Skip to content
Who Matters In America episode artwork

Oct 22, 2020 29 min

Who Matters In America

from Trump, Inc. Hosted by WNYC Studios

Trump, Inc. co-host Andrea Bernstein sits down with Kai Wright, host of The United States of Anxiety, to discuss how American history informs the 2020 election. The conversation, called "Who Matters in America 2020?," was part of Reporter's Notebook series at The Greene Space. Sign up for email updates from Trump, Inc. to get the latest on our investigations.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Who Matters In America

0:00 29:14
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hi, it's Andrea here in your podcast feed with something extra. With the end of voting rapidly approaching, I recently sat down with my colleague Kai Wright, host of the podcast and now weekly radio show, The United States of Anxiety, at a virtual event hosted by The Greenspace at WNYC. We discussed the tattered state of democracy, the encroaching oligarchy, racism, nativism, voter suppression, and how Donald Trump's central principle of us versus them has infected almost all of American government. These are things we think about a lot. We call the conversation Who Matters in America 2020? And we talked about the Trump presidency and this campaign through the lens of my book, American Oligarchs, the Kushners of the Trumps, and the Marriage of Money and Power, and through the long lens of history Kai and the United States of Anxiety team employ every week on their show.

Let's start with the biggest question we had of the night, which is, you know, who matters in America? And you said something about Donald Trump on our show, actually, the week of the Republican National Convention that I kind of want to bring us back to here. You know, I mean, he has said, certainly in this election, he's made it fairly clear that who he's saying matters are suburban residents, particularly white suburban residents. He sort of changes whether he's trying to bring people of color into that or not. But he's explicitly saying, OK, who I'm talking to are white suburbanites. And it's interesting because, you know, you mentioned that he has such...

a long and unique understanding of the suburbs, but that it might not be right. Can you unpack that a little bit, like his history with the suburbs? Yeah. So, I mean, I guess the first thing to say about Donald Trump is that he has this entirely consistent business model, which he's basically been the kind of person he is since... in his 20s when he started working for his father. So that was in the 70s when, with New York, there was, you know, decades of white flight. There were all kinds of things to stimulate racial segregation in New York City. And the Trumps really benefited from that by the location of their projects, which were sort of out in the outer boroughs and, you know, what is called in political parlance, white ethnic enclaves. But the Trumps, who got millions and millions and millions of dollars in federally backed loans, it was the federal government and we, the taxpayers, that really launched the Trump.

business. And the Trumps used that to create a housing project, which the Justice Department sued them for being basically whites only. And that was the moment at which Trump hired the infamous lawyer Roy Cohn to fight that. And eventually they settled that lawsuit, promising, as we know, Donald Trump is a man of his word, that they weren't going to discriminate ever again. And that is the pattern that we've seen with Trump forever, is that sort of who is good for his business is who matters. And the question about white suburbia right now is that he understands that that is sort of the key to his election. So right now, those folks matter. But it's kind of a myth, because

That piece of white suburbia, as he's envisioning it, is sort of stuck sometime back in the last century, and he hasn't really updated his model. And do you think it changed between, you know, 2016 when this started and now in terms of if you're pointing out that, like, who matters to him is what matters to his business? Has that shifted? No, not really. Although I think that, you know, we've been doing this reporting for four years at Trump Inc. And there's been a lot of other great reporting out there. The recent revelations of Trump's tax returns, which was an amazing thing by the New York Times. And you think that like DAs couldn't get it. Congress couldn't get it. Various prosecutors couldn't get it. Obviously, we, the public could not get it. But the New York Times got Trump's tax returns. And we understand his business model is one of.

