Skip to content
When Do Protests Actually Work? — with Erica Chenoweth episode artwork

Apr 9, 2026 43 min

When Do Protests Actually Work? — with Erica Chenoweth

from The Prof G Pod with Scott Galloway Hosted by Vox Media Podcast Network

Erica Chenoweth, political scientist and professor at Harvard’s Kennedy School, joins Scott Galloway to break down what actually makes protest movements succeed. They discuss why most movements fail, the four factors that drive real change, and why mass mobilization alone isn’t enough. They also unpack the “3.5% rule,” the role of business and institutional power, and whether economic resistance can be more effective than taking to the streets. Also, friendly reminder that we're live on Substack. Subscribe at profgmedia.com to get ad-free versions of all our podcasts, the full archive of Scott’s newsletters, and exclusive content including deep dives, livestream conversations, and subscriber Q&As.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

When Do Protests Actually Work? — with Erica Chenoweth

0:00 43:35
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

With Fin, we've built a number one AI agent for customer service. It solves up to 90% of queries for businesses, tops all the performance benchmarks on the G2 leaderboards, and it comes with a million dollar guarantee. Check it out at Fin.AI. Support for the show comes from Odo.

Running a business is hard enough, so why make it harder with a dozen different apps that don't talk to each other? Introducing Odo. It's the only business software you'll ever need. It's an all-in-one fully integrated platform that makes your work easier.

CRM, accounting, inventory, e-commerce and more. In the best part, Odo replaces multiple expensive platforms for a fraction of the cost. That's why over thousands of businesses have made the switch. So why not you?

Try Odo for free at odo.com. That's O-D-O-O.com. We all have to drink water. And staying hydrated is one of the simplest ways to feel your best.

But come on. How is your relationship with water really? Are you getting enough from it? Is it satisfying you?

Or is drinking it becoming a chore? Here's a tip to spice things up. Hint water. With delectable flavors like watermelon, Georgia peach, even lemon zest freeze, hint is water that will make you desire water.

No sugar, no sweeteners, no calories. It just goes to show. Sometimes the right hydration partner changes everything. Try Hint.

Available at drinkhint.com and in stores nationwide. Episode 391, 391 Broadway is a historic building located in New York City True Story. When I first moved to New York, my best friend Lee introduced me to a bunch of Broadway dancers. And I dated a racquet and I went to meet her in Chicago when she was on tour for the Christmas spectacular.

Came into her room where there was a little person cutting lines on the ass of a dancer. True story. No joke, true story. Welcome to the 391st episode of the Prof.

G pod. Didn't see that coming, did you? Didn't see that coming. What's happening in today's episode?

We speak with Erica Chenoweth, a political scientist and professor at Harvard's Kennedy School, whose research focuses on political violence, civil resistance and social movements. Professor Chenoweth is widely known for their work on the effectiveness of nonviolent protests, something we've spoken a lot about. We've even quoted their work many times in our newsletter, No Mercy No Mouse, specifically on the topic of resistance unsubscribe. Anyways, with that, here's our conversation with Erica Chenoweth.

Professor, where does this podcast find you? I'm in Cambridge today. All right, let's let's write into it. You spent your career studying how nonviolent movements succeed or fail.

And we've cited your work in our newsletter several times. We even launched our own economic resistance campaign earlier this year, but I want to make sure, well, I'd love your insight. How would you describe what your research actually says in your own words? I think the most relevant research here is about what is it that makes movements more likely to succeed or fail.

And I think the sort of synthesis I would offer from a huge range of research studies on this, my own and others, is that there are really four things that make movements more likely to succeed than others. The first is very large and diverse participation that builds momentum. The second is the ability to leverage that participation into creating defections within the opponents' pillars of support, whether those are the sort of political institutions, the social and cultural institutions, security forces, the business and economically that uphold, you know, a sort of authoritarian status quo, if you will. The third is the ability to shift between methods of protest, to methods of non-cooperation, like your campaign, and methods of alternative institutions are building mutual aid networks and things along those lines.

