Packages by Expedia. You will make some occasionally take the hundreds to the top of the Eiffel Tower. We will make it to easily bundle your trip. Expedia made to travel.
From your time's opinion, this is the Ezercline Show. So we are talking on Friday morning. It's March 8th. It is the morning after Joe Biden's State of the Union, which was a raucous enthusiastic affair.
And we thought we'd do a kind of bigger picture episode talking through a bit of State of the Union. And more broadly, what the State of the Union was beginning to preview, which is what Joe Biden's second term will look like. What his pitch in 2024 for that second term will look like, and then what actually that second term will look like. Which I've also been doing a fair amount of separate reporting on.
So I'm joined as I often am in these days by my illustrious editor, Aaron Radica. Aaron, thank you for being here. You're welcome. So where do you want to begin?
Well, the audience can't see it, but I have brought you a replica of a medieval hair shirt to where to mortify yourself after the State of the Union. You know why, but I'm going to ask you about it anyway. Many people actually were tweeting away and talking about how the Biden's performance during the State of the Union was essentially a refutation of your argument from a few weeks ago that he should, in fact, aside from the campaign. So could you talk a little bit about how you felt watching it and what you think about that idea?
I've been the way I felt watching it was excited to see Joe Biden giving a really great State of the Union. I think it would truly be like the height of pundit, ecotism. It'd be like the important thing about this election is whether it proves my prior takes right or wrong. Look, the argument of that piece is that at the time I wrote it, Joe Biden was not performing into the campaign well.
He was doing very little campaigning, doing very, very few interviews, doing relatively few appearances. The ones he was doing were trying to be low-energy affairs when he was going out to give that big press conference. It both did not go well on its own terms, and then he badly messed up the question of how to reassure people about his memory. They were skipping things like a Super Bowl interview.
And the argument of that piece is that Biden was not showing that he's up for this campaign. And if he can't be up for an aggressive campaign, he should not run. Look, if the Joe Biden we get is a Joe Biden of the State of the Union, because that was genuinely an excellent State of the Union. It was surprising in a bunch of different ways, and we could talk about them, but it was very, very well delivered, very high-energy.
I've not seen that Joe Biden in a while. Now, why he was so much better there than he's been in a bunch of other formats I've seen him in cleaning very structured formats, a campaign to set up for him. I'm going to go look at the kind of social media clips they have been circulating. I don't really know.
And I don't really care. The absolute best thing, easiest thing here, is that Joe Biden kind of shook the cobwebs off and is going to campaign like that from here until November. And if he does that, and in the end he beats Donald Trump by five, and people want to say my piece was stupid and alarmist, I will happily say my piece was stupid and alarmist, and I was wrong, and that would be a great outcome. But it was really quite good speech, and Biden wasn't just energized.
He was very, very quick on his feet, and he had something I haven't seen from him in a while, which is something I've associated with him throughout his almost entire political career. A kind of joy, a happy warrior affect. He seemed delighted to be up there. He seemed to be having fun sparring with Republicans, making fun of Lindsey Graham.
I mean, it was a very bare knuckled partisan State of the Union for what that affair typically is, but Biden didn't seem to be plotting through it. There was a real intense energy to him. So there's a long time to in the election, but I hope that guy keeps showing up. And what I will say just from having conversations, even with top Democrats since it, is I think he, at least for now, quieted a lot of the fears, right?
People needed to see a performance like that from him, and they did. What's funny about that is that the State of the Union last year was supposed to be that moment. They were supposed to get crushed in the midterms. They did not get crushed in the midterms.
He then did incredibly well in the State of the Union in 2023. Everyone calmed down. Then all the questions started again. Now he's done well in the State of the Union in 2024.
What do you think they can do to make that a more permanent change and not just he's good when he goes to Congress? Look, I don't know Joe Biden the way they know Joe Biden. I don't really understand the variance in his public performance. It isn't that people were inventing the thing that happened between the two State of the Union's.
The amount of conversation even among top Democrats who were not talking about this in public was very high. People who were out there with him saw him. His styles have become often times very listless, but sometimes it's called low energy. And then he really, really brought it last night.
The reason I am not fully comforted is an election is long. What you're trying to both do is campaign well to a media event, but also avoid things that become a crystallizing moment of fears about you. I don't know that having given a good State of the Union fully comforts me because I don't really understand what separates his good performances from his bad ones. Nobody needs to worry anymore.
But I think the thing he proved last night is that he is capable of extremely high performance. The argument I made in the initial piece was not that he's doing a poor job or not capable of doing the presidency, but that lately he's not improving capable of performing the presidency, performing the campaign. The skills he needed as a campaigner are different. The thing he did in the State of the Union, which more than any State of the Union I've seen was a campaign speech.
I mean, this was much more of a campaign speech you typically get at that particular event. He showed the skills of a campaigner. And if he keeps showing that, then my piece was simply wrong and I will happily own that. So there's been a tremendous amount of chatter about Trump 2025 in our own newspaper, Maggie Habermann and Joe Savage and Jonathan Swan have had an incredible series about what they expect his administration to look like.
Our own Carlos Rosada had a great piece about Paradise Foundation's project 2025. There's been comparatively little discussion of Biden 2025, and that's something that I really want to talk about today. There was not so much about that last night. There were pieces of it, little programs, more like triangulation type bits.
But what do you see as the essential elements of a Biden's administration as it looks now? So I've been doing a bunch of reporting about this. I was at the White House not long ago talking about a bunch of people before the State of the Union about what was the agenda going to be? I was struck talking to people across different issue areas, how much the first thing I heard was finished the job.
