It may be fall, but winter is coming. BetMGM Casino is putting a spin on the iconic television show Game of Thrones. You can now play the Game of Thrones casino game at BetMGM Casino. Forge your path to the throne with Dragonfire and over 4,000 ways to win and more. Journey through Westeros and discover casino excitement like you've never seen before. Download the BetMGM Casino app and check out the Game of Thrones casino game. Will you be next to take the Iron Throne? BetMGM and GameSense remind you to play responsibly. 19 plus to wager. Ontario only. Please play responsibly.
If you have questions or concerns about your gambling or someone close to you, please contact Connex Ontario at 1-866-531-2600 to speak to an advisor free of charge. BetMGM operates pursuant to an operating agreement with iGaming Ontario. At 2.40am on the 9th of December 2001, novelist Michael Peterson made a hysterical call to report an accident. His wife Kathleen had fallen down a flight of stairs where he had found her lying in a massive pool of her own blood. By the time the paramedics had arrived, it was too late for Kathleen and within two weeks, Michael Peterson would be indicted for his wife's murder.
The case, which stretched on until 2017, would only get more bizarre from here. You're listening to What's Up Doc, The Staircase. Hi guys, I'm your host Gemma Delaney and you have tuned into What's Up Doc, the documentary review podcast. Today we are discussing the masterpiece that is Netflix, The Staircase. Have you watched it? What did you think? Okay, I'm going to talk you through it step by step. So...
It's really hard to summarize this documentary in 30 minutes, but I'm going to do my best. You got to hold on there with me, okay? I've summarized it, I think, into the bits that I personally, anyway, found were the most interesting. I hope you'll agree with me. So I don't think I've ever had so much interaction once we've announced a documentary. So obviously the last couple of goes that we've done, we've given you the option of voting for one or the other. And you seem to like that, so I'm going to stick with that format. But when there's been a winner, I don't think there's ever been such a...
oh my God, you're doing this. And on the flip of that, oh my God, if you're doing this, you must do this. You know what's coming. If you've seen the documentary, you know what I'm talking about. It's the bloody owl theory, all right? So you can't do the staircase and not do the owl theory. I'm going to dedicate a whole segment at the end of this podcast to that alone. But look, back to the beginning.
As I said, Michael Peterson, fairly well known around his neck of the woods, novelist. He's ran for mayor. He's got kind of, you know, political inclinations or ideas. And he's, you know, writing in the press in North Carolina, where he lives, Durham, County Durham, about kind of, you know, things going on maybe in the mayor's office, things going on in the police department, things that, you know. allude to funny goings on, shady dealings. So what I'm saying is this guy is well known in his locality and he hasn't made any bloody friends. So this guy makes a 911 call, says his wife's fallen down the stairs. What do I do?
Like I said, initially, he's not actually thought of as a suspect, but it is the case that has so many twists, so many turns. I mean, you'd be forgiven for thinking the fella might have something to do with it. I'm still undecided, to be honest with you. I'm still very much on the fence. But look, I'm going to talk you through what I thought were the best bits of the documentary, the notable points. OK, the first thing I like to call.
careless with the truth okay so this guy has a history of lying or at the very least as I said being careless with the truth he loves a good story does our Michael right he is as most storytellers are I think a little bit on the exaggeration side right if you're going to be good at talking up a talk telling a story you know how to embellish and by god does Michael Peterson know how to embellish so from the get-go this guy is casting himself in a bad light because of course when you are up for the murder of your wife every little white lie you're going to have ever told comes out and makes you look like an absolute gobshite. And he does. I mean, the poor chap. I was absolutely... The parts of this documentary are just scarlet firm. Some of the things are trivial, in my opinion. Some of the things are...
Pretty bloody major, but look, you have to be, you have to be your own, you know, make your own decisions in that regard. The couple of points of interest with regards, Michael Peterson being careless with the truth. Okay, he has been found to have greatly exaggerated bits and pieces from his past. For example, in the documentary, we learn that he has said that, or basically his whole life, he's got this injury and his whole entire life, his story has been that this was a war wound. So he is an army vet.
