Skip to content
When a Stranger Called: Debra May Helmich & Shari Smith episode artwork

Jul 27, 2026 1 hr 3 min

When a Stranger Called: Debra May Helmich & Shari Smith

from True Crime Brewery Hosted by Jill

Lexington County, South Carolina in the 1980s was a place where doors were left unlocked, neighbors knew one another, and high school graduation marked the beginning of summer and endless possibilities. For eighteen-year-old Shari Smith, the future was wide open. Talented, outgoing, and days away from celebrating graduation, she was making plans for college, family […] The post When a Stranger Called: Debra May Helmich & Shari Smith appeared first on Tiegrabber.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

When a Stranger Called: Debra May Helmich & Shari Smith

0:00 1:03:03
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

True Crime Brewery contains disturbing content related to real-life crimes. Medical information is opinion based on facts of a crime and should not be interpreted as medical advice or treatment. Listener discretion is advised. Hi, welcome to True Crime Brewery. I'm Jill. And I'm Nick. So today we're going to go back to the 1980s, Lexington County, South Carolina. My old stomping grounds. Yep. So in the 80s, this was a place where doors were left unlocked, neighbors knew one another, and the high school graduation was marking the beginning of summer and endless possibilities for the graduates. For 18-year-old Sherry Smith, the future was really wide open. She was talented, outgoing, and just days away from celebrating her graduation. She was making plans for college, family vacations, and everything that comes with starting a new chapter in life. But then she vanished.

Join us today for When a Stranger Called. What happened to Sherry would shatter a community and launch one of the most chilling criminal investigations in South Carolina history? Mysterious phone calls? A killer who really seemed to relish control? And a family who was forced into an unimaginable nightmare. But the terror didn't end with Sherry. Just weeks later, a young girl named Deborah May Helmick disappeared. She was only nine. As investigators searched for answers, one haunting question emerged. Were these tragedies connected? And could the person responsible strike again?

In this episode, we unravel the story of two girls whose lives were stolen, the fear that gripped an entire state, and the hunt for a predator who was hiding in plain sight. So today's story is the story of Sherry Smith and Deborah May Helmick. And this is a case that South Carolina has never forgotten. Yeah, I lived down there at that time before I moved back to Maine. And I can tell you that that case had everyone in the state on alert. A tough time. Now, we do have some good beer, though. Okay. We have a table beer. In fact, that's the name of it. Table beer from Westbrook Brewing Company in Mount Pleasant. So this is a bohemian pilsner.

5% alcohol by volume. Hazy yellow. Big white head. Nice aroma. Some sweetness. A little herbal. Citrus. Has a taste of grapefruit, lemon, white bread. It's crisp and hoppy like it's supposed to be. Excellent beer. All right. Well, why don't we open some up? Okay.

Okay, so Friday, May 31st, 1985, had already been a very busy day for Sherry Smith. After hurrying through her breakfast and a brief prayer session her parents required for her and her 15-year-old brother Robert, she raced to Lexington High for graduation rehearsal at the University of South Carolina's Carolina Coliseum. So Sherry had been chosen to sing the Star-Spangled Banner, and she'd spent the morning practicing with chorus teacher Mrs. Bullock. The rest of her day was planned to be just as hectic. Graduation was only days away, and the senior class cruise to the Bahamas was coming up the following week. So lots of excitement about that trip.

That's a pretty nice class trip. I think so. I didn't have anything like that. Zero class trips. Yeah. So Sherry had always been a busy girl. She was a chorus member, a stage choir performer, a jazz band soloist, a three-year student council member, and an all-state chorus honoree. She'd also attended the Governor's School for the Arts and planned to study voice and piano at Columbia College. And she'd be following in the footsteps of her older sister, Dawn. So these blonde, blue-eyed sisters had become known locally as the Smith Sisters, performing solos and duets at Lexington Baptist Church and other churches throughout the area.

Sherry really did love to sing and perform, often practicing dance routines on the basketball court in front of the family garage. She looked forward to spending the summer performing at Carowinds Amusement Park alongside Don, who was already working there. So against the odds, Sherry had won a spot in a summer show, but then she developed vocal cord nodules and a specialist ordered complete voice rest for the two weeks and no singing for another six weeks after that. There goes the summer. Yep. So the news really devastated her and ended her summer plans before they even began. So that Friday morning, Sherry called her mother several times from school to coordinate meeting at the bank. She wanted to buy traveler's checks for her class trip. So around 1130 a.m., she asked her mom to bring a swimsuit and a towel so she'd be able to head straight to the pool party afterward, which was at her friend Dana's home down on Lake Murray. So at the bank, Sherry met up with her boyfriend, Richard Lawson, and her close friend, Brenda Boozer. Now, after getting traveler's checks, the three left for the party together. And around 230, Sherry called home to say she was heading back.

About 15 minutes later, she, Brenda, and Richard returned to the shopping center where they'd left their cars. Brenda drove off, and Sherry spent a few minutes alone with Richard before she climbed into her blue Chevy Chevette and headed home. Richard followed her for part of the drive before she turned toward Red Bank. So the Smith family lived on 20 remote acres off Platte Springs Road, which was about 10 miles outside of Lexington. Although Sherry had missed living in nearby Irmo, she had embraced this country life. She rode motorcycles with Robert, had once helped care for horses on the property, and balanced her graceful stage presence with a really tomboy-like personality.

So about 3.25 p.m. that day, Sherry turned into the family driveway and she stopped at the mailbox as she always did when she got home. Since it was only a few steps from her car, she left the engine running and didn't bother putting on her black jelly shoes before she got out of the car. The afternoon sun shined over their backyard while Bob and Hilda Smith were enjoying a quiet afternoon in their pool earlier that afternoon. And that's when the phone rang and it was their 18-year-old daughter, Sherry. She was telling them she was leaving the friend's pool party and heading home. And when the call came in, nothing seemed unusual. So the Smiths came inside shortly after so Bob could prepare for a golf outing.