And in a way that makes sense because if you think about the major bills of Biden's first term, the Inflation Reduction Act, the Bipartisan Infrastructure Bill, the Chips and Science Act, those are all long multi-year efforts to change America's built environment. And the other in changing the environment, as I report on a lot, is slow going, particularly in this country. And so the Chips and Science Act, one of its core things it's doing is giving $39 billion to semiconductor manufacturing firms to build fabs to the big factories here. That is just beginning giving its initial grants.
They've given only a tiny fraction of the money. The word is we're going to be hearing more such announcements soon. So helping to oversee that, trying to clear Genore Mondo, the Secretary of Commerce has been trying to get Congress to exempt these projects from environmental permitting, which says it'll add years, which I think raises a bunch of questions about what should and should not go to environmental permitting review, but trying to make that actually successful. That's a real project.
The IRA, right? I mean, that is trying to do a huge upheaval of the built landscape. Some parts of that are going really well. We are installing solar faster than we had anticipated or hoped.
Wind is coming in well below expectations. So solar is faster. Wind is slower. This question, particularly offshore wind is proving to be a problem.
Trying to figure out how to un-kink that. That's a lot of work. Building that nationwide EV charging system, which is not yet been built, but is funded in the IRA. That's a big project.
Then all of that needs to plug into a grid that is actually giving you not dirty energy from coal or certain kinds of natural gas or whatever, but is giving you clean energy. The IRA is not going to hit its goal. So they can't figure out how to make it easier and faster to build interstate electricity transmission lines. If they aren't able then to get that clean energy generated from where it is generated, to where the car plugs in, or where the heat pump plugs in, or where whatever it is plugs in, then you didn't solve the problem.
So one thing that I think they are pretty clear-eyed about is a huge amount of their agenda requires a huge amount of implementation and oversight. And if they lost the White House, they would not be able to do that implementation and oversight. And in fact, probably the Trump administration, number two, would throw a huge amount of sand in the gears of that, maybe roll it back all together. So that's a place where I actually do think a lot of the second term agenda in their minds has to do with making their first term agenda into a success.
They pass the bills, but they've not actually yet changed the built environment. Then there are a couple other, I think, big pieces of it. You did hear a fair amount last night about Roe or Dobbs. It's maybe the better way to put it.
It is a little less clear to me what they're actually promising there. So they say, send this bill to Codeify Roe. They don't have votes for that now, right? Republicans control the house.
But even if they had control of the house and Senate, they're not going to have the votes because you can't do that in budget reconciliation. So you need either 60 votes to get around the filibuster, or you need 51 votes to get rid of the filibuster or get a filibuster exemption. Very, very unlikely Democrats have either of those things in the Senate. But simply by being there, they have something that they will lose if Donald Trump came into office, which is, as we talked about on the last episode we did, which is about the way the different state policies on abortion are colliding now, there is a huge amount of effort.
And it would go up to the top of the Trump administration, if they won, to make it illegal, possibly to even use, but definitely to send these abortion pills, which have become the dominant way. The abortions are happening in the country. And the reason that DOB does not lead to quite the restriction in abortion access, that its proponents thought it would, if Trump is elected, they have all kinds of plans to do away with that, including potentially saying the FDA wrongly approved mythopress tone when it was evaluated the first time. So long as Biden is there and is appointing the FDA commissioner, that's not going to happen.
So that is in practice a very big deal. And I guess we'll talk about this, but Biden is not going to wrap up the major foreign policy crises or projects of his presidency in his first term. There's going to be no end to Russia's invasion of Ukraine. It seems unlikely to me they'll be able to execute the pivot they want to execute on moving towards this kind of grand deal where Israel gets recognition from Saudi Arabia in return for recognizing a Palestinian state.
That's a much bigger project. And then of course, the geo strategic competition with China. And so that would be a huge part of a second term to and all those things obviously were big parts of speech. Okay, I'm going to take those one at a time and just go on the order that you did implementation administration.
How did those become transformation? Obama famously criticized Clinton for not transforming America. The way Reagan had if Biden has eight years in office, you know, looking back from Biden in 2029. Does the kind of work that you're talking about finishing the job on the chips act and IRA transforming the way he wants to do?
Or is that even though it's an enormous project too small board to actually change the way the United States operates? I think I have two levels to this. Let's take level one in the hypothetical where he wins the second term and all these policies work because that's an asterisk. But if they do, then yes, I think so.
I mean, take Obama's example here, right? Obama wins two terms. I don't think most people can name very much legislation passed in Obama's second term. They do do something.
I mean, they do a huge education reform bill, which was passed relatively quietly and mattered quite a bit as a kind of update and reauthorization and transformation of no child left behind. But I don't think people think that is transformative. What they think of as transformative about Obama are things like the Affordable Care Act, the investments made during the stimulus, the Dodd-Frank financial reforms. I mean, those were all first term bills.
I think Biden is likely to look similarly. I mean, one reason is the map for Democrats in the Senate is just God awful. In 2024, even if Biden wins and does really well, it is a very tough road in a way that it wasn't even in 2022 to keep the Senate. So they're going to lose with the West Virginia seat.
Joe Manchin is retiring. They're not going to keep that seat. And they have a bunch of other. That brings them just for clarity to 50, right?
That would bring them to 50. They just got to win. They got to win in Nevada. There are a bunch of places Republicans could easily pick up a seat and not many places where Democrats could easily pick up a seat.
So Democrats basically have to run the table, not completely impossible, but unlikely. So that's one one to mention this. I do think, though, that if these policies worked, if at the end of Joe Biden's second term, you look around and there is a nationwide, like coast to coast real electric vehicle charging structure, such you can truly have the electric vehicle revolution without people being limited by range anxiety and the feeling that they couldn't make an interstate drive feeling safe about it. That's a very big deal.
