Skip to content
Who Should Get Credit? episode artwork

Aug 7, 2026 1 hr 10 min

Who Should Get Credit?

from Liminal Dialogues Hosted by Gabriele Pizzi and Nicolas Delgado Alcega

This is a conversation between Nicolas Delgado Alcega and Gabriele Pizzi starting from a practical question of attribution, examining how contemporary academic systems of credentialing, bibliometrics, tenure, and diffuse responsibility shape both the production of knowledge and the incentives of those who produce it. Francis Bacon’s New Atlantis provides a contrasting institutional model in which differentiated roles, intellectual autonomy, political service, and a shared orientation toward truth permit contribution without converting every contribution into a claim on authorship. The discussion ultimately proposes authorship as a locus of responsibility rather than a reward for participation, and asks how institutions might preserve originality, excellence, and intellectual independence without collapsing their members into either interchangeable labor or competitors within a single hierarchy. GP: Okay, well let’s get into it. Do you want to give an intro? NDA: Yes so it’s been a couple of interesting days on this convergence of things we’ve been reading I just finished listening to this excellent audiobook version of New Atlantis by Bacon in some of these new... This recent episode from the students that we both heard on... I don’t remember what they call it, but something like academic decline basic academic apathy and a few other things right? You’ve been catching up on your friend Ahmed’s work at... In the project that’s been evolving in an interesting way. And it’s nice to go back in and see what he is up to. But then also all this collides with some of actual work and problems it brings up over the last couple of days, in particular around the topic we thought would be good to dedicate an episode diving into of authorship. Authorship in particular in relation to how it affects or what is its place in attracting maintaining and stimulating if we want to use the term from the students passionate individuals inside an institution like the one we’re trying to build. And also I would say how it relates or maybe where this comes from at a practical level is because we have for a while been working on a more now substantive version a media apparatus of the organization maybe not in the way one would conventionally think of media which is maybe more like communications like “what are you doing on social media?” But actually in what are all the sort of communicational outputs that we produce that do two things: One of course interact with the outside world but are also the vehicles through which to give a logical form clarify problems put pressure on some of ideas results methods we have. So those move everywhere from things like wide literature from academic publications to maybe great literature to reports that we produce after we run a challenge, to lectures and opinion pieces that are just trying to flesh something out, podcasts articles case studies you know there’s a whole series of things that have been sort of coming together as now may