Hi, I'm Solana Pine. I'm the director of video at the New York Times. For years, my team has made videos that bring you closer to big news moments, videos by Times journalists that have the expertise to help you understand what's going on. Now we're bringing those videos to you in the Watch tab in the New York Times app.
It's a dedicated video feed where you know you can trust what you're seeing. All the videos there are free for anyone to watch. You don't have to be a subscriber. Download the New York Times app to start watching.
From New York Times Opinion, this is the ESSER Climb Show. It's not the beginning. Elon Musk's Department of Government Efficiency seemed to have ended up with a fairly narrow mandate. You can look at the Trump executive order, creating it, and it says, the purpose is modernizing federal technology and software to maximize governmental efficiency and productivity.
In the last couple weeks, it's become clear that Musk's role is a whole lot larger than that. Elon Musk right now involved in almost every agency and corner of the United States government. Offering all federal employees a buyout to resign. Musk and his team have access at least 11 agencies, and the count is growing every day.
This team has gained access to something extraordinarily sensitive. The Treasury Department's payment system. Which handles trillions of dollars in payments. And the private information of every single American in this country.
Elon Musk seized control of USAID. People getting fired, people getting furloughed, in droves. Hosting on X quote, we spent the weekend feeding USAID into the wood shipper. They are raiding the government.
We don't pledge allegiance to the billionaires. We don't pledge allegiance to Elon Musk. What's the plan? What's the plan?
And so far at least, Musk's patron Donald Trump seems to be on board. I think he's doing a great job. He's a smart guy, very smart. And he's very much into cutting the budget of our federal government.
And as I've watched all this unfold, I've been wondering how Elon Musk has evolved in the way he has. How did he go from conventional Obama-air liberal worried about climate change and who wanted to go to Mars? To right-wing conspiratorial meme lord, work into a far-right in Germany. And shred the federal government in the United States.
What led to this transition's evolution for Elon Musk? And what actual strategies does he bring to the government that he now seems to have quite a lot of control over? To talk about all this, I wanted to buy Cara Swisher on the show. Cara is one of the great tech reporters of the age.
She's been covering Musk for many, many years. Along with many of the other tech CEOs who become such key political figures now. She's of course a host of the great podcast on Cara Swisher. And Pivot, which he co-hosts with Scott Galloway.
As always, my email is at mytimes.com. Cara Swisher, welcome back to the show. Thank you. I've never been here.
You've been on my show before. I have not. Yes, you have. I'm going to go back to Chewiecy.
You were like my second ever episode. Oh, that's because I suggested you do podcasting. You've done rather well. Master Costen interviewing from Cara Swisher.
It was called. Wow, I must have forgotten it. I can't see such a similar moment. Well, it's good to see you.
Good to see you. How did you describe the role Elon Musk has been playing in the federal government in the first weeks of Donald Trump's second term? Well, a little more strongly than the New York Times did. I'm not a young person walking through.
I think he's a one man wrecking ball, really, then he's being used by Trump for that purpose. There's lots of ways you could use metaphors. You could say junk yard dog. He's the one sort of taking all the flack going in and breaking things.
But you could be funny and call it wreck and Ralph. I don't think it's particularly funny or the right way to do it or constitutionally sound. But that's the kind of thing he's going in there like he does with his companies and doing the exact same thing. He's got a series of moves that he makes every single time and he's doing them writ large on the federal government.
Walk me through the moves. What is his playbook? Well, it's changed in more than the years, but always drama, always a massive amount of drama centered on him. That's, tends to be the thing he does.
He can be very dramatic in a very poignant way. There's a period where he was very worried about the fate of Tesla, if you remember. And he was sleeping on the floor there and he gave a really, he actually gave me an interview in your Times where he seemed to cry. He seemed very emotional.
And at one point, when we were talking, this was, I think, off camera, he said, if Tesla doesn't survive, the human race is doomed, which I felt was a little dramatic, you know, when I thought, wow, this is what man in his forties, who thinks that he's the center of the universe. And so it always has that element of drama. Like it has to be that and he has to be at the center. I think he's greatly informed by video games.
And so that's, he sort of, someone described him to me as ready player one. And everybody else is an NPC, which is a non-player character. So he always has to be the hero or the person who matters the most. And sometimes he does, and sometimes he's engineered it.
So, you know, just like getting the founder role when he's not actually the founder or rewriting history or using PR to make himself the founder. So he understands the hero's journey kind of thing really rather well. He also, the stakes have to be very high. And if it doesn't work, we're doomed kind of things.
So he uses language like that, doom. And he tends to overstate the problems, most companies have problems, but everything is a disaster here and I'm here to fix it. Where everything sucks and everybody previously is criminal or evil pedophiles where he likes to use a lot, but he uses the terms like evil. And in one tweet he called the O.L.
Roth, who was head of Trust and Save to Twitter, who he did like until he quit. And then he became evil. In one tweet he called him evil and I was seething with hate, which is really dramatic and ridiculous. I'm not seething with hate.
Very Trumpy on that. Yeah. Yeah. That kind of thing.
