You may not agree on the temperature, but it's easy to agree that 125 bucks off a smart thermostat is a pretty great deal. Save energy automatically, adjust from anywhere, and redeem before or after you buy. Offer ends November 30th. Terms and conditions apply. Claim your rebate at homerenovationsavings.ca slash thermostat.
Hello and welcome back to What's Up Doc, the true crime documentary podcast. I'm your host, Gemma Delaney, and I am here to tell you what is up, what is up, what is up with the latest true crime documentaries. This week's episode. Funnily enough, you'll hear in a minute anyway, you'll know what I'm on about. It was one of the first episodes of season three that I recorded. It was recorded back in the Christmas breaks. There's a lot of talk of Christmas and New Year's resolutions. And also, for the love of God, please forgive me. The audio quality is absolutely shite because it was the first, one of the first episodes I recorded via Zoom. So whereas normally I would obviously have guests in my little lair in my studio, this was all online and it was a lervin curve and thanks for the days as I've gotten better at it. But yeah, not so hot with the audio quality on this one. Look, hopefully.
the guest will more than make up for it. On this week's episode, we have broadcaster, TV presenter, radio presenter, comedian, and just all-around fucking really sound bloke, Keith Walsh of the Keith Walsh Podcast fame. Keith is good enough to come on and listen to my nonsense and shite on about the new Netflix documentary, Trial 4, with me. And I hope you enjoyed this one. Keith Walsh, thank you for joining us. Thanks for having me, Gemma. How are you? I'm good, I'm good. How'd you get on over Christmas?
I had a fantastic Christmas. Very nice. I enjoy the quiet life, so it suited me. I know a lot of people were upset not being able to see friends and family. It suited me down to the ground. I had everybody I needed here within the four walls of this house. Yeah, I think we even said that during the production meeting, did we? I was saying as well that I'm, I wouldn't say notoriously anti-social, but I like my own space. So this lockdown malarkey is suiting me down to the ground.
Yeah, it's not a cool thing to say, but yeah, it's fine to have to stay away from. Maybe it's something that comes with age, I don't know, but yeah, like you said, everyone that you need being in the four walls of the house, that's a nice way to put that, actually. Yeah, it's definitely age, because I imagine, like, my daughter's 18, and let's say between the age of 18 and 28, I craved other people and being out. Yeah, you'd be climbing the four walls trying to get out. And like I'm saying to you, I have a 14-year-old daughter, 15 actually, I'm 15, but they're very same. Like, you know, it's, we're having, I thought up until this point, we didn't have the terrible team.
But we're getting there. She's struggling with lockdown, 100%. And every day it's like, can I go out and see my friends today? I'm like, nope, we're still in level five and we've got 10 million new cases. But look, I see there on Instagram, you're doing something exciting. You've been busy anyway. You're cracking on with this 100 days of no booze. But you've been booze free for a while now, right? Yeah, a year now. I started last year when I did at the end of Christmas, got through Christmas.
usual christmas and then i was doing a lot of work with rt i was covering a lot of radio stuff for the week where everybody's off so i decided to just work and stop booze and kind of shortly after christmas and then decided in my wisdom to do 100 days of no booze because i saw kira kelly on news talk does this thing that's right yeah i wondered if you'd been inspired by her all right yeah Yeah, so I said, I wonder what it'd be like to do 100 Days of No Booze. And I didn't really think how long 100 Days was. I was thinking, oh, that'll bring me up to what, middle of March, maybe Paddy's again, you know, that wouldn't be too bad. But it's a lot longer than that. It's 10th of April, if you start on the first. I'm glad I didn't know how long it was, because yeah, 100 Days of No Booze. And then I just continued and kind of had a couple of weekends where I drank during the whole year. And after those weekends, it sort of made me double down on the fact that I'm not probably ever going to drink again. So yeah, about a year. And then this year, I thought it might be interesting. Other people might be interested in doing that. So I sort of just put it out there. And yeah, we have a look at...
We have a WhatsApp group with about 200 people in it, which is the biggest WhatsApp group. That's deadly. 200 people. It's a lot of people. And then we have a separate Instagram page. The No Booze 100 crew. That's what we are. It's good. It's good. Even if one or two people get through the 100 days. That's deadly.
It's very of the moment. I mean, a lot of my friends have gone, you know, booze-less over the last couple of years. My brother and his partner were probably the first that I knew of maybe five or six years ago. And like that as well, it was a Christmas thing. I don't know if it was a New Year's resolution or what, but come Christmas, they decided to just knock it on the head. I mean, it's not that they ever drank excessively to begin with, but I suppose just Irish people, as I have it, when we do drink, we don't stop at one. You know what I mean? It's not a glass of wine, it's a bottle or whatever. But yeah, there's so many of my friends, booze-less. And then, you know, you had a post on Instagram there a couple of weeks ago as well, and you were looking for recommendations for like booze-less drink. And I commented under.
We started it about a year ago as well. It wasn't our Christmas time. It was probably a year. It was only 12 months last summer. And like that as well, I don't know. We just decided we didn't want hangovers anymore and decided to try the booze and stuff. And like, there's no difference in the taste. This is what I keep saying to people, definitely with, you know, some of the beers. The beers, I think, are probably the better ones. And the no seco as well. The wines, not so much. They're not great. And that's probably why I haven't gone completely te-total. I do like the classic wine. Yeah, we had some no seco last night. It's nice, isn't it? Yeah, it's perfect. It's fine. There's no difference. And I definitely can have Heineken 0-0 when you get the credit. Yeah, it's lovely.
does it for me every time so yeah i mean and you know again it could be an age thing but i think i just want to be more productive i want to get more stuff done you know I just have so many hours in the day now, so I can do whatever I want, which is great. Yeah, I suppose that's what it is. It's getting busier and, like you said, wanting to be more productive and just not being able to justify, you know, wasting a day in bed dying or your head in a bucket of vomiting like after being on the razz the night before. I never really got bad hangovers, which is a great excuse to drink, but it was just the... I would feel very lethargic during the week and not really care about things. You know, it wouldn't be the hangover. It would be the following week. The sense of, like, horror and guilt and the fear that would just last until Thursday and I just wouldn't get anything done. So, yeah, here's to the...
Weekend. Here's to the week. Here's to the rest of the week. I'm assuming then, well, as you said, you started this last year, but this is kind of your version of a New Year resolution, or have you set yourself any New Year resolutions this year? No, nothing really. I'm just keep doing, keep being as brilliant as I am. Being an exceptional human being I am. Just keep being perfect. No, I'm still, I'm still very fascinated by things like therapy and self-improvement. Yeah. So just to continue trying to be better, the best version of myself, I suppose, is one way of putting it. Yeah.
Well, a nice little segue, I think that is, into then true crime and true crime documentaries. Because that's what I always say. I'm big into self-improvement and psychology. And I think both of those things go hand in hand. So I think if you have an interest in psychology and how the mind works and how the brain works, you'll naturally have an interest in true crime as well. Or maybe that's just me. Maybe that's just how I reasoned myself. But when we had our previous meeting, our production meeting, and I asked you, were you a true crime enthusiast? And you were very honest in that. Not really. You'd watched a few documentaries on Netflix. But how did you find it when I set you this task?
Yeah, I think I'd said to you that I enjoyed, my daughters kind of would be more into it. I think it's a young person's game, young people like yourself. But I'd watch The Staircase and, you know, obviously the big ones when they come along, you hear about them and then you recommend a podcast, true crime podcast. I like the Aussie one, which is, I think it was called Teacher's Pet. That's right. It's really good. Absolutely fascinating.
To a lesser degree, where's George Gibney, the Irish one, which is a brilliant podcast about George Gibney's swimming coach who absconded to America. And it was a bad, bad guy. But yeah, the staircase. And yeah, I didn't really know. Like, I suppose I'm in a phase in my life where if people ask me something, I'm more likely to say yes than no. So I didn't really know exactly what you're asking me, but I was like, okay. This person seems to be, you know, interesting. And I didn't really know what I was saying yes to. I know when you discovered there was eight hour long episodes and say you're absolutely cursing me, were you? There was a moment where I was like, oh, okay, I better watch all this. But no, I was glad I did. You know, it's funny, and not to get too philosophical, but...
