Skip to content
What's Up Doc: Daisy's Destruction episode artwork

Sep 23, 2019 29 min

What's Up Doc: Daisy's Destruction

from What's Up Doc: The True Crime Documentary Podcast Hosted by Gemma Delaney

Investigation into Peter Scully

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

What's Up Doc: Daisy's Destruction

0:00 29:24
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Please be aware, this episode of What's Up Doc discusses a case involving extreme child abuse and murder. Listener discretion is advised. In 2012, the internet ran rife with rumours of a horrific snuff film. Its content, so gruesome and horrific, for many it was believed to be an urban legend. Unfortunately, the film in question, Daisy's Destruction, was real. This is What's Up Doc, Daisy's Destruction.

Hello, guys. Welcome back to What's Up Doc. And as you heard at the head of the show, we are discussing Daisy's destruction. As always, I am your host, Gemma Delaney. And as always, we are on Instagram and on Facebook. That's at What's Up Doc Podcast. So look, you know the drill at this stage, guys. I put things to vote. You tell me what to do. And I do as I'm told. So this time around, the poll on Instagram, two polls, actually. First poll was, should I stick with reviewing true crime documentaries or should I branch out into cases of true crime, kind of irrespective of whether...

there's a documentary made about them or not. And ye voted yes, overwhelmingly. And then I put a poll to ye to vote for which true crime story to go for. So you had a toss up between the true story of the Friday the 13th killer, or you had the option of the story behind the most horrific snuff film ever made, as we heard in the intro there, Daisy's Destruction. I think the Friday the 13th killer got like four votes. So it was overwhelmingly in favour of Daisy's destruction, which I was surprised by and a little bit scared by as well because I have not covered anything so graphic before. So guys, I'm just going to ask for you to, you know, stick on in there with me, hang on in there with me. I'm going to try and do this story justice and handle it as sensitively and as, you know, professionally as I can. But I am a student. I'm learning. So like I said, bear with me. I'm going to try and talk you through this case in...

as objective a way as possible, which is what I always try and do in my podcasts. And I have tried to get as much information on this case as I can possibly. But what I really found in this is that there's just an overwhelming amount of conflicting evidence. So anything I quote in this podcast, I have sourced from between three to five websites. So when I'm finding three to five websites in the same thing, I'm hoping they're accurate. So guys, look, if it's wrong, by all means, get back to me on it. But I've done my best on this one. So look, backstory, take it back. What happened? Who is this guy? Where did it all come from? Peter Scully.

A little bit of backstory. I'm very hard to find anything about his early life online. What I do know is that he was born on the 13th of January in 1963. That makes him 56 now in Melbourne in Australia. I was able to find out that he was married with two kids and ran a very successful business where he actually managed to scam 2.6 million out of investors in an IT fraud. So a very smart man by all accounts, living, you know, a supposedly normal life in a quiet Melbourne suburb.

when his scam was unveiled in 2011 he fled to Mindanao in the Philippines to prevent himself incurring any charges as a result of that scam now what I have been able to find out is that previous to him moving to the Philippines like it wasn't like he moved to the Philippines and became a pedophile he did seem to have his finger in a lot of pies and one of those pies was child prostitution from Melbourne so he ran an escort agency online using his Filipino girlfriend again accounts vary of what age she was she seemed to have been somewhere in her late teens and her name was Ling So she was escorted out from this website. So he was involved in the sex industry before he ever fled to the Philippines. I guess by moving to Mindanao, it only enabled him to scam and fraud further and have, you know, easy access to, you know, children, street children, a plethora of kids who are hungry and, you know.

that whole thing of, you know, the wealthy white man comes in and by all accounts, I can see that, you know, there are various accounts of him offering food, of him offering education, of him offering, you know, a place to live and a nice life to these impoverished families and in this way was able to gain access to the children that unfortunately would become his currency. So how did he become discovered? Well, you heard me talking about this infamous snuff film at the head of the show, Daisy's Destruction. Again, I'm not going to go into too much detail of the snuff film itself. You guys have Google. You can, you know, search that stuff out if you want that level of detail. I'm going to keep it very generic for the purposes of the podcast, because like I said, I do want to be sensitive and I do want to be professional about this case. These kids are still alive. Their families are still alive. They're still young. They're human beings. And at the end of the day, there's always a human story behind the headline. So that's where I'm going to go on this podcast. But Daisy's Destruction was a film that came to light.

sometime in 2012. I haven't been able to find a date. Really where it gained traction was on the likes of Reddit. OK, so these conversations, these, you know, chat rooms and people going, have you heard of this? And like I said, like a lot of stuff that starts out on Reddit, it was just assumed to be an urban legend because it was just too horrific. It couldn't be true or could it?

