From that first copy of the day to driving off your dry cleaving on the way from stepping onto the subway to opening your doors to your first customer of the day We're here to power you along the way Manneris powering Canadian commerce visit us at manneris comms slash commerce in the days after October 7th President Joe Biden tried to help Americans touch the size of Israel's horror and its grief By trying to translate it into the terms of our own tragedies since this terrorist attack took place We've seen it described as Israel's 9-11 For nation the size of Israel was like 15 9-11 Imagine what that level of trauma would do to us Imagine what that level of loss would do to us We are almost two years on the death toll in Gaza is now estimated to be over 61,000 people There are a little over two million dozens The leaders in the US government are not spending time trying to help Americans grapple with the scale of their grief of their loss But that would be for our population like 2,500 9-11s I know there are many who want to cast a doubt on that death toll We're told that it's from the Hamas run Ministry of Health and that's true But look when the Lancet the medical journal tried to fill in the gaps in the data by adding in new sources They concluded that the true number the real death toll was far higher Gaza is a strip of territory about the size of Detroit, Michigan Since October 7th Israel has dropped more than a hundred thousand tons of explosives on this tiny sliver of land that is more tonnage of explosives It was dropped on Dresden Hamburg and London combined during World War II Aerial photography shows just absolute devastation It's estimated that 70% of all structures in Gaza every home every hospital every mosque every school are severely damaged or completely destroyed You cannot drop that many bombs on such a densely populated strip of land without mass casualties You just cannot But it is not just the casualties Israel has also been restricting the flow of food into Gaza Eight organizations have been warning all along of growing hunger of the possibility of famine Then in March Israel located in Gaza for 11 weeks Then it largely ended the existing aid infrastructure that you wanted built and replaced the hundreds of operating sites of aid distribution with four sites Four run by inexperienced American contractors famine is now spreading across Gaza people are dying of hunger The images and the videos and the stories here not just of the starving but of the people of the children They're bowls out begging for help lining up to get food hundreds having been killed at these aid distribution sites It is beyond what I have the capacity to imagine What would it be like to not be able to find food for my children to not be able to feed them To have them lose their mother or their uncle or me because we went to get food for them The idea that this is made up that it is a concoction of Hamas or anyone else just just listen to the aid workers who have been there People have been hungry for months. We are seeing this is starvation is why this is now a day famine is unfolding It's not pending anymore. It's happening people are starving to death as we speak children are starving to death as we speak And I want to be really really clear. This is not a drought situation This is entirely preventable famine that we are witnessing in front of us The parents are riding on the social media and they are thanking God for the loss of their children Who have been killed in a certain time of the world because of the bombardment or the invasion They are thanking God that they have lost their children for not to reach this stage while their children are asking them to feed them And they didn't have any capacity and any ways to just for the needs of their children So this is this is beyond description and even unimaginable And if it really isn't that bad if this is all just propaganda Israel could prove that easily let reporters in let independent inspectors in but they won't do that because this is not a trick Because it is not just propaganda.
This is hunger as a policy hunger as a weapon of war. This is a siege Almost two years after October 7. What is the point of this siege? Is it to break what is left of Hamas?
What is left of Hamas a group of about 600 ex-Israeli security officers including former heads of Assad and shin bet Release the letter saying the quote it is our professional judgment the Hamas no longer poses a strategic threat to Israel Is a point of this to get the hostages back? This is endangering the hostages They are being starved alongside the gossons the main group in Israel representing the families of the hostages said quote net yahoo Is leading Israel and the hostages to doom Is a point of this to make Hamas capitulate? I threatened to starve thousands or tens of thousands of gossons to death to malnourish and stunt The generation of children that is illegal under any conception of international law What is this? This is a war crime.
This is a crime against humanity But more and more people are using another word a word that I've stayed away from on the show Genocide is this a genocide In December of 2023 when sav africa accused israel of genocide before the international court of justice I thought they were wrong to do so israel had been attacked its self-defense was legitimate The blood here was on hamas's hands is there was doing what any country in the world would have done in response But over the last year I've watched a slew of organizations and scholars come to the view that whatever this began as it has become genocidal Amnesty international that's the limb human rights watch Melanie O'Brien the president of the international association of genocide scholars Amos goldberg professor of holocaust history at the Hebrew university of Jerusalem the list here could go on and on But one reason I have stayed away from the word is that there's an imprecision at its heart When people use the word genocide, I think they imagined something like the holocaust the attempted extermination of an entire people But the legal definition of genocide what it means in international court encompasses much more than that At the same time the word genocide has the power it does because it is rooted in the holocaust To accuse israel to accuse any state or group of genocide is to tie them in cultural memory to the worst acts human beings have ever committed If israel becomes widely seen not just as the state born of genocide But as the state that then perpetrated one it will forever transform the meaning of the jewish state So again, what is a genocide and is this one? Felipe sands is a lawyer who specializes in genocide cases. He has tried genocide cases. He is trying one now He teaches on these questions at harvard law school and university college london And he's the author of among other books east west street Which is about how the idea of genocide was developed and written in international law So sands is really the best possible guide to the hardest possible topic He joins me now Felipe sands welcome to the show very good to be with you So I wanted to begin in the story you tell in east west street Which is a remarkable book and particularly the the person who creates the word and ultimately the legal concept of genocide rafael lemkin Tell me about them born at the turn of the 19th and 20th century in A territory small hamlet is now in bellarus grows up loves his mother who sings him songs about mass killings in the past the Romans killing the christians and so on and so forth There are pograms in parts of russia that he hears about goes university in the city of the distibale of eve in ukraine Studies with a Polish professor of criminal law and in the early 1930s as a public prosecutor Starts thinking about how the law international law can protect human beings from mass atrocity and he focuses on the protection of groups He starts with ideas about barbarism and vandalism and he wants to come up with a way to change the world of international law and to be able to Come up with a concept which allows people to say you cannot treat groups of human beings in this way He begins thinking about this set of questions before what we would think of as the holocaust begins What is in his head?
What are the influences of the historical moments that begin to set him on this path His own recordings of the path that he took are complex and I noticed in research on the prone to exaggeration or sometimes even invention But it does seem that the crucial factor that influenced him was a case in Berlin in 1921 the killing of a Turkish military guy who was alleged to have been involved in the massacre of the Armenian population And he describes a conversation with his law professor who I think was a man a Polish professor called jewellism at graverch Why is the man who killed the Turkish guy an Armenian called it allerian? Why is he being prosecuted for killing the person who killed his family in hundreds of thousands of Armenians and the professor says to him because under international law As a citizen, you're no different from a chicken You're the property of your country of your ruler if they want to kill you They're perfectly free to do it And that is the moment apparently when he starts to think about another conception of the protection of human beings from their own governments in their own states The other thing threaded through this book threaded through the debates we're going to talk about here Is the existence of international law as a shelter as a protection As a shield for people who do not have a state that can protect them right either They are at the mercy of their own state or they are part of a state too weak And it's not an accident these ideas are developed by jewish lawyers during and then after the holocaust But there's something here about not just the way in which you could be the property of the state But what does it mean to not have a state that can protect you do not have a state that can advocate for you You've got a wind back all the way to the 1910s and the 1920s It was a very different world people didn't even have passports but people could move freely between countries The idea of nationality was often defined not by your statehood but by your religion or your race It was a very different world, but it was different in this way also until 1945 a state was basically free to treat Anyone subject to its jurisdiction As it wished there were no restrictions. There was nothing called human rights law under international law The only international crimes were in relation to war crimes There was no such things crimes against humanity or genocide these things were invented in 1945 for the famous in euroburg trial And the ideas that came to fruition then basically said for the first time it's a revolutionary moment The freedom of the state is not absolute the emperor doesn't have absolute power the king doesn't have absolute power Tell me what lemkin spends the war working on Lemkin has a remarkable escape from Poland. He's there on the face of september 1939 when Germany launches an attack on Poland and starts what is under the second world war And then makes his way up through Latvia and eventually to Sweden And then he procures an invitation from Duke University Law School to be a visiting professor And he makes his way the long way through the Soviet Union across Japan across the seattle of Chicago down to north carolina He travels from europe to the United States with no personal luggage and no money He's completely broke But he travels with a lot of luggage full of pieces of paper because he's been collecting all the decrees passed by the Nazis across occupied europe And there in north carolina He receives a commission from the Carnegie foundation to write a book on what he has seen in occupied europe And whilst he's at Duke he starts assessing what he's seen and he identifies a pattern of behavior In other words, he looks at restrictions on jobs restrictions on work restrictions on living And sees a pattern which is to eliminate an entire group or groups because actually he focuses not just on Jews But also on Roma and on others and he calls that concept genocide So I want to hold you on what you just said for a minute because I think this is important for this whole debate today We are talking there before much of what we think of as the holocaust of the final solution of the industrial extermination when he's looking at those degrees And I think we now think of genocide colloquially not necessarily legally as industrial slaughter His definition includes something that can happen before slaughter, which is this Kettling constraining displacement destruction exclusion of a group to sort of change their role into society Tell me a bit about that distinction that idea maybe of what genocide is meant for him to describe if it is describing something that was happening before What we now think of as the holocaust sure that's exactly right.