It's a failing business model, but it keeps itself afloat by constantly finding some new people to buy in and to believe that they can be part of his successful project that he's pitching, which is not really successful, until the point at which that project fails and he goes on to somebody else. So, I mean, in 2016, when I spent a lot more time out on the campaign trail, Trump was sort of much more actively pitching himself to sort of white, rural, non-college-educated voters. This year, he has come to understand that he can't win with just those people, which is why he's talking so much about suburbia. But on the other hand, I mean, who understands Trump's strategy? It's kind of nuts, right? I mean, that's what he was talking about at his convention. He's not really talking about that now. It's true, right? Like, it's so changed. And, you know, his actions in the debate.

where he wouldn't even disavow white supremacy, you know, and he wouldn't even, he told the Proud Boys or whatever he said to, you know, stand back and stand by, like that was the best he could do, which was, you know, obviously the opposite of what he was supposed to do is not appealing to those people that he's been told he has to appeal to. So, you know, this is sort of the kind of last stage of the campaign. I mean, whatever comes next, this is the way it is with Trump's business, which is he sort of desperately tries to, you know, keep the boat afloat until he can jump off and go to a new boat and everybody on the old boat can sink. So I have a question for you, Kai, because... I have been thinking about this issue, especially the way in your podcast, United States of Anxiety, you talk about the lessons of history, you talk about Reconstruction. And in the epilogue of my book, back a year ago when I was writing it, I really wrote about how oligarchy, which is really the form of government that Trump has...

brought, which is sort of in the oligarchs world, like only the oligarchs matter, right? So if he matters and then everybody's going to pay him or be part of his family, which is something that he's constantly redefining in a sort of mafia-like way. Like you're in the family if you're loyal to the family. And then you're out of the family unless you're the actual family if you're not. And sometimes even the actual family, like his niece, Mary Trump, is actually an outsider. But one of the things I was sort of thought about is this issue of nativism and oligarchy and how I wrote that there.

two heads of a hydra. But one of the things I've been thinking about is talking about the codes of enforcing white supremacy as sort of the third head of the hydra of sort of Trumpism. And I'm just kind of wondering because, you know, I think about money in politics all the time and you think about white supremacy all the time. And I'm just sort of wondering what is the project of kind of slaying this hydra and how do you see it? It's a small question. I don't even know where to begin on having slay the hydro. I mean, I think what's interesting, what I have found challenging in thinking about the Trump era is that you do have these two explicit things happening at once. You have an explicit white supremacist project. I mean, I think you just have to name that. And that's been the case since the beginning of his administration. Arguably, that's been the case through much of his public life. It is an explicit white supremacist project, which is different and new in modern politics where the white supremacist project, which I think, you know, we have been in it for some time, but it hasn't been an explicit white supremacist project. He has an explicit white supremacist project and he has a fairly explicit oligarchical project.

You know, I mean, both things are quite explicit. So how do they then relate for him? In history, the way they have related is, in the history of Western culture, but certainly in the United States, has been that the white supremacy was constructed to serve the oligarchy. Martin Luther King said it best in one of his speeches about that when the poor white man is, I'm now paraphrasing Martin Luther King, so you'll have to forgive me, when the poor white man's stomach cried out for food, the aristocracy gave him the gamey old bird Jim Crow. And so an explicit project of white supremacy from its inception has been to justify and hold up theft.

theft of labor, theft of black labor during slavery and ultimately. So the relationship between theft and white supremacy, which oligarchy is theft, are inextricably tied. So how do you then take it apart? You know, we've had wave after wave after wave of effort in that, but most of those waves have been focused on rights. That's what I think is an interesting thing that we have to think about now, right? Is that throughout...

Right after the Civil War, the first wave of taking it apart was an explicit economic project. It was, hey, you know, there is white supremacy allowed a creation of wealth that was unequal. For these few people, we have to redistribute that wealth. That actually happened in the country. We had an open wealth redistribution effort in the first 10 years after the Civil War. But after that, it's largely been a conversation about rights and culture. And all those things are important, but they don't touch the wealth part. They don't touch the oligarchy part. From which everything flows. From which everything flows. But other scholars would argue you can't divide it that way. You know, I hear Ibram Kinsey in my mind now saying that the two things are necessarily tied. You can't.

say either or, it's both. But Donald Trump is interesting in that he made both things so explicit. It's almost a gift. You know, he made both things so explicit that we now have to have explicit conversations about the way they're tied. And that's not something we've done since the Civil War. Right. I mean, I've had a set of discussions with the author, Masha Gessen, about can you even call it corruption when they say it out loud? And I think that is the same thing with white supremacy. I mean, I'm so used to covering political campaigns where we're like, oh, look, there's the dog whistle. And it's just not even a dog whistle. It's just a, you know, a fire hose of coming at you of sort of these are our beliefs. And our belief is...