He has served for his country. And he comes home from the army with this injury and says, oh yeah, oh yeah, you know, I've got that in them. Not necessarily, but you know what I mean? And blames it on shrapnel. So shrapnel is how he sustained this injury. But we do learn that that is not the case. That in fact, he sustained this injury as a result of a car accident. Come on, Mike. Like this, Marto for you. So, so embarrassing. Some of this information coming out. So that's the first thing. Injured by a car accident, not by shrapnel.
Michael Peterson, being careless with the truth, strikes again. He goes for mayor. So County Durham, North Carolina, where this whole documentary is based. He goes for mayor in 1999. So two years before the death of Kathleen Peterson. And during his mayoral bid, it is found that not only did he lie about the car accident and the shrapnel, he has also lied about the fact that he has got two purple hearts.
So if you don't know, Purple Hearts are what army veterans or army officers are awarded for great... acts of bravery okay and this guy has got not one but two of them so obviously this is a bit of a plug when he's going around for mayor this is one of the stories he tells and sure obviously Arrival or the newspaper or just anyone with a bit of common sense who knows how to dig around does a bit of digging around and finds out that this is a load of hokey he does not have even one purple heart he has zero hearts so that's another you know again is it an exaggeration is it a major lie is it indicative to murder I don't know but like I said these are interesting points to note throughout the documentary The next thing and look I'm kind of putting a lot of things under the one bracket here so just go with me for a minute.
He's claiming to be happily married. Now, I'm not saying that he's not, but there's a lot of evidence to the contrary. At least there's a lot of evidence that casts doubt on that. And what I mean is this. Firstly, Kathleen Peterson, the victim at the centre of all this, is about to lose... This episode is brought to you by Spreaker, the platform responsible for a rapidly spreading condition known as podcast brain. Symptoms include buying microphones you don't need, explaining RSS feeds to confused relatives, and saying things like, sorry, I can't talk right now, I'm editing audio.
If this sounds familiar, you're probably already a podcaster. The good news is Spreaker makes the whole process simple. You record your show, upload it once, and Spreaker distributes it everywhere people listen. Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and about a dozen apps your cousin swears are the next big thing. Even better, Spreaker helps you monetize your show with ads, meaning your podcast might someday pay for, well, more microphones. Start your show today at Spreaker.com. Spreaker. Because if you're going to talk to yourself for an hour, you might as well publish it. Her job. Hmm. Not such a major thing you might say. Maybe not. But...
Kathleen is actually the breadwinner in the Peterson household. So she brings in the big bucks, okay? Michael is, you know, struggling artist for all accounts. So he's a novelist, has had kind of some level of success. But, you know, he's not John Grisham. So she is bringing home the bacon. She's about to lose her job. 45,000 other employees in her company have been let go. She's next in line. Second point of interest on the happily married, happily ever after. Kathleen is not only the breadwinner and about to lose her job.
But the Petersons, as a couple, are $150,000 in debt. Yes, you heard me right. So these are wealthy folks. They got a lot of money. They're living in a big house. I mean, if you've seen the documentary, you've seen the house. It is stunning. Not only is it stunning, interesting note, it was actually used for a film set for The Handmaid's Tale. Not the one we're all watching now, but the 1990.
version. It was a made for TV movie, an adaption of the book. And that was actually filmed in their house. So it was rented off them to be used as the set for The Handmaid's Tale. So that's, like I said, these guys are, you know, they're not short of a few bob. So they're in debt to the tune of 150,000. The next interesting thing, which I found very interesting, and I've lined these up in this order specifically to bring you to this. Kathleen Peterson's life was insured to the tune of 1.4 million dollars.
