What is the pros and cons of living in an urban wetland? I'm trying to think of pros. Pros is that I suppose that you might be lucky enough to be adopted by some group of people who won't look after you. Sorry, dude. Alright, so one more time. Welcome back to another episode of the Urban Wildlife Podcast. This is one of your co-hosts, Billy Brown, sitting with co-host Tony Crowsdale and guest host Matthew Halley. And Matthew Halley was just talking about what he spent all day doing, no? Yeah, I spent all day skinning birds.
Yeah, okay. That's something. Why would you skin birds? Why do an ornithologist skin birds? Well, there are gads and gads and gads of birds that are hitting windows everywhere you look. Whether it's in the city here, the skyscrapers, or if you go out to the suburbs and birds are hitting the screen doors of folks in the suburbs, there's all these birds that are dying. Which is a very special problem. Yeah, it's a whole other problem. And of course, cats are eating birds, too. And occasionally, the cat drags in a carcass. And so people will take those carcasses and they put them into an individual...
Ziploc bag and they put their location and they put the date and they put their name and they put it in the freezer. And then at their convenience, they deliver it to the Academy of Natural Sciences of Drexel University where the ornithology department, we are processing all of these window strike birds and we're skinning them and we take tissue samples of the heart and the liver and muscle tissue and all of that tissue gets cataloged and put into a minus 80 deep freezer that's going to preserve those tissues for years and years and years to come. And then we're sequencing DNA from those tissues to figure out the... family relationships and figure out the evolutionary relationships of the bird species. Lots of cool research can be done with the genetics, but it's amazing that these birds that would otherwise just decompose and be destroyed or thrown into the garbage can are actually being recycled for science. So if these birds have to die for a crappy reason like this, which we hope fewer of them die in the future, we can find solutions. At least they can be used for science. Yeah, exactly. Would you recommend that? So if someone's listening to this and they find a dead bird on the sidewalk outside their office building. Yes, please. The most important thing is to put it into an individual bag. So if you find two birds that hit the window, and that happens sometimes, if you throw them into the same Ziploc bag, it seems really easy for you. But when it comes to us,
It turns out that each bird is carrying special species of lice and mites. The parasites that are on the bird are also really interesting. And if you put them all in the same bag, then the parasites jump hosts. And then we can't tell what parasite came from what. But if you put them into an individual Ziploc bag, then when we get to process the bird, we can actually ruffle the bird for lice. And we take each of those lice and put them into ethanol. And we freeze them and we do genetics on the lice too. So it's a whole...
We call this data-rich specimens. For a single specimen, we're getting data from genetic data and the skin and the lice and the whole package. We're getting all sorts of many layers of data that are going to be useful for scientists now and in the future. Right on. So from a morbid topic to slightly happier topics. Mixed morbid. I don't know. I take the bar. But we're going to now shift to the major focus of this episode, which is turtles. And not just any turtles, but sea turtles. But actually, before we shift to the major topic of the episode, I almost forgot. Let's do our standard introduction stuff.
If you do like this podcast, please do rate us on your podcasting platform of choice, iTunes, Stitcher, whatever you're using. Please tell your friends about it by whatever means possible. And post about it on Facebook. You can contact us with any ideas for stories or even content that you record to see if maybe we want to put it on the air, because we just might. And you can hit us up at urbanwildlifecast.gmail.com. You can find us on Twitter at herbwildlifecast. Pretty easy to find on Facebook. And you can get in touch with us that way. Also, let us know what you think of the show, suggestions, ideas. We're open to all of it. So now to the topic of the day, which is sea turtles. And this is all.
Stuff that we recorded like a year ago. We got way ahead of ourselves at the beginning of recording everything. And we recorded so many stories that we're sort of working through a backlog of really interesting stuff. And today we put together three stories about, I'll sort of say sea turtles. Not all of them are actually in the sea. But the ocean urban intersection is something neat that we've talked about before. We think of cities as being on the land. But so many cities are ports on oceans that you have these important interactions between what lives in oceans and people on land, whether direct or indirectly. The first season we talked about the Gotham Whale Project in New York City. And actually a few episodes I posted a little bit of my own.
Finally, I did my own whale watching trip out of New York, where humpback whales seem to be visiting more often now because of improving forage fish populations, because of improving water quality. So right there, we have sort of like a land pollution to water pollution to, you know, to positively cascading trophic systems in the ocean, bringing whales closer to New York. We talked also to fisheries. biologist in Philadelphia named Joe Perillo about migratory fish in Philadelphia's rivers, whether that's sturgeon or his favorite shad. We also talked to people at Miami's Coral Logics, a project that's really into the corals of urban Miami. It didn't come out yet? It did come out. Oh, I thought you... Oh, yeah. I'm talking about things you already put on. Oh, yeah. Yeah, I was confused for a second. Oh, no, no, no. And so then here in New York, we're going to start off listening to a little bit from Dr. Russell Burke, who's a herpetologist at Hofstra University, about his work with diamondback terrapins. So here we go. My name is Russell Burke, and I'm a professor of biology at Hofstra University. So for people who are unfamiliar, please describe a diamondback terrapin.
Dinobacteropin is what, you know, mostly we call a medium-sized turtle. So for a lot of people, I say it's about the size of a full-grown red-haired spider, which some people, you know, ring the bell with some people. But, you know, it's something in the neighborhood of, you know, eight or nine inches long for a big female. Males are considerably smaller. And they live in brackish water. That's the somewhat salty water along the coastline from Cape Cod in Massachusetts to Corpus Christi in Texas. And the other important thing about them is that they are a marsh-requiring species. They need to live around marshes.
