a lot of things with the name Audubon that aren't necessarily the same organization. Yeah, Tony, that's a very good thing to bring up because it is confusing. The National Audubon Society has been around since 1900, but since that time there have been other Audubon groups that have come up that are independent of National Audubon, but they still have Audubon as part of their name. For example, New Jersey Audubon and Massachusetts Audubon are organizations that work on bird issues in those respective states, but they're not part of the National Audubon Society.
So very quickly, the state programs that are part of National Audubon have Audubon as the first name. Audubon Pennsylvania is part of National Audubon. But if the state name is first, like New Jersey Audubon or Massachusetts Audubon, then that's a separate organization. We do work together, and obviously we have overlap in the things that we're working on all the time. But as far as them being part of National Audubon Society, they're officially not part of National Audubon Society. And to be honest, in a way for Philly, when it comes to the Parks and Rec angle, I'm almost reluctant to have Audubon involved.
the perception would be that Parks and Rec just opened the gate in the morning and then some of them Audubon led the walk. People wouldn't realize our own expertise was involved because Audubon has such... The perception, I think, in the public, if you're advocating for birds... Birds equal Audubon. Which is great for Audubon. There's a lot of power involved in that. But I mean, it's jokingly frustrating for people who, you know... Well, I appreciate your sharing your observations about that with me. So I will certainly be...
trying to be sensitive to the issue. Come on, float about it. It's more of like a joke. But it's true. It does come up. If you're Robin Birds, you always hear Autobahn, Autobahn, Autobahn. And you know what? I mean, Autobahn's done such great stuff. They deserve to have that reputation out there. So in a minute, let's segue into talking about some of the stuff we're doing in Philadelphia. But first, how did you get involved as an Autobahn outreach? What's your title? I'm sorry. My title right now is Program Manager for Urban Conservation. How did you get involved as a Program Manager for Urban Conservation? Well, I started working with Autobahn actually
In 2003, I worked for the National Audubon Science Office, which is, Audubon has got all these different layers of, anyway, an organizational chart. But this is part of National Audubon. They have several national offices. There's a policy office, you know, there's a science office and so on. And the science office now is sort of split between the East Coast and Washington.
and so originally it was all located here in pennsylvania up near warminster so i started working with them working on the important bird area program okay so um that's a national program and i was involved with you know figuring out a lot of stuff that was going on with that program nationally and locally but um around 2005 there was a focus that needed to be paid to pennsylvania and specifically to what was going on in philadelphia so i started working on nominating fairmount park as an important bird area because it had not become important bird area yet and so um After that nomination got approved, I then switched to working for Audubon, Pennsylvania, the state program. And we have about, I don't know how many employees we have. I think it's between 15 and 20 employees around the state. I should know that, but it varies from time to time. And most of us are located in southeastern Pennsylvania. And again, there are now three Audubon employees working in Philadelphia. I've been working the longest. And during that time, it's a great job because you sort of have to figure out what types of things are important for us to do and how to address them in the city. But my focus really has been...
on the Fairmount Park IBA and just figuring out a number of things that need to be done to address issues that birds deal with, particularly in Philadelphia, and those tend to be urban issues. They tend to be things associated with human structures like birds and glass, birds and lights, birds and non-native plants that people plant, and so on. So my focus since I've been in Philadelphia has been on these issues, and so the titles I've had have changed over the years. I'll pick one of those out just so I know more about it, the building collision issues. You did a study on that.
We did, yeah. Audubon has been working very close collaboration with the Philadelphia Zoo's Conservation Department since 2006 on that particular issue and also with the Academy of Natural Sciences. We have had so few staff that it's been difficult for us to do certain things because we just didn't have the capacity. So most of what we have been working on in Philly over the last 10 years has been done in collaboration with other organizations, including Fairmount Park. We've done a lot of work with the park. And the park has helped us on this particular study. But the zoo came to Audubon in 2006 and wanted to...
