Skip to content
What Is Going On At The Washington Post? episode artwork

Jun 27, 2024 42 min

What Is Going On At The Washington Post?

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

The Washington Post, long held up as a beacon of great american journalism, has found itself the subject of some very bad headlines the last number of weeks. NPR's David Folkenflik and Peter Jukes of The Byline Times, join Tina Quinn to discuss how the esteemed 'paper of record' has itself become the story.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

What Is Going On At The Washington Post?

0:00 42:51
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome to For The Stage, so show about journalism. We're coming to you from to Aziran, Sydney, on the Gadigal lands of the Eora Nation, right across Australia on the Community Radio Network, and directly to your device across the Globe via podcast. I'm Tina Quinn, there's always, it's a pleasure to have your company. This week we head overseas to a scandal that's been engulfing the Washington Post.

The paper that has long been held up as a beacon of what great American journalism represents, which broke the Watergate scandal and has at least 73 Pulitzer Prizes to its name as itself becoming the story. In May, its publisher and CEO Will Lewis announced that the Post had lost $77 million last year, and then revealed a major restructure was underway, which would see AI taking front and centre. Then came the shock resignation of Sally Busby. She'd served as the Post's executive editor since 2021.

Lewis then announced her replacement would be an old colleague of his from the United Kingdom. His name was Robert Wannette. As the weeks following revealed, both Lewis and Wannette had been named in British lawsuits for their roles in the phone hacking scandals, which taught through a news corp more than a decade ago and led to the Levison inquiry. As the backlash worsened and it was revealed Lewis had tried to prevent his involvement in these scandals from being reported, Mr Wannette stepped aside before he'd even begun.

But Will Lewis remains amid deepening questions around his suitability to lead the Jeff Bezos-owned paper. So this week we ask, what's going on at the Washington Post? To discuss where joined from New York by NPR's media correspondent, David Falkenflick. Welcome David, thanks so much for joining us.

18, great to join you. And from London, Peter Jukes, the co-founder and executive editor of the Byline Times, welcome Peter, thanks for being with us. Great to be with you both this warm summer evening. David, I've just given a brief overview of what's been going on, but I'll go to you to expand and give it a bit of a greater outline of what's transpired over the last few months.

You know, there are two ways of looking at this, and one is the way in which it unfolded, particularly for the staff of the Washington Post and their outrage reaction and the backlash against their new publisher and his appointees editor. And the other way is to look at it as it actually unfolded and played out somewhat behind the scenes, somewhat unnoticed to arrive at that juncture. You talked about the surprise resignation of Sally Busby in mid-May. But what really happened was that Lewis, who took over in January, decided to reformulate the newsroom, restructure it.

Have a what he called the third newsroom after the conventional sports news, the kind of things that you think of as a core of a newspaper, at least in the States. And then separate that out with a kind of skunk works where you have experimental notions of what content was, what people might be willing to pay individually for, and certain kinds of professional services that you might be able to build an additional subscription tier for. So you think on the one hand a little bit of the New York Times, and it's very popular, games function, it's very popular, cooking offerings, it's offering sports through this outlet called the Athletic that acquired Wirecutter Reviewing Services. These are elements that are adjacent to, but not necessarily core to a prime newspaper product.

He essentially said to Sally Busby that he's executive editor, Hey, I want you to run the skunk works. It was a demotion from running the entire paper, including whatever innovation they were doing. She didn't want to accept it. The problem with that was twofold.

One was just logistically, he announced it by complete surprise. On a Sunday night to try to beat the New York Times, which was going to break that story. And he wanted to get it all at once without anybody. But they also didn't know that she was on the block.

Replacing where it was a perfectly logical move, that if the Washington Post lost $77 million last year, over a hundred million a year before, it's lost about half of its web audience since 2020. Let's be fair, that's happened to a lot of nonpartisan and ideological sites in those years. Do you think that could be a trip hold to her? Well, certainly the paper's conservative critics would argue that she's gone all in with social justice and she's been anti-Trump.

And they would argue a lot of things. There may be pieces here and there that contribute to that. But I think there's been such broadly problem with traffic in my shop in right wing organizations that are monitored as well. That it's very hard to attribute it to anyone like that.

I think people are desperately tired of the news. They're fatigued by Trump. They're fatigued by after Trump. They're just tired of bad news.