An engineer, Bob had left the South Carolina Highway Department to sell electronic scoreboards and signs for Daktronics. So much of his work was done from his home office. Beyond his career, he was very involved in ministry, volunteering in prisons, and juvenile correctional facilities. So often, Sherry and her older sister Dawn would join him, sometimes singing for the inmates. Sherry's mom Hilda worked part-time as a substitute teacher, and like Bob, her faith was a big part of her life. So together, they raised their children with the priorities of religion, then family, then community. So a few minutes after Sherry called home,

Hilda happened to look out the window, and that's when she saw that Sherry's blue Chevette was parked at the beginning of the driveway. When the car didn't move after a few minutes, Hilda guessed Sherry must have received a letter from her sister Dawn, and she'd sat there to read it. Sherry really loved hearing from Dawn, and Hilda was worried that Sherry was kind of living vicariously through her big sister, since her summer plans to sing and dance at Carowinds had been canceled due to her vocal cord problem. But then about five minutes later, when the front door had not opened and Sherry had not rushed in, Bob looked out the window of his home office, and he saw that her car was still parked down by the road. So that was really odd. Hilda told him,

that Sherry was probably just sitting in the car reading a letter. But Bob thought, no, this is too long. Something's not right. So Sherry had diabetes insipidus, also known as water diabetes, that causes persistent thirst and frequent urination. So she's always in a near constant danger of dehydration. Sherry did take medicine that replaced vasopressin, the hormone that regulates fluid balance, that her body didn't produce. So one container was always in Sherry's purse, with another kept in the refrigerator at home. So if for some reason Sherry had not taken her medicine, she could pass out. So whatever the reason was, she hadn't come down the driveway yet, and Bob was worried.

So is that very common for a teenager to have that? No, it's a pretty uncommon disease. So everybody knows about diabetes mellitus. In general, yeah. And this is diabetes insipidus. It sounds insipid. Well, that's how God is named. So the sugar, the sweet urine, diabetes means blowing through in Greek. Okay. Okay. So diabetes mellitus, sugar diabetes is where your pancreas doesn't make enough insulin.

In diabetes insipidus, there's a problem with the amount of vasopressin, the hormone that regulates fluid balance. So if you're taking it, you'll be able to concentrate your urine and not lose it all. If you have DI and you're not getting medicated, you'll have to drink gallons of water because you're going to be peeing it out. Okay. So is the vasopressin like an urgent medication that would work right away? Well, it'll work right away. But what you're looking at in this situation is that if she goes a length of time without it, I think she could probably get through a day without a problem. But if they haven't given her the vasopressin or given her medication, she'll get dehydrated and can get into real trouble with that. So that's a big concern when she goes missing.

Absolutely. Serious, yeah. It's a serious concern. So Bob knew that, and he grabbed his keys and went to the garage, got in his own car, and headed down the long driveway. So you might say, gosh, couldn't he just walk down? But this was a long driveway, and he wanted to get there quickly. So a few seconds later, he reached the road, and the driver's side door of Sherry's car was open, and the motor was still running. There were some letters on the ground near the open mailbox, but no Sherry. He called out for her, but got no answer. He opened the car door, Sherry's handbag was on the passenger seat, and her shoes were on the floor.

So Bob pulled open the top of the handbag and rummaged around inside. He saw that her wallet and her medicine were still there. These are not things she would just leave. Shoes, medicine, and wallet. Very strange. In the dirt, there were bare footprints leading from the car to the mailbox. But quite ominously, there were none leading back to the car. The timing of this had to be pretty impeccable. I know, but I think he must have been following her. Had to have been. Yeah, because she was sitting for a while with her boyfriend in the car.

Then she got in her car, the boyfriend followed her, so I'm assuming her abductor followed her as well. Yeah, and he got her at the right time, but just the audacity of a guy to do that. Yes, it's a bold, risky thing to do. So then a few days later, June 3rd, Ron Walker, a member of the Behavioral Science Unit's small profiling team, appeared in John Douglas' doorway with news of a new case. Authorities were requesting help with the disappearance of teenager Sherry Smith. So Walker explained that he'd just spoken with Lewis McCarty.

the county undersheriff, and according to the information available so far, 17-year-old Sherry Smith, a high school senior, had been abducted near her mailbox at the end of her family's driveway the previous Friday. So official reports had not yet arrived, but the circumstances were very troubling. Because there's no sign that Sherry had left on her own. Her car had been found with the engine still running. Just days away from graduating, she was also planning on that senior class cruise to the Bahamas. So it's pretty definite she did not leave voluntarily. I wouldn't think so. No. Not the way the scene looked. No, it wouldn't make any sense.

So investigators believe that Sherry had stopped at the mailbox to collect the mail on her way home. Letters addressed to the family were scattered on the ground. So this suggested she may have been surprised and overpowered before she could get back to her car. When Sherry failed to come home, her dad contacted the sheriff's department. An officer responded, but investigators found no obvious fingerprints, forensic evidence, or any immediate leads. Now this might be the kind of thing a ring doorbell would have picked up nowadays. Yeah, probably. Although it was a distance from the house to the road where the mailbox was. That's true. Yeah. But we don't have any technology like that in this case.

So the sheriff organized a large-scale search that expanded over that weekend, and despite the extreme heat, there were hundreds of volunteers who joined sheriff's deputies to comb the area. Now at that stage, investigators had very little concrete information. The sheriff's office had requested that the FBI's Columbia Field Office open a case file, and the available reports and evidence were forwarded by the Behavioral Science Unit. Once investigators were convinced that Sherry had been taken against her will, the field office implemented standard kidnapping procedures. So that means agents were assigned to the Smith House, trap-and-trace wiretaps were placed on the family's phones, and surveillance teams were deployed.

