My country is Venezuela, and my name is John Rodriguez. My name is Juan, and I'm in Caracas, in the capital. My name is Carolina Hill. I live near the most important military complex here in Venezuela. Early January 3rd, it was like 1.57 a.m., and I was watching a movie with my sister, and everything went completely dark. And five seconds later, we heard the first explosion.
I ran through the window to take a look at what was going on. My hands were shaking. I could only see the light of the moon. And we could hear the airplanes and we could hear the helicopters, but we couldn't see them. And the walls of my building and the windows were shaking. I thought, now the Ringoes are here. They are attacking Caracas.
Everybody in the city heard the noises. I think we were nervous, but at the same time excited because we thought they were overthrowing the government. They were freeing us from the dictatorship. My girlfriend and I were crying and screaming. I called my mom. I called my brothers. I called all my family. We were waiting for that for years. When Donald Trump put up the picture with Maduro captured, I am so happy in that moment. Oh my God, man. Honestly, I cried for that picture. It's finished that. This hell.
This felt like a real victory, like someone in this government that has done so much damage to my country is going to finally face real justice. After this attack, we were like, okay, they did it, but what's the meaning of that? What will come for us? I mean, what's the next step? Because, okay, they took Maduro out, but we have Belsi, we have Padrino Lopez, we have Jorge Rodriguez. I mean, they are still here. Other people, government is free. I am confused. The future in Venezuela really, really is...
From the New York Times, I'm Natalie Kittreweff. This is The Daily. On Monday, as Nicolas Maduro and his wife Celia pleaded not guilty in a Manhattan courtroom, the nearly 30 million people of Venezuela struggled to absorb the reality of a post-Maduro era. An era in which the United States appears to be the dominant force reshaping their once firmly anti-American government.
Today, my colleague Anatoly Kermanayev explains why President Trump chose to back a Maduro loyalist to run the country and what Venezuelans think of it all. It's Tuesday, January 6th. Hi, Anatoly. Welcome. It's good to have you here. Thanks for having me, Natalie.
So in the last couple of days, we at the show have talked about how this operation to capture Nicolas Maduro went down. We've talked about the legality of it. What we haven't talked about as much is who is running Venezuela right now and how is all of that going to play out? Because that feels very uncertain in this moment. You've been in the country as this all has been going on through the mission itself. You're in Caracas right now. So just to start, how does it feel there?
It feels surreal. The city is still coming out of Christmas holidays. It's a metropolis of more than 4 million people and it's full of lights and decorations. And I was driving through the city last night and the city was completely deserted. There was not a single soul on the streets. No sounds to be made. It felt like I was in a zombie movie. And I think it just sums up this atmosphere of expectation, of fear, of concern. It's just tense. We have not seen mass signs of jubilation at the fall of Nicolas Maduro. At the same time, we have not seen any genuine mass outpourings of grieving for him and his wife. And this atmosphere of quiet tension is taking place.
amid growing signs of repression, of people being detained, of journalists being harassed, which shows to me that even though this government has a new face, the brutal repressive apparatus that has kept it in power for decades remains in place and is cracking down again. It sounds like everyone in Venezuela is just kind of waiting with bated breath for what's to come. So let's get into that. And my first question is, is what we're seeing actually regime change? Because now that the dust has settled a little bit, it seems as though the regime is actually still in power in Venezuela. That's right, Natalie. The regime...
is in place. The people who are no longer here is Maduro and his wife. And around 80 people have died between his Cuban bodyguards and Venezuelan civilians, Venezuelan security service members. But beyond that, we have seen the same cast of characters. Most of his inner circle is intact. It is in power and is led by Delce Rodriguez, known universally as Delce, who was Maduro's vice president, who was the first in line to replace him under any circumstances. So the same characters are ruling the country.