We went through an exhausting four years and this is one of the repercussions. But what people at the Post can't quite get their hands around was, was this a strategic decision? Were they breaking this up and offering Sally a much diminished role that essentially she wasn't well suited for? The idea of innovation and was very unlikely to take?

Or was there a reason that he did this that contributed to that? So go back to December of last year when I was reporting about these allegations in court having to do with these years old cases involving Rupert Murdoch's British tabloids and having to do with essentially an allegation that there was a cover up that prevented people from knowing the full extent to which they were being hacked or in other ways they're privacy illegally invaded. And these allegations being brought by Prince Harry at that time to Grant who's since settled by several Liberal Democrat former cabinet ministers, senior government officials among others. Who else's name kept popping up?

So I was doing a story about a former cabinet minister who was alleging that Murdoch's tabloids had hacked him to try to advance their corporate interests, which would be the first time that was successfully alleged if they prevailed. That's a major story. I did that story. Basically no one in the States followed up on that.

But will this name kept popping up? He was about after the turn of the New Year to take over the Washington Post. This fabled incredibly important pillar of American journalism and beyond our own borders as you so eloquently pointed out your introduction. What is will Lewis doing in there in the middle of these allegations about a cover up?

He greenlit according to some of this material and I'll let you unpack that in a minute. But he greenlit or seem to greenlight the deletion of millions of emails that Scotland Yard was pretty explicit and wanted to see. And the allegation is he covering this stuff up. So I did a story on that.

I was working on a story that in December and will Lewis did everything he could to intimidate me and then to essentially offer me something else to get me to drop that story. I did my story anyway. Did not acknowledge his efforts to offer me to some story. When you say that, I mean, how did that actually play out?

How did that manifest? What did that look and sound like? Well, let me say this. We talked off the record because I wanted to give him time and space to address these concerns.

Byline times among a very small number of outlets really has been following this doggedly. But I felt that I had new material that had been newly leveraged in court, which would offer greater half to some of the broader outline allegations that come before and Peter can backfill if I'm getting that if you disagree with that characterization. But it seemed to me like we were advancing the ball significantly back in December about Lewis's role and about the role of others. Lewis was heated in talking with me.

I'm not going to talk about the substance of what he had to say about those allegations. But Lewis kept trying to drag the conversation in place that I had the great, which is say, do this other story instead and I will sit down with you. If you drop this, I will sit down with you and talk to you about my plans for the future of the Washington Post. Now, would I like to have that story?

Absolutely. I cover the media for NPR. The Post is an important peer institution. It's a good story.

I would rather have both. I don't think it's my place to close my eyes to something which could reflect something about the character of the chief executive of the Washington Post when the most important institutions on my beat, simply because I might get something in the future. And to be honest, there's almost no story I could be given that would make me say I shouldn't do this story. It's an improper offer.

It may be proper in a different and ruffle tumble world of Fleet Street, particularly the tabloids, which actually, Lewis was not a part of. But this was not appropriate to me. So I certainly noticed it. He then did it in a second conversation.

His PR person then essentially alluded to it again. And finally, I called back. I called her back before public. I said, I just want to be really clear about this.

Are you telling me if I drop this story about the material on which allegations arresting that will Lewis participate in a significant cover up of the extent to which executives knew about how widespread hacking was in other legal activity at their tabloids in London that he will give me a sit down in Washington and talk about his future for Washington Post. And she said, yes, you've got it exactly right. I hung up the phone. I said, OK, well, there's no room for misunderstanding this there.

So I didn't report that back when I did my story in December. But I stuck it in my back pocket as something that informed my thinking about among other things or at minimum. Will Lewis's sensitivity to this topic. Why did you wait six months to reveal this in your reporting?

Well, so it became very important when after he announced Buzzbee's surprise departure from the post, the New York Times weighed in to say that he had pressured her in May, just two and a half, three weeks earlier, not to report on new developments about this very topic where the British judge overseeing these cases said essentially to the litigants. I am giving you authority to dive deeper to do what we hear called discovery in the States. You are going to be legally entitled to get a trove and a host of information from him and about him that he will be a central player, although he's not a defendant, which is important to note. He's not charged with any crimes and he's not a named party to this, but he has a core player to it.