He's very methodical in looking at the preparatory work He goes through the idea of firstly identifying People by reference to their affiliation to a particular group then restrictions on educational restrictions on the use of language restrictions on housing Then they've got to live in a particular place. Then they can't do certain jobs Then they've got to be gathered together in certain places then they're sent to camps then they're sent to another place and then eventually they are killed But for him The entire process is a genocidal process So you don't wait until the ninth step the actual act of killing human beings are in type of protections And there are basically two ideas that emerge at exactly the same moment raffael lemkin Invents the concept of genocide, which is focused on the protection of groups And then his counterpart who he never actually meets her from now to pat who studied amazingly at the same law school Comes up with a different conception crimes against humanity Which is focusing on the protection of individual human beings and is juxtaposition of tension between the protection of the individual and the protection of the group Has gone on ever since 1945 and interestingly Lao to pat was always opposed to the concept of genocide He worried that the concept of genocide focusing on the protection of groups by reason of ethnicity religion race nationality Whatever it may be would replace what he considered to be the tyranny of the state the power of the state with the tyranny of the groups the power of the group Lentin rejects that argument and says people don't get killed or attacked or targeted because their individual qualities or what they've done as an individual They're targeted because they're a member of a group that is hated at a particular moment in time in place And therefore if you want to protect human beings focus on the group not the individual so for for london is Genocide the way of just describing crimes violence that is committed against groups for being groups that he just felt we didn't have a Category that described when the motivation is the destruction or antagonism towards a group and as such you have not just all the way up to the maximum Of crimes, you know mass slaughter the extermination but down to these other crimes that are bodily harm and That he just simply creating a category of group violence To understand what lemkin was hoping to achieve you've got to go back to the 1930s and imagine the world as it existed at that point And at that point Domestic laws and international laws offered no protection to human beings Simply because they were a member of a group usually a minority group that was targeted at a particular moment in time in place And so I think the operating principle of lemkins idea is that that needs to change We need to firstly recognize that groups have identities that are culturally significant and important and secondly We want to protect the diversity of groups in our communities and in order to do that We need a law to help us a law at the national level Isn't enough because the state can then just change its law And so what we really want to do and paraphrase in here is create an international law which says States every state has an obligation to safeguard look after and protect different groups within its community and cannot undermine their existence Cannot threaten them. He said that are low but the essential idea is to put group identity onto the agenda of international law Which it was not in the 1930s and it was not until 1945 when that idea finally came to fruition Tell me a bit about loud about he's the other main character of your book He's a more central figure to governments more respected figure in his time than then lemkin What is his path? He's a very different kind of a character Um, I'm often asked if I were to have dinner with one of them, which would I choose?
I think lemkin would probably be the more entertaining character in terms of the anecdotes and the stories Loud about was much more scholarly much more restrained in his views He came from a more middle-class family loud about grew up with books and ideas In the city of leviv mostly in what is today, Ukraine and he moved into an academic direction He becomes professor of international Cambridge university and when the war begins his family moves to america And he is introduced by phoenix frankfurter justice at supreme court to robert jaxon And he works with jaxon on the arguments to allow the united states to enter the second world war and get around the arguments from neutrality And then he works with jaxon on the creation of the statute of the new mbo tridunal And his fundamental interest in life is the belief that every human being has minimum rights under international law He's one of the parents of others the idea of international human rights law And he draws this from the u.s constitution the french constitution english common law and practice from around the world And so he is focused not on them inside which he opposes on the protection of groups but on individual you have rights as recline Not because you are a member of xy or z group, but because you are an individual human being Both lemkin and lata back spend the war primarily in the united states And in in lata backscades in the uk what happens to their families And the point of connection between them and the point of connection with my own family my grandfathers They all were connected to city of viv and all three men my grandfather lem bachal sesh lata pakt and rathalenkin lost their entire families and What I have found so striking about their story is that despite the fact that this has happened and they only learn about this after the war Has come to an end they are then remarkably retained respectively by the British and american prosecutors to assist at the new mr Burgh trial and lata back focus on crimes against humanity lemkin focuses on genocide They both prosecute without realizing The man who is responsible for the murder of their families And uncle hence frank who had been at office personal lawyer and it's only halfway through the trial that they learn that the man they're prosecuting Is responsible for the deaths of their families their siblings their parents their cousins their nephews I mean dozens and dozens of people and it's very very poignant that even in the midst of such horror Neither of these two individuals remarkable different individuals Curl down sat in a corner and wept instead of this and uh We need to think about ideas when you think about ways of stopping these kinds of horrors and they came up with their respective Different and actually in conflict ideas and that I you know in difficult times that we're living in right now I find rather inspiring Tell me about the the number trials. How do they come about what distinguishes them from what came before? So this is the first time in human history that the leaders of a nation are put on trial for international crimes before an international court It has never happened before so in 43 44 the idea emerges what do we do with Nazi leaders church? He'll ensure we'd like to line them up and shoot them Roosevelt and Stalin say no we're gonna put on a trial They obviously have different motivations as to what that trial should be about But they then agree that three leaders at yelter that they will be for the first time in international military trial They don't have to deal with the leaders and they have a problem They've got no crimes to charge them with the only crime that exists at the time is something called war crimes Which doesn't govern the totality of what's happened and that was pretty limited in terms of its scope What it basically did was said how you attack your enemy in times of war is limited You have to distinguish between combatants and noncombatants and so on and so forth So they basically invent three new crimes Lauterbacks idea was to take war crimes further with something called crimes against humanity Which would not be limited only to the protection of people in times of war But at all times and which focused on protecting individuals from attack in different ways Lauterbacks crimes against humanity is inserted into the statute the crime of aggression by doing illegal war newly invented in 45 Is inserted to the statute lincoln is devastated There is no inclusion in the statute of the kind of genocide But he then flies to London just before the trial begins and persuades Robert Jackson and the Americans to include genocide as a subhead of war crimes And so it is included so on the opening days of the trial For the first time the prosecutors from the UK France the Soviet Union and Robert Jackson is the chief prosecutor a Supreme Court justice on leave Make arguments about war crimes crimes against humanity and the crime of aggression now interestingly Americans never use the concept of genocide There's something interesting in the way lemkin conducts his advocacy and in what his victories are during that trial And it was so striking to me that he was also trying to persuade the lawyers for the defense for the Nazis Of the concept of genocide and one of his victories is that they tried to rebut that they were guilty of genocide So why is he doing that?