It's funny in life where if you allow yourself to say yes to things, you'll find yourself somewhere where you didn't expect to be and enjoying yourself. So, yeah, no, I'm glad you asked and I enjoyed watching it. Perfect. Well, look, I'm going to go through the boring bits first of all. So obviously the title, the one we're dealing with today is Trial 4. What did you think of that as a title actually? What did, you know, when you first heard the title, I'm assuming you didn't know anything about the case. What kind of images did that awaken in your mind? What do you think it might be? Well, Trial 4 I thought was, it was, I just thought it was.
in room four in the court you know there was a courthouse and there was four rooms or 30 rooms it's just in in room number four so i didn't really get the significance of it and to sort of um not to be come across as totally stupid it was a long time into it where i went ah this is the first trial and that should have that should have occurred it should have occurred to me a lot sooner But like, no, I'm much there to be honest with you. I didn't think it was a great title for the documentary. I didn't really, you know, like that as well. I was into it a while and I was like, okay, that makes sense. But I think to the layman, you know, flicking through Netflix, it's not something that's necessarily going to grab you. And that's a pity, I think, because I thought this was a crack in the documentary, but we'll get into that more. Yeah, I do think just as we've explained, there was a lot.
tastier elements to the documentary than the fact that this is the fourth trial. I do feel like, especially for Irish audiences, there might have been an Irish element that they could have highlighted and made it about that, but they didn't. And as I was saying to you in the production meeting as well, you said to me that you've seen all the bigger ones, the more well-known true crime documentaries like The Steercase. And I said, well, that's really interesting because the guys who directed this, Remy Berkel and Jean-Exavier de la Sprout, really had to be Remy Berkel with it and Jean-Exavier de la Sprout. I would assume, or some kind of pronunciation like that. They did the staircase. And then they did, I don't know if you've heard of it, Sin City Law. That was a big hit at Sundance. But it was funny that you had said you had seen the staircase and liked it. And here I was giving you a documentary by the very same guys. Did you see any similarities, production quality-wise? Really? Nothing struck me. I thought the openings were very similar in the way that they were constructed. So I don't know if you noticed the kind of imagery that was used. So in the staircase, they used this kind of graphic of a winding staircase. And then they kind of had shots.
What's the word I'm looking for? Like black and white kind of a projector. Projector is what I'm trying to think of. Shots blasted onto the screen. And they've done a very similar kind of thing with the opening in here. I did say to you, though, that I didn't like the music for the opening of this. It reminded me kind of Dropkick Murphys style. Dropkick Murphys, yeah. It probably was Dropkick Murphys. I didn't get a chance to look into that, but I didn't mind the music so much. I think your man, Berkel, is that his name? Yeah. You probably pronounced his name Berkel because he's French-American. Berkel. But I think he studied graphics.
I think that was his kind of thing because he put together the trailer for the pitch to make the documentary. So I think the graphics were probably because he was involved in the staircase as well. So probably coming from his head, I'd say. Yeah, yeah. He was determined to get that in. This is what he does. Didn't strike me. It's probably too long ago since I watched the staircase. Also, I'm a nerd and this is what I do. So don't worry. This is what I do. But like in terms of then, you know, like you said, and I both agreed that we didn't think that the documentary's title really sold it per se or gave a whole lot away.
Did you, had you heard of this case before, like, you know, before I set you the task? No, no, I'd never heard of it. I hadn't either, to be perfectly honest with you. It's weird because of the Irish elements that it didn't make headlines over here or, you know, you'd imagine it's not that long ago and there's a huge Irish element to it. I would have thought I would have heard of it. Because it's funny because, and I spoke to you about a different documentary, The Central Park Five. Yeah, Central Park Five. Which I'd heard, you know, I'd heard of that. And so obviously when I came across that on Netflix, I was drawn to watch it. But yeah, I didn't hear anything about this one at all. No, no, never heard about this case either. But like you'll find, if you ever choose to go back into the true crime genre community again, you'll notice that, I suppose, is that, you know, the volume of.
you know, cases, wrongful convictions, corruption. Again, I don't want to give too much away before getting into the kind of summary of the doc, but it's so ten a penny over there that, you know, I'd say the story don't ever make it outside of America, which is great for us as true crime enthusiasts because it means we have a plethora of cases to dive into and things we've never heard of. And, you know, whereas... I guess over here in Ireland, everybody knows everybody. There's that six degrees of separation and there's a murder or killing. It's front page news. It's on the news for the week, you know. It's nearly oversaturated and we find out every element of it. So that's the good thing and the bad thing, I suppose, about the corruption is that it's so prevalent that there's so many cases that we're spoiled for choice. But then on the flip, that is the negative of it as well, that there is so much going on over there. I do think you should watch this and be glad of our justice system because we are very hard on ourselves as a country and what we do with the law and how we run the country and all that kind of stuff.
And we're very, very lucky to live in this country. Yeah. I've said it before on different episodes as well, Keith. It's like, you know, no disrespect to our own government. But I mean, trying to be funny about it, I suppose really we just have a bunch of like, you know, farmers trying to run a country. You know, we just don't even have the level of, you know, in terms of finance, you know, corruption, the power they have over there. It's just not even it's oranges and apples. Like, you know, we're dealing with.
much smaller fish in a much smaller pond here as well. We're a very small country. We're a very small country. We're just a little island. We're not that important. We shouldn't worry too much about things. This is it, exactly. So look, I'm going to quack on with the summary of the documentary then. So interject if I miss anything here. There's anything you feel needs to be said. So basically, it is about a young black man in Boston, Sean Ellis. He's 19. To give a very rough, I suppose, synopsis of it, he's buying nappies or diapers at Walgreens. There is a police officer shot outside.
in his car detective john mulligan it's kind of an executioner style murder um which you know some that would say that's a personal thing you know if you're going to get into the psychology of a murder and that kind of thing um and basically very very quickly fingers pointed at this young black man sean and that's that's the general gist of the story again without giving too much away too early in the in the podcast um It starts off at the end. It starts off, you know, with Sean doing a piece to camera. The opening shot, I think, is like a pan over the Boston skyline and then like a Boston courtroom. And then it shows Sean doing a piece to camera, talking, you know, that kind of, at the end of it kind of going, you know, I never thought I'd find myself here. I never thought I'd end up in this situation. And then, you know, his defense lawyer, who you mentioned there earlier, Rosemary Scappanteo. I'm not sure. I always butcher these names. Her talking about the case then as well.
Was there anything in the first episode that surprised you or shocked you? Not really, but like there was, it's funny the way it, maybe it was just me, but the way it evolved, there was moments where I actually thought, you know, when you, when you watch it at the start and you're kind of like, okay, he's definitely, you know, cause he's older, he's talking about it. So that would indicate that he's free, you know, you know, he's, it's, it's been solved and he's, he was, he was, he was innocent and he should have been locked up. But at the same time, the way it evolved, I was like, well, maybe he did do it or.
You know, because it was his friend who, it was the whole hiding of the guns and the friend and the person who saw him crouching behind the car. And, you know, there was moments where I was going, this is going to, I thought it was set up like. you know, to look like this guy was innocent and he got out free. Oh, yeah, that's interesting. That's interesting, yeah. But I'm a bit tick when it comes to things. I need things spelt out. You know, so I was like, wow, imagine if, like, you know, they're going to get to a point where actually he did do it and, you know, the cops were right because the cops were so, the white cops, obviously, the white Irish cops. Yeah, I know, for a shame. They were so adamant, you know, right to right. You're dead, right. They're very convincing in the first episode as well. So you triggered a memory in me that I forgot. I'm with you there. I actually did think that in the first episode. And again, not having any knowledge of this case because...
Again, I'm going to do the briefest of synopsis now of the first episode. But like I said, Sean, he's introduced to the protagonist, 19 years old. He states from the get-go that he's 22 years incarcerated. We know that. And then Mulligan is this cop who was shot dead. The only thing that I think really alluded to something being a miss, I think, anyway, in the first episode, I don't know if you remember, Keith, they said that his nickname, John Mulligan's nickname was Clearview. Because every case that came up against him, any evidence he found was always in Clearview. He never had to go searching for it. So, you know, this was a little nickname that he was given by.
judges, lawyers, and even fellow policemen alike kind of taking the piss out, you know. Yeah, because what I read in that was Clearview meant that he didn't have to do any paperwork, he didn't have to prove anything, everything was just obvious. Yeah, yeah, conveniently, conveniently. And then they said as well that he had, again, I can't remember the exact figures, if not the most arrests, you know, some of the highest arrests in the Boston Police Department as well. And then they do talk of him briefly having a history of wrongdoing. But apart from that, the first episode really went into then...
Next, it went into his, I don't know if you remember his partner, Nancy. She was the initial suspect. So that they learned that John Mulligan, after being killed, like I said, executioner style, and that tends to be a person. You know, that doesn't tend to be like a robbery type killing. That's a person. That's when there's emotion involved. So she was the initial suspect, and she was brought in to be questioned. And, you know, the documentary shows, or you can hear the audio of that. And she admits to knowing that he was cheating on her at the time. You know, she was aware of that, but that everything was fine. And they asked her point blank, did she kill him? And she says no.
And that's kind of the end of the line of investigation with her, which is strange to begin with anyway, I thought. Yeah, I kind of forgot about that bit. Yeah, and you'll be forgiven for her because it's all about, you know, like I said, these episodes are 45 minutes an hour long and that's all about five minutes of the first episode. Like it's just skirted over so quickly. But I guess maybe I'm wrong. At what point did they bring in the journalist from the Boston? I can't remember her name, but it was Blunder. What was it?