So they're restricted to places where there are either marshes, and in some cases they live in mangrove swamps, but mostly salt marshes. So they're pretty widespread in kind of a linear range that goes along the coastline, almost the entire United States' eastern coastline. Can you describe where you find them around New York? Well, New York has actually quite a number of terrapin populations. We have them all around Long Island, which is most of our marine coastline is Long Island. And so they're all around Long Island, but generally pretty spotty, like a small number here and another population here and another population there. So there are not large stretches of shoreline on Long Island, many, many, many, many miles where you could go and not see terrapins or not find terrapins. But on the other hand, most of those populations are relatively small. And then they go up the Hudson River for quite a ways on, up about 25 miles from the mouth of the Hudson up into...
a marsh called Piermont Marsh a little ways up from the Hudson, and that has a small population of terrapins as well. So Long Island and the lower Hudson are terrapin habitat. So if you're a terrapin, I usually think in terms of cons, but what are the pros and cons of living in an urban wetland? I'm trying to think of pros. Pros is that I suppose that you might be lucky enough to be adopted by some group of people who will look after you.
that's a pro, but nearly every place where they live anywhere in their range, there's enough of a human impact that they're very likely to be experiencing subsidized predator populations, even in areas where humans don't live in high density. So even in non-urban areas, raccoon populations are probably better off because of humans being around. Just the trash that washes up on beaches everywhere, that feeds raccoons. So every place is really humans are subsidizing raccoons. And even in areas where there isn't high density of human populations, we have roads. And roads are major mortality sources for terrapins as well. And again, even in areas where humans don't live at high densities, people trap blue crabs. And blue crabs trapping is a major source of mortality for terrapins as well. So there really is no place, you know, there aren't very many places where terrapins live where they're not impacted negatively by humans. So with all that working against them, what is New York City doing to help them?
I think that the single biggest thing that New York City is doing to help terrapins is something that it's not doing for terrapins whatsoever, but it's doing for other reasons and is secondarily helping terrapins. Probably the biggest, most important thing that New York City itself is doing is improving the quality of the sewage outflow in the Jamaica Bay so that it's not releasing nearly so much nitrogen. And as a result, we are expecting to have healthier marshes in Jamaica Bay. And as a result of that, we expect to have maybe some better conditions for the terrapins that live there. Thanks.
I guess if you're just sort of listening to this and decide you like terrapins, are there volunteer opportunities or ways listeners can get involved with helping terrapins? Well, a great way to start to get introduced to terrapins is the Diamondback Terrapin Working Group, which is tdwg.org, which is easily accessible on the web. It's really the place to go for people who are seriously interested in terrapins. And it's really a meeting place, a collecting place for all serious researchers and students and just anybody who's interested in learning more about terrapins. It has a massive collection of literature on terrapins.
And it's a great way to get plugged into the conservation efforts everywhere. Second to that, it's got, you know, if you're in the New York City area, my research project is really a large citizen science project. And we have usually in the neighborhood of 30 to 60 volunteers every summer who come out and help with our terrapin research at Jamaica Bay. So if you contact me, I can definitely set you up to do some of that. Great. Thank you.
Just to ask you to tell an anecdote, I remember you, I think this was you, sorry if it wasn't, but tell them a story about raccoon, sort of, I guess, raccoon dumping that might have artificially increased raccoon populations in Jamaica Bay. Yeah, it's an interesting story, again, probably one that we'll never be able to nail down entirely, but the main island where we do our work in Jamaica Bay is called Ruler's Bar, and this is an area that actually is a man-made island. Before the turn of the century, this was a marsh with maybe no real uplands at all, a marsh that flooded. completely at every high tide or at least some high tides. And I had no upland at all. And there was a period of time when Jamaica Bay, some parts of Jamaica Bay were excavated to make the water deeper so the bigger ships could get in. And they took the sediment that they dug up when they did that digging and piled it on top of marshes. And one of those marshes was the one that is where the island is now. And so they essentially created an island where there was a marsh before. And I say all this because
suggest that probably there were not raccoons there when the island was first created. And there was actually some mammal surveys that were done back in the 70s, some medium-sized mammal surveys, and they didn't find any raccoons there at all. So I interpret the fact that it's a recently created man-made island and the fact that mammal surveys failed to find raccoons to conclude that there probably weren't raccoons there in the early years of the island. And so then the question comes, how did the raccoons get there? And in the 1950s and 60s, bridges were built out to the island, and certainly raccoons could cross bridges, and certainly raccoons can swim, and they can also cross ice.
So there's lots of opportunities for them to get there basically on their own. But we also know, because I've observed it, that exterminators or animal control people in New York City have sometimes brought raccoons out to the island and released them there. That island is, of course, now a wildlife refuge. But people have brought raccoons out there and released them with the understanding that they're doing a good thing for the raccoons because they're taking a lot of people's backyards and letting them loose in a wildlife refuge where they can be free and be happy and all that kind of stuff. So we have good evidence that... All right. Thank you very much and have a great day. You too. Take care.
These are some of my favorite turtles. We live in Philadelphia. They're relatively easy to spot in the marshlands around, or the marshes around the Delaware Bay, and the marshes on sort of the, what's it called? On the Jersey Shore. The Jersey Shore. If you go down to Stone Harbor and Avalon. Yeah. So when people talk about the Jersey Shore, you're talking about like a whole bunch of barrier islands. And then on the, I don't know what to call it, the ocean side, and what's the other side called? Bayside. Bayside, thank you. Great. The bayside of these barrier islands.
You have good dive-back terrapin populations. They are an important subject of conservation because a lot of the reasons that Russell was talking about, whether that's the ghost crab traps or the active crab traps killing them. Or the raccoons. Raccoons, subsidized predators, pollution. A big focus also, I know, on the Jersey Shore is automobile traffic because the females will cross roads trying to nest. And the worst thing you can do to a long-lived animal is kill the breeding females.
