I'm Brian Myers. I'm Mike Ritalik. I'm Becky Hideoed. And this is Alpelance, a podcast featuring tips for ag teachers.
We are your agricultural education resource across the web, sharing research-based tips and tackling the tough questions facing agriculture teachers every day. Hey Alpelance, this is Brian here with Mike and Becky. We are by the Alpelance once again and we are continuing our conversation around the idea of mentoring and mentorship. I hope you have enjoyed all of the discussion thus far.
We're also seeing that so many of our conversations with our colleagues around the country. When we talk about the research going on really kind of comes back to this idea of mentoring and building those relationships. So Becky is leading us through this conversation even though she says she's not We are having the conversation. People are going to get really sick of hearing that.
We are having the conversation. So he didn't say that. I know. That's what I have to keep saying.
He said you were leading our conversation. I'm aware. He said every time. I'll work conversation.
So should we go back to in the court reporter, please. We have to keep striking it. We don't have to keep striking it. We'll start today too.
I think one of the things that I hope is that is people are listening to these conversations that it's really causing some thought. And I'm hoping that outside of just listening to these you're spending some time thinking about mentorship and all the ways that we receive or give mentorship and what that looks like. And I think that's probably a good place that we're going to be starting today. Yeah.
I mean, talking about it and continuing the conversation because even the difference among the three of us reading the report and then getting to come back and talk about it. Hopefully there are things that people are able to take from this and continue that conversation as well. So I think today one of the things that we've talked about a bit off air has really been how do we how do we differentiate what mentoring is compared to some of these other relationships that we have with their students whether they're with our own mentors or other roles that we have in our jobs. When we think about all these things that we're maybe doing at once and what are the pieces that are actually mentoring and how does that differentiate from coaching or advising or role modeling and sponsorship.
And these are all terms that we've talked about a little bit as we've gone through this series. But we want to take some time today to really kind of dig into what are those characteristics of that mentoring relationship and how does that really set itself apart from some of these other roles that we fill? And probably just to state the obvious we're not suggesting that every relationship should be a mentoring relationship because this is one more type of tool in relationship that we have and you're not going to mentor everybody nor should everybody be mentoring you. But when you're going to do this, this report is a great guide on how to have that and build that relationship.
Well, because we've talked about the huge investment that mentoring is, it's not something that anyone really has the capacity to do for a large number of people. And I think some of this is also recognizing by not calling it mentoring, we're not diminishing those coaching relationships or those advising relationships. I think some of it is recognizing what's the place of those and what role are we actually filling? And even in some of our state programs, when we're thinking about coaching early career teachers, it doesn't have to be a mentoring relationship.
Are we thinking more about the instruction of the coaching? Is it more about career advice than that and that ladder? And so when I think when we think about those characteristics of that mentoring relationship, just to kind of resituate, we're emphasizing helping the individual grow and accomplish goals with a lot of different approaches providing that professional and career development and having a really reciprocal relationship, which looks different from some of our roles with coaching and advising and even sponsorship. And so as we think about that idea, what are some of the things that come to mind that really start to differentiate those concepts that we've been talking about when it comes to mentoring?
I think one of the things I keep coming back to is how reciprocal mentoring is. I think that really struck me in this report and wasn't something that I'd given a lot of thought to in mentoring relationships before. And I think some of it just by the function of where I'm at in my career, I'm more off in the mentee. And when I think about the mentors that I've had, it really made me pause as I was reading through to think about who are really those like where have I really had that reciprocal relationship where it's it's more than advising or kind of telling me where to go.
It's who are those people who really know enough about me to go through that process. The list got a lot smaller that didn't diminish those other relationships in terms of coaching and advising and sponsorship. But I think especially with sponsorship, when we talked about that a couple episodes ago, sponsorship is is a lot less relational. Like it's more about the relationships that you have outside of that mentoring.
Who else can I connect you with? Who else can I promote you to that I think that's mentoring apart a little bit. And then one of the questions I've been thinking about, we talk about the reciprocal nature of true mentoring is, because again, I'm like you Becky, when I think about mentorship so much, I do think of a little bit of a power dynamic between the person that is the mentor, the one that is the mentee or the protege, there's some there's some power there that sends me one way. And this report's really got me thinking about this two-way relationship that maybe in those cases when I was being mentored by somebody else, maybe I didn't even realize how much the other person was gaining from that relationship, what they were thinking about.