So once we knew that I was able to go and show that actually not only had he pressured her there, although did not prevent her from covering it, he had pressured her two months earlier when this question was posted to the judge. Can we get more leeway to explore and investigate? Will Lewis? And he said, don't do it.

And so I said, look, these are at least three times where he has pressured her. And since then, by the way, it turned out that when I published my story back in December and broadcast my story on this very topic, she brought the issue up to him. He wasn't even publisher yet. And on that day, he said, don't cover it.

It's not a story. So four times he did this. There's a pattern, but fascinatingly. And I want to hear Peter on this.

It's a pattern about the same story. This is a pressure point for him. So all the other things are fascinating to me that have come fast and furious about Lewis's record, some of which I've reported on two. But this very instance is clearly signaled to him anyway in terms of defining, am I going to be able to go forward and have a successful venture here at the Post?

Peter, if I can bring you in here to give some context on this really crucial point, because I know most people would be aware and well aware of the news of the world, phone hacking scandals and engulfed Murdoch and newscorpand led to the Levison inquiry. But even though that was quite a long time ago, it hasn't quite gone away. Has it the embers of it all have really continued to spread through the air? Yeah.

So I, in the autumn of my life, I became a journalist by covering the phone hacking trial and I like tweeted eight months of it. And out of that came a key narrative. And so will Lewis, I'm going to remember, this is very important. He had worked with the Sunday Times.

And what is clear is that some of what is called unlawful information gathering affected other papers on part from the world. The sun, the daily tabloid, it wasn't involved, but they have paid out 500 million in settlements. But what you had is also those kinds of activities prevalent in the Sunday Times. It's slightly different.

So I didn't know this at the time. So I always tweet out whenever what is called the Management Standards Committee. This was, will Lewis was taken from the telegraph. He'd been the Sunday Times, worked with Robin at that.

But they both gone over to telegraph, which is now ailing, but was a writing publication, but with great standing, but news gathering. In fact, cover the phone hacking trial. So it actually wasn't a tabloid. And I say the news of the world is unknown.

It's like this. It's great. These are, but that's also invited the murder of, you know, they are, they are not tabloids. They are not interested in sneezing, kiss and tell.

They're interested in politics. So he came from that background and famously obtained. There are now questions, especially in America about the ethics of it. The MPs expensive became a huge scandal.

These hidden amount of expenses. Margaret Thatcher didn't want to give them a pay rise. So she allowed British members of the claim is expensive. So he came over to lead with some greenbird salad seats.

This ethical, the MSC. Now, as the New York Times has recounted, they his attitude of what he says now is, I'm here to clean out the organ stable. I'm here to help, but it became apparent. And what the lawyers involved in this case say, particularly from my tweets, that nearly every time operation, meeting the first police investigation, all the civil cases, Ciena Miller said, please preserve any evidence that massive amounts of emails were deleted 20 minutes.

Some of those about 12,000 were recovered because they had backups. And there was a consistent pattern of a document which called concealment and destruction. And that went to the highest level. That was a corporate decision that was well above NGN, the publisher of News of the World Sun.

This was at news core level, which will, though, is at with a group of lawyers. Also now revealed at this time, thanks to the work of Nick Davis, who, your patient retired after exposing the scandal, took him two or three years as the new hacking has emerged since thanks to disclosure from these civil cases would be going on for 10 years. Mother Book has paid out a billion pounds. That's $1.3 billion to settle IE to stop them coming to court because there's a weird part of English law that if the judge award you less in their degrees, you have a case, then then the court costs your liable for the court costs.

That's why you grant a settle that in how much you got somebody just under a minute because if the judge had awarded him less than the murder of off again, he'd be liable for 12 minutes. So they settled settled settled up to have. But what emerged in that disclosure from those civil claims was hacking continued, particularly against a high level against members and coalition government. Presume of its cable, who was the business actually making the decision about this key merger between news core and B Sky B, which was created as additional hub.

That was going on. All this is the claim. This is what the numbers and hub that these politicians, including the very committed. This is 2012, 13, investigated phone hacking, DC, MSC, which people like Tom Watson, called Farrelly.

They all found out they were hacked during that. So this is all actually post the news of the world scandal. This is post the Levesant inquiry. Fine hacking.

