Skip to content
Victim. Criminal. The Myth Of Difference. episode artwork

Jul 15, 2020 24 min

Victim. Criminal. The Myth Of Difference.

from Unprisoned: Stories From The System

Victim/Criminal tells the story of Hakeem Carter, who was brutally attacked while walking home from work one night.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Victim. Criminal. The Myth Of Difference.

0:00 24:40
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

I'm not a criminal. Not a criminal. I'm black. Yes.

I'm tatted. Yes. Maybe have the image of a thug? Yes, but you don't know me.

Hakeem Carter was charged with a misdemeanor crime and spent around two years working his way through the court system. But that's not where this story begins. In order to understand how the system saw Hakeem as a criminal, we need to start a few years before that, on the night Hakeem was a victim. This is imprisoned by me, Abrams.

This is about three in the morning, three thirty, four in the morning. I worked with 12 hours shift. That catch me on karaoke on Berryman. It was my second day of training.

I was a houseman, clean up crew, while everybody else bought in, so I just came through, made sure the folks clean for us while everybody's doing it. It was a real party environment. Everybody could move, I was saying they're doing karaoke, so it was pretty cool, and then we can get involved in it. So it was fun.

I was walking home because I didn't have no transportation at that time. I had just found employment, and I was excited because I actually get to start making my money tomorrow when I come to work. Tomorrow never came. I was 23.

I almost didn't love to see my 24th birthday. I just wanted to get home. I had just texted my mom was like, if you cook, make me a plate, and leave it on the stove. She was like, okay, so I knew she was up.

From that point, I noticed a white truck. I don't know who the truck is. I'm trying to get home. It's four in the morning.

He drove past me. He was going to opposite directions. By the time I had off the cater into Franklin, the truck was coming up again. It was on the corner of the church.

That's the church right on the corner. I guess they had the high beams on, so I couldn't really look and see what type of truck it was. The next thing I knew I had a man running towards me with a shotgun. I couldn't think of nothing.

I was in complete shock. He ran towards me. He drew the gun. I don't know where the shotgun came from.

I guess he drew it out his pants. He ran towards me. He grabbed me and was like, don't go nowhere. You coming with us?

I thought I was going to be kidding now. It was three guys. I thought he was going to throw me in the truck. But they took me on the side of the street with the church.

It went in my pockets, basically interrogated me. Like it was weird. Like where I was coming from. Did I have kids?

I'm doing out on how old am I? It was just random questions that I figured was just to throw my attention off of what was going on. The shotgun, it was pointed down at the time. I'm not even looking because it's three guns.

One had a shotgun, one had a revolver and a pistol. So it really didn't matter where I looked. If I turned my head anybody could have shot me. He was like, you don't have nothing.

I said I don't have nothing for ya. I don't have nothing for ya. After that boom, out of nowhere. Boom.

I thought I was dead. I never was shot before. And he hit me in my stomach. I had an orange polo shirt on.

My work shirt. Like Dickies. It's on white y'all and fives. My girlfriend had bought me for valentimes.

When I woke up and looked down, my orange shirt was completely red. Like I bought it that color. My dickies was soaked with blood to her as the dickie patch on my pants was just red. My Jordan's was just covered in blood.

I'm saying to myself like man, he shot me. He shot me. I was conscious for every shot after that down to the one in my face. The second shot he hit me in my hip.

Cause it felt like a brick in my leg. I think he's done. I look up. I'm looking at him, but he's not looking at me.

He can't look at what he's doing. So I look at him and he's still aiming at gun. He shot again. My right arm completely dropped.

I can't even use this on the cover of my face. By the time I turned my head the second time he had an explode at my face and blood just was pouring on my face. All I can do is roll over and pray. I was just was there.

Bleakin. By the time I finished praying, a guy came out of nowhere. I'm hearing him. Like I'm blanking in and out cause I'm losing blood.

I'm dying at this point. Just like I'm a doctor. I live down the street. I heard it.

So Emily and I were sleeping and you know just heard the gunshots very loud. And I remember the first thing I did was just like we both dropped on the floor. I wasn't sure what exactly was happening. And then when it stopped Emily had her call 911 and then I went to our front window to just see what was out there.

My name is Jerick Pytel. I'm an addiction medicine and primary care doctor. In 2014 I was a medical student at LSU Health Sciences Center in New Orleans. That intersection is pretty broad.

It's three streets coming together. There was a street light. It was relatively well lit and he was just laying on the corner. And nobody was out.

I mean he was completely alone. It was eerie how just dead the block was. There was nothing there. You just kind of see him in the middle of the street.

On his back moving but not really like moving around. Just kind of rocking. So I put on some clothes and gin shorts, t-shirt, my tennis shoes. And as I was coming towards him I was just saying like it's okay.

I'm like here to help. And just to make sure I didn't start a limb. And at that point just kind of went into medical mode. And by the time I was a fourth year medical student and had seen lots of gunshot wounds relatively lots more than anybody should.

You know the face was the thing that kind of just sticks out to me because I think it was the most obvious wound. You know I was asking him like hey what's your name and kind of having a hard time understanding. I'm so I understood that there was probably some trauma. You could just kind of see a bloody mess on his face.

