Solved, cushy, plush, cozy, soft, smooth, buttery, marshmallowy, warm. Solved, socks, underwear, tees, and more. Bomb health, everyday comfort, worth obsessing over. Visit bombus.com.audio and use code audio for 20% off your first purchase. That's B-O-M-B-A-S dot com slash audio.
One purchase equals one donated, always. I'm Ina Garten, and each week on Happy Hour, I invite new and old friends for drink and a fun conversation at my kitchen table in New York City. On this week's episode, I'm joined by Julia Louis-Dreyfus. We talk all about attending a fashion show in Paris together, throwing dinner parties, and making her Broadway debut in other desert cities. New episodes of Happy Hour are available every Wednesday.
You can watch on YouTube or listen wherever you get your podcasts. Cheers. How far would you go to have a healthy baby? Embryo editing is very much illegal in the United States, is illegal in most countries. But there is growing interest as the technology has gotten better.
This week on Explain It To Me, the ethics of embryo-maxing. Listen to new episodes, Sundays, wherever you get your podcasts. Hello and welcome to the Curator. I'm the Eyepital Editor in Chief of the Verge, and Decoder is my show about big ideas and other problems. Today I'm talking to Robert Hart, the Verge's London-based AI reporter, about what AI is doing to the field of mathematics.
In the existential crisis, many leading mathematicians are having about it. The news here is that opening eyes just published a set of solutions to longstanding problems in math that went off like a bombshell in the field. It's caused a huge debate in the math community, and Rob talked to some of the most accomplished mathematicians of our time in math. It's funny that AI systems are still pretty bad at elementary school arithmetic, but they're getting increasingly good at very high-end abstract math. All of this raises some big questions for the field of advanced mathematics.
If AI can do math at this caliber, does that mean AI labs can transfer their skills to other domains? What good are the academic grants and university programs designed to train new generations of human mathematicians to identify new problems as they try to solve existing ones? If the frontier models simply solve all of the outstanding questions? And perhaps most importantly, what if all this attention to math is just another marketing exercise for the frontier AI labs? Don't seem to care less, but what happens to one of the oldest and most fundamental academic disciplines there is?
There's a lot here, and Rob talks to a lot of people with a lot of views on all of it. Okay, Verge AI reporter Robert Hart, on what AI is doing to math. Here we go. Robert Hart, your London-based AI reporter here at the Verge. Welcome to the Curator.
Thank you, Happy May. There's a lot going on in particular with AI and math that you recently dove into. You spoke to a lot of leading mathematicians about the crisis in mathematics due to AI. It feels like a lot, and also like there's a lot yet to know and discover about the interaction of these two things. A full existential crisis, which is pure decoder bait.
Broadly tell us what's going on. I think a lot sums it up quite well. I mean, basically a bit of an existential crisis within what is mathematics, what are mathematicians doing? What is the role of mathematicians going forward? And a lot of that is inferred by kind of a phrase transition in what AI is capable of that kind of being exploded would be a reasonable way of saying in the last six months to a year.
And it's gone from being very terrible to seemingly genuinely quite good at a professional level in a very short space of time. And so I think it's a lot of what these other fields have been struggling to deal with for the last five years in a very compressed period of time. I would put that next to software engineering. We've been living through the AI crisis and software engineering for some amount of time. But as recently as 2024, even last year, the conventional wisdom was that AI models were particularly bad at math.
The famous examples that could not count the number of ours in the word struggle, even just counting sort of eluded them. What has happened to make them better at math? Are they still bad at general arithmetic? And they're like, advanced math or is it something in between? Yeah, I mean, they are still truly, truly terrible at some areas of math.
I did check they can do strawberries now. I think someone's tweaked that. I think strawberry is hard-coded. I want to be very clear. My conspiracy theory is the strawberry thing is hard-coded in all the models.
I think so. I have to. That is a conspiracy I'll buy into. But yeah, I mean, it's still terrible at those kind of things. I mean, it's math.
It's arithmetic. It's I mean, even the days of the week, my boyfriend was saying the other day, he's like, it keeps thinking it's Wednesday. It's not Wednesday or time. I mean, a little bit of a worry for us a few months ago. I think we're over at the chat GPT.
Can't tell time. It's still fun. That's all of maths. So there's this sort of disconnect. I think we always kind of create or to be good at math, you've got to be good at counting or adding or multiplying.