OK, so Delce Rodriguez, the vice president now in power, is someone that Trump has endorsed. The administration says they're going to be working directly with her. And I want to talk about why. Why her? Because honestly, when you and I have talked about this, the most obvious choice for who was going to work with the Trump administration in the event that Maduro was no longer in power was someone else. It was Maria Karina Machado, this famous opposition leader. So explain for me, Anatoly, why it's not Machado and why it's Delce instead. But short answer is continuity. Trump.
wanted to stop the flood of drugs from Venezuela. He wanted to stop migrants, but above all, he made it very clear he wanted Venezuelan oil. And Nelson Rodriguez has been able to sell herself as a reliable guardian of Venezuela's oil industry, as a person who can manage Venezuela's resources and protect foreign interests, which in this case will be American investor interests. And Machado was not able to sell herself as that figure? She was not. And this is perhaps the biggest surprise of this theme. My shadow is by far the most popular politician in the country. She has led an election campaign in 2024 that has led more than 70% of Venezuelans to vote for the opposition. And she has won the Nobel Peace Prize for her efforts. She has global recognitions and global respect. And she comes with impeccable, conservative.
credentials. She's a daughter of a wealthy industrialist. She has an impeccable record of supporting free markets, of supporting personal freedom, supporting Christian faith, all values at the heart of traditional Republican agenda. But she's a product of a different period of American politics. And Machado's greatest mistake was not being able to adapt to the transformation that Trump has brought to the American right. What do you mean by that exactly? Well, the adjective defines...
Machado, more than anything else, is consistency. She has been extremely consistent in her belief, she has been extremely consistent in her political agenda, and this consistency is what brought her to the cost of gaining power in Venezuela during the last elections. This is the reasons why she has galvanized Venezuela populations, because people believed in her, they believed in her values, they believed in what she stood for, and that she would defend them, that she would not negotiate with Maduro, that she would not sell them out. This consistency was at its core. But in the current transactional...
Washington of today, this has become a liability. She has not been able to adjust to a very transactional approach to politics that we see in Washington, a ideologically agnostic approach to Washington where beliefs and policies are ditched and sacrificed and adjusted on a daily basis to suit the whims of people taking power. And this has gradually led her to lose allies and make a grown number of enemies in the Trump administration, which eventually has contributed to her being sidelined at these crucial moments in Venezuelan history. Okay, can you go a little deeper there? Like, give me examples of how she wasn't able to adjust.
So, for example, when Trump returns to power, his initial focus on Venezuela is getting Americans detained there out of jail and back into the United States. And he sends his envoy. He sends a man called Richard Grenell, a businessman and former ambassador to Germany, to Caracas, to negotiate the deal. And then Grenell arrives in Caracas. He reaches out to Machado because she's the representative of Venezuela in a position. She's seen at the time as representative of American interests. And he starts a dialogue. He starts a relationship that very quickly goes off the rails because getting Americans out means talking to Maduro's government, means negotiating. Negotiating is an...
anathema for Maria Karina Machado. She has argued for decades that freedom is not negotiable, that democracy is not negotiable, that there can be no compromises. And that set the stage for a train wreck between Richard Grenell and Maria Karina Machado, a clash that has repeated itself over and over throughout the Trump administration as she lost national allies and created new enemies. You're saying basically Machado is such a purist that she's totally opposed to any notion of negotiating with Maduro. And this alienated Trump's lead negotiator in Venezuela, who's there to try to get a deal.
He was there to try to get a deal, and he's there to get economic deals. He started negotiating a deal with Maduro's officials that would see Maduro hand over Venezuelan resources in return for him staying in power, at least for the time being. Again, this goes completely against everything that Machado has stood for. And over time, in the months since the election, as Venezuelan government stepped up with repression, Machado's movement became increasingly marginalized in Venezuelan political life. They increasingly had to flee in exile. Machado herself had to go into hiding. They have gradually lost touch with what is happening on the streets in Venezuela.