I think he means it though. I think Trump sometimes is just doing it for show, you know, showmen and reality show kind of thing. So there's a story that Musk tells as sort of dramatic story. It's him against evil doers.
But there's also mechanics, right? He has people who tenants fan out to keep points. One thing we're seeing right now with what Musk is doing in the federal government is an identification of choke points, of information and money, the treasury payment system, right? The office of personnel management, which is a place where Musk has installed trusted aides and they're using that as a way to fan out across the federal workforce.
So tell me a bit, beneath the story Musk tells the grand narrative when he takes things over and what he's brought from that to the federal government, what does he actually have the people under him do? What is the theory of action? Well, he has people around him. They're just enablers.
They're sort of all these Silicon Valley people do, all his minions and their minions. They're all lesser than he is in some fashion and they all look up to him. They're typically younger. They laugh at his jokes.
Sometimes when you apologize for a joke, which is not very often, he said people around me thought it was funny. Well, they all do because they're like, to be in the room is to watch it happen. I was when he was being interviewed at Code once, he had a couple of them there and he's told a really bad joke and they all went, oh, like that. And I was like, that's not funny.
I was like, I'm sorry, did I miss the joke? And they looked at me like I had three heads. And what they do is it's that hard to figure out choke points, right? This is where we need to be.
And then they go into it in this way that is violating of typical rules. And I don't mean necessarily laws, although I suspect many laws may have been broken here, but not caring about breaking laws. And so they go in sort of full force and question, what do you, let me see your code. Let me, why can't we get in?
We're getting in. We have the law. We have federal marshals. Let's see what they'll do.
And that is a really big quality that he has. Let's say things and wait for them to sue us or wait for them to stop us. They won't stop us. And again, very much like Trump, the people don't stop you.
We just operate on a set of, you know, polite rules in society and they just barrel right through them. I want to zoom in on that breaking of rules because I think something must understand Trump's understood in different ways. Is it at high levels of society, the recourse for breaking a law, breaking a rule is legal. You don't get frog marched out.
Right. So the law is, is somebody sues you, they need to have standing at work to straight through the courts. You have lawyers as well and it moves slowly. Right.
And so a lot of law following and rule following is just a norm at that level that you follow the laws and you follow the rules. If you don't, you can move much faster than the courts are likely to move. Right. They can fire all these people, many of them potentially illegally given civil service protections and what they're going to sue over the course of six to nine months or four years and maybe get some back pay.
Corporations do this against people organizing unions all the time, but as an insight that a lot of what has constrained other executive branches is not actually a constraint because by the time, you know, you're going to be able to get a lot of money. Because by the time the legal system catches up, you've already achieved what you want to achieve. That's correct. It's pretty profound insight.
Yeah, it is. And if he gets caught, he's some people see's willing to pay, right? Like he's willing to go toe to toe legally. And I think what a lot of people are is, I don't want to fight this guy.
He's unlimited money, right? Like you have to think twice if you're going to mean, you know, journalists have to think twice. You know, it's very similar to these media companies settling, you know, CBS has done nothing wrong in this Kamala Harris situation, yet they're going to pay. It's pretty clear that meta did nothing wrong with Trump and yet they're going to pay.
You do it to make it go away or you don't do it at all because of exhaustion. And he understands that. He understands that he can wear them down. And so it is true.
If you blow lights, you mostly get away with it, right? Like you don't always get caught or if you don't pay bills or in his business life, let's blow up 90 rockets because the 91st will work. And that's his attitude towards pretty much everything I can tell. Although to be fair to him, it led to some amazing rockets.
It did. But who else gets to look? And then he insults NASA, which is not allowed to blow up rockets. NASA can't blow up rockets because then they blow up one rocket.
That's the end of it, right? And so it's a real advantage to be able to blow up rockets and then keep going. You know that Thomas Edison quote, there's a famous quote that they all quote back to me. I have not failed.
I found 10,000 ways that don't work, whatever. And then you eventually get to it. And so it's very, it's part of the ethos of tech is that there's no such thing as failure. There's only it didn't work that time and I'll get the right one next.
But this gets to I think the deeper question is because there are these tactics and strategies, but towards what? When he's blowing up rockets, he is trying to make rockets at work in a certain way and eventually he did. And I think the world factor is better off for him doing it. Tesla had many failures, but really did make better electric cars than anybody else made and help the electric vehicle transition happen.
Sure. What does he want now? What is this all in service? What is the vision in your view that he's trying to affect the world?
That he's trying to effectuate with all this power that he now wields in the government? It's not money. Money is not, I hate to say this, I hate to say this, but it's not that important to many of them, right? You know that.
It's not money. Some of them really like money. That's for sure. But it's not money.
It's the power that money brings and it's power to decide. And you know, I think it started off. I have some good ideas and I'd like to put them into place. And now it's I have all the ideas on every topic.
And therefore what I say goes, it's a very king-like attitude towards things, right? Or the, you know, that philosopher they like, that we should have a functional CEO running our country that gets to decide everything. Screw Congress, screw the courts, we should have a king, essentially a CEO that has unlimited power. He also does have a really weird sense of mortality in a way that he wants to be legendary, right?