Yeah, so that's really down that explodes. This big close off of 2009 2011, really down that they closed news of the world. This is 12 and 30. Right.

So this is an, and DC mess is committed in this case. So obviously without there being any hard evidence, the influence is people high up in the MSC would have couldn't only have known about this and there's certain interactions with certain lobbyists, certain bits of information that came out. And there's lobbyists ghost things stable after there's a parent hack, parent hacks of his phone with information, which can only come from a phone conversation. So the state of his knowledge that high up in the company.

But I think where this really speaks to is something deeper, which is as David alerts to his culture, our British newspapers. Now, the Sunday Times, the Times, Rupert Murdoch took over 1981, which is huge debate. There he was, the unusual world. The son, he was going to take over the very organs of the Times of London.

This is the first ever independent newspaper. This is the almost served institution of state, but they were free from this kind of activity. Now, what I met in 2017 and you've heard from him in Sunday's article here, Northman, a guy called John Ford, who word for the Sunday Times, where we networked and where will Lewis also word obtain information, not by hacking, though. It's not similar by impersonating people.

You get called books, blanket, they call it. He get hit impersonated, go round against back. It's called unlawful information. So my question would be to something like Lewis.

Why doing Lewis? Will Lewis involve? Why would you get him to clean up Sables? Could it be?

And I'm suggesting I'm sure he'd have to answer these questions. He knew what emails to clean up. And the wider issue is for me, as somebody became into journalism to counter this corruption, comes out of monopoly, comes out of abuse of power with one strong media proprietor dominating all the employment. So nobody wants to speak out against murder because you'll never work again.

But this infection, which I would say, as my cousin, has infected British society, led to the catastrophe of Brexit. All many of the wrongs we've seen now is because of this political media class, which includes Boris Johnson, journalist, which includes Michael Goge, journalist. It's now infected. What we look up to as a standard, which is the Washington Post.

Are we always joking? We actually with the Miretica, Hadi Matharov. Yeah, imagine the Watergate scandal happened in the UK. What would happen with a Bernstein?

We'd go to a conservative central office and say, look, I've got the story. Shall I bury it? Can I become a government spokesman? Like Nandi Coulson convicted as editor of the World States head of communications.

Now, to me, I look to America for the things that antidote that. That is the standard and the idea that we've somehow exported the immersive, classic mafia phrase that you keep silent, you know, where the bodies are buried, never tell. What David, the narrative David's talking about, which is I'll give you access. I'll tell you this if you bury that.

That's the modus operandi of the British press. That's what's led us to this state. And it appalls me that this could have crossed the Atlantic. If you've just tuned in, you're listening to Fourth Estate on the Community Radio Network.

I'm Tina Quinn and joining me is Peter Dukes of the Byline Times in London and David Falcon Flick of NPR in New York. We're talking of the recent goings on at the Washington Post and whether the embers of the news of the world scandal have indeed traveled across the Atlantic to the United States. David, we've just heard from Peter there about the sort of reverence that people all around the world have for the Washington Post and the sort of journalistic ethics. It's long and body, all been seen to embody.

What's the reaction been on the home front to all of this? The Washington Post is one of the three great American national newspapers, The New York Times, controlled by the Salzburgers, the Wall Street Journal, controlled by the Murdoch family since 2007. But Murdoch has not transformed it into a partisan or ideological outlet in its news pages because its connection with its paying readership is so strong that to do that I think would, you know, Murdoch understands the business proposition when he sees it. And he wants the respect that it affords.

It's the reason he paid so much for it. It's actually a good financial standing. And one of the reasons why it's not good financial standing is probably because of its digital subscription strategy that will always help to oversee and keep going from 2014 to 2020 when he was publisher there and CEO of its parent unit. But the Post is one of these great independent newspapers.

It's owned by Jeff Bezos, the founder of Amazon, before that it was owned by the Graham family, or controlled by it, I should say, publicly traded. And, you know, it is an independent paper, an independent minded paper, federal newspaper, one that struggled a little bit to figure out whether it's truly a national paper or more of a regional paper that happens to be in our federal city. But it does enterprising and intelligent crusading work, war and crisis coverage coverage of matters far near, not just political bickering. And it's had its financial troubles, in part because some of the warping war of political life in Washington has been covered in greater minutiae by some of these startups, Politico, Axios, more recently punchbowl is a new thing.