Us. We matter, those in the favorite circle, and everybody who's not in the favorite circle, which now includes the 213 and counting thousand Americans who have died of COVID and their families. To Trump, they are nobodies. Nobody gets COVID, he said, before he got COVID. Well, let me ask you this on this story. So right now, of course, we are watching a Supreme Court nomination unfold that is raw. Whatever we think ideologically, it is a raw use of power to move the Supreme Court nomination. And it is tied very explicitly to Trump's relationship to the Christian right.

He has decided that the Christian right mattered, right? Like that's somebody he decided mattered because it was good for him going back to 2016 and he's still trying to make good on that. And it just, where I'm going with this is it brings me to, it makes me think about the transactional nature of everything with him. And you've written a lot about this, you know, about for him, it's all a transaction. But what I'm wondering about is the people on the other side of the transaction, you know, who, for whom in your reporting, it usually doesn't work out well.

I mean, I feel like you can take about a million examples and let's just sort of put aside our current pandemic and the incredible loss of life and loss of livelihood that's been associated with Trump, who has a non-scientific and indifferent attitude, which he articulates towards the disease. We have this figure, you know, who is so consuming and because of the explicit nature of both the white supremacy and of the oligarchy is such a threat. And, you know, that's how I feel about him. I feel very comfortable saying that. He's such a threat to black people and to the health of the country. Literally. Literally. And so.

The ability to have a conversation, even myself, to think about, OK, but what about after? What about after? You know, say Donald Trump is soundly defeated, then what? You know, and the interesting thing is, you know, when you listen to, as I have been doing, if you listen to folks in the conservative thinkers, folks in the Republican Party who are the anti-Trump Republicans, right? They understand that the Republican Party itself has already given up on what about after in terms of democracy, that it's almost a zombie party, that it doesn't matter because they know that they have shrunk the party to the point where it cannot win in democracy. And thus, both the courts and the census become such raw political battles. Right. A way for the minority to rule the majority. To rule the majority and for 30, 40 years. And history tells us that that is absolutely 100 percent possible. The fact that we fought a civil war and rewrote our Constitution, three amendments, 13th, 14th, and 15th Amendment, rewrote our Constitution in order to make it a multiracial society. And we did. And those are lovely amendments, you know, have flaws.

lovely things. And it is the Supreme Court that proceeded to rewrite those, or reinterpret those amendments, particularly the 14th, to mean that corporations had rights over labor, not that black, that black citizens had rights equal to white citizens. And, you know, and at the same time, there was this project over the entire 20th century to make us forget what we did in those 10 years after the Civil War. And so that's, that's why the remembering is so important now. And again, I keep returning to, it's almost like...

Donald Trump has given a gift. I mean, that's an absurd thing to say, but by making things so explicit, we have been forced into a conversation that we had avoided for 100 years. I mean, I think that's also just really true about sort of talking about the influence with Donald Trump because, I mean, he's made it so clear, so clear. He says it every day, pay me and I'll give you something. I mean, it's just sort of corruption couldn't be more messaged. You know, go to my hotel, do a business deal with me, you will be in the family. And that is the window of what matters. And yes, it is very apparent. I mean, there's no way to even cover Trump with this sort of traditional journalistic tools, this and that.

Because it's so clear what he's doing. And even he is acknowledging that there's no that to his this. So you mentioned the tax story earlier, speaking of trying to cover something. What about the tax story? So what in there, was there anything that you were like, whoa, that I did not see coming? I mean, I think that it really crystallized for me the extent to which Trump has a huge financial stake in winning this election. He's got $400 million of debt coming due in his second term, which we knew about some of it. We knew about, you know, $350 million of it. But the extent to which that debt comes due and then...