She did a kind of piece, a weekly piece called Blundering the Basics, wasn't it? Or something like that. Yeah, yeah, yeah. She was really good. And she was young at the time. She was this young, enthusiastic journalist. And she was kind of like, shit, if I'd known, you know, the wrath I was going to incur as a result of this piece, I probably would have shut up and said nothing. Like, she kind of starts. That's in the first episode as well. Yeah, so she was on to them. You know, she was saying, was it? Yeah, the Boston Globe, I think. But she was saying there was bad things going on.
within the organization. Yeah, so it's sowing the seed there, I guess. It's sowing the seed from the get-go that maybe, you know, not is all what it seems. And then, kind of midway through the first episode, we become aware of Sean's existence within, you know, they stop talking about the Mulligan murder and we become aware then of Sean's two cousins getting killed two days after. And they don't really go into any detail other than that the police thought there might be a potential link. I don't know how. They don't really go into it too much. But Sean's called in for questioning and like...
being the nice guy he is, or at least appears to be at this point in time, he freely admits to being at Walgreens at the time of the murder. And then, you know, his lawyer, Rosemary, is like, are they really the actions of a guilty man? Like, would you actually be stupid enough to admit to being at the location of the crime when, you know, you're the crime suspect? You wouldn't like it. You'd make up an excuse. But somehow the police kind of find this link between the two murders, which is, I think, sketchy at best. Yeah, there was something that maybe, maybe that the documentary, I don't know if that was intentional, but I was a bit confused around that. I was going, you know, there's so much going on.
it was his cousin he was just dragged in you know he was in it was a different case that kind of you know suddenly he was involved you know it didn't seem to make sense nothing seemed to join up it was confusing and you're like okay hang on a second and you know because it's confusing you're like oh i must have missed a step there something must have happened that i didn't see or noticed that the cops noticed or something you know so maybe that was intentionally confusing but but it was uh when you think about it it's bizarre you know and and uh you can see the reasoning behind it as you watch more of it uh why they did what they did but uh you know obviously some guy comes in not related to just mentions the just mentions the shop would be like me saying you know i was i was on my way to help my wife who was you know giving birth in in at home and i passed by duns you know and ran in to get you know some wipes on the way and they go duns that's the same place that murder happened the other day okay let's go it's funny you should say that actually because i was um reading an interview with the director uh remy burkel and they asked him the last question they asked him in in the interview was you know what was what was the message you were trying to get across and i just thought it was you know
really blunt but then i suppose you know just he's telling it how it is as well he said you just point your finger at a poor black man in boston to make a problem go away yeah that's the point he's trying to get across so it's you know and that's exactly what you're just saying there like it's it was at best you know it was it was so flimsy this connection between sean and it was just because he happened to mention being there buying nappies at the time of the murder which then kind of further on in the documentary to find out isn't actually the case it wasn't there at the time at all but also wasn't there a connection between i could be wrong here somebody he knew a friend of his or cousin of his And one of the other cops was in a relationship with her mother or something. Yeah, yeah. No, you're back on it. Am I skipping? Am I too far ahead now? You're not, to be honest, because I think like a lot of episode one is, like you said, a little bit confusing, maybe deliberately to show how.
you know, the tactics, the confusion tactics maybe that the Boston Police Department used. Because the way the first episode ends up is that there is a car scene driving away from the crime scene. It's found belonging to this guy, Terry L. Patterson. And then they bring him in for question and he says that Sean was the trigger. That's right. We should say that he was probably, I always think of Jerry Maguire in the UK, the Guildford Four, the Birmingham Six. He was...
He was kind of encouraged to write this confession, wasn't he? Yeah, he was. Look, we're going to lock you up. And he went, oh, the best thing for me to do is blame my friend. Because if I say he killed him and then I just get accessory or something. And that was his game, wasn't it? Because he thought, well, I'm a black guy. I mean, obviously it was with black people in Boston. They obviously knew, well, I'm not going to get away with this. So I'm just going to try and do the best. So he basically hung his friend out to try to try and make his situation better. Is that right? And again, you know that you're hitting the nail on the head and that's a really common.
reoccurring theme i find in true crime documentaries as well you see this over and over and over again you've seen the innocent files you see it in uh you mentioned earlier there about the the the central park five as well yeah you know i'm gonna go down anyway because i'm black so it's about getting the lesser charge it's not i'm not gonna not get a charge you know because as it works out in the central park five they get one kid who's who's who's particularly you know i think i remember the central park five is actually the kid's dad who said to him just you know just admit it make you say point the finger at those guys you're not you're not gonna you know and the situation you know you're so tired and you're in you've been locked up for so long you're so confused and you just think someone tells you this is the best thing to do for your situation and you're sort of you know you're meant to feel like but but you know to point the finger at other people you point the finger at other people you sign the statement to say yeah we were all there i was there but he did you know he bet the girl up whatever and for the cops there's your evidence you gotta sign statements yeah yeah and that's all they want at the end of the day they don't and again this is already a current theme they don't seem to be too interested in the truth they just want to really you know so like moving on then to episode two i'm gonna absolutely hammer through this i should say at this point
all the telltale signs are all there that this has been done before this isn't the first time they've done this before and if we talk we're talking about this particular case there's obviously many many more black people that went to prison that never that didn't get someone like Scapeggio to represent that didn't you know weren't as lucky and are probably still locked up to this day for some reason yeah and lucky is the operative word there because like that woman is an absolute beast I think my favorite bits in the documentary are her like you know on the in the courtroom you know tearing various members of police force down on the stand like she's an absolute animal you know she's not one to reckon with definitely but if you think like when she met Sean she said to him why you so obviously Obviously, she probably gets letters all the time of, you know, black people saying, I'm innocent. I didn't do this. Please help me. I saw you on the TV because she was kind of, she was involved in a famous case. You know, she made him prove to her that she should, you know, so that was what you're dealing with. So you can just imagine, and this is only Boston. You can just imagine. Yeah, yeah, 100%. But then in episode two, again, I don't know if you remember, but it was one of my favorite parts of the documentary. They initially started out then, episode two was kind of, you know, it's introducing Sean as he was at 19. You know, it kind of gives a brief synopsis. A member of a street gang. He's in a poor disadvantaged area.
and he was arrested the day of the cousin's funeral and he was paraded in front of the cameras so obviously they tipped off the local media as well it's paraded in front of the press by the police and and and he hadn't even had a chance to speak to a lawyer at this stage so then when they're talking to i don't know if you remember his initially poor rosemary he had these two guys whose names completely at the moment but they said that you know he hadn't even had a chance to speak to them yet and if he had they would have told him to stand up straight you know don't shield your face you're an instant he was hiding his hand yeah he was 19 he was a kid like you were saying you give an 18 year old daughter home imagine next year she gets you know fingered for uh a crime she didn't commit like you know and doesn't get to speak to you or legal representation and then she's in front of the media and cameras and on the news before you even know it like it's it's absolutely bonkers when you think about when you put it in context of your own life and people you know and love you know it's crazy but also you this guy is people are looking at us they're looking at the telly the the way it's set up is we've got him you've got the guy you're sitting at home in your house watching this and you go they've got that guy that killed that girl that's what you go straight that's it conclusion and you are the public who are watching that tv and they're going to be the jurors
who haven't yet been selected. Do you know what I mean? So you're already been fed that idea that he's guilty. How do you be objective when you've already been told this to the guy? You know what I mean? Yeah, because obviously straight away you're thinking of, you're trying to find reasons why he's not guilty rather than trying to find reasons why he's guilty, you know? Yeah, but it then jumps back to, and again, you mentioned her in the previous, when we were talking about episode one there, the journalist for the Boston Globe, whose name we can't think of, I can't remember the life of you. We can't remember the T. We can't remember the T. But she said that she watched the TV and hoped it wasn't going to be. Tony. Tony. Tony. Tony Loki or Losey or Loki.
Tony, that's it. She hoped it wasn't going to be another Carl Stewart. And I had no idea what she was talking about. But then she went in to explain that four years previously, this white woman in Boston called Carl Stewart had been murdered. And so basically it was a carjacking gone wrong. And once, do you remember this? Yeah. Once her husband gave the description of the black man that carjacked them and killed Carol, it was just absolute bedlam. Like they arrested nearly every black man in Boston. They tore apart apartment blocks, you know, not just, not just, you know, not, not just interviewing people, but actually, you know, tearing up apartments, trashing places and, you know, talking about Tony was talking about how quickly it became racial and, you know, just tearing through these, these communities. It's funny because it reminded me of a,
It reminds me of something happening in Northern Ireland and they're looking for a suspect amongst the Catholics. You know, it's very similar sort of, you know, they just, once the guy mentioned it was a black guy, gave a free description of him, they just, they just locked everything down, pulling people out of their cars. As you said, like trashing apartments, just, you know, like totally just, and obviously whatever way things were set up racially was, you know, anybody other than the white community would have thought, well, it's seriously a black guy anyway, so they're well within the rights to do what they're doing, you know, no sense of like, well, what are the rights of these people? You know, they didn't have rights, you know. Yeah, yeah, absolutely. And then they ended up arresting... We should say, this is 1995, isn't it? Like, it's not... Yeah, it's not that long ago. This isn't, like, you know, Rosa Parks. You know, this is very recent. It's not that long ago at all, but they ended up arresting this guy, Willie Bennett. And then he was going to be... I can't remember which he confessed or did he claims in this. I'm not really sure it's going to be, and I don't think I looked into it, to be perfectly honest. But they were going to stick him forward until Harold Stewart's brother-in-law came forward and admitted that it was actually himself and his husband had done it, and he helped cover it up.
and they set it up because basically the new how racist the cops were and the new bitch they'd hear black and discover it yeah and it worked except if the brother-in-law had in caves there'd be another black man locked up just like that for killing an innocent white woman and also if that happens and he's locked up for carjacking and killing a white woman this black guy it further enforces the racial stereotype further divides the community and you can see how all this feeds into what we now have in basically the cops lying about stuff has fed into the, you know, white people's distrust of the black community. Yeah, there's false narrative. But it's all based on lies. Yeah, absolutely, absolutely. But, yeah, I thought that was one of my favourite bits in the whole documentary because, again, that was another case I'd never heard of, but that's an infamous case over in America, the Carl Stewart case.
it's funny then that it being such an infamous case I don't know maybe they should have been you feel like they should have been much they should have been wary yeah when that happened you'd imagine certain steps would have been taken to make sure that that didn't happen again or you know that the Boston cops should have been, there should have been a clampdown. Like, there should have been an investigation. They should have weeded out whatever, you know, was going on. At least, at the very least, a cloud over, you know, their words. Their words not being good, you know, basically. But yeah, that's kind of episode two, I think, in a nutshell. And then at the end of it, what you mentioned there earlier was this woman coming forward, Rosa Sanchez. And basically, she IDs Sean. She said that she, you said correctly, saw a black man stooping outside of Mulligan's SUV outside of the Walgreens.