And a lot of it is reasoning. I mean, if you look at academic math papers, a lot of the time you won't see numbers, which kind of sums that one up, I think. So this is terrible. But then I was a very good at this other part. And as to why, I mean, I think it's something when you reach critical mass of what these systems can do.
We've seen it with writing, we've seen it with programming. And they're very good at kind of forging connections between different areas or applying old methods in new ways or those kind of things. And it appears that the newer models they're training have apparently reached that level where it clicks. And now it can do maths. I mean, it's important to say that we speak about it especially from the outside as a sort of unitary discipline.
But I mean, imagine say biology, you've got something that would range from literally watching animals and describing behavior all the way through to like cellular mechanisms and biochemistry. Like maths is not a unitary discipline either. Some bits is really good at. Some bits like counting. Still really bad.
And even on the more kind of abstract levels of that, I mean, so I mean, they float into topology as one area that it's apparently still quite bad at. I can't verify that to be honest. It's beyond my own expertise. But it's still, yeah, it's a bit of a mixed bag. So you're just trying to map next is a huge field, obviously many, many academic areas of interest.
And there are some parts where the models have gotten quite good. Some parts, maybe the basic parts of the people think of as math, which is simply counting where they're still struggling. And there's a wide range in the middle. Is it the wide range in the middle or the existential crisis is people don't know what's going to happen? Or is it at the ports where it's really good?
Bit of both. Which I feel is going to be running through this. No one's really afraid of being a mediocre mathematician. But obviously there's a huge element of what this still does. And like in terms of the research element, so like the cutting edge kind of, as we see with a lot of the results that generate hype, like what can it do?
There are areas now where it seems to be producing work that is on par with good mathematicians alongside other parts where it can't count. So I think it's, and all caught up in that is whether it's going to be right. Employment structures, funding structures. I mean, you also raise the murky question of like, what is mathematical knowledge? And the roles that these workers will be doing as well.
So it's kind of all of that wrapped into one. I think that tracks broadly with sort of the rise of AI in every field where you can just add horsepower or compute to a problem and there's some kind of verifiability. It seems like the models continue to get better. Everything in the middle where you might need some world knowledge or the models might need some actual intelligence about the world itself. They seem to struggle.
The parts of math, at least reported out in your piece and what the labs are talking about, they seem to be almost entirely self contained theoretical problems where the models can generate a proof or solve a problem that knows to be able to solve and then try to verify that that has existed and it can just run again and again and again. That brings us, I think, to May of this year where an internal open AM model, which we have not really seen, disproved the unit distance conjecture, which is an 80 year old problem, and then just recently we heard about Astro from open AI. Astro is the one where it seemed like the switch flipped and everyone decided it was an existential crisis. What did Astro achieve and why is it a big deal? I'm also pretty sure that Astro was probably behind the early one as well.
Open AI just listed it as a unnamed internal model. It was probably Astro. They didn't answer me when I asked, but there we go. Open AI a few weeks ago dropped a blog along with a lot of paperwork, proving it, I think, several hundred pages that they described. They called it 10 advances in mathematics and theoretical computer science.
It was basically an array of disciplines that they claimed the newest model Astro had solved in some capacity that ranged from, hey, what was in quantum game theory, which I don't know how to begin to explain, and even less how to explain is kind of there was say a packing and higher dimensions, so one three dimensions, and there was sort of a lot of other disciplines as well. And it was, I mean, yeah, it caused a lot of stir in the community. It was, I think a bit of a bombshell. I mean, as we said, there'd been these individual breakthroughs that happened, but to drop 10 in one go, and they were quite big ones. I mean, researchers had just told me that, yeah, these were, if a human has solved these, we would be impressed.
If a human had solved all 10, we probably wouldn't believe that. Their problems they actually care about as well, I think, is an important one. A lot of previous ones have been accused of areas that mathematicians didn't really bother with, and these are ones of mathematicians, good mathematicians, have spent a lot of time trying to solve, and had them. We need to pause here for a quick break. We'll be right back.
What if we told you that there was one thing you could eat to reduce your risk of death by about a quarter? Interested? And what if we added that this magical substance can dramatically lower your cholesterol, improve your mood, and keep your weight stable? No, it's not protein. It's actually fiber.
The least sexy, most overlooked nutrient of all. But what is fiber? How could one nutrient do all those amazing things? And how can you get enough? Is it powder you stir into some water going to do it for you?