Because I can think about for myself when I've probably been now, as we said, this stage of my career, which might be a slightly different stage than what Becky is in as she points out some time to time. I walk away from a relationship with some with from a mentoring relationship with that that more junior person of all the things that I've learned from that conversation and that relationship that maybe the other person didn't realize. Because we kind of only know what we get from the relationship and never have taken a chance to stop and learn to really understand and think about that two-way relationship. I don't know if I'm communicating that well, but maybe I don't know what the other person is getting out of that relationship.
Well, I think that brings up a huge piece with the expectation that I hadn't thought about, so you were talking about it. But some of the really great mentors I've had are people that I come back to the next time we meet and say, I really was thinking about this thing that you said, or like, this really made me think about something differently. And that I think is something we tend to forget about in the mentoring relationship, especially when we're talking about a more senior and more junior person that I think it can be easy for a mentee to really diminish what they bring to the relationship. So the balance, I think, is also is, I mean, it's not a one or the other and somebody's got more responsibility in this.
But as we mentor, how are we really making it clear what each person is bringing it? Are we doing that on both sides? Is the mentee making an effort to come in and say, hey, I really appreciate this thing you said or I acted on this this way because I think it can be easy as a mentor. You give the advice and you don't always see it, but you don't always see it happen.
And it might have not some of it is they may have taken your advice, but it's not the way they would have done it and kind of the same thing on the other side with the mentee. Yeah, and I think that's that's one of those things we started to unpack in the last session and we spent a lot of time on career guidance and and skill development. But there's that psychosocial pieces that really play an important part in that. And so whether we're thinking about those social interactions that we have with one another role modeling and just that friendship after you we've talked about building that trust up, I think are all important elements.
And what I hear you saying Becky is the value of that psychosocial experience and Brian's comment that I think it's a it's a win-win situation because it's not a give or take or we're trying to deplete one the mentor. It's really recharging and building up for the mentor as much as it is the mentee in a lot of cases. And I think again that just really builds the case again that these true mentoring relationships are probably going to be fairly few because there's going to be a time that there are other people that I go to just for coaching. And I know we're having this conversation probably in the past I would have used the word mentor but that probably is not accurate as the way we're having this conversation now because I go to that person just for advice and say here's the situation in give me some coaching on what I need to be doing to address this.
And it truly is a one-way relationship rather than this true mentorship long-term and and that's okay. There's you need those types of relationships because you need to be getting information and ideas for people from that coaching and that advising and having a few core mentors. And to that point I think the article does a nice job about lining what those stages of mentorship are and so that goes right along with what Brian is saying and there's really four stages initiation, cultivation, separation and redefinition. And so it's more dynamic than just a one-way solving a problem, generating some ideas of how to work yourself out of a situation that you might be and and it's more long-term and and multi-dimensional.
I think those stages really speak just how long-term it is. And we brought it up a couple times since we've talked about this mentoring, this ongoing relationship I think so often we've really conflated mentoring and coaching and advice. We've conflated mentoring with shorter-term things and so we attach it to things that are meant for a year-long program or a six-month student teaching experience or whatever amount of time we have with somebody and I think when we think about mentoring it's not really something we've attached to a fixed amount of time because we think about those stages that Mike just brought up with. Initiation itself could take years.
I've not done some of this before this. I wouldn't have called myself your mentor. Well, because maybe I didn't set out to be one. To be a mentor or be a mentee.
So even the amount of time you initiate that relationship can take much longer than some of these things that we try to push as mentoring. Well, and then you go back with the idea we think about initiation and starting when we start something we want to be able to say on July 23rd, 2023 is when I initiated my relationship with you about you being my mentor. That's probably not going to be going to be one year. You didn't have an anniversary.
Because again, when you use that word organic things are going to evolve. When I go back, some of the folks that I look back and I gain so much from and a mentor relationship, I couldn't tell you the exact date we met or the exact date that this happened but it kind of evolved over time. I found myself more and more having these conversations and learning more from these folks and doing this. I couldn't give you a date on when this thing first started.
So I think that's something to think about that initiation part. It's not a fixed thing. It's kind of that idea. When we talk about it being organic, I hadn't really operationalized it this way before you said that.