If the percentage of energy generated from clean sources, skyrockets, that's actually a very, very big deal, right? And including solar wind costs come down as part of that. If some of the deeper investments are making and things like green hydrogen, right, they have a lot of more long shot investments happening there. They're trying to decarbonize industrial buildings like that isn't super sexy, but if they are able to build these innovation hubs and able to get these things moving and get people using heat pumps, all that is a really big deal.
I mean, in a very literal way, if they succeed, the appliances that people have in their homes are going to be different. They are going to have heat pumps and not gas furnaces. The cars they have in their driveways are going to be different. That would actually be quite literally transformational.
And then, of course, there's chips in science, which I think the big thing people know there, if they know anything, it's a semiconductor effort. If we're able to onshore advanced semiconductor manufacturing, which is a very big if that would be a huge deal, right? That is, I think, probably the single most important and strategically critical industry in the 21st century. Then you have the question of will all this work?
And all of these two achieve what they need to achieve still have pretty big roadblocks. The way I would put this is that Democrats have been very good at addition and not very good at subtraction. Tyler Cowan, who's a more right leaning economist at George Mason University, he had a good Bloomberg column on this, where he was skeptical. He was thinking it's too early to know if I did not make this work.
And I thought his best line in that column was what they have not done is really any deregulation. And I do think that's true. So take chips in science. They need a huge amount of workforce to make that work.
We do not have enough people who know how to do semiconductor manufacturing and building semiconductor facilities. And so the ones we are building are coming in way over cost and are getting delayed and delayed and delayed. And we don't have enough people who don't run those facilities. They have all kinds of ideas in the regulations they've built around that to try to bring more women and minorities into construction there.
They have ideas about how to train workforces and community colleges. And it's all laudable stuff. But if you want to serve the workforce problem fast, what you would do is create a visa pathway for skilled workers on these issues from other countries. We should just be bringing a lot of people from South Korea and Japan.
So you can deregulate that and bring people in if you were able to get the votes on it. Similarly, the environmental permitting is proving to be a very, very big problem on semiconductors. Again, Ramondo is trying to get the house on the Senate to pass something exempting this part of the Biden agenda from the environmental bills like NEBA. That failed in the house.
They were not able to get that done. Similarly, the permitting is a big problem on the inflation reduction act. They want to do all of this building and all this building which is built to help the environment can all be sued under its environmental impact. I've done a huge amount of reporting on the San Francisco's big theme of my coming book.
Even something as simple as congestion pricing in New York City, where you're just hanging sensors on poles to charge cars for driving into New York City, that was tied up in years of environmental assessment. And so they really do have a problem here. One place where I would ding the Biden administration is even hiding behind other people in their effort to address this. They sort of hid behind Joe Manchin's proposals here, right?
Manchin is demanding this package and they put some stuff they liked into the package. Then they tried to sort of do it in this weird debt ceiling deal. What they have never done, what they did not do at the State of the Union, is come out and say, this is our agenda for building back faster. We have passed our agenda for building back better.
Here's how we are going to do it faster. Here are the ways we're going to unshackle government to reach its goals more quickly. Coalitionally, that's very hard for them. It puts them crosswise with environmental groups with various kinds of social justice groups.
Now, you have to get to see some movement here. There has been a movement among some House Democrats to come up with a permitting reform bill of their own. I think that has some good aspects and some not as good aspects. But that's interesting, right?
That's a move you haven't seen really before. The Democrats are getting engaged on this. So yes, if everything they have passed worked, I think that would be remembered as genuinely transformational. Whether the things they have passed will work.
That remains to be seen and is not simply an outcome on autopilot. One thing that they're doing that sort of stealth and fusible is having programs that are not just one group or another. Republicans are always trying to make it seem like this is for climate lunatics or whatever. But actually the number of people who are affected by this is in the hundreds of thousands of millions for all of these programs.
And they're not specifically for the poor. They're not specifically for any particular group. And they're more of a rising tideless all boats kind of structure, which I think is interesting. And do you have thoughts about this with politics in that?
I don't think that is actually so different. I mean, Obamacare was also a race neutral bill. And I think that reflects how Clinton governed. I think it reflects how Obama governed.
I think it reflects how Joe Biden governed. Inside these bills, there is a lot of effort to address certain kinds of equity. If you look inside the guts of all these proposals, you'll find things about how different bids are getting evaluated and how different grants are getting given out and the bonus addition on the money. If you're building this in a disadvantaged community, there's actually quite a lot on that.
I think more than people realize, but that also goes backwards. So I've been doing a bunch reporting for both my book and for a piece on California High Speed Rail. And one of the things people in California wonder a lot about is why did they start building this line in the Central Valley, Baker's Field and Merced, which is currently all they have any real plans to build or finish, which is not where you build high speed rail. The population centers are not nearly dense enough to make that work.
One of the reasons is that when the California High Speed Rail Authority tried to get that federal money that Barack Obama talked about a lot in the stimulus and Barack Obama talked endlessly there about high speed rail. High speed rail across the country, but part of California, as one of the signature reinvestment dimensions of the stimulus, one of the signature projects. But to actually apply for the program, it wasn't just, can you build some high speed rail? It had these preferences, including for things that would handle or clean up air pollution in disadvantaged communities.
And so if you wanted to look for where you had really bad air pollution in your disadvantaged community, you were looking at things like Fresno, California. And so the actual money that came from the feds in the stimulus was in a way people did not realize actually not just for high speed rail, but was to also hit these other equity markers. And so that led to them beginning this bill that in a place that in terms of the political economy of it doesn't make a ton of sense. There are other things that might be good about it, like it's a little bit flatter and straighter for you to test your trains, but it's I think politically a huge problem for high speed rail that it has started in the politically weakest part of California.
You know, you got a high speed rail near LA. It's like, great. You have it from biggest field of timber said, people are like, why? Inside these bills, there's a lot of that.
