Skip to content
What Next - Why is Everyone Fighting Over... Macklemore? episode artwork

Sep 21, 2026 30 min

What Next - Why is Everyone Fighting Over... Macklemore?

from Slate Daily Feed

What it means that Macklemore decided he’d rather keep speaking out for Palestine than continue opening for Ed Sheeran. Guest: Soraya Nadia McDonald, cultural critic and writer. Want more What Next? Subscribe to Slate Plus to access ad-free listening to the whole What Next family and across all your favorite Slate podcasts. Subscribe today on Apple Podcasts by clicking “Try Free” at the top of our show page. Sign up now at slate.com/whatnextplus to get access wherever you listen. Podcast production by Evan Campbell, Madeline Thames-Ducharme and Patrick Fort. Paige Osburn is the senior supervising producer of What Next and What Next TBD.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

What Next - Why is Everyone Fighting Over... Macklemore?

0:00 30:15
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Welcome back to Fresh Matters, where we discuss matters of freshness. I'm the grossier here with Kat from Metro. Kat, your produce is impeccable. We have high standards. We... Meat is custom cut on site to my very delight. Yep, it's important that we... And the baked goods? More like baked grates. Fresh in store every day. So at Metro you would say fresh. Matters? It does! Find fresh meals and deals at Metro!

Support comes from Wise, the smart checking account for home and abroad. Got a Canadian salary, property in the U.S., sending money abroad? You're juggling multiple accounts, currencies, and a headache. Manage it all the smart way with Wise. Save up to 65% on exchange fees and give your everyday money a boost with interest. Plus, switch your direct deposit to Wise for the monthly chance to double your paycheck. Be smart. Get Wise. Canada residents only, excluding Quebec. Up to 60 winners. Odds depend on entries. Offer ends September 14, 2027. Learn more at wise.com. Soraya, before the last week or so...

When was the last time you thought about Macklemore? Oh, wow. More than a decade ago, probably. Oh, yeah. This is Soraya McDonald. She is a cultural critic. And if you are like her or me and you have not thought about Macklemore in a very long time, give us 30 seconds to catch you up.

Macklemore is the guy behind the song Thrift Shop. Maybe you remember when he won a Grammy that even he thought should have gone to Kendrick Lamar. All you need to know about Macklemore now is he's still performing. In fact, Ed Sheeran took him on tour. But at the very first stop, Macklemore gave a speech about Palestine. I've been trying to figure out a way to say this all day. One of the reasons why I wanted to come on this tour was because I wanted to stand up here on stages and stadiums across America and say two words that are very near and dear to my heart. Free Palestine. After this, the internet lost its mind.

I said free Palestine. How did you hear about this whole dust-up? Oh, I mean, well, it's doing numbers on threads. Did you have a chance to listen to what Macklemore's been saying from the stage? I didn't see anything that was particularly hateful or concerning to me. Macklemore got booted from Ed Sheeran's tour anyway, after the pop star Pink spoke out, and then some stadium owners intervened. What those decision-makers did not seem to anticipate, though, was everyone else's opinions.

Weird to me about the trajectory of the story, the Macklemore story, is that the people who were worried about what Macklemore was saying, in some ways they won, right? Macklemore was removed from a tour he was on after comments about Palestine got so much attention. But it just wasn't the end of the story, you know? Yeah. I don't know. I mean, did they win? I mean, so he's off the tour and now all of the other opening acts for Ed Sheeran also left. His tickets are, I think, selling, you know, are being offered for like 65 bucks in the stadium tour. Yeah. That's a deep discount, I assume. Today on the show, how did Macklemore become a lightning rod on Gaza? Why now? Why him? I'm Mary Harris. You're listening to What Next. Stick around.

Hey, it's Kat Nat from Kat Nat Unfiltered. You know what matters most to us when cooking for our family's freshness. That's why we always choose Metro. Their produce is hand-picked, their bread is baked in store, and their butcher's custom-cut meat to our exact needs. Freshness is the thing that can make a simple meal simply amazing or turn an ordinary bite into an extraordinary night. At Metro, fresh matters because fresh changes everything. Find fresh meals and deals at your local Metro.

At Capital One, we don't just use technology, we architect it. Our teams have true end-to-end product ownership, shipping distributed systems at scale right here in downtown Toronto. That's technology at Capital One. Search technology at Capital One Canada. Introducing Pandora's Holiday Collection. This season, celebrate the ones you know by heart with a gift that says it all. Because the best gifts don't just look beautiful, they mean something too. From engraveable pieces to festive charms to lab-grown diamonds, our jewelry is made for the ones who inspire you, who've been through it all. Give a piece that says exactly what words can't. Pandora, more than a gift. Shop new styles in-store or online at pandora.net.