But the mentors, it's like they've always been there. Yeah. And they're always there when you need it. And they're always there when you need it.
They're always there when you need it. They always have it there. They always will be there. Which then we look at some of the things.
We don't realize how much time we spend in that initiation stage when we're mentoring or being a true mentor-mentee relationship. And I think some of that initiation also, it's not necessarily clear this was our initiation stage. This is our cultivation stage. And so much of those intertwine and go back and forth.
And even when they talk about the next stage of separation, it's not necessarily a separation and done. And so the iterative nature of these stages I think is a really interesting dynamic in the mentoring piece. Where you don't see that as much with coaching and advising. It reminds me of that copiloting analogy that we had in an earlier podcast.
Where we're continuing to help that person develop and we're letting them continue to bloom as they move through that their stages in their career. And then certainly probably one thing that we don't spend much time thinking about is really that fourth stage when we talk about redefinition or redefining. So as people do grow, and you become copilates or peer to peer, it doesn't mean that that mentorship doesn't end. It just takes on a different form and a different shape.
And so really seriously thinking about how does that relationship continue to evolve in bloom as people move into different stages of career and have different needs in both personal career life as well as professional and those all change and evolve. And it's another chapter. And so what's that next chapter like? Well, I think you bring up a great point there because I'm guilty of this.
Sometimes you think of the person that I consider a mentor just as I'm changing that person's changing too. And often don't time don't acknowledge that or understand that person's evolving and moving through different life and career stages. And you understand that, oh, things are different now. And it may be one of the maybe the more obvious ones as you talk about a career or a professional mentor, folks that go into and they retire, they may have a different set of ideas and they may want and be a better resource to mentor you on the on the personal side of things rather than the day to day of your of your professional life.
But there's still that relationship is still be good that has to evolve and redefine those things. And I think about some of the other there's different goals I have for that relationship now and things I can bring to the relationship and I learned I gained from them because of we're in different life stages than we were 20 years ago. And on the mentee side of that, I think also the importance of the mentor saying being able to redefine that relationship. I think about the mentors I had in my undergrad and what I took from a mentoring relationship as a student teacher compared to an early career teacher compared to somebody entering grads.
But like that mentor has been there and seen that whole process. But if at this point in my career, they still saw me as a student teacher, we probably wouldn't have much of a mentoring relationship anymore because I'm not crying in my car in the parking lot. You're not my mentor is left right. I think we can pretty clearly take that from what we talked about the last couple.
That's why I always have Kleenexes behind me in my office. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, on that. If you are a mentor who is not as comfortable with tears, I was reading something the other day to not keep the Kleenexes in your office.
You can give the person a minute to like if they don't actually want to cry in front of you and they need like I'll be right back, go build your water bottle or like get the Kleenexes and come back and set it down. Don't keep them as accessible if you're not that comfortable. Or just say I'm gonna grab you a Kleenex and then just don't come back. There's all that.
Take all the time you need. Take all the time you need. And by the way, Brian's got room in his schedule for more mentees because of the way he approaches again. I think we don't even know what to say about that.
But I was going to go back and tell us the four stages again if you would, Mike, just to remind us. I think there was one of those in there that I think we've been talking about there. I think we skipped one of them. Yeah, so the four stages initiation, cultivation, and then separation, and then the final one is redefinition.
So I think that second one of cultivation is I think it's important to be thinking about as well. So it's we don't just initiate it and then it's perfect. You know, I think to me that's kind of that that maintenance stage that you're going through again, I'm thinking of the garden I have at my house. You know, that initiation is preparing it, putting the seeds in the ground, but it does take time to maintain and to be thinking I have to be intentional about maintaining that relationship and investing in that.
And I think that's important for us to be thinking about as well because we talk a lot about assuming and it gets us in trouble. And I'm glad you came back to that, Brian, because I think we really jumped in and started talking about these four characteristics without defining them or even having a conversation and just an assumption that it's going to mean something to everybody. And so really what they were talking about with the cultivation was when the relationship matures and mentors typically provide the greatest degree of psychosocial and career support. So that's kind of the sweet spot.
You know, when things are kind of kind of cooking along there. And again, we've said it several times, and I'll say it again, it takes work to be here. And this is kind of where you're maybe getting some of the fruits of that labor, but it still takes work, you know, again, with my garden, it's probably the least amount of work, but it still takes me to go out there. I have to weed, I have to maintain, I have to make sure things are going just right in that garden, because if I don't, then I'll think of all this part.