So initially, authorities anticipated a ransom demand. Although these aren't wealthy people, so I'm really kind of surprised they would expect that. But instead of a ransom demand, they received something far more unsettling. So in the early hours of the morning, a phone call came into the Smith home. Sherry's mom answered and she took notes. The call really alarmed investigators enough that recording equipment was installed for all incoming calls. So although one anonymous caller demanded money over the weekend, investigators believed that that call was a hoax that was completely unrelated to her disappearance. The calls that concerned them appeared to be coming from the person responsible for taking Sherry.

Nearly three days had passed and there was no credible ransom demand. And in cases like that, the absence pointed away from any financial motive and toward a very dark possibility. The investigation was beginning to look like the work of a predator who was driven by something far more dangerous than getting some cash. Investigators realized they needed to look beyond Sherry Smith herself and really consider other motives behind this disappearance. Her dad, Bob Smith, was a respected volunteer chaplain at the Lexington County Jail. Remember, he ministered in prisons and juvenile detention centers. So detectives checked whether the abduction might have been connected to someone Bob had met through his ministry.

either as maybe revenge or resentment towards someone associated with law enforcement, or maybe even some kind of unhealthy fixation on one of his daughters. So because Sherry and her sister Dawn occasionally went with their dad and sang at these prison events, authorities had to consider the possibility that a former inmate had developed an obsession with one of the girls. The Sheriff's Office and the South Carolina Law Enforcement Division, otherwise known as SLAD, committed significant resources to this case. The investigation also focused on reconstructing Sherry's final known movement. On that Friday she disappeared, she and her boyfriend Richard Lawson had met her mother at the bank to get traveler's checks for her upcoming senior class trip to the Bahamas. Then Sherry was at a graduation pool party with friends, and then she made multiple stops around town with Richard, so there were a lot of opportunities for an unknown offender to just notice her and follow her. Investigators did theorize that the abductor may have observed her that afternoon, followed her home, and waited for a moment when she stopped at the roadside mailbox. A mysterious phone call made to the Smith family after the abduction suggested the offender knew the household's routines, though, including the family's mail delivery time.

So this reinforced the investigator's belief that the crime was more likely planned than just some random encounter. When Sherry didn't return from the mailbox, Bob immediately had sensed something was very wrong. After a brief search was unsuccessful, he told his wife Hilda, I don't know where Sherry is, but she's gone. So the couple, very religious, had prayed together before contacting authorities and had searched the area themselves. Hilda wondered whether Sherry's medical condition, the diabetes insipidus, might have caused her to leave the car unexpectedly, but there was no sign of her, so that didn't add up either.

So as officers arrived and assessed the circumstances, including Sherry's running car, abandoned purse, and her medication that was left behind, they concluded she did not leave voluntarily. Officials publicly rejected the possibility that Sherry could have been a runaway. Now at the same time, in Charlotte, North Carolina, Sherry's older sister Dawn was out shopping for a graduation gift when she heard the devastating news. Struggling to comprehend the word abducted, she called her mother and was told to pack a bag immediately as arrangements had been made to bring her back home. On the drive home, Dawn felt disbelief and fear.

Part of her thought the whole situation had to be a mistake, but there was this other part of her that worried that something terrible really had happened to her little sister. And meanwhile, news of Sherry's disappearance spread through the family. Friends and relatives were contacted, and Sherry's boyfriend Richard rushed to the house. When Dawn finally arrived, the sight of patrol cars, police officers, family friends, church members, and neighbors gathered outside the house made the reality just impossible to ignore. Inside, the family prayed as Bob reminded everyone that although they did not know where Sherry was, they believed God knew where she was.

As investigators from SLED and the Sheriff's Department worked, volunteers flooded the area to help in the search despite the intense heat. Search teams, bloodhounds, helicopters, FBI resources were brought in. A possible clue, a red bandana belonging to Shari, was found near a nearby road, and witnesses reported seeing several unfamiliar vehicles in the area around the time she disappeared. The family gained a bit of hope when the ransom demand came in, but authorities later discovered it was just a cruel hoax. As the search continued, Shari's classmates graduated without her, an empty chair at the ceremony.

represented her absence, and students, teachers, and families struggled with the realization that someone everyone loved could simply vanish. Her disappearance affected the entire community, leaving many people shocked, heartbroken, and wondering if anyone was safe. Yeah, this was a small, close-knit community, so this was very big news. Now, how far away from this were you living when this happened? Ten miles. So was it big news where you were? Ruled the newspapers and the TV. I mean, that's all you heard. So big news. It was very big news. Well, after her disappearance, the Smith home was filled with family friends and church members and police, you know, around the clock.

The emotional strain for the family was overwhelming and they found it difficult to sleep at all. Then around 2.20 a.m. on that Monday, the phone rang. Sherry's dad answered, but the caller insisted on speaking with her mother. So what do you make of that? You think he's like afraid to talk to the man of the house or something? Why would he want to talk to the mother? It seems like he could be more hurtful to her. Yeah, I didn't dwell on that too much. I think it's odd. It is. I think it tells you something about this person. Maybe a bit of a coward. I don't know. Maybe he hates women and wanted to torment the mother. That could be it too.

So at first, Hilda assumed she was talking to a law enforcement officer and reached for a pen to take notes. But once she got on the phone, she realized she was probably speaking to the person who had taken her daughter because this guy was able to describe what Sherry had been wearing and claimed the search was happening in the wrong place. He also said the family would receive a letter from Sherry in the mail the next day. So after hanging up, Hilda told the family that the caller had Sherry. But the mention of a letter gave them one small reason to have some hope because if Sherry had written it, that could be a sign that she's still alive.

Yeah, how many days are we into this? Three. Monday. She was taken on the Friday, and this happened on the Monday. I would guess that given what everybody knew, police authorities knew, she wasn't alive. What about the letter? The letter can be written anytime. Yeah, that's true.

