Before he published the Prince, Machiavelli published a seducer. Before he published a masterpiece of political philosophy, he published a comedy. The Mandugola, or the Mandrake, tells the story of Kaleemoko. And by the way, these Italian names, if I put drum, forgive me, go back to Italy, whatever you want.
Do the best I can. Anyway, he tells the story of Kaleemoko, a handsome young man and seducer of women. Kaleemoko hears about a Florentine beauty named Lucretia and begins a conspiracy to seduce her, the problem that she's married. She's married to a wealthy old man who can't get her pregnant and the need of son to maintain their political position.
Kaleemoko shows up disguised as a doctor and convinces her husband to give her a Mandrake potion to increase her fertility. The problem is Kaleemoko tells the old man the first man who sleeps with her after she takes the potion will die. That's the problem. They decide to find an unwitting dupe to have sex with her.
Kaleemoko, in different disguise, becomes the dupe, much to his delight. And Lucretia's. You see, at first, she was hesitant to sleep with Kaleemoko, but she relented and convinced it was divine providence, takes a mess with her lover indefinitely. So it's like Al's wall that ends well, it turns out, well, the old man got his male heir, spawn of Kaleemoko.
And Kaleemoko gets Lucretia over and over again. So that's good, right? It all makes sense. The old man gets his heir, Lucretia gets her son and stable marriage, and a young lover, Kaleemoko gets laid.
The problem is it's adultery. It's prohibited by the sixth commandment. But there were earthly ambitions at stake. Kaleemoko's lust in the old man's societal position.
If a rational plan, a design to accomplish an earthly goal, is impeded by an old legend from Mount Sinai, the old legend must be ignored. The Mandagolo was, practically, a bizarro, medieval morality play. The morality play medieval times, basically had a Christian moral, this is like the bizarro, Superman bizarro flip it over, completely opposite. Now I shift over to the prince.
The same mental dynamic is in play. There is a clear, earthly ideal in Machiavelli's appearance, improvement of one's country and its rulers, bettering their position. All efforts must be rationalized from that ideal, even the concept of quote-unquote virtue shifts and turns in Machiavelli's hands, depending on how a supposed vice of virtue must be used to accomplish those ideals. It sometimes means traditional notions of morality or virtue.
It sometimes means whatever advances the ruler in his country, no matter how devious. And all those other things from Mount Sinai, like prohibitions against murder, stealing, and lying, they get sloughed off Machiavelli tells us by the good prince, just as long as the prince is furthering his and his country's interest in the process. Okay, now Machiavelli lived from 1469 to 1527, just before Descartes and Bacon, who have pointed out before are the builders of modernity's Tulane Freeway. He lived as Christendom was nearing his final stage before crumbling.
He lived to see the first years of the Reformation. He was born just after the Roman Empire, completely fell. That's the fall of Constantinople in 1453. And shortly before Columbus showed everyone the elementary geography lessons had always been wrong.
He lived in that final stage I've written about, or talks about rather in previous podcasts. After 200 years of upheaval and catastrophes, both physical and mentor, Europe was strung out. I call it the Great Fatigue. The Great Fatigue first manifested itself in literature through this proto-modernist Machiavelli.
He latched on to an ideal, the ideal of a perfect ruler who advances his country, and explained how to reach that ideal. For the good prince, all of the considerations and rules are ignored if they don't fit into the logic that flows from the ideal. Murder and dishonesty, those are fine, as long as they're logically fitted into the ideals of promoting the ruler in this country. Adultery?
That would be fine too, as long as it furthers a rational ideal like it did in the Mandagola. Now if you dig into Machiavelli's roots, you'll get to the real problem with rationalism. It rejects irrationalism. More precisely, it rejects as irrational anything that conflicts with a rationalist ideal.
If an old man needs a son, and the traditional prohibition against adultery thwarts it, then the traditional prohibition against adultery needs to be eliminated. The stupid to uphold the archaic prohibition when there's a greater good, i.e. rationalist ideal, at stake. By eliminating the prohibition on adultery, which is simply irrational in this situation, the old man was free to attain the ideal of a male heir.
The loosing of a myriad of irrational norms or customs that had developed over the centuries became the drumbeat of freedom in the early stages of modernity, greatly celebrated by the rationalizing likes of Voltaire and the Enlightenment, who'd never missed an opportunity to attack a norm whose roots were so deep and intricate, they could neither see nor understand it. Not a big fan of Voltaire and the Enlightenment, you may figure out. They attacked things and didn't even understand. And that's a fact, by the way, that's not an opinion.
All sorts of explanations, justifications, and yada yada yada, that's fine, but Voltaire has been proven just the things he said. And retrospect, he does see this shot from the head as a celebrity scholar. He had no idea what he was attacking, often didn't even have his facts right. Anyway, in the modern world, this song means everything that does not fit into the logical scheme that flows from rationalist ideals is rejected, often vehemently, by people who aren't aware that they're rationalizing from ideals that have a little more substance than what their minds have told them.
Now, I kind of like Machiavelli. He was, as I said, a proto-modern. He came early enough in the game that he knew what he was doing. He knew he was promoting ideals that were consistent with traditional rules, hence his use of the word virtue in different ways, enamelses if he was like playing with or taunting traditional authorities, probably in particular with the Catholic Church.
Now, the real problem is, as my dirty March Donne, Machiavelli's approach became implicit. After Descartes, after Descartes explained why ideals should be celebrated and revered, everyone became Machiavellian, but they increasingly didn't even know it. They increasingly discarded norms and customs in pursuit of the rationalist ideals, but completely ignorant that they had to even embrace rationalist ideals. So anyway, what are some of these rationalist ideals?
I like to mean many things. They might be still to worldviews, like those that snare G.K. Justin's maniac. And if you go to the blog that you'll see a brief essay on, Justin's maniac, they might be privileged polls in a new system of binaries that emanate from a new local centralism in the terminology, Jacques Derrida.
Such things, these rationalist ideals restrict our thinking and our existence. They limit our development. Sometimes they morph into a type of rationalist or secular religion. They become Ursat's religions in the terminology of Eric Vogelen.
In light of the Cartesian tendency to elevate rationalist ideals to lofty status, they tend to attain deity status in our little rationalist pods. And when they do, they're serious trouble. Quote, for when gods fight among themselves, men have to die. Unquote, that's a ten-gill song from his excellent book, God of Philosophy from Yale University Press, like 1952, something like that.
So these rationalist ideas get elevated in our minds, higher and higher, higher, they become little religions, or basically secular religions like Fascism or Communism. A lot of our political beliefs are little religions, or Ursat, fake religions. That's a major problem. We're going to be exploring these in great detail.
Thanks for being with us.