And then, yeah, the episode two kind of ends with her picking him out of a lineup. And again, I don't know if you remember, but it shows live footage of the lineup. I don't know why all this was recorded. That seemed really bizarre to me as well. But, you know, that there was something they started doing. Yeah, it was just it was just strange. Was it going to be on cops or something? But they actually had footage of the lineup. And there's the lawyer arguing with the police in charge, telling him he wants to move around the lineup because he believes it's raped. I don't know. Yeah, it was interesting. It's great to see. I mean, look, it's brilliant that they did record it. It's great for us to be able to see this.
in real life and not just a reenactment or whatever. Just because you didn't like the animated reenactment. I didn't. No, not at all. I didn't like the animated... I just thought they were jarring. I thought they were, you know... But then you said that they were kind of reminiscent of the kind of R&B and hip-hop and rap videos at the time. Yeah, I thought they were like... I don't know. They remind me of... Or hip-hop sort of... There's an animator. I have a book somewhere. I can't see it now for the life of me. But also Gorillaz, the band Gorillaz, that kind of band. Very like, yeah. Yeah, very like Gorillaz. I agree with you there. So I kind of liked the...
You know, I suppose it's funny because the opening music was American Irish, Dropkick Murphy, Diddley Eye, but rock. And a lot of the music was kind of hip hop, 90s hip hop, and then the style of the animation was 90s hip hop, I thought as well. So it was kind of like, it was even almost maybe a little bit of a clash between the styles of music, shows and graphics as well. I liked the style of the animation, to be honest with you. But I could see why it might put, it could jar.
you know, it's almost, you know, you're dealing with a serious subject here. And there was something quite, I don't know. I think that's why I didn't like it. And like, even if, if I remember back to the first time I watched this documentary, just go show you as well how. A, I probably watched way too much true crime documentaries, but B, how poor our attention spans have become. I thought the first episode was very slow and I nearly didn't continue on with it. And I'm delighted that I did. But I've read other reviewers' opinions off trial four and they all say the same thing, that episode one is very slow and so much so that they nearly gave up on it. And I definitely found that at the time as well. And then, you know, I didn't particularly like the animation. And then the music as well. I was just like, here, you know, it was just a bit mishy-mashy for me. But it gets better as the production goes on.
And in fairness to him, like, he's recording this over a series of years. Like, your skill set, your style, everything is going to evolve. It's very hard. You know, I think in this documentary, you do see the evolution of his style throughout it. I think it's much more crisp and sharp. And the production quality is much more in keeping with Netflix style towards the last couple of episodes. They don't, you know, do the animation so much or that kind of thing. I noticed in the last couple of episodes, instead of the animation, they do, like, I suppose what you'd see in a courtroom. You know, those kind of, I'm not sure what the correct word is, that kind of 3D.
scale reenactment thing that they do so it kind of comes up from the ground do you know what I'm talking about this is the directory to the wall and they put in all the mathematics and all they use that in the last couple of episodes instead of that kind of they keep when they're showing the shooting of Wolligan they keep using that that graphic over and over again but they do yeah I think I don't think I'd have I don't think I'd have stuck with it if I hadn't if you hadn't asked me to and then it is it's a little proper like as it goes on it's just a little bit slow like yeah yeah to begin with but then that episode then episode two kind of ends with It ends hanging on the question, as most episodes of True Crime Documentaries do, and the question is about these detectives, Sarah, Razzle, and Robinson. These are the three guys who keep finding the evidence against Sean, who keep finding the people who are IDing Sean. As you correctly said, one of them is in a relationship with Rosa Sanchez, the girl who picks him out in the lineup. Who's a key witness. And a key witness, yeah, yeah. He's won out for act. I think it was a Sarah. Don't quote me on that.
I think it was Sarah who was dating her. But yeah, that's kind of the question episode two ends on is, you know, how come these three guys are the ones finding all the evidence? And not only that, but they're actually like, this isn't their area. That's not their area. No. They're drugs. They're drugs. Yeah, they're nothing to do with homicide at all. As the lady from the Boston Globe points out, like they're in every picture, they're bringing them into court, they're standing, everything, everything's coming through them. Yeah. And she kind of explained how many cops are involved or could be involved or should be involved. You know, it's not even their department and they're just, their hands are on everything, you know. Yeah.
obviously straight away like you know everybody must be turning the blind eye yeah yeah and then look I know hindsight is 20-20 and we're watching this you know looking back and kind of going ah here how could you not have known but I guess as well in not necessarily the police's defense but maybe in the public at large's defense you know a world of social media now where we have all this information at our fingertips we can you know you've seen it in other documentaries like don't fuck with cats you can nearly be an archer sleuth now you can nearly solve a crime for the comfort of your own home without ever looking at the crime scene but like we're talking about a time when you know if you didn't hear it on the telly on the radio or seen a newspaper you didn't know about it like and that was only if you watched them or read them whereas now we're getting all this information so I guess nowadays this would seem like a much more straightforward case that you would imagine would be solved much quicker but I guess have we seen as has McAnally been introduced yet No. The big Irish boss. He hasn't been introduced yet. He hasn't been introduced yet. But again, I feel like we can kind of fly through the next couple episodes because it then goes to trial. So there's the first trial, which results in a mistrial. There's the second trial, which results in a mistrial. And then the third trial, which obviously results in his conviction. And what episode three and four are about are basically what changed between those trials. And I go into a little bit more with Rosa Sanchez and the aunt and how, I don't know if you remember, Sanchez didn't initially ID him. Do you remember that?
She ID'd another guy. They took his picture away, took her out of a room for a private chat, down to their car. This is Sarah Robinson and the other guy. Bring her outside of the station. And she comes back up to the line-up again, and this time ID's them magically. But it's just crazy. But also, there was a lot of question about whether it should have even gone to a third trial. It reminded me of the Nice Treaty here in Ireland.
They just kept going until they got the result they wanted. They kept coming back until they got the result they wanted, you know, which is blatant for everybody to see. And that's why I keep saying there's so many cover-ups, there's so many people turning a blind eye, there's so many obvious, like, why do they really want to convict this guy? Come on, alarm bells, you know? Yeah, 100%. And then, as well, they talked to Tia, who was Sean's girlfriend at the time, and she had a kid, not Sean's kid, she had her own kid, and basically she said that, you know, initially she was like, 100% Sean's innocent, there's no way he's done this. And then the police were harassing her daily, like her house was surrounded.
And then the DA at the time was super friendly and said, like, you know, Sean is criminal. He did this. He's going to hurt you. You need to side with us so we can protect you. And then they fingerprinted her. Do you remember this? They fingerprinted her. And suddenly they found the gun that was implicated in the crime and Mulligan's gun buried on this vacant lot, again by a Sarah and Robinson. And her fingerprints that had been taken a day or two before this discovery were miraculously found on the gun. None of Sean's fingerprints were found on the gun, funnily enough, but her fingerprints.
And the implication was that he hid the gun in her house or she hid it for him under a table or something like that. I was kind of a bit confused by all that. But yes, she ended up being put in a position where she was implicated in the crime as well. And did she testify against him? She did testify against him because the DA, who, like I said, was friendly, first came to her house then and point blank said to her, we can take your child if you don't pay ball. And again, she was 17. I don't think she was 18. I think she was 16 or 17.
But they were threatening to take her child away. And you'd do anything. Of course I would. You would at, you know, me at 34, I would do that. Never mind at 16, 17.
But it just shows the balance of power, you know. 100%. I'm Devin. And I'm Steph. And we are The Podcast from the Crypt. Join us every Friday as we discuss accounts of murder, mayhem, paranormal, and all things spooky. Plus a dash of comedy to help soothe your soul during these chilling tales. You can find us anywhere you listen to your favorite podcasts. Spotify, Stitcher, Apple Podcasts, etc. Also, you can find us at thepodcastfromthecrypt.buzzsprout.com And you can choose from there how you'd like to listen.