They wanted us to collaborate with them in starting a Lights Out program in Philadelphia. And Lights Out programs exist around the country in various cities. It's a way of getting building owners to turn out lights during migration because lights can confuse birds and contribute to birds flying into buildings and getting killed that way. So we agreed to work with them on that because we were interested in that particular issue. But in the long run, what was needed for us to raise awareness about this issue and get people to actually participate was local data.
We went to the Philadelphia Building Owners and Managers Association in 2006 to try to get them to participate in the lifestyle program. And they said, well, we'd be more interested if you had some data from our own buildings than from Philadelphia. We had anecdotal data, but we didn't have a whole lot of specifics. So we did wind up going back to the drawing board, and we did a study in downtown Philly from 2008 to 2011. So it was spring and fall, spring and fall for three years. We went out and monitored an area of about three and a half square blocks for dead and injured birds.
every day during the spring migration and the fall migration. And we got a lot of great data. It was a really intensive study. We would be out monitoring every day at 5.30 in the morning, and we'd stay out until 8. So it was a lot of early days. But we found a lot of birds, and we got a lot of great information about how collisions occur. So basically, from that study, we made estimates about how many birds were actually colliding with buildings in that area that we looked at.
We got some competitive information from other areas downtown, and we're now taking that information that we got and we're trying to move the dial by helping people who have buildings that bird collisions are happening at to actually do something to prevent those collisions from happening. So we've been working with some colleges and universities in Philadelphia, some private businesses and other organizations to actually put up film on surfaces that they have on certain buildings with birds of gliding. And the film has patterns on it that birds can see, and that prevents them from wanting to fly into those glass surfaces. because a pattern looks like something they can't fly through. So that's one of the big issues that we've been working on, and it's been a very exciting issue to work on because it's a really big problem in cities all over the world, and there are estimates that anywhere from 300 million to a billion birds are colliding with glass on buildings and other man-made structures every year just in the United States. And from the data that we collected, we know that there are probably thousands to tens of thousands of birds colliding with buildings just in the center city. So it's a huge problem. It involves...
probably as many as 100 species in Center City, and everything from wild turkeys to ruby-throated hummingbirds. And we had a wild turkey that flew into a restaurant on Broad Street right near Temple University, of all places. It's hard to believe, but all kinds of birds are flying. I'm late to the club of realizing that wild turkeys fly. Yeah, they fly. I don't know if it was a few years ago, but I still don't think of them as...
I think it was flying from, like, short distances, from up in the tree of the roof, back down to the ground, getting away from something for a little while, but not, like, flying across the city. Well, I wouldn't have imagined that a wild turkey would be found dead in front of a building on North Broad Street, Wightner Temple University. Another one flew into a building at the University of Pennsylvania, which is closer to Woodland Cemetery and stuff. But they get around, and, you know, there's all kinds of species that are colliding with buildings in the heart of our city. One of the more unusual birds, too, that collided downtown was a yellow whale.
a bird I personally have never seen in one. It's a pretty elusive species, very hard to find. It's a small, rail marsh bird, and it's sort of a tawny, yellowish, brownish, prumish. It's only about five or six inches in length. Streaky. They're really hard to see. I only saw one once because I was in such excruciating pain because the terrain was so terrible that I was looking down. At the right time? Yeah, I wanted to skirt across.
That was lucky. They're hard to find, and they're not common. They're really uncommon. Anyway, it's a huge problem. Birds migrate, and they have to go through cities to get to where they're going. And a lot of birds will actually stop and land in the middle of the cities looking for food and shelter. So we got a lot of information about birds colliding with buildings here, and now we're working with organizations throughout the city that have these problems trying to actually do something about them. Also, Matt, who is probably the next episode will be on, he's been on for my roommate, Matt Halley, at the Academy of Sciences. He says that the vast majority of...
Specimens, modern specimens in the museum collection all come from window positions. People bring them in. Yeah. And he said recently he was going through, or I don't know if he skimmed it and put it in or just saw it recently, but he saw a specimen that I collected on your study. Okay. Yeah, when I was volunteering for a key study going downtown. That was so strange, the emotions, because you're still looking for birds in some respect. And so you kind of have this thing where you want to feel like you're doing a good job.