If Trump were reelected to a second term, he would be in charge of making macro and sometimes micro economic policy that could affect his lender. So what would you do if you were a bank? Would you default the president if he doesn't pay his bills, which we see he doesn't have the money to do? So that is a very real thing. I mean, the sense of like he doesn't have any money and he has a lot of debt is a problem. On top of that, he has this, you know, audit.

with the IRS. And we've seen how he'll just use the mechanisms of government. I mean, it's just become so apparent that he'll use anything for his benefit. You know, he'll use the Secret Service to take him on a campaign stop effectively while he's infected with COVID. He'll have a political event at the White House. His daughter, Ivanka Trump, is using her Twitter feed, which she uses for official White House business, to campaign for her dad. I mean, it is just really clear, not to mention, you know, the fact that he got his Justice Department to try to dismiss the case against Michael Flynn, to commute Roger Stone's sentence, on and on and on and on. It is clear that he will use the mechanisms of government.

government for his personal and political agenda to maintain power. That is what he will do. So why wouldn't he say to the IRS, you must forgive this $100 million debt that I potentially owe you? Given all of that, what do you think? So I'm going to ask you just to be a prognosticator here. I mean, this is the question a lot of our minds. So given what he faces if he loses, and you've seen, I mean, he's had so many lives. You've seen him with, you know, you've covered what he does when he's got his back to the wall. What then do you expect? What are the next?

couple of months have for us. How would you expect him to react? Not good, not well. I mean, what happens in a normal transition is all kinds of patronage hires, contracts going out to your friends, regulations being removed from your donors. That isn't a normal political administration that happens. And we've seen that Trump just wants to sort of continually help out his friends. So were he to lose, I would expect a very intense...

period of attempted grift of the kind that we have seen that has taken place during his administration. Now, there have been a lot of people who have tried to buy influence that he hasn't been able to quite deliver for them, which is a particular phenomenon of Trumpism. On the other hand, if you're a business person and you have to give $300,000 or buy a block of rooms at the hotel, or T-Mobile spent $200,000 at his hotel, while they were lobbying the Justice Department for support of their merger and then got that. So these are small sums. So even if you don't get what you think you're going to get, it's not a huge investment for somebody in business. And that's the sort of...

money in politics cycle that Trump has really turbocharged. It's always been there. He was somebody who played the game from the other side when he was a private businessman, and now it's just accelerated beyond belief. I am totally focused on the idea that how much he will undermine the process of transition politically and democracy, his willingness to tear things down on his way out the door. That seems to be something I take from the reporting, is that he will destroy things. He's very happy to destroy something if he can't have it. And I hadn't thought about it as...

rather just a sort of mad grab of corruption. Again, we can't call it corruption if it happens in plain view, but a mad grab at grifting on the way out the door. So, I mean, would you downplay the sort of my terrors around what he'll do with his refusal to leave office? You know, I sort of really go back and forth on this. I mean, I think he's been quite clear and there's no reason to, you know, doubt Trump. It's the Maya Angelou quote, right? When, you know, the...

I don't think the word that she used was oligarch. She says, you know, when the authoritarian or whatever she said says something, believe him. Believe them when they tell you about themselves. Right. And Trump has been very clear. He's like, well, we're going to see if it's an honest election. But of course, he's predefined what honest election is. I mean, it's extremely alarming. And Judge Barrett refused to say, well, that's bad. And Pence refused to say that's bad in his vice presidential debate. So, I mean, it's sort of like, you know, it is, as you say, it's sort of this is the zombie party. This is the Republican Party where they're basically saying, like, we will hold on to power if it's not fair as we see it. Things are obviously extremely unfair for people who want to vote against them.