You can find us on Instagram and Facebook, both at The Podcast from The Crypt. Be sure to tune in and listen to us discuss what nightmares are made of. Let's get weird. But look, as we said, anyway, then the jury deliberate, I think they were hung after, they deliberated for like eight days or something. It was something ridiculous anyway. They were hung and then it was declared a mistrial.
Terry Patterson was found guilty and sent. And then Sean's second trial began and that was another mistrial. And they talked to a juror as well, a female juror. They talked to her on screen and they asked her why, you know, in reflection, looking back on the trial 20 odd years after the fact, why didn't you find him guilty? And she said that they all felt that something didn't add up, that there was something without. Catherine Hunt, was that her name? I think so. I think so. You're just so great for the old names. What have you? No, I just have you. And then trial three, obviously, begins.
as opposed to you know the eight day deliberation that the previous trials had this one had a three hour deliberation and John's found guilty and he sentenced men to life with no chance of parole which is again a really common thread you'll see in in true crime documentaries as well it always seems to be like with no chance of parole And it's just because they need this to not come back up again. They need this guy to go away, to stay away. Obviously, if he was up for parole, he'd be able to sort of get an attorney and defend himself. With America as well, though, I think I have said to you in our production meeting as well, they've monetized the criminal system over there.
It benefits them to always go for a life with no parole because then they have, in effect, you know, if not a slave in shackles in the deep south, a slave by another name in, you know, a justice system where they can't ever get out. And it's free labor. It's slave labor for life. So, you know, that's the long and the short. But that's, I think I was telling you before about the documentary 13th, which is about the 13th Amendment. And that's literally what it is. This amendment to the Constitution, which said slavery is illegal unless you're convicted of a crime.
That's the loophole that was put in there. And the prisons in America are run by private companies. Of course they are. Yeah, absolutely. I mean, there was an uproar there a couple of years ago when they found out that, you know, Victoria's Secret had all of their stuff made in American prisons amongst others. I mean, they were just one of the more famous names. But there's even, there's an Irish, a very famous Irish shop that maybe I won't name, that is owned by the same company that owned prisons in America, which is just very sad to see. Yeah, it is. But if this documentary shows us anything, it shows us that, you know, we're not...
We're not a bit of scandal. No, no. So this is what we kind of jump into then, I suppose, in the next couple of episodes. I think one of the episodes of the documentary is actually called that, isn't it? It's like... The Irish... Black Irish or something. Black Irish. Black Irish. Yeah, yeah. And it's kind of twofold because it's about...
obviously the dark side of the Irish immigrant cops, but it's also this new, is it TA she's going for? I think it's, yeah. Yeah, she's running for district attorney. She's black. Her dad is Irish, I think. Yeah, he's first or second generation, right? Her mother's black, yeah. Yeah, yeah. She's a powerhouse. She is. So it's kind of talking about the two of them. And then I suppose in the episode leading up to that, they're talking about, you know, obviously Sean is jailed. He's in there and they're then talking about how,
he has to there's this thing called rule of 30 so in order to get a new uh lawyer you have to fire your counsel for ineffectiveness so it's something he becomes aware of while he's in jail uh watching a show he sees rosemary talking about this guy she's representing um in a very similar situation so um rosemary being obviously his future counsel then so he sees her on this tv show while he's in jail and she's talking about this guy she's representing in a very similar type story and so sean looks into how can he get her instead of the lawyers that he currently has and the lawyers There, David and Norman, David Duncan and Norman Zalkindon, they were really, I mean, you know, you kind of look back at this stage and go, maybe they didn't do a great job, but they really tried to do a great job for him. They tried, yeah. And he liked them. And he was definitely torn about getting rid of them. Yeah, yeah, like he says that, like, it was the only option to get new counsel was to use this rule of 30 and you had to fire your counsel for ineffectiveness. And look, it doesn't seem like they held it against them because, I mean, they take part in the documentary and they speak in his favour, so they understand it was a... A procedure, wasn't it? It was a procedure for a person. Exactly. And then in that episode as well, they kind of talk about...
Rosemary's backstory, which, you know, she's from projects herself. And then she was the only one in her family to graduate high school, to go to college, get an education. And so that she said, you know, if she got an education, this is what she was going to do. She was only going to take on clients from similar backgrounds. And we should at this point look at the fact that it's the women.
So there's Rosemary, there's that lady who was running for DA, the black Irish lady. And also, if you think about his friend, I don't know if we've met Elaine yet. Oh, Elaine Murphy, his godmother. Yeah, if we talk about Tony, the reporter, it's men. The women are the ones trying to do the right thing. But you know, I never thought of it like that at all, actually. There's not one.
Rachel Rawlings. Rachel Rawlings is the black woman running for DA. That's a very good point. The men, apart from his defense attorneys and a couple of journalists, it's all the women who are trying to get to the bottom of it and trying to solve it and trying to do the right thing. She, as an attorney, she's not friends. Rosemary, she's not friends with the cops. Where you'd find that in a city like Boston, you need to be friends with the cops and these things are sort of all tied up. So it's the women that are showing the way here.
There you go. This is what's great about getting another opinion. I never even actually thought it like that, but I guess, yeah, you're right, actually. It's a fairly straight slate, isn't it? It's all the cops are guys. But it's worth noting because, you know, women aren't as easily bought or, you know, not in this case, anyway. Yeah, yeah, not in this case, definitely. But yeah, so we're introduced to Rosemary, given her backstory, and...
yeah basically like she you know as you said earlier she's kind of like why you and then she talks about meeting him and she's saying you know he's this lanky you know tall skinny you know unassuming black kid with a stutter and and she said i just didn't see i didn't see a criminal i just didn't see this is not a cold i think she said a cold killer or something yeah yeah she knew she had a good gut instinct and also but also around that time uh one of the cops i don't know uh if it was edward mcnally about, you know, these attorneys, if she gets the conviction overturned, that's a big payday for her. So it plants a seed. You're like, oh, maybe she's just in this for the money. And she seems, you know, I still wasn't, you know, there was always moments where you go, hang on a second. You know, they throw in these things where you think maybe she's only in it for the money. Maybe he's not in it. So they're quite clever that way as well.
yeah definitely I mean that's the measure of a really good true crime documentary I suppose is that every episode in the docuseries it should end on a cliffhanger or at least a very provoking question you know because then it encourages that binge watching so you're not going to leave it there you're going to keep watching to the end because you're like shit what happened so that episode then ends on Rosemary kind of looking into Mulligan and just briefly just to see whether she's actually going to even take Sean's case and just by barely scraping the surface she believes that he's a dirty cop because she finds out how they buried his finances. Do you remember that? So that's how this next episode then starts, is how literally, I think it was maybe the next day or the day after, so maybe two days after Mulligan's murder, there was a thing on the news in Boston whereby they kind of said that.
things look shady in regards to his finances that he had these Corvettes there was some other car that I'd never heard of but apparently that was a luxury car as well and he had like eight luxury condos eight properties yes suspiciously in his sister's name and valued at a dollar each or something so that's yeah but he had taken a loan out to buy them and he owed the money or something like that but she basically had that information within seconds of looking into this guy so this is what determined you know her opinion that she was going to take Sean's case she was like hang on now this is looking very suspicious how come this wasn't spoken about more in the media or brought to light and then they're talking to uh elaine murphy so elaine was this lady that it's um it's not something i've ever heard of it that's a metco and kind of what you call it it's kind of not a fostering system but whereby kids from disadvantaged areas got to go to school for um a year or maybe all of all of their young lives in a better school so they're shipped out bust out to these better predominantly white areas so sean was in this metco program and elaine murphy was the mother in his host family so i think he lived for like a year or something
I think I was in school with her son and they became really good friends. Yeah, as part of the system. But she has since then, she was living in Boston at the time. She's since moved up to Canada somewhere. And then one day out of the blue, this newspaper lands in her lap and it's Sean on the front. Some friends called in, just happened to call in on that day and they just left the newspaper on the worktop. Just like, when you think about it, it's like total coincidence, you know, a zillion to one chance of it happening. And she discovers he's in jail. Yeah, yeah, absolutely. And like, even though she hadn't.
