Hello, and thank you for downloading Witness from the BBC World Service. Fifty-five years ago, a show opened on Broadway which proved that stage musicals could deal with heavyweight topics. West Side Story, with music by Leonard Bernstein, was inspired by Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet, but it moved the action to New York, then plagued by violent street gangs. For Witness, Vincent Dowd has been speaking to two people involved in the original production.
These days, Midtown Manhattan, between 34th Street, 8th Avenue, and the Hudson, is officially called Clinton, but it's long had another name too, Hell's Kitchen. Until the 50s, it had a reputation as home to New York's violent gang culture, but in 1957, the area became the unlikely setting for a new Broadway musical based on Shakespeare. The basic concept had been kicking around for a decade, but choreographer Jerome Robbins' idea of updating Romeo and Juliet to contemporary New York changed radically along the way. The eventual producer was Harold Prince.
Because originally it was going to be the love affair of a Gentile and a Jew, and they don't slice each other up with knives. Then circumstances changed, and there was a race war on the streets of New York in what we used to call Hell's Kitchen. That then changed the whole storyline and made a much more dynamic one. When you're a jet, you're the top man in town.
You're the gold metal kid with the heavyweight crown. When you're a jet, you're the swing and it's big little boy. You're a man, little man, you're a king. Another producer had been working with the composer Leonard Bernstein and the young lyricist Stephen Sondheim, but she pulled out, fearing the challenging material was not commercial.
That was when Sondheim called his friend Hal Prince at work out of town. And I said, we have a Sunday off, I'll fly into New York with my partner Bobby Griffith, and we'll meet you at Lenny's apartment. Lenny played the score very loudly because he was nervous, because it was, after all, a very audacious project. Steve sang the lyrics with Lenny, and by the time we'd left, we had decided to produce the show.
Two things about West Side Story were new. The plot, a love story against a background of violence between two gangs, the Jets and the Sharks, was gritty and dark. It showed parts of Manhattan's West Side as dominated by tensions between locals and new immigrants from Puerto Rico. Jerry Robbins also did something which was a real innovation.
The young cast had to do three things on stage which had been separate. They acted, they sang, and they danced in a new jazzy idiot. One of the young dancers playing a jet was Martin Charnin. There was an open call for authentic juvenile delinquents who could sing and dance.
They would assemble at the Broadway Theatre in the alley. At that point, Robbins and Steve had run out of places to go in terms of having scoured every conceivable avenue for people who could perform as Jets and Sharks. You were cast as Big Deal. Right.
Big Deal ended up being the only one who had any one-line jokes to the extent that in my audition, when I auditioned, I read two scenes that had a couple of jokes in them, and I got the laughs. If we listen to the original cast album, are you audible on that? Is there anything where you can go, that's Martin Charnin? Oh, sure.
I'm the judge in that recording of Krupke, and I'm very, very proud of that moment. Lyricist Stephen Sontine and scriptwriter Arthur Lawrence weren't sure a slightly corny comic number suited the show, but how Prince knew who would like it, the audience. The creators were so pure that they didn't want Officer Krupke finally, and I know, my partner and I thought it was vital to let a little of the steam out that the audience was feeling, that it was maybe just too tense an experience. But of course it's inappropriate, because a bunch of street kids do not sing a song about psychoanalysis.
In the theatre's like that, every once in a while you have to be pragmatic. So this opened exactly 55 years ago. Was it a smash hit? It was not.
It was reviewed as a cold piece by the major newspapers. They thought it was more intellectual than moving. We always had walkouts every night because it was so untraditional. As many as 200 people would leave the theatre.
The first audiences were split by the show's bold new style of dancing. It's no secret. Choreographer Jerry Robbins could be difficult to work for. Martin Charnin says in rehearsal he could be a monster.
But funnily enough, it was one of those situations where Jerry's monster, which surfaced absolutely, was acceptable. If being a monster is ever acceptable, you realise that you were in the presence of an extraordinary talent and somebody who knew what he wanted and was trying to get the best out of you. However tough Robbins was, his dance was a huge part of what's made West Side Story a classic. Plus, of course, the sheer kinetic energy of Leonard Bernstein's music.
How Prince says he knew that was special long before he ever heard an orchestra play it. After all, when Leonard Bernstein plays the piano, you hear the orchestra. Seriously, he does a lot of his own orchestrations as well, the way traditional operatic composers did. I knew standing in the back of rehearsals or in the back of the theatre when we started to perform for audiences, what I was seeing was unprecedented.
Leonard Bernstein went on to write symphonies and much else. He died in 1990. Jerry Robbins died in 1998 and Arthur Lawrence last year. Stephen Sondheim, now 82, went on to write the most influential music theatre of the past half century.
As for Martin Charnin, he gave up performing to become a writer. In the 70s, he wrote the lyrics for the smash hit musical Annie. 55 years on, he recalls West Side Story as a timeless classic. The music was stunning, and those people who really knew and appreciated what Lenny was doing and what he ultimately accomplished with the score were in awe of it.
To my way of thinking, and I've been in this business a really long time, there has never, ever been a score that approached West Side. Never, ever. Really cool. Witness was written and produced by Vincent Dowd.
For details of our complete range of downloads and our terms of use, go to bbcworldservice.com slash podcasts.