These digital natives, many of them drawing upon post alumni who have great sourcing, great energy, ambition, and just saw leans of opportunity where the Post was a little too conventional and did not. And that's a problem for the Post. But it is the Post is a great paper with great ambition, a tremendous staff being owned by Jeff Bezos was seen as the salvation of a lot of its financial troubles when he purchased it a little over a decade ago, or what is for him pocket change. And that said, Bezos wants the paper to be financially viable on its own, not simply a charitable trust.

And while I could wish and think that actually the great digital giants of America deserve or owe it to Americans and to the world to fund through billion dollar level largesse local and national news that Google and Amazon and Microsoft and Metaphasbook and TikTok and all these guys have just scraped content of journalists and slapped it up there for people to absorb their time. I also think there's a value in the Post itself being financially viable. And right now, they were looking actually, they were charmed by will Lewis at the Post. They were ready to be seduced by him.

They wanted somebody who was a man with a plan. Lewis is fluid. He is charming. He is smart.

He had some successes at the telegraph at News Corp, particularly at the Journal. And he was scandal free at the Journal and was a newspaper editor of the year at the telegraph. And this guy sounded like he had verveate just down a startup and blown up. But then again, it only been there for a couple of years was toying with the idea of buying the telegraph himself.

It sounded like this guy was bringing great energy. But they were shocked to learn that their editor was being pushed out, not because they all thought this is the greatest editor we've ever had. A lot of people felt like she hadn't quite gotten the mix right. A lot of folks at the Post even though it was out great.

What was the general feeling about Sally Busby at the Post? Look, she was a very good conventional editor of the Associated Press and she was willing to work on innovation, but it didn't necessarily play to her in neat strengths. So people saw, hey, a new publisher gets a new editor. I think my sense is from people that Busby has talked to, that even Busby conceded that if he replaced her, that would be a legitimate thing for a new publisher to do.

But the way they did it, the backstory to it, what happened just a few weeks earlier, the timing of it. The fact that they didn't, you know, it wasn't as though Rob Winette came and met discreetly with a few editors and was vetted. And so was Kevin Merida, the former managing editor who went off to head the LA Times for a few years or other plausible candidates. It's that they said this guy who we'll work with for many years and who we've never heard of over here and works for a fairly high-level candidate.

Partisan, if reputable newspaper is going to come in and be our editor. And his boss as a guy who also is more as much British as American newspaper traditions that was complicated for them. So I think that's part of what they see. I mean, Lewis, let's be clear also in just five short months, not only was his editor in chief to be a former mate, the other editor they're bringing in to do the skunk works who's now leading the conventional user named Matt Murray was the guy he had promoted to be editor in chief of the Wall Street Journal.

His chief strategy officer was somebody who had worked for them for years in the Murdoch world. His chief growth officer, the same. He named a chief of staff, which was a new position who had worked with him prior at Dow Jones Wall Street Journal. He named a director of communications for the Office of the Chief Executive, which was a brand new site that kind of caused confusion among the people trying to do PR for the post itself because it was never clear who was supposed to speak on behalf of the post during this moment of crisis.

Right? And so Lewis brought in this retinue of people that nobody knew. Some of them may be quite good. And again, I'm not saying that he's got the wrong tack here.

It's just that it created a ton of confusion at a time where it turned out his values, his dedication to American journalistic principles were suddenly being cast into doubt. Yeah, exactly. And you've spoken to Sally Busby since all this has happened. Does she feel that she was pushed out?

Does she feel she was pushed out because of her pushback on the post reporting on Lewis's ties to the phone hacking scandals and he's being named in those lawsuits? Well, she hasn't really commented since this. I haven't secured an interview with her. But my sense from talking to people who have talked to her is that she's not confident that the pressure that she received from Lewis, which she denies, but she tested to contemporaneously to a number of colleagues and trusted associates.

She's not confident that that didn't play into his decision to restructure and to give her something that she signaled that she would not find accepted. He's entitled to fire her outright, but this is not the way in which the newsroom that feels as though it has a role to play in innovating and changing the way they do things and being along for the ride. You want to do radical change? You need people to embrace it.