I mean, I think he was like maybe eight, nine when she had him as, you know, when they were his host family, but she said it was just, it wasn't the Sean that she knew. And then, you know, like you said, coincidentally, some twist of fate, she's this writer. So she starts writing about it as well and doing articles about it where she is in Canada. And she kind of gives a brief synopsis into Sean's childhood then as well. I don't know if you remember, you know, about how his brother drowned. His older brother drowned and then his mother became a crack addict and then the father left. Yeah. And this is important because
At the end of the day, Sean is innocent. Spoiler alert. But even if he was guilty... And this is the thing that we do all the time, is we don't look into the reasons the person ended up the way they did. And if you see this family, it's a black family, they have to survive so much more hardship than we do. We don't have the empathy we should have towards these other people because you would look at his mother and go, she's a crack at it. It's her fault. It's what you expect. No wonder her son is in prison. There's no smoke that I'd fire there. She'll look at his mother's crack at it. And then when you look into it, you realize that her son died.
and her grief was so great that she ended up becoming addicted to drugs to deal with to try and get through life because she probably would have at that point chosen to die but she you know as a mother you need to be around for other kids you know that and that's why people self-medicate and become crack addicts and that's it's very important that you know that that's shown as well yeah that tragedy happened to that family and you know and even sean talking about his brother that he still missed to this day and he still visited and still You know, it's so tragic. And it's to look at that family's life and how they were struggling just to live. Yeah, absolutely. And then, I mean, it brings them back into that cycle then again, because he's coming from parents, you know, that aren't educated. And then he himself, he says even, he's like, you know, this happened, my brother drowned, my mother's on drugs, my father left. I graduated from high school. He said, I tried to find jobs, but nobody would hire people from his neighborhood. They'd see his address and that would just be an instant. And he said, so what can you do when you sell drugs? So you do fall into that lifestyle of, you know, your bills to pay, you have a family to support, you know.
father's gone your mother's on drugs she's not going to do he's got younger siblings he has no option it's actually in a weird way very responsible of him to start selling drugs to try and make some money you know to pay the bills and you can't blame him yeah i mean maybe not the job of choice but i mean how many 17 18 year olds have to go out after doing their leaving certain ireland and find jobs to support their younger siblings and their mom you know not not many so like you said we've seen it as an admirable thing in many ways at least also our view of the choice to sell drugs is totally different to their view of the choice you know it's not it's chalk and cheese you know we see we see black and white it's not it's not the same for those guys for people like that you know but um yeah so then like we digress but this is what happens when you start talking about these these uh true crime documentaries like you can edit all this out you can edit all this out no this is brilliant this is brilliant because this is what you want you want you're you know uh breaking down the documentary and what it made you think and what it made you feel and like i mean that's why i love documentaries they're educational in nature you know and i'm a sponge i want to know everything so nosy by nature um but yeah so rosemary decides to take on this uh case and like i said she just learns that mulligan is you know
just a bad a bad egg and and that it seems like the police are hiding information that Mulligan Sarah Robinson and Brazil were all corrupt and that they were ripping off drug dealers remember this they were like they were literally beating up small-time drug dealers taking their drugs and selling them on and taking the money that they found on them and hanging on to it or hanging on to the majority of it at least you know and depending on the amount they were seizing so you know not to rouse suspicion they'd hand in so much of it but jeez I don't know how much money they said they made over the the couple of years they were they were basically hoodwink in the system. They were running this. A lot. They earned a lot. Well, they must have if he had eight luxury condos and two, you know, twice my cars. Well, the worst thing about it was he was in debt. You know, he wasn't even a good second, you know, I mean, I was embarrassed to be Irish, you know, looking at this guy. He was a bent cop. He'd invested in flats that he couldn't afford and he was driving flash cars and working at night as security for Walgreens because that's what he was doing outside. He was like nighttime security. So he was double jobbing and he was still in debt. I was embarrassed to be Irish. And then there were scenes as well, actually, he was throwing in these, he was throwing in these overtime slips for court dates. Yes.
Do you see that? So yeah, basically, I don't know how he wouldn't be well off working as a cop in Boston. He should have been retired. The way it ran at the time, I don't know if it still does now that they realize there was this massive loophole, but they were saying at the time, the way it ran was that whether you were in court for 10 minutes or four hours, you were paid for four hours. And so what he would do, he being mulligan, would be on his day off, he'd just hop around from courtroom to courtroom. He'd show up with coffees for whenever cops were on duty, stay there for 10 minutes so that he could get paid for four hours, then drive, you know, half a mile or a mile down the road to the next courthouse and do the very same thing. They said he actually put in...
He put in so much overtime for these court cases. Half of them didn't exist. And there was more dates that he put in for overtime on than court sessions that actually took place. Yeah, there wasn't enough hours in the week for all the hours he did. Yeah, exactly. And he was still in debt. And he was still in debt. This is a stupid man. This is a stupid man, definitely. You know, when you look at the system, a cop system, they should be looking to weed out these stupid cops, not put black people in prison. Absolutely. But then it kind of gives, I suppose...
this is one of the times i did like the graphics in in this documentary actually to do um a kind of a fast forward you know it was either a montage or it's this and i like the way they've done it so it's it's quite often hard in a documentary to show the passage of time without making it look cheesy you know without like sun coming up sun goes down the ticking of clocks that kind of stuff so what they do instead is they do a very simple black screen and i don't remember this line keeps popping up with text on it um and then that'll stay up for a couple of seconds and then the next line so it first says something like you know she starts working on the case her being rose right in i think 2012 um and you know first thing she does is make a records request and then it says a year later it's denied and then she makes another request and it's like 17 months later they request that she pays them I think it's like three and a half thousand to have these records she cuts the check within five days a year later it's denied you know so straight away there's a year 17 months in a year like that's the bones of four years you know three and a half four years straight away and she's actually his lawyer for the bones of 10 years before she just gets the records requests that she
That was the first thing she did when she took on his case in 2000 and, you know, whatever. She makes this request and it's 10 years before she gets it. Like, it's insane. Yeah, I mean, like, you know, don't get locked up if you're innocent in the first place because it'll take you a hell of a long time to get out of there and because of bureaucracy and because of paperwork and because, you know, the system is slow by design, but also people, you know, there's reasons why they don't want to be, they don't want to help you, you know, because it's going, like, I mean, Mulligan is a bad cop and, you know, his friends are bad cops, but this is definitely systematic. This is definitely all the way up and down, you know, to the district attorneys, as I feel like we found out.
Yeah, I'd say as well, it's the, I don't know, whoever's in charge of the record requests being released. I mean, it's a matter of all the cops being in cahoots with each other as well. Yeah, totally, yeah. Probably golfing on the weekend and working together for the last 30 years and there's nobody going to rat anyone out. There's this, you know, you scratch my back and I'll scratch yours. It's the ultimate mafia, the cops, you know. Yeah. So finally, she gets the record requests.
I think they're for, yeah, it's for Asera and Brazel. And it's about this Robert Martin case, which I'm not going to go into too much detail, but it's basically where he's a small-time drug dealer and he's held captive in his car by Mulligan. Do you remember that? While Asera and Brazel ransack his flash, take his robes, take his money, and that's not handed in. So she finds this. So obviously this is the reason they've been withholding these record requests for the last 10 years because they knew if she got her hands on this, this is the missing key. This is evidence that this wasn't a one-off for Mulligan. He's done this before.
So they are granted a new hearing based on this. And then I kind of, I mentioned this earlier, that this is when we see Rosemary then attacking your man on the stand, Mr. Homicide. Remember this? She tears him a new one. She actually goes to the drug killer here. He's, you know, he keeps referring to Sean as Mulligan's murder and she just takes him down like she absolutely. Yeah, that guy was an asshole. He was a real asshole. Yeah. That's all I can remember from that. He was slimy. He was an asshole. He didn't tell the truth. The fact even that he's given himself the nickname Mr. Homicide says it all really, you know, he's so.
cocky in his ability to solve homicides that he you know gives himself this nickname but also you don't he doesn't care he does not care that there's a that there's another human being because we keep referring to sean as a black person but there's he does not care that there's another human being in prison innocent and this guy's innocent he does not care he doesn't even see him as a human he's just like yeah i'm just covering my own ass i don't care i actually don't like he literally did not care there was no sense of uh remorse you know you'd imagine what most people at that point would be going yeah fuck look this is like you know i've got some bad stuff you know i really want to see this guy you know at some point yeah and if rosemary says that she's like how do these people sleep at night how do they know knowing that an innocent man is in jail because they know he's innocent and how she knows that they know that he's innocent is because they clearly framed him to, I think she calls it, well, she's an analogy.
I can't remember what she calls it something to do with a lid but basically what she means is that they just wanted to put a lid on this case solve it and get shone behind bars as quickly as possible so that they didn't look into Mulligan's finances because if they did they would see that the whole lot of them were dirty and that's why those three even though the fact that they were drugs cops they were on this homicide case they wanted to make sure it was solved solved quickly so that nobody would go look and find them as well Mulligan was dead nothing could be done they were still alive they could all be still hung for this so but do we know at this stage that they had already been done for being corrupt yeah so this is this is then this is then it shows the footage of the trial and it shows the DA disclosing documents made to trial, basically. Do you remember that? And Rosemary just loses it. And it's a female judge. And the female judge is like, sir, does it not look good for the Commonwealth? You know, like, you're giving her 500 pages 10 minutes before you're going to use them as evidence to your benefit. So they, again, have to, you know, kind of go on a break from the case and to give her a chance to, you know, glance over the 500 pages. And in this, there's an anti-corruption file on Mulligan and Robinson. So basically, the anti-corruption department have been looking into them about robbing drug dealers.
And it's a single piece of paper. And there was a whole file on it. Yeah, that was never followed up on. That's it. It was just that one initial, you know, taking the evidence from the guy that they robbed and nothing was ever done about it then. And then, really interestingly, what's found then as well is that single piece of paper where a guy comes forward. He's a cop in another town, I think. But his father is a detective, Armstead, in Boston.