Well, that plus the strange tale of the Gorilla Poop Obsessed, father of cornflakes in the latest episode of Gastropod. Find Gastropod and subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. We're back with the Virgis Robert Hart talking about AI's math capabilities, and what happened earlier this month with an all-new AI model called Astra. Let's talk about these 10. You reported them out.
Open, I did produce some documentation, but they're not all entirely horse-powered out of nothing. They're based on previous work. There's some question of attribution. What was the response? Is it, oh, the models did this?
Or was it a response we see to so much AI work, which basically goes down to, well, you stole this and didn't attribute anyone, and you've built on the shoulders of giants without mentioning it? How did the response land? By and large, it was generally one of being quite impressed from the people I spoke to. It was, as I said, these are problems mathematicians cared about. There was one that drew a particular potential for how they credited it, and also how they announced all of this in their blog post openly initially, I think, had said that these are 10 problems that have been no progress in the last 10 years.
And then if you actually read the papers, one of them, it quite clearly says, oh, we build on progress from these two researchers. And so, I mean, that was later changed quite quietly as well, but a few of the researchers I spoke to were quite unimpressed, and they did fill up an element of, as well, yeah, you've not credited something that you've used heavily here, but your own acknowledgement. That said, whether we such a teacher who was one of the ones named was a bit ambivalent on the whole thing as well. So it was a real mix that. But I mean, the general vibe, I'd say, other than this perhaps was oversold in terms of what came before, which was corrected, to their credit, I don't think it was anything other than I think the word sloppy was what was described to me for one person.
The general impression was quite impressed. These were actual breakthroughs that bothered people, and it did move the field forward in a way that, yeah, as I said, if it was a human mathematician that'd done these, I think, I mean, several researchers actually said that, well, if a researcher had done any one of these problems, they'd probably be set for an academic career. So yeah, it was impressed with what it did, if not the credit for some of them. Yeah. Well, that's why credit and attribution in academia is the whole game.
And it seems like the AI companies get away with being sloppy in a way that no human would be able to get away with being sloppy. Did the scale of the discovery or the work overcome the sloppiness? If a human had accomplished singles and it didn't as sloppy, would the reaction be the same? I mean, part of me always wants to lean on the whole, like, oh, it looks like plagiarism, kind of element. But if you actually read the papers, they kind of produced, and I mean, they're one of the researchers I said, there's probably about 50 people in the world who are going to bother reading through this in depth.
It is very clear. Like it doesn't attempt to plagiarize. I think it was just a poor press release, to be honest. And as much as I love to go in on it sometimes, I find that having I suppose having covered science for a decade plus the press releases are often overselling what discovery has actually been made and the import of it and the novelty of it. And I think that's just another case of what happened here.
Does this seem repeatable? There are some proof that they provided that they solved 10 problems that were unsolvable. Do they provide any proof that they can solve another 10? That's the question. I mean, it's also so the big unknown from, oh, God, the near dozen people I spoke to for this was, well, how many did they try to get these 10?
Who knows? I mean, they know, but they won't say. But that is the big question here is, is unclear how many attempts it took to get these 10. Impressive as it is, it's not like that was, I mean, I would be very impressive. It was the kind of first thing they sort of go and then how come these 10 impressive results.
It's unclear kind of what areas they would focus on next and why I mean there are, I imagine business reasons as to putting together which problems they are choosing to publicize that their models can do. So it's, yeah, and they've all the AR labs have been hiring a sort of cohort of senior mathematicians behind the scenes. So it's anyone's guess I think as to whether they do it again. But on the question of proof, I mean, that's is, I suppose, a bit, it's an odd discipline in science and that repeatability is kind of not the same thing like with experimental sciences, a proof is a proof and if it works, it works. It's the problem here is, well, can people follow through what they've done?
Each field is quite highly specialized. So there'll be individual mathematicians who are in those fields that go through those I spoke to that worked in some of the fields that were covered here. Say it all looks very legit. There's also in math says a programming language slash computational proving type thing called lean where you can basically codify mathematical proofs and run them through and it kind of proves that I keep saying prove a lot here. But it will test the rigor and the assumptions of everything going on there and they've published that as well.