Some of it, of course, Biden is bragging about, right? He talked about by American and he talked about the ways in which that has not been enforced even by recent democratic administrations. And there are people who care about climate who think that's a bad idea that we should be just trying to get as much climate infrastructure as cheap as we possibly can as quickly as we possibly can and trying to combine that with the construction and preference of American supply chain. Even if that is good political economy, even if it sounds good, in the end won't be good because it's going to slow you down.
It's going to raise prices and people aren't going to like or benefit from the program the way the otherwise would. The people like low prices for things. But in terms of that sort of macro impact of the bills. Yeah.
I mean, they're trying to build a nationwide electric vehicle charge station. I think in a direct way that's probably going to be aggressive for a while because electric vehicles are somewhat more expensive. But in a long term way in terms of if it actually works to reduce air pollution and to help with global warming, that helps everybody and helps people know a progressive way. I think the way they do this, which is universal bills inside of them have significant equity considerations is pretty standard at this point for democratic lawmaking.
Hi, this is Ashley. I live in San Francisco with my boyfriend. We would love to officially share a many time subscription with separate logins. We both love cooking, loving in the kitchen, but I'm a 30 minute and under efficient dinner.
GIRL-E. I want a sheep manual. He is very elaborate. He wants to get into the storytelling.
I want to be able to save my easy meals and check off the ones I've completed. And I think him having his own profile would be great. Ashley, we heard you. It's why we created the New York Times family subscription.
You get your own logins and Mr. elaborate. It gets his plus room for two others. Find out more at nytimes.com slash family.
On Dobden Row Biden was making the case last night that there's a larger issue of freedom here. Obviously it's a tremendous issue of freedom in its own right. But he was also making the case that it was a bigger issue tied to larger issues of freedom in the United States. I'm wondering what your thinking is on how that is going to play out in 2025 and further as they are developing their agenda in the second administration.
That question makes me think of an interesting detail in the profile that Evan Osnost did of Joe Biden in a recent New Yorker where he got some time with Biden in the Oval Office. Biden has a really interesting and complex history on abortion. He opposes the initial road decision. He's a moderate Catholic Democrat at the time that it happens.
And moderate Catholic Democrats in general were pro-life. Throughout his career, he has then largely tried to protect abortion rights. He's got a pretty good record on that. But he's always said, and I don't think he's actually bad politics.
And I think it is authentic to him that he is personally uncomfortable with it. And also just talking about a bit of this history. And he notes then that when the decision came down that Biden's reaction inside the White House is at least it has been reported was we're just going to roll back 50 years of rights now. And he experienced it.
And I think this is true for a lot of people, even people who may not personally be that comfortable with abortion is as a rollback of rights that however you feel about abortion, you shouldn't be taking the choice away from people. I mean, this is the power and potency of the framing of choice. People believe in Roe or the set of rights. The way they understand this is not pro-abortion typically.
It's pro-botily autonomy. And I think that Biden is doing a fairly good job talking about it in those terms. I don't know about the kind of connection to this other set of things, right? There was a sort of effort in framing at the beginning of the speech to sort of say, you've got Putin on the march in Ukraine and he's not going to stop there.
You had an assault on this chamber, the Capitol on January 6th and Donald Trump and that movement are not going to stop there. And you've had an assault on rights from Trump appointed judges, like on dogs, and that movement is not going to stop there. I don't necessarily disagree with any of this. It was not the framing of their message in the state of the union that I found most compelling.
I mean, I think that the simple abortion argument is very, very compelling and very true. I don't think the trying to make everything into one issue tends to work. I think that's something that appeals more to what the political scientists would call highly ideological thinkers than to just normal people who mostly don't really feel that what the Supreme Court did on dogs and what Putin is doing in Ukraine are all kind of part of the same bucket. The Biden team wants to make this election about freedom.
To some degree, I think that's going to resonate freedom in democracy is definitely a motivating argument to voters. And I think what is very clear from every speech Joe Biden gives, from every report we get about Joe Biden is that it is motivating to Joe Biden personally. I would not say that I hope it is the central framing of their campaign, but again, I'm not like, I don't win campaigns. So I don't think we really care what I think about that.
I think that's the question of why was he so much more vibrant in the context last night. Maybe this is the thing that animates him and therefore it has to be the thing that they pursue because it's what brings out his best self. I mean, that could be part of it. I don't know.
That may be, but I thought there was a great argument in the state of the union. And for me, just listening, the thing that hit the hardest and felt like it was solving the biggest problem they had and was the most flexible of their arguments, which is midway through when you begin talking about the economy. They have been facing this problem for a while, which is the economy by every measure and marker you can choose looks pretty damn good. Hell of a lot better than anybody was expecting two years ago.
Inflation has come way back down. There's a specific problem of grocery prices, which is very, very upsetting to people and understandably so. But overall inflation is way down. There was no recession.
The labor market is very tight. Way just continued growing, particularly for the poorest Americans. American GDP growth has been very strong. If you compare us to other countries, we look incredibly strong.
You compare how we have grown since the pandemic to a bunch of major European countries to Canada. We're looking great. And yet people are pretty unhappy about it. And I'll be unhappy about it.
They think Donald Trump is much better on the economy. If you want to know the number I find scariest in the whole election, it is the size of Trump's advantage on who do you trust to run the economy. So on the one hand, you can imagine a version where they're trying to say, I feel you're paying. We have a lot of ideas here.
And on the other hand, you can imagine a version of actually wrong. The economy is great. What they did was they began to build this idea of a comeback America, right? Biden says in the speech, America's English comeback, and it is the greatest story never told.
Let's tell it here. And I think comeback America is a really good frame for them because it does two things simultaneously. One, it allows them to make the argument for how far we have come, and we really have come very far for how good the economy is, given where it was a couple of years ago. And it allows them to keep space for the fact that we're not where we would like to be.