So if you think you might like some more of our storytelling and analysis of little-known and some well-known crimes, there is an option I want to remind you of, and that option is to subscribe to our premium show by going to tiegrabber.com slash subscribe, or you can also do it on patreon.com slash tiegrabber. And once you subscribe, you can enjoy every episode with zero ads, even these ads that we do ourselves. You can stay immersed in all the sordid details without any annoying interruptions, and you can also get access to our exclusive bonus episodes, which are about some of the most fascinating and disturbing cases, and we often will kind of recap and discuss a true crime documentary. So head on over to tiegrabber.com slash subscribe and you can join the Tie Grabber community.

So this call was traced to a payphone several miles away, but by the time officers arrived, the caller was gone. The way he had handled the call suggested he was kind of organized and methodical, and definitely intent on leaving no evidence. Determined not to wait for the afternoon mail delivery, the authorities worked through the early morning hours searching incoming mail, and eventually they found an envelope addressed to the Smith family. So following really strict procedures, it was open to preserve any possible evidence. What they found inside was a letter from Sherry. Those who read it were very disturbed by its contents. For her family, this was heartbreaking, and they'd never forget it.

But the letter made it clear that this case was not a ransom kidnapping and that the situation was very dire. So in this letter, Sherry expressed deep love for her family, her boyfriend, her friends and relatives, and urged them all not to let her loss destroy their lives. Drawing strength from her faith, she encouraged them to stay close to God, support one another, and try and remember the happy times they'd shared. She apologized for any way she may have disappointed them. She thanked her family for the positive influence they'd had on her life. And she asked them not to become bitter or discouraged.

So throughout this letter, she showed her warmth, her humor, and her concern for others, leaving behind a message of love, courage, and hope for the people she cherished most. But of course, for the people that loved her, this was just awful. It's like the last will and testament. It sounds like it's a goodbye letter. Absolutely. So she must have known. So she must have known she was going to be killed, it seems like, which is just terrible. So after they got this letter, investigators examined the envelope and the contents, and handwriting experts confirmed that Sherry herself had written the letter. But a thorough forensic analysis found no fingerprints or any other identifying evidence.

Specialists even used advanced techniques to search for clues, including examining impressions that were left on the paper that might reveal information about pages written before it. But despite these efforts, the letter and the envelope provided little direct evidence about the person who was responsible for Sherry's abduction. Although the contents of the letter raised serious concerns about Sherry, her family and investigators still held on to some hope that she could be alive. So the family made a public appeal asking for her safe return, while authorities announced a reward for information and emphasized that the search would continue. So by this point, the Smith home had become the center of a massive community effort, with friends, church members, and volunteers offering support as the search operations were expanded. Then that Monday afternoon, just as everyone was trying to stay hopeful, the phone rang again at the Smith home, and the recording equipment that had been set up immediately was activated. So Sherry's sister Dawn answered. The caller immediately asked for her mother and refused to identify himself. So Dawn ended up handing the phone to Hilda. The caller began by asking whether the family had received the mail, and when Hilda confirmed that they had, he reminded her that he had correctly predicted the arrival of Sherry's letter.

So still, Hilda remained cautious and told him she needed proof that Sherry was safe. The caller wouldn't answer directly, but instead claimed that the family would know more in two or three days. So when Hilda pressed him about what he meant, he avoided explaining and instead urged her to have the search called off. Desperate for information about her daughter, Hilda shifted the conversation to Sherry's well-being. Knowing that Sherry had a medical condition requiring care, she pleaded for reassurance that her daughter was alive and being looked after. Rather than providing a clear answer, the caller continued to evade her questions, leaving the family with even more fear about Sherry's fate.

Now they traced the call to a payphone at a shopping center that Sherry had visited on the day she disappeared. And this led investigators to wonder if the kidnapper had first noticed her there and then had followed her until she arrived home. They also learned that the caller had used a device to disguise his voice, suggesting he was being careful, organized, and had put some thought into avoiding being detected. So as investigators reviewed these calls, they noticed that the caller really seemed to enjoy controlling the family's emotions. He seemed to take satisfaction in making them wait for answers, reminding them about the letter, and really keeping them uncertain about Sherry's fate.

The caller's refusal to give clear information about Sherry's condition, along with his demand that the search be stopped, really worried the investigators. They felt like he was trying to buy time, either because he was still holding Sherry or because he just wanted to delay any chance of being caught. Now, at the same time, she was deeply moved by how much the letter focused on the people Sherry loved rather than on herself. Then, later that evening, the phone rang again and Dawn rushed to answer it, trying to sound calm despite feeling a lot of anxiety, of course. So there was a closed casket request in Sherry's letter, and of course that was significant because it suggested Sherry believed she was going to die. To her family, this was really heartbreaking because it seemed to indicate she expected her body would not be viewed after her death. So her sister Dawn hoped it might be a hidden clue or some kind of coded message, but when read alongside the rest of the letter, it appeared to be part of Sherry's goodbye to her family and the people she loved, and it became one of the strongest signs that she believed she would not be coming home. By listening to the kidnapper's phone calls, investigators realized he was following the news coverage of the case.

And that was important because it meant his actions could be influenced by what he saw and heard in the media. Based on past cases, investigators knew that offenders who followed media reports often reacted to public information, which could provide opportunities for them to predict their behavior or even encourage them to reveal more about themselves. The calls also revealed key aspects of the kidnapper's personality. He really seemed to enjoy manipulating the Smith family. He liked to control the flow of information, and he liked to keep them emotionally off balance. He told them authorities were searching in the wrong place.

He hinted that Sherry might be released, like just toying with them, and suggested her condition could be serious enough to require an ambulance. Now, investigators believed he was just taking satisfaction in making the family wait for answers and just hearing how desperate they were. When another call was traced to a payphone that was several miles from the Smith home, officers rushed to that location. But once again, the caller had disappeared and had left behind no useful physical evidence, so they still were having a really hard time tracking this guy down. Over the following weeks, the abductor continued contacting the family and investigators.