I mean i'm trying to imagine this man who's also much of his family Seeking to sit down with the people defending the people responsible for the laws of his family And persuade them that this crime should exist And then second how do the lawyers for the Nazi defendants try to rebut it? What is their answer to the charge that's what they were attempting was the extermination of the jewish people So lemkin really is a fascinating character I can really quite a modern character louder part who is this or a classic academic lawyer just sticks to the lawyers works with lawyers lemkins on a one-man campaign He is trying to persuade governments. He tries to persuade public opinion He gets in touch with leader writers of the new york times as a leader that he influences and he's on a sort of Huge letter writing campaign on this important concept of genocide Which bears some fruit because it does get included in the trial I then discover one in the research that not only has he been trying to persuade you know the lawyers for the prosecution the British French the Americans the Americans are Pretty skeptical roberjacks and thought he was a pain and and irritant but he also gets in touch with the defense Lawyers and has conversations with them and we know about that because in the transcript Some of the defense lawyers without even the crime of genocide hadn't been alleged Raised the concept of genocide and I'm able to trace that two conversations between lemkin and some of the defense council They basically rebutted and say it's a total invention. This is new.
This didn't exist in 1933 This didn't exist in 1939 you've invented this concept any any event on the facts It's not true one of the things that people forget is that the focus at nuremberg was not largely on the extermination of particular groups jews or roma They were really second or third tier the main focus of nuremberg was the kind of aggression waging illegal war and everything else was secondary to that main Objective but it is those concepts of crimes against united genocide which have risen from the trial even though the judgment never mentions the word genocide Why are the Americans and for that matter? They mentioned it a bit here latte-bokt so skeptical of the concept of genocide Lattaback skepticism is that he worries it's gonna sort of reinforce the group identity in international politics replace the state with a group The Americans have another concern Jackson comes under pressure from Southern senators in the United States who are extremely worried that The crime of genocide will be invoked in relation to lynchings in the southern states of African-Americans black people and also historically in relation to Native Americans and the effort works and Jackson never mentions the word genocide the Americans never mentioned it It never comes up the set of laws that they are at some level inventing in this period These countries are arguably guilty of over and over again I mean wars of aggression what is a history of Europe aside from wars of aggression the crimes against humanity Are genocide I mean you look back in our treatment of Native Americans in the United States treatment of black Americans There is an invention of International legal standards that under any plain reading the people not prosecuting the Germans for their countries have culpability in their own histories Absolutely I often think about the fourth character in my book who is Interesting and sort of devilish individual called Hans Frank the one who is at office was lawyer highly cultivated highly cultured That's German law schools could you know recite Shakespeare and Heiner and Gerta world-class pianist how does he get mixed up in all of this? It's an interesting question. I often think of him on the first day of the trial when he's presented with the indictment and he sees that he's been indicted for crimes against humanity genocide is mentioned crime of aggression and his reaction with his lawyer is gonna be What's this about these have been invented?
This has been invented for this trial as a principle of the non-retroactivity of the law You can't invent you know a crime in 1945 and then applied retroactively to what happened in 1940 or 1937 or whatever and it was one of those moments in life where you know the horrors of what had happened crystallized a Sentiment yeah, there's probably forced to those arguments and yeah, this is a lot of just is this is a form of victor's justice Which it is plain leaders and it's one sided and that has dogged New York ever since but these ideas invented from your burger then take off the new United Nations General Assembly meets in the United States and They endorse the crimes that have been laid out in the new and black statute and say crimes against humanity crime of aggression genocide These are now part of international law going forward But but forgive me if I misunderstood senior book genocide is not one of the crimes in the Nuremberg statute Genocide is mentioned in the indictment but not in the statute and when you then come to the judgment on the first of October 1946 the word genocide is not mentioned not even once there isn't even a reference to it was argued But we're rejecting it for the following reasons the four principal judges just passed in silence on it Lempton describes the day of the judgment as the blackest day of his life worse even than the day on which he discovered the loss of his beloved parents and his cousins and uncles and aunts and so on and so forth and he resumes his campaign and he begins to lobby within the context of the UN General Assembly which passes a resolution in December 1946 saying basically the tribunal got it wrong and genocide is part of international law And what he achieves is a commitment by a general assembly resolution that they will then be negotiated a convention against genocide on the prevention and punishment of genocide and that is again his almost one-man show in December 1946 he succeeds and the first modern human rights treaty adopted with strong support of the United States and about 50 other countries is The adoption of the convention on the prevention punishment of genocide in 1948. So I want to read how it is defined in that treaty Genocide is quote any of the following acts committed with intent to destroy in whole or in part a national Ethical racial or religious group as such killing members of the group Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group forcibly transferring children of the group to another group To people who I think in their head genocide is the Holocaust or maybe the Rwandan genocide if you're younger That's different. There is more in it. I some of you has tried genocide cases What is in it?
How would you describe what the legal definition of genocide is and how it may be different from the cloguel one Right, so I have a problem to alert the list of says which is that I've argued genocide cases before international courts And the difficulty that I've often faced in those cases is that the definition that is adopted in the 1948 convention is different from the definition that Lemkin originally conceived of as I've already explained He set the bar much lower if you look at the definition here Just a couple of examples that you read out committed with intent to destroy then his conception didn't have what has emerged as a special intention that has to be proven and Lemkin also had a much broader conception of which groups were covered you'll have noticed political groups are excluded and the Concession that he made and he knew it at the time was that it was a more limited definition and it set the bar much higher That was 1948 and he accepted it what happened next between 1948 and the 1990s nothing happened really with the interpretation application of the genocide convention then in Ninety-three and ninety-four we had the horrors of Rwanda which you've already mentioned under the former Yugoslavia and the security council creates Two new international tribunals to deal with those horrors and cases reached the international court of justice on the horrors of Yugoslavia And before the international court of justice in particular the court takes a particular definition of what it means to intend to destroy a group in whole or in part In short we can pick this now in relation to what's going on right now in various parts of the world You start with Lenten's conception in 1944 at a lower bar you then get the convention definition in 1948 Which pushes the bar higher and then in the 1990s and in the 2000s the bar is pushed even higher by international judges who want to limit What genocide means in international law and the end result is you've got a gap You've got a gap between what ordinary folk think of as genocide Which is much closer to what lemting imagine it to be on the one hand and the legal definition taken by international courts And much of the mischief that is faced today is about that gap You are vastly more expert on this than me, but it seems to me that you have two gaps and they're different there's a gap you described So Lemkin has a definition of genocide that is consequential. It's not just about intent But there has been a gap between Genocide is the Holocaust it is a race to exterminate every single member of a group that you possibly can And so if that is not happening then whatever it is it is not genocide and then this legal definition Which is much more even if it's hard to prove for reasons we'll talk about around intent It's more expansive it is you know causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group It is deliberately inflicting on new conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part That much smaller actions can legally be genocide than something of the level of the Holocaust or the Rwandan genocide And into that I think a huge amount of debate has fallen That is generally right Lemkin Had a conception of genocide which was much closer to what most people think that Lemkin did not believe that you needed something of the scale of the murder of the Jews of Europe to amount to genocide For Lemkin genocide was not a numbers game and nor did it require a specific intention I've always understood that Lemkin if you have you know a village of nine people coming from three different groups group A group E group C If group being group C you know co-joints and then attacks and kills people from group A The killing of those three people constitutes an act of genocide. So in Lemkin's notes We find examples of relatively small acts of killings of groups In part a part of a community living in a particular part of the world for him For example the pogroms that will carry out in Russia about against Jews in particular towns those were genocidal acts And so his conception was not the vast conception His conception was not that it has to be the murder of six million people in order to amount to genocide It's essentially the targeting and the killing or they're not only the killing of people because they happen to be a member of a particular group That is hated at a particular time in place But I think it's very important to explain something else that we haven't mentioned right now is that in the popular conception the public conception Genocide has emerged as the crime of crimes in international or it's not the crime of crimes If you kill 50,000 people as a war crime or a crime against humanity or genocide It's all on a level playing field and the issue that has arisen in my mind is this problem of labeling What Lemkin did was he invented a word that has opened the imagination. It's a brilliant word It's not technical like war crimes and crimes against humanity.