And then the fourth is the ability to maintain resilience and discipline, even as repression against the movement escalates. And the movements that do those things well tend to succeed more often than the movements that struggle with one or more of those four factors. Where do you think most movements get wrong because my sense is becoming just a sophomore student in this recently and listening to you and Timothy Snyder and some other people, is that the vast majority fail. Which of the four hurdles do you think trips people up most often?

I think getting defections is the hardest. In a study that I did with Zoe Marks and Andrew Hawking, we did a sort of computational study that ran three different types of strategies. The first is the mass mobilization strategies just get as many people in the streets as possible, as quickly as possible, and hope for the best with regard to pillars defecting. The second strategy was what we call the naive pillar strategy, which is protest in a way that's trying to get those defections, but you don't know in advance which pillars are most likely to defect.

You just go to the nearest one and protest and hope for the best. And then the third strategy is what we call an informed pillar strategy. And that's where the activists have some advanced information about which of the pillars are already kind of on the fence, and they focus on those first. And that then creates early defections in the movement that can create a cascade of defections.

And that third strategy is by far the most likely to succeed in the least amount of time. And the first strategy, the mass mobilization strategies, get as many people in the streets as quickly as possible, and hope that the pillars defect is the least likely to succeed. And so I think part of it is just it's actually very challenging both to build a strategy that creates defections and to understand how to do that in a way that creates the cascade of defections, not just an occasional defection here or there, because they happen to push the right button one day. So using those four criteria evaluate the No Kings protests?

Yeah, so I mean, my sense is that the No Kings protests, and by this, let's just talk about the national days of protest, right? Which is not all that it is, but the protest themselves. I mean, we are seeing growth in numbers over time. We're seeing a diverse range of people from all walks of life coming out and participating in those protests.

You could argue it's building momentum in the sense that there are lots of protests that happen between those very large scale days of action. For example, my team at the Crowd County Consortium documented that June 26 actually had the third most protest events in a month in the entire first and second Trump administrations. And that was largely in reaction to ICE in Minneapolis, and the killings that happened there. But that just speaks to the fact that the pace of protest and the pace of protest mobilization is quite high and increasing over time, even between these big days of protest.

And then when it comes to defections, I think that there are kind of cases where we see that happening and there are cases where we don't and where you'd otherwise expect them to happen. And I think that's a pretty natural thing to expect at this stage of a movement, which is to say the mobilization against autocratic consolidation in the US has been going on now for the entirety of the second Trump administration. But the average movement takes about two and a half years or three years to run its course in creating the defections cascades that are necessary to bring about a pro-democratic outcome. And so I think it's sort of on pace, but still with a way to go.

And then when it comes to diversity, we're sort of a broader range of methods of protest. So it's clear that the large scale days of action are important in both bringing in new participants to the movement and in encouraging existing and new participants about the power of their collective action. The key here is like channeling it into political power through encouraging people then to meet in their communities to build more community-based organizations, to channel it into electoral power, to potentially channel it into methods of non-cooperation and other strategies of dissent. And then the last thing I'll note is I think it probably is one of the most disciplined movements we've seen in recent years in terms of the ability to not overreact to provocations and to maintain basically non-violent discipline, even as repression has been escalating in a way that signals that the movement is both prepared for that repression and that when that repression happens, the movement can respond to it in a way that shifts the balance of power rather than sort of succumbing to potential disarray or in discipline.

Yeah, that really struck me. Nine million people. And I have yet to see any reports of any type of violence or civil disobedience. Any thoughts on one of the criteria was that the participants in the protests are from a diverse group.

My understanding is these protests, no kings. And by the way, I find them inspiring and I don't mean to, I don't mean in any way to be critical of them, but people have brought up to notion they seem to be, the participants seem to be older and wider. Any thoughts on their ability or the importance of reaching across different demographic groups to make this more effective? It really depends on where it's happening for one thing.