The calls revealed a man who appeared to enjoy the attention generated by the case and the power he held over the victim's loved ones. Investigators came to believe he was closely following media coverage and taking satisfaction in keeping the family emotionally trapped in uncertainty. Every call was analyzed for clues, and authorities gradually built a profile of the person responsible. So just two weeks after Sherry Smith disappeared, another young victim was taken. This was June 14, 1985. It was nine-year-old Deborah May Helmick. She was playing outside near her family's mobile home with her three-year-old brother in Richland County when she was abducted. A neighbor witnessed a man talking to the children.

and saw as he lured Debra into his vehicle and drove away. But there really wasn't much time for the neighbor to act because at first he just assumed that this man knew the children. So these crimes really terrified residents in the community, especially because the search for Sherry was already dominating all the headlines. Many feared a serial predator was targeting young girls in central South Carolina, and they were right. They sure were. Debra's disappearance turned what had seemed like an isolated kidnapping into something much larger and more frightening. Investigators began looking for links between the two cases, particularly when the same man who had been calling and tormenting the Smith family

continued to make contact. The connection became undeniable when the caller provided directions that ultimately led authorities to Debra's remains. Evidence indicated that Debra, like Sherry, had been murdered shortly after her abduction. Right, so he killed these girls and then he continued to call the family, so it's a real sicko. All throughout June 1985, Sherry's family endured a nightmare as the kidnapper repeatedly called, wrote letters, and just tried to manipulate their emotions. Although he implied that Sherry was still alive, investigators eventually learned that she had likely been killed within just hours of her abduction.

After days of these haunting phone calls, the killer eventually provided directions that would lead authorities to Sherry's body, which was in a remote area of Saluda County, South Carolina. The discovery confirmed the family's worst nightmares and really transformed the investigation from a missing person case to a homicide investigation. The killer's cruelty didn't end with Sherry either. After abducting Deborah, he again inserted himself into the investigation. He contacted the Smith family and provided detailed directions to another remote location. Following those directions, authorities found Deborah's body.

Her body was in a wooded area of Lexington County. The similarities between these two crimes helped investigators solidify the link between the victims and now focus on one single offender. Of course, the discoveries of both girls' bodies were just devastating for their families and for the community, too. But they also became critical turning points in the investigation. As investigators collected evidence from the crime scenes and continued analyzing the caller's communications, they gradually did build the case that would ultimately identify and convict Larry Jean Bell. What had begun is a terrifying series of phone calls and disappearances.

was now clearly the work of a serial killer. So a serial killer is three separate murders. So they obviously think there's more. They must. What made the crime especially horrifying was that the kidnapper didn't disappear after taking her. Instead, he was repeatedly calling and writing to Sherry's family, really inserting himself into the investigation and trying to torment them. Those same actions, though, would eventually lead investigators to him. So tell me a little bit about this guy, because you said he's just a horror show. He is, or was. Larry Gene Bell was born in Alabama in 1949 and moved frequently with his family while growing up.

He later trained as an electrician, got married, and had a son before divorcing his wife. Now, before the murders, Bell had already shown a history of violence towards women. According to reports, he had been involved in several attacks and had served time in prison for one of them. By 1985, he was living in South Carolina and appeared outwardly unremarkable, making it difficult for anyone to imagine he would soon become the target of one of the state's largest manhunts. Well, Bell had been careful, but he did make one mistake that changed the course of the investigation.

Forensic document examiners subjected Sherry's handwritten letter to specialized testing, which is designed to detect impressions left on the paper from previous writing. So hidden indentations revealed part of a telephone number that had been written on another sheet from the same pad. Investigators traced that partial number to a couple who had hired Bell for work and had allowed him access to their property. So this was huge. The discovery gave investigators a direct path leading to Bell. They got additional evidence linking him to the crime and began closely examining his movements and his background.

What had been a frustrating search with thousands of possible leads now focused on this one guy. The crime shocked the state and intensified fears that a serial predator was operating in the area. So Bell once again inserted himself into the investigation by making more phone calls. He eventually provided information that led the authorities to Deborah's remains and established the connection between the two cases. So it didn't take that long, actually. It was June 27, 1985, when Larry Jean Bell was arrested. During searches connected to the investigation, they discovered evidence that further tied him to Sherry's murder.

including hairs that forensic analysts concluded were consistent with hers, and combined with the document evidence and Bell's communications with the Smith family, the case did get a lot stronger. Detectives believed Bell's own need for attention had ultimately helped expose him. If he'd simply abducted and killed his victims without contacting the families, the investigation would have been a lot more difficult. But instead, every phone call, letter, and taunt gave investigators clues that they could analyze to track him down. Yeah, he just couldn't keep himself from, I guess, bragging. Yeah, well, I'm really glad that he couldn't, because otherwise there may have been many more victims. So he did go on trial for the kidnapping and murder of Sherry Smith in 1986. Prosecutors presented evidence linking him to the abduction, the phone calls, the letter, and the discovery of Sherry's remains. Throughout the proceedings, Bell engaged in unusual and sometimes bizarre behavior.

but the evidence against him was substantial. The jury found him guilty of kidnapping and murder, and he was sentenced to death. He testified in his own defense and tried to plead insanity. He was later tried and convicted again in the murder of Deborah May Helmick. These convictions confirmed that the same man who had terrorized the Smith family had been responsible for both murders. Based on court records and reporting from the case, both Sherry Smith and Deborah May Helmick were murdered by Larry Jean Bell, but the evidence available from their autopsies differed because of the condition of their remains when they were found.