It portrays absolute horror And what that means is that if an American president takes to the airwaves and says I've just seen something happen That's a genocide. It will be on the front page of every single newspaper in the world But if the president says oh that's war crime or crimes against humanity It will pass in silence or to be on page 15 There was an example of this quite recently in 2022 23 President Biden took the airwaves in a moment and said the killings in Ukraine by Russian troops looked to him like genocide and I read it off air to peace in the New York Times So hang on a second. Let's be careful what we're talking about It certainly looks like crimes. It certainly looks like war crimes It may be systematic and crimes against humanity, but the definition of genocide sets a high bar But in any event what does it matter for those people what we call it?
They're dead They've been massacred in appalling circumstances whether it's a war crime a crime against humanity or genocide I'm less interested in it's wrong and it should not have happened and it needs to be punished Well, maybe this gets at the other way the concept of genocide evolved so as you mentioned it in Nuremberg It's not a major player and at Nuremberg the trials are not primarily about what we now think of as the Holocaust It is later in our collective historical memory that the Holocaust becomes definitional the epicenter of all 20th century evil And the worst possible thing the embodiment of human evil is a dollar the embodiment of collective Industrial evil is the Holocaust and so that this crime that doesn't end up in the final charges of Nuremberg is the one that Comes to define I think even Nuremberg in the collective imagination So genocide kind of takes on this life of its own but because it is tied to something that is central to our historical memory When we say never again never again is meant to describe the Holocaust It's something very specific and it is from that specific thing that our collective fear excess right that what do we do? What structures need to exist to make sure that level of barbarism and humanity never reveals itself again And so even as you have the legal term of genocide emerging as well more limited and more expansive I think than than what people think it is you have this cultural idea of genocide Which is to connect you to the worst thing human beings in our collective understanding have ever done And that gives it a cultural meaning that is maybe different It's very much in that direction. What seems to have happened is that genocide has emerged as the crime of crimes and many prosecutors International criminal tribures and in national courts will tell you that in relation to the worst acts of killing have taken place Whether it's Sudan or Congo or Kosovo or Yugoslavia or Rwanda or whatever They want their crime to be treated as the worst crime that has happened and in popular conception that is genocide And so there is disappointment if a prosecutor only invites for war crime or crimes against many my own viewers That is misplaced, but that's the reality and what you then see is the focus on genocide as a comparator to what happened between 1933 1945 war crimes and crimes against humanity are there more regular that happens the whole time We want our crime to be right up there in the Premier League of horrors And that means if it's not called genocide, we are disappointed and you see that produced consequences that are very painful I've mentioned the case that I argued for 15 years for Croatia against Serbia on what had happened at the town of Vukovar in 1990s where Croatia went to the International Court of Justice and argued this was the crime of genocide and the International Court of Justice Said no, it's not and left the consequence that it was the crimes against humanity and war crimes and the consequences have been devastating Within Croatia and within the region why did the Bosnian's get a genocide for sure bonnets And we only got a crime against humanity for Vukovar and what that causes me to ask is what is the social utility of that distinction? What is the social usefulness of having a sort of category of horrors in which some things are treated as so much worse than others?
And I think the concept of genocide in that sense has been unhelpful because it has created a hierarchy and that hierarchy has caused the great deal of grief and a great deal of conflict in of itself Notice how some homes self-assert your neighborhood. It's not luck. It's local know-how Relax agents know their street schools and communities inside and out and with remax those local pros are everywhere Which means when you're written to buy your cell, you'll get trusted neighborhood insight that puts you a step ahead Reach out today Relax the experts closed home each office independently owned and operated From that first copy of the day to dropping off your dry cleaning on the way from stepping onto the subway to opening your doors to your first Customer of the day. We're here to power you along the way Minaris powering Canadian Commerce visit us at minnaris commers Last summer the coolest place in the house was in your freezer this year It's time to level up reliance home comfort has over 160,000 five-star reviews for delivering the type of outstanding customer experience Canadians have counted on for over 60 years right now Don't pay for 12 months on a featured air conditioner or heat pump calling the experts that know how to beat the heat Conditions apply see website for details Why is genocide so difficult to prove?
Genocide is difficult to prove before international court because it has and comes back to what we've already touched on this special intent You have to prove you read out the words from article two acts committed with intent to destroy and hold her in part So the first thing to say is that since Nazi Germany Leaders who want to destroy groups have learnt that you don't put in writing You don't articulate your intention to destroy a group in whole room part and so courts and judges are left to infer from a pattern of behavior What is the mental element? What's what's motivating action? What's the intention behind the act of killing of destruction of harm and in the Croatia case of 2015? Which I have referred to a couple of times the court said the following I think it's words are very important the court said to state that for a patent of conduct to be accepted as evidence of Existence of genocidal intent it must be such that it could only point to the existence of such intent and the court says What this amounts to saying is that in order to infer the existence of that special intent from a pattern of conduct?
It is necessary insufficient that this is the only inference that could reasonably be drawn from the hats in question Now what does that mean? What that means is that if you have a double or triple intent You want to act in self-defense you want to act to protect your national security But actually on the side of the helpful to destroy these people as part of a group you happen to hate It's gonna be very difficult to prove that it's the only reasonable inferred intent and that in practice is what has caused so much difficulty My own personal view is that that definition is wrong It sets the bar far too high that the psychologists that I speak to say that when human beings have an intent to act They're often motivated by multiple different intents and to say you've got to have only one intent It makes it very very difficult to prove so we are not having this conversation abstractly We're having it in the context of a debate over whether What Israel is doing in Gaza should be understood as a genocide And this debate has been playing out and it is I think the most red-hot word in all of this I mean for Jews for them to be accused of or where the two them means the Holocaust and for Palestinians To have what has happened to them be seen as what they understand to be which is an effort to destroy them I'm gonna ask you to argue this both ways and go through the arguments with me not to answer it but to understand it What is the argument that it is a genocide that the intent here is not just to destroy Hamas Which is what these are like government at different times is said the intent is but that it's genocidal I'm going to answer that question But I just want to contextualize by saying that I understand this is a red-hot issue and part of the reason I've been quite restrained and what I said in my Characterization is I think you know I'm counseling another case that's coming up before the international court of justice in the next few months A case brought by the Gambia against Myanmar alleging genocide in relation to the mistreatment of the Rohingya I'm not involved in the case brought by South Africa against Israel But I was counsel for Palestine in another case at the international court of justice the Palestinian Authority I should say involving the question of the right of self-determination So but these are my personal users that I'm now expressing the very first thing that I would say is I think it's entirely fine for people to Freely express their views if you want to say this is a genocide They should not be criticized for saying that if people want to get upset that others characterizes as genocide I understand that also it's become a lightning rod for so many Different perspectives and difficult issues the case for South Africa is very straightforward It is that the only reasonable inference you can infer from the pattern of behavior particularly in relation to statements of genocide are rhetoric by various ministers and the In particular use of famine as an instrument of conflict the only reasonable inference You can draw from that is an intention to destroy a group in whole or in part And that is the argument that South Africa will have put in its the argument that they have put in their Partition and it's the argument that the judges addressed in four Provisional measures orders interim relief that the court has given offering certain degrees of protection to the Palestinians In Gaza against some of the attacks that are taking place, but that in essence is the argument that South Africa will put so When South Africa brought this argument it was not how I saw what was happening at that moment right just mere months after October 7th This seemed still to me like a war that whatever the absolutely traumatized and infuriated statements of Top Israelis right up, you know days right up over seventh It seemed to me that any country that had been attacked the way Israel was attacked would respond with overwhelming force and attempt to destroy the organization This case mass that attacked it that that is war as we understand it self-defense as we understand it I have watched over the months and months that have gone on as many Holocaust scholars as many human rights groups Even people who did not agree with South Africa at that moment Have come to accept the term genocide and it seems to me for a few reasons I guess one is the and maybe the most important is the targeting of civilian populations through siege tactics That if Israel wants to argue that all they are attempting to do is to destroy Hamas Hamas is Completely degraded as a military fighting force yayasim ours dead and yet they are starving the people of Gaza in a way That it is it just extremely extremely difficult. I think to argue this is an act of war against a live Military or terrorist organization and I've seen this I think more than anything this has brought people to a new understanding of what is happening here How do you think about that charge? I mean I think about it a lot I've already said publicly that if Linton would review what has happened he would have characterized what happened on October the seventh as meeting his definition of genocide And he would certainly characterize what is happening now in Gaza as genocidal for exactly the reason that you have stated The challenge as we've seen is not to determine whether crimes are being committed There's no question that what you're describing is a walk on there's no question in my mind either that it is so systematic That it's likely also to be a crime against humanity in the conception of international law The debate and it's a legal debate which as I've said it's not a helpful one is what is the intention?