So I think that the people who have actually done surveys and demographic counts in those surveys have noted from some of the big cities that they've seen this kind of that demographic description that you just gave. But there were probably over 3,000 events that happened on Saturday, many of them in places that have never seen a protest in the last generation, many of them. A lot of rural towns, right? They're mostly Republican.

Exactly. And I think really, there's also kind of a convergence, I would say in some places where ICE operations have been very intense, that has drawn in a lot of younger people and people from different walks of life into the movement. And so I actually think this last note, kings saw the convergence of, you know, it was probably more demographically diverse than the prior, in part because of how many streams of opposition and resistance are kind of emerging in those big days of action. Clearly, like the more people from the more walks of life who take part, the more powerful movement will be.

And it's often the case that movements, you know, different formations appeal to different demographics. And the more those formations come together, the more powerful they will be in ensuring up the capacities of those different segments of society. I wonder, I'll just before the thesis, I'm literally flying on instruments here, but I wonder if some of it is that younger Americans, the most recent protests, Black Lives Matter and the Women's March, which were inspiring, but I'm not sure those groups felt like they registered a lot of change. Whereas older Americans still remember the protests, the Vietnam protests, civil rights protests, or at least learned about them in school, which had a huge impact.

I wonder if it's just one group says, this is where it's my Saturday and another group is maybe a little bit more cynical. You could be onto something in some cases. I would just note that there's some interesting research out there that shows that, for example, the Women's March of 2017 was the participation in women's marches, just in that single day, had a really powerful predictive effect on the diversity of candidates that ran in the midterm elections in 2018. And the blue wave that came in 2018 flipping Congress to be a Democratic Congress, they can show a strong correlation between the numbers of people who participated on that day and the outcome of that election.

And the same is true for the 2020 election, actually, that large participation in Black Lives Matter protests in the summer of 2020 were also correlated with outcomes in the presidential election results and in shifts in public opinion and in changes that were substantive around, for example, progressive attorneys general or DAs being elevated in local and state elections. So I think that there are reasons to be skeptical, but also those types of stories aren't necessarily very prominent out there in the world. And I think it can be really important to elevate the ways that even a single day of protest can have those types of electoral impacts, saying for the Tea Party, the Tea Party protests, there was a paper by economists that showed that it was powerfully correlated with the 2010 midterm election result, right? So people shouldn't underestimate how important it is and they shouldn't overestimate how important it is compared to the other things that also lead mass movements to succeed.

Yeah, so one of these is an observation if the connection between inspiring candidates and people to turn out to the voting booth and at a minimum, this creates infrastructure and makes you more invested in outcomes, right? It sounds as if, if this holds and I'm saying the reason why I wouldn't, it's going to be a very ugly November for Republicans. Yeah, I mean, if the pattern obtains in this case, then we would expect a loss in the midterms. Now, I also think that none of these models have predictive power, right?

So lots of things can be different, but I think the, yes, if what we saw in 2017 and 2018 tracks in this case, then we would expect in a normal election year and under normal circumstances to see a similar outcome in the 2026 midterm. We'll be right back after a quick break. Support for the show comes from BetterHelp. May is Mental Health Awareness Month, a reminder that whatever you're going through, you don't have to go through it alone.

Here's the thing, no one's journey through life is totally smooth. Ups and downs are baked into this thing, and it's easy to feel like you have to figure it all out on your own, but the truth is, no one person has all of the answers and a lot of them you have to find internally. That's why therapy works. You can give therapy a try with BetterHelp.

With over 30,000 therapists, BetterHelp is the world's largest online therapy platform. They've served over 6 million people globally. They do the initial match of refuse, so you can focus on your therapy goals. Just fill out a short questionnaire that identifies your needs and preferences.

