Hi, I'm Solana Pine. I'm the director of video at The New York Times. For years, my team has made videos that bring you closer to big news moments, videos by Times journalists that have the expertise to help you understand what's going on. Now, we're bringing those videos to you in the Watch tab in The New York Times app.
It's a dedicated video feed where you know you can trust what you're seeing. All the videos there are free for anyone to watch. You don't have to be a subscriber. Download The New York Times app to start watching.
From New York Times opinion, this is the Ezra Klein Show. We've talked a lot on the show about the way Donald Trump has transformed the Republican Party. On all kinds of issues, trade, foreign policy, immigration, he has challenged even upended the old consensus. And he did that by giving people a very different story about what was wrong in America, about why they were struggling.
And to be clear, I think most of Trump's policies and many of his stories are quite bad and often false. But to give some credit to the Republicans, they are having these big internal policy debates, and the people coming up behind Trump are having even more of them. The world has changed, their party has changed, their voting base has changed, and so they need to change. On the Democratic side, you haven't seen as much change.
That's a normal for a party that is going to run an incumbent president again. There wasn't a presidential primary this year where different candidates hashed out, their different visions in front of the voters. Biden himself has not been a strong messenger. Kamala Harris hasn't had much time to build out an agenda of her own.
The Democratic Party has been unified the last few years, but they've been unified against Trump, against Maga. It's not been in their communications in the way they've run elections, primarily about their policy vision. But there are people who have been trying to change where the Democratic Party is. Brian Schatz is the senior senator from Hawaii.
He's one of the Democrats in the Senate doing the most work on these issues. He's been a very influential policy voice. But over the last few years, his focus has changed. He's had a bit of a political evolution on the issues that matter most to voters, particularly affordability.
As always, my email is reclanjo at mytimes.com. Senator Brian Schatz, welcome to the show. Thanks for having me, Ezra. So I got asked what's it been like to be a Democratic senator of the past month or two?
Like what's the emotional, intellectual experience have it been? I'm glad you started with the question as an emotional look. There's a saying in Hawaii that everything in Hawaii is political, except politics, which is personal. And that's what it felt like.
This was deeply gut-wrenching. It was obviously politically difficult, even the strategic challenge for all of us. But more than anything, a lot of us really revere Joe Biden. Look, I got to the Senate for the specific reason to take action on climate.
I was the lieutenant governor of the state of Hawaii, and we were doing good things on climate, but climate action has to be federal and then international. And so that's why I moved here. That's why I came to the Senate. And we were able to do this incredible work and to be able to accomplish everything that we've accomplished together.
And then to say, hey, thank you very much. We don't think you're our standard bearer anymore. It's just deeply, deeply painful. But people have been underestimating Kamala Harris all along and underestimating the pent up demand of the anti-Trump coalition, which basically was just sitting there latent.
I actually thought the algorithm wasn't going to permit us to feel hope anymore. And suddenly the internet was like fun again, and Twitter was a little fun, and fundraising was going crazy, and people were making jokes. And so I always think the campaign that's having fun is the one that's likely to win, and we are definitely having fun now. How do you think about the light and dark side of high levels of partisan energy in politics?
What this kind of overwhelming cardiosis can lead you to see and make possible, and also what it can lead you to miss? I don't know what it is. It's hard for me to know what we're missing right now, because we've been missing the enthusiasm for so long that I'm just going to bask in it. And I think one of the things that I've been talking to colleagues about is like, we don't actually need to pivot from this moment of enthusiasm.
We don't need to expect something bad to happen next. We will have dark days during the campaign. We'll have bad polling results during the campaign. But right now we need to roll up some wins and enthusiasm, and some volunteers and some political infrastructure and some good vibes.
Like all of that makes us more resilient for whatever is to come. My old buddy, Neil Abercrombie, the former governor of Hawaii, said a movement is faith in strangers. And I feel like we now have a movement where we have faith in each other, and leftists and moderates and center-right people are going, all right, if it's common, let's roll. And coconut's, I believe.
I'm going to be honest, that was a bridge question, because one of the things I think Democrats have grappled with is when I look at polling, when I talk to people, even when I have tried to convince people about the good parts of the economy, the level of anger about prices, about affordability, it feels to me like something Democrats have not fully faced up to. It's been a lot of effort to tell people it's not quite so, or it's getting better, but there is a real fury around the economy. It's something that you've begun to talk a lot more about over the past couple of years, and I'm curious about your evolution on this. Well, first of all, I think it's understandable when you accomplish a bunch of things that, as Jeff Merkley likes to say, it's run, govern, run, right?
And that sounds lovely, but the fact is we passed the biggest climate action in human history, and basically nobody knows about it. And whether it's the biggest climate action we've ever taken, or the biggest investment in Native American communities that we've ever taken, it's true to say those are the biggest actions ever. It's also true to say that that's not enough. And if you are 19 or 23, you don't remember when you were in junior and high school, and stuff was bad, and then we made marginal improvements that will eventually change things over the next eight to 10 years, you have more immediate needs.