But it got enough traction and was talked about enough online that it actually got the attention of the international police. And they got word of this and decided there was enough merit in it to launch an investigation. And unfortunately, when the investigation was launched and when they went looking for this video, they were able to find it. It's on the dark web and it was a pay-per-view video or series of videos, actually. Reportedly, 10,000 to pop, 10,000 to view. So, you know.

for pedophiles and pedophilia money just isn't a question um it's not a barrier when you are that way inclined when you have that urge so in terms of the snuff film itself it's not one continuous film it was a series and again accounts vary from you know website to website and i'm sure as hell not going to go looking for the video itself to verify these things but accounts vary from website to website it is thought to be somewhere between three to five series actually episodes um varying in length from kind of five to nine minutes each The name Daisy's destruction derives from one of the victims in the video. And, you know, I guess really probably the video's cash cow for the simple fact that she was 18 months old at the time. So this would be big money in paedophile land. So Daisy, 18 months old. The other two victims in the video were identified as being Liza, who was 12 at the time, and another little girl, Cindy, 11 at the time.

Like I said, I'm not going to go into the details of the video too much, but Peter Scully himself partakes in the videos, as does one of his teenage Filipino girlfriends, Lizelle Margalo. She was 19 at the time. She plays the part of a mistress in the video. And by all accounts on all the research I did, she seemed to be the main, if not the sole abuser of Daisy herself. And that is.

the story in this film or this, you know, series of films that Daisy is being taught to obey her mistress. It didn't really clarify what Liza and Cindy's parts were in these films, other than that they were fellow victims. So they were also abused. I guess what kind of blew this film up online, as I said, is that it is a snuff film. Snuff, for those of you who aren't aware, is this just...

majorly fucked up industry where people are found for the sole purpose of being tortured, raped and eventually murdered. And again, there's something that nearly exists in urban legend. Are they real? Are they not? Are these people really been killed? Are they actors? And I think the truth lies somewhere in the middle. You know, it depends with some films. Some are genuine murders and some are acted out or simulated murders.

But the rumour regarding Daisy's destruction was that this 18 month old baby, whose name unfortunately became part of the film, was murdered at the end. That's how this film ended. Now, through my research, I have been able to find that is not the case. Daisy was not murdered. She is alive. She is well, if you can call it that. She has...

survived but been left with lifelong physical injuries as a result of the harm that she came to in the video Daisy's destruction Liza who was the 12 year old again found to be alive and well in school a bright young girl by all accounts Unfortunately, and rather sadly, the same cannot be said for the third victim in the video, Cindy, who was the 11 year old. She could not be tracked down by the police. And eventually, Peter Scully's second Filipino teenage girlfriend, Carmen Ann Alvarez, actually.

confessed that Peter had told her she stated that she hadn't witnessed it herself but that Peter had told her that Cindy was murdered at the end of the film so the last episode in Daisy's destruction actually depicts Cindy being murdered she was strangled to death after being forced to dig her own grave in which she was then buried so just horrific horrific stuff So because of that information, the other girlfriend then who, you know, wasn't being particularly helpful up until that point, Lysel decided to come forward and, you know, proclaim her how sorry she was and led them to the house in which Cindy was buried under the floor and her body was found, was retrieved. And I guess finally got the respect and care that she never got in life, you know, and was buried properly.

So, like I said, with these urban legends, sometimes the truth lies somewhere in the middle, you know. So it wasn't, in fact, the 18-month-old that was killed. It was the 11-year-old Cindy. And like I said, her body was retrieved and it was buried. What I've also found in the course of my investigation is that there's actually another child still missing. So the police, you know, just this investigation was second to none. They literally went door to door.

in the Philippines with stills from this video, trying to find the locations. And by doing that, we're able to locate 15 of the locations seen in the films. These films, by the way, were all distributed through Peter Scully's own film producing company that he set up. So this is how he kind of, you know, he had another lucrative business. He wasn't the first. He obviously had scammed people and all of that kind of thing. But this film production, no limits fun.