It's really put the population into a tailspin. It's the kind of thing where you can also go out when they're nesting, and there's places that make a point of this, giving you opportunities to observe them or see some of them that have been rescued and see some of the nests that they've protected, like the Wetlands Institute of Stone Harbor, where they've got a great collection of rescued terrapins. And actually, a segue to your bird thing, where if you find a recently killed female terrapin, you can bring them in, and sometimes they can rescue the eggs out of their carcass and incubate them and hatch them. And then they do the cutest release thing ever where they get kindergartners to release the head-started baby terrapins. And as far as salvage goes for birds, you can also collect salvage birds in New Jersey too. Academy will take salvage birds from New Jersey too. I know I'm harping on the same topic over and over, but it's a great way to utilize these otherwise sadly killed animals. And I'll say this also, you can do the same thing with a lot of different kinds of dead animals. I know people who will, sometimes you have to have the right license to do it, but usually people are pretty cool about it. Like if you find like a dead, like you're saying a salvaged dead bird, if you're finding a dead snake on the road even or something like that, if you pop it in the freezer, record where you found it and when. That's the most important thing.
And then you can use that, whether you take it to your local university, biology department, or something like that. They'll know what to do with it. Local Natural History Museum. And they can use that as a voucher. The animal itself will be useful, as well as having documentation of it occurring where it occurred is also a useful data point. So, Tony, do you ever interact with diamondback terrapins when you're down the shore looking up at birds? Oh, I mean, you know me. I love everything. I'm a huge fan of diamondback terrapins. They're so gorgeous. I mean, they have beautiful lips.
I love their spotty heads. They're a treat. Sometimes you just see little heads spoken up in the water. Sometimes you see them hauled out. They're gorgeous. They're among my favorite turtles. So yeah, I'm quite familiar with them. I've also picked them off off the road in Apsecan and stuff and released them back in Salt Mart and stuff. Yeah, so when you see them, if they're nesting, leave them alone. If you see a turtle crossing the road, I always have to say this, always take it in the direction it's heading. They can be stubborn, and so they might just like, if you take it back the wrong way, they'll just try again. And we'll segue now into...
to Umair Shahid from the World Wildlife Fund in Pakistan, in Karachi, talking about green sea turtles in Pakistan waters off Karachi that face some of the same challenges, actually. We've got subsidized predators, whether it's crows or feral dogs or raccoons from the U.S. side. These are all things that eat sea turtle eggs. And when human activity, whether it's littering and trash and rubbish or whether it is intentional, like putting cat food out for the cats outside, it attracts them.
You know, all these things kind of boost the population of critters that eat sea turtle eggs or dinosaur eggs. My name is Omer Shahid, and I'm working as the North Indian Ocean Coordinator for the Marine Program for WWF Pakistan. Could you give just a quick introduction about that marine program? What do you guys do in general with marine ecosystems and marine conservation in Pakistan? Great question, because we started off the marine program about three years ago, and we focused more on data collection and filling in the information gaps because three years ago we did not know exactly what was happening on the coast of Pakistan, and it was all new information for us. So we started off with collecting a lot of data on the resources that Pakistan has, and then we built on...
working with capacity building of the government stakeholders. And then we started working at the regional level. So it was a lot of advocacy. It was a lot of lobbying for having compliance to international binding and non-binding instruments, such as the UNCLOS, which is the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, as well as FAO's International Plan of Action for Sharks, which says to have shark management measures in place for all the countries that are targeting sharks. So overall, we have a human welfare focus because we believe that we only have to manage people.
If you can manage people, you can manage the resources. So let's start then with talking a little bit about the marine turtles that you find off of Pakistan. What species are we looking at? Oh, we're looking at about five species which have been reported from the Pakistani waters. Now, the thing is that the marine turtles are really a species of special concern, and they are considered flagship species, they're iconic, they're very important to the ecosystem. So we're looking at about five species, but only one of them is nesting on the coastline, which is the green turtles. Unfortunately, we used to have a lot of Oliverly turtles nesting on our beach, but the records date back to about 12 years from now, and we haven't had any nesting. There have been some unconfirmed reports of leatherbacks and loggerheads as well, but...
There are still unconfirmed reports, and there's no convincing evidence to prove that. So the places where they nest, are they sort of beaches, like isolated beaches in the middle of nowhere, or are they beaches closer to people? Talk about sort of the places they find themselves nesting in relative to the people that you talked about managing. Well, relatively, the beaches are quite close. It's actually in the city, which is Karachi. Karachi is in the southern part of Pakistan, and it's right on the sea level. So it's a metropolitan city, very densely populated, hosts a population of about 20 million or even more, which contributes to about 10, which is actually 10% of the total population of Pakistan. And it's quite close. Then there are beaches which are isolated, but they have fragmented nesting on the western coast. So most of the nesting is focused in this particular area, which is categorized or famously recognized as Sandspit and Hawkes Bay beaches.
They are located southwest of the Karachi City and stretched to about 15 to 20 kilometers long, of which about 5.5 kilometers is the area where all these green turtles come to nest. And on an annual basis, they come to about 2,500 to 3,000 green turtles. And we have a very extended period of nesting. It stretches from July of each year to December. Sometimes even January and February have nesting, which is quite odd at the moment. So what kind of challenges does a green sea turtle face when it's nesting near so many people?
Well, just to give a brief background about how many people are visiting. There are about 100,000 people coming to the beach on a monthly basis. So it's a famous recreational spot, to be honest, and people from the capital and other parts of the province come here. And all these people, they bring in a lot of stuff, a lot of garbage, they do a lot of littering. There's a lot of disturbance during the nifting activity, which happens at night. Sometimes they do it intentionally, sometimes they do it unintentionally. Even the habitat is not much protected because of the coastal development that's going on. There are more than 200 cemented huts, and these are permanent structures located right there on the beach. According to the legislation or according to the international law, there should be a setback line.
So all the development that happens on the coast should be at least 500 meters away from the high tide watermark. But unfortunately, these are about 100 meters away from the high tide watermark. So all the habitat is being lost. And these species are struggling in terms of where they will be nesting. Now, these are known facts. These are anthropogenic factors. But there are also natural ones at play, such as predation, which is due to the increase of crows. They're scavengers, but they also hunt. And the common kites, the seagulls, or the feral dogs, which the population has bloomed for feral dogs.