Again, go back to video games. But I think he wants the glory of it. He has those images in his head. And that's not a way of excuse, it's a way of explanation, right?
That this is how he looks at himself. It's on a grand journey of the hero. He's not a hero, by the way. Let me be clear.
But I think this gets it. What to me is one of the mysteries of us because of the ideas that he seems committed to have changed. You know, Peter Thiel, who is contemporary, they co-founded PayPal together, but teal has always been pretty far, right? You know, back to things he's writing at Stanford.
Moss, you go back to say to Obama era, he's a kind of standard Obama era liberal. He has a series of companies that are solving problems that are important to Obama era liberals. Those companies survive off of Obama era policies from different contracts to electric vehicles subsidies, right? Loan guarantees, you know, Tesla saved by Obama loan guarantee.
Yeah. I mean, even in 2017, he joins an advisory board for Trump and then he gets back off of it when Trump pulls out of the Paris climate accords. So you have someone who is running public private partnerships, working endlessly with the government, working on things like climate change. And within a very compressed matter of years, moves very, very far to the right.
So I really want power for his ideas, but it has always been a little bit mysterious to me. What led to the striking radicalization in him? You're right. During Obama, he was supportive.
When he joined that week, texted a lot during that period, he was on the Trump thing. And he was like, they're trying to do an anti-gay thing. I'm going to get in there and stop them. Like he was very much, I need to be here to change Trump's mind.
I can only, I can change it kind of thing. He wasn't anti-Trump, but he certainly wasn't pro-Trump. I can tell you that. He was very much in the, he's kind of a con man school of thought with him around COVID.
I saw a lot of changes, you know, around. I talked to him quite a lot and people give me a hard time for having done that. I get it, but he wasn't that off beaten track before. I mean, he was, he was Megalomot and I, he was typical of a tech person, but doing more interesting things.
But there was a real shift during COVID. I noticed it. He got very upset. He got very like overly upset and overly dramatic.
Look, if you think your company is critical for the future of human race and then California closes it down because of COVID, you get in that mode. That's one. I definitely, he was very, he sort of got very unreasonable. And in one interview, I did with him.
He started saying only a few thousand people or whatever. I don't remember precisely. We're going to die from COVID and he had read all the studies and he knew and I didn't. He's never liked unions or the government or regulation.
That's, that goes way back for all these people. And so it became more profound during COVID, this idea. I think the issues around his trans daughter seem to have affected him quite profoundly. I've noticed that in a number of tech people who have trans children.
The second thing I think the Wall Street Journal has correctly reported on is his use of ketamine and other drugs. So I think that was another thing that seemed to have changed him. That's, but otherwise, you know, they all use drugs. I don't know.
I don't know. People use ketamine. They don't tend to turn that far. Correct.
But I think he was doing him, he was like the world's expert. He was also staying up late at night. He has this weird proclivity to be up at three in the morning and obsessively. He's got obsessive personality.
You know, we all have that element to us, but he's got it in spades. And the one thing that I think, I keep saying this to people, and I said it at the time, when Biden did not invite him to that EV summit and invited Mary Bara instead and treated him shabbily, he was very upset, like very. I talked to him a lot about it or he texted me and other people did too. Other people noticed it too.
And this was a summit that Biden had, and he couldn't invite him because of the union issues. He was very, very anti-union. So they didn't invite him and he was very upset, like personally upset, like wounded almost. And I even went as far as to call Steve or Shady, who works for Biden.
And I said, why have you made a mistake? That you should bear hug this guy. He's really mad. And you know, Steve or Shady is a nice guy.
He's like, oh, you know, it's the unions. He should understand. He's a big boy. And I was like, no, he's not a big boy.
He's a little bit. But Biden people are all very relational for them to have missed what a relational snub like us could do to somebody with his ego is it's a mistake of the kind of politics they were supposed to be so good at. Well, the thing is, you know, again, a lovely guy actually ran into him at a movie premiere for Wicked and he goes, guess you were right. I'm like, guess so.
You know, this is the way he takes slights is really strange. So I'd seen it in action, sort of petty anger and slight slights. And that one really stuck hard and they kept the Biden people kept tweaking him. And I found that to be, you know, I mean, you'd be like, so what?
And like, why would you do that? He actually does deserve the accolades around Tesla. So why not just give him that? And I never understood why they wouldn't despite the union stuff.
There's a factor you even mentioned here, which is Twitter. Oh, yeah. So the Wall Street Journal has a piece from years ago where it's tracking his number of tweets here by year 12, 20, 13, 20, begin to see it really explode 2016, 2017. It's really big 2018.
And I mean, then he's really off to the races. Yeah. And it was a lot going on in his use of Twitter. And obviously he eventually buys Twitter and we'll talk about that.
But clearly he becomes very influenced by some quite radically right subcultures on Twitter. The part of Twitter he ends up falling into, whether he looks for it or just gets into it. I don't know what the chicken and the egg is here, but he doesn't become a normal Republican. He doesn't become a normal, a normal, a modern Republican.