So I do think Kamala puts us in a better position to just talk about the future, and it's very, very challenging, I think, for Donald Trump and JD Vance to talk about the future at all. Let me show you how they're talking about this particular part of, if not the future, the past. Months ago, I heard some young family member observe that their parents' generation, the baby boomers, could afford to buy home when they first enter the workforce. But I don't know this person observed if I'll ever be able to afford a home.
The absurd cost of housing is the result of so many failures, and it reveals so much about what's broken in Washington. Now I can tell you exactly how it happened. Wall Street Barons crashed the economy, and American builders went out of business. As tradesmen scrambled for jobs, houses stopped being built.
The lack of good jobs, of course, led to stagnant wages. And then the Democrats flooded this country with millions of illegal aliens. So citizens had to compete with people who shouldn't even be here for precious housing. Joe Biden's inflation crisis, my friends, is really an affordability crisis.
And many of the people that I grew up with can't afford to pay more for groceries, more for gas, more for rent, and that's exactly what Joe Biden's economy has given them. What do you think of that, diagnosis? Well, I think there are parts of it that are pretty effective, right? He basically touches on what people are experiencing, and then he goes straight to racism and xenophobia and a bunch of right-wing tropes.
But I think your point is well-made by that clip, which is to say, we don't really talk about the affordability crisis, not all of us, right? And we don't talk about struggling families. Because somehow we think that if we talk about people not being able to afford, for instance, prescription drugs, we are like duty-bound, honor-bound to talk about how we catheter-priced of insulin and did all these other wonderful things. But it's sort of like, yeah, that's great.
Also, it's still not affordable, right? And so I don't think it's that hard for us to kind of live where people are, which is you are actually struggling to make ends meet. That is not imaginary. We are not going to talk you out of it.
But I think all they do is scapegoat. And what we need to do is talk about solutions going forward. So the way he frames it there, which is I think something you see happen a lot in political history. There's scarcity of something.
In this case, housing. And then he moves, as you say, to xenophobia, right? It's the undocumented immigrants for the problem. But there is some problem here, right?
There's some reason that not enough homes have been built. And that's been particularly bad in places, Democrats have power. It's bad in Hawaii, where you're from. It's very bad in San Francisco, where Kamala Harris had the beginning of her political career.
So what is your diagnosis? Like what has happened in housing? We have created the scarcity on purpose. We have elevated something called community engagement, but it's not actually like objectively community engagement.
It's the ability for a few people who already have homes to hijack the whole process above the needs of the many. And so here we are, stroking our chins wondering how to alleviate the housing shortage. But we're actually making it nearly impossible for people to build anything. And I think the premise here is that we can have nice things.
We can have enough of the things that we want. If you operate under the assumption that there will only be 100 homes built, it is not unreasonable to say, well, listen, I want 35 of the 100 homes to be capital A affordable. That's a totally reasonable, progressive approach. But the truth is, if you require that, it's likely that zero homes will be built and nobody gets any housing.
Something you're pointing out here is that there is an incumbents versus new commerce problem is one way to put it. I think Vance is weaponizing that dynamic in a much darker way. But the problem in a lot of places is people move to a community. That community was a certain way when they moved there.
They bought a home. And for a bunch of different reasons, they don't want a bunch of big apartment buildings going up next to them. Maybe they don't want it because they don't want people who live in affordable housing to live there. But they also might not want it because they like their views.
They like their parking. They like the community small. It's not good for their housing prices. It's quiet.
It's quiet. Right. Some of it is politically malign. A lot of it is just human nature.
It's also dangerous thing for politicians to try to take on. You like the way things are here, I want to change it. Right. A lot of power over your local community.
I want to take some of that. When you're making this argument, you've been very frustrated about it. How do the people in Hawaii or the other people you're talking to respond? They forgive me for it, but they're not thrilled.
I'm not serious. Like, look, my district, when I was in the state legislature, was Makiki Manoa, sort of like by Punahou School, by the University of Hawaii. A very nice beautiful suburb. And those are some of the folks that are most worried about what a deregulatory environment would look like in terms of the neighborhood.
So after the Hawaii legislature passed some pretty aggressive housing reforms this session. And I was one of the people strongly behind it. I tend not to weigh in with local issues, but make some exceptions. And I made an exception for housing.
You know, I was at Safeway. And I was running into like, I'm not kidding my base. People who contributed to my first campaign with 15 bucks. People who stood on the corner and, you know, and waved with my sign.
People with whom I went to high school. And they were not happy. I don't think it's unforgivable, but this is an uncomfortable conversation among friends. Right.
