Was SEO Content Ever Good? JH Scherck on the AI Slop Debate

Ross Hudgens sits down with JH Scherck, founder of Growth Plays, for a refreshingly contrarian take on AI content. JH argues that with the right context and execution, AI already gets you 85–90% of the way to a strong B2B article, and that the real skill in 2026 is being the person who can take a B+ draft to an A+.  Along the way he flips the industry's favorite critique on its head: was SEO content *ever* good? He makes the case that the bar was always low, and that it took removing humans from the equation for anyone to start caring about sentence construction and quality at all.  Ross and JH also dig into where AI content genuinely works (dev tools, technical docs, location pages) versus where it falls flat, the telltale "it's 3 a.m. and your microservices are failing" intro pattern, why plugging more data sources into your workflow isn't differentiation, whether people will stop browsing websites and just chat with them, the perils nobody's discussing, how your product's history follows you around in LLMs, and why AI turns C players into more prolific C players rather than A players. Show Notes 0:00 Getting 85% There: Where AI Already Beats Most Writers 4:45 The AI Doer vs. the AI Reviewer 8:48 "Was SEO Content Ever Good?" Rethinking the Slop Debate 12:24 What Actually Differentiates Content Now 16:13 Will People Stop Browsing and Just Chat With Your Site? 21:45 The Perilous Side of AI Content Nobody's Discussing 33:07 Maintenance Mode & Why Your History Follows You in LLMs 39:29 Educating Executives & Avoiding the "Slop Cannon" 48:12 Traffic Recovery, Brand Problems & Qualifying Clients Out 53:34 The Truth About ChatGPT Leads & Aggregate Citation Data Show Links Visit Growth Plays Follow JH on LinkedIn Preorder "Generative Engine Optimization: The Definitive Guide to AI SEO" by Ross Hudgens Subscribe for weekly episodes Listen on Apple Listen on Spotify Follow Ross on X Follow Siege Media on X Email Ross Subscribe today for weekly tips: https://bit.ly/3dBM61f Listen on iTunes: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/content-and-conversation-seo-tips-from-siege-media/id1289467174 Listen on Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/1kiaFGXO5UcT2qXVRuXjsM Listen on Google: https://podcasts.google.com/feed/aHR0cHM6Ly9mZWVkcy5zaW1wbGVjYXN0LmNvbS9jT3NjUkdLeA Follow Siege on Twitter: http://twitter.com/siegemedia Follow Ross on Twitter: http://twitter.com/rosshudgens Directed by Cara Brown: https://twitter.com/cararbrown Email Ross: [email protected] #seo | #contentmarketing