BetterHelp has more than 12 years of experience in industry leading match of film and rate, which means they typically get it right the first time. But for whatever reason, if you want to switch therapists, you can do that at any time from their tailored wrecks. You don't have to be on this journey alone. Find support and have someone with you in therapy.

Sign up and get 10% off at BetterHelp.com. That's B-E-T-T-E-R-H-E-L-P.com. Prove G. Support for the show comes from NetSuite.

Every business is asking the same question. How do we make AI work for us? The possibilities are overwhelming. But sitting on the sidelines is not an option, since you know your competitors are already making their move.

No more waiting. With NetSuite by Oracle, you can put AI to work today. NetSuite is a top rated AI cloud ERP trusted by over 43,000 businesses. It's a unified suite that brings your financials, inventory commerce, HR, and CRM into a single source of truth.

Now, with NetSuite AI Connector, you can use the AI of your choice to connect to your actual business data and ask every question you ever had. From key customers to cash on hand to inventory transplus, you can automate those tires and manual processes. Let's see your competitor do that. This isn't another bolted on tool.

It's AI built into the system that runs your business. Whether your company runs millions or even hundreds of millions, NetSuite helps you stay ahead of the pack. If your revenues are released in the seven figures, get our free business guide to mrfyingai.com.com.com.com.com. The guide is free to you at NetSuite.com.com.com.com.

NetSuite.com.com. Support for the show comes from Odo. Running a business is hard enough. So why make it harder with a dozen different apps that don't talk to each other?

Introducing Odo. It's the only business software you'll ever need. It's an all-in-one fully integrated platform that makes your work easier. CRM, accounting, inventory, commerce, and more.

And the best part? Odo replaces multiple expensive platforms for a fraction of the cost. That's why over thousands of businesses have made the switch. So why not you?

Try Odo for free at Odo.com. That's Odo.com. The other question I have for you is I keep hearing this 3.5% number. And that is, if you get to this 3.5% hurdle, and I think it's 300,000,000 people to say that would be a 12.25 million, I think, if I'm doing my math correctly, somewhere in there, right?

12 plus million. That's when you see real change. That's when the government can't ignore it. Where did that number come from?

And it strikes me that my understanding is the no-kinks road test went from 7 million to 9 million. So it's building momentum. It's no way fizzling out. And why is it we need to get to 12 and a quarter million?

Do you buy that 3.5% number? Where did it come from? Yeah. I was in the past movements between 1900 and 2006.

And it came from a conversation I was having with an activist, actually, who asked me if there was some kind of critical threshold above which no movement had failed in terms of mass participation. And so this was after a study that Maria Stef and I did. Our book had come out, and I was doing some workshops and talks about it. And so just looked at the data and then found that observation that among the campaigns that we had documented and for which we had kind of peak participation estimates, none of the campaigns that had moved above that 3.5% national population threshold had failed.

So I think the things to know about that are, first of all, is historical observation, not a prediction. Second of all, as you know, historical observations are always just that. They're not also prescriptive, which is the sense that if we try to aim for 3.5%, knowing that that's the target, are we doing something different than what people did historically when they didn't know about that kind of threshold and wouldn't have been trying to game it as it were. And then the third piece is that there have been, since that period, exceptions to the rule, which is to say, like Bahrain, for example, had its own attempted Arab awakening in 2011 that fizzled out fully by 2014.

And in that case, it looks like during their peak moment, they had about 6% of the population mobilized in their sort of central area. And that ended up failing. And one of the reasons that it was defeated is important and instructive. It was defeated because there were no defections.

And there were no defections because in that case, the monarchy decided not to send its own troops out to repress and got help from Saudi Arabia to do it. And that is a really important technique of preventing defections that we've then seen happen elsewhere. And the logic is that if there are fewer kind of social connections between the security forces and for people protesting, that there will be less hesitation and brutality toward the protesters. That's just something that has been an adaptation on the side of pretty persistent authoritarian regimes at this point and kind of taking the wind out of the sales of these movements, even when they get very large.