The fact that you're in a comeback, even a really great comeback does not mean you've won. Does not mean you can unroll the mission accomplished banner to use the old George W. Busch thing. It does not require you to tell people that everything is great.
It is a way of making an argument about to be a dork about this, a trend and not a level. And I have not heard them come up with a frame for how they talk about their own record in a while. When you go back to Biden's campaign kickoff speech at Valley Forge, it was, I thought, a very strange speech in many ways to have a campaign kickoff speech that has nothing about what you as president have done. It's all about your predecessor.
And I think it's fine to make Donald Trump a big issue in this election. He is a big issue in this election, but you still have to run as the incumbent. And the comeback America framing Biden adopted last night was the strongest run as an incumbent message. I have heard from them by many, many miles.
Yeah, it's an interesting thing because people have been saying, oh, well, you know, he can't run the way Reagan did in 84 as morning in America, and he can't. Because as we've discussed before on the show, like the kitchen table conversation and the elite conversation are very divergent. But the comeback argument does allow the space for that because it allows, as you said, for recognizing that there's still a lot that's not going right. Insistic people that everything is fine would be politically suicidal, actually.
I think one of the challenges they've been facing and people have been talking about this, like pretty openly in this election, is that there's an argument 2020 was a kind of return to normalcy return to stability. And Trump has taken a very direct aim of that argument, right? He's been basically arguing what you've got in his chaos. Chaos in Ukraine, chaos in Israel, chaos on the border, chaos just in the country, look at grocery prices and I, the strongman, will return normalcy.
I will bring back order, right, which is for many people close cousin normalcy. And there's been this question of, you know, what they're going to do about that. Like, no, no, you're the chaos candidate. No, no, you're the chaos candidate.
And this is a place where I disagree with a lot of the media critiques. I think the media's done a very good job reporting on January 6. I think the media's done a very good job reporting on wild things. Donald Trump says, I think people know who Trump is.
Like, even if you look at the New York Times poll that came out recently, we're buying into this quite far down from Trump, a majority, 50 some percent of people believe Trump is guilty of serious. Because Trump is guilty of serious criminality. Just some percentage of those people were going to vote for him anyway. And it is not that it does not deserve reporting, but people know who Trump is.
The thing that I think they do not know or have somehow sort of forgotten is if he's actually not going to running things. That Trump's management is chaotic. That he is not going to run an economy, right? That by the time he left the economy, it was a crap show.
And so I think it's actually quite important for Biden to do to Trump, which Trump is trying to do to Biden, which is take away what Trump's actual strength is. Trump's actual strength is not that people have forgotten in January 6. Trump's actual strength is that people remember January of 2019, right? His actual strength is people look back in a sort of rose colored way, I think.
And remember kind of good economy that they're making more money, that inflation hadn't been high, and they don't really blame him for what came next. Somehow people have just memory hold the last year of the Trump administration, where he mishandled COVID terribly, just absolutely terribly. The economy was in tatters. He was responding to a crisis in just the most bizarre, erratic, egotistical, callous, possible way.
And that's the mess Joe Biden inherited, like just like a total absolute chaotic situation. And they rited the ship. And what I think the comeback economy idea does, the comeback country idea does, is it allows them first to remind people that we were coming back from something that it was not just like 2019 happened in our 2024. Like there was some stuff that occurred in between 2019 and 2024, Donald Trump was president during it.
And comeback America is a good way of combining an argument about how much Joe Biden has done with a constant reminder of what it was Trump left. And you want to run at your opponent's strength, like not just at their weakness. Yeah, there's so many things that are fascinating about this whole situation. But one of them is that you have on the one hand and incumbent to sort of running against an incumbent, except he's not actually, and he has the privileges of the challenger, right?
Trump does. And for them to reset that is absolutely critical. And my sort of fancy pretentious way of thinking about it is that if this is a John Locke election, Biden wins easily, right? But if it's a Hobbes election, everything is more complicated.
All right, you're going to have to explain your fancy way of thinking about this. Well, basically, this is what it is like being edited by Aaron Radica. You'll be turning into peace. You'll be like a little com like this is John Locke election.
I'm going to get started by talking about 1892 in a minute, which is the last time this fall. I'll just say it now, which is the last time this happened, right? We had Benjamin Harrison in Grover Cleveland, Grover Cleveland lost to Harrison, came back in one in 1892. And why did he win?
Well, that's a good question that I don't know the answer to really. I mean, there's no direct comparison to the situation now. It's just the last time where you had to, what is similar is that you had two very unpopular politicians running against each other. And for the Biden administration, it should be a source of fear in the sense that Harrison was unable to push back against Cleveland's idea that things had been better under him.
Anyway, the point of all this is that it can and does happen, that the person who was out gets back in on the argument, both that their administration was superior and that they're going to change what was done. But let's stick with Hobbes. Let's stick with Hobbes and Locke. The basic idea being that, right, if the question is one of order and constitutions and who's going to provide greater freedom and who's a greater threat to the constitutional system, if those kind of questions, which you say Biden is interested in, but it's quite possible that most of America isn't, then he wins easily on that, right?
Because Donald Trump is a clear threat to the constitutional order. It's not a question. It's not a theory. They actually marched on the Capitol, right?
But if it's a Hobbes election, a war of all against all state of nature, right? And you were just driving it. This is what made me think about it. It's an election where the question is, who's strong?
Who's weak? Who's going to save me? Who's going to potentially hurt me? And Biden has to be able to win on those terms also because we don't know what events are going to be like.
If 2024 somehow turns out to be like 1968, right, then so much that is going to come. We haven't seen it in that case. The Martin Luther King Jr. being assassinated to have, kind of being assassinated.
Someone ends up being the Democratic nominee who didn't run in a single primary. I mean, there's so many things that no one could possibly have known were going to happen in March of 1968. Johnson hadn't even said he wasn't going to run yet. That's what I mean.