So it does appear to hold like no one I spoke to was they may say that the press release has a lot of hype or there's a lot of hype around it. No one seems to be doubting the kind of essential breakthroughs that they're claiming here. I want to stand this subject for one more second. There's the mathematical proof we've generated a proof and that is, as you say, just repeatable in a way that math is just logic. You can just go through the steps and say this proof worked and anybody listening to this who had to suffer through writing a proof in calculus in high school probably remembers that process.
There's something that's pure logic. Then there's a part of it that is software code is just grabbing lean where you can take the pure logic you can express it in code and you can run it to see if it works. I understand how AI is theoretically good at all that. You're just going to run the reasoning and the reasoning is going to generate some code and run the code and it's a bearifiability. We've seen this play out in software engineering where the code runs are not it's verifiable or not and the models can just reason out of it.
Then there's to me that the big question that you alluded to how many times you have to run this. Can we verify that the models did this and they weren't directed by human mathematicians who have been hired at high rates by the labs in a way that suggests the field is going top sea turbine. You have a quote here from James Mater who is one of the fields metal the highest prize in mathematics who said he's been soul searching and I keep looking at that similar quotes from all these mathematicians in the piece and it seems like they're soul searching against a thing that kind of hilariously they cannot verify which is how did the models do this and is that being scalable in a way that threatens mathematics. What do we know about how the models did this? I'd say as much as we normally do and do not know about this.
I think there are a few issues there. One is the nature of the model as well. This is an unreleased model so good luck to anyone wanting to independently test it. I mean the same with that goes with anything proprietary really. That said I am inclined to kind of almost get the benefit of the doubt that they're not lying in some capacity about the models they're using.
As for the other part I think it's perhaps more noteworthy on how do we prompt this or how has it been guided and whether that's by a mathematician that knows what they're doing. I think that's probably a key factor here is a lot of mathematicians I suppose when they've tried using these and this is often the consumer models but still it kind of speaks to a broader landscape and they say that if you know what you're doing and you can kind of point things out it's good or you can use it as a tool in a way that you want. In a way that you wouldn't be able to if you didn't really know how to fact check it. I mean the same time as if I mean I've had it where I've had it where I've had to chat to be teal saying doing a basic sum and I'm like that number is not right. It's like, well, sorry, you're right, it's this and it's still wrong.
But that's kind of still needed at this level as well. I think it does allude to a kind of broader problem. As you said, kind of this almost soul searching of, well, what if we can automate that away and what if it gets a point where we don't understand it? That really cuts to a deeper question like, well, what is mathematics? Why do we do it?
Why do we value it as a field? I mean, everyone will have different answers to that I think. A fear of a lot of people I spoke to was that if this might kind of move beyond around the human interest, in which case, well, maybe they just won't engage with it or it'll be something that interest of people will go through and then the rest will kind of continue as normal. You got a quote here from a researcher in Zurich named Johannes Schmidt who says, we'll be headed toward a situation where the math problems get quote, mowed down by AI, but we don't actually push the field forward because humans are taken out of the loop and they're not either checking or they don't understand it or they don't know what the future breakthroughs might be. How likely does that feel?
Is that a big concern? There is an element of that of the mowing down of the problems and especially those are used as a training field for younger mathematicians coming up and to cut their teeth, so to speak. I also think that this problem solving idea is a very much out-of-siders perspective of the mathematical endeavor. A lot of the mathematicians I spoke to sort of found that almost tick box part, the least interesting and valuable part of the field. The areas that are valuable for them aren't that you've solved something or you've proven something.
It's what happens from that. I think it was James Maynard that said the most interesting discoveries in this isn't that you've solved something, it's what evolves from that. Is it open and tiny? And you feel the research that they've never thought was possible? Or, oh, this is a new tool that you can apply everywhere in the exciting ways.
I think if we look at what almost the kind of popularization of maths, even what I'm thinking of is kind of those theorems that people oppose. It's the questions that didn't do it, not the solutions. It's always kind of fun, that's the last theorem, not like, well, here's the solution to whatever the last day proposed. I think the concern here is that they're going to take off all of these questions, but normally in the process of doing so, one would hope would branch out into all of these new exciting areas or pose new questions, but it won't do that. That's the concern.
And then that would kind of leave the field quite sterile. And it will have all of these things that have been done and maybe nothing left to pursue. And the general consensus was, well, the jury's out. It's too early to tell. Like, even with human mathematicians, it takes a lot of time to kind of realize the impact of these kinds of things.