And it's something that we should know is just that there have been adaptations on the government side and that movements shouldn't take for granted that if they hit a historical threshold that the same effects will naturally attain without other types of strategy and organization building and leadership. So granted, it's probably harder to get more granular data, but the protest in Iran, a different complexion, much more complex, more severe, whatever the term is. What are your observations? What do you think of media is getting wrong about the protests today in Iran?

I guess I have two observations about it. I mean, first of all, the repression that took place against the civilian population there, massacres that took place are some of the worst we've seen since first year of the Syrian revolution in 2011 and 2012. You know, one of the things that I remember happening at that point is that after the U.S. extracted Maduro and brought him to the United States, there was strong and powerful signaling by the United States that Iran would be next.

And that coincided with a period of improvised protests in response to basically economic concerns, like a currency crisis and other things that people were reacting to on the ground. And then when it sounded like there was going to be some kind of external intervention, from what I understand, there was a sense of now or never among many of the protesters who were aware of that. And it allowed for or even enabled more risky action than the otherwise would have taken. And then the fact that the U.S.

didn't actually intervene at that time or do a similar operation, as it were, you know, just kind of speaks to the very tricky global dynamics of these things. And the, as I say, moral hazard problem of signaling different types of international support when none is necessarily forthcoming and that the people on the ground paid the price, I think. And there are some similar dynamics with that and the Syrian revolution, in fact. I remember in those days, there were people who were exiles from Syria or, you know, had recently departed from there, trying to lobby, you know, foreign governments to intervene the way that they had intervened in Libya.

And there was a sense that was almost inevitable that it was going to happen in Syria. And more risky action was taken as a result of that in a way. So I think that's really very tricky. The second observation I would have is that what happens on the ground in Iran is so hard because there is not really a formal opposition or opposition groups that have the capacity to even connect with one another, much less organized strategic mass movement.

Or spoke to people. Isn't that key to our resistance that you have, spokespeople that people are rallying around? Spokespeople for sure, but also just strategy, right? Like thinking about beyond just going to the streets and trying to amass large shows of force, but also like how to tap into the different sources of weakness in the government and begin to, you know, chip away at loyalties.

Like those types of things are really important and necessary, particularly against an authoritarian regime as durable and as formidable as the Iranian regime. And so what organizational capacity does exist is outside the country, right? So you have people who are sort of more recent departures from Iran, from say the reform era, who have more ties to people on the ground, but fewer kind of resources to help mobilize. And then you have people from the previous era, like the previous Iranian revolution, many of whom are kind of organizing around the crown prince and the like.

And so even the external opposition is quite divided. And those who are rallying around, resuppulavi, like don't have nearly as much legitimacy on the ground as the more recent departures, but they don't have the capacity that he has in the resources. So it's just a very, very tricky situation that I think helps to illuminate a lot of the fact that when people rise up anymore, it's not just against their own government. Like they're in this sort of global environment that's changing very quickly, and it's creating very challenging terrain.

And Admiral James Stavridus on who was the NATO Supreme Allied Commander, and he said something obvious, but insightful. And that is the shock troops, kind of the Marines of the protest, the ones who are most aggressive and quite frankly willing to give up their lives. And they did. There was 30,000 of them and they're dead now.

And that kind of the timing was just wrong, right? That you wanted to want to support from America or perhaps military action before those 30,000 people took to the streets. And there's going to be a limited supply of people who are willing to give their lives for a movement like this. I have been shocked at the lack of resistance and the lack of protest amongst corporate leaders.

I'm convinced that 500, 400, 500 leaders, 490 of them wake up in the morning, look in the mirror and say hello, madam or Mr. President. I think they're all waiting to be drafted to run for president. And I have been, the silence is deafening.

And whatever your politics are, I think there's a very solid argument that what is going on right now is not good for business at a very capitalist level. And there has been crickets. Have you done any research on the importance of, I go back to Weimar Germany when a lot of the industrial captains of industry in Germany stay quiet or kind of bit of deal with Hitler, if you will. But any parallels or any historical references around the lack of protest or resistance from the corporate world in your studies?