So you want to collect things, but then you don't want to collect things because... Because it means it's dead, yeah. Yeah, you want to bring stuff in to feel like you're contributing to the study, but you're also like, well, everything I bring in is dead, so it's really weird. You're trying to find stuff, but you know that what you're finding is going to not be good. Yeah. It's a really strange yo-yo of emotions. I did see something cool that I saw, just a head of a yellow boat cuckoo. So I assumed that a peregrine... Got it. Yeah, there was a place in our study area where there was a really, really tall building, and peregrine falcons were posted on the top of that building all the time trying to find or catch migrating birds.
And that's where we found heads all the time, because they would drop heads off the top of the building, the birds that they had caught. The podcast building, right? Yeah, that's where I found the head, yeah. This actually resonates with one of the stories that we have on the podcast out of Manila. A little bit. Well, no, I'll say it resonates. We have a bird club where you have birders engaging in advocacy, not just in getting out and seeing stuff. And so in that one, we have Mike Liu from the Wild Bro Club in the Philippines. I'll start off and say the club is relatively new. I think it's only from about within the last 20 years. And they had started off, well, it has to be, because it started off as an e-club, as he put it.
Just an online group of people who coordinated to go out and look for birds together. And then they formalized into a group once they started doing advocacy because they needed to have an official organization to be able to have any kind of standing with the government. And one of their early victories was preservation of the Manila Bay. I guess they're islands in Manila Bay. And one of them, which was a mangrove marsh kind of habitat, they ended up getting preserved because it was critical habitat for some rare birds. I'm going to ask Tony, who I think of as my friend with Asian birding experience. He mentioned Philippine ducks and black-made stilts. Ring any bells? Yeah. Okay, what do they look like? Black-made stilts look very much like R.
What's stilt? So stilt is a type of sandpiper, but they're, sandpipers are usually, you know, we think, most people think sandpipers think of like a tan or a gray streaky bird. These are more boldly colored. They're usually black, they're pied, black and white, and they, and really, really, really long legs, like extremely, like maybe the longest legs proportion to their body. I think them and flamingos are tied for having the longest legs proportion to their body, and the legs seem to be pink or red, and then their body's usually white with black wings and some black on the neck and the head. Ours have actually black to go in the form of a mask, but these are just black on the nape and then on the wings. Very beautiful, and it really...
like an ice pick for a bill. They're like medium. They're not tiny, but they're not huge either. And he was describing the Philippine duck as having, it sounds like what I think of as basic duck. I mean, looking kind of, he was describing similarities between how it looks and how Mallard might look, but he's saying they have what people describe as kind of eyeliner. I found you because I was reading about the Las Piñas, Paraniake, critical habitat, and ecotourism area. So if you could describe what that place is.
One of the places that we looked for was the reclamation area. At the time, there were a few buildings. And slowly, the buildings were starting to come, and our bird-watching sites kept getting developed. So this had all cordoned off. Then we stumbled upon this last piece of mangrove island with mud floods. And wow, there were so many birds there. So we started recording. We listed down what we saw. And then one day, we heard that it's going to be reclaimed again. So we got in touch with the media, with some of the...
people in the Department of Environment and even with government agencies. One of the senators heard about it and conducted a press conference. So that's how we got into the media at that time. And the Department of Environment used our five-year database to declare it as a critical habitat because it's the last mangrove with mad flat island in this part of Manila. And it's a migratory stopover point for a lot of bird species, including globally threatened Philippine duck.