So if the world continues to feel like it's a state of nature to people, then Biden has to be able to win that election. And I guess what I'm asking is, do you feel that the comeback kid framework will work if that's the field that is prepared for the election? I think I actually really like this. The binary you said.
And I think the thing is you really don't want this to be the binary. This is my biggest worry about a lot of the kind of liberals I've spoken to about the election. They want this to be a referendum on the Constitution, on the existence of American democracy. And to extend the American people refused to cooperate in seeing the election that way.
Their argument is the media needs to yell at them more about it. And tell them they're more wrong about what Donald Trump was like and the threat that he poses. And it's not that you can shelve any of that. I mean, again, the number of stories that we've all done, I mean, we just did an episode on the show a couple weeks ago about whether Donald Trump should be barred from running constitutionally because he's an insurrectionist.
But I do think there are things people know about Donald Trump. And at some point that you have to ask like, the voters you need to win, is this the way they're going to see it? Like, are they open to hearing this from you? I'm not sure all of them are.
I think you have to make arguments that hit people where they are not where you are. And the reason I like the comeback America argument is it's neither a Hobbesian nor a Lockean argument. Because I say maybe it's a Rawlsian argument. You can do it too.
It's a little bit more about, you know, go behind the veil of ignorance. Imagine there's another crisis, right? Imagine another COVID. Imagine another recession.
Like think about how this actually went last time. Who do you want? And which kind of group of people do you want managing it? Well, like, let's look at how America is actually doing now.
And like, let's look at how it was doing at the end of the last guy's presidency. It doesn't require you to force people out of something that they're used to thinking about. So look, I mean, I think you should have both arguments there. And I think part of the power of that state of the union was that he did, right?
He began with the argument that is most compelling to him, the freedom argument. But he made it at some length, the argument that has not really been that present, which is an argument about his own record, his own incumbency. And the kind of America that he is trying to build, right? The kinds of jobs that he is trying to create, the picket lines he has walked, the new technologies he's attempting to invest in, right?
We are in a comeback. The thing it is like is Obama in 2012, right? Obama in 2012 had at this point, he was pulling way above our mind. It is not pulling.
He was beating at Romney in polls. He was pulling in the high 40s and not the high 30s in favorability. So he was already at a much stronger position. But it's easy to forget that the economy was much, much, much worse than, right?
I mean, we were still in a slow, grinding recovery from the financial crisis. And Obama was running not against George W. Bush, who was blamed for the financial crisis in correctly. So he was running against Romney, who had a very good claim to being a strong economic manager.
He had been a governor of Massachusetts. He had been a bank capital. Like he was a businessman. He had made a lot of money.
And what the Obama team was able very effectively to do is make an argument about comeback. We weren't where we wanted to be. But my God, look where we were just four years ago. Look how far we've come.
And if you can just get people to the point that, yeah, things aren't perfect, but things are going well enough that it's better not to do something crazy right now. Somebody is like, you know what? I don't love Joe Biden. I just love the guy.
But I don't know. The economy actually is pretty good. My paycheck is pretty good. Trump seems kind of crazy.
Better just to not rock the boat. You want that voter, because that voter exists. And that's a kind of voter who might swing out of the way. You want that voter to come to you.
And that voter is, I think, not just sitting around thinking about the democracy, other conversations with Jared Polis, who is the governor of Colorado. And he won in 2022 by something like 18 points. So I'd have to go back and look at the exact number, but it's in that range. That's a huge victory.
Right? Colorado is a, you know, it's a bluish state now, but it's still swinging. You state 2022 could have been a very hard year. I remember saying, I think actually on the show with you right after the midterm that I thought Polis's victory was as or more impressive than Ron DeSantis victory, even though he was getting like no coverage at that point.
And I talked to Polis recently about, well, what was it? And he said that we have focused in Colorado very heavily on a cost of living agenda and message. And I'm paraphrasing him here, but he said, there are a lot of voters who just don't spend their time thinking about liberal democracy. Like we want every voter who does spend their time thinking about liberal democracy.
And I spent a lot of time thinking about liberal democracy. But we need the voters who don't. And so we have here's a cost of living message. And you know what?
And I'm not going to say that. And so we have here's a cost of living message. And you can see that in what Biden was doing, right? One of the things when he got into talking about second term policies and began actually talking quite a lot about were a bunch of policies that he had either already passed that he had passed and now wanted to expand and that he had not yet passed and wanted to pass.
There were all costs of living oriented, right? Getting rid of title insurance, but only back mortgages. There was the work he has done to cap the price of insulin for a lot of people. The work he has done to get Medicare to begin to negotiate down drug prices and only for certain drugs, but that can be expanded.
Right? There were a bunch of things there that were reminiscent to me a little bit of second term Clinton. Where he's like, we're doing good. And we got a bunch of ways.
We're just going to try to make your life also just a bit better. He had a whole kind of funny little riff on shrinkflation and how there's not as much snickers in the sticker bar anymore, right? That cost of living stuff matters to people. Because again, there are a bunch of voters who are not going to be motivated by liberal democracy.
They're going to be motivated by which of these guys can just kind of help me make it through the day a little bit more easily. And Biden really needs to win that argument or at least win it with enough people to win the election. Hi, I'm Solana Pine. I'm the director of video at The New York Times.
For years, my team has made videos that bring you closer to big news moments, videos by Times journalists that have the expertise to help you understand what's going on. Now we're bringing those videos to you in the Watch tab in the New York Times app. It's a dedicated video feed where you know you can trust what you're seeing. All the videos there are free for anyone to watch.
You don't have to be a subscriber. Download the New York Times app to start watching. America is going to build a functional military port to be able to autonomously bring aid into Gaza. That is not going to satisfy people who are furious about American support of the Israeli attack on Gaza.