Let that sit with you for a minute. So, if Kathleen Peterson dies, or in the event of Kathleen Peterson's untimely death, her spouse, a.k.a. Michael Peterson, is up to the tune of 1.4 million. it would eradicate that debt and it'd leave Mike with a nice little tidy sum to tuck under his mattress as well. So again, not saying this means he killed her, but I'm giving you the evidence as it's presented in the documentary. So I find that really interesting as well. And this is a kind of a sub note, which again, I'm not saying it means the guy killed her. And like I said, I don't really know. I still, I'm kind of on the fence. But again, if you haven't watched it, spoiler alert, the guy is partaking.
infrequent homosexual affairs outside of the marriage. Now, Michael Peterson's claim is that Kathleen knows she's always known, she's fine with it, he's bisexual, and look, it's just a role she can't fulfil. And so she's happy that he goes elsewhere, but he loves her. And in fact, you know, some of the people that he solicited for sex... are you know in the documentary you know they're spoken to and by all accounts they say he spoke very highly of her and how she's the love of his life and that this is just something else in his personality that he needed to kind of get off his chest and that's what they're for so he always spoke very highly of her even to these guys he was sleeping with so like I said doesn't mean to kill her but I think it's an interesting point to note as well um so gay gay gay affairs right so put that in there with he's got a tendency to be careless with the truth and what's also interesting right and I'm digressing slightly but I found this out on me travels while I've been doing my research for this documentary it's not ever mentioned in this documentary that Michael Peterson is in a relationship for the duration of the trial, the documentary, and everything else that goes on. I won't get into it too quickly because we don't want to spoil the end, but everything that comes to pass throughout the documentary, he's in a relationship with a woman who is an editor for the documentary, no less. So he meets her on set and they start this relationship and this is all going on. Now, none of that is shown in the documentary. I get that to a degree. I don't necessarily think they're trying to be shady. I mean, obviously, if it started on the documentary, it would have been quite new when the staircase was being made and you're not going to want to flaunt that all over.
all over TV. So I get that. That is the first point of interest is he does have a tendency to tell a bit of a tall tale. Michael likes exaggerating things. The next thing I found super, super, super interesting, you might not agree with me, you might agree with me, was that women plus stairs plus Michael Peterson equals not a good outcome. All right, so again, throughout the course of the documentary we learn, I think it's in episode three, if I'm not mistaken, out of 13, that Kathleen Peterson is not the first woman in Michael Peterson's life to suffer this fate. What do I mean by that? I mean...
Elizabeth Ratliff. OK, so again, if you watch the documentary, you'll know this already, that Michael was married before to Patty. They had two sons. They lived in Germany. What happened was Patty was a teacher in a German school where she became friendly with another teacher by the name of Elizabeth Ratliff. Now, that surname might sound familiar to you. That is because she is the biological mother.
to Margaret and Martha Ratliff, Michael Peterson's adopted daughters. So how did this come to pass, you may ask? Well, like I said, Paddy and Liz, great friends because they're working together. Michael and her husband, George, great friends because Michael is an army vet. George is a serving officer. So they've loads in common. And both have two kids. The Peterson's two boys. The Ratliff's two girls. So loads in common. So they live two doors down from each other. They're having the crack. They socialise together. And they are nearly like, you know, peas in a pot. Everywhere one family goes, the other family goes. What happens then, unfortunately, is George Ratliff...
dies he has a massive heart attack and leaves poor old Liz and the two children um leaves them behind obviously so I mean tragic and the Petersons step in and they you know help with the raising of the kids they they say in the documentary that uh Michael often did the bedtime stories with the girls um Patty often helped Liz took the girls in um and that they would share where they had dinner nightly so one night at the Petersons one night at the Ratliff's so that she wasn't dining alone. I mean, it's heartwarming. It's lovely. But what you then find out is that when all this was going on, this was back in the 80s in Germany, in 1985, Elizabeth Ratliff is found dead at the bottom of the stairs in a pool of blood. Sound familiar? Yeah. Okay. So pretty much the very same circumstances as Kathleen Peterson's death. She's found by the children's nanny.