or NLF Productions. Daisy's Destruction by no means was the only film that he produced, but was by far the most famous. But I guess what I'm saying by the fact that there's still a girl missing, again, I couldn't clarify this in my search, but I mean, that alludes to the fact that this is not the only film they found with a murder in it. That, you know, he produced multiple snow films. Again, tried to clarify exactly what he had been charged for as well. There were 75 charges against Peter Scully and he was only done for trafficking.

and abuse rape there wasn't actually a murder charge against him I'm not sure why but like I said the police were meticulous they combed through these stills and through that were able to find 15 locations and were able to garner that there was definitely still one girl missing that they were able to locate the other victims in the other films I again could not find any details of that girl I couldn't find an age I couldn't find a name just that there is still one girl missing Peter Scully then was found as a result of Daisy's destruction. So his own face was pixelated out in the film as he, you know, partook in these horrific acts against these babies. And his accomplice, Lysel Margallo, wore a mask. But even with the mask, you know, the police said that it was very obvious who it was. She was very easy to find. And then while Peter had his face pixelated out, his voice was very clear. And so a fellow policeman was a fellow Australian policeman, I should say, was able to go.

You know, I'm sorry to say it, but that is that is one of my fellow Australians. And that was Detective Paul Hopkins. He recognized the Australian voice and he was in the Australian Federal Police Force and working on this case. So you can just imagine, you know, as well, the disappointment with knowing it's one of your own. It's, you know, it's not some monster, you know, living under a rock. It's one of your own. Through the course of this investigation, then they were able to find, obviously, the other girls that were filmed and photographed and abused in these videos.

And I guess one of the most, you know, sad stories is the story that he asks his 18 year old girlfriend at the time, Carmen Alvarez, to go out and get some street children. He says he wants to adopt some street children. Carmen suggests her own sister and he goes, no, no, I want a nine year old and a 12 year old specifically. So he gets her, enlists her to go out and find these kids. So these kids were literally brought into order, you know, as part of a paedophile ring. So this was to create another video to order.

for another paedophile. The two girls, I could only find a name for one. So one was Rosie or Rosie. Again, conflicting reports depending on what website you go to. But they were lured to his house by Carmen with the promise of food. That in itself, I just think is so fucking tragic. That is all that is required.

to lure these kids to, you know, potentially their deaths. It's just they're hungry, you know, just basic shit. But they were lured to the house with the promise of food. They were fed. Again, I am going to choose not to go into graphic detail. You can find the detail online if you so wish. But again, for the purposes of my podcast, I won't be glorifying this. After they were fed, he asked them to remove their clothes. They were asked then to do various things to each other and him while being photographed and while being filmed as well.

they were then put in dog collars and tied up so that they couldn't escape. The following day after an attempted escape, and again, depending on what website you go to, some say the next day, some say after a five-day ordeal. Again, I'm sure the truth lies somewhere in the middle. They tried to escape, though. That seems to be the running threat. And to teach them a lesson, Peter Scully made them dig their own graves. So again, you see this pattern emerging. And again, when I first kind of looked into this, I wondered, were these various stories getting mushed up? But again, with the research, it seems to be that these two girls, one being Rosie or Rosie, one was nine, one was 12. They were cousins. They were made to dig their own graves and were told they would be killed and buried in them if they tried to escape again. Again, that is what we were told happened to Cindy as well. But unfortunately...

We know Cindy died and that she was strangled to death. Rosie and her cousin. managed to survive for the simple fact that Carmen, who again was one of Peter Scully's teenage Filipino girlfriends, came back to the house. Again, like I said, some people say the next day, some people after five days, felt remorse and felt sorry for what she had done and actually let the girls go. Again, conflicting reports on what happened here. Some reports say that Carmen with the two girls went to the police. Some say that the two girls went to the police by themselves and then the police came back and arrested Carmen. But either way, Carmen got arrested and Peter Scully went on the run.

So that's how he kind of became alerted to the fact that the police might be on his trail, might be on his case. So this all happened and he's on the run, but still operating this lucrative £10,000 or dollar a view snuff and, you know, films and a paedophile ring. His main market, through my research, it seemed to have been Germany, the UK and America as well. But I mean, obviously other countries involved as well, but they seem to be his main sources of revenue. These were the big books guys that were investing in his business. It's just horrific. I've tried, like I said, to find some evidence on his backstory, some, you know, very hard to get anything about his early life. And in fact, I wasn't able to find anything other than his date of birth, where he was born. And again, with the wife and the kids as well, very hard to find anything. There's no mention of them other than that. There's a wife, there's two kids.