He's not like Steve Bannon or something. He falls into a sort of world of Twitter anons and. Well, it's not up with joking stuff. Like he liked all those memes, dank memes.
He loves dank memes. I always tell when I don't know very well, but I always felt when I left his presence a couple of times I happened around it. And this was years ago before he was who he is now. I would tell people he was the smartest 15 year old boy in the world.
Yeah, that's a very good way to put it. And so he got really into the memes and this was always a real door into a dark right wing on a particular platform. It always is. You know, I have experience with my own son.
Like he loves dank memes. Like he always sends me dank memes or whatever. And you can fall down it. And I think that's what attracted him to Twitter for sure.
And then it took off into a darker place that other things impacted it. But you know, he's an addictive personality clearly, like whether it's to work or hardcore is one of his favorite words, which is I find to be hustle porn. You know, so he's attracted to addiction. And so he's Twitter use.
You can watch it. Like you can't. You can see it. It's it's manic and he's a manic person.
And I think it's again, not an excuse, but an explanation. He has a manic personality and and violative. So that's also reality that in a way that is unusual among people's class, he's really good at social media. Good at social media and the way young people are not in the way, you know, Barack Obama is right.
You get. I don't think he's good. My kids are cringe. They're always like cringe.
No, I don't. Fair enough. But there's an official voice of social media, right? The voice Mark Zuckerberg used to have before he became a Elon Musk imitator online.
The voice that you know, you would get from Obama or Bill Gates. Yeah. And Musk isn't in that voice. He's constantly responding to small follower accounts.
And he really does build up an intentional power that he didn't have before it. He begins to really trade in his coin of attention. He loves attention. He loves attention, but he's, you know, he uses it to drive meme coins.
I think I think to understand in a way other people don't because he's experimenting with it. What you can turn attention into. Right. What set him apart from sort of the other people who superficially looked like him that made him terribly suited to doing that?
Well, his manic nature, right? It's got a manic addictive quality to it. And he does have a sense of humor. It's not my sense of humor and people will hate me for saying this, but it can be rather charming, right?
Like when he was on Saturday Night Live. Look, I know I sometimes say or post strange things, but that's just how my brain works. Do anyone have offended? I just want to say I reinvented electric cars and I'm sending people to Mars in our rocket ship.
Did you think that was also going to be a chill normal dude? He was so awkward that it was charming and other people are going to say care loves in, but I don't care. Go watch it is. I don't, just the way.
You really have all these people in your life who are surprised as a reporter in tech. Oh my God. You brought him. You made him.
Oh, yes. I can't tell you. Sometimes I left. It's a ridiculously sensory.
It's kind of like, no, I don't want to use sensory. It's not, they're just like, scolish. I don't want to use, they're not censoring. But yes, I get a lot of like, you made him like you didn't know.
I didn't know how he was treating his kid. I'm sorry. I didn't know that. It had I known.
Also, I did a make in the car company with successful cars. I was covering him as a car manufacturer. Look, that's not, I'm not going to excuse. So I don't know.
He has a million people like him. He was very typical except he was doing more interesting things than other people. So getting back to how he's good at it. I think the people that are very good and I once wrote a column about in the times when I was writing for the times about two people I thought were very good, which is AOC and Trump, right?
They're genuine to themselves or Kim Kardashian is another person who's like this. You don't have to like any of these people, but boy, are they good at channeling themselves as an image online and it feels genuine. It feels like them doing it and it is them doing it. It feels like it's their voice, if that makes sense.
People love when someone that famous reacts to them and then it creates a sensation around them, right? And so then you get a lot of acolytes. Oh my God, Elon Musk responded to me and he feeds off of that too. Again, he combines humor.
He initially combined humor with that or insights, right? Interesting things. And then very quickly twisted into stuff he doesn't know anything about and he just pontificates and that's his favorite thing is to say all manner of nonsense and inaccuracies about things he doesn't know what he's talking about. I remember being at code years ago and you all had Musk on the stage and you sort of talked through the he believed in the simulation hypothesis, which is a hypothesis that you should expect a nice fishy event.
Civilization will begin running simulations of the world. There will be more simulations and there will be base realities. And so by a simple matter of arithmetic, we are likely to be living in a simulated world in the real world. And Musk said, you know, he bought this and thought there was a pretty low chance we were in big game.
He said there's a non-zero chance and it fascinated him. Again, it is. Well, that's not going to get it. Not the simulation.
I think people can make too much of whether or not that idea matters. But he has a mind, has always had the kind of mind that is attracted to unusual ideas that the things that most people believe are probably wrong. You kind of can't do what isn't isn't true. And I mean, he has been proven right a number of times in very, very big profound ways.
You know, now he's a richest man in the world. I mean, he's has the most attention in the world right from where you start to end up there that's going to change your psychology. Right. So he's got a lot of ideas, but he gets more conspiratorial as I watch him on Twitter.
And I'm curious how you understand that dimension of him. Well, you know, Kevin Rus did a great thing about that. You know, you go down this rabbit hole. It really is.
It can really be, you know, did you know this or, you know, everybody is subject to it with the way social media works. And that's a mind of technology people. They're like, this could happen. We could go to the moon, right?