Okay, I want to dig into the Macklemore mishigas with you. Because it's just really complicated. Yeah. We have Macklemore, this artist who people are maybe familiar with because of a 2012 hit thrift shop. There you go. White rapper. On tour with Ed Sheeran, of all people, who seems to have really put into his act this moment where he talks about the war in Gaza and Palestine and makes a real statement to the crowd about what he believes about it. And he says, Free Palestine.

And my colleague Alex Kirshner has pointed out part of the reason I think this has attracted so much attention, what happened here, is that Macklemore is not an ideal ambassador in this fight. And I want to get into why, because I think that, I mean, we've talked about how his music is kind of not like highbrow music. Exactly. It's corny. It's corny. Thank you, Soraya. That is the correct terminology. But also he has a history, which I was unaware of until all of this, of like dressing up in an anti-Semitic costume on stage. This is 2014. Can you just tell the story? Yeah, there are images of him.

dressed to perform, I think what kind of really sends this over the edge in terms of plausible deniability or lack thereof is that the fact that he's sort of dressing up in this very big sort of hooked nose, a beard, which is black, and then dark black hair, like the only other... Visually, maybe the only other comparison that I could make that is not of a sort of anti-Semitic Jewish stereotype is maybe the buzzards from The Jungle Book. Wow. OK, that was a deep cut. Yeah. So he dresses up this way. And that combined with, you know, the fact that he is singing about like saving money, like buying all his clothes at the thrift shop.

you know, really converges on the stereotype of Jews as especially tight-fisted. Yeah, and he did this at a concert and he said, I did this to like blend into the crowd and be in disguise. And he later apologized for it. I feel like we have to say all of those things did happen. But it really was this moment where people looked at him like, guy, what are you doing? And then it sort of went away. And then now it's like, we hear about him again and he's very much speaking up in defense of Palestine. How quickly was it clear like, oh, this is going to be a problem for some people, specifically for people who own stadiums in the United States where he might be performing? Yeah, I think it was the...

The news story, when Bob Craft specifically characterized Macklemore saying free Palestine as hate speech. Bob Craft, notoriously the owner of the New England Patriots. Friend to the president. Friend to the president, friend to other stadium owners where Macklemore might be performing. You know, sort of someone who could rally the elite here. And I just think that...

how people responded in the wake of like Macklemore getting all this attention is so telling. Like you have like the social media response of like, you know, artists saying like, I support or don't support him. And of course it creates all of this pressure on Ed Sheeran, who Macklemore is touring with to say something, anything about what's going on. Like I stand by this guy, don't stand by this guy, whatever. Or just artistic freedom, right? Like you could have just. Exactly. And eventually it becomes clear Macklemore is departing the tour and Ed Sheeran comes out with a statement. And I want to pick apart this statement because it's so.

telling. It's like a classic Instagram, like slide after slide kind of thing. And he basically says, this wasn't my decision. It was a promoter's decision, which to me is the first misstep because you're not acknowledging your involvement at all as like the lead headlining artist. Yes. It feels like absolution seeking, like from jump. Exactly. Exactly. And then he's like, well, I want my space to be a place for children and all of these things. You're like, well, why is saying Free Palestine not for children? Like it just creates all of these questions in your head. And he says, I don't want to be complicit. I'm like, hold it. Isn't this the definition of complicit? If you're not, if you're just going along with what your promoters are saying here.

You are saying something. He's trying to say he's not saying something, but he is. Yes, right. That is the essence of, you know, when Howard Zinn said you cannot be neutral on a moving train, this train is definitely moving. And I'm not sure that Ed quite grasped that, you know, just going from the Instagram carousel statement that he made. I think it's strange because of what it reveals perhaps about his priorities. Tell me more about that. Like his first priority seems to be...

again, like one of absolution seeking, like, please don't blame me. Please don't, you know, it's, I don't want to be like drawn into this. I think he referred to this as a conflict, you know, like he, he would like to sort of remain politely on the sidelines, not being expected to have thoughts or opinions or anything, but like at best, then you're just, you're just passive. You know, you're just, you're Gumby. I'm confused about the motivations of some of the people involved in this fight because Robert Kraft, of course, like, He kicked things off, but he got other stadium owners sort of involved in this fight. And if you look at where Macklemore was prevented from appearing, some of those same places are places where you could find a Kanye West concert. And Kanye West has said much more explicitly anti-Semitic things than Macklemore. I just don't understand. The only people whose motivations I understand in this very clearly, frankly, are Macklemore, who's been pretty explicit about like, I...