I don't know what age is. I also tried to look and see if there was any evidence that Peter Scully had abused his own children. Again, there's just nothing online. If it happened, it's not out there. But what I did find, I guess, is interesting is that he was well liked. This is a really well liked, well thought of man. And when I say that, I find that interesting is that isn't that often the case in these instances that.

people are like i just wouldn't have suspected now obviously he had swindled people out of money listening to their reports definitely they said that you know they yes and no they thought he would have been capable of something like that but you know maybe not to that level um you know working within the sex industry maybe you know the escort agency yeah they could see how how that kind of you know that wasn't too far a leap from what he had been doing um with the it fraud and all of that kind of thing but then the transition into pedophilia and this you know pedophile sex ring one of the biggest if not the biggest in the world I mean it's very hard to get facts and figures on these things because obviously half the members have not been caught yet you know he's caught which is great and a great step but there's hundreds of thousands of them still out there you know But this is what they're saying is that he's a well-liked guy, well-thought-of guy. Disappointed I couldn't find anything on the wife and the kids. I mean, I know they're probably under some kind of protection by the media, or from the media even, I should say. But it would have been really interesting to have found an interview with the wife and just even to get her take on it. You know, was this the man she knew? I'm always, I don't know about you guys, I'm always really interested into the psychology of these things. And I want to try and understand what has pushed you to that point. Not even pushed you, what has made you...

go to that point what's brought you to that point in your past in your life I don't believe people are inherently evil maybe I'm very naive but I like to see the backstory and see if I can make sense of it and I think a lot of us are like that we like to believe that there was something that happened that created this just god-awful series of events and that it just went to this level where unfortunately at least one little girl that we know of was murdered another one is missing and God knows how many more, you know, with the levels of street children in the Philippines as well and the poverty and all of that kind of thing. You just don't know how many more out there. Look, a fascinating case. Peter Scully was sentenced to life. That was back this time last year, a little over a year ago, June 2018. But look, it's a fascinating case by all accounts. If you're like me and you have a morbid curiosity, you just need to know these things. I always say I need to know how bad it gets. I need to know the worst of the worst. And it's not trying to glorify this shit, but this is happening.

whether we talk about it or not and aren't we better educating ourselves on these subjects without glorifying them and like I said I for that specific reason decided not to go into the details of the abuse that information is out there I'm not glorifying it and I'm not having some fucking sicko listening to my podcast and getting off on the nitty-gritty details of it either so that's my care duty as you know just a human being I'm not going to go into those details but I think it is important It's not glorifying it. It's educating ourselves. This stuff is happening. And I had never heard of this case until I stumbled across it. I thought, Jesus, this would be a fascinating one to cover. Maybe it's too far, Gemma. Maybe, you know, you've pushed it too far this time. I'll put it to a vote. I'll put it to a vote. And I was just astonished by how many of you wanted to hear about it. But maybe it's not just me who has a morbid fascination with these things and this morbid curiosity, you know. And look, as I always say, forewarned is forearmed. And that would be my opinion on things like this. Guys, look, if you've been affected by this podcast, as I'm sure you have.

There are charities out there to donate to. I'm not going to flog any one charity, but that's what I'd be asking you to do on the back of this podcast. Get on the computer, look at charities that are championing, you know, just working against trafficking, working against sex crimes, working against, you know, these millions of kids that are caught in this system. and, you know, the relentless work of these tireless police and detectives and only for them, where would they be? But that's what I'd ask you to do after this podcast. Let's get something good going. So guys, look, that is the story of Daisy's destruction. As always, if you want links to documentaries, there hasn't been a solid documentary per se done on this, but there's a couple of, you know, shorter ones, 15 minute, half hour ones. If you're looking for links, as always, you're welcome to DM me on our Instagram account or our Facebook account. Again, they are at what's up doc podcast. Guys, as always.

I have been your host, Gemma Delaney. I hope you've enjoyed this episode of What's Up Doc. I hope you found it, you know, informative and not gratuitous. And as always, guys, you've been great. We will talk to you next time. Take care. Bye-bye.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of What's Up Doc: The True Crime Documentary Podcast?

This episode is 29 minutes long.

When was this What's Up Doc: The True Crime Documentary Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on September 23, 2019.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this What's Up Doc: The True Crime Documentary Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.