I do think it's very important to keep these things a little bit separate. Many people, including at this point myself, do not believe we should be backing what Netanyahu is doing. And bringing an aid with one hand while protecting Israel in its, at least at the UN, while it continues to promote a war that at this point seems truly detached. From like an actual goal that is achievable.
Nevertheless, it is very, very important and very unusual step for America to take to build its own way to bring an aid to help the people in a territory that our ally is bombing using our bombs. The whole situation is genuinely weird actually when you think about it. But it's a very strong message from Biden, at least even where he's been, that we find the condition of the Palestinian people right now unacceptable. And, you know, is definitely better not be bombing our, our created port.
And it's notable that the part of the thing they're doing is things like aid have been held up by the Israelis, right? Which is illegal under American law. There are a lot of people who believe, and I think correctly so, that we're not correctly enforcing our own laws here. It is not legal under the rules we have on how we export arms for some of the kinds of human rights abuses we're seeing to be happening with our armaments.
We're not really enforcing those rules. But this is something, the other thing Joe Biden really made a point of saying at the State of the Union is that there is a grand bargain, a grand outcome he's trying to get to in the region. Where he is trying to trade Israel, recognition of Saudi Arabia, and support in containing Iran for Israel's recognition and acceptance of a Palestinian state. So far the problem is not whether that is Joe Biden's position.
It's whether it is Benjamin Netanyahu's position. Now if Joe Biden has a second term, I think the assumption is Benjamin Netanyahu will not be part of it, right? Benny Gantz is expected to win the election whenever it happens. We don't know that that will be the outcome, but it seems quite plausible.
He was just treated here like he was ahead of state. Right. He was starting to be treated in other places like kind of state, he just had a meeting in the UK as well, right? The West is beginning to treat Gantz like the real leader of Israel, Netanyahu like a lame duck like a problem to be managed.
So one argument is that what will happen eventually is that this war will end. There will be an election Netanyahu will lose and Biden and other Western leaders are going to work with Benny Gantz to try to execute this huge rearrangement. We don't know. Right.
I mean, that's the right way to put that. Right. You don't lose money betting against peace in Israel and among Palestinians, but we don't know. I think the thing that Biden is going to be trying to do right now is show that he really does value Palestinian life.
I mean, at the core of the fury and the critique of him is not that he supports Israel. It is that he is supporting Israel in a way that makes it seem like we do not truly value Palestinian life saying they are going too far while they go too far is not enough. Building a port while they go too far. I don't think that's going to feel like it is enough to people.
Well, it's also can be read quite easily aside from American weakness because we can't get it. Yes, we can't get them to stop it. Right. It's a very again, I want to say this.
I both respect what they're doing. It's a very strange thing. Right. I think we're going to far.
Maybe we don't give them our weaponry, but you heard this too from Biden. Biden is very clear. You know, he began that by saying, actually Israel is right to be attempting to eradicate Hamas. And my understanding and something Richard Haas, the president emeritus of the Council of Formulations was saying on the show a few weeks ago that the reason that this government is still as strong behind Israel as it is and is not moved into a significantly more critical position where it is more willing to draw red lines is by itself.
So I mean, this is Biden's view and he's trying to balance these two views against each other and it's a very complicated thing. I don't think by the 2024 election, the pivot that the grand strategy he's laying out, well, it had time to come to fruition. I do think in a second term, it is likely we will see negotiations in that direction, right? They're going to try to reset this entire thing under leadership.
That is his promise, right? That is that is the policy he's laying out. In another ongoing area of conflict, the war between Russia and Ukraine, Biden made a big deal talking about how Putin was as he's portraying him on the march. And obviously, at the same time, the administration is having tremendous difficulty getting Ukraine aid through Congress.
So what is the second term agenda there? And some foreign affairs thing I was reading that were saying, like, OK, now it's time to start talking about talking. And obviously, that's how talking has to start. But is there another approach you can imagine the Biden administration taking in the second term?
I mean, I don't know. I'm not deep enough on this issue to know. But I will say, I think it's worth understanding that what he was doing at the State of the Union was trying to pressure House Republicans to let the aid package through and also trying to make this as part of their kind of anti-freedom agenda, right? To the extent that one of the overarching arguments here that Biden is making is there is actually a worldwide fight between freedom and tyranny.
He was connecting Putin and Trump, and he was connecting support for Ukraine and support for American democracy. I think there was a belief that at this point, right? And I've seen a number of articles saying that it is privately believed and they're trying to figure out inside the administration that Zelensky needs to move into a more defensive position in terms of the war strategy and basically grind Russia to a halt. You can make this continuously costly on Russia.
And at some point, you're going to sue for peace here, right? And nobody's going to like it. But the belief they can win is something that is currently being said but is not truly and internally believed. But the thing that can happen is they could lose.
And they could lose if we stop giving them military aid. And the reason we stop giving them military aid is that Republicans have decided they wanted Russia to win. And they wanted that because Donald Trump wanted that. I thought it was very striking when Biden just said that it is unacceptable, right?
To say that Vladimir Putin can do whatever he wants to NATO members that we feel aren't doing their fair share that Trump has moved into his uniform policy. It's actually unacceptable that whatever you believe that Zelensky strategy and whether or not they can actually win, making an American policy that Russia should win is unacceptable. That is un-American. And Biden's right on that.
And I think that's among other things, a strong contrast. I actually do think Donald Trump, when you get out of sort of high flying, you know, we shouldn't be giving our money to other people. We should be building things here at home. You actually get down to brass tacks on what he is saying.
We should let Vladimir Putin overrun Ukraine. I don't think people agree with that. That was by using the state of the Union speech in a more traditional way to move aspects of his agenda. In that case, Ukraine aid.