The communities that reside around the beach, they feed them, and they offer protection to the communities. So that's an added issue as well. But there are emerging threats that we are not fully aware of, such as climate change. We're not sure how it may impact the total population, but it's slowly being recognized as one of the threats, which needs a lot of attention and research. I'm not sure if you've heard about ghost nets at the moment. Ghost nets are mostly those nets that have been discarded in the sea. These are nets that...
that the fishers use. They have been replaced. They have been, either they get stuck on the surface or on the bottom, and then the fishers, they just release them, or they cut them down, so they float, and they are not visible. And the reason why they're not visible are because of the material that they're made, and then they're left tangled on the rocky reef or even drifting in the open ocean. And these are really direct threats to these populations.
And I wanted to come back just to ask you a couple other points you mentioned there because they're really interesting. I want to make sure we understand them. The feral dogs. So talk about how they – I think of feral dogs as usually sort of as a pest. Talk about how they protect villages or people. Go ahead.
That's a very interesting question, and I think the social scientist or the anthropologist would be really happy to answer that. Me being a natural scientist, it's difficult to integrate those elements, but I'll try my best. I might have understood a comment that you made. I thought you said about somebody, the dogs protecting people, or people protecting the dogs. It's both ways, actually. So what happens is because these coastal areas, the villagers, these are mostly fishers, and they're mostly off to fishing at night. So all the men go out for fishing, so they're females, and the children are left alone.
So they have a fear that people may intrude into their privacy or they may be going about cutting down the mangrove forest, which is also located around that area. So in terms of having protection, it's a relation that has developed over time. They feed the dogs because the fishermen communities think that everything that they consume and everything that they left out should not go to waste. So they offer that food to the animals, which in this case are the stray dogs. In turn, they give protection. So if they see any person which is outside the village or they don't recognize, they set an alarm. So everyone is active.
So in that sense, it gives a lot of protection. And even there have been cases where snakes have come into their houses and dogs have actually saved children from being bitten by snakes. How might global warming affect these nesting turtles? Wonderful question. This is really complex as well, because what we have seen in the past is that...
The sea level is rising, and the sea turtles' memories are imprinted with a magnetic map of the sandy beach where they hatch. So this gives them the ability to return on the same site. So decades later, these animals will come back and nest in that same location. So ideally, if a marine turtle has nested on one beach, it will come again for nesting. So considering the climate that's there, and we did a pilot study quite recently, and we found out how these sea turtles are being affected is because of the temperatures in the sand.
in which the eggs incubate. And these temperatures, they actually determine the gender of the hatchling. So typically the eggs in the lower part of the chamber, which is the nest, will be cooler, while the part of the nest which is on the upper side of the chamber, which is the nest, will become warmer. So the part that's cooler will have more males, while the eggs in the upper part, which is warmer, will have more females. So with increasing nest temperatures, scientists have predicted that there will be more females than male hatchlings. So this is creating a significant threat to the genetic diversity. You know, warmer ocean temperatures.
will also likely affect the negative impact on the food chain, such as the coral bleaching, so there will be less food supply for these animals. And also it will change the ecological processes. So there's not just one way climate change can affect them. It can skew sex ratios. So if there are more females, there won't be any males to reproduce. And likewise, if there are more males, there won't be any females for enough reproduction to happen. And the chance of one turtle to survive in its lifetime is 1 out of 10,000 approximately, or maybe I'm stretching it a bit, but 10 out of 10,000.
maybe the ones able to survive and live off to 150 years, like it's mentioned in Finding Nemo, if you've seen that animated movie, which she talks about that. Yes, we have. So it's kind of because the issues are really complex. What's happening on the coast can be managed, but what's happening in the sea in terms of the ecological processes, the predation, or the fisheries, because the fisheries poses a huge threat to these animals, because they come as bycatch. So bycatch is becoming a significant issue with the increased fishing effort. Everywhere we see the fishers that we meet, they have huge, huge nets. The use of advanced and modern technology, the use of crawl nets for catching shrimps. So they're targeting fisheries at all trophic levels, so nothing is being spared at the moment. So the bycatch is becoming one of the biggest threats.
So now we've gone through some of the major threats to the turtles. Can you talk a little bit about your programming? You said in WWF Pakistan's view, the thing to do is to try to manage the people. Can you talk a little bit about what you guys do? Absolutely.
Just before I talk about WWF programming, I would like to just highlight the efforts made by the Sun Wildlife Department. Oh, please do, yeah. The Provincial Wildlife Department, they have been the pioneers of sea turtle conservation work. And they have been declared protected under the Wildlife Protection Ordnance back in 1972. And they started off their projects in 1979. And they developed hatcheries and they monitored the populations. They rescued turtles where they were hatching, where they're not. And then also, you know, they rescued stranded turtles. But of course, governments have some gaps and they have constraints.
WWF really came in and tried to ensure that the marine conservation efforts are focused. And because you cannot work in isolation when you're doing conservation work, you need focus, you need stakeholder involvement, you need multiple partnerships to help those things out. So in that sense, we did an analysis of the threats. And as I mentioned, bycatch is one of them. So how we came into play was to understand that we need to manage people. What we did was we basically...
targeted fishers. Now, what we did was we trained the fishermen who were going on these boats and who were the skippers, who were the captains of the boat. And we gave them trainings and we inquired what kind of species were they catching. So we provided them species identification guides so they can recognize turtles because in general sense they would recognize all the turtles as turtles but not as individual species. It took a lot of time. It took a lot of capacity building, a lot of sensitization for these fishers. And once they started bringing in records through digital cameras, which we had given them, we found out that, wow, what are the catching is huge. And the way they are handling the marine turtle catch is also considerable.
So when we gave them trainings, we asked them to record the data. We defined the safe release practices for the biquat sea turtles. And these included, you know, when they haul the handling, when they haul the net. That is, you know, when they lift the net when a turtle is confirmed to be entangled. And then handling while on board to ensure that they take careful measurements. If possible, holding the specimen from both sides of the carapace and lifting it so they're not manhandling it. And then releasing it back into the ocean. That is, you know, leaning towards the side of the vessel while handling the turtle and bending as much as they can, stretching and releasing it face down.