You have a union in place. You can't just simply say, okay, I'm going to let go. This afternoon everybody has to reapply for their jobs. That's not the way that's not the way it can work.

I just have to push back a little bit on the reputation of the telegraph under Lewis. So, I mean, there's a famous phrase that I've lived dated, worked in America. That when you have an English accent, you get 10 IQ points added to your intelligence, because it's just the exit. We're not that much smarter.

And look, will Lewis's time that this big scoop, MP expenses scandal, though, questions about that? During that time and in the background, I completely agree with David. It's the tech giants proving up all the advertising, who read up the stories, you know, being just a platform on the publisher. The telegraph was in Darth Straight.

It took a lot of Russian money from the Russian government to survive under Lewis. And it is a gutted shell of its form itself. It has, you know, this is after his tenure. It has really sacked all the great news journalists that it had.

It is very pro-Ferrage, who's this white-wing Trumpite insurgent leader here. It's really not got the reputation which it had for 100 years as this paper. And I have to question, given the fact that whatever he allowed the Wall Street Journal to be independent, the ultimate property is the man behind Fox News and the Dominion Scan and the lying about a stolen election. And what emerged about will Lewis, I think it was in the Guardian, a great story in the Guardian about a week ago.

He's very close to the Boris Johnson. In fact, he paid Boris Johnson $200,000 a year, which Boris Johnson, as he was just an MP, may have landed that time called Chicken Feed. A puff colony wrote every month. Right?

When Boris Johnson was in difficulties, particularly this party gets scandal where we all look down and they have 100 people finding down in the street for partying when they shouldn't have done. Well, Lewis is part of 18 called a big dog because Boris Johnson might call himself a big dog and he recommended according to the Guardian report, which has not been contested. Go and delete all your WhatsApp. So when the public inquiry happened where required under Enquirer is Act, the Johnson released his WhatsApp messages 5000 on his side.

So there's a pattern here. And this is not the pattern of independent journalism. This is a cronyism of a political media class where journalists get very close to power. They aid power when it wants to cover up stuff.

And so to me, one of the most amazing incidents of this whole scandal is we call it contention in the last week has been the Washington Post investigating their own publisher and incoming executive editor. Can I say that would never happen in the UK ever? And I spoke to them these journalists. But they had to find more.

But look, they're doing it. It's just to me, this is the gold standard. When there was this great scandal that Jimmy Savo, the famous presenter here, who turned out the rampant abuse of the BBC started investigation into him, but next it, right? And I TV eventually did it by completing commercial time.

This is a gold standard of journalists to me. You can investigate your own properties longer. And so to me, you know, I don't know what happens with this story, but it is clear to people, right? That we have a functional press.

It's different than the broadcast on BBC's much better than most American broadcast. But when it comes to press, this sense that you suited as independence of the new steam from the proprietors on advertising these Chinese wars. If you let that wall go down, if America lets that will go down, there's no else to look to honest, excoriating probing journalists. I mean, the way of which, you know, framing the telegraph is sort of how people here were interpreting it, putting the best frame they could for thinking positively about it.

I think they're ways in which you can interpret his times at these papers is promising. And they're absolutely ways in which even his great much lauded scoop, the parliamentary expenses scandal, is problematic by American standards. The post would not have allowed him to pay the £110,000 that he authorized to acquire a database said to have been stolen. But that did serve a public good and showing abuse of taxpayer funds, for sure.

And that is a tension there. But there are times where, you know, you want to break a story, but if you can't do it without violating your ethics, you have to do that. I mean, what he failed to do, at least in the initial going, was to even acknowledge they made a payment. You know, the initial wave of that, my feeling is, look, I do have principles.

I hope, I hope I think I do. But at minimum, I think you have to be transparent if you're transressing that. You know, you have to keep faith and say we've decided an extraordinary act to do this. Ultimately, one of the assistant editors went on the BBC and acknowledged the payment.

But that's not to me. If you're doing that, you kind of need to do it in the upfront. The tension here is that in reporting and being able to reveal this unethical behaviour by someone in power, the means in which he was able to do that was by the standards of some unethical in itself. Yeah, it's tricky.

It's a tricky one. In British circles, there's different more is that obtained there. I mean, that turns out to be on the more acceptable side of things so much of what was done in Britain that had been revealed as part of that hacking, blagging and the legality scandal. Ultimately wasn't in the public interest.