So it sounds like they start to sour on her in part because they don't believe she's giving valuable intel. And that's... Despite the fact that, as we know, in recent months, Machado was really doing everything she could to kind of ingratiate herself with the Trump administration as they began to dial up the pressure on Maduro. She even dedicated her Nobel Peace Prize to Trump. I guess all that wasn't enough. All that wasn't enough. And to me, there's a certain tragic element to this because this is a politician with impeccable moral credentials. Machado has built a presidential campaign on the focus on Venezuelan migrants, of reuniting Venezuelan families, of returning the millions of Venezuelans that have fled the country from Maduro, bringing them back home. And since Trump...
to power, she has stopped talking about Muslim migrants because these are the people that Trump was arresting, Trump was deporting, Trump was jailing in foreign jails where they were tortured. And Machado stayed silent. As flights into the country were gradually cancelled under American pressure, she stayed silent. As inflation rose under tightening American sanctions, complicating people's daily life, she has stayed silent. This has caused the political capital inside the country. She has sacrificed a lot of political goodwill that she has built inside Venezuela to please this one man. She has gone out of her way to praise him. She has published op-eds saying that Trump is the greatest defender of freedom in the Western Hemisphere. It was very clear to everyone observing Venezuela that Machado is speaking to the audience of one, and her entire strategy has been on bringing Trump to her side. And so far, she has failed. You know, Trump said in this big press conference he gave over the weekend that Machado just didn't have the support in Venezuela. So...
Was that actually true, based on what you just said? Credible polling in Venezuela is very limited, but the evidence we have shows that her popular support has been gradually, very slowly, sipping away from a very high point. Crucially for Trump, when he says that she doesn't have the respect, he is talking about respect to the people that would make it possible for her to govern. And Machado's inflexibility and focus on pressure rather than negotiation has meant that she has lost the support of Venezuela's economic elites that have traditionally supported their position. Venezuela has for decades been...
informally governed by groups of rich businessmen who have among themselves divided the southern economy. It was an old boys club for many decades. And these people had a natural repulsion to Chavismo and everything that stood for the people from the slums coming in, taking power and telling them what to do. But as time went on, things began to change. More and more captains of the southern industry realized that if they wanted to continue working in Venezuela, they had to come to an understanding of the government. They had to live with the government. And Machado's message is overhauling this completely, scrapping this whole system, is starting from scratch.
Business wants stability and they turn against Machado's message of radical change. While at the same time, she has not been able to gain the support of the armed forces that she herself has constantly said are crucial to removing Maduro. She has, again, to please Trump, she has gone out of the way to mimic his talking point that the Venezuelan government is a narco-cartel. She has mimicked his language that Maduro is flooding the United States with drugs and criminals. And this has meant that for the officers watching her speeches, for the members of the government, for the people that actually make the state sick and hold the guns, that she was painting them as members of the narco cartel, as part of a problem, as people that need to be eliminated from Venezuela's public life. And the dissonance between her calls for the armed forces and government employees to rise up against Maduro and the way she has branded them as members of the narco cartel ended up spelling her political downfall inside the Venezuelan political system.
So ironically, in order to align herself with Trump, Machado starts saying these things that actually alienate all these elites within Venezuela that she actually needs to have on board in order to persuade the Trump administration that she's a viable candidate to run the country. Is that right? That's right. That's exactly what happened. These are people that have been in charge for a very long time. And the Trump administration became convinced that to get the country running quickly, to keep it stable, to keep it from collapsing and sending hundreds of thousands of migrants to its borders, to keep the oil flowing to the United States, to boost that flow of oil, they needed to work for people who were already in charge.
And that's why we picked Delcy over Maria Karina Machado. This is the great irony of the current political drama, that Delcy, despite of her Marxist roots, despite being the handpicked protege of a person labeled as a narco-terrorist by the United States, despite playing a crucial part in a repressive machine, the White House has decided that she is the most likely candidate among the available options to bring Venezuela into the American sphere of influence. We'll be right back. This is how the future of agreements is being crafted now. Harvey. Learn more at Harvey.ai.
Harvey does not provide legal advice. Users should always independently review and verify any output from Harvey. Hey, it's Anna Martin from the New York Times. Wherever you get your podcasts. You've heard that line before, right? Wherever you get your podcasts. Wherever you get your podcasts. Of course you have. But what if I told you you never have to hear that line ever again?