And it's, as I said, it's kind of exploded in the last six months to a year, which, I mean, maths is not a false moving discipline at the best of times, but it's too early to tell really whether that will then be a kind of concern. But it is a concern and a big one. You have another quote from Inert here saying, if the standard for a published paper and maths is something that AI cannot do, particularly when a PhD is typically four years, the challenge is you're not trying to come up with a problem that AI can't do now, it's an AI in four years time. And so this is really related to the rate of improvement of the models, which, as you say, particularly math, it seems to be increasing, but not in even right across all of the domains and mathematics. That appears to be what is causing the soul searching, right?
If you're a student and you start today and you pick some obscure domain that maybe the AI isn't good at, sometime halfway through your PhD thesis or your PhD research, they will just solve it and you'll be done. And that is a real problem for you. Is the field reacted to that yet? Or are they just in the truck of the models can start to do things that we didn't think they were capable of? Yeah, I think it's shock, really.
I mean, I, the little notebook I have when I do these inches, I keep one to the side to just do broad feelings and I've written shell shock in it because it just feels that it's and it's far from universal, but it feels like it's happened so quickly that it has just taken a lot of people by surprise. I mean, even if it's, they kind of knew in theory that, well, this is coming, they've seen all these sort of AI math startups kind of going, they've seen colleagues being moving around to different labs or kind of areas of work, but yeah, it's just happened very, very quick. And so it's given them very little time to kind of figure out what, and it's not so even the fields that might be good at, it's more just like what can it do?
Like it's just that's how quickly it's happened is that. If I think like what six months, I'm thinking of like an academic year in the UK from, well, I guess I'm like October through to, well, October, but I can't imagine how when I was studying if something like this had gone out and literally in the space of half a year, it just upended what was possible and over the summer as well. So students are possibly coming back to a completely different discipline off a break. We have to take a break. We'll be back in just a minute.
We're back with the Virgis Robert Hart discussing my mathematicians are so concerned that what AI is doing to the discipline. There's some skepticism here in the world. The theory market is a reliable skeptic of AI. And he pointed out that over and over again, what you see is AI accomplishes something in one domain and then it's used to generalize AI's ability across every domain. A good quote here, as we learned a decade ago from AI, shembalik and ultimately failed the term, jeopardy-winning Watson into a cancer-fighting machine.
Success in one domain does not guarantee success in all. I can read this two ways. One, there's AI has solved math, which is not true as you've pointed out in several ways. All the way down to it's still bad at counting. And then there's AI solved math.
And that means necessarily it's going to come for everything else. It will come for physics. It will come for law. It will come for whatever you want in the world. And you can see if there's any verifiability AI can solve it because you can just run it in this way.
I understand both sides of that argument. The obviously success in one domain does not guarantee success in every domain. And then the arc of AI is, well, it keeps collecting domains. And if there is any verifiability, it is more likely to connect those domains than not. How do you see it?
I'm not entirely sure that the people that Marcus is criticizing here have actually said quite what he says they are saying as well. There's a lot to say about the hype. But yeah, success in one domain does not even equal success throughout that domain alone other domains. I mean, that said, there has been an undeniable trajectory, I think, in the last few years of a broadening capability increase. And I don't think you need to be on the whole AGI train to acknowledge that and to acknowledge that that will have an impact.
I mean, with the mathematics, I mean, it is the case of, I think was Andrass Duhas, I've probably butched his name there. But one of the professors at Oxford, I quoted in the story, but something else he'd said to me was that he's been kind of toying around with Chatsu BT a bit. And he's like, I don't think it has any geometric intuition whatsoever. And he's like, which might explain why there have been a very kind of limited amount of progress in fields like topology. I mean, no position to verify that in terms of the maths of it.
But I think it illustrates it quite well. I mean, it is, it's almost like what is it they call it a jacket edge. And it felt like an easy argument for me. The whole let's, let's criticize the whole, the singularity is near. And I mean, I think that's what Elon Musk said in response to the astro thing, which it's a lot.
I also think it's perhaps the least generous interpretation of that argument you can take to argue against. I think if you take them when you want to element that does acknowledge that there has been clear progress here and quite quickly, and as you said, it is racking up domains. I feel there's a trajectory that is like a reasonable one to like consider rather than just miss out of hand. One of the bigger arguments about AI in general is that it democratizes access. I was not a great software developer in my days trying to write software code.