You have to have that element to you if you're going to do very difficult things. And so you have to start with that personality. And therefore, anything, every single thing is open to question. Why do we do it this way?
Why do we do it this way? And it's a personality. I like. I like the way it is when you start to go out to Ukraine or vaccines or whatever, they have to question everything and posit themselves.
I always joke about it with my wife. Oh, we had another bold truth teller, right? Like I'm so tired of them. Like I'm here to boldly tell you the truth without any actual information or reporting.
And so he's attracted to that idea like the simulation. Like why can't we live on Mars? Not everybody does that. And I think when it starts or not, it starts off from a good place, but often in the social media world, as Kevin correctly put out in that podcast he did, is it goes down into the sort of conspiracy theory avenue really quickly.
It's a very specific kind of conspiracy theory he gets into. And you have him, you know, he responds to him to tweets that choose quote, have been pushing the exact kind of dialectical hatred against whites that they claim to want people to stop using against them and must reply. So you have you have said the actual truth in July of 2024 just before I came out in support of Trump, he accused Democrats of quote, trying to import as many illegal voters as possible. And in this way, I think what is going on with him is a little bit distinct from a lot of the people who superficially have similar politics.
Because I think he's really bought into a lot of great replacement theory. Yes. A lot of this idea. So with a lot of people in Silicon Valley, let me say he's not alone.
No, he's not. He's got to cut like this Curtis Yarvon stuff. They've all sort of been taken by these. It's almost religious if you think about it.
Right. And so one of the things that I think it goes back to and I hate to say this is sad little boy wasn't loved enough as a child is searching for meaning, right? Is there searching for love searching for an again, not an excuse because I think it's a terrible person and he should get therapy. But when there's easy answers like that, oh, this is why you're so unhappy.
Oh, this is why the world is the way it is. These right wing conspiracies do scratch and itch for these people. It's a religion. It's their answer to the world.
It's also a politics. So Musqueous of African Peter Thiel spent much with Charles David Sachs is South African. And there's a very distinctive experience to being somebody born in or lived in South Africa during apartheid. And also then saw apartheid dismantled, saw South Africa change.
I never quite know in myself how much weight to put on this interpretation, but it seems relevant. It seems interesting that Thiel, Musqueous and Sachs, who are three of the most significant figures in the Silicon Valley, embrace of Trump, have this very, very distinctive political experience of watching South Africa's white minority move from being in control of the country to a frightened minority in the country. I mean, there is that element to a lot of these people. And the same thing with Silicon Valley people.
Again, when you merge that with the ideas around Silicon Valley, which is highly male, highly, we have all the answers. Why are these silly people in our way? And with the South African thing, I don't know what happened there that created this group of people, but you could say that about people come from Russia or China, or, you know, there's an element of a whole bunch of people who have created from India. So you know, they bring with them whatever culture happened there.
And it's South Africa, you know, one of two ways, right? You can go in the Apple Feuard way, or you could go in this way of longing for pastimes, I guess, in some fashion. So Musk goes and buys Twitter. So sort of unusual acquisition, he tries to get out of it while it's happening, but he does buy it.
He does. And he comes in and he immediately does this huge cutting, just like slashing right through it. And people talk about this as headcount reduction. They talk about it as cutting waste.
They talk about it as cutting bone. I think when you look back on it now, what it both was in reality, and also, and you know more about this than me, but what it becomes culturally in Silicon Valley is the reassertion of control of a CEO over an annoying and overly empowered liberal employee base. They loved it. The CEOs loved it.
Talk a little bit about not exactly just what he did, but what the cultural effect of what he did was on his cohort. Well, I think what was really interesting is a lot of these guys, you know, I can use this in their times, have tiny dick energy. I don't know what else to say. They just, they want to be big swinging dicks and they won't do it, right?
They won't go there because they're worried about what people will say or everyone sort of watching each other. And this guy goes in and just does it. Like Silicon Valley, the employees run the show. Like they really do.
They like to get their lunches. They like to get their cars or dry cleaning. They like to speak up. And by the way, they started it.
Like Google starting with having the employees talk back every Friday. What do you think was going to happen, right? They're going to be kids. And they're going to be in a Friday meeting where we're stuck over against employee questions.
I hear you. And they all create the internal chat software, right? Like Slack and TV. Everybody has a point where it allows employees to be speaking in a way that they can sort of organize that speech even without unions.
Right. They gave power to their employees. And I had a discussion. I don't think it was Mark was like, now they're talking back.
I'm like, what did you think they were going to do? You indulge children for long enough and give them sugar all day long. They're going to become terrible people. Like, you know what I mean?
And so that they were surprised by this is what happened when they created these cultures. I'm always surprised by. So they have all these employees that annoy them. So they let them say whatever they wanted.
And then they said whatever they wanted. And then they were annoyed by them saying whatever they wanted. And they found it, you know, very hard to push back because talent is at a premium in Silicon Valley. So you have to kind of let everybody be themselves.