Behind the acts that you are describing South Africa will make a strong argument that there is no military justification and therefore there cannot be an intention other Than to destroy the group in Holmen part that is the argument they will make and the judges of international court justice will then Assess that on the basis of the evidence that is before them and they will assess it presumably on the basis of an argument by Israel No, we're not intending to destroy a group in Holmen part We're seeking to protect ourselves against further attacks of this kind but until the judges have spoken We don't know whether they're going to take their definition from 2015 and apply it to these facts or whether they're going to tweak the definition and say This is totally unacceptable reduce the bar and conclude that this is genocide or do something else which is to conclude that now I've mentioned another case that will come up before the case of Israel in South Africa And that is the case of the Gambia and Myanmar and the judges are going to face exactly the same issue in that case They are going to have to determine whether Myanmar's arguments that it is acting in self-defense against a threat to its national security Justifies the court ruling that this is not genocide That's not the argument that I'm putting but these will be the legal issues that will be put and it imposes a particular burden on the judges for another reason in the whole of human history The International Court of Justice has never ruled that a state is responsible for genocide. It has never happened in the case brought by Bosnia against Serbia The court say yes, there was a genocide But it wasn't one that was intended by the state of Serbia Serbia failed to prevent a genocidal act by paramilitary groups and so for the judges of the International Court They're in this rather awkward position of having to decide for the first time it will be in the Myanmar case brought by the Gambia But then it will also be in the South Africa case with Israel Do we put the label of genocidal state on the forehead of one or both of these countries something that has never happened before? And that I think concentrates the minds of judges But it may well be that they say yes one or both or neither of these cases meets our definition the judges definition of what is genocidal and in the meantime people will continue to make the arguments and People will be pretty incandescent I suspect in both cases if the court says no this doesn't meet the legal definition so there is the level of targeting the civilian population and then there's the the level of targeting the structures and infrastructure of Normal life of any life in Gaza There are estimates and upwards of 70% of the physical structures in Gaza are destroyed the the footage is just a wasteland And anti-specialist in the area Daniel Blatman and Amos Goldberg they wrote in in Haritz The way they put it the way they said they had moved to believe in this was a genocide was I'm gonna quote them here The murder of children starvation destruction of infrastructure including that of the health care system destruction of most homes including the erasure of entire neighborhoods and towns such as Jabbalah and Rafa ethnic cleansing in the northern strip destruction of all of Gaza's universities and most cultural institutions and mosques destruction of government Organizational infrastructure mass graves destruction of infrastructure for local food production and water distribution all these paint clear picture of genocide Gaza as a human national collective entity no longer exists This is precisely what genocide looks like and so the claim being made here You're being made here that it's more than just a tax on the people that in destroying everything that Gaza was making it functionally uninhabitable by human beings that that is part of genocide that is part of revealing an intent to Make this place and people no longer exist in the form they once did How do you think about that? I think about it?
I think pretty much the same way you think about it I mean it's playing if you read the provisional measures orders of the international court of justice that in particular the judges have already addressed what's been of the case so far are deeply concerned about famine I think there was another statistic in the paper in the last few days that I think one and a half percent of Arable agricultural land remains in the whole of Gaza It is not possible for a population of that size to sustain itself with that amount of arable land So all of that absolutely points to that kind of genocidal intent if the court takes the definition which allows it to happen one of the complexities here also is that ethnic cleansing moving a population out of their homelands People will find it's difficult to believe has been ruled not to be genocidal in international law on the particular definition that international courts have taken But coming back to the factors you have set out They are exactly the kind of factors that you will find in Lemkins book from 1944 as indicating his conception of what constitutes a genocidal attack These are exactly the kinds of factors that are taken into account by judges when assessing how to characterize certain crimes as part of the effort to Define or to reveal intent something that is a backbone in South Africa's filing is statements from from top Israeli officials So Benjamin Netanyahu the Prime Minister has repeatedly referred to biblical verses around the Jewish people's war with the Amalek and in Deuteronomy Specifically the area that he's referring to it God commands the Jewish people to blot out the memory of Amalek from under heaven There's elsewhere in the book of Samuel go and attack the Amalek Heights and completely destroy everything they have don't leave a thing kill all the men women children and babies the cattle sheep camels and donkeys now you can debate which biblical passages Netanyahu is referring to I find that to be a little bit strange but the Amalekites exist in the Torah as an example of people that God commands the Jews to destroy utterly blot out the memory President Isaac Herzog of Israel. It's an entire nation out there that is responsible It's not true. This rhetoric about civilians not aware not involved It's absolutely not true many of Israeli leaders have simply said that Hamas is the gossons and the gossons are Hamas There's not a distinction worth making and while you can say that that is statements Made in the midst of trauma and rage. It does seem to be governing now two years on the war The people gods are not being treated as distinct really from Hamas.
They're being starved. They're being punished. They're being displaced Do statements like that create intent? then I feel like a terrible pedantic law but there's a distinction between genocidal rhetoric and genocidal intent it's plain from the provisional measures orders that the judges at the International Court of Justice were very concerned very focused on these statements which are appalling statements and which will undoubtedly make it more difficult And obviously there are many many many like in preparing on this I have lists of these that are pages and pages But there are other conflicts in the world where we get the same kinds of statements that are made I'm very involved also in the current conflict between Ukraine and Russia and many of my colleagues and friends in Ukraine consider That what is happening in Ukraine is a genocidal act that President Putin has made statements saying the Ukrainian's don't exist There's a people that shall not exist as a people they have no right to exist as a people And I've had to explain when I've been in live if that yes These are appalling statements and they might amount to genocidal rhetoric But there's a distinction between that on the one hand and what you actually do on the ground On the other and that's what the courts are going to have to decide in these cases to clarify here What is the distinction between genocidal rhetoric and genocidal intent?