And he also tried to do that on immigration, which we haven't talked about, but we should. And then brought up the border deal they negotiated, which for a moment, it seemed like it was actually about to happen. And he called out Trump for scuttling it in the most overt and direct way because of what her Trump's campaign. So again, looking head to 2025, let's say Biden wins.
Let's say he does not have both chambers of Congress. He has one or he has none. Is there a space for a deal like that to finally happen? I think it's very hard to know the condition of the Republican Party and the leadership trends in the Republican Party in the event of a Donald Trump loss, right?
What you might have expected would happen if Donald Trump lost in 2020 did not happen. But there was a period after 2020 when Republicans were more willing to work with Joe Biden. I mean, Joe Biden really did get bipartisan votes on the infrastructure bill. He really did get bipartisan votes on the chips and science act.
So there very much could be a period where some kinds of deal making are possible. And it was interesting watching the camera pivot to Senator James Langford, who's very conservative and was the Republican negotiator on the bipartisan border bill. And he was like nodding along with Joe Biden, right? I mean, he has suddenly been demonized for negotiating a very conservative bill, a bill that dragged the Democratic Party substantially to the right immigration and got a lot of things Republicans have often wanted.
And then for the very crime of trying to solve a problem, Republicans said they wanted to solve, he became the enemy of the day over there. And so there are people like that. And what you would have to trade or not trade, what you're buying can do through executive orders is also a kind of interesting question. I was saying, I've done some reporting with the Biden administration on this.
I think it, one, it's very important to realize that they believe this is a real problem, right? They are not sitting there saying, as has been true at other times, Fox News is making up a border crisis, right? You remember the caravan, right? Like that was kind of a made up crisis in 2018.
What is happening at the border now is not a made up crisis. We are actually dealing with record levels of apprehensions, the asylum system as Biden very, very well described is completely broken. People are coming in, they get put into America for years to say wait a hearing because the system is so overwhelming overloaded. That's a perfectly reasonable, like, bet to make even if you don't think you're going to prevail your hearing, they want to fix it.
And I guess in theory, eventually Republicans want to fix it as well, but they're not going to fix it any year when Donald Trump is running for president and when he's telling them not to. The other thing you saw though is what a gift Trump gave Biden, right? What a gift Trump gave him. Because now you can imagine a world where the bipartisan border bill passed and these things take some time to implement.
It takes time to hire and train however many thousand new asylum officers takes time to bring in those verification and drug machines that Biden was talking about. As Biden is talking about how we passed the toughest border bill in American history, whatever, but actually it doesn't look like anything is all the different at the border by election day. But by killing the compromise, what Trump gave them was a way to say we were the ones who wanted to pass the toughest border bill and you kept us from solving the problem. You kept this from happening.
Rather than having to own the actual outcome, Biden doesn't have to own the outcome. Trump in a way is owning the outcome or at least can in an argumentative way and Biden can own the desire to solve the problem. I think that's a good place to end actually because we've more or less run out of time anyway. Obviously we didn't get to everything but we got to a lot and there's another eight months.
God help us of this campaign. So plenty more time for this kind of conversation. But I'm going to spend something on you because as people maybe have gone to, you're a man who reads a lot of history. You're a man who's deep in the stacks.
What are three books you'd recommend to the audience to understand or contextualize this moment in American political history? Oh, wow. Okay. Was I warned about this?
You were not. Okay. I'm going to push one book that I've been pushing on everybody. I would not call it a book that will tell you everything you need to know about what's happening now but it's a really interesting and instructive book about what we've lost.
It doesn't mean to be that but it is because we've lost it and that is this biography by John Farrell of Tip O'Neill that I just read that has many incredible things in it but it represents a world where Tip O'Neill and his speaker of the house, Ronald Reagan, his president and they are in fact able to function. They're slashing each other all day and then they say, you know, we're going to be friends and it's perfect and that's not perfect and many terrible things were done but even so the political process is functioning in a way that right now it's not and it was very interesting to read that. I guess another way I would also answer that question is that the 19th century always tells us a tremendous amount about the 21st something I've been reading that I haven't actually finished that is speaking to the moment very much for me is Stephen Hans history of the 19th century. It's an Eric Fonehner's Penguin history of America series.
It's called a nation without borders but the reason it's so resonant now is that the 19th century still informs so much of what happens in the 21st in that you're seeing America attempt to become an empire even though that of course is not what was supposed to happen right you're seeing America in terms of its internal colonialism with regard to Native Americans right the seminal war which Han points out is like the longest American war until Vietnam and like you know just a whole set of thoughts and ideas that I think are helpful for this moment. All right well that's two. So for a third I'm going to stick with the theme of the 19th century controlling the 21st and I recommend Joanne Freeman's book Field of Blood which is also incredibly resonant today. It looks at political violence inside Congress inside the building itself in the 1830s and 40s and 50s actual brawls between congressmen thrashings there's lots of weapons and she uses that as a way of understanding the political violence that was taking America over at the time and that culminated obviously in the Civil War that kind of intersection between personal and political violence has been the subject of all of her work and in this book it's really quite extraordinary.
Yeah, Field of Blood is amazing. It's one of those books that after you read it you'll never get listen to somebody say to you oh my god the American political division has never been this bad. Aaron Radikah thank you very much. Thank you for having me.
This episode of the Ezra Cluncho was produced by Roland Ho, fact-checking by Michelle Harris, Kate Sinclair and Mary Marge-Locker, our senior engineers Jeff Gell, the additional mixing from a theme ship hero. Our senior editors, Claire Gordon, the shows production team also includes Annie Galvin and Kristen Lin, original music by Isaac Jones, Audien Stradgy, by Christina Samuuski and Shannon Buster. The executive producer of New York Times Opinion Audio is Andrew Ostrasser and special thanks to Sonya Harro.