So reducing impact as far as possible. So during the study, which we have been doing since January 2013, since then, we've seen that, and I'm just talking about four vessels at the moment. The data is just from four vessels. And they were catching about 600 sea turtles, which included about more than 400 olive riddles, around 200 greens, and very few, very few hawkswell turtles. And sorry, for context, how many vessels are we talking about as the total number of working in those waters?
I'm sorry, I should have mentioned that. There are about more than 500 fishing vessels. The length of the nets range from about 4,000 to 7,000 meters long, which means 4 kilometers to 7 kilometers. It's long. We call it the Great Wall of Death. And rightly so. Yes, absolutely. So nothing is spared.
You talk about sharks, you talk about cetaceans, including dolphins and whales and manta rays, species that are endangered, species that are categorized as high interest species on our list. They are all caught. But the good thing about it is through this awareness program and through this training and capacity building on the fishers, we reduce the mortality to a significant deal. So among those 600 sea turtles that were caught in these four vessels, About 500, more than 500. The figures that I have were 540. And I published a paper on this as well, which you can easily find on the internet. About 540 turtles were released alive, and only 60 turtles died. So that's reducing the mortality to about 10%, which was previously more than 50%. So that's a great amount of work that we had to do for reducing the mortality from 50% to 10%. And we aim to go down to 1% and even zero, inshallah, very soon. Do you have anything else you might like to add before we wrap up?
I'll just reiterate the fact about the success from the training of the crew-based observer coverage program that we have. Since 2005, we have been able to safely release a live 22 whale sharks. six manta rays, three bottlenose dolphins, one long man's beet whale, stingrays, sunfish, sea snakes, sea birds, guitar fishes, and thousands of marine turtles. These include greens, olive ridleys, hawksbill loggerhead, and leatherback. And all of these have been published, and they have also aired in a U.S. magazine. I will be happy to share those materials with you and your audience.
And the second thing that I wanted to highlight was about ghost nets, because I think we haven't really touched a lot on that. But just to give you an estimate about how much does it impact, the UN has estimated that about 640,000 tons of ghost care are lost on an annual basis. That's a lot of ghost gear. And it's really expensive. And it's a huge problem. We've just started a project with an engineer that's called Oliver Ridley Project. And if you want to know more about it, you can go on their website, which is oliveridleyproject.org. And we're trying to now work on removing these ghost gear from our coastal beaches.
as well as the core of reefs, because that's where all of these kind of aggregate. So in that sense, I think my shout out to the public would be to join hands with conservation organizations and also with other government organizations and spread the word about why we want to secure these turtles, why these turtles are important, why these species can play a significant role. Because I believe that... If you can save these turtles, they are very helpful in maintaining the ecosystem health. And when we success or when we succeed in securing the ecosystem health, it will be us, the humans, who will benefit. And I don't want my children to see these animals in history museums or in history books. I want my children to see them alive. And I think it's our obligation to pass this on to the next generation.
Another thing I had thought about being in common with the Terrapin situation is the fishing equipment. Whether that's ghost nets in Pakistani waters, and we just stop there and talk about, wait, how long are those nets? Because seven kilometers is just a frequently falling object. Yeah, it's just incredibly long, and anything that falls into that net is going to die. And any time those nets are put out, it's kind of assumed that anything that gets into that net is going to die. And you're dying, it's going to attract more things to feed on them. And it's going to attract more things, yeah. It's a very long net of death. Yeah, a wall of death. I think it's a wall of death. I know a band that has an album in Wall of Death.
The system. My band. Our first album. What was it about that? So far, we're going to get into this term later on with the Long Beach one we're talking about. The term Discharge, which you mentioned is another band title. We've got Wall of Death. We'll see how many punk references we can inadvertently... I think that Mortality would be a good band name, but it's interesting to think about the many different types of infant mortality. The different types of mortality. Anthromortality. We've got... Turtles are dealing not only with adult mortality in long nets, but they're also dealing with...
hatchling mortality when they're leaving the nest and running across the beach to try to enter the water for the first time. Run the gauntlet of crows or whatever. Gosh, yeah. Crows and monitor lizards and, you know, you name it. Depending on where they are in the world, they're going to be facing a whole suite of predators during that run across the beach. Then, once you get to the water, then you're dealing with a whole other suite of predators. The lives of these turtles or every stage of life is a daunting challenge, to say the least. Sweet predators is also a good band name. Sweet predators. Okay, we'll take that. That was Gigi with her contribution to the podcast episode today.
And then the thing is that with turtles, though, once they get to be a certain size, they're supposed to be safe. I mean, like, the way they've evolved is to get to adulthood, and then it's a lot harder to kill. And then... So on top of all those problems, now when you've got terrapins trapped in a crab trap, or you've got a green turtle trapped in a 7km long net, and it's just hard to think of. And when the nesting season comes, and this green sea turtle, for example, or olive ridley turtle, or leatherback sea turtle, or there's many different sea turtles, they come back to their natal site to breed, they come back to the very same beach that they hatch from, and...