And he reports that a week before Mulligan was murdered, his father found out that Mulligan, and we find out through the course of the documentary, this guy has a petient for prostitutes. He's a petient for underage prostitutes, particularly. Well, you can call them prostitutes, can you? Underage victims of, you know, sex trafficking, but they're addicts. And so because he's robbing these drug dealers of their cocaine, he's then hanging on to it to curry favour with these, you know, kids. He's giving free drugs too. He's a paedophile giving free drugs. He's a paedophile, exactly. So this detective, Armstead.
gets wind of the fact that Mulligan is messing around with his 13 year old daughter and says that he knows where he does his detail outside of Walgreens and that he's going to be found shot between the eyes and then long hold a week later he is so they find this this guy coming forward going this is what my dad has told me and this statement was taken by this guy Mr Homicide and this is the scene I'm talking about Rosemary then tearing him a new one going are you telling me you didn't think this could allude Sean's innocence or not even if you don't care about his innocence it could allude to the fact that you know this is cold hard evidence there's another investigation there's another suspect at least you know which is and then that episode just kind of ends with the graphic on the screen then saying that you know Detective Armstead refused to comment and that seems to be where they've left that I guess maybe they can't say a whole lot more about it without leaving themselves open for libel but it Again, I don't want to say a whole lot about it either, but it alludes to the fact that maybe that's worth investigating, certainly, and it's probably the closest that the documentary comes to.
a satisfactory conclusion, would that be a fair affair? Yeah, it would have been a lot easier and taken a lot less time for the justice system in America to, you know, find the actual suspect and lock him up, you know? Too much shit to be covered up by the cops. Absolutely, absolutely. So look, I mean, Sean is granted bail as a result then of that hearing. He gets out. He's then working in this program called Community Heals. He's living with the minister of his mother's church. He's doing kind of TV interviews. He's studying his own case files as well and getting a kind of a very quick...
education in law he's you know it shows scenes of himself and rosemary sitting down and she's kind of going this is what we need to do and then he's interjecting with very valid points you know she's nearly teaching him uh on the job as they go yeah but it's brilliant because he like she's like i need you i need you to be to step up here you know i need you to be involved he's getting involved he's educating she does say that yeah she does she kind of says i need you on board like i need you yeah you're part of the team you know you're going to help us prove your own innocence you know like he very much felt part of he wasn't a bystander he wasn't waiting he was in control which i thought was brilliant from her because yeah i wonder how how often realistically that that happens. Like, that's quite unusual, actually, when you think about it, isn't it? Yeah, I mean, like, you know, I suppose normally you've no control, you're hoping that the other person, you know, does the right thing by it, but he was right in the middle of it. She was happy for him to be, she wanted him in the middle of it. He was very clearly an educated, or an intelligent guy, and knew his shit, and, you know, was interested, and obviously interested because he wanted to prove his own instance. So that was very nice to see that as well. And just to show, the other side of Boston, there was a very powerful, wealthy white woman, more than happy to work side by side with this black person from the wrong side, the tracks, as it were.
Yeah, yeah, absolutely. And then... The women leading the way again. The women leading the way again. Yeah, yeah. I'm kind of disappointed I didn't copy that, actually. Yeah, you're dead on there. But it then kind of jumps forward. I mean, that whole episode then is just about that, really. They go into this thing. It's neither here nor there, really, about this one-eyed Mr. C. So they're talking to this again.
a trafficked child who was a drug addict and thought that Mulligan would give her money for drugs in exchange for sex and sexual favours and she talks about like he was quite violent this is the blonde lady that they're talking to in her apartment she had a pimp didn't she she did and there was this guy yeah basically the night that Mulligan was murdered because remember in the first episode there is something about the fact that there was rumours that he was found with his pants around his ankles but like that was all cleaned up before you know they took the crime scene pictures and that but yeah this She says the night he was murdered, she was cooking coke and that she couldn't go down to him. So he was in the car at the Walgreens and was looking for her services. Yeah, some company. Some company. So she didn't go down, she was cooking coke, but she said that she would send down a girl called Bunny. And Bunny went down with this guy called One-Eyed Mr. C. And that Bunny told this, Misty, Misty was this blonde-haired lady's name actually. Bunny told Misty that One-Eyed Mr. C shot him out of him. So here's another potential.
Alternative. Yeah, yeah. And then it said that one-eyed Mr. C was murdered in 2005. So I mean, that line of inquiry just ends with that, really. And then Misty says that, like, she told all of this to the police. Yeah, yeah, yeah. The cops knew all this. There was no evidence. There was nothing. There was no transcript of her interviews. Nothing. And she didn't just do it once. Like, they interviewed her, I think, four times. I could be picking up on that number from nowhere now, but I'm nearly certain there was four times she was interviewed. And there just, there was nothing. There was no notes, no nothing. But then, yeah, so look.
the final episode like we said we said we weren't going to go through all those episodes but anyway the final episode then before the penultimate episode is where we're kind of introduced to this this Rachel Rawlings who's going for the new DA and seems to be the underdog as well because I don't know if you remember the start of that episode she's not there's the two favourites the guy who's endorsed by the police department and then there's the white lady yeah there I think it's even Rosemary who says it's one of those two when you know she'll be very surprised but she seemed to rally the black community in Boston which I mean in America we know that the black community don't vote because they don't think it's their political system so they don't get involved so she seemed to get voters that wouldn't normally go out and vote and rallied you know the people but but also it does bear mentioning i mean obviously the white guy who was who was uh being supported was endorsed by the outgoing attorney and the cops and he was there with their great white hope he was going to continue you know, he was, you know, he was going to continue things the way they were. The corruption. The corruption. Scratching each other's backs. The old boys felt like, yeah. I'm worried now about, you presume that he might continue to do things the way they were being done. Yeah. Maybe he would have changed things. But the white woman who was running, who was one of the favourites, she was very much, she was saying a lot of things that were very much about changing the system and talking about corruption and talking about, I think she talked about the Sean Ellis case at one point as well, maybe I'm wrong, but she was very much for.
it seemed to me like even if she got in she would have done a lot for the black community and made a lot of changes so there's another woman for your list of women that we're trying to change the ever expanding growing list of women yeah but so Rachel gets in then and she's the first black female district attorney in Boston at that time and she's Irish which we should say and she's yeah her dad's Irish so Rawlings Rawlings Rawlings I don't know could be oh she could be Protestant Irish Rawlings of Roscommon well the only other Rawlings I know is Rawlings but Henry Rawlings is a singer yeah but Yeah, because obviously Mulligan is an Irish corrupt to the bone. Stupid as well. Let's just not forget that. And a total narcissist. An idiot. An embarrassment to the Irish people. And thankfully we have this Rachel lady coming along to redeem us. The good name. Yeah, absolutely. In that episode as well.
there's like it like i said it's close to an episode so it's kind of wrapping everything up it really focuses on rachel's uh election i mean the one-up two and the election um and i think the first time i watched the documentary i was kind of like why is this here but you know i haven't watched it a couple of times now it's probably one of my favorite episodes um in in the series um it kind of just because it's worked it's worth mentioning that the DA in situ, like he was, he was leaving early, but he was doubling down on what the cops were saying about Sean Ellis. You know, he was, he was going, no, this guy is, he was saying publicly, no, this guy's a murderer. He killed him. You know, he was not, he was not, he was not for moving on that subject. Suddenly shit stars coming to light. He suddenly decides he's leaving the post early. Doesn't want to be around when the shit hits the fan, it seems. Yeah. And that's why it's so important who gets in next and who, you know, because.
big side not to have the four trial basically. Am I right? Yeah, no, no, you're dead right. And like, this is the episode as well. Oh, I just skipped ahead. No, you're fine. No, no, this is the episode as well where that Rosemary discovers that, again, a minor thing, they kind of gloss over it with it. But I thought it was interesting was that this reward money that was put up in the initial, do you remember this? The reward money that was put up in the initial investigation, it was put up by the Boston Police Union. But she has to fight tooth and nail to get that information. Like that is very deep. Nobody is saying, you know, she just kind of, and I mean, it's something that,
the ordinary person mightn't even think to him. You know what I mean? Like, obviously you're trying to prove Sean's innocence, but you might never think to look at, hang on now, who actually offered that reward? Because it was just this kind of anonymous reward money that was put up initially with the investigation, the initial one back in 92 or 93. And then, yeah, she goes digging, like she does, and finds that it's the union, the Boston Police Union themselves that put up. And what I liked about that episode as well is the episode where Sean starts working with the Innocence Project. Oh yes, that's right, yeah. Yeah, that's, you know, they've obviously now had their own Netflix series as well.
