Skip to content
Weight Management Myths - Part 3 episode artwork

May 6, 2025 15 min

Weight Management Myths - Part 3

from The Daily Dollop with Kate Freeman

On this episode of The Daily Dollop we're chatting about weight management myths. When the majority of nutrition information on the internet is all about weight loss, it's really difficult to know what's the truth and what's just marketing to make you buy into a product or program. Let's unpack this today! Download the Ayla Health App. Join the conversation over in the Ayla Health Community Group on Facebook. Follow Ayla Health on Instagram Follow Kate Freeman on Instagram Ayla Health Website Kate Freeman's Website

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Weight Management Myths - Part 3

0:00 15:14
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello, I'm Kate Freeman, and this is The Daily Dollop. Transform your eating habits and achieve long-term wellbeing with Ayla Health. Ayla Health is a mobile app that combines microlearning with meal planning into a seamless user experience that teaches you how to eat well for the rest of your life, one habit at a time. Download it now from the App Store.

It's free. On this episode of The Daily Dollop, we're chatting about weight management myths. When the majority of the nutrition information on the internet is all about weight loss, it's really difficult to know what's the truth and what's just marketing to make you buy into a product or program. Let's unpack this today.

It's dollop time. Hey, hey, my name is Kate. I'm a registered nutritionist. And after 20 years in the field of nutrition, I'm tired of seeing people stressed about eating and confused about where to start.

And so I'm changing the conversation. You deserve to feel confident in your food choices and empowered to maximize your health. Every weekday, we'll dollop an episode into your feed covering everything from busting nutrition myths, practical food ideas, my thoughts on trending topics, and habits for a healthy life. My promise to you, it will always be sustainable, realistic, restriction-free, and strictly no woo.

Only good science translated into easy everyday advice. Let's do this. Welcome back to the show, everyone. We are chatting weight management myths today.

And myth number three is that you must fast to manage your weight. Now, fasting actually reminds me of something that I did when I was a teenager that I now think is totally not cool to do for teenagers and older kids. And that is the 40-hour famine. So if you were a nineties kid and you remember doing the 40-hour famine, you will know that you cannot eat for 40 hours.

And the idea was that we were, you know, experiencing food shortage for children who were starving in third world countries across the world. And we would raise money. So a noble cause, but I would argue not a really great thing for vulnerable young people in a weight centric culture full of body shaming to do. And I remember being probably only 12 when my youth group did the 40-hour famine all together and we had like big sleepovers at the church and we were playing games and doing things while we were all not allowed to eat.

But because I was young and 12, I think they had rules. So I did an eight hour fast. And by golly, not eating for eight hours as a 12-year-old. I just, I still remember it.

It was really difficult. And yeah, absolutely not something that I would condone in any shape or form. And I'm actually super glad that it's not something that people do. However, I do see a lot of social media posts around fasting, particularly around new years.

I also actually in the entrepreneurial world of startups and high flyers and big companies and CEOs, there's a massive trend within like entrepreneurs and CEOs to fast. It's like an ego thing that they think they're like the bee's knees or just some like epic hardcore person because they can fast and run their company. And I don't know, but if you want to be on the top of your game, make good decisions, have plenty of energy, go to the gym, be active, kill at your startup or your job. You do not wanna be fasting a hundred percent.

You'd wanna be eating. Like eating is good concentration. But anyway, we're not talking about concentration today. We're talking about weight management and we're talking about the myth of whether you should fast to manage your weight.

I got fully sidetracked with the 40-hour famine. But who remembers that? Hit me up with your story of the 40-hour famine. I just think, golly, I'm so glad that that is not something that young people are encouraged to do these days because I'd have issues with it for shizzle.

Okay, so the question that I wanna answer in today's episode is, is fasting the superior weight management strategy? So let's understand it first. The definition of fasting is to abstain from all or some kinds of food and drink. And so as you would be familiar, if you are on social media or you've researched into this or you've maybe done different fasting protocols before, you will know that there are numerous different types of protocols available to do.

Some of them are just fasting food. Some of them are fasting food and water. Some are just fasting intermittently. Some are not even just full fasting.