Not only are there temperature effects on the sex ratios, like our guest talked about, but also we've got light pollution from the town. And these creatures are very, very sensitive to light. And there's so many different anthropogenic influences that are going to affect their behavior in some way that might have some repercussions down the line that is going to increase mortality at either the nestling stage or the nest stage or the adult stage. So these anthropogenic factors that are human-caused are affecting the sea turtles at every stage of their life cycle. not just at one stage. That's the critical thing. And so there's no saving grace for these turtles. It was interesting. I mean, it was hopeful also talking to Omer about sort of what they're doing, as he put it, to manage the people. You know, hopeful signs with helping fishers, the fishing industry in Pakistan do things to not kill so many turtles. Also on the...
to call it um the send basically the as for the wildlife officials the provincial wildlife officials um working on sort of the land side threats to the turtles um there's like a robust response it's kind of it's and you know it sounds like that even observations going back just a dozen years that it's sort of something people are newly aware of you know for a guy who loves turtles it's a gratifying thing to see that whether you're in like miami beach or you're in karachi you know huge cities on oceans that people can sort of you know come together and say we like sea turtles we'll come do a saving we've come to a point here where we we think of sea turtles as this uncommon thing which is In many waters, right? And if we look back into history, we see that they were huge populations of sea turtles back in the day. They were back during the colonial era when Europeans were traveling across the Atlantic Ocean to colonize. Colonize, that's a good word. Maybe it's more appropriate than colonize. And they...
sea turtles were an excellent source of food because in these big ships that are traveling across the ocean, and you can capture a sea turtle and keep it on it, turn it onto its back, and it's upside down on its shell, and as long as you keep putting water onto it, it's going to live for a while. It's going to suffer incredibly, but it's going to... It works if it's what you need to eat. Yeah, but it's great for a source of food, and so sea turtles were an abundant source of food for the colonists. Didn't they say that the ships, they would just hear clunk after clunk of hint sea turtles? It's a thing that I've seen covered a little more, that we focus so much on biodiversity and on extinction.
that sometimes people don't focus as much as we should on the loss of abundance of wildlife. I don't know, man. I saw this thing on the Discovery Channel that convinced me that there's mermaids, and I'm sure they're eating sea turtles. Why can't the mermaids eat vegetarians and just eat kelp? That was a weird man. That was the weirdest, weirdest program and quite disingenuous. Do you know how I first saw that? It was when my apartment and I finally got bed bugs and I like, and I went to the, so I like got a price line and like ended up staying at the sheriff in a few nights while I was like, while they're treating my apartment and I was, um, watching cable and I was having my, you know, I was like having my clothes like washed and dried at high heat and everything, all that stuff. But I did it on the cable and it came on. It was like, I turned it on like mid-show and I was like, I was like, what the hell is this? Like, it was crazy. Yeah, the description has come a long way since I was like watching it on my parents' sofa growing up.
Last up, we've got Cassandra Davis from the Aquarium of the Pacific talking with Tony about green sea turtles that live in the San Gabriel River in Long Beach, California. How did you find this one? I saw an article on Facebook or something about it. And I was like, maybe my buddy in LA said it to me. I forget. But I was like, this is crazy. Like, this is like, I mean, I just had to know more about this. So who discovered the phenomena?
So it has been reported a number of times by different fishermen or bicyclists, but the primary people who started to document the turtles in the river included some volunteers at the Aquarium of the Pacific, as well as some naturalists who were studying the area for the wetlands project. So the river, the San Gabriel River, has been channelized. It and the Los Angeles River were channelized in order to prevent flooding. is an area that is a larger channel because it's at the mouth of the river, and it's where the freshwater mixes where the saltwater. And they go through a mixing process for the brackish water. And in that brackish water, that wider channel, you have our marine life appearing, including juveniles, as well as the fully grown sea lions and other animals that might swim up the river. And you also can see the sea turtles there, who do tend to be in their juvenile or teenage years. And how far up do they go up the river?
So there's a section of the river that's about one to two miles that allows them access to that brackish water. It's not possible for them to go past that section. There is a bit of a barrier between the freshwater and the brackish water. But they do tend to swim up and down a pretty large section, and many cyclists will be able to see them because there's a bike path right next to that section. Wow, I've got to go see that. Is there a specific season that they're there, or are they there year round?
Well, we have observed turtles there year-round, and our citizen science project is in the process of seeing what we can determine as far as estimates for... population numbers, population trends, and tendencies. Yeah, they do leave the river, and they do breed elsewhere. So they do spend time in the river, and they do seem to enjoy and feed in the river, but they don't spend their entire lives there. They do leave for breeding grounds probably in the warmer waters of Mexico. Green turtles have been observed as breeding on Hawaii, Mexico, Gulf of California. We don't know where these specific ones do breed, but there have been trackers attached to them.
There was a tracking project done in cooperation with the California State University Long Beach, as well as a few other entities that did attach some radio trackers to them. So they would ping a specific radio telemetry station, and that would measure where they traveled in the river, how fast they traveled up or down the river, and whether or not they left the river. But there are some challenges when tracking any type of sea turtle. And the biggest challenge is that the tracking device is lost or falls off during the natural course of the turtle's movements. So for those tracking devices, we were able to determine that none of the track turtles in that period of time left the river while they were wearing a tracking device.
And how long time were they being tracked for? It was over a year. The longest time that a tracking device stayed on a turtle was just over a year. It is a common area for juveniles to spend time growing up. It's a safer area because it's more sheltered from predators that would be in open water. You can often find many juvenile ocean animals in those brackish water areas at river mouths and outlets. And, in fact, wetlands communities are essential to ocean habitats and ocean health because of this. They are a nursery for different animals.
area where these sea turtles are found is actually an area that was once a natural wetland, and the Los Cerritos Wetlands Authority and Conservancy and other organizations around that are actually actively working to restore those wetlands and habitats for the turtles and for many other animals that are located in that area. Sea turtles in general, especially the green sea turtle, but many other turtles have a temperature range that is their ideal temperature range, and that usually requires warmer waters, and it's because at a certain point, if the water becomes too cold, the turtles will suffer from what's known as cold stunning, and that renders them in a catatonic state, and they can't really survive or thrive in that way. That being said, we do have here the northernmost known population of green sea turtles.
on the Pacific Coast, on this side of the Pacific Coast, I should say. And we do know of green sea turtles that will travel up the Gulf Stream while the Gulf Stream is further north. So you will find instances of turtles being cold stunned or being rescued far up into New England areas, so Maine or Massachusetts. You will hear reports of that. They'll transport them back down to Florida. Those will happen in the fall and winter months.