So this is a really important issue. It's not my primary area, but what I'll say is, if you think about cases like South Africa, for example, this is a case where clearly the linchpin and the sustainability of apartheid ended up being the corporate and business elite. And that was a case where the security forces were never going to defect to the sort of United Democratic front and the black opposition. But the sort of implication of that was that if the security force pillar is not available, then what about the business and economic elites that are polling via apartheid state?

And so that is the way that apartheid ultimately fell was by a variety of economic actions, whether those were boycotts of white-owned businesses, whether they were ultimately multinational corporations pulling out of the country, whether it was strikes and work stoppages combined with massive protests and marches. Like that is ultimately what pressured the business class to pressure the national party, which was the pro-partite party to elect a reformer and to clerk when they had the opportunity to do so. And when he came to power in the national party, he immediately pushed through legislation on the ANC and start negotiations. And they found a path to a democratic transition without a civil war in a country that looked like it was on the path to either continue to, you know, military garrison state with the white supremacist government or it was on the path to civil war.

And so they found that way. And it was because of the pressure put on the business community to change what they viewed as their own interests and in the stakes. And so I think the business and economic community is so important. And as you mentioned, there are other cases of you know, autocratic breakthrough moments where, you know, if big business has had acted a different way, it probably would have created huge amounts of friction.

And instead they didn't. And so it didn't. We'll be right back. Support for the show comes from Harvey AI.

The future of law is a gentic, not just tools that assist, but AI agents that navigate complex matters. That's why Harvey created agents that can do the work from end to end. They build a plan, pull from secure data sources, run subagents in parallel, and draft the work product ready for your review. So you delegate the work and own the judgment.

Trusted by more than 60% of the Amlaw 100 and leading Fortune 500 legal teams, Harvey is the AI operating system designed specifically for legal work. Harvey, AI, tailored for law. Learn more at harvey.ai. AI is moving fast across the enterprise.

Without visibility, it's just chaos. Different tools, different models, different teams using AI in completely different ways. ServiceNow turns that chaos into control. With the AI control tower, you see all your AI across the business in one place.

What it's doing, what it's done, and what it's about to do. So you stay in control. To put AI to work for people, visit servicenow.com. We're back with more from Professor Erica Chenoweth.

So do you think we constantly as a term, there's a difference between being right and being effective. And the note King's protests are both. But I'll put forward a thesis or a question and obviously it's a loaded question because I advise here, what would be more effective? The protests of 9 million people or potentially 9 million people stopping all spending and not going into work for a week?

I'm going to give it totally unsatisfying responses. It depends on the context, which is to say. There's some nuance there. I think it depends on the durability of it.

And actually how much cost is imposed. I also think that imposing cost is not the only way to to change behavior. So there are other ways to change behavior in negotiating. Inducements, trying to get, sometimes an oppositional approach or an adversarial approach like that is necessary to demonstrate what can happen or what the consequences are of inaction or complicity.

And sometimes there's low hanging fruit and just finding a way to identify shared interest and then go with that is another way. There's a study out by one of my colleagues, Jonathan Pinkney, who together, I think with another author who was talking about methods of inducing defections, in particularly, I think, for the business community, they were saying that sometimes more private behind the scenes, quiet organizing and persuasion work is going to go a longer way than public adversarial approaches. Now, there's always going to be a range of interests and where different businesses and corporations place themselves on that spectrum. And the ones that are the most tightly aligned with an authoritarian or aspiring authoritarian regime are going to be the hardest to get at.

But others who are a little bit further just trying to stay out of the fray or whatever, those are the ones to think about focusing on first. And then the more adversarial approaches, then can be applied to those who are further along in the authoritarian direction. So I think that's an intriguing proposition. And it hasn't been fully tested in the US case, I think, but is an interesting way to think about it.

