What warrants a five-star restaurant review?

Barons on 1st impressed our critic James D. Watts Jr. so much, it earned five stars in all categories: food, service and atmosphere. Watts and Jimmie Tramel discuss why the honor is so rare. Barons on 1st earns rare five-star review for its exceptional fine dining experience | Review Five-star sweeps: Restaurants that scored top ratings in all categories On Route 66, have some Toast for dinner | Restaurant Review   Contact us Scene Writer Jimmie Tramel: Email | Twitter | Follow his stories Scene Writer James D. Watts Jr.: Email | Twitter | Follow his stories Scene Editor Nicole Marshall Middleton:  Email | Twitter Follow Tulsa World Scene: Facebook | Twitter Contact Tulsa World Editor Jason Collington: Email Subscribe to this podcast on: Apple | Google | Spotify