And that's one of the things that I think the progressive movement has to grapple with is that there are a lot of communities that are 70, 30 or 80, 20 Biden and are pro-immigrant, pro-LGBTQ and certainly pro-choice and pro-climate action and on housing, they're shitty. And I don't think that that can stand because I think there's a generation of people who are progressive and who are struggling financially. And they're starting to figure out that it is their fellow so-called progressives that are preventing them from being able to make a living. I think there's a real deep tension on this inside progressivism because it pits two values against each other.
One is a procedural value for input. Progressives in many, many places, like from California, we have a lot of this. Have created a lot of places for input. There's a real feeling that in post-neudial liberalism, we, we, the government ran over particularly marginalized communities, but not only, right?
It was building freeways recklessly. It was building them through parks. And people like did not have any democratic input. And then on the other hand, there's this other dimension I think you're getting at, which is being welcoming, right?
Being interested in opportunity, being interested in, I always call the firefighter test, can a firefighter who works and risks their life to keep a city from burning down live in the city, but they keep from burning down? How do those come to conflict and how do they get unwound? I think the constituency for proceduralism is small but vocal. And it's not that there should be zero public input, but we're at the point, right?
Where, I mean, I talk about this when it comes to housing in the state of Hawaii, we have extraordinary protections for natural and cultural resources as we should. But there was a lot that was like one of the last standing bowling alleys in the primary urban center of Honolulu called stadium balladrome. It was the old stadium that turned into a balladrome, not an ecologically significant site, still subject to all the same environmental review that like some of our most precious places in the state of Hawaii were subject to. And I think most regular people are able to kind of go, if you're going to throw up a 10-story building with apartments surrounded by, by the way, other apartments, then you maybe don't need the same sort of environmental cultural analysis that you would if you're building in coastal Maui.
And when I make that argument, everybody nods. Now, who doesn't nod? The people who live adjacent to the stadium balladrome. So I agree that there's this tension sort of superficially.
But I actually think you can kind of puncture it by talking to regular people and then finding out that the proceduralists are like 11 people who just consistently show up. But the procedure is so profound here. I mean, the more I have dug in to a bunch of different places where the thing that Democrats said was going to happen and appropriated money for isn't happening, the more I've really recognized how procedural liberalism is. And I get credit here in Nicholas Bagley, the law professor of the current term, the procedural fetish, your guy who is in politics because of your environmental commitments.
And the Senate, you do a huge amount of work on climate, you're one of the key people there. And I find a lot of people in your place are starting to wonder, are these environmental bills, are they doing as much to stop clean energy as they are to stop fossil fuels? Are they doing more to stop clean energy as they are to stop fossil fuels? What's been your sort of intellectual evolution on like liberal proceduralism?
It's been rapid and it's been sort of almost radical. It's a planetary emergency. We did pass the biggest climate action ever. But as you know, we need transmission and distribution and that is going to be stopped by local communities and state governments and oppositional mayors and other nimby's.
And what's really clear is that right wing groups and fossil funded groups are now funding the sort of so-called left wing proceduralist to stop good stuff from happening. And you know, it was on one level, it was ever thus. And we had a wind issue on the island of Lanai. We couldn't get an inter-island cable to connect our state.
But this is now like we are on the edge. We are on the precipice and we are going to have to make it easier to meet our clean energy goals. All of these environmental safeguards were about stopping bad stuff. And now the new progressive movement is not just about stopping bad stuff.
It's about building good stuff. We're gonna have to be the party of construction. We're gonna have to be the party of financing things. We're gonna have to be the party of breaking ground and not stopping the, you know, paved paradise and put up a parking lot.
President Biden has always talked about his second term in terms of finishing the job. He still talks about the work he's gonna do in office in the coming months as finishing the job. And to me, this feels very related but in a very frustrating way. A couple of years ago in some bills you all passed, there was a ton of money for Rob Roband.
Let me read you a story from The Washington Times. Quote, residents in rural America are eager to access high speed internet under a $42.5 billion federal modernization program. But not a single home or business has been connected to new broadband networks nearly three years after President Biden signed the funding into law. And no project will break ground until sometime next year.
And that is assuming things go well. The Times and the blaming that's up to putting some people on various requirements or painting the funds, climate change mandates, preferences for union workers, you know, that's the things I don't know if that is why. But I do often find this problem where something big gets passed and you check in on it a couple of years later and actually people aren't benefiting from it. I always think about the stimulus under Obama, like how much we talk about high speed rail and the smart grid and the rail is not high speed and the grid isn't all that smart.
There's something here about this sort of follow through on some of these big priorities. They're exciting to people when they pass and then like not that exciting when they're being slowly implemented. What's going on there? Well, I think you pointed out one of the failures that we have both governance wise and politically.
I guess what I would say is that I don't think we just like administer harder, implement better. Obviously, we hope that all the chief executives and implementing individuals are doing excellent work. But it's like, I think about the state historic reservation division of the State of Hawaii, right? The federal law says that you may consider something historic if it meets these criteria.