In American history, the response to oligarchy, and we've been in moments before in our history, the Gilded Age comes to mind. There's just been like an incredible rise of oligarchy and very anti-democratic systems. And what's happened is that systems have come in to increase democracy. So you had, at the turn of the last century, you had the progressive era, you had various reforms, you had labor laws, you had the first federal income tax, you had direct Senate voting, you had women's right to vote. So all of these sort of more democratic measures were...

ways of checking that. And it's not like we've ever been a totally non-oligarchic egalitarian society, but we've been worse and we've been better. And now we're definitely in a moment of incredible inequality, which Trump helped to build even before he was in government by sort of having this transactional view, he would pay somebody to get something from the taxpayers, basically take money from the taxpayers and then not give back. What we know from history is that the antidote is more democracy. I sort of feel like as people are voting, I have slight glimmers of hope that sort of exercising the franchise will make it extremely difficult for Trump to not leave, but only if enough people do it. Really, a lot of people do it. My conversation with the United States of Anxiety co-host Kai Wright will continue right after this break.

On this week's On the Media, the new leader of the House Republicans rose to his current position via a novel selection process. Jim Jordan is the chairman of what I call the Fox News Caucus. Jordan has made at least 716 appearances on Fox Weekday programming since August 2017. Don't miss this week's On the Media from WNYC. Find On the Media wherever you get your podcasts.

And we're back talking to Kai Wright of the United States of Anxiety. With the end of voting rapidly approaching, we sat down to talk about the Trump presidency, white supremacy, and the long arc of American history. I like to read history because I feel like it gives me hope because I'm like, wow, like that was a shit show, but they lived through it and we're still here. So I feel like, you know, that's one of the main reasons why I go back and sort of read about really difficult times in history. I'm wondering, what do you think about this moment? And does that historical lens that you've been examining or sort of, you know, how we got here at this point make you feel like, yeah, we'll get through it? Or wow, like we've just never seen anything so bad before, like we can't possibly. Well, I'm going to say, I'm going to start with something that is, you know, real but not positive. You said, you know, that was a shit show, but we lived through it. Not all of us, not all of us lived through it. You know, one of the things that ended Reconstruction was a horrific reign of terrorist violence against Black people that went on for decades.

tens of thousands of people. We don't know how many people were murdered. You know, the National Memorial for Peace and Justice down in Montgomery, Alabama has been trying to, a modern effort, it's just now starting, trying to document those murders and how many we have. But it's a terrifying thing. If you haven't been there, I encourage everyone to go and to just see the number of people that were murdered. And it didn't stop there. I mean, what our history tells us, and this is the sobering thing, I'll get to something positive, but the sobering thing is that at every juncture that white supremacy, that the project of white supremacy has been beaten into retreat, it has happened at gunpoint and through violence.

And that is not to condone either thing, but it's the reality. Ultimately, in order to pass the Reconstruction Amendments, one, we had to go into the Civil War. And then in order to pass the Reconstruction Amendments, they had to ultimately send the army back into the South in order to force it. Because on their own regard, they were not going to accept that Black people were citizens. And so they had to send the army back in order to pass those amendments. And then there was this reign of terrorist violence. And it ultimately took the federal government to step in and start reining in that violence through intervention by, again, sending troops to the South. Again, in the Civil Rights Movement, what it required, what moved the needle for the nation? Was it required Black people putting their bodies on the line in front of?

the television screens, to show the kind of brutality that they were living through. And right now we can see, right, the violence is happening. Charlottesville. We see these sort of moments of violence as wet-offs, like crazy lone wolf moments of violence. But you can also see them as part of a pattern of violent engagement to try to maintain white supremacy in the face of a changing society. And so we should get our heads around the fact that there are people in this country and they're not just fringe elements. There are people in this country who are prepared to fight to the death to preserve the status quo. That is what our history suggests. And that's just sobering. And I don't have anything to say about that other than it's true.

Right. I mean, I appreciate the correction. You're absolutely right. By we, I just meant that the world didn't end. But maybe it's the wrong way of looking at it because obviously it was apocalyptic for an awful lot of people. The fact is, my life is better than my parents. I face less racist, white supremacist violence. White supremacy gets in the way of my life much, much less than it got in the way of my mother and father. Not my grandmother, my great-grandmother, my mother and father. And so progress is a real thing. But I think the challenge we have because we're such an ahistorical society is that we think of progress as inevitable.