They're just really low calorie days. Some, what we call time-restricted feeding is fasting for a period of the day and then only eating for a certain time period. There are lots of different ones. The worst I've seen are like seven, 10-day fasts, which are completely ridiculous.

You're supposed to eat. And do you know what? And I would say that people who do live in third world countries and genuinely experience food insecurity and food shortages and famines would look at us purposely starving ourselves and just think we are absolute nuts. But this is my thoughts on that.

So fasting works by drastically reducing your eating windows, which is a very effective at creating an energy deficit. And the reason why fasting is so popular and is easy to stick to is because the rule is very black and white and easy to follow. You can't eat today or you can only eat for these particular time frame. Whereas other rules like cut out bread, you know, and a little bit more specific or a little bit more complicated or a little bit, you know, around different foods, are harder to stick to.

And so, look, if you think that fasting is helpful or you've, you know, you've done it before and were successful at it in that you lost weight, that's, it's great. All power to you. But I would say that if you stopped fasting and weight returned, or if fasting then triggers a binge or an overeating response, or makes you afraid of eating, or makes you feel like you can't trust your hunger and fullness cues, I would say that fasting is an unhealthy thing for you to do. And it's, in my opinion, fighting your body in a food supply where we're actually are surrounded by abundance and we're not in a famine at all.

Essentially what happens for a lot of fasting protocols, depending on how long they go for, some of them, depending on what people are eating and yeah, how long they last, induce a state of ketosis, which is where the body has to use ketones for energy instead of carbohydrates. And it's starting to use body fat and break that down to ketones. And then there's other metabolic adaptations. One of the things they talk about with fasting online is this idea of, I can't remember, apophegia.

I can't even remember the word. That's because it was just like something I thought off the top of my head, but I'm going to look it up and I'm going to talk about it later. One of the problems guys with my brain is I can't remember specifics of word names. Anyway, I'm going to talk about that in another episode.

But let's talk about the types of fasting. First, the main types of fasting is the 16.8, so time-restricted feeding. Another really popular one is the 5.2, which is known as intermittent fasting. And then we've got full day and multiple day fasts.

So there are lots of scientific studies on fasting. It's been very well researched now, particularly over the last 10 to 15 years. And studies show that fasting can result in weight loss. So when we say does fasting work?

Well, when we define work as inducing weight loss, yes, fasting does work. That makes sense though. I feel like that's not groundbreaking. Like if you don't eat, you lose weight.

Like that, we've known that for a very long time. Anyway, it makes sense. However, what the studies also show is that it is not more superior than other ways of creating an energy deficit and losing weight. So it's not a better way.

It's not a more superior way. It's just another way. So other things about the studies is they show a really high, what we call attrition rate, or it's really difficult to stick to. So many participants in fasting studies don't finish the study and they are excluded from the results.

Most studies are short-term, so three months, sometimes six months. So they're not really looking at the long-term implications. And they have small numbers of participants, so less than 40 people. So we don't actually know the long-term effects of fasting.

And there are studies that also show that fasting is associated with disordered eating, binge eating, and eating disorder behaviors. So I think what I want to say is that everybody has the right to choose what they want to do for their body. And that is absolutely your prerogative. Just be mindful of the fact that there are consequences to all the actions that we take.

And so for me, the main reason why I am not a fan of fasting is because it is working against the body, not with it. I much prefer working with people to work with their hunger and fullness cues rather than ignoring their hunger and fullness cues. I'm also want to prevent disordered eating and eating disorders, because as a health professional, I should, in my opinion, do no harm. So that's really important to me.

And so I want to work with people to change their eating habits without any risk of that turning into disordered eating or an eating disorder. And lastly, is I guess the social and psychological element of eating in that, you know, we set examples for children. And I just think that regular fasting is absolutely not something we want to see children doing. But we model that to them if we're not eating dinner with them or not eating meals with them or they're seeing us do these behaviors.

So socially and from teaching children, and if you're a parent, I just think fasting please let us know. Email us at [email protected] or you can send us a message on Instagram. Until next time.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of The Daily Dollop with Kate Freeman?

This episode is 15 minutes long.

When was this The Daily Dollop with Kate Freeman episode published?

This episode was published on May 6, 2025.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this The Daily Dollop with Kate Freeman episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.