I believe in Palestinian liberation. OK, I won't be performing at these places. And so therefore, I will be donating $1 million to Palestinian causes. And by the way, I want all of you to keep paying attention to Palestinians and not myself. Like, I understand that motivation. I understand the motivation of people who have since left Ed Sheeran's tour, people like Phineas, who are supporting Ed Sheeran. And we're like, hey, yeah, sorry, we just can't be a part of this anymore. Ed Sheeran, Robert Kraft, these other people, it's harder for me to understand their motivations.

at all other than like they want to keep making money like that makes sense to me but yes i think that is that is the thing that they are that appears they are most loyal to god that feels so hard for us to say out loud but yes in this case consider you know seeing the fact that his his tickets now with dynamic pricing have dropped you know he's trying to sell tickets for 65 i'd sure it is right the remaining ones for his tour yeah even from that standpoint of like well i'm just focused on the money well now you you've screwed that up too so we'll be right back after a quick break For most of the history of professional sports, there was a wall between the game and gambling. Then suddenly it was everywhere. Ontario is all in on sports betting. Make every moment more with FanDuel. But that wasn't supposed to include the players themselves. Raptors for Jonte Porter is under NBA investigation. Athletes are the perfect gamblers. Understood the big bet. Find us on CBC Listen or wherever you get your podcasts. I finished a 5K in 94th place, right after a man wearing jeans. Then a volunteer gave me a medal. But I don't want participation trophies, unless they're from Bet365.

So I'm trying to understand what just happened better because I don't know if it's some kind of turning point at all in terms of how the American public thinks about Gaza or Israel. But I do think it was an intentional event that... that moved in a way that I didn't expect. And I was trying to think of analogies in like artistic history, right? Like, what do I compare this to? The thing I immediately grasped for was that 80s song, I Ain't Gonna Play Sun City about South Africa, where a bunch of artists sort of came together. And it was about money, right? Like, I'm literally not going to play this venue, which I think is a really important part of this, like that sort of money piece of it. Is that an analogy you'd reach for here? Like, would you reach for a different analogy? The other person who I think of with some sadness is Nina Simone.

Purely, and I want to be clear, politically, musically, not so much in terms of similarities. But particularly toward the end of her life, or the latter half of her life, after the assassination of Martin Luther King and after the assassination of Malcolm X. You know, Nina had recorded so many protest songs, whether it be Mississippi Goddamn, but also, you know, the beauty that is to be young, gifted, and Black. You know, all of these things. But she lamented, like she understood that her appeal commercially had declined.

Because she was so vocal and committed to the civil rights movement, you know, even after, say, the passage of the Civil Rights Act or the Fair Housing Act and, you know, Lyndon Johnson could say, see, we did something, you know, and she's still going and kind of witnessing herself fade from the zeitgeist in a way, you know, because I don't know if it's because of necessarily even disagreement in the public with her sentiments or just fatigue. you know, like this is because these problems are so, so big and they can feel so overwhelming. And it's like, well, what else can I do? You know? It's funny because Malcolm Moore in this analogy, he's kind of like a Trojan horse. Like, I don't think of him as like the political guy. I think of him as like the thrift shop guy. And then all of a sudden he like comes out. He's like, also, I'm the guy's guy. You do not expect that. Really? This guy? Yeah, in some ways, like, I feel like you're pointing out like why it worked, quote unquote, like why it broke through. Like, you're just sort of like, why? It's like, why do peanut butter and jelly work? Why do all these things work? You're not expecting it.

You're not expecting it. And he is very much, he is a mascot for just normie. He is extremely normie. And I think has been able to kind of retain that in a way that even Ed Sheeran and Taylor Swift, who are also considered very like kind of mainstream, I don't want to say Starbucks musicians. That's not quite right. But there's a broad appeal. He's so normie, he's not even that popular. Right. But they have, he's kind of mid all around. Just extremely mid, just aggressively mid.