Blackwing still. So that's how we were able to declare it as a critical habitat. It fell into that category called critical habitat. So if this is an area that's mudflats and mangroves, how accessible is it? Oh, because there were initial reclamation development already. The two islands were already joined together, and there was a short highway where you can drive straight to the island. So you don't even have to wait or take a boat. You just drive.
drive your car straight to the island. We conduct guided bird watching trips for the general public. So when we have... Bird watching activities, we bring the people there. I mean, among other bird watching sites in Metro Manila. There are schools which are specifically asked to be taken there. And it's not just schools. Sometimes there are bank employees, rotary clubs. So slowly people are new about the place. And because of what we had on the media campaign, a lot of people know about that place. Okay. And so one of the things that when I was reading about it seemed interesting to me was the claim that there is a conflict with the airport.
There was a big company, one of the biggest companies in the Philippines that wanted to do the reclamation. And this claim about the possibility of first airstrike only came out when the reclamation issue came out. The airport was built in 1969. The islands, the birds have been there since way, way back before. So how come no airstrikes have ever happened from 1969 until now? So one time they did a press conference at the airport and we insisted that we be taken around the runway.
to see what birds are there. We saw a lot of cattle egrets and they were pointing out, you see flux and flux of these cattle egrets here. And our response was, The cattle egrets that you find on your runway are not found on this island because cattle egrets don't go to saltwater. So it's different species that are found on the runway. We've talked about what the threats have been. Is the area still planned for development or reclamation? So far, I haven't heard of any plans in that area, but they are trying to develop other areas in Manila Bay, which we are also against. But at least for now, the critical habitat is safe. Okay, great. What kind of birds do you see around where you live?
Oh, no. I live in downtown Manila. And if you've been to Manila, there are very few green areas. But surprisingly, I see swallows. I see night herons pass by during sunset. There are some bobbles and fantails. There was one time a friend was calling me to...
to look up because a flock of buzzards passed by his house. So I ran out to the top of my building and I saw part of that flock. So it was so surprising to see them pass by the city. So maybe if we look up more often, we'd see more birds. It sort of sounded to me, I mean, it was a little bit more contentious, maybe, with trying to stop development on this island. But the story about birders sneaking or finding a way onto sort of no man's land to look for birds and then that converting into some kind of preserved habitat or park made me think of the East Park Reservoir stuff with Audubon. I met you, I think, around 2008. There you go. Look at a picture of a flipping duck. And in 2008, you were talking about it as something that could happen soon. And then... It's all relative. So go ahead. What's the story of the East Park Reservoir? Well, Audubon has a number of educational centers.
around the country some of them are in pretty you know rural settings and some of them are in pretty urban settings and um we don't have an audubon center here in philadelphia but we should have one fairly soon we're going to be opening a center in north philadelphia in a strawberry mansion neighborhood at a site called the east park reservoir within the next two years we've actually been working on some of the early parts of the construction of the site, and fundraising is about 95% done. So it was done, and then the cost of the project actually had to continue fundraising. But we're going to have a center at the East Park Reservoir that is operated by Audubon and the Outward Bound Organization. So both of us will occupy the center. We'll both have staff there, and we'll both have programming there. So we hope it will be a nice collaborative project where people can come from the neighborhood or from wherever.
and enjoy Outward Bound activities as well as activities that we have. And we'll have staff that are operating from that center that are going out into schools, and we'll be doing programming throughout Philadelphia that will all be operating from that center. And I'm going to include also, I recorded some audio of when you led a walk there last year. Podcast listeners, on this recording of the bird walk that we took in December of 2015, led by Keith Russell to explore the East Park Reservoir, the site to be of the Discovery Center, you will also hear some other voices, notably of Robin Irasari and Matt Haley, friends of the podcast and frequent guests and contributors. And my daughter, Magnolia, also chimes in. The West Basin. This is about 37 acres of water. So this is the basin that's still left. We'll come all the way around this basin and be able to see the basin that is still used by the water department for water storage and the basin that's been abandoned that's now growing trees. So let's see what's out here. It looks like a bunch of gulls. I see two Canada geese.