It's an interesting insight. And again, it's kind of hiding in plain sight. But the thing about the No King's Protests is they are very positive, they have a really nice field of them. You bring your kids, you, the signs are funny, you feel a sense of citizenship, camaraderie.

They are very positive. And I think it's hard to be critical of them. They just look like good people doing good things. Imagine there's a large swath of the population that is really upset by the administration's activities.

And they believe that action absorbs anxiety and they want to do something. And they all got together and elected a board of directors and said, all right, who do we reach out to to organize the next big form of resistance or protest? And I said, okay, we're going to reach out to Professor Chenoweth. And you are given the ability to organize a protest or a form of resistance to shape it and say, this is, this is, I want to be focused on effectiveness, whether it's getting a mass secret police out of cities or changing our policies on immigrants, whatever it might be.

But if you were given, if you were, if you will, CEO of this thing, and you got to shape it, what elements would be incorporated? What would it look like? Do you mean on the infrastructure side around the tactical and strategic side? Yes.

Okay. If it's on the infrastructure side, it's an interesting question about what capacities are needed right now and at what scale. And I think that my argument would be that in other cases where we've seen successful democratic U-turns state place, usually there's been some kind of umbrella formation, like the United Democratic Front and South Africa, or like its comparison in Chile under Pinochet, or more recently in South Korea, there was sort of a United Alliance. And I would argue that we need some kind of umbrella formation that's giving shape to what already exists in the US, which is a huge number of ingredients for what makes for a successful democracy movement.

And I think that in terms of the capacities needed, there's clearly the sort of mobilization capacity that exists already, but then also kind of an ability to communicate broadly about what's happening in a way that brings common knowledge to the population at large about what's going on and what they should know about it and what they might do about it. Like I said earlier, I think what we're seeing right now in the US is consistent with what we've seen in a lot of different successful democracy movements, in part because there has been such robust training infrastructure set up for things like observing ICE operations. And because of that, the killings of Renee Good and Alex Pretti backfired. It's only because cameras were rolling and people were observing because they knew how to do that and they knew how to get the information out that those stories ended up being the sort of official narrative about those stories ended up being contested in the first place, right?

And then there's training in nonviolent discipline, there's training in non-cooperation, like all of those things are happening. There's so many people around the country in organizations trying to support that work. And I think that's part of why we've seen it play out the way it has. So I think in terms of, it's hard to focus on more than the sort of four things that I mentioned that successful movements do.

And so I think those things are happening. So I guess this is all to say, I wouldn't really suggest that much is different in the country, except what I mentioned about a sort of broader umbrella formation helping to make it more than the sum of its parts. You brought up something that I hadn't thought of before that I think is an outstanding example that we don't talk enough about. Can you talk about what went down in South Korea?

So the really abbreviated version of this is that last December there was an attempted coup by the incumbent president. And while it was underway, meaning after he declared martial law and was enacting the coup, there was a huge umbrella formation largely represented by trade federation and unions that came out and said, by declaring martial law, you have declared the end of your presidency. And we're going to bring the country to an orderly standstill tomorrow morning if this thing goes down. And they were able to bring thousands of people to within minutes of the declaration of martial law also to a nonviolent protest outside of the main government building.

And by the morning had made such a credible commitment to being able to shut down the country that the people who were doing the coup blinked basically like the senior military kind of hesitated and said they didn't think they would go along with it. And the president had to basically cancel the martial law order and effectively try to cancel the coup. And then, you know, by the next day, the trade unions and the sort of pro-democracy movement had come out and said, we're really glad the coup has ended. But that's not enough.

Like, you tried to have a coup and so you're going to be impeached. And they launched impeachment proceedings after one failed attempt because the ruling party tried to get around a quorum rule. So that they didn't have to show up and actually participate in the impeachment proceedings. The movement basically demanded that they show up and vote and they did and the president was impeached.