Yeah, put it on autopilot now. But then also to move to the next one, we talked about a little bit, but I do think it's worth a couple minutes to do that separation. I mean, a mentoring relationship can end. You know, that redefinition time before, I mean, that being that our relationship is no longer going to be a mentoring relationship, it's going to be a coaching or a collegial, which is fine.
And the text says when mentees seek autonomy and more independence from mentors. Yeah. I think another way they phrase it in terms of these four stages, they talk about effective mentoring is aligning expectations, so that initiation stage, that building rapport. And so that's a lot in that cultivation, that who's checking in when, that what's actually the maintenance that Brian talked about, that maintaining open communication.
And I think that's a piece with that separation that I didn't really align there. But some of that is saying, maybe I don't have the capacity to be the mentor that I need, or we've gone in different directions that I'm not in as good a position to support you as I was before. I think it's better if I take an advising role, I think it's better if I take a coaching role. And the same thing from the mentee, some of it's just recognizing where are we at in this relationship in these stages that we can, we've cultivated this enough that we can be open about what we need from this mentoring.
Because I think when we think about, again, that redefinition piece and facilitating that autonomy in that agency, there's there's got to be enough room that we've been able to say, this is where this is, or this is when you from this is where I see this. So it's not, because as that elephant comes into that relationship, it gets a lot harder to be to have the reciprocal nature of that partnership that you need for it to really be effective. And where my mind goes back, he's kind of the example that you were given earlier that, you know, you've had mentors since your undergrad, but the mentors that I had as a cooperating teacher, first year, second year teacher, were great for that role in that stage in my career. But you move on to grad school, you move on to become a university faculty member, and no longer can they provide the type of support and the type of mentoring that you needed in year one, two, three of your teaching experience.
And so yeah, there is, there could be a season for the types of mentorship that you have with a specific individual. And also understanding here that separation can be initiated by either party. You know, I think you talked about that early on, it would be great if you are the mentor, the more senior in the relationship and you're saying, Hey, I've, we've moved to a point where I'm not that person, maybe going back to sponsorship and say, you know, you know, we're this place now, Mike, maybe I'm not the one to be your mentor, but let me introduce you to Becky. And Becky can now pick up the role of being your mentor and you're going to see that.
And that's one possible way there. The other way, if you're maybe the more junior in the role, and this person was there, and maybe that relationship has changed and you're like, it's okay for you to move on and move into a different part of that relationship. But it can be hard because we're dealing with people, but it is okay to kind of understand that that relationship needs to change. Yeah.
And I think to be clear, we're talking about this formal mentorship role. So you're not moving away and no longer having a friendship, no longer having a relationship with this individual is just a different stage. And they're still part of your network and part of who you are. But that role and the position that they play in this mentorship is going to look different or move on to someone else.
I mean, you probably could feel like we're really splitting hairs when we talk about the difference between mentoring, advising, coaching, role modeling, sponsorship. But I hope to some degree it gives those who are listening a little bit of room to say, okay, if mentorship is this, and this is how we're going to operationalize mentorship, it gives us some room for some of those stages of mentorship, especially in that separation that can be kind of uncomfortable to have a name and have some vocabulary for the other ways that people are in our lives and supporting us. Yeah. Well, I think it's been a great conversation.
I really enjoy the thinking and talking about mentoring, coaching, advising, the difference around those things and the idea of the different stages of coaching. You know, it's my test. It's initiating, cultivating, separating, redefining. You almost got to hit the yellow button again.
Here's the yellow button. Here you go. This is what we do every day, folks. So again, hopefully you have enjoyed this conversation as well.
I really think our profession is in a place where we can spend some more time around this idea of mentoring, both for all of us and helping everybody understand that you need to be in these mentoring relationships, both as the mentor, but also as the one gaining from somebody else's experience as well. And yes, it's reciprocal, but different relationships bring different things to the table. And I think this is important for our professional development to be doing these things. Hopefully you all have enjoyed this conversation and this entire series as well.
It's been great. Hopefully you are going to interact and share your thoughts on this topic and others on social media and share the podcast with other folks. And so for Becky and Mike, this is Brian here by the Appellate saying, thank you and hope you all have a phenomenal rest of your day.