that that is people sean and so many like him that have these you know wrongful convictions um and i don't yeah i don't think we're i don't think we're doing any um spoilers by saying wrongful conviction i mean i think after the first two episodes it's quite obvious that this guy is like you said they do throw a curveball in here and there but it's it's just that you know yeah it's pretty obvious that he is he is innocent and that he's been set up um and yeah rachel has then voted in as the first black da and then as you rightly said your man very rushedly um announced this press conference something about the trial remember this and they're literally let know what is it an hour before the press conference is it even yeah i think your man is sean is in work rosemary rings and said look we're about to do an announcement we don't know what it is they won't tell me what it is she's ringing she's like she's like i don't know what it is and then sean has to leave work and someone drives him over to rosemary's office they don't even know what's being announced it's all cloak and dagger yeah yeah but there is a press conference and even he reassures rosemary you know you will find out i'll tell you before anyone else knows you know it's just bullshit they don't you know um but look thankfully and you know
luckily, I suppose, not even luckily, but satisfactory for the documentary makers. Sort of satisfactory. I wasn't satisfied. I wasn't satisfied, but like, I often think with these, you know, documentary makers, like, you're taking such a risk because you never know what way the case is going to go. I'm like, you can't really release a documentary without some level of satisfaction to the audience because it just gets slated. People don't like, you know, they want everything tied up in a nice little bow at the end. They want the good guy to prevail. They want, that's just, that's from fairy tales that we've been told since we were kids that we want.
a satisfying ending so you're always taking a big risk taking on a documentary and following it in real time like a case like this but the case is dismissed against Sean he doesn't get exonerated though so I know what you're saying he doesn't get exonerated you want him to go you want him to take them to trial and to prove it I have a theory about this though and I'm going to bore you with that theory but yeah my theory about this is that if you look back at the previous famous cases of wrongful conviction so you know making a murder Stephen Avery you know, the Central Park Five, they were all exonerated and they all got hefty payouts as a result because if you're exonerated, you're innocent and then you can file a counterclaim for, you know, you've ruined my life, you've put me away for whatever, 20, 25, 30 years. And I have noticed this change in the last couple of years whereby people are getting their cases dismissed or in the case of the documentary you referenced, the staircase. He went for an Alford plea. An Alford plea is whereby you're saying I'm not...
guilty but I don't want to stay in jail anymore so you don't end up with a clean criminal record but you do get released but yeah there's a lot more of this going on and they're obviously pushing back on the exoneration because it's costing them an arm you know an arm and a leg they're paying out millions to these and there's so many of them this is the thing I suppose that they're probably shitting it they're probably like fuck you know there's Stephen Avery in the you know Central Park 5 and they're actually getting you know millions between them I would imagine that there's a you know a statewide countrywide you know Word has gone out. We can't be paying out anymore. Keep these guys in prison because it comes down to money. Everything comes down to money. So there are a lot of cases being dismissed and not as many exonerations in the last number of years, I have noticed. And noticed as well since all of these true crime documentaries have become so popular. They've had their renaissance now in the last eight to ten years.
because well largely in part because of Netflix and it's streaming into your front room now and people are like I said armchair sleuths and social media and social media yeah people are an expert then yeah absolutely so like to the end of this documentary unfortunately the DA well the outgoing DA and police still maintain was him but basically they say too much time has passed to prove it and Rosemary you know kind of the closing shot on this documentary then is Rosemary saying that you know she believes the case was dropped before the new DA came in because she would expose the death of the corruption you know if there was an open case there so they wanted to shut it before Rachel Rawlings comes in because they were like shit this one is whiter than white she gets a sniff of anything corrupt she's going to take us to task like and she probably would have and so they were able to shut it all down in one fell swoop and you know they only were down one man they were only down Sean as opposed to the whole lot of them torn down I suppose and so that's it that's pretty much how you know
And Rosemary then kind of discusses whether they should take a case against the Boston police. Like I said, you know, they weigh up pros and cons and she kind of says she'd love Sean to be declared innocent and get restitution. However, she just knows the Boston police and she knows about the power if they want to put him back behind bars and start this whole process again. But also there's kind of, and this is always the worry that it's the unseen stuff. Like, you know, you won't be able to drive anywhere without getting stopped by the cops, getting parking tickets, getting, you know, all sorts, you know, harassment. Your life will be ruined. It's not worth it. And that's the sad truth. And that happens all the time as well. Yeah.
Absolutely. Something to be aware of. But yeah. What have you learned, Keith? What have you learned? What surprised you with your foray into True Crime? The Irish built America badly in some cases. We're not always good. And we should be very careful. We should be very careful, especially in Ireland, because, you know, there is a sort of a nasty racist edge to some of what you see in Ireland at the moment, especially on social media. And we need to be very careful of where that's coming from. And you have to understand that where racism comes from.
and class divide comes from and who it suits. And you have to follow the money every time. And, you know, if it seemed in this case, it was in white people's and the cops and the system's interest to have a scapegoat like the black community and to make white people afraid of the black community, because if they ever needed someone to, you know, if they ever needed a suspect to send to prison, they could just pick up a black person and nobody would question it. And that's why racism exists. It's not. Racism is not.
me not liking a black person it's us being told for generations that black people are bad by a system that wants you to think black people are bad and it wasn't black people it'd be another race because the system always needs scapegoats and that's look not that I learned that but that's it's very much in evidence here and that's what you should learn from this you know yeah 100% um I checked out the ratings this one got online like I said I read a few reviews that it got as well um predominantly favorable it got 7.3 on IMDB I got 100% on Rotten Tomatoes but to be fair that was only I think 10 or 11 uh ratings but it hasn't been the runaway success of say making a murder or say the staircase or whatever and I mean it's I think we're both in agreement it's a little banter it's a cracker of a documentary why do you think that is why do you think it hasn't been the blowout success I think it's hard to get past it's hard to get past the first episode and it's confusing in places I think it's not like the staircase was confusing but in a good way in a good way pointedly confusing yeah the Central Park Five I don't know
I don't know. I think maybe the first episode was hard to get past and in parts it was confusing. I think, and obviously, I mean, I'm not the director, I'm not a director, but I wonder if they had focused on the Irish side of things rather than, I think they could have made more of it. I think they could have named it something else. They could have named it Black Irish. Yeah, yeah. We did both say that from the get-go anyway, we didn't think, you know. I mean, really, like...
in anything the title needs to hook that needs to be the hook you know you go shit what the hell is that about like it's very elusive it doesn't really give a whole lot away and I think personally as well and I've I've touched on this on other episodes of What's Up Doc and my regular listeners will know this and that again harping back to the lack of you know, focus we have. Does our attention span become so short? This is eight parts. That is considered quite long nowadays. Like back in, you know, The Staircase, Making a Murderer, The Keepers even, they would have been the first wave of this kind of new renaissance, that true crime scene on Netflix. And they would have been all 13 episodes long. I mean, if you try and watch them now, they're painful to try and get through. They're just so long and so drawn out, which is terrible. It's terrible because this is someone's life. We're trying to watch The Trial and The Times and, you know, get all the information. But it is, it seems very long-winded now. They've kind of pushed most of their work.
nowadays, down to between three and six episodes. I do feel like eight is a bit of a stretch. Having said that, look, you know, what episode could you pull out there? If I had to throw out an idea, I'd say maybe that whole... that whole thing with the one-eyed Mr. C. That never went anywhere. Did it need to be in there? You know what I mean? Maybe they needed to put that in for balance because the record mentioned this cop and it couldn't just be seen to throw out one potential. I don't know. I don't know. Or they had decided it was going to be eight episodes and they needed to put that in there. But I wonder if that wasn't to their detriment because like I said, people's attention spans are just, you know, we're not really built for eight episodes anymore because there's so much information coming to us so fast. It's sad to say, but it's the truth. And like I said, most of the True Crime documentaries are like, you know, ones of old, 13 episodes. They've now got all the way down to between three and six. So I wonder if the fact that it's closer to that kind of...
longer style format and older style was that maybe where they lost they lost people as well because people just weren't willing to stick with them for eight episodes and or the other thing I think and again it's awful because it's on us it's not on anything to do with storytelling is that kind of genre of wrongful convictions is it just really is it oversaturated now I mean there's a lot of that kind of thing out there at the moment and I would have thought that this would have done better you know I really did particularly the year it was released in it's so timely with you know I'd love to see them I'd love to see them just do one on Boston Cops around that time. Just that. Would you recommend it? Would you recommend it to a friend? Yeah, totally. But I would say, look, you need to stick with it. And it's worth sticking with. And, you know, there'll be times where you'll drift. But, you know, I would say definitely watch it, but stick with it. Yeah. Yeah. And I think I agree with you on that one. It's probably, it's a bit more of a slow burner. But then, I mean, like we say, it's the case.
goes on over 22 years how do you break that down into three episodes six how do you break down into eight episodes like i feel sorry for the editor editing is not my my forte anyway so my sympathy is definitely i would get it but i think overall they did an excellent job i think it was a cracker and i would recommend it i don't really rate things i don't say out of 10 i'd say watch it it's um it's a nice uh easy one to watch in terms of an education as well uh into just the corruption like you said in in boston in america at large and maybe an understanding as well of where our racism inherent racism comes from as well Yeah, and I think I would recommend you watch it for that alone, you know, but unfortunately on a podcast like this, you're probably preaching to the converted, whereas, you know, you'd want, you'd like this to be shown in schools or, you know, that would be great, you know, but look it.
It is what it is. It is what it is. Heath, thanks a million for joining us today. No problem at all. Thanks for having me. Thanks for joining us for another episode of What's Up Doc, the true crime documentary podcast. If you'd like to show your support for the show, make sure to head on over to Apple Podcasts where you can rate us, you can give us a review and you can subscribe as well. We'll see you next time, guys. Good luck. Good night. God bless.