In the State of Hawaii, the assumption is everything more than 50 years old is historic. Now, the problem is we just have old houses and so now they're all potentially for state historic reservation division review. And so for like four years, everyone's like, we got to get more bodies over there so they can process more applications. And I sort of raised my hand and said, those people who process those applications can definitely make three times that amount of money working for a private developer, which is why when we authorize all these new positions, nobody ever gets hired because why would you make 70 if you can make 210?
Okay. What I said was there should just be fewer things on these people's pile. And so I'm wary of the like, we just have to have a laser focus on implementation. We have to clear the thicket here and we have to be unapologetic about clearing the thicket.
And by the way, this one is both really good for results, but it also is quite attractive to like moderate swingy voters who just want government to like kick ass and accomplish things. And they're really looking for like a effective mayor of the country. If you have an attitude that it is not just a question of the competency of the individuals administering the law, but like maybe this law is too down complicated. And I think part of the problem for Democrats is that we have programs and projects and line items and processes and bureaucracies that have nice titles and work on certain things when I think the solutions have to reach people, the COVID relief plan.
There are lots of really good things in it. But the thing that resonated with people that I knew were the checks, right? And I was kind of anti UBI and anti direct cash assistance because I did think it was like the Silicon Valley way to like wave a wand at the disintermediation of employment that they were causing. But I saw it impact people.
And I got to say, boy, fast really works. It works on policy. It works for people and the politics works. And so it is an open question whether or not we should be parking money in certain administrative agencies.
And then they do a notice of grant award and then it goes to the so and so agency of the state government and they do a sub grant to it. And then by the way, that's 36 months later. And then the recipient still has to go and do the thing, right? Which might be another two to five years.
This just doesn't work anymore. And I think we should have the kind of impatience that regular people have, which is like, what the hell? I thought you did this thing. Where's my stuff?
And I don't think we have that impatience. I think we have the sense that we enact and then we take credit. And there's also, I mean, your point that just implementing harder is a way of denying what the trade-offs you're implementing really are. You're demanding more auditing oversight, right?
Report filling out. I mean, I've often called this everything bagel liberalism. I've seen it at every level of government. So that's my only problem with your everything bagel thing is, well, they're delicious.
I want there to be a better example of you just keep adding stuff and then it doesn't taste good. But it wouldn't be delicious if you started putting all this stuff on at the raisinsons. It is an analogy from when everything everywhere, all at once was big. And there was like the everything bagel that actually has everything on it and it comes to black hole that just went into our world.
No, not just talk of chips, like everything. You've never seen everything everywhere all at once. I don't want it. I'm a very well-expertory.
I do it. I take your point on it. But there is this problem. I see it at every level of liberal governance I report on, where somebody gets to the ability to do something good and then sort of other good ideas get layered on, right?
Well, we're going to do that. Like, let's make sure there's a preference for people from marginalized communities. Let's make sure that the labor is from union shops. Let's make sure that we're using small contractors.
Let's make sure that we have a climate plan. Let's make sure that they're getting money for local child care. Let's make it all sort of good individually. But if you're implementing across that many goals simultaneously, it's going to be harder to run the thing.
Often times you have a labor shortage. You don't have to kind of labor. You're looking for how do you think about those because there is a real reason to try to attach other good ideas onto what government is doing. And on the other hand, if government doesn't end up doing any of them, then the cost is greater than the reward.
Yeah, I mean, I think you know, you and I earned pretty vigorous agreement about this one that the city of Honolulu was considering an EV charger requirement on each new housing unit. And it was sort of like developers were like, oh, that's five grand. So, maybe that's cool for non affordable units, but like five grand across, let's say 150 units might be the total profit that a developer had. And therefore they go, well, I can't do this anymore.
Then what happens is you're able to metabolize those requirements if you're building fancy housing, because if the units are five million a piece, then five extra grand for an electric vehicle charging station is like a rounding error. But if the units are if you had like 165 each, which would be very cheap in Honolulu, 170 just like breaks it. And so that was a good example of like a very, very worthy goal that is like consistent with my core values that just didn't make any sense. And I remember being in the Hawaii legislature on the education committee.
And there was like a bike safety requirement for graduation, which sounds cool. Everybody should be able to ride a bike safely. And then there's also a swimming test requirement before graduation. And again, neither of those would I like necessarily personally want to vote no on, but there are like 30 of those.
And then you have teachers and administrators and parents and kids who are like in the compliance business as opposed to in the education business. So what is remarkable to me about Biden's legislative record about the legislative record of the Democrats alongside him like you is how a typically physical it is. I mean, Trump endlessly talked about infrastructure weeks that he never delivered. Biden has delivered what will be should be an infrastructure decade.
But all the people around him, like the people work on this off the record, they will chew your off about how hard it is to get these things built. And I've seen some of the moderates in the Congress come up with nipping around the edges procurement and permitting reform bills. But there's never been like, this is what the progressives think is necessary to get this all built as fast as it needs to be built. Why is that like, where's the sort of follow up pieces and say, this is how we think we get it done?