And we think of progress as a direct line. But progress comes through great pain, usually. And you're right, there can be great change on the back end of it. But every time we've had great change on the back end of it, there has first been great pain and great struggle. And one of the big deciding points on whether something positive comes out of that great pain, again, history shows us, has been how long people who have something to lose are willing to sit in the pain.

Right. You know, like ultimately when it comes apart, it's been when white people, men, middle class people, those of us who have some sort of investment in the status quo, get something out of it, say enough, you know, like it's been enough. Like we got to I got to move forward. And when that happens, then you start. Because the thing is that what does not happen, the people who are fighting for white supremacy do not get tired and do not give up. And so that is one of the great lessons is that it's hard and it's going to last. To me, what feels like hope is doing the thing that we do, which is doing the documenting.

telling the stories, trying to create the space for the truth so that what happened, you know, what Bryan Stevenson says happened after the Civil War, which is that the North won the war, but the South won the narrative. So for me, just doing the thing that we do is an act of hope. And the moment when I stop is when I lose hope, and I haven't done that yet. This conversation was produced for The Green Space by Saatchi Azura with podcast help from Matt Collette and Bill Moss. You can listen to Kai on The United States of Anxiety on WNYC every Sunday night at 6 p.m. Eastern or download the latest episodes every Monday. And you can listen to Trump, Inc. at TrumpIncPodcast.org or wherever you get your podcasts. My book, American Oligarchs, is out in paperback now. I'm Andrea Bernstein. Thanks for listening.

Capital Ideas podcast Capital Group Want to learn how professional investors do it? The Capital Ideas podcast brings you the latest investment thinking from Capital Group, one of the world's largest investment management organizations. Each week we'll get inside the minds of portfolio managers, analysts and economists to break down market trends, macroeconomic forces, investing approaches and lessons learned from personal experience. Take 30 minutes and tap into the intellectual capital of Capital Group. Capital Client Group, Inc.All Capital Group trademarks mentioned are owned by The Capital Group Companies, Inc., an affiliated company or fund. All other company and product names mentioned are the property of their respective companies.For full disclosures go to capitalgroup.com/global-disclosures. Hold The Line with Buck Sexton The First Digital Inc “Hold The Line with Buck Sexton” is Conservatism’s new command and control center. Former CIA Analyst and nationally syndicated radio host Buck Sexton is ready to stand athwart the progressive tidal wave. One of the movement’s fiercest “wartime conservatives”, Buck brings his unique perspective to America’s most pressing concerns, from domestic policy that values liberty to a foreign policy that puts American interests first. Hold The Line draws upon Buck’s encyclopedic knowledge of the issues, and his experience combatting America’s enemies abroad. Under assault on all fronts, Buck Sexton is ready to inspire viewers to take their place on the battlements and prepare to Hold The Line. Profit Powerhouse Glenn Poulos Glenn Poulos is the co-founder, Vice President, and General Manager of Gap Wireless Inc., a leading product and service distributor for the mobile broadband and wireless markets. With over three decades of experience in sales, he has spent thousands of hours in the field or on the phone with customers and working with salespeople to help create several very successful companies. He is now also the host of this podcast, Profit Powerhouse!Our 20 to 30-min podcast shares amazing founder stories who reveal the smartest strategies for scaling TODAY. AdLunam: The Future of NFTs AdLunam Inc. The Future of NFTs, hosted by AdLunam Co-founder Nadja Bester, is a deep-dive into the fascinating world of NFTs. Join us as we speak to founders, leaders, and visionaries in the NFT space about the unique role NFTs will play in the Web3 landscape. A radical shift in the new era of digital transformation is upon us. WAGMI!

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Trump, Inc.?

This episode is 29 minutes long.

When was this Trump, Inc. episode published?

This episode was published on October 22, 2020.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Trump, Inc. episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.