What what beyond public statements is needed to prove intent in court of law? Well, genocidal rhetoric is an expression along the lines that x or y group doesn't exist or has no right to exist or to be destroyed as a group and it can create a context in which People then act to implement that idea the classic example is in Rwanda There was a radio station called had your new colina radio a thousand hills which put out really nasty stuff and that Created an environment in which people on the ground then implemented genocidal acts But you know someone expressing genocidal rhetoric go out and do nasty things to these people doesn't actually Prove that the acts that follow were intended to destroy group in holering parts So you have to show a connection between the expression and the act on the ground if the expression is made by a minister acting in official capacity It's going to be much easier to show a connection between an expression of genocidal intent as rhetoric on the one hand and the act of killing or targeting Or exterminating on the ground on the other hand But the essential thing that you have to prove is that the act of targeting on the ground the act of killing the act of imposing hunger Or using famine as a weapon as an instrument of conflict or extermination Is intended to destroy the group in whole or in part rather than simply to diminish that group as a fighting force It's I think also important just so that your listeners are aware Of the dynamic between the political and the legal because that's essentially what we're talking about here is whether a group of judges Are going to be willing to cross the line if they want to they got all of the material to allow them to do it To make a finding in favor of South Africa Well, I do think that this between the political and legal is important because on some level I don't understand all this to be really about a court case that will happen at some point in the future I understand it to be about a cultural understanding that the real damage here that the real demand here the real effort here Is to attach to israel Because it was current leadership to the jewish state The charge of genocide and make it stick in cultural memory to change the meaning of the jewish state And not just that but the other piece of all of this is just the reality of what is happening and why whether intent can be proven or not the why of what is happening Reading your book is really hard for me And I read actually a fair amount of it in Berlin and Poland on a trip that was supposed to be the separate friends birthday But but being in these places while reading this book which was maybe not my greatest idea ever Was to really try to imagine all this and how it happened and how the people around me where I was enjoying their coffee shops and going to see music and How you know their? grandparents and great grandparents could have done this to my great grandparents and great grandparents It imbues the world with an unreality And I thought a lot about what allows you to dehumanize other people There's a really startling moment in the trials in your book where I forget who says it But he says About the extermination of the jewish people that it never occurred to him and the people around him to have any attitude towards it aside from indifference And this goes back to you know, um, hana rents books and and indifference is actually not just hatred but indifference as the soil in which something like a genocide can emerge and around the same time a poll came out that was reported on by harritz Uh where 79 of israeli jews 79 So they are not so troubled or not troubled at all By the reports of famine and suffering among the palstonian population in gaza I'd seen another poll along before saying that israeli jews felt that they'd heard enough about the suffering in gaza And what chilled me so much about it even beyond the level of suffering in daza Was the level of indifference that had grabbed hearts of israeli jews that the I mean if the hawkishon It says anything it should be the dangers of dehumanization And I'm not saying this is something you prove in court or it's part of the legal case But I think those polls and thinking about the places I was in now where he was perfectly nice and wonderful and I have I have friends who are reclaiming german citizenship um That it was the reality of the dehumanization by those kinds of comments mixed within the indifference That I think if you read books like yours that there's something very I mean Astonishingly dangerous about that that intent is not always hatred intent can be But what makes it possible in some ways is not So seeing any humanity and in other people Attempt in my book can also be turning a blind eye to what is happening and a blind eye is being turned and I To be frank find it incomprehensible. I I have trouble understanding how it is possible to treat human beings in this way to treat children in this way To treat elderly people in this way.
It is literally beyond my comprehension Save that as with so much of the work that I do in cases about mass atrocity It's always about dehumanization. They're not like us They're different and therefore we are free to treat them in this way and in a sense where I come back to It's I'm not focused on whether it's a war crime or a crime against humanity or a genocide which is a distraction from the real issue It is utterly appalling and unjustifiable and it should not be happening And these debates about whether to characterize something as x or y or z are not helpful because they distract us From the horror that is happening underneath unfolding before our own eyes One of the debates around Lumpkin's definition of genocide that takes hold is whether or not acts from before the war are included in it Or it's just a subcategory of a war crime that can only be prosecuted in the context of a war And I was thinking about this because many of the Palestinians I've talked to about this To them the reason that the concept of genocide was so close at hand was they believe This is something israel's been seeking for sometime that the palestinian people look to israel as a problem to be solved Maybe caged up in gaza and unable to leave maybe their existence in the west bank made more and more tenuous and more More difficult and more dangerous and so they they self-report that the way they understand this period is that october 7th and somebody's opened up a window of opportunity for israel to Execute a project that some in it had been thinking about in planning for some time And you can look at you know work from some of the more far-right ministers to for antecedents for that And so to them that there's a continuity there was a siege on gaza before the siege is tighter now But israel had gods of blockade it for quite some time. That's why there were tunnels in part How do you think about that question of of what was going on here before the war and the way that the groundwork for what has happened after october 7th Might have been laid in a long period in which certainly parts of israeli society came to the view That the palestinians were not a people to coexist with and to find a way for for both to live in self-determination and equality But some problem to be solved to be cleansed be displaced to take what they would call jade and samaria back For palestinians I talked to this all did not begin on october 7 one of the ways that they believe the conversation is biased against them is We speak about purpose of this beginning and they don't see it that way they see it as an eruption of islands inside a long process of their erasure Well, I think that I think everyone is right to see it as a long process I mean the things were indeed happening before on the west bank in terms of the settlements in terms of the right of self-determination Which the international court of justice a year ago said not only that the palestinians have a right of self-determination But the right of self-determination implies the existence of a sovereign state and what we are actually beginning to see right now I think curiously in the consequence of the horrors in our newspapers and our tv screens is a move Which I think will be very problematic for the current Israeli government of recognition of palestinian statehood the First two european countries to break with the kensensas against recognition Was main and island and they've now been followed by france Which is very significant because it's a permanent member of the security council and now the united kingdom has effectively said in september It will recognize the existence of a palestinian state and this is I mean I know for many people this seems only symbolic but actually in terms of symbolism it is sort of a game changer because once you recognize palestinian statehood as 147 states already have and I think now may european countries will follow suit You essentially put palestine and israel on a level Footing on a footing of equality in terms of their treatment under international law and that's one of the reasons I suspect the Israeli government has opposed strongly recognition of palestinian statehood but once you recognize palestinian statehood then the borders become Inviolable and you can't annex parts of the west bank and you can't occupy and then annex Gaza without causing significant problems with some of your allies including your allies in europe And so if this path continues if use of salvation and if the military tax continues There's going to be recognition of palestinian statehood and there are going to be other consequences in relation to trade With israel not just armaments but also other products Isospic and it will become an overwhelming cry in many countries around the world to adopt the kinds of sanctions that have been adopted in relation to russia On ukraine and the israeli position will become Increasingly isolated and increasingly untenable now whether that is sufficient in time to stop suffering on the ground children and moms and people who have nothing to do With a military conflict time will only tell but we know in life that every act has unintended consequences and it may well be That this is really government has simply now taken things too far And made things too intolerable and unacceptable for too many people around the world that finally something will crack ordering to start No, let me enjoy things the bills already too much you signed up for this and maybe sign off then whatever It's time to break up with your debt fiber debt solutions licensed in solvency trustees get the truth about death From that first copy of the day to driving off your dry cleaning on the way from stepping onto the subway To opening your doors to your first customer of the day. We're here to power you along the way Minaras powering Canadian commerce visit us at minaras.com slash commerce Last summer the coolest place in the house was in your freezer this year It's time to level up reliance home comfort has over 160,000 five star reviews for delivering the type of outstanding customer experience Canadians of count it on for over 60 years right now Don't pay for 12 months on a featured air conditioner or heat pump calling the experts that know how to beat the heat Conditions apply see website for details So then there's the case israel's making and we'll make it's defense both to the courts and and to itself If you were the lawyer for israel, what would you argument be?