You know what? You caught me. I actually can't tell you that. But I can tell you somewhere I think you might want to go. It's the Shows tab in the New York Times app. You can find full episodes of The Ezra Klein Show, The Interview, Modern Love, The Daily, new and classic episodes from Serial, and so much more. So much to listen to and watch. I think that's really special. I did this interview once on Modern Love with the actor Andrew Garfield. He was reading an essay and suddenly he was moved to tears. And when you watch the video, you feel like a part of it. The Shows tab. Find it wherever you get your... Just kidding. It's in the New York Times app. Explore the Shows tab and follow a show today.
OK, let's talk about Venezuela's new leader, who, as you said, everyone calls Delcy. She sounds like an unlikely choice for the Trump administration in many ways to support. Explain who she is and what the Trump administration sees in her. First and foremost, they see Delcy as a capable economic manager. And that reputation that she has earned has come at the end of a very unexpected journey.
She's the daughter of a Marxist guerrilla who was tortured by the security forces of the previous pro-American governments during the Cold War. So she comes from a background of impeccable socialist credentials, but they also come from money. And she enjoyed quite a privileged upbringing. She went to university in France, and she joined the government, the current regime, under the wings of her older brother, going up in the ranks of the Chavismo government. And that rise really accelerated around 2019. Then Venezuela was facing tremendous economic pressure from the United States that had just sanctioned its oil industry.
Revenues have collapsed. The Maduro government has struggled to just keep the lights on in the country. And Maduro turns to Delce and basically tells her to fix it. And what does she do? Does she fix it? She completely re-engineers the Venezuelan economy. She and a group of technocrats allied to her began a process that, in a very short period, discarded the socialist tropes that the government had based its legitimacy on for many years. Price controls, currency controls, focus on the needs of the Venezuelan poor, and turned it into a free-for-all market economy where money ruled and investment was the only merit.
It's so interesting that the daughter of a Marxist became this trusted steward of something approaching capitalist reform. In many ways, Venezuela is an extremely corrupt country, and it is as corrupt today as it was under the nominally socialist principles. But in terms of actual policies, the LC has turned Venezuela into a radically capitalist society that there's practically no regulation, that there are practically no rules, that money is the only variable that governs society and governs the interaction between the states and its citizens. But did it work, though? Did it stabilize the economy, which is what Maduro was originally asking for? It did work and led to a period of moderate growth. Starting in 2021, the inflation subsided. People started to open up businesses. People started to travel more. The oil production began to gradually edge up. And remember, Natalie, that this is all started from a very low base. We're not talking about Dubai or Latin America, but we're talking about a country that had suffered a tremendous economic collapse where millions have fled, where people have suffered from malnutrition, and it gave them a modicum of economic stability.
Okay, so it sounds like the reforms that Delcy helped engineer, they didn't, you know, bring wealth back en masse to Venezuelans, but they did right the economic ship. They helped stanch the bleeding. Did that do anything to help the regime's standing with Venezuelans? I mean, obviously, they still voted for the opposition in the last election, so I would imagine the answer is no, right? The answer is no, and the elections of 2024 have proven that the government had gone out of its way to sell itself to Venezuelan as we are stability. The opposition is chaos. Stick with us. You can live with us. You can breathe with us. And still, more than 70% of Venezuelans, including massive proportions of public sector workers and the poor, voted for the opposition, voted for the candidate of Maria Carina Machado, showing just the scale of exhaustion and repulsion that this population has against President Maduro.
And what about the elites that we talked about earlier? How do they see Delcy in all of this? Delcy's reforms gave them space to grow, gave them space to invest. Again, not talking about massive investments. We're not talking about tremendous growth. We're talking about a climate where people that have money can start making more money.
It's really interesting, right? Because Machado in many ways is a more natural ally of theirs too, right? She comes from this family they probably know, this industrialist. She has these impeccable credentials as a free market capitalist. And yet here she's the one with the broad-based popular support who's lost the support of these elites. While Delcy doesn't have that popular support, it sounds like, but she has one over this group of business titans that is still incredibly influential in this country.
This is a fundamental paradox, Natalie. I could not have summarized it better. And I think only just goes to show that economic freedoms do not always correlate with political freedoms. And the reality is that for Trump, what matters to him is the deals and the investments of the elites. And that has led him to gradually ally with Delcy, the self-styled technocrat who would bring him Venezuelan riches over Marie Curie Machado, who was promising political liberation, but a very volatile and unstable economic environment. Okay, so now I think I get why Delcy is preferable to Machado in the eyes of Trump.