Yeah. Swimming around there. We didn't see them before while they're swimming. Mallards? Flying. The wood ducks flying. A bunch of, um, two wood ducks. Going to the left. And a bunch of mallards. And, um, I think there might be a redneck grebe out here. Which is a pretty neat bird. It's a really hard bird to find. Um, it goes. And it was right beyond the mallards. Yeah, it's a pretty big grebe. Here are the wood ducks swimming.
So I don't see the greave right now, but it was not a pie-bill greave. It's pretty big. We might have a merlin in that tree over there. That looks like a merlin to me. It's kind of chunky and robust. It's like my merlin's like my suit. So that's the color of a merlin, and when it flew, it had those rings on the tail. Is that a kestrel up the top?
Well, the blower bird looks like a merlin, doesn't it? Yeah. And you see the upper bird is smaller. And it does look like it has a different pattern on it. So, it was a kestrel and a merlin? It is, it's a male kestrel. You see it first on the pike? You can really see the difference in structure of those birds. Oh, yeah.
Yeah, this is a site that was created in the 1880s, and it was an engineering marvel then. It's 100 acres, and it's basically a place where the city stores treated drinking water. So water is disseminated from the reservoir out into people's homes or out into businesses throughout Center City in North Philadelphia. So originally there were three large basins there in the 1880s, and gradually over time the city's population shrunk, the number of businesses declined, and businesses use a lot of water. As the need for water declined, the need for using all three of those basins changed. So the city gradually used fewer and fewer of those basins. And by the late 1990s, they were only using one basin. So one of the other basins, the largest basins on the site, is the West Basin. That had really been abandoned for a long time, and it had become basically a wild lake. So there were fish in it, there was aquatic plants, and there were a lot of birds. So what about an outward bound will be utilizing that basin and the area around that basin while the rest of the site...
is still going to be used by Philadelphia Water for storing treated drinking water. My understanding is there's also a site that people have been sneaking into to look at birds over the years. Well, I wouldn't characterize it quite as sneaking in, but I got permission to go into the reservoir. I requested permission to go into the reservoir during the 1980s, and I wanted to basically find out if there were... Birds using that site. What gave you the idea that there might be? During the early part of the 20th century, people could go into the site unencumbered. It was open to the public. But by the late 1960s, early 1970s, gates were put up to protect people from going in and drowning and protect the city from the liability.
from that. So nobody was going in looking for birds in recent decades. I had a romantic idea that people were hopping the fence. Well, not supposed to. But there were reports in the literature from the early part of the 20th century of all kinds of interesting waterfowl that had been seen there. So I was just interested in seeing if there were still birds there. So the water department very graciously allowed me to come in and look around. And then each year, we were able to have someone come in and do a survey of what waterfowl were there during January. And that information was...
helpful in attracting Audubon to the site as a place to build a center. Great. And also about the site, I think it's worth highlighting that we have other nature centers around the city, the really prominent ones, whether Elkowhine's in there, but also where you work in Wissahickham and the Northeast in Pennypack and the Schuylkill Center. True. That a lot of them are more middle class or bordering middle class and sort of maybe upper class neighborhoods. Strawberry Mansion, though, is one of the, put it bluntly, one of the poorest neighborhoods in the whole city.
It's got very challenged educational outcomes for the kids there. It doesn't have great health outcomes for people who live there. And so I've been such a huge fan of the project because it's siting an environmental education center in a place that you don't think of them usually. You can walk to the center from Strawberry Mansion, and there are a tremendous number of people that live right there in Strawberry Mansion. There are a number of schools. And so, yeah, it's positioned in the park, but it's positioned very, very close to the neighborhood so that hopefully people in the neighborhood will want to have...
access to the center and use the center. So we very purposely wanted to have the center there so that it would be easily accessible to all the residents of Strawberry Mansion. And those are some of the people that we are most interested in having come to the center. We have, over the years that we've been working on this project, we've worked with residents of Strawberry Mansion on this project, and they've been very much involved in what we're doing and how we're doing it. So it's very much about them as well as other people. Hey, podcast listeners, we're going to wrap up the first part of this urban birding episode.
with an interview with Dr. Joseph Onoja of the Leki Birding Club in Lagos, Nigeria. All right, I'm Dr. Onoja Joseph Daniel, and I'm the Director of Technical Programs of the Nigerian Conservation Foundation in Leki, Lagos, Nigeria. The Leki Bird Club was started as a volunteer-based bird conservation group.