He's just the emperor of myth. I think that allows him, he's also in a different financial universe from either of those two people, right? From Ed Sheeran or Taylor Swift. So even as they are sort of like aesthetically occupying this middle ground, they're extremely wealthy people compared to the rest of us. Whereas Macklemore hasn't quite ascended to that level of financial success as the other two. The other thing I think is important about how this all played out with Macklemore is that unlike other...

political protests from people in Hollywood in the past, there was a place for regular people to enter. And I say that because after he made this speech, there was this push by, you know, stop anti-Semitism people who were like, we want refunds and here's what we want and like petition type stuff. And what they found was that when they riled regular people up like this, the response wasn't what they expected. They expected like we riled the people up and they're like, yes, we demand a refund. And it was like, huh, nope. Yeah. Which seems to be like a recurring theme.

right now, like this year, this half, this quarter. I don't know. Yeah. I mean, well, one of the things that I think that people are finally sort of. catching up to what we're seeing the ways that like there's a class silo i think that exists in terms of the information that people get um and and their attitudes about it uh and how that is how that is shaping their opinions or lack thereof and responses um versus where a kind of large plurality of people are and when i say large plurality i am also including american jews um who are extremely you know myself included like furious at Benjamin Netanyahu. If you look at the most recent polling data, who do not support this military action that is taking place there, who do not support the impunity with which settlers are acting in the West Bank, and who see through the ways that I think...

the White House and American foreign policy more broadly has kind of been able to enact this sort of like decades-long filibuster on a real Palestinian state. And like those chickens are coming home to roost. Like there's nowhere to hide. You're saying people are underestimating the public anger about this. Oh, yeah. In part because, you know, we have gone through what? We're now in our like third year of seeing these horrific images appearing in our social feeds that are very, very real.

Yeah, and this Macklemore thing came after what I saw as like a summer of artists speaking out continually about what's going on in Gaza. You had people like Mark Ruffalo, who got a lot of pushback because he was criticizing the Ellison family, linking them to Israel. The Ellisons are, of course, behind the Paramount Skydance merger. You saw actress Hannah Einbinder from Hacks speaking out and basically just saying like, this is worth more than my career. Like me saying this is like more important. And so it's like there's been like, I feel like the path was made. And then all of a sudden there was Macklemore who we were like, wasn't expecting that. And so like it was all of this happened.

Yeah. Is this the thing that breaks containment finally? Maybe? I don't know. Exactly. Maybe. You've also spoken, though, and I think this is so important, about...

You know, I sort of analogized the apartheid state South Africa thing, but you've talked about how criticizing Israel and what's happening in Gaza is different when you're talking about Hollywood people, people who are artists in the artistic industries. And I want you to talk about that a little bit more because I just think it's important and something that may be forgotten by some people. It's very tricky to talk about this. I think it makes people very uncomfortable because we are asking them to hold sort of complicated and competing realities in their head at the same time in terms of the ability of a person or a people, right, to be. as Beyonce has said before, victims and villains at the same time. That our historical experiences, the literal epigenetic trauma that we carry in our bodies, both from Jews. And you're saying Jews in this. With a memory of the Holocaust or the Shoah, but also thousands of years of being...

scapegoated and then driven, you know, from societies in the way that that has shaped Jewish life, right? The way it shapes the stereotypes and bigotry, right, toward Jews. The idea of Jews as puppet masters, you know, or these people who are sort of working behind the scenes and subverting people's lives, right? That is a harmful and insidious bigotry, right, that has followed us. At the same time, Jewish people hold real power in the entertainment industry. And that is also true. And much like you have this stereotype of Jews as bankers that arises, you know, from a history of Jews being excluded from other professions, you know, and sort of ghettoized into this industry and then making it work. Just, you know, particularly salient for me as a Dutch Jew, because a lot of that history takes place right in Amsterdam.

And there's a similar sort of history and circumstances that shapes like why early Hollywood and those studios, Warner Brothers, are started and helmed by, you know, like human, imperfect, sometimes really frustrating, imperious Jews. They are not imperious because they are Jews. They're imperious because they are humans, right? Yeah. And it just sounds like what you're saying is all of this history makes it hard.

for people in Hollywood to tell a more nuanced story about themselves and the world, because that involves... Reassessing. Yes. Right. Including the stories that we tell ourselves about ourselves and that like we are constantly like renegotiating and arguing and getting in our feels about that. But it's so funny to me because that questioning is so baked into Judaism. You know, if you if you like if you look at like Passover, for instance, there's this whole part where you talk about like you could be the simple child, you could be the wicked child. And it's like you can be all of these things. And so the idea that you can have multiple identities is actually not foreign to any of these people. It's just a matter of like breaking your.