And now I can buy code apps, it will, to do all kinds of dumb stuff in my house. Is there a similar argument here where a bunch of people who had mathematical intuition but did not have a formalized language or training of academic mathematics can now access a model and push the field forward? Because that is usually the thing that undercuts the criticism from the professionals is well, many, many more people have access to things that only you had access to because of your money in your training. Yeah, I mean, annoyingly, I am going to say it's a two-prompt thing again. But yes, I mean, on a broad sense, yes, it is.
I mean, a lot of the mathematicians I spoke to were almost quite weary of this, actually. They love the idea and theory of democratizing access. They are also quite fed up of AI-generated slash assisted papers that are flooding every publication manageable as well as the preprint servers that they use in these fields. At least two, I think I spoke to you were like, oh, I got three emails this week alone with people being like, hey, is this legit? Because they thought they told something with chat to be here with Claude.
They also don't have the mathematical skills with which to check whether they have actually solved something. I mean, on the flip side, they are part of where they said we have taunted on the ground, we have attempted on the ground, we have never managed. And here they are doing grad level work and they have produced a paper that is legit. And on the kind of bigger schema things, a few I said, well, yeah, a lot of these kind of are in the ivory tower, having access to this kind of thing globally could really boost access to the kind of things. I mean, on the flip side, the cost.
I mean, these things cost to run. It's always easy to forget. I think when you say free version of chat GBT or Claude or something to the high levels, these things cost money. And whilst they may not necessarily cost a lot of money, I mean, opening, I claimed, I think it was 2K for these 10 results, which again, doesn't factor in literally anything else once they've got these. So it's a very generous number.
But even taking that figure, that's quite a poor discipline, even at very well off institutions. I mean, Colvo, Rini, Duke, St. Andrew's, so I said, she said, well, a lot of the time I don't bother getting a research grant, I don't need one, I just had the blackboard. And so like, if you're not even getting, say, research grant, two grand is a lot to put up. And so it could lock out researchers that way, even at quite well-funded institutions.
Not to mention that the speed of which is happening that actually nobody would have been able to bake any of this into a ground proposal yet was another theme that I came across a lot. So Rini Tugel has another great quote in your piece about the nature of the AI labs and how they are talking about math. She said, the treating our discipline is an advertising playground, a bunch of mathematicians have signed something called the latent declaration, which is an open letter to pledge not to buy into hype around AI. These things are running right at each other. The AI labs are not going to stop using every discipline as an advertising playground.
And a bunch of mathematicians saying we refuse to buy the hype certainly does not seem to be stopping the hype. There's just a piece of this that is organized professional resistance to a thing that is up ending a field. This, as you say, been pretty cheap to operate and now might be getting cheaper or easier to access or easier to up end day by day. Do mathematicians feel that is going to be effective? Historically mathematicians are not like savvy political operators.
They're just going to get run over. I do know the history of maths actually. I think a lot of them were quite savvy. Isaac Newton is the one that always comes to mind for that. They're quite a petty political operator as well.
But yeah, I mean, that is the fit. I mean, it's a few that I spoke to and one really comes to mind as they say that there's often this belief that maths is kind of the pinnacle of knowledge. We're not live so I can be free on this one. But he was like, well, that's bullshit because he wasn't alone in kind of illustration. That sentiment, but it is good for showcasing.
And it's a lot neater as a discipline and a lot cheaper than, I mean, you mentioned with Marcus saying, I DM's what's most this cancer curing thing. Well, that involves lots of messy experiments, including on people. You don't need that in this. So it's a really easy discipline to kind of come in, throw your weight around and then move to somewhere more lucrative if that's what you want. I'm not saying that that's what they are.
I mean, a lot of the people at these companies that have kind of been hired. I mean, I don't doubt the credentials for sure. I don't doubt the motivations as well. It does raise a question long term as to like how viable is this because I mean, let's declare as a field goes, I cannot imagine them being a very lucrative enterprise customer for these companies. The thing that might be lucrative is pushing a field forward to turn it into something economically viable.
Right. We push mathematics forward as a field that turns into some engineering or physics breakthrough based on mathematics and that turns into another yet another way to launch rockets. Some circle happens in there that I don't quite understand, but that is the history of innovation, right, from research to engineering to products or services that make money. Is that on the minds of any of these mathematicians that pushing the boundaries here is upstream of something radically, economically lucrative? The immediate counter that we're contemplating here is that a lot of scared that it's closing off the field.
