What Happens When We Tear Down Our Heroes?

As America marks its 250th birthday, Rabbi Yitzchok Adlerstein and Rabbi Simi Lerner begin by reflecting on the extraordinary blessing that the United States has been for the Jewish people. But that conversation quickly leads to a deeper question: What happens when a society loses faith in its heroes? From America's Founding Fathers to Gedolei Yisrael, they explore whether it is possible to acknowledge the flaws of great figures without tearing down the ideals they represent. Along the way, they discuss patriotism, historical memory, the current crisis of confidence in rabbinic leadership, and the difference between righteous criticism and destructive cynicism. The episode concludes with Rabbi Adlerstein's moving reflections from Treblinka, offering a powerful reminder that even in times of profound disagreement, anger is not the same as hatred.