And what kind of drives the nail in Michael Peterson's coffin is that it... If this sounds familiar, you're probably already a podcaster. The good news is Spreaker makes the whole process simple. You record your show, upload it once, and Spreaker distributes it everywhere people listen. Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and about a dozen apps your cousin swears are the next big thing. Even better, Spreaker helps you monetize your show with ads, meaning your podcast might someday pay for, well, more microphones. Start your show today at Spreaker.com. Spreaker, because if you're going to talk to yourself for an hour, you might as well publish it. ...is alleged at least. They don't really hash it out in the documentary. I don't know whether it's ever actually ascertained or not. It is alleged that he is the last person to have seen her life.
that basically they were having dinner at her house. He was giving the girls a bedtime story. Paddy was already gone home to Peterson's house with the boys by his claim. He said bye to Liz. She was grand. He went home and then she found by the nanny in the pool of blood at the bottom of the stairs. So...
Back in 1985, when all the shiz went down, obviously there was an inquest. And at the time, there was absolutely no heat on Michael Peterson. He wasn't even suggested that there was any foul play. The death was ruled as accidental and as the result of a brain hemorrhage. So it's alleged that she had a massive brain hemorrhage at the top of the stairs, fell down, hence all the blood. And in fact, then that story is corroborated by the fact that eyewitnesses, friends, family, work colleagues at the time, all testified to the fact that in the weeks leading up to this...
accidental death, you know, ruled as a brain hemorrhage, that she had been complaining of migraines and had refused to go to the doctor. She hated the doctor. So there's a lot of, you know, a lot of stuff pointing in in the right direction. So there was no reason for them to think there was any other, you know, circumstances or anything else to consider. So it's ruled accidental. Liz is buried. That's the end of it. Fast forward 18 years, Kathleen Peterson found at the bottom of Michael Peterson's staircase in the very same circumstances. So, of course, what happens next, and we know because we've watched the documentary, is that Michael and Paddy adopt Liz and George's daughters, Martha and Margaret.
And they're there for the whole trial, the whole of Michael's trial. And that then when Michael and Paddy separate, although they're still on very good terms, he moves home to the US with their two biological sons and their two adopted daughters. So Paddy stays in Germany. Mick is back to the US with all four kids. OK, so you're thinking like this guy is a good guy. You know, his ex-wife is going, yeah, you mind my sons. You mind our adopted daughters. I trust you. I don't think a mother would do that if they didn't genuinely think their spouse or ex-spouse was, you know, a decent sort.
But of course, the prosecution here about the second woman at the bottom of the stairs, and I'd say they thought all of the Christmases come at once. I mean, wouldn't you? If you were on a defence team or on a prosecution team, sorry, I should say, wouldn't you just be like, oh my God, this is the best news ever. And it definitely points the finger. I mean, it's such a bloody coincidence. It's too much of a coincidence to be a coincidence. So...
Due to the uncanny similarities, the prosecutors exhume Elizabeth Ratliff's grave. So she's brought back to the US and buried, so they don't need to go far. But they do, however, need to get the approval of the daughter. So Martha and Margaret have to sign off on that. But in fairness, in the documentary, that is at the behest of their father. So the father's like, please do this. And they're like, they think this will be of benefit to him because it will show for once and for all that he had absolutely nothing to do with the death of their mass. So they think they're doing the right thing. Unfortunately, the forensic pathologist on Kathleen Peterson's case is obviously going to be the same on Liz Ratliff's.