What I still don't understand, though, is why Delcy is preferable to Maduro. Because you've told us, Anatoly, the few times that you've come on to talk about this, that Maduro was actually happy to let the U.S. into Venezuela's oil fields, to give up those natural resources as part of a potential deal with Trump. Why did Trump reject that, only to go for what sounds like a very similar deal with Delcy? I don't think we have perfect clarity to that question at the moment, Natalie. My hunch is that the campaign against Maduro, the campaign to brand them a narco-terrorist, and the cartel chief who's at war with the United States has gone simply too far for...
Trump to tolerate him and make a deal with him. I remember that while oil is the driving force of Trump's policy towards Minnesota, it's not the only one. And there are advisors within his administration, there are people in his administration that are pushing towards our goals. There's Stephen Miller with his focus on migration and illegal drugs. There's Secretary of State Marco Rubio, who has been a declared anti-communist warrior. These people have been sworn enemies of Maduro. And as Maduro repeatedly rebuffs Trump administration's attempts to provide him a soft lensing, to provide him a golden parachute, Trump's position hardens.
By December, his patience finally snaps. Maduro's response to increasingly explicit ultimatums for America was to present himself as a carefree partier. He constantly dances on television. He sings, no crazy war. You know, he's a good dancer. He puts out the moves and he does on a regular basis. And at some point, Trump snaps.
Wait, are you saying, Anatoly, that Maduro dancing on national television is an actual factor here in everything that ends up happening? My understanding, it was the straw that broke the camel's back. Meaning what exactly? That Trump saw Maduro dancing and said, this guy's not taking me seriously? Or what? Meaning that Trump saw the ongoing dancing as a humiliation, as Maduro calling Trump's bluff, as Maduro telling Trump, I'm here and I'm here for as long as I want to be. And Trump could not tolerate what he saw as a personal affront. Wow. We are truly living in wild times.
Remember, naturally, history is often made by seemingly sort of small, banal circumstances, right? It's an accumulation of major factors, major forces like oil, migration, drugs. But, you know, it can be something as sort of small as a little techno dance on a public stage that can tilt the scares towards a momentous policy decision that will change the history of Western Hemisphere, perhaps forever. OK, we'll have plenty of time to talk about that future. But for now, the Trump administration is counting on Delcy. And this is someone who, in the last few days, has come out very strongly against them.
It's worth saying. She said Maduro is the only president of Venezuela. She refers to herself as the vice president. And I'm wondering what we should make of that. I know that there are a lot of people from the regime that are still in power in the country. And I wonder if this is her playing to them, to that domestic audience. She has to appease them, right?
That's right. Remember that the attack was a major humiliation to the armed forces and security officials that formed the core of Maduro's regime. It was an operation that caused the life of 80 people, causing major destructions in capital Caracas. Delce could not just sort of wave this off and open her arms to Americans. You know, she has to satisfy the domestic audience. She has to show to the ruling party's faithful, who are not numerous in numbers, but who hold a lot of guns, that she's not an American pawn, that she's someone who will defend the country's sovereignty, someone who will defend the country's standing. While at the same time, she has to...
satisfy American demands. You know, the Trump administration and his officials have repeatedly stated that Delce must do their bidding or else she will face the same fate as Maduro. So she's trying to play for both audiences. And as you said, she started off making very aggressive remarks towards America, but just in a matter of... days, in a matter of hours, her position has softened. She has issued a statement calling for corporations with the United States, for peaceful coexistence, for working together, for joint business ventures. And just let it sink for you, Natalie. This is a statement towards the government that has just blown up your capital and killed 80 people living in the capital. And you are basically opening your arms to their investments and to bilateral relations. No, it's totally remarkable. And it makes me want to ask you about what this means for the Chavista movement that has been in power now for almost three decades in Venezuela.
