Skip to content
Weight Management Myths - Part 4 episode artwork

May 7, 2025 15 min

Weight Management Myths - Part 4

from The Daily Dollop with Kate Freeman

On this episode of The Daily Dollop we're chatting about weight management myths. When the majority of nutrition information on the internet is all about weight loss, it's really difficult to know what's the truth and what's just marketing to make you buy into a product or program. Let's unpack this today! Download the Ayla Health App. Join the conversation over in the Ayla Health Community Group on Facebook. Follow Ayla Health on Instagram Follow Kate Freeman on Instagram Ayla Health Website Kate Freeman's Website

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Weight Management Myths - Part 4

0:00 15:12
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello, I'm Kate Freeman, and this is The Daily Dollar. Transform your eating habits and achieve long term well-being with ALA Health. ALA Health is a mobile app that combines micro-learning with meal planning into a seamless user experience that teaches you how to eat well for the rest of your life, one habit at a time. Download it now from the App Store.

It's free! On this episode of The Daily Dollar, we're chatting about weight management news. When the majority of the nutrition information on the internet is all about weight loss, it's really difficult to know what's the truth and what's just marketing to make you buy into a product or program. Let's unpack this today.

It's dollop time! Hey, hey, my name's Kate. I'm a registered nutritionist, and after 20 years in the field of nutrition, I'm tired of seeing people stressed about eating and confused about where to start. And so, I'm changing the conversation.

You deserve to feel confident in your food choices and empower to maximize your health. Every weekday will dull up an episode into your feed, covering everything from busting nutrition myths, practical food ideas, my thoughts on trending topics, and habits for a healthy life. My promise to you, it will always be sustainable, realistic, restriction-free, and strictly no-woo. Only good science translated into easy, everyday advice.

Let's do this. Welcome back to The Daily Dollar Podcast, everyone. What a great day. It's going to be today.

We are talking myth number four on weight management myths, the series that I'm chatting on this week. And the myth is that you must eat or drink special foods to lose weight. But you know what? My brain has been in overdrive after I had a brain fart in yesterday's episode where I couldn't remember the name of a word to do with fasting.

Anyway, a quick Google and I reminded myself, the word is autophagy. That's how it's spelled. And I'm actually a really bad speller, guys. That's a fun fact about me.

Cannot spell to save my life. Like if someone put a gun to my head and will like, spell this word, I would die. Anyway, so autophagy, A-U-T-O-P-H-A-G-Y. The Americans that I hear talk about it on Instagram, social media, autophagy, is how they say it, autophagy, or autophagy, anyway.

But essentially it is a process where when you fast for long enough, so you go without food, you obviously get a drop in blood glucose levels and insulin levels. And this triggers the cells to start breaking themselves down. Now, the way that it is argued for people who love fasting and promote fasting is that they're like, the cells are regenerating themselves. And it's this beautiful process where the cell is breaking down its damaged, terrible parts and rebuilding new, beautiful cells.

That is one way that you could look at it. Or the other perspective could be that the body hasn't eaten for 16 hours. It's starting to go into stress. It now needs to prioritize functions of the body to keep you alive.

So it will start to break down cells that it deems as lower priority and start using those spare parts to ensure that the important functions of your body keep ticking over because it wants to keep itself alive. And we could say that autophagy, or autophagy, is your body's survival mechanism to help you last as long as possible without food. Because the cool thing about the body that you need to understand it is not static. And when I'm in static, it's not just staying the same.

It is dynamic in that your body is constantly breaking proteins down, rebuilding new proteins. The cool thing is it's like your muscles. The muscle proteins turn over where the breaking down of muscle proteins and the rebuilding of new muscle proteins happens every roughly 40 days. This is how we get stronger.

Because we put the stimulus of exercise and weight training on our muscles and because muscles are constantly being broken down and rebuilt, every time they're rebuilt, they're rebuilt stronger because they've got this constant stimulus of us like pulling on a heavy weight. But if we're not pulling on that heavy weight and we're just sitting on our bums for days on end, okay, our office workers, aka me, our muscles decline over time because each time our muscles are broken down and rebuilt again, the body's like, we don't really need this. We're not really using it, right? Bodies are dynamic.

And so I just, yeah, I wanted to touch on this idea of autophagy. I've had a few people tag me in different reels over the last few months and I haven't really addressed it because I haven't had time. And then I delved into the research and it's really complex and cellular. And I was just like, oh, lordy.

But I am skeptical about accepting autophagy as this wonderful, renewing thing. Because as far as I'm aware, with my 20 years of experiencing nutrition, getting nutrients into your body is better than not getting nutrients. And that I'm a nutritionist, so I'm always pro-eating. Let's just put it that way.

All right, let's talk mis number four for weight management, which is that you have to eat or drink special foods. And this is definitely something that's used by industry to sell particular things or different protocols, but there are like so many like magical things, and I'm saying magical with rabbit ear fingers, promoted online to lose weight, but they are not actually getting it. First up is lemon water, so a squeeze of lemon in a glass of water. The magical things that that can apparently do, like it blows my mind that a squeeze of lemon juice in a glass of water just has blown up and has so many amazing things.

Like it's crazy to me that this happens, but it doesn't do anything magical in your body. It's digested and metabolized just like everything else you eat. It might damage you tooth and animal because of the acidity of the lemon juice if you have too much of it and you don't brush your teeth. So it provides with vitamin C.