So by definition, those breakthroughs that lead to something surprising and new, that you can say, oh, this works here. It may not be happening anymore. And so if anything, that kind of lucrative endeavor of like applying master in this entire new field that may have a lot of money in it, I mean, it remains an open question as to whether that would be anything like that would be possible if we're closing off that new sort of opening them up. Right. If the economic incentive of solving the unsolved problem is reduced because you personally don't get rich if a computer is just solving every unsolved problem, like something very fundamental breaks there.
I mean, a lot of it comes down to though, like, it's not just solving problems. I mean, a lot of these things as we said, like, it's about what solving that problem tells you elsewhere. And it's those else where's that like these were very lucrative problems to be solving. I imagine more people will be trying to solve them than to solve left them for decades. So like, but it's possible that in and this is the nature of a lot of kind of pure science.
And it's, I'd say, broader criticism of what is going on. Perhaps with the Trump administration's approach to science policy at the moment, in that it's very applications focused, there is something to do in pure research that can yield potentially very big dividends. That is by definition utterly unpredictable as well, but you cannot plan for it. And the fear is, I think, with maths is that in solving all of these problems and then also in doing so, not opening up new areas of research, in that sort of, I suppose, that open question, well, what are you left with? Even if it's from more lucrative, kind of like, what are you going off the point of view?
If you're not opening up new areas of research and you're just taking off old ones, we kind of just leave some big sort of question mark as to what might be left in its wake. And I think the sentiment of almost even from those I was excited that I was very excited about what's happening. They said that even they don't really know what's happening. They're excited from a personal level, because all we might be just doing is that. But there was still this lingering uncertainty of, well, where does this leave the field?
Especially for more pure disciplines like research and mathematics, it's tougher to say what comes next. Because in a lot of the other sciences, you can say, well, okay, well, they'd shift on to more engineering problems or applying that. But if you solve all the problems at the ground, and there's nothing being built up from that or where do you go from there? One great thing about the Verges, our commenters are vast, they're very knowledgeable, and there is a comment from a mathematics researcher on your story that I just want to read to you and see if you think this is the right framework. Here it is.
Quote, I have no doubt these models will bring massive change in the field, but in their current state, they won't yet drive us to obsolescence. Just occupy a particular useful spot in our bag of tricks. My apprehension comes from not knowing where these things will peak, but overall, I remain optimistic. I think AI will be a net boon for math when used properly. I feel like AI will be a net boon for X when used properly is just where you land in life in a lot of things.
But that's the most optimistic response that I've heard. If we get it right, it's going to be great. Is that kind of the vibe, or is it still more shell shock than that? Yeah, I'd say shell shock is still the overriding impression. I mean, I think perhaps the gut response is that it will be a net positive for whom and what is properly.
All of those are quite legitimate questions here, I think. I mean, some of the bleak responses from graduate students are in essays posted online. Where's their placeness as future researchers? Do they have a place in this? Is it as glorified AI proof checkers?
That would be quite unsatisfying career, I imagine. Or maybe not, I don't know, but that's, we will see, I think anything used properly will be in that boon. But yeah, I think it will come down to what properly means and for whom we're talking about. I suspect over the next year or so, things will come into focus because at some point, OpenAI will have to show people how they did the things in the models. And perhaps more importantly, the other labs are going to want to either replicate these results or show that they can push farther, which will necessarily have to lead to a little bit more transparency and yet more mathematicians having a crisis with you.
Rob, thank you so much for being on the show. We'll have you back for a second. Thank you for having me. I'd like to thank Rob for taking the time to join me on Decoder and thank you for listening. I hope you enjoyed it.
So if you don't know what you thought about this episode or anything else, drop us a line. You can email us at decoderattheverge.com, really do read all the emails or you can be directly on threads or blue sky. Also on YouTube, you can watch full episodes at decoderpod. Also, TikTok and Instagram, same handle at decoderpodat and they're a lot of fun. If you'd like to carefully share with your friends and subscribe over your podcasts, the Curtis Freshman version, part of the Boxing and Podcast Network, show us free space by K-CocksNix.net, this episode is edited by Ursa Wright, our supervising producer at Screg Ot, our editorial director is Kevin Machine, the decoder music is by Greg Master cylinder.
We'll see you next time.