And they got, they got annoying for a lot of these people because they had effective control over things. But with Musk, when he did it, you could see everybody in Silicon Valley. They already had this, oh, he gets to do that. I don't get to do that.
I have to like listen to my diversity equity inclusion people like, oh, I hate those people. Like, you know, but he doesn't have to. He can do whatever he wants. And when he did that and cut people, they wanted to do that too.
This feels to me like part of the covid era radicalization. It happened to the Silicon Valley CEO class that, you know, something happening during covid during the rise of various reckonings, me too, of Black Lives Matter. I really think it has a lot to do with the rise of slack and teams. It gets a very underrated dimension of what changed the relationship between the bosses and their employees.
It feels to make a lot of the CEOs just hated their employees. What radicalized them was that they had lost control of their companies and they wanted that control back. And that as much as anything feels to me like the theory Musk is importing out to the government. It's not he's talked about cutting spending ways.
What he's trying to get for Trump or for him is control. Right. It's sort of the rid me of this annoying priest kind of thing like rid me of this and these people. Again, it's like a king thing.
The way they set up their companies is a king chip, right? Mark Zuckerberg has complete control. He can't be fired. He's there for life, dictator for life or whatever.
The joke you want to make. And so they like that. But it's not in practice. It doesn't work that way because he's got reporters annoying him like irritating reporters.
He's got, you know, he's got his staff. He's got to like, at least give a nod to diversity or else he gets shamed and he doesn't have the fortitude that Musk has in that regard. And so they themselves are trying to assert themselves in sort of what they consider a man, right? This is the definition of what a man is.
A lot of them were not considered manly when they were in high school or, you know, sort of revenge of the nerds kind of thing. So they are trying to hold on to all these kind of manly cosplaying, I guess, you know, with markets, the stupid chain and the t-shirt, which good luck, it's fine. I think it looks ridiculous, but fine. He likes it or the MMA.
Like I can feel like a man like they hold on or I'm going to hydrophile or I'm going to do work out. I'm going to show off my muscles. That's what Bezos is doing. Like here's my muscles.
There's my pretty fiance kind of thing. They're trying to sort of cosplay a version of a man that I think seems pathetic to me, but I think gives them great comfort. One of the Rosetta stones to me of the intellectual shift happening among this class was, I forgot now exactly what this was, but when Musk and Zuckerberg were talking about having a fight in a cage, and this has its own funny sub themes where Zuckerberg is taking it all incredibly earnestly and Musk is clearly mocking him the whole time. Totally the whole time.
And so there's like a whole dynamic where like they don't have the cage match, which Zuckerberg would win, but actually Musk wins because of what he was doing was making fun of Mark Zuckerberg. They didn't like each other. Yeah, but then there's a third here. So there's an Allen and company conference when he's big CEO at conferences and Andreessen is asked about it and he ends up sending out his answer on his sub stack and he basically says, I think it's great if they fight because we've lost all the masculine virtues of the Greeks.
And if it was good enough for the Greeks, it's good enough for us. And one of the things happening, it seems to me in the right wing intellectual culture, these guys are increasingly part of, but also among them is a sense that the world has feminized and that the masculine virtues of aggression, of combat, of conflict, of daring, of risk, of just making decisions and to hell with it has been diminished and that the thing that is needed is some kind of correction that modernity is going off the rails because we're becoming womanly and soft. And I guess this class of VCs and tech founders is going to show us our way back to it. They don't like women to start with, come on, they don't like them to start with.
So this is not a student be surprised. They don't like the ladies kind of thing. Well, they intellectualized it is what I think becomes interesting here. What's interesting about what you're saying, and it's absolutely true.
Let's start. They don't have women in their midst. I wrote a piece once to say, the men and the men and the women of Facebook and Mark got hurt by it. And I was like, what?
I'm just putting up pictures of your management. I don't know what to tell you. Like you hire them. They're very fixated on what a man is and what have been.
And what's really interesting, especially Mark and Theresa, I mean, if you could jog like 10 feet, I'd be surprised, right? Talking about the manly virtues, give me a break. I mean, somebody said that. I'm like, I could beat him up in five seconds.
Like, I don't even understand where this comes from. Now he's going to challenge me to fight, whatever. So it's concept of what a man is that is not what a man is, but they've decided it is. Now, if all these people, Elon didn't cosplay a lot like that.
Like he didn't. Except now he's starting to wear the cowboy hats and that'll nonsense that he's doing. But he actually didn't as much as they did. And now they sort of take all his cues from his aggression, which is kind of interesting.
That was the thing I was going to sort of get out was Zuckerberg too. When I think back on that fight, they were going to have an ad to be positing himself as the Elon foil, you know, he was having threads, Elon had X. And now you see Zuckerberg copying him. I mean, the way he engages on threads is the way Elon engages on Twitter.
Yeah, it's like we're going to get such a beta. I love saying that he probably drives him crazy. There is this deep way in which Musk seems to have reset the culture or at least been the signal that allowed a lot of the people who weren't quite ready to come out and say how they've been feeling themselves to move. He led a lot of the flood towards Trump of tech leaders.