Bell would later describe to investigators and to Sherry's family how he had killed her. According to court records, he claimed he gave Sherry options for how she would die and ultimately murdered her by suffocation, using duct tape wrapped around her head after restraining her. So, I mean, really, that's horrible, especially that she knew this was happening. Now, he also provided details about the suffocation to family members during some of the taunting phone calls. Because Sherry's body wasn't found immediately, though, decomposition made it difficult to determine the exact cause of death through autopsy alone.

But Bell's detailed description of the murder was consistent with the available evidence, and suffocation did become the accepted cause of Sherry's death. Regarding whether there was sexual assault, Bell told the family he had sex with Sherry, and court records note that he described sexual activity during his calls. However, because of the condition of her remains, we couldn't find a source that was stating the autopsy conclusively proved or disproved sexual assault. So it seems like sexual assault was at least part of his motivation. Yeah. Yeah. Now, Deborah, though, just a baby, just nine years old, was abducted about two weeks after Sherry. And court records and case summaries indicate that she was also murdered by Bell after being taken from her yard. Evidence suggested that she was also suffocated. Now, as for sexual assault, several secondary sources would describe Deborah as having been raped before she was murdered.

Sources identify her death by homicide and reveal evidence that's consistent with suffocation. So he took both of these young girls, raped them. God knows what he did to them, right? Probably some kind of torture. I don't want to think about that. Yeah, I know. It's just horrible. But he murdered them, and that wasn't good enough. He had to torment the families. So he was convicted, sentenced, and then after years of appeals, he remained on death row. Then in 1996, 11 years after the murders, he was executed in South Carolina. So relatively speaking, it was pretty quick. Although I guess South Carolina is one of those states that really doesn't mess around.

Now, his convictions brought legal closure to two of the state's most notorious murder cases, but the losses suffered by the Smith and Helmick families will never be undone. The case remains notable not only because of the brutality of these crimes, but because of his obsession with controlling and tormenting the victim's family. Now, his desire to remain involved in the investigation did give authorities the clues they needed, though, so absolutely helped in identifying, arresting, and convicting him. No question about it. So the surviving family members of both Sherry Smith and Deborah May Helmick played really important roles in keeping their memories alive and in helping to tell the story of the case. At the time of her abduction, Sherry was living with her parents, Bob and Hilda, and her younger brother, Robert. Her older sister, Dawn, was attending college in Charlotte, North Carolina, when she got the news that Sherry had been kidnapped.

Throughout the ordeal, the Smith family became the public face of this investigation, because the killer was repeatedly contacting them. Sherry's sister Dawn was often drawn into these conversations with the killer, and she would later speak publicly about the experience and its lasting impact on her and her family. The Smiths relied heavily on their Christian faith during the weeks after Sherry's disappearance, and then throughout the trials that followed. The family's pain was really compounded by the killer's deliberate attempts to manipulate their emotions. Now despite this, they remained deeply involved in the search, and later in the prosecution of Bell.

And in the years that followed, both Dawn and Robert participated in interviews and documentaries to honor their sister's memory and to educate others about the case. Deborah May Helmick was only nine years old and, of course, lived with her parents and her younger brother when she was abducted. On the day she was abducted, she and her three-year-old brother were playing outside of their family's trailer home. A neighbor witnessed a man approach the children and take Deborah, and the younger brother was one of the last people to see her alive. Now, unlike the Smith family, who were thrust into the public spotlight because of the killer's repeated contacts, the Helmick family got a lot less attention. But of course, their loss was just as devastating. Deborah's parents endured the sudden disappearance and murder of their young daughter while watching the investigation unfold alongside the highly publicized search for Sherry. So her case became a critical part of the evidence used to convict Bell and to demonstrate that he was a serial offender and responsible for multiple abductions and murders. So together, the Smith and Helmick families endured one of the most terrifying criminal cases in the history of South Carolina.

Their perseverance through the investigation and the trials helped to ensure that Bell was held accountable for the murders of both girls. But besides the murders of Sherry Smith and Deborah May Helmick, Bell has long been suspected in several other cases involving missing and murdered women. So for many years, Bell was considered the primary suspect in the 1984 disappearance of 26-year-old Sandy Cornett from Charlotte, North Carolina. Cornett vanished after arriving home one evening and never showed up for work the next day. Bell knew people in her social circle, and he was investigated at the time, but never charged. Then, in 2025, after a new review of the case, the Charlotte-Mecklenburg Police Department officially concluded that Bell had kidnapped and had murdered Cornett.

and stated that he would have been charged had he still been alive, but they'd already given him the death penalty. And her remains have never been found. Bell, though, has also been considered a suspect in the 1975 disappearance of 21-year-old Denise Newsome Porch. She was a young apartment manager in Charlotte, so Denise disappeared while showing an apartment to a prospective renter, and she was never seen again. I really think a lot about showing apartments and houses, people working in realty, especially women. It just seems really risky. I think a lot of times now they bring someone with them. I was going to say.

Our realtor didn't when we moved to Las Cruces. I mean, it was the two of us, but you never know. I mean, the woman could be bad too. We've seen many cases like that. So it just seems really risky.

So she was showing an apartment to a prospective renter, and investigators noted that Bell lived nearby at the time. And also, she resembled some of Bell's other victims. Although he was investigated at the time, he wasn't charged, and that case remains unsolved. Over the years, investigators and crime researchers have really examined Bell as a possible suspect in additional disappearances. And that's because of his history of targeting women and girls, also his mobility between North and South Carolina, and the similarities between several unsolved cases. But the evidence linking him to those cases has been insufficient for formal charges.

So no other murders were proven in court beyond those of Sherry Smith and Deborah May Helmick. Although they are certain of that third murder, even though he wasn't alive to be prosecuted for that one. But they're pretty sure that he's got more victims out there. Oh, yeah. I mean, they really see a connection and they feel like this isn't something that someone just starts doing one day in the middle of adulthood. There was something wrong with this guy going way back. He might have been. Well, he was. He was a handful as a child, right?