case so she is part of the exhumation she you know does her thing and she determines no this is not an accidental death in fact the injuries on her body aren't consistent with an accident in fact there are seven lacerations uh which indicate blunt force trauma so basically the same thing as what they're alleging kathleen has died from because they're not they don't think kathleen has fallen down these stairs they say they're all these uh kind of whip marks on her head that are you know indicative of a long thin object being kind of bet down on her. In the documentary, it's a blow poke, which is a type of poker for a fire. So that's what they are saying happened to Kathleen. And then the forensic pathologist goes, actually, that's what's happened to Elizabeth as well. So this is trying times for Michael Peterson and all, because they thought they were going to absolutely clear themselves by having this body exhumed, kind of backfired and done the exact opposite. Now, what's interesting though in the documentary as well is that the prosecution used the evidence to draw the parallels between the two cases. So basically to say, you know,
He was here and this happened. He was here and this happened. You know, he is the only common denominator. But Michael is never actually formally charged for Elizabeth Ratcliffe's murder? I don't know, death, I guess. He's never actually formally charged for it, but they just use the exhumation basically.
to kind of put more evidence behind him say you know where staircase and women and michael peterson are concerned there is death you know so and it is it's like i remember the first time i watched this i think this is probably my third or fourth time watching this documentary now remember the first time watching this going like this guy is guilty as hell like come on what else is there to hear and like in fairness i think anybody i think the same thing it's just What are the chances of the very same circumstances happening with two women in your life? I don't know. But then, you know, they have this nice little part in the documentary where they speak to, they kind of do a group, you know, where they have like a group from the community and throw them questions out and kind of see what they bounce back. And so basically one of the guys says like, yeah, I mean...
you could say that this guy is very clever, that like he was having an affair with this woman, pushed her down the stairs and then adopted her two daughters so that he wouldn't be suspected. I thought that was kind of genius, actually. I was like, jeez, he might have a point. Maybe he's onto something. I don't know. But look, that's for the sceptic, I guess. So that is the second point of interest. There are many, many points of interest in this documentary, but I thought the Elizabeth Ratcliffe, the fact that this is not a once-off in Michael Peterson's life. And like I said, that's brought in, I think, in episode three. And that is fascinating stuff. It's really, really compelling viewing. But look,
I'm going to segue nicely then to what we know if we've watched it is that Michael Peterson, spoiler alert, he is convicted. Okay, he's convicted. but he then goes for a retrial so he has a subsequent retrial and as a result of that retrial I don't really understand the ins and outs of the American justice system but they have this thing called an Alford plea which is named after the first guy who got it but basically what it is it's where somebody can acknowledge that the prosecution has enough evidence to convict you but they maintain their innocence. It sounds very, yeah, it's round and round in circles. Like, so what is that? Like, are you guilty or are you not? Look, in the documentary, they're like, the guy has already served time. He doesn't want to serve any more time. This is a way of getting the prosecution office back. They get the result they want and he never has to serve another day in person. So.
I don't know. I mean, what's your opinion? Do you think he did it? Do you think he didn't do it? It's so hard. Like, he's not the most likable guy either. He comes across as being a bit pompous and a bit of an arse and, you know, just likes the sound of his own voice, I suppose. But again, don't all of us storytellers. That's what we do. We embellish the truth. We make the story sound better. We made it more entertaining than the way it went down. So I don't know. But as I said at the head of the podcast, you can't talk about this flipping documentary and not talk about what? The Owl Theory.
It should be mentioned that barred owls are known to owl experts to attack people out of the blue, unprovoked, with no warning. So the fact that Kathleen lived in a place where these owls are prevalent and she got whacked in the head by one is not far out of the ordinary. Okay, so if you've been, you know, living in a cave since this documentary came out, you may not know what The Owl Theory is. I watched this documentary the first time when it came out on Netflix. And it had been on TV before that. I hadn't seen it in various forms. So Netflix got the rights to it and showed it. But like this had actually been doing the rounds for a couple of years. You may not know that. But yeah, this wasn't a new documentary. So it kind of came then to infamy through Netflix getting it.