Here on the west coast of America, we don't have the same current pattern. So we don't have a Gulf Stream that moves up the coast and back down the coast. But we do have inlets and estuary areas that are warmer because the water is shallower. And that's really what's happened with these sea turtles. It's primarily because the water in that river area is warmer that they're able to stay and survive and even thrive in that type of environment. They're not necessarily as many as you would find in a warmer environment or warmer location.
The fact that they're there and they seem to be doing quite well is pretty exciting. And is it warmer because of the urban area they're in, or is it just some other function of the climate there? Yes, that part of the river is warmer because of the city. at this point in time. However, historically, the wetlands areas would naturally warm the waters because the waters are shallower and the wetlands would have seagrass or other darker grasses that, you know, the sun coming down would heat up and provide a great environment for the turtles. So although it is warmer now because of human input, which includes the channelization of the river, the water in the channel actually heats up as the sun shines down on it, and some of our warmest parts of the river can be found up where the river meets the brackish water, meets the ocean, essentially. And we also do have...
to power stations that are using what's called once-through cooling, and they take in water, use it to cool down areas of the power station, and pump it back out, and it's a warmer water in those locations as well. It is very likely that the turtles have been present for quite some time, and it's likely that they were present before these anthropogenic contributions to the river, before our artificial heat was added to the river. And it's very likely that with the restoration of the wetlands habitats that they will continue to be present. And we see evidence of that a little bit further south, not too far south, but a little bit further south in an area known as Bolsa Chica, which is a wetlands area that has been relatively restored. We do find turtles there as well. And the fact that they are present there...
indicates that they will probably continue to be present with the restoration of the Los Ritos wetlands. What's the population size there? In Long Beach? Oh, no, it's the turtles. Oh, it's the turtles. Sorry, it's the Long Beach population. It's the turtles.
So one of our observation project's goals is to determine some rough estimates of the population of sea turtles, both population trends and a general baseline picture of the population and their habits. And one of the things that we found is there are probably about two larger-sized turtles, and those are at the fully-grown or near-fully-grown stage. The remainder of the turtles are teenagers, so they haven't yet reached the age where they can go reproduce, and they're possibly spending the time in this river area to grow up and become larger, grow larger and stronger before they go out and migrate to the breeding grounds. Now, our population estimates range from greater than 10 to as high as maybe 100. They range 10 to 100.
It's a big range, yes. And that's because we are not yet at the point where we can ascertain whether a sea turtle that has been spotted is going to be one individual traveling a significant distance or going to be multiple individuals. And that's one of the challenges of wildlife observation, especially wildlife observation in the ocean. One of our next projects is to start a photo ID of the turtles. So in addition to working with NOAA and the National Marine Fisheries Service, as they use our data to help them tag and measure and count the turtles, We also are hoping to start a photo ID program. You might have heard of photo ID programs in citizen science for whales or dolphins, other marine mammals, where they can identify them. Yeah, based on their tail fluke or based on basically distinct markings of an individual. One of the things that's been discovered is that sea turtles have very distinct scutes or plates around their eyes, and you can identify individuals based upon the pattern of those scutes around their eyes.
we're hoping that we can begin taking pictures of the turtles and matching those individuals. It's a time-consuming process, and it's also one that is only really recently available because high-powered photography hasn't been available to the general public as something that you can do quickly and easily with a high zoom in an urban environment where you don't have much space to work with until recently. So new camera advances have really done a lot for citizen science, not just... for our turtles program, but for many other programs out there that are working on things like animal identification without disturbing the animals in their natural environment. And, of course, being able to do so when you only have a few seconds while the turtle surfaces to take a picture and hopefully get it to come out clear and focused and aligned so that you could use it as an identification picture. That is really cool. So you think the turtles might be coming in there because it's warmer. Are they coming in and warming up and feeding elsewhere, or are they feeding in the river as well? Are you spending the whole time in the river?
likely feeding in the river. There are not the seagrasses present that you would expect the turtles to naturally feed off of. However, there are quite a few small animals and vertebrates and other food sources for the juveniles that can help them develop and help them grow. It's a pretty fantastic opportunity to observe wildlife and see wildlife in a place that most people don't get a chance to connect with wildlife. In Los Angeles, we don't have very many areas where people can see or connect with the natural world. So it's nice to have these areas that we can see something unique and different and hopefully draw those connections to the great wide world out there and especially to ocean life, which everybody in Los Angeles is connected to, whether they know it or not, because of our watershed, because the Los Angeles River, the San Gabriel River, and some of the other rivers in the area drain directly into the ocean.
And so I guess the last thing that I definitely want to ask you is are there negative impacts that you observe of these turtles? Are there dangers? Do you think these turtles are doing well in the river or are they getting caught up by boats or ingesting trash? How do you think they're doing in the urban area? Well, it's a hopeful sign that they are there at all and that they do seem to be, in general, as a population worldwide, recovering or starting to recover. But in the Pacific San Gabriel River, boat strikes are definitely a threat to them and a threat to turtles inside of the greater Los Angeles and Long Beach area, and that's certainly a concern. We have absolutely seen sea turtles swimming through trash in the river. Fortunately, the river is not usually...
full of trash. It's usually fairly clean, but there are certainly more signs of trash and trash cleanup efforts that are needed, especially after a heavy rain. You will see plastic bags, styrofoam caps, single-use products that have washed down through storm drains. and washed out into the river, and storm drains will feed directly out into the river and into the ocean, so anything that's there just gets washed down, and we'll see the sea turtles surfacing between those pieces of debris on a fairly regular basis after the rains. I don't know what dangers those pose to the turtles overall, but I do know that we've certainly seen them in and around that kind of debris on a fairly regular basis.