Seemed to be, yeah. Just a disturbed human being. So you go along and you get older. You're capable of coming up with these ideas of kidnapping and harming them. Yeah, I think it starts with fantasies about it. And this was early in the time of criminal profiling. So this was kind of groundbreaking as far as that goes. And really connecting these calls and his behavior with the kind of person that would do this. In addition to him just kind of giving himself away, thank God. Thank God he did that.

Well, you start out doing little things, and as you go along, the crimes get worse and worse. That seems to be the way. With Ted Bundy, at first he was a peeping Tom, you know, and then he liked to kind of just scare girls when he was young. And then the animal abuse and animal killings, just working his way up to a full-blown psychopath, one of the most violent, prolific killers ever. OK, well, that's just a sad one. Yes, it is. But thank God for criminal profiling and the fact that they can discover these things. It's dreadful for the families of the victims. But we also have to think that some abductions and murders were prevented. We have to think that way. And I think it's true that they were. It's time for listener feedback.

Okay, so what do we have for feedback? You want to start with our first email? They're all emails today. All emails today. So this is from Lindsay. I love your podcast. Your soothing voices, streamlined storytelling, and a human touch of your occasional disagreements have gotten me through multiple 14-hour drives and countless DIY projects. Thanks, Lindsay. I'm ready to recommend a case from my hometown of Crystal Lake, Illinois, and that's the tragic April 2019 murder of five-year-old A.J. Freund. I know many shows avoid cases with young children, but I believe your empathy and medical expertise make you the perfect voices to do this.

story justice. I'm thinking, okay, this isn't going to go well. Well, none of them go well. It's a true crime podcast. None of them go well, Dickie. This is worse than that. Well, yes, this is worse. This is actually a domestic violence, child abuse case, which is really difficult. The night he died, AJ was beaten, forced to stay in an ice-cold shower and lock in his room alone. He died from an intracranial bleed. His parents wrapped his body in plastic, hid it in a suitcase, and buried him in a shallow grave seven miles away.

Then they go on TV to plead for his return, claiming that he was a runaway. Yeah, these kind of things are just above and beyond that anyone would do this to their own child, let alone any child. These are some of the worst things that there are. You're right about that. The investigation timelines revealed really horrific details and a sharp contrast in how the siblings were treated, which we see a lot, which is just one sibling who's really picked out of the bunch and gets the most abuse. The mother in this case was an addict who brought this child to drug pickups while he had the flu, and his father, a lawyer, enabled her.

Yet AJ's older brother had already been removed from the home, and his younger brother showed zero signs of abuse. So it seems like poor AJ bore the brunt of the abuse. Now, as in many cases we've seen, DCFS ignored countless calls, claiming they were overloaded. And as of 2026, the parents are serving 30 plus years in prison. Also, the ex-DCFS caseworker was convicted, and that's very unusual. So a heartbreaking story, but she would still like us to tell it. And Lindsay says, thank you for your thoughtful dedication. Even if I sometimes have to remind myself, these aren't actual bedtime stories. Thank you, Lindsay.

So we will consider it, although Dick's not enthused. Well, I'm enthused about the case. Well, it's horrific, yes. But let's look into it, see if there's anything we can add to the story. Yeah. Yeah. Okay, our next email is from Denise, and Denise writes, I'd like to request a review of the case of Charles Frederick Albright, also known as the Texas Eyeball Killer, who was active in Dallas in the late 1980s and the early 1990s. The case has disturbing forensic elements and unresolved questions that would make for a very compelling analysis. So you looked that up. What did you find out? I'd never heard of this.

It's new to us. The title, Texas Eyeball Killer. It really brings to mind some graphic images. Yeah. Anyway, he was active with his killings in the Dallas area from 1988 to 1991 and known as the Eyeball Killer for obvious reasons. And what are the obvious reasons? He would take their eyeballs, cut their eyeballs out. Ooh, what would he do with them? Don't know that. So he would remove the eyeballs of his victims? Yes. Okay. After they were dead. So he didn't want them looking at him? There's some psychology there that I don't know. That's right. Right. So he was convicted of one murder and he was charged with three others. But once he was convicted, the other three murders were dropped.

Due to a lack of evidence. Well, how could there be a lack of evidence? How many people are taking eyeballs? You know, we should look some more into that because that's interesting. Well, he's still considered the prime suspect in those cases. Yeah, but he died in 2020, right? So it looks like he was just found insane and was not in prison, but in a psychiatric hospital in Lubbock.

Until he died. Yeah. He never got out of the psych unit. Well, he probably shouldn't have. That's probably a good thing. Yeah. Okay. So I have another email from Doug in Los Angeles. And Doug writes, Hi, Jill and Dick. I love the podcast and would like to suggest the case of Jason Sweeney, who was murdered in 2003. Three teenagers were convicted of first degree murder in Philadelphia for bludgeoning a friend to death for $500, money they used for a drug binge. So this sounds like one of those stories that's really going to just be hard to believe, shameless. And then the idea of the betrayal really gets to me. So Jason Sweeney was only 16.

and he was lured to his death by a girl who promised him sex, prosecutors said. When he got to a secluded spot near the Delaware River, he was ambushed by the three guys with a hatchet, a hammer, and a large rock. So, Dominic Coya, 19, his brother Nicholas, 18, and Edward Batzig, Jr., 18, are serving mandatory sentences of life in prison. Before Jason was killed, the 16-year-old seemed happy and he was excited about his life. He'd recently started dating a girl named Justina Morley and told his mother, Dawn Sweeney, that he really liked her and wanted her to meet his family. So she's the one that lured him out for the murder.

It was the night of May 30th, 2003, and Justina Morley lured Jason to a wooded area known as the Trails near the Delaware River in Philadelphia by promising to have sex with him. Instead, he was brutally attacked and beaten to death. Now, according to police and prosecutors, the main motive was money. 500 bucks. I guess people have been killed for a lot less, though. It's terrible. And if the main motive was money, they sure didn't pick a good victim. Well, I guess. I mean, sometimes when you're a teenager, $500 is a lot of money. I certainly wouldn't justify any of this, though.