And then he tried to appeal it. He lost the appeal in the Supreme Court. Like, he's out and going to be held accountable for it. So that's the way both a successful movement works and how to stop a coup and prevent it from happening again.

I think the one of the things that's so powerful about the example is that they could credibly commit that they could bring the country to an orderly standstill. That's why it worked. And so I think the deterrent impact that they were able to have was profound. And it's just a lesson to learn, I think.

This is such fascinating material. Just for a lot of young people listening to podcasts, how did you stumble on or was this more deliberate? How did you stumble upon this domain? It was actually when I was finishing my PhD in political science that I was invited to apply to go to a workshop on how to teach about nonviolent resistance.

And this was a topic I had never learned about, had not encountered in my research. I studied terrorism and political violence exclusively at that time. And so I wanted to go to the workshop to put it on my CV and draw my network and get free books and learn how to teach this topic. And I just thought that the material was very interesting.

But I noticed that there hadn't really been a quantitative treatment of the question about whether nonviolent resistance was actually a realistic alternative to violence in different difficult settings. Like in settings where we would typically expect people to use armed conflict to promote their agenda. And so my colleague Maria Stefan and I, who I met there, decided to team up and do such a study. And so that's what led to our 2011 book on which is called Why Civil Resistance Works.

And in that book, we start with the descriptive observation that the nonviolent mass campaigns that we studied from 1900 to 2006 had a higher success rate than the violent campaigns that we studied. And we set about trying to understand why that was the case. And so the book sort of has two parts. The front is trying to understand the strategic advantages of nonviolent resistance.

And the second half of the book is trying to explain why some movements succeed while others fail. And there's been then a very large literature that's emerged on this topic, which has both been critical and reinforcing of the findings depending on what they are. And as I mentioned, I think there's this sort of consensus now 16 or so years later about the things that make movements more likely to succeed. And so that's the four things I mentioned.

Eric, China with a political scientist and professor at Harvard Kennedy School, whose research focuses on political violence, civil resistance, and social movements. Professor Chenoweth joins us from Cambridge. Professor, I just, such a nice moment for you, unfortunately, under not great circumstances. But it's just, it's rewarding to see people who have devoted their life or their professional life.

They've becoming an expert in something that feels fairly germane at the time. And then all of a sudden becomes incredibly important and relevant. So congratulations on your good work and what has well earned prestige and attention and relevance right now. So it's weird to say a nice moment for you, but an important moment for you.

And thanks for all your good work. Thanks to you. And thanks for the opportunity to share with your listeners as well. This episode was produced by Jennifer Sanchez and Laura Janer.

Cammy Rieke is our social producer, Bianca Rosario Ramirez is our video editor, and Drew Burrows is our technical director. Thank you for listening to the PropG pod from PropG Media. Support for the show comes from Odeo. Running a business is hard enough.

So why make it harder with a dozen different apps that don't talk to each other? Introducing Odeo. It's the only business software you'll ever need. It's an all-in-one fully integrated platform that makes your work easier.

CRM, accounting, inventory, commerce and more. And the best part? Odeo replaces multiple expensive platforms for a fraction of the cost. That's why over thousands of businesses have made the switch.

So why not you? Try Odeo for free at Odeo.com. That's Odeo.com Support for the show comes from Odeo. Running a business is hard enough.

So why make it harder with a dozen different apps that don't talk to each other? Introducing Odeo. It's the only business software you'll ever need. It's an all-in-one fully integrated platform that makes your work easier.

CRM, accounting, inventory, commerce and more. And the best part? Odeo replaces multiple expensive platforms for a fraction of the cost. That's why over thousands of businesses have made the switch.

So why not you? Try Odeo for free at Odeo.com. That's Odeo.com.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of The Prof G Pod with Scott Galloway?

This episode is 43 minutes long.

When was this The Prof G Pod with Scott Galloway episode published?

This episode was published on April 9, 2026.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this The Prof G Pod with Scott Galloway episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.