And what we said that as soon as people found out about it, I mean, there were still questions about those expenses. I hate that exactly how they obtained them. I'm not sure we've got the whole story and it was late coming. It was also Heather Brooke, an American journalist, got the FOI, the disclosure, the telegraph got the database and leaked selected.

So the first most common, they did target labour politicians before conservative politicians. So like the questions over June, the Sanj, recently released, maybe that's a good thing. When you have a database, how you release it. And I think that, you know, you're right, that is the standards of modus operandi of the British press, not of the public.

I'm not sure they are having. I think that's right. Murdoch famously said, and I think it was a talk he gave in 89 in Edinburgh, that whatever the public is interested in, you know, providing that as a public service. That is an absolutely alien conception of public service to mainstream American reporters, but also the reporters in the Washington Post newsroom.

After I did my reporting, and I also then acknowledged the pressure and the offer that Lewis offered, you know, presented to me as a get out of jail free card. I perhaps a little too severe, given the circumstances. Again, he's not charged with anything criminally or being sued, but unless it is troubles in court and just sidestep that. So maybe I wouldn't pay attention.

Maybe the American press wouldn't see it and wouldn't pay attention to it. What have you? He called me an activist, not a journalist. Well, this was a shock to people at the post, not because they're rallying with torches to defend me for me.

But they see that as an attack on assault on what they do for a living and how they conceive of themselves, which is not as activist, but in asking at times impertent questions to figures in power. And will Lewis is among them right now. The Washington Post is a purge of great influence and of great significance for the American political system, but he does not see itself as a political player. And so Lewis, if he is injecting a more British sensibility, making these walls or boundaries more porous or actually more yielding.

If he is taking up the interest of a party or a political figure, if he is bending the newsroom to the interests of a billionaire owner or a corporate interest, these are not the values of the newsroom that he wants to inspire to embrace radical change feel that they embody on a daily basis. That is the tension that you are seeing inherent in the newsroom. It's not that there were these little things around the edges. I really think that it's the biggest thing in some ways is the question of, did he cover up?

Did he actively participate in cover up great criminality and unethical behavior at big British newspapers for his billionaire owner? And did he seek to intimidate or buy off journalists who sought to report on that? And does he have an answer for those things? He hasn't addressed any of them.

And those are alien values to journalists. It was one of the most distressing moments when I saw him call me an activist. And I look back to an article we never published a cover. Remember why it wasn't anything legal in 2018.

Why put a white of applies for Wall Street Journal? Journalist was all but you're just a bunch of disgruntled feminists who don't like the free price. So the principle of the free price. This is from Lewis.

This is what he said to you. Yes, the principle of the free price that speaks about fear of fame. Anybody who speaks Gates power is an activist. And this is what happened in the phone hacking scandal.

Everything afterwards was a very extreme version of libertarianism, which anybody who challenges. Power is secretly an activist is muzzling the free press and free speech. But of course the writer of free press and the free speech is a challenge people about either they do speak up for classes. This is what's happened in the UK.

And it's very worrying seeing those Trump is tenders is in fact mainstream America. Do you think Bayesos in choosing will Lewis as his executive editor and CEO? Do you think part of it was that he liked the fact that Lewis was someone who would bend to the will of a proprietor? I think look, Bayesos has been exemplary in terms of not interfering with the post covering either anything to do with Amazon.

Or anything to do with his messy personal life. He just didn't get involved. He blew up his own personal life. He exposed literally and figuratively pretty much everything to do with himself.

And he was on his is the model of discretion compared to what will Lewis did. But it does seem likely that he was happy to know that Lewis, I mean, this is projection at a certain point. But one of Lewis's attributes is he knew how to manage a billionaire with strong thoughts on things. And he also, as Peter has indicated, will Lewis knows how to deal with a conservative force in government and to do business with it?

And for that matter, Rob Winnet knew how to make peace with essentially an extremely populist right wing element of British politics, the Brexiteers. And we're Trump to come back for another term. And it may well be that Bayesos and subsequently Lewis is convinced that would happen. You might want somebody from this perspective as a proprietor who knows how to make peace with that after years of Trump's fans accusing the post as being sort of repository of some sort of left wing social justice anti-Trump movement, which I think is unfair to the post, but certainly developments and recent years of the press make that a little easier to watch as a complaint.