And you know, now is like showing, oh, you can actually turn this into political power in a way that I think nobody quite really could do directly. I mean, Peter Teal, I think for better or worse, it's a lot of credit for he supported the Trump early. He made his bets, but Teal didn't try to wield the power himself. Teal makes bets and watches him pay off or not.
But Musk is going in and showing, oh, it could just be you. You can not only have all this powers of technology CEO. You could be one of the most important celebrities in the world and you could be functionally shadow president. Like, oh, you did it.
Figured this out. I figured it out. Yeah. Zuckerberg hid from the attention, right?
He liked the acclaim, but he never liked the shit that went with it. And so that's why he didn't push all the way through. And that was interesting. And Musk does have these guts to do that.
Like I'm going to do it no matter what. If I get attacked and in fact, I eat my attackers for breakfast, right? I love my attack. Come and get me.
Well, this is Trump's personality to him. Exactly. He seemed to me to be as temperamentally actually quite somewhat. It takes a very unusual personality to be shameless at that level.
The amount of genuine hatred you need to absorb, you know, there's a decision they both made that, you know, if you want to really wield power, you have to be willing to be hated. And one of the things most of us are not willing to do is to be truly hated. And most of us are not willing to be truly hated. It seems like that business of nothing else.
That disinhibition is to be central to their alliance. Well, they do care though. Underneath Trump wants nothing more than have the New York Times love him. Like you can feel it, right?
You know the sense of victimhood. People say this. I think they both care quite a bit of what people think. I think they care almost too much what people think.
And so I think it fuels their rage in a lot of ways. I think there is a little piece of them that is never not going to care about what people think of them. And they become more and more emboldened by that. It fuels it's the center of their rocket fuel, I think.
There might be some truth to this rocket fuel for them. I just think that at a certain point, you lose the belief that these people or even friends used to want to have. And that's I think what real radicalization is. Radicalization I think often takes just the normal pluralistic give and take rollings together off the table.
It becomes an all out war. And I do think Trump in a very different way. But in some ways, a more I think intellectualized way Musk now see this as all out war. You have to gain control.
If you don't, I mean he was on Rogan's show saying that there'd be no more elections if Trump didn't win this time. I mean Musk has really gone into the civilizational battle, right? He clearly believes in some level of great replacement theory. He's now trying to get the far right AFD elected in Germany trying to get labor out of power in the UK.
And this to me gets it away that I'm curious if you think he's changed it for a very long time to line a Musk was that everything is backwards from his belief that eventually he might need to be a interplanetary species. Well, look at all his children. He manifested himself by having so many children and seemingly not spending time with him except for one. He wants to have children not necessarily be apparent, which I think is an interesting thing to plumb at some point.
But so what is the goal that now motivates? Do you really believe it's still the interplanetary thing or is it a view that these countries are losing their cultures and if you lose those cultures then everything is lost? I do think it does manifest from the need to get off this planet. I do.
That is the one consistent thing since I met him, which is this idea that civilization is doomed and therefore we need to get off this planet. I think at their heart, they do believe the version of themselves is the greatest version of man, which would be a white guy, supreme kind of thing. I think they actually believe that at their heart. And so you're going to see that manifest in these statements that he makes all the time, which are very clearly we need.
I forget what he said, but essentially we need more South Africans here in this country or something like that. And he's always sort of pulling in that direction. I have never heard him express any kind of what I would consider. I've heard difference in his express racism.
His is a different kind. It's more around social engineering and the idea of that the best people are being replaced. I think that's really where he lives, which is also racist, of course. So to you the synthesis of these positions is it must be still motivated by the desire to become interplanetary, but he just believes that we are corroding the civilizational virtues and genius that you would need to do that with the EI and the book mind virus.
And everything is in the way of our getting somewhere else because the lesser people are in charge or the lesser people. He does talk about this a lot of like at one point he was tweeting about cesarean sections, right? Did you see that to me? Or he said, if you have a cesarean, you have a better brain because your brain comes out better because you're not going through the vaginal canal.
This whole thing he was talking about. And I've had a cesarean, so I sort of was like sit down, so you don't know what you're talking about, but everyone sort of past people by, but I was like, oh, he thinks you have to like preserve the work, like he's sort of eugenics almost. Like, you know what I mean? Like it was such a weird thing for him to go down that avenue, but he has these theories about human brains and development.
Obviously he's involved with Neuralink. So he's always been interested in the idea of machine people merging together. That's certainly an area he's that hasn't been plumbed enough, his neuralink stuff. And so if you put all this together and bring it back to the government, it sounds like if I pull out what you're saying here, what you have is someone who in order for humanity to achieve its own goals, you need people like Elon Musk in control of a federal government that is responsive to people like Elon Musk, purged of the forces that were not responsive, that's so down a person like Elon Musk, in a polity that isn't infected by these modern progressive ideas of equity, of consensus, of doing all these things that are to slow and burn in some and regulatory and soft and don't allow for the risk and the daring value blow up 90 rockets.
Is that your view of like the put it all together that he's trying to functionally make the federal government something that can be effectively controlled by people like him to get to the goals he wants to get to? Yeah, I think he thinks they're in the way. This goes back to Peter Thiel. Peter Thiel is everyone's like, oh, they want to reform it.