That's good. Like a lot of other fruits and vegetables do, which is good. It's hydrating like water does. So that's good, but it's not any more magical than that.

And it certainly is not a magical weight loss. The licks are a drink. It's just crazy to me. It's crazy to me.

If you have lemon water, great. Like do it. It's great, but it's not magical. So yeah.

Next up, one of my favorites is celery juice made up. The guy who started the celery juice trend. I think he's named David. He heard about this from the spirits in space or something.

The medical medium here, the spirits told him about celery juice. And the spirits tell him about things that modern medicine doesn't know. Guys, it's just juiced celery. So they just took all the fiber out and they just, this is the watery part.

Like it's not magical. Sure. There's some antioxidants in there. Maybe some nutrients, mostly water.

So it's hydrating, which is good. It's got some nutrients. A little bit. It's good.

But it's left out the fibrous part. And it can't hurt you. But I think promoting it as like this magical like special weight loss drink is just crazy. This is crazy to me.

It's not. It's totally not. And that's pretty much it for that section. And any other thing that you see promoted on the internet is eat this food and it will magically melt your belly fat away.

No. They are not things. Don't click on those ads. Don't read those articles.

Don't share those posts. They are not real. If they were real, we wouldn't be having a five part series on weight management. Right?

Which is wouldn't. Because people would be like to eat that food and you will magically be the body size that you want to be. But that is not how it works at all. Alright, myth number five is you must follow insert special diet here.

And so every single dietary program on the market today will promise you that they are the ones that will have what you need. They've done the thinking for you. You know, they've given you a meal plan. They've given you a shopping list.

They've told you what you can and can't eat. Just stick to the diet. Right? The fat diet menu is crazy.

And in fact, I've been a nutrition now for over 20 years. And I just, I cannot get over the misinformation on the internet nowadays. And I know that social media has played a huge role in that because it basically gives every single person on the internet an opportunity to have an opinion about stuff. Which is fine.

I'm all for people having opinions and sharing them. But you now as a consumer have to be so savvy. You have to be really critical. You need to really think about where is this information coming from.

And yeah, it's tough. It's tough. It's tough out there. So let's talk about a couple of different diets that are really popular at the moment.

The keto diet has come and gone over the years. So the keto diet is a very, very low carbohydrate diet. So generally speaking, you kind of have any more than 10 to 20 grams of carbs a day, which is not very much at all. And the keto diet, a true keto diet should actually be 80% fat, a little bit protein, and then very, very little carbs.

And it works because cutting out carbohydrates, one drastically reduces your food choices, which makes you eat less. And also it kicks you into a metabolic state called ketosis. Hence its name, keto. And yeah, so that's where ketones are created for your body to use for energy.

And they're created from fat. But those fats could be coming from your diet, or they could be coming from your fat cell. So keto only works in the very long term, still if you're in an energy deficit. Can't avoid diet is pretty much the keto diet, except for the fact that you can't eat anything else but animal products and meat.

And it works for a very, very similar reason. A shake diet works because it controls your energy intake to a very low level. Most shake diets are around, you know, 800 to 1,000 calories a day, which is actually not enough energy to fuel a toddler. Barely, like your average two year old.

Not enough food for them. And you're expecting yourself to like work and parent and do all these things. Awful. And you could name a diet and I'll tell you how it creates an energy deficit.

And that reminds me of that movie, My Big Fat Creek Wedding. Do you remember that movie guys? And the dad? Give me a word, any word.

And I will show you that the root of that word is Greek. You're so good. But I could be like that. I'm like, give me a diet.

Tell me a diet. And I will tell you how it creates an energy deficit and what the rules are in order to work. And when I say work, I mean weight loss. Does that mean it's healthy?

Not necessarily. Does it mean it's sustainable? Not necessarily. Does it mean it's realistic for you to do long term?

Probably not. Let's talk about the carb debate really quickly and then we'll finish off this episode. The science actually says that it doesn't matter what the macros are. High protein, low protein, high carb, low carb.

It doesn't matter when it comes to weight loss. And a very big landmark study showed this very succinctly. And there's lots of other studies to back this one up. But this was a 12 month weight loss study that looked at the effect of low fat versus low carbohydrate diets.

And they also looked at the genes of these people as well to see if certain genetics should be on a certain type of diet. And they found that it didn't matter. That it was the creation of an energy deficit and diet quality that were the two key factors regardless of their genetics and the type of diet that they were on. So I don't know why we're still arguing about this, but it doesn't matter.

Well, that is it for today's episode. Thank you for hearing me out on four days of my soapbox. We're busing a couple of weight management myths. In the last episode, I want to talk about a few things around body image, shame, guilt, weight stigma, the pursuit of weight loss, weight versus health, and potentially following a different approach.

I hope you try this. The Daily Doll Podcast is proudly brought to you by ALA Health. Build food confidence and learn how to choose foods that are right for you and your body. Download the app today and build habits that last.

As always, you can find out more about our chat in the show notes. You can also join the conversation over in the ALA Health Community Group on Facebook. We'd love to see you there. If you've got a topic you'd love to hear a chat about on the Daily Dollop, please let us know.

email us at hello at alahhealth.com.au or you can send us a message on Instagram. Until next time.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of The Daily Dollop with Kate Freeman?

This episode is 15 minutes long.

When was this The Daily Dollop with Kate Freeman episode published?

This episode was published on May 7, 2025.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this The Daily Dollop with Kate Freeman episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.