And this was established in March of 2009. And this is to raise the stake of bed conservation in Nigeria. So the Leki Bed Club has its first series of bed clubs, the first series of bed clubs in Nigeria that we're going to set up. And we hope to also set up these bed clubs in other communities, in other cities around Nigeria. And the activities of this bed club is to go bed-watching trips, to organize talks and lectures, as well as publication in the form of newsletters and trip reports to reach wider audience and people who are also interested in.
bird conservation or who are nature enthusiasts. Who takes part? Like what kind of people end up birding with the bird club? Well, actually, it's open to everybody who is interested in going birding with us. And people who love nature, people who love to be around nature, natural environment. So usually these birds, we go to the natural environment for us to be able to see them. So as we are there, we also encourage people to look around and appreciate nature. So basically, nature enthusiasts are people who go out birding with us. But it's open to a wide range of anybody who wants to come out.
Yeah, so far we visited Bredclaw. I mean, the areas that have been visited are reserves. You know, an urban place like Lagos lacks some of these reserves. So we go to beaches where we can find coastal birds, seabirds. So we go to also some personal protected areas.
People who set up their orchards. So we go in there to find birds. And also, there are some monumental areas that are surrounded by lakes. So we go there also for some water birds. So basically, where those activities are carried out, bird watching activities are carried out, are mostly areas where we think birds can be. And then we go there, we just look for birds. Since Lagos is an urban settlement. What do you mean by an urban settlement? What I mean by urban settlement is the fact that Lagos is one of the largest growing cities in Africa.
So you have very few places, green areas. You have very few places that are green areas. You have everywhere it's almost built up. So except places that we're consciously reserved as green areas, even though every other place is a concrete jungle. So what are some highlight species for you and for the bird club? A very common species that is seen around Lagos is the red-eyed dove. It is something that is very common around Lagos. So you find that very often.
built-up areas. And then you find other birds that are quite... You can find them as they fly around because of the swampy nature of Lagos. Lagos is a coastal town. Because of swampy nature, you find water birds flying around. Sometimes you see white-faced whistling docks. They fly around. Sometimes also you see common laughing doves, common boo-boos. Sometimes you see western gray plantain eaters.
And sometimes you even see kingfishers. For instance, the woodland kingfisher. Woodland kingfisher. Okay, yeah, the bedwatching challenge was initiated by the Lekki Bed Club and the Nigerian Field Society. They invited interesting bedwatchers with all kind of experience, with the different level of experiences. And the purpose of the event was to promote bedwatching awareness on the environment and the protection of local habitats. And usually the competition began and ended in the Lekki Conservation Center along the Lekki Expressway. So they had a team of three to five members who can compete in full 12 hours, at least half a day, and they won for shorter hours of six.
are in a shorter time of six hours. And individuals that do not have a team will be paired with other groups who want them to participate with them. So the teams that sports the most species of wild, free, living birds will be declared the winners. So in a way, you stimulate people. Sometimes bird watching also has to do with a conscious effort.
Sometimes you don't just walk and the birds meet you. Sometimes you have to look around. You have to really consciously look around for you to be able to spot the birds. Because it's not all the birds that are as noisy as the one we call the common bubble. Common bubble is very noisy. If it's fetched on the tree, you'll always find it because it always calls. But others are quiet. So it requires somebody who is consciously looking out for them to be able to see them. So what kind of counts? How many birds did the team see?
Yeah, the teams that had the hires actually got like 36 pieces on their list. Yeah, 36 pieces on their list within the time they had the competition running. Hey, podcast listeners, this ends part one of our Urban Birding episode. We hope you enjoyed it and download part two. Thank you.