At that point Emily had stuck her head out of the door and I said okay bring a bunch of towels. One of my other neighbors had come out at that point as well and started to help. You know I just remember rolling him over trying to look at his back to see if he was any bullet wounds there. If somebody's gonna die it's because they're going to bleed out and the only thing that you need to do until they get to a trauma center and a surgeon has stopped the bleeding.

So I was trying to figure out where the most blood was coming from and push and whole pressure. Once the EMS came in very professionally I took over and after that I went back and washed on a clothes. You know washed my hands. I think we ended up just throwing away all our towels and then just try to go to sleep I think for an hour or two and then I had to get up and go to work the next day.

I remember I reached out to one of my professors at LSU because you know I'm just curious to see if he had done well and they said he had. So I felt relieved to hear that he had survived days afterwards. It was really just kind of relief that he was okay processing this event and then just kind of just feeling sad that these things happened to kids walking in the street. It's sad that this is kind of the common place occurrence in the city.

A lot of people think I'm crazy. A lot of people look at me as psychotic. A lot of people look at me as troubled. But it's because they don't understand why I come from you would never understand how they feel until it is done.

Like every time I look in the mirror he shot me. I take a bath. He shot me. I go use a bath.

He shot me. I have a scar everywhere I'm about it. People were coming to the supermarket not knowing that I'm the department manager and they'll go asking everybody else for something that because they didn't want to look in my face. I was missing 19.

I was called the hunch pack of Notre Dame at this time. Snagger to ball mouth. I had people introducing me as they partnered. They got shot up.

It's not cute. Like the type of stripes or credibility you're expecting from this. People figure you only can get PTSD if you serve in the war. If you was in the military.

And that's not true. You know the same thing you experienced in the wars what we experienced and now just in our community alone. My name is Karen called up and I'm a king's mother. I came to my oldest son.

He'd be 29 years old. Even from a kid he never hung in the street. He paid basketball. Do a game.

He's back home. He's back in the drum. Back on the computer. I always was inside.

People always knew where I was at. Went to work came home. Had limited friends. I played the game.

Stood inside. Making beats or rapping. But his real joy was just being helped with his nephew. I really was a good kid.

After his shooting it took a long time for him to be around crowds and even go to the store. So that's what made him get a gun. But he got it the legal way. He didn't buy nothing off the street.

He went to the gun store. Made sure they did the background check. So he had people with everything. He didn't have it for trouble.

He had it for protection and his protection that he needs. I got that gun soon as I was able to walk on my feet again. Just that quick. I had bought one and I had bought two.

Then I had about three and I actually used to watch TV with a Glock 21 right here and a Glock 17 right here. And I used to tell my mom you will probably want to tell anybody who come here to call before he come here. The only person who wanted to study was my mom. My mom did not complain about those guns being right here.

And it is just from one mistake. Instead of him having to have now on a holster exposed he had it in his pocket. And that's where the night now began. The incident or the arrest occurred on May 20, 2017 at 2 in the morning.

My name is Eliza Gottfried. I'm an attorney at the Orleans Public Defender's Office and I represented Hakim Carter in 2017. The officers got an alert I think over the radio that there had been a shooting somewhere in the area. And the only description given was a black male in a black t-shirt and black pants.

And I see Hakim walking with his friend. And he fits this description. It's extremely vague description. But his friend was wearing all white.

And the description wasn't too men walking. It wasn't even walking. It was one person running. And he's had nothing to do with the shooting.

But basically they approach him. Search him and they find a gun. And he has a gun and while it's legal to carry a gun if you're going to conceal it under your shirt, you have to have a concealed carry permit. Which he didn't have.

And he had it in his waistband and his shirt was over it. So the fact that it was covered and even had a concealed carry permit was the issue. First of all he had no prior. He's never been in trouble.

The whole reason he carries a gun, I mean the reason why most people want to own guns is for protection And of all people to want to have protection Hakim wants him with anyway because he was a victim of such a violent crime. Whatever you find on the legal side of it, in reality he was at the wrong place at the wrong time. He happens to be a black person. A black man at the wrong place at the wrong time.

He wasn't doing anything wrong. And if you've been following the law and had his gun out in the open, I just feel like there's also the potential for a bad interaction with police or with others. Obviously under the law everybody talks about your innocent, ill-proven guilty. It really doesn't work that way.

It's just an uphill battle from the beginning. In the courthouse but also in the realm of public opinion. As soon as those articles come out with people's mugshots posted or as soon as someone is arrested and shackled and brought an orange jumpsuit and their entire worth and their case and their monetary amount is set for them within a minute. And then you're kind of thrust into the system where especially for someone like Hakim where he I'm sure was like why is this even happening to me?

Why didn't do anything wrong? And he really didn't. I mean he was missing paperwork. He's not struggling with being shot out.

He didn't learn to cope with it. He looked at himself as a survivor for that. But what plays the big part is the legal system, it's the law. It's what's went on the criminal part, going to trial.

That's the bigger thing. That's what triggers everything off. That's what triggers PTSD. That's what triggers the depression.