This is a movement that has staked its legacy on being an anti-American bulwark. What happens to that legacy if Delcy follows through and really does become a willing partner of the Trump administration? To me, Natalie, the events of the past few days exposed the hollowness of the nationalist rhetoric behind the Chavismo movement. At the time when the country came into the attack, no one was prepared to defend President Maduro. There was no notable resistance from the armed forces. And to me, this peels another layer of mysticism and ideology.
from the movements. But over the years, over the decades, this movement has gradually lost the pillars of its ideology. First, it lost the populist supports. Then it lost the socialist credentials. Now it loses nationalism. And what is left, Natalie? Survival. Survival is the core aspect of Chavismo movements. And the senior officials who have been at Maduro's side for years and have now closing ranks behind L.C. are focused on survival at any cost.
And Atoli, I want to end by just asking how the Venezuelans you're talking to are perceiving all this, how they're feeling right now. I have to imagine that the many people who voted against Maduro are happy that he's gone on the one hand. And yet the regime that he led is still very much there. And not only that, now there's also this added element of Trump having a potentially very heavy hand in their country. So how is that playing with people? This is a country that has gotten used to disappointments.
that has gotten used to tragedy. In the years that I have lived here, I have experienced time and again a moment of extreme exaltation when it appeared that freedom and democracy were just within grasp. You know, I've witnessed millions of people come out on the streets in popular protest against the government. And every time that hope, that democracy, that freedom was snatched from under their nose. This is a country that has been burned many times and where people have learned to temper their expectations. And I think most people in Venezuela, when they watch Chelsea being sworn in as the country's interim president, this is not the outcome they would have hoped for. This is not the outcome they would have chosen. This is an outcome, but it's not just, but it's not fair, but it's an outcome that just might make their difficult life just a little bit easier. Well, Anatoly, I hope you get some rest in the coming days, and thank you so much. Thanks for having me.
On Monday, in her first interview since the capture of Maduro, Maria Carina Machado told Fox's Sean Hannity that she hadn't spoken with President Trump since the U.S. deposed the Venezuelan leader. But I do want to say today, on behalf of the Venezuelan people, how grateful we are for his courage... She also thanked Trump for the, quote, courageous actions that led to Maduro's removal. It's a milestone, and it's not only huge for the Venezuelan people and our future, I think it's a huge step for humanity, for freedom and human dignity. We'll be right back.
Hi, this is Carolyn Ryan, managing editor of The New York Times. At The Times, we strive to help everyone stay informed. And at this critical moment, we're making all of our election coverage free in our app. This election has an expansive battleground map. States that hadn't been in play before are suddenly competitive. We have more than 100 reporters out there talking to voters. I wonder if I can just call Will to get the actual numbers.
Hey, how are you? How many voter interviews do you think we've done? Our plan is to talk to 30,000 voters this year. Okay, you're awesome. Thank you very much. Thank you. Don't you love the New York Times? On election night, we are the place to go for race results. Our maps are updated minute by minute. Our data team can show you what votes have come in, what votes are yet to be counted, and how that might affect the overall results. Come experience all of our election coverage for free right now in the New York Times app.
Here's what else you need to know today. On Monday, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth said the military had begun administrative actions against Mark Kelly, the Democratic senator from Arizona, a move that could end up reducing Kelly's rank and the military pension he receives as a retired Navy captain. The review stems from a video that Kelly and five other Democratic lawmakers released in November that reminded service members they were obligated to refuse illegal orders. Hegseth called the video seditious and called Kelly reckless for trying to undermine discipline in the ranks. Kelly and his lawyers have argued the senator was simply articulating a fundamental principle of military law. They've also pointed out that Hegseth himself has made similar comments in the past. Today's episode was produced by Olivia Knapp, Rob Zipko, Rochelle Bonja, and Claire Tennesketter, with help from Carlos Prieto. It was edited by Paige Cowett and Liz O'Balen. Contains music by Marion Lozano, Pat McCusker, and Rowan Nemisto. And was engineered by Chris Wood. Special thanks to Isayen Herrera, Annie Correal, Maria Victoria Fermin, and Adriana Fernandez.
That's it for The Daily. I'm Natalie Kittroweth. See you tomorrow.