I go, no, no, no, they want to burn it down. And start again. If you spend time reading Peter Thiel, that is what he's saying. Democracy doesn't work.
It doesn't work. We're going to start with something else. And that is sort of the ethos of move fast and break things, right, which is a software term. They want to break.
They don't want to build. They want to break. And they can't build until you break. And that's the disruption.
Think of all the words they use. It's all about destruction. And it's not creative destruction. It's let's wipe the slate clean and then we will build the civilization we want and let us show you the way of how we can get back to glory kind of thing.
And like it's just that is that theory. But they sort of burnish it with this techno utopianism that is really techno authoritarianism. If you break it down that they know best and that is we just listen to them. The world will be a better place for everybody.
To try to be generous to it is a theory of governmental reform, which I know you'd like to do that. I think democracy's worked pretty well. But go ahead. So Musk said regulations basically should be default gone, not default there, default gone.
If it turns out that we missed the mark on a regulation, we can always add it back in. And so if you take the view that we have a longtime stable government, there's a lot of across the lot of your arc of see that the theory here, which I guess is also very from Twitter is like, yes, you rid it, you turn things off, you turn them back on, you cut hugely. And if it's a problem, then you go fix a problem later. But better to cut deeper and then be able to rebuild in a cleaner way than to cut not deep enough to only get a quarter loaf.
And politics is normally does not go that far in reform. It's very, very hard to reform institutions. And there are no problems from that. I mean, San Francisco works quite poorly.
Much of the federal government leaves something to be desired. So is there a case to be made here for Muskism that he is doing what normal political reformers won't do and taking risk in order to do it. But this is actually the only way to actually create a federal bureaucracy that is not quite so sclorotic. It's not at all.
I think I'm a reform person, right? Obviously everything's not going to happen once. There is an ease to tearing it all down, isn't there? And it has to be a willingness to sacrifice people, right?
We're going to sacrifice this group of people, these young women, these young, they don't care about that. And one of the things I say over and over again, they're like, I have a lot of people like, how can they do this? How can they do this? I'm like, they don't care.
They don't care for you. They don't think about you. You're nothing. And I remember one time, Musk was the earliest person to talk to me about AI.
Yeah, he's been around forever, but he was really concerned about the impact of AI on the humanity. That was another thing. He was like, hey, I was going to kill us. It's going to turn the Terminator idea, right?
It's going to be self-aware and 20, whatever. And then it's going to turn around and bomb us and kill us and start again. And we got to stop that. That was his theory.
Next time I saw him, I thought he came up with a much more sophisticated idea of it, which was they're not going to kill us. They're going to treat us like house cats. We're house cats and they're fine with us here and they're going to build everything around us, but we're not in danger. We're in danger in the way house cats are, as long as they like house cats, we're fine.
Like they don't think of us as anything more. Then the next time I saw him, he had evolved into this idea that AI was more like, we're going to build highways the way we build highways across the country and humanity is a bunch of ant hills. And we go across ant hills without thinking when we're building roads. We don't know that the ant hills were there.
We just do it. I thought the progression was really interesting to me that he was looking at it. And to me, that's how he was expressing how he operates. These things are ant hills.
I don't have to think about them because we never think about them. And so to me, that was a really interesting progression of the first one cares about what happens to humanity. The last one doesn't. I like that progression of metaphors because very classically what you put into the metaphor reveals what you can see and not see out of the metaphor.
And I think the dominant comparison for what Musk is doing is Twitter, where he came in and used it in some ways, a somewhat playbook to cut through it and take control of it. But during that period, Twitter broke down terribly. It's advertising collapse that's still a much chankier platform than it used to be. I mean, it hasn't even happened before, like Rock, but the search doesn't work.
One thing that just strikes me when I look at what Trump is outsourcing to Musk right now is I wonder if they have really thought about the risk they're taking on. Because I've never seen an administration come in and so completely own everything bad that might happen that the federal government does or is supposed to regulate in the coming years. If you imagine something like the terrible plane crash had happened just recently happening in a year when push retirements have come through the FAA and, you know, Musk had already pushed the administrator of the FAA to be on leave or resign. You would get a lot more blame for that.
But bad things happen all the time. The federal government is supposed to stop financial crises and on and on and on. They're coming with this axe to the government pushing indiscriminate resignations, reassigning people, pushing out very talented career staff, anything that goes wrong. They are truly going to own.
Yes, but they won't. They will not. They will say it is not them. It was we're cleaning up from the previous right.
They will not take control because one, as you think they care about consequences, one of the messages in my mouth. I think they care about power. They don't care about the consequences of damage. They do not care.
They don't anticipate it. You write about Twitter. It's a lesser business. The only way he's getting advertisers is by threatening them.
Like they're just doing these lawsuits and and of course these advertisers are going to go back just to acquiesce to him, right? I mean, now he's power, right? Not a better business. Tesla is not a better business than what it was because they haven't innovated the cars that that that stock may be going up, but the sales are going down because the cars aren't as good.