That's what he's struggling with. He's don't like being a statistic. Like they look at him as being another black man on the streets that just don't want nothing in life. Basically the judge was asking me like why did I happen here to carry fire on?

And I was explaining to him a few years ago that I was shot multiple times. And he did find that illogical enough reason for me to have a fire on. He asked me once again, why do you feel you need to have a fire on? At this time I feel like he's torn with me because I just explained to you in detail a real life situation.

And from now he basically was like well I'm going to find you guilty because you carrying a fire on another innocent black chug in the dead on the streets from trying to take it from you. So you just feel like oh he got arrested for a gun. He's a criminal. Plus the color that I am is like I'm the perfect target to make a criminal.

This going back and forth back and forth back and forth with the court system and everything that I have took him a toll with my anxiety level. When he used to have to go to court I literally got sick of the stomach. But sometimes I had to even miss it because I was just afraid once he got in there it was going to lock him up again. And that's a hard pill to swallow not just for a young black mother but quite sure for all mothers.

I always prayed and I always told my kids that's not worse than I am to see your shaft and handcuffs to other people like animals. But they feel the real life when stuff happens and you do stuff in the court system you're not just told him him. I was just talking to me as a mother as a parent because at the end of the day I'm the only person he had. So when you arrest him that's funds I really can't afford.

I had to pay bail money I had to pay fines and fees he had to do hundreds of hours of community service. And all this first time of it he lost a couple of jobs due to this and it wasn't his fault. And that player told and it don't just pay a toll on him. It pays a toll on me for the simple fact I get one income a month.

And we worked together as a team. And then it's going to go away very quickly. You throw a picture on your internet hashtag rest in peace. That's a wrap.

What you survivors people don't really care about that. They don't really worry about somebody who survives the situation. They don't check on you. If I can see you and you walking up the street you're okay with me.

But they don't think about the mental impact that I did with mental trauma. None of the physical is wrong with me. I didn't stress due to this. I didn't suffer with depression due to this.

You know my anxiety level then went to the roof. I had to go be counseling for my own self. Due to this one incident because y'all refused to admit y'all made a mistake. From a legal perspective I thought we had a pretty good case that we could argue that they had no probable cause to stop him.

If you have reasonable suspicion to believe someone has committed is committing or will commit a crime. You can stop them and kind of investigate more. We weren't arguing that the cops were necessarily lying or anything like that or that. Hacking didn't have a gun on him.

The facts were not going to be. It was why they had a reason to stop him in the first place. And unfortunately we lost that argument. Who's labeled a victim and who's labeled a defendant.

I mean his story and many other stories is that the lines are very blurred I think. It's rarely clear cut. I just think the majority of our clients who have been labeled criminals from the moment of their arrest whether or not they've been convicted or not. They always have reasons for why they're in the situation they're in.

And often they have been victimized themselves and it just happened that in this certain circumstance when we meet them they're the criminal. And if things had turned out a little differently they might not have been. He was carrying this gun because he was brutally assaulted and I wish I could have won for him. After that happened they took his gun.

He wouldn't go out. He wouldn't go outside. He wouldn't go nowhere. Now I don't regret him getting a gun.

And I'm beyond this. When all is over I expect him to go get another one. Because he's not just protecting himself. He's protecting me.

He's protecting the household. He's the man of the house. He's protecting his nieces and his nephews. And it's dangerous but like he's gonna make sure he has his paperwork as he did before and he's gonna have a consent to carry it.

Like he should have had. I go to church every Wednesday and Sunday. I pray constantly. I walk the house with sage.

Just an ongoing prep battle. I wish I could close my eyes and just sit my heels three times. And everything be over clear and we can just start over again. But I know that's just a dream.

And it's gonna constantly go on. It's hard. It's very hard. I don't think people really understand how hard it is.

Trying to keep your composure. That's a long term scar. The New Orleans Police Department never caught the people who assaulted Hakim. Hakim was never charged in the shooting that police say gave them cause to stop him, frisk him, and charge him for carrying a concealed weapon.

After Hakim completed 20 mandated anger management counseling sessions and 50 hours of community service for this gun conviction, his judge closed the case. A year later when Hakim tried to get his gun back, he was denied. Because Hakim now has a criminal record, he's had trouble finding work. But before the pandemic, Hakim did find an employer willing to take a chance on him.

He was working retail in a clothing store. A huge thanks to imprisoned editor Katie Wreckdall, who's reporting on Hakim Carter made this story possible. Vicki Merrick also edits the show. Special thanks to Johanna Zorn.

All the music in this episode, including our theme music, is by Gradeshots. Thanks to the Robert Rauschenberg Foundation for supporting season two of Unprisoned. Learn more about the show at Unprisoned.org or www.wono.org, where you can see Merle Cooper's beautiful illustration for this episode. If you haven't already, subscribe to the Unprisoned podcast.

And please, write us a review. It helps other people find the show. I'm Yvee Abrams. This is Unprisoned.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Unprisoned: Stories From The System?

This episode is 24 minutes long.

When was this Unprisoned: Stories From The System episode published?

This episode was published on July 15, 2020.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Unprisoned: Stories From The System episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.