Tell your minisist to zip it to start with stop making these statements well, that's your strategy, but what's your argument? The only argument that is available to israel is the one that is based on a very particular reading of the language that I read out to you Earlier, it's necessary and sufficient that the only inference to be drawn from our acts is that it's the other side of intent and it's not Israel will say we are acting in self-defense the bombs continue to fall unless the hostages continue to be held We are entitled to take these steps in order to protect ourselves from an existential threat And therefore our intention is self-defense self-protection. It is not the extermination of a group in whole or in part That's the kind of argument that they would wait incidentally The relevant people concerned are well aware of the history of genocide and of the meaning of the genocide convention There was a piece in time magazine about it. Well a few five six years ago Profile of Benjamin Netanyahu and the piece included a photograph of him reading East West Street And I have to say as astonishing I think it's very painful And the idea that the person who is most responsible for what is going on right now Is someone who is well aware of the historical matters because he has read himself into them and frankly he should know better I want to that's a remarkable Thing to know well the other thing to know is that who reviewed the book for harrettes Isaac Herzog the current president Israel So it's very difficult for me to comprehend how individuals who have themselves through their own family stories lived through In a historical sense the kinds of things that happen to their forebears can find a justification for this kind of behavior Is very difficult for me to comprehend but let me let me try to put myself in their shoes to create fairness here um One is that their view is this is hamas that the actor here was hamas hamas attack on October 7th hamas has held the hostages since The way you know that it is not genocidal in intent is if hamas would lay down its arms Give itself up as an organization release the hostages This would have ended long before now that what this is analogous to is a war fought through siege And they're sijing Gaza until the I don't know if you came a call with hamas anymore governing authority I don't really think you can but they're sijing Gaza until what used to be the government of it gives up gives up the hostages And and so war and Israel's not attempting to exterminate the gazan people did not start this war that this was It was on hamas then and it is on hamas now And whatever you think about the level of pain is willing to cause gazan civilian population that doesn't change their intent which is to destroy hamas utterly and completely as an organization to Restore their deterrence to make clear to anybody that if you do something like this to Israel your society will be annihilated And to punish the Palestinian people for ever having supported hamas or ever having thought that hamas like organization Was a good idea or vehicle of national rebellion or freedom?
Well, I mean I understand that to be an argument that Israel would make of course I'm not privy to the detailed negotiations. I don't know what's been on the table. What's not been on the table We've seen it evolve over the course now of nearly two years But even if all of this is true under international law this kind of treatment is not justifiable Whether you call it war crimes or crimes against humanity or anything else including genocide. It is simply not Justifiable there are norms of international law that are very clear in preventing this kind of it does not justify that that What israel is entitled to say is that the attack that occurred on october the servants was such as to entitle it to respond I wrote a letter I wrote a piece In the financial times with other British Jewish lawyers at the end of october including former presence the uk supreme court David new booger and we said look three points one the attack of october the seventh is a crime under international law two israel is entitled to use force In self-defense to protect itself against such attacks But three the right to use force is not unlimited and it is constrained by the requirements of international law and it may not go beyond Those requirements and we were very criticized for the third point because it was said we're assuming israel would violate international law But everyone knew what was coming and we wanted to put a mark down that as and when lines crossed We would be on the front line of saying this is not acceptable behavior and that is what has happened This is not self-defense.
This is actually not preventing attacks So I I do not see a defense that israel is not guilty of at this point war crimes and crimes against humanity But the debate has centered around this question of genocide and to be fair to that debate There was not a surrender the Jews could make in 1940 that would have ended the holocaust or stopped the holocaust This is the view I hear from israel eight jews and for many jewish people here There are conditions israel has laid out if hamas capitulated, you know, they have rejected many ceasefire agreements or broken ceasefires But to call this a genocide is flatly untrue even under any colloquial definition of genocide because this would at least they believe Stop if hamas surrendered and gave up the hostages But israel has endangered the hostages further by containing war. I think it's also undeniable but in terms of intent Is that not an argument? I mean, it's You know, I had no idea what would happen if they laid down arms now and said here are your 20 women hostages and we give up and you take over and you occupy We have no idea what israel would actually do in those circumstances, but your question brings to my mind this thought The longer this goes on the more difficult it is going to be for Israel to resist the argument that this meets the definition of genocide under international law And I'd be very surprised if the israeli government is not getting that advice from its lawyers The more you persist in this direction the more likely you make it that ultimately one or other international court is going to conclude Not only colloquially, but as a matter of law that these facts constitute a genocide and that again causes me to ask question Why exactly are they persisting? What is the military advantage that they seek to gain and the more difficult it comes to answer that question The more likely it is that a group of judges of the international court of justice will conclude that there is no military justification The only intention is to destroy large parts of this group Here's I think how they argue this and I think also goes to your point of the longer this goes on the heart of the circuit becomes to sustain which is to say that Hamas is interwoven in civilian life in Gaza both inextricably and strategically it operates out of mosques out of Hospitals out of university as of out of all these things that the rest of the world is condemning Israel for destroying that it is Hamas's fault because it hides among the population Israel has argued that Hamas has been diverting food aid, which is why Israel had to stop the food aid and then rebuild this absolutely horrific Structure of food assistance, which has led to so many deaths now I'm not saying I buy this argument I do want to say that the investigations have found that Hamas has not diverted food aid systematically but that has been their argument that the targeting of what looks like civilian infrastructure is necessary because Hamas hides among civilians and inside civilian infrastructure The very first truth is justify what's going on under international law in terms of international humanitarian law war crimes law crimes against humanity and perhaps even crossing the line into course whatever the judges decide it's not an answer to those claims and if it is an answer to those claims Then you have opened the door to an end to these rules that we've spent 150 years Struggling to put in place So if you accept those kinds of arguments you are in effect accepting that total war total destruction total Annihilation is now permitted under international law in such circumstances And if you use it one day against others then others one day will use it against you and you ought to be prepared for that time when you find yourself under attack in such conditions and you need to say this is not permissible So there is no justification on those grounds in law for what is happening period How much does that also extend to the arguments around self-defense?
Which is to say that when you look at the history of genocide proceedings I think it is very hard to find one that does not claim on behalf of those who committed the genocide going back to the Germans That they were acting in self-defense that they faced a threat from this group It was sabotage from within there was an attack there was an assassination And they had no choice the only way to protect themselves was to Destroy the scrips capacity to be a group or capacity to act or capacity to exist Utterly how does genocide law balance? The omnipresence of claims about self-defense But it doesn't balance it well in relation to the you know single intent argument that seems to have merged which as i've explained I'm deeply troubled by but if you go back to lemkin's original conception He could well imagine a situation in which a double or a triple intent would not preclude a finding of genocide I mean your account reminds me of an exchange that took place in a book That is the sequel to east west recall the rat line in which the nazi governor of le viv receives a letter from his father his name is autovector and he receives a letter from his father general vester who Tells him look I have come to learn that within your district of krakow um There is a child who happens to be jewish And I would be grateful if you could take steps to secure the safety of that child who happens to be you know the child of a friend of mine The son Vester writes back and says I looked into this. Yes, this child is present in our territory But I have to tell you that the laws that we have in relation to threat posed by these people including the children Is such that we have no other way of proceeding than to apply the full force of the law to them in order to protect ourselves So this is a timeless argument. This has been used Across history that in order to protect ourselves against the other In particular circumstances.