So it was interesting. I met with a couple of like sort of left think tanks in this particular space, because when the so-called permitting reform negotiations started and stopped and started again, I was in the middle of a bunch of them. And it was very clear that our negotiating counterparts had a punch list presented to them from the American Petroleum Institute. Like they know what they want.
You got to put on the right, you mean here? On the right, yes. But listen, you know, under President Obama, we lifted the oil export ban, which is not amazing policy, but we did it in exchange for extending for a long time, the solar and wind tax credits. And what I did, and this is how I do this kind of analysis, is like I went to the Department of Energy and said, well, how does this net out, right?
Like, I'll make a deal, but only if it's good for the climate. And they said, this is 90-10, good for the climate, you're going to have to swallow this thing. But it's basically a net positive. So we did my problem in negotiating on permitting reform is this is such a new conversation that even our think tanks weren't quite ready to even provide us ideas about what would actually work on permitting reform.
We are in a different place now, and we know specifically what we need in terms of it gets technical, it's cost allocation, and all the rest of it. But there is now clarity about what we need to demand if in case we do permitting reform. Get technical with me for a minute. This is a podcast where people will accept it.
What are the couple of things that you think would have the biggest impact? We need the ability to do regional planning, right? You can't let a mayor or even a public service or a public utilities commission to have sort of total authority over citing of transmission lines and distribution lines. So that's number one.
And so giving FERC, which is the federal agency, some authority is something as of national importance. And the other is you need to be able to allocate the costs of a transmission line across a bunch of users. And it's kind of very easy to characterize that as, hey, listen, I'm not using these electrons. Why are you charging me over here and a public utilities commission that is in the pocket of fossil, is in a position to stop that.
So a lot of this is giving authority to the FERC to, if necessary, override the normal state decision-making process. The thing I'm hearing from people who have been involved in trying to roll out the IRA is that the two hardest problems are permitting and the utilities do not have business models. And they control a lot of this that are amenable to building clean energy at the rate they still make money from building dig natural gas plants, decentralized energy that goes into the grade can be a real problem for them. How do you think about that?
Well, these guys are the incumbents. And I guess there's a political theory of the case where we could dislodge them completely. But I'm not really sure how to effectuate that. I think it is better to cut them in on all of the profitability and let them transition with us.
In Hawaii, what we did was decoupled the Hawaiian Electric Company's profitability from their gross electricity sales. If you're a publicly traded company, as you know, you have a fiduciary allocation of to maximize profit. So fewer electrons means less profit. And so what we did was we bifurcated the question that they would be guaranteed some minimum level of profitability because they're regulated entity, but that they would not be penalized if the total number of electrons went down.
And it did. And they went from among the most aggressively opposed to the Hawaii Clean Energy Initiative to our biggest cheerleaders. And it was 99 or something like that. I was in the state legislature.
We had like a 7% clean energy portfolio standard that wasn't even mandatory. And now we are on track towards 100%. And the Hawaiian Electric Company and the local chamber of commerce and our tourists, folks, and the military, everybody is on board with the Clean Energy Initiative. But what unlocked all of that was, like you say, changing the business models.
And I mean, my best analogy is when my predecessor and others were establishing the time, the biggest marine monument on the planet, Papa Hanamo Kukkaa. There were a bunch of tuna vessels based in Honolulu that were fishing in that area. And Noah just bought them out. And it worked.
They were perfectly happy as long as they made money to participate in a conservation effort. And I think that all these utilities, if we can show them away towards profitability, they're in. I always think this is actually an underused strategy that for some reason, we will allocate all kinds of money towards doing things that are in the public interest. But the fact is that, particularly when you are building things in the real world, people next to those things are sometimes a loser in that, in a way, people further away or not.
And I think that you would get compensated for that. It doesn't seem crazy to me, right? I mean, I'll use a San Francisco example or an LA example, because this happened in both. But in both cities, there are terrible homelessness problems.
And so people want to build shelters. They want to build sites where people can get services. And the people who live near these proposed sites organize against it. And on the one hand, from a kind of progressive or principled stance, that's bad.
On the other hand, the idea that it will lower their housing values, et cetera, is real. And what you're very rarely here, anybody say, well, we've allocated a lot of money to this. We will cut these communities. It doesn't even be a payment for being your housing shelter.
But there can be things built in the community. There are ways you can bring people into a project. Well, a good example is what the Indigenous New Zealanders have done with geothermal energy. I don't know much about that.
Maoris are participating in the utilization of geothermal energy. And it helps native people. There's now a conversation among Native Hawaiians to say, hey, we should talk to our cousins in New Zealand about how they did it. So I just don't accept the premise that there's no way for all of us to benefit when we build things.