And will this has the advantage of seemingly live, right? There's a kind of error about him. He seems to borrow politics. It's not like Descartes famous editor of Paul Descartes of the Mail, or like Oscar Joe, it's like on the left.

He seems to escape the apolitical. And, you know, he is the guy who gets the job done and doesn't seem to make much noise. I can see, yeah, in doing deals with voice Johnson, he did with Trump. So Robert Winnet has obviously decided to stay in the United Kingdom, or maybe the decision was made for him.

What do you think will Lewis's future is at the Washington Post as publisher and CEO? You know, there's really only one vote that matters that belongs to Jeff Bezos. I do think that a lot's going to depend on what the journalists, including those at the Post itself, further turn up. I think that while Robert Winnet's withdrawal has the ameliorative effect for Lewis of not erasing the question, but lowering the temperature on the hot chase on to figure out what the heck Robert Winnet stands for as he was a person of, I'm not saying he's not capable or that there aren't positive attributes that he would bring to this job.

I'm just saying he has zero profile in the States. If you're not worked here, he's not doing these transcend figures who, you know, he's not a Harry Evans. He's not an Alan Rusperger. He's not a figure who crosses the Atlantic with some sense of stature and bearing nobody knew about him here.

So people were delving deep to figure out what made him tick and a lot of this stuff. A lot of things that got him to where he is did not reflect well on him by American standards. You know, Lewis, there are some of my peers who are media critics and reporters who have said, well, you know, this matters really been adjudicated or litigated. You know, did he participate in packing?

He was never charged with anything. These things seem relatively small, poor and not perfectly nailed down. The New York Times's incidents, you know, is relying on sort of a little bit of assumption by one of the reporters involved, although it seems fairly credible. You know, this happened over 20 years ago.

Why should we care? But I do think that the matters I sketched out a couple minutes ago, the question emerging in court right now where more information is likely to be leveraged as the judge has given the lawyers for Critteri and others much more leeway to go drill deep and find whatever has been recovered. But whatever still exists all these years later, you know, Lewis wasn't supposed to be part of the population of people being investigated. He was the guy supposed to be relaying information over to Scotland Yard, but it turns out his role matters a lot.

The allegation is that among the things he did was protect Rebecca Brooks who at that time and now is once again the head of Murdoch's publishing arm in the UK, an incredibly powerful figure, a surrogate daughter to Murdoch. I mean, that's an interesting story within itself. Rebecca, but I'm just saying Murdoch doesn't settle all of these numerous cases that are still going on. Revelations are likely to ensue.

Will there be a drumbeat that continues going? Will there be more findings from his own journalists working at the Washington Post, independently of pressure from the publisher's office on that? Will the Times or others come forward with other things? Will the Guardian find more things about?

Will Lewis's fate does not appear currently in his own hands? It resides in the wisdom and discretion of Jeff Bezos and it resides in, I guess, a little bit potentially like the Tell Hill heart beating beneath the floorboards on what revelations come to light in court in London and on the pages of the post and its competitors, and that will dictate his fate. It's a very uncomfortable place for a person to be in because he's got to perform his job and show his strategic and lift the post out of these incredible losses financially, resurrect some sense of goodwill that initially existed from the staff toward him. And at the same time, hope to hell that something doesn't emerge from Britain that blows it all up once again.

We'll have to leave it there, but David Falconflik, thank you so much for joining us on Fourth Estate. Pleasure. And Peter Jukes, thank you so much for joining us as well. Great to be with you.

And thank you for listening to the program. This edition of Fourth Estate was recorded at the studios of Tue SIR and Tuttacross the Country on the Community Radio Network. Fourth Estate was produced with the assistance of the Community Broadcasting Foundation, a big thanks to the foundation for their continuing support. Make sure you subscribe to Fourth Estate on your favourite podcast app so you can hear us talk about media, politics and everything else in between.

We'll be back with more next week of course about In The Meantime You Can Stay in Touch with us on X, formerly known as Twitter. Our handle is Fourth Estate AU. I'm Tina Gwyn, please do stay well, stay safe and we'll catch you next week on Fourth Estate.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 42 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on June 27, 2024.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.