We are entitled to take far reaching and even exponatory methods And what happened in 1945? This was the revolutionary moment was no, that's not a defense anymore You're not allowed to do that Everyone has rights either as an individual or as a member of a group and in order to safeguard human beings against these type of arguments We under international law are going to protect and ensure the protection of the rights of those human beings And that's right now what is under attack in world right now to basically roll back the frontiers to pre-1945 world In which the ideas of now to pack to lemkin writes for individuals and writes for groups not under domestic law But under international law are rolled back and that's why this moment is so important And what's happening in places like Ukraine and in Israel and Palestine is so emblematic for the future well-being of these rules This felt to me and even more so knowing that yahoo and hertzog have read your book like the The historical tragedy that is playing out in this moment not the tragedy playing out in this moment Which is the actual thing happening to the gossants but the historical tragedy Which is that the creators of these rules lemkin and around crimes against humanity a lot of power They were Jewish people at a time when Jewish people had no power and could be annihilated by states And now that Jewish people have a state and have power They are flouting these rules profoundly and Watching a structure of law built by Jews in their moment of absolute weakness and vulnerability Destroyed by them in some way as they have become stronger and more state-bound It's almost a like a historical tragedy irony Strangeness, it's really it was almost too much to bear Indeed and it rather proves the old adage that the international rules like other rules are not intended for us They're only intended for others when it suits us and I think that will come back to haunt because at the end of the day Any community requires protections not only under domestic rules, but under international rules They will come at time again When israelis and jews and panistinians and muslims and Ukrainians and russians and sydnes and kongalese Come to understand that these ideas of latipack and then can be there for a reason and the anything that gives me a modicum of hope in what is You're absolutely right a tragic and painful moment is that at some point Those in power will come to realize that what happened in 1945 The idea that the state's power is not absolute the human beings have rights as individuals in this group Will return it's not the end of that argument and People like me just have to keep making those arguments That's why I stand up at the international court of justice in january next year on behalf of the gambeere a small african country Making allegations in relation to the mistreatment of the rohingia and I have to hope that the judges of the international court of justice Adopt an interpretation of the genocide convention which does justice and which protects Essentially the fundamental thrust of what rafel lemkin wanted to do. I mean look you've read east westward you have understood That throughout the book I got this internal struggle in myself am I with latipack protection of individuals or lemkin protection of groups And you'll have seen throughout the book I'm basically intellectually with latipack and then we get right to the end of the book And I am taken in a small town called julkyev just outside of yviv in ukraine To a forest and in that forest is a mass grave and in that mass grave on the 25th of march 1943 Three and a half thousand people from the village of julkyev were taken Made to walk along the plank shot in the back in the head and killed and in that mass grave today Unmarked today lie the bodies of latipacks family and my grandfather's family and at that moment I understood what it was that lemkin was trying to do and I came to understand the force of his arguments on genocide So even my most strong intellectual arguments in favor of the idea of protection The dignity and the rights of individuals when faced with a group of which I am a member my grandfather's family Face those kinds of actions It was a sort of moment of epiphany and I understood the force of lemkins arguments and notwithstanding the horror that is happening right now The horrors of october 7 terrible horrors that have followed the force of lemkins arguments I have no doubt will eventually prevail in some way, but that does not provide solace for those people who are on the receiving end right now I fully understand that I fully understand what would it mean for international law to work whether it's crimes against humanity Whether or not it's a charge of genocide. It's not stopping the war right?
We mentioned preliminary findings and injunctions from international court justice It is not as best we can tell significantly constrained Israel's conduct in the war It is not as if there is an international coalition that has demanded cease fire in a serious way america's sheltered israel from international condemnation If you know 15 or 20 years from now We are to look back on this as world of international eventually worked obviously international had to not work during world war two What would that mean? What are the remedies here? How do you imagine that as somebody who devotes much of your life to this? Well working over time it will work The question is what's the time 1945 was a revolution?
I mean it's very recent when I was a young academic at Cambridge University I had a colleague sashon baker professor of English legal history and he would occasionally invite me for lunch and he'd say what he worked on I'd say x or y and he stroke his little bit and he said oh yes Yes, we had a similar problem in English law in about 1472 and it took 275 years to sort it out And frankly that's where we are the difference between today and 19 39 and 1941 is we have these pieces of paper called treaties on torture on genocide I had an extraordinary conversation just before I argued the provisional measures order in the case for the gambe against me and my With a man called Thomas Bergenthal Thomas Bergenthal was the american judge of the international court of justice But before that he was a young jewish kid in Poland and he was an Auschwitz and just before I argued the case on The allegations of genocide in relation to Myanmar tom is sadly no longer with us said to me Felipe Can you imagine if in 1944 when I was at Auschwitz There had been a piece of paper called the convention on the prevention and punishment of genocide and they've been an international court And they've been a country far away which had gone to that court and said you can't treat those kids in that way This is inhuman. This is a crime. This is against international law Felipe said it may not have stopped what happened But it would have given us hope and it would have given us an understanding that what was being done to us was wrong And it should not happen and at the very least that is where we are today We have standards which tell us thanks to the work of people like loutipack to lemkin and the government successfully that have followed it up That this kind of behavior this kind of treatment of human beings of kids Totally people had nothing to do with wage and war simply because of where they happen to be and who they happen to be It's totally unacceptable totally intolerable must be held to account and must be punished And that's where I come out on these horrors. I'm less concerned about the label We put on things.
I'm most concerned with causing it to stop now And if the law can help to make that happen, that is a good thing But we know the limits of law and we know the limits of international law. That is the political reality in which we live And so it will take time in the meantime There will be horror after horror after horror and we have to construct and elaborate and build over time We don't just down tools and give up and say oh, it's all useless and there's no point and we just have to keep going And out of this horror, hopefully something will come which causes us to reinforce Our commitment to the idea of a rule of law at the international level to reinforce the powers of our international judges to Make the consequences of breaking the law at the personal level or the state level much greater But that's gonna take time. I wish I could say to you it could all be fine in 15 years It won't it's it's a multi-detate century project and we have to be honest about that, but it's a project worth engaging Absolutely, it's project worth engaging Then always our ending question. What are three books you'd recommend to the audience?
One book that I would take is called Janet Flanner's World Uncollected writings in 1932 to 1975 Janet Flanner was the New Yorker correspondent in Europe and he wrote extraordinary letters from Europe including on Nuremberg and they are so personant for What we've been talking about today in terms of the historic Aspect a second book. I'm gonna recommend a book by Anne Patrick called Commonwealth, which is about Relationships. I did not expect that book to come up here. I love that book.
Yeah, it's a wonderful book It's a wonderful book and it draws the connections between the personal and broader political in a way that really resonated with me And the third book that I'm gonna take is by Chilean writer called Roberta Bolano and it is called Knights in Chile And I love this book because it is a fictionalized account of Tales that are central to a book I'm publishing shortly I called 38 Long Rest Street, which is a sequel to East West Street and examines the relationship between Agusto Pinochet and Anadzi Who became the manager of a king crab cannery in Punta Arenas in Chile, but it raises many of the similar issues today that we've been discussing on personal responsibilities In a sense, I'd say that's the theme between the three books personal responsibility in times of conflict Felipe sounds. Thank you very much terrific to be with you This episode of the subconscious produced by Jack McCordick and Annie Galvin fact-checking by Michelle Harris with Kate Sinclair Our senior audio engineers Jeff Gell with additional mixing by Isaac Jones and Amund Souta our executive producer is Claire Gordon The show's production team also includes Marie Cassione, Elias Isquith, Marina King, Roland Hu, Kristen Lin, and Jan Cobol Original Music by Mary and Lozano, Dan Powell, Carol Saburo, and Pat McCuster Audience strategy by Christina Samuuski and Shannon Bussa The director of New York Times Pending Audio is Andy Rose Russell