Judaism is, I think, extremely beautifully pluralistic in all of the ways that you can be a Jew. It's constantly being discussed and argued about and renegotiated to the point where you can have favorite heretics. Mine happens to be Spinoza. But do you feel like that's appropriately reflected in the Hollywood discourse around Israel? No, not at all. And I think there are folks who are trying to push it in that direction. I think Hannah is a good example of that. Hannah Anbender. Yes, Hannah Anbender. Also, Yuval Abraham, one of the co-directors of No Other Land, who has faced, along with his colleagues, direct threats from the Israeli government.

because of the films that they have made. You know, you could say that also about Jonathan Glaser, you know, the filmmaker who made The Zone of Interest and who very, you know, who did not shy away from the fact that there is a way that you can sort of look at that film and see parallels between the sort of peaceful, bucolic, just beautiful life that seems to be taking place, just steps away from a murder factory. Yeah, The Zone of Interest was about a family that lives right by... Auschwitz. Yeah, by a death camp. Like, he's not discouraging people.

from making those analogies with Israel and Chazit. In fact, like he sees them himself, right? Like he is, I would say he is, if not encouraging them, then certainly like he's not steering people away from that and has also been very vocal about the suffering of the Palestinian people. And there are, you know, like so many Jews, I think myself included, who feel very deeply that it is our duty to speak up, you know, as we go about this. I think this very beautiful project of in season of Teshuvah, you know, of thinking about how we want to and can, you know, make 5787, you know, a more peaceful, a more just, a more sweet year. Does this whole Mechelmore thing give you, I don't know, more hope? Yes. And I will say, you know, I think.

Part of what we see in this sort of, like, divide between, like, ardent Zionists and other American Jews, like, I think if you kind of, if you sort of spread open the data, what you will see, like, there are generational distinctions, certainly. But I think this is also about class. And this is taking place at a time where, like, we are experiencing greater income inequality and wealth inequality in the United States than we were during the first Gilded Age. It is wide. And so when you have, I think, a generation of decision makers who have kind of held positions of power for a long time, right, and who've essentially built themselves up as the establishment and who hold a lot of institutional and financial power, the people who are challenging them are their children.

their grandchildren, right? The ones who are, you know, Bobby... The Hannah Einbinders. Yeah, the Hannah Einbinders. The folks who are also, like, more politically aligned with socialism. And, I mean, I think that's wonderful. Like, we see that over and over again, whether it be with Naomi Klein speaking up, whether it is Molly Crabapple's new book, right, that is encouraging us to look back at the history of the Jewish Bund and Joycat and...

heroism and an embrace of diasporic Judaism, as opposed to this idea that like, we all have to, you know, like the only place we could possibly be safe on earth is Israel, which I just don't think is true. I really like living in bedside. Soraya, I'm really grateful for your time. Thanks for coming on the show. Thank you so much for having me. Soraya McDonald is a cultural critic, and you can go see what she's up to at soraya.press. She is about to launch something brand new, and you should really be checking it out.

All right, that's our show. What Next is produced by Evan Campbell, Madeline Thames-Ducharme, and Patrick Fort. Paige Osborne is the senior supervising producer of What Next and What Next TBD. Mia Lobel is the executive producer of podcasts here at Slate. Ben Richmond is the senior director of podcast operations. And I'm Mary Harris. Go check me down on Blue Sky. Say hello. I'm Matt Mary Harris. All right, thanks for listening. Catch you back here next time.

Hey, it's Kat Nat from Kat Nat Unfiltered. You know what matters most to us when cooking for our family's freshness. That's why we always choose Metro. Their produce is hand-picked, their bread is baked in store, and their butchers custom-cut meat to our exact needs. Freshness is a thing that can make a simple meal simply amazing or turn an ordinary bite into an extraordinary night. At Metro, fresh matters because fresh changes everything. Find fresh meals and deals at your local Metro.

Support comes from Wise, the smart checking account for home and abroad. Got a Canadian salary, property in the U.S., sending money abroad? You're juggling multiple accounts, currencies, and a headache. Manage it all the smart way with Wise. Save up to 65% on exchange fees and give your everyday money a boost with interest. Plus, switch your direct deposit to Wise for the monthly chance to double your paycheck. Be smart. Get Wise. Canada residents only, excluding Quebec. Up to 60 winners. Odds depend on entries. Offer ends September 14, 2027. Learn more at wise.com.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Slate Daily Feed?

This episode is 30 minutes long.

When was this Slate Daily Feed episode published?

This episode was published on September 21, 2026.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Slate Daily Feed episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.