Investigators allege that the four teenagers did plan the attack in advance, which is just diabolical and horrible. They killed Jason and stole his paycheck. Then after they killed him, they split the $500 paycheck and spent the money on drugs. The suspects were also accused of discussing and planning the attack for at least a week before they carried it out. So of course, this case drew widespread attention because of the extreme violence involved and because one of the accused was supposed to be Jason's girlfriend who he really cared about and another was supposed to be his best friend. So there's no way that Jason could have predicted or avoided this really. How would you ever think this would happen? You wouldn't.

Okay, and I have one more email from Maura J in Boulder, Colorado. Hey, Jill and Dickey, I have a case for you. Crystal Klug was a 44-year-old chemical engineer and mother of three from Broomfield, Colorado, who was murdered on December 14, 2023. In the months before her death, she reported being stalked and harassed by someone she believed was a former boyfriend. She'd received threatening messages, emails, and other communications that scared her and led her to keep detailed records of this harassment. So when Crystal was found dead in her garage, investigators initially focused on this alleged stalker. But the investigation revealed a shocking twist. Prosecutors allege that her husband, Daniel Krug, had been impersonating the former boyfriend and orchestrating the harassment campaign himself.

Authorities said he used fake accounts, burner phones, and other methods to create the false impression that an outside person had been threatening the family. According to prosecutors, Daniel Krug murdered his wife as their marriage was falling apart, and then he attempted to mislead investigators. But obviously he planned this ahead of time, right? Oh, absolutely. Now he was arrested, charged, and later convicted of first-degree murder, stalking, and criminal impersonation. The cases received national attention because of the elaborate deception that preceded the killing and the devastating impact that it had on Crystal's family and three children. She had three kids.

And this was the person who was supposed to love her. Yeah. So Maura says, I know you will be able to shed new light on this case as you all are so good with shocking domestic situations. Well, I guess it's from our experience. We have our shocking domestic situation here. What do you think? But our shocking situation is the shock of three dogs, a very loud house, not murder. Thank God. Okay. One more Dickie, right? Why don't you read this one? Suzy. Email from Suzy. I hope you're both well and having a good week. I'm a big fan of your True Crime Brewery podcast and have been for several years. Thank you both for all the work you do.

I'm from the UK and wonder if you would consider covering the UK case of Jessica Patel in a podcast episode. It's such a sad case. It has really touched me and I feel so sad for Jessica and her family. Thank you both again. I love your podcast. So who is this Jessica Patel? Well, she was a 34-year-old pharmacist from Middlesbrough, England, who was found dead in her home after what was initially reported as a burglary gone wrong. Now we know how that goes because investigators soon uncovered evidence that the scene had been staged. So the investigation revealed that Jessica had been murdered by her husband, Mitesh Patel.

Prosecutors stated that he had carefully planned this crime, then attempted to disguise it as an intruder attack. So it's kind of similar to the previous one, right? So digital evidence, including data from mobile devices, helped expose inconsistencies in his account of events. During the trial, the court heard that Jessica had been looking forward to building a future, and she hoped to start a family. The judge described her as someone who loved her husband and just wanted a normal family life. In December of 2018, Mitesh Patel was convicted of her murder and sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum of 30 years.

So remembering Jessica with empathy means recognizing that she was far more than the circumstances of her death. She was a daughter, a sister, a friend, and a professional who was deeply valued by those around her. This case remains a tragic example of how devastating domestic abuse and betrayal can be. And it's prompted discussions about identifying warning signs and really improving support for victims. So the motive was that Mitesh wanted to leave his marriage and start a new life with a boyfriend in Australia. So we think he was a closeted gay man and for some reason just couldn't come forward.

I don't know why. I think it was a combination of that and the money, of course. Yeah, two million pounds. Yeah. Okay, so prosecutors said he engaged in relationships with men and he wanted to relocate, which is fine, but why do you have to do this? The court also heard that he stood to receive the two million pounds from life insurance policies after Jessica's death. Prosecutors believed he intended to use that money to fund starting pretty much a new life.

It's also documented that Jessica and Mitesh Patel had undergone IVF treatment and that frozen embryos were being stored for future implantation before Jessica was killed. So there's been a lot of media and true crime discussions that make claims about these embryos being part of his plans. Maybe he wanted to go with his boyfriend, but he wanted to be able to use these embryos, which of course were from his sperm, to start a family with his boyfriend. But that's not verified. I'm not sure on the legalities of that. I would think if your spouse dies, the embryos are yours. Yeah, someone's property. Right. So if you and your spouse...

Freeze embryos for future use and your spouse dies. The embryos are yours, which is a bit controversial because that means even if there wasn't a murder, he would make all the decisions about the embryos. Although on the other hand, when you leave your kids behind, the spouse has all the control of the kids. So I guess in that way, it really isn't that odd. It's just the laws with those things are pretty interesting to delve into. Okay, well, that's all I have for feedback today. And it was a good batch of feedback. I have to say, thanks guys. Really appreciate that. I love the feedback. And I definitely always keep these cases in a little notebook so that...

When I'm looking to make the schedule of new cases, which I do like three or four months in advance, I'll make the schedule. The first thing I do is I look through the feedback. So if there's a case you really want covered, please send us an email or even better a voicemail. But I think a lot of our listeners are too shy for the voicemail. They're much more generous with the emails for sure. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Well, thank you for the feedback. Thank you for listening. We really do appreciate everyone. We hope you're doing well and we'll see you next time at the quiet end. Come on down. Yeah. Bye-bye. Bye guys.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of True Crime Brewery?

This episode is 1 hour and 3 minutes long.

When was this True Crime Brewery episode published?

This episode was published on July 27, 2026.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this True Crime Brewery episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.