Tell me about the issue that I know you run into a fair amount of just the decentralized federated nature of authority, I mean, across the domains we're talking about, housing, clean energy, but I can name a bunch more. A lot of the power is not at the federal level. What gets built, I've sent ex-governors, they're saying to me they're lamenting to me. It's not even at their level, right?
Like the local planning board has power. Like they, the governor, do not have power. How do you deal with the fact that there are these national and actually global issues, but on so much of this, the power is fractured down to the state level, down to the local level, down across a variety of local cities. Yeah, I mean it's fractal almost.
Well, the way I look at this is two things. First, I do whatever I can on federal policy. But second, I have a voice. And to the extent that anyone listens to me, I think especially in housing and clean energy, I have some credibility as a progressive here that I have to just say there is nothing progressive about stopping your neighbors from being able to live in the state of Hawaii.
There's nothing progressive about forcing a fire fighter to drive an hour and a half to where they work. And so I do think we have to actually change the politics of this while we're working on the policy. Like, look, I'm the chairman of the Transportation and Housing and Urban Development sort of money committee. And we've done some cool stuff and we have a $100 million incentive program for counties to do, basically, yes in my backyard projects.
And that's cool. And that's important. But I think the most important thing we can do is create a movement of young progressives articulating that in my progressive future, in our collective progressive future, we're all going to live together. And in a Hawaii clean energy future, which is probably polls that I would say 85% in the state of Hawaii, you think you're not going to see a windmill?
You think you're not going to see a solar farm? You think we're not going to do any geothermal? Like, we're a small place with 1.5 million people. And if we are going to house the people we care about, and if we are going to address the climate crisis, just talking about my state, we're going to see it.
It can't all be someplace else. And I think one of the most important things I can do is just say that as much as I can as unapologetically as I can. And one of the things that I think is encouraging is that, yeah, I've gotten pushed back, but it hasn't been that ferocious. It hasn't been, you know, you've done the unforgivable, because I do think in a lot of people's heart of hearts, they go, he's probably right.
Is it not that ferocious because it's not primarily built around the money, though? It's built around the communication. I mean, in your subcommittee, there is a lot of money, right? And across the broader US Congress and the presidency, there is a lot of money, particularly around transportation, right?
And the states do rely a huge amount on grants and other kinds of guarantees from the federal government. Could more of that be tied to these goals? Yes, absolutely. But I got to, you know, listen, I think this is one of those things where, as your colleague, Nati Glazia talks about, like, there are certain things you want to keep the salience of the issue at like medium.
And I don't want to polarize this issue, right? Especially Yimby and housing, like we've got some really good conservative support. Now they've got some other reasons for feeling strongly about housing, mostly because, you know, it's an article of faith for them, the deregulation is good. But I want to keep that coalition together and not have it turn on some partisan questions.
So I am trying to push as fast as I can, both at the policy side and incentives and programs and projects. But I honestly think that if I'm going to make progress fast enough, that there have to be Yimby mayors and council members and new members of Congress and members of the legislature and speakers of the House that are just like, you know what, I'm a left wing, pro building kind of politician. One thing you said a couple different times here is that you see this less as this set of policy changes. So there's a set of policy changes and more as a sort of ideological shift, right?
People need to begin thinking about things in a different way. And I started the conversation here talking about affordability. And something I've come to believe, and I'm curious if it resonates for you, is that on the left, we'll talk a lot about affordability, but what they think about is subsidy. The left is very comfortable.
Democrats are very comfortable with how do we subsidize something, right? How do we give you vouchers for rent? How do we give you money to buy all the insurance, Pell grants? But affordability is a sort of mixture of how much people have to pay for something and how much of the thing there is.
And the same- And the retail cost of it. But that supply side, right? That question of how much of the thing there is and what is keeping us from creating more of the thing, that feels to me like something where the policy muscle, the Democratic Party is not what one might wish. And I think it's a couple of things.
First of all, it's just habits, habits of the mind and habits of the political ecology of Washington and every other place. But I also think it's like this, first of all, no one wants to be characterized as some supply side or neoliberal, right? But the truth is there are shortage. I mean, you're fine.
But that's not a 50 plus one coalition. Yeah, I don't need to win elections in Pennsylvania. But I think the truth is there are shortages for various reasons. Sometimes the government creates a shortage.
Sometimes a corporation is creating the shortage. And so here we are when Big Pharma comes up with something big that everybody wants. We say, why aren't you selling this to everybody? Perfectly reasonable position.
And here we are. We want more housing. And we don't demand that the builders build more housing. We demand that they build less.
And one of the most high impact accusations you can make of politicians almost anywhere, but particularly in the urban areas is they are in the pocket of developers. And it's like, are these the people? I mean, listen, they want to make money and some of them are bad. But aren't these the people building the thing we say we want?
And so I just think we got to get out of that mindset of scarcity. And I also think that for left-wing folks, we like to focus understandably because we're compassionate on those who are suffering and those who are experiencing scarcity. So we operate under the assumption that if someone says, hey, there could be enough of this. It sounds like bullshit to us.
It sounds like a waving away of the problem. And so my own judgment here is that we need to tell people that they can have nice things. And we need to operate under the assumption that whether it's housing or clean energy in particular or the affordability of prescription drugs, we need to look people in the eye and say, all of these scarcity are created by corporations or by governments. And sometimes the solution is deregulatory.
Sometimes the solution is more aggressive regulation. Sometimes the problem is not a big enough subsidy. Sometimes the problem is that we're subsidizing the wrong thing. But the premise here is that we do get to have enough of the things that we say we want and that the government should be working on that.
So my friends who are supply side neoliberalists, much more than me over at the NISCAIN Institute, they call this cost-disease socialism. And their point is that a particular policy pathology, say that three times fast in the Democratic Party, is a tendency to subsidize what you are constraining with supply of, to pump money into something where you've made it hard to build a lot more of that thing. Right? We put a lot of money into healthcare, but we don't make it easy to train or have more doctors immigrate, energy has some of these dimensions, that there's this particular failure mode of putting money into something where you have not made it possible for then the market to give you a lot more of the thing for the new money.
Yeah, that's right. The incentives for an individual legislator, right? We're still in a direct mail mode for an individual state house race. And you can credibly say, I put $65 million into the White Housing Finance Development Corporation for affordable housing, and I gave $9 million to the Institute for Human Services.
It all sounds good. So you can be like, I'm working on housing. So the political incentive is to just throw a few dollars at the problem while it gets worse. Noah Smith, who's an economist and political writer, he calls us checkism.
This tendency to declare victory based on how big the check is. I mean, that in a way brings us to the Yimbi Act that you have with a colleague across the aisle. I was always interested in it because a big name for an act right there, yes, in my backyard act. It's not a very aggressive piece of policy, but it is a dashboard, right?
It is an effort to try to create a different way of tracking what's going on here. Tell me a bit about why that's a good bill. Well, he basically asks that cities and counties and recipients of HUD funding report on what they're doing regarding deregulatory efforts on housing. And I agree with you, it's not like, it's not going to transform the universe overnight, but it's a pretty important federal level bill that's bipartisan.
And I think it was marked up on the house side unanimously, or closely unanimously. And so I think this is a marker here. And we have an opportunity to, at least in the housing space, to find bipartisan agreement to just say like, hey, maybe we just shouldn't have housing shortages, right? Maybe a bunch of so-called greedy developers would be happy to build all the housing that people actually need.
But we have created the shortage on housing. And it is lots of policy issues, you know, AI and lots of this stuff is so fraught and so challenging that I don't even know where I'm landing yet, right? Because it's evolving and we're going to just have to iterate this. Housing is not that damn complicated.
We just need to make it easier to build it. A political mentor of mine, Mark Schmidt, he is a line I've always loved, which is it's not what we say about the issues, the issue you say about you. Donald Trump has like four policies, but they also think something very clear about him, you know, the big we're going to tear everything comes into the country. That's about how he feels about other countries, right?
So something very clear about him. I'm going to build a wall on the southern border, whether or not he will, something very clear about how he feels about people coming in on the southern border. And so I want to start this back to where we started, the reason I started with Harris and the Democratic effort to win back the White House this year, which is there needs to be something big Democrats can say on affordability, people are mad about inflation, they're mad about prices. At some point it is going to come up, what are you going to do about it?
You all have been in power. This has gotten worse. Why should we trust you again? What are some issues?
What are some policies that they wouldn't solve the whole problem, but would reflect in your view, Democrats communicating to the public that they understand there is a problem and are going to take this seriously. So I'll give you two examples. One's a little wonky and one's not. The first is a bill that I have on college affordability, and it does two things that are kind of different than the just pure subsidy or free college or whatever.
And it provides subsidies, but provides a match from state government. Because as you know, one of the reasons that universities and colleges have increased the net cost is not just the Pell grants coming in and pushing the cost up, but also the legislature has basically defunded their flagship university systems. And so we have a system, we have a bill that would say, look, we're going to provide you subsidy, but only a state government does. And only if you reduce the retail cost of college.
So it incentivizes the university to drive down costs as opposed to, cool, 500 bucks more for me, now it's $500 more. So that's one thing. And I think that, look, that takes a bit to explain, but I actually think that Vice President Harris should enough to use this example. But I think it is a question of respect to the voters and the citizens who want to hear something new.
I actually think that she has a window of maybe, you know, five to eight weeks where people are willing to kind of like listen, listen, and take an hour and say, does she have new ideas? And I think that it is okay to say the things that we've tried have been great, and they have ameliorated pain and made incremental progress. But here's a new one. And I think on college affordability, it's just plain as day that throwing more subsidy at colleges, they're just pocketing the money in my opinion.
So that's one. And then the other one is prescription drugs, because we did good stuff on prescription medicine. Like for me, my father-in-law, like actually personally benefited because we were subsidizing his prescription medicine, because he just couldn't afford it. You know, he's on Social Security disability, he's in his 80s, he's blind.
And there are a lot of people who are helped, but there are a lot of people who need more help. And I think that we should not be too clever to talk about. We did that and we're going to do a hell of a lot more of that. I'm so glad you brought up drugs, which I was not expecting to get a chance to talk about.
But this is a place where I, myself, am genuinely frustrated with Democrats. The one thing Donald Trump did well, in my view, like one policy, which is Warp Speed. And it worked amazingly. And it, to me, it's such an amazing dream of a policy that we created a speed run to get the first mRNA vaccines ever developed and approved in record time.
And then when they came out, the cost was zero. The federal government footed the bill and helped clear the way. And then when it came out, everybody could have it like perfect. Everybody got one.
As good equity as there's ever been in like a newly launched product in human history. And so your point, not a like sort of income test, only more people get it for everybody gets it for free. Everybody gets it. Where are the other Warp speeds, right?
We know there are other problems. Where is the eight more Warp speeds? Yeah, and this is a very smart idea. And I have a couple of staff as you know, and back and either taking notes.
I like this idea. I'll also say specifically as it relates to the FDA that with AI, there's just going to be a throughput problem in terms of the FDA's ability to like process and vet and approve drugs safely as though it is 1977, right? There's just going to be too many things in the pipeline. So I agree with you.
And I think that's a very smart area for innovation. I'm not sure Kamala can run on that. It's a little bit of an abstraction and a two-question shot. But I agree very much that if you're talking about an abundance agenda, if you're talking about me being able to look at my voters and other people in the eye and say, we're for you having nice things.
We're for the government, not just claiming to do things, not just trying to do things, but actually doing things for you. Then the government has to work at the speed at which people experience problems, not at the speed at which the general counsel of the department, whatever can move. In a weird way, I do think one of the things that gives you credibility in politics is showing that you are creating friction with your traditional allies. And the places where Trump has been good on this are trade in his coalition.
It was surprising people to see the team's president up there. They're going to follow through with any good ideas about labor. I'm a little skeptical, but we'll see. And there has been some things around them and business that have actually in mind you've begun to make the economic populism a little bit more credible, not fully credible, but I'm more interested there than I was a couple years ago.
What are the places in the Democratic coalition that look like that where when you think of something where people should be honest and say, look, we have a problem here and we're going to have some hard conversations. Where should Democrats begin and showing they're not the exact same as they've always been on that. I think it's housing for sure. I think it's clean energy as well.
I also think that there are a lot of parents out there who were pretty damn frustrated with state and local government, state and local school boards, as they were saying, hey, remote school literally doesn't work. Right? There may be exceptions, maybe some kids thrived, but for the most part it was terrible. It did not work.
And because Democratic government was in charge and trying to be as safe as possible, I think we were late to come around to the idea that remote school was just a dog. It was a political shit sandwich and it was bad for kids and bad for people's trust in institutions. And I think we should be really crisp about that. I also think that because the so-called parent empowerment movement, the youngkin stuff had this conservative valence that had to do with right wing politics, that there's a little bit of a hesitancy to jump fully into what are we going to do about kids on social media?
But every parent that I meet wants there to be a federal law that does not permit kids to have an under from being on social media at all. And I think some of our coalition members are very uncomfortable with that for understandable reasons. But I think those are some areas where the vice president could demonstrate some independence here and basically lose nothing. It's a good place to end.
Always a final question. What if we book you recommend to the audience? Walk ride paddle is Tim Cain's book about when he walked the Appalachian Trail, paddled the James River and then did some other bike ride. Tim Cain, you're Senate colleague.
Tim Cain, that's a very, yeah, it's a very fun book. And he's just such a lovely man and he's such a travel book, but it's sort of interspersedes what was happening at the time, politically, including two impeachments and the rest of it. I just finished reading The Manifest Effect by Rabbi Sharon Brows, which I loved. It's probably the first thing I've ever read by a rabbi.
I'm sorry to my current and former rabbis. And I'm just finishing up a book by Heather Cox Richardson called Wounded Knee and it's about Sue and other tribes in the Dakotas. Senator Brian Schatz, thank you very much. Thank you.
This episode of The Other Clients Show is produced by Elias Esquitt, fact checking by Kelsey Kudak. Our senior engineer is Jeff Gell with additional mixing by Amman Sahota. Our senior editor is Claire Gordon. The shows production team also includes Annie Galvin, Michelle Harris, Roland Hoop, Kristen Lynn, the original music by Isaac Jones, Audine Stradgy by Christina Simuluski and Shannon Buster, the executive producer of New York Times Companion Audio is Andrew Ostrasser, and special thanks to Sophia Belade, Afeam Shapiro and Sonya Herrera.