So when I had watched this, when it was first released on Netflix, within I'd say about 72 hours, everyone was online talking about the owl theory. And I was like, what the hell is this about? So I gave it to Google. And I just thought it was the most ridiculous, far-fetched, bloody thing I'd ever heard in my life. But...
the evidence is kind of compelling. So look, I'm going to put it out there, give you the facts. It's not up to me to judge. You make your own decisions, but it is, you know, it's for this to be a whole podcast. You can't talk about the staircase and not talk about the aisle theory. So what is it? It sounds absolutely ridiculous when you first hear it. I'm not sure if I believe it, but it goes something like this. Basically, 48 hours from the end of Kathleen Peterson's murder trial, forensic testing discovered that the wounds she had sustained
that the experts on both sides had not been able to explain, that the experts on both sides had not been able to recreate either the pattern of the lacerations or the pattern of the blood cast off from the impact, it was discovered that the lacerations on Kathleen Peterson's head were in the perfect shape of talons. Stay with me. In the perfect shape of talons. And, like, Google it, guys. Google it. The pictures are out there. Like, you know, they're all over. Used to gain Kathleen Peterson's, you know, skull laceration photographs or whatever. It'll come up. They do look like claws. I'm not going to, like, I mean, there's two of them that, like, you could get two chicken feet and just put them. It's the perfect shape, like, you know, it's... So maybe it did. I don't know. But also...
the forensic report found microscopic teeny tiny little feathers in the lacerations and in Kathleen Peterson's hands. So along with that actually they found clumps of her own hair in her hands. Now obviously they had been able to physically see the clumps of her hair in her hands. They hadn't seen these feathers because they are teeny tiny microscopic feathers. But...
Allegedly, there's only a handful of species that actually have these teeny tiny microscopic feathers. And one type of bird that is indigenous to their area in County Durham is what's called a barred owl. OK, so look it up. Barred owls have fluffy feet. These tiny little feathers all the way right down to their talons. Couple that with the fact that barred owls are known and have a history of attacking humans completely unprovoked and totally out of the blue. OK, next up.
Kathleen and Michael's house is in an area surrounded by woodland, which is home to, you guessed it, barred owls. Barred owls roost all over the place over there, okay? So again, not beyond the realm of possibility that she could have got these fingers in her hands because they're living in and around the same area as each other. But basically, what they're saying this evidence alludes to is that Kathleen was on her way back into the house. Crazy barred owl attacks her completely unprovoked. Kathleen fights to get the barred owl off her as it's clawing at her scalp. As it's clawing at her scalp, it gets entangled in her hair because it's got little talons. And so she is pulling her hair out, trying to get the owl untangled from her hair. Runs inside, away from the owl, runs to the stairs and bleeds out. So.
Look, I don't know. It sounds very far-fetched to me. I've seen the pictures. Like I said, they do look like claw marks. You can't discuss the documentary and not discuss the theory. And like I said, the reason why the defence never brought this in was because of the simple fact that they only got this forensic evidence two days before the end of the trial. And obviously, at that point in time, you have to have presented your case. You can't just throw something into the mix when they're two days away from a closing statement. So as a result, it was never used either for or against Michael Peterson. But that, ladies and gentlemen, is the crazy-ass owl theory that you've probably guessed by the tone of advice.
Not a big fan of. It's interesting, but everything's interesting. I just think, for me personally, sounds too far-fetched. Far too far-fetched. But look, guys, again, it's been half an hour. Where does the 30 minutes go? I need more time to talk to you, to talk to you through these documentaries. But that was The Staircase. As I said, Michael Peterson was then convicted in 2003. After subsequent retrial and the Alfred plea, he was released. And I've done my research. He is now living with his family. And, wait for it, he's writing a book.
I cannot wait. I'm going to be the first on the list to get that bloody book. I can tell you. Guys, thank you so much for tuning in to What's Up Doc. You can find us on Instagram. We're at what's underscore up underscore doc underscore podcast. And you can keep up to date and get your say on our fortnightly polls where you get to pick your next documentary that we review. As always, I'm Gemma Delaney. You've been great. Thanks for tuning in.