Any turtles that are found are reported or hopefully should be reported to the National Marine Freshly Service. They are a protected species, and they are a species that whenever they are injured or... If anything can be done for them, the National Marine Fisheries is going to take care of them and see what can be done to rehabilitate them. Or if one is found, they're going to take them in and discover what may have happened to it or what danger it may have encountered. I know that there are certainly turtles that have been found that were stunned by boats or hit by boats going above the speed limit. And we did have an instance that was covered.
by a few news outlets where we found a turtle that was entangled in fishing line. In fishing line, it can entangle all kinds of marine life. Well, it did happen to entangle this turtle. We were able to work with our NOAA marine nymph person and get that turtle to shore and get it untangled. He was able to measure that turtle and document it, examine it, determine it was healthy enough to be released, and they were able to release that turtle. We do see it still in the river. So that's nice to still have him around.
quite some time, almost a year now, since that happened. And have you surveyed the other river, like, other similar rivers in, or are there other similar, like, is this the one-off, are there similar systems in Los Angeles County that could potentially have these turtles that no one's noticed, or is it, like, pretty much just specific to this that you know of? Have you gone looking for them in other similar... So, yes. The sea turtles are known to exist in many of the waterways coming up the coast in varying numbers, so not necessarily in the numbers that we have. It might just be as small as one was spotted at one point in time at this location. So we do know that they do spend time at different waterways coming up the coast. We know that there was a river with a similar population of turtles in San Diego, and that river also had the once-through cooling that was going on, and that was a population that then...
moved to be still in the San Diego area, but slightly more dispersed within their bay area once the once-through cooling from the power plants was shut off. So the turtles are still there. They're just not necessarily concentrated in one spot as much as they were before. And that may indeed be the case with other rivers in the Los Angeles area, where they may be there, but not there quite as concentrated or quite as frequently. Well, I just, in general, a take home, I think, is really fantastic that we're able to connect people to wildlife this way. And I think it's really amazing that these do exist so close to
such an urban environment. And it's surprising what animals are able to do in those urban environments and how those populations are able to not only survive, but thrive. I hope that anybody who's listening goes out and explores their urban environments and sees what there is to see out there. Synanthropic organism. I like talking to her because she's like another.
So she totally has that voice. You can hear how she explains things. She's usually talking to groups of 25 fourth graders. It's funny because I'm an educator but I don't talk about that at all. I have a completely other persona. But I recognize that persona in my field. But I have this other kind of persona of being charismatic and surly at the same time.
You're saying she's charismatic or you're charismatic? I'm charismatic. So this is one of these ones where I guess they're studying it. You hope it isn't bad for the turtles to be drawn into artificially warm water where they just stretch their flippers out and chill. They just want to hang out with Snoop Dogg. Long Beach. Yeah, I mean, it's neat to think that they're definitely there because of human.
It's tracking them there. They're getting the warmth. They're getting some other benefits. I've seen manatees do this in Florida, right? Where they go to the water coming out of... Nuclear power plants. Yeah, just chill. Yeah, we need to definitely do some more stuff about manatees. They're fun. I love them. That's why I'm with manatees in Blue Springs State Park. It's in between Orlando. Oh, I've been there. I canoed with manatees there. Oh, they're right there in the water. No. You're feeding the line, right?
You don't need to touch them. They're right there. I saw an American bittern. I was in a canoe at Blue Springs State Park, an American bittern standing on the back of a manatee. The manatee's munching on some lilies, and the bittern is hunting from the back of a manatee. That's so awesome. When I was there, we found out about this place because we played Daytona, right? And we went to this visitor center, nature center in Daytona, and they had information or pictures of their other nature centers in that county.
I guess it was a state park. It was another state park that had a Durant Pots Inlet thing. And then they had this picture of Blue Stream State Park in Volusia County. And I said to the person at the desk, I was like, what county are we in? And they're like, Volusia. And I was like, well, how far is Blue Stream State Park? They're like, oh, it's not very far at all. It's like half an hour away, whatever. 45 minutes. And I was like, so guys, can we go there more? And they're like, yeah. And they're talking about all the manatees there. And I said, can you swoop with them? And they're like, yeah. And they're like, can you touch them? And they're like, no.
But they can touch you. So you can't touch the manatees, but they can come up to you. Do they? Yeah, they do. You have to get out of their way or the rangers will yell at you. You're not supposed to touch them. And you have to literally dodge a manatee trying to hang out with you. And sadly, you can identify the individual manatees by the scars. These ones weren't too... I saw some of the scars. Yeah, I don't think they get too scarred up compared to the ones in the more estuarine areas. I think these manatees might live their whole lives in the St. John's River system and not really get too many boats like they do in Miami Bay.
All right, guys. So we talked about manatees. We talked about the green sea turtles on opposite sides of the world. We talked about our diamondback terrapins. If you like this episode and you like the podcast, please tell your friends about it. Please rate it on your podcasting platform of choice. Please get in touch with us at urbanwildlifecast at gmail.com. Please hit us up on Twitter at urbanwildlifecast. Find us on Facebook. Tell us what you think of the show. Tell us ideas for programming. Feel free to pitch something where you might record something and send it in. We can't pay you because we have no money.
And we don't make money from this at all because, you know, we haven't figured that out yet. But if you want to share your research project or something cool you see in your neighborhood, we want to put that on the show. So get in touch. And if a bird hits your window and you find the carcass, put it in an individual Ziploc bag with the locality and the date and put it in the freezer and bring it to the Academy of Natural Sciences of Drexel University where the ornithology department will skin your bird and put your name on the tag collected by... Generations from now... Where it will live in perpetuity for scientific research. Researchers will look at that tag as they pull it out of the drawer and be like, who the hell is that? But...
That's great. He brought us a dead bird. I feel bad now. I remember when I lived at 47th and Pine in a high-rise there, I remember seeing a dead, I think it was some kind of dead warbler on the sidewalk outside the apartment building, and I think I fed it to my snakes. So I was like, okay, snake food, sure. Don't do that. Save it for science and feed your snake a startling or something. But thanks a lot for listening, and until next time. Cheers. Adios. All right. Thanks, guys. Who the hell is that? It's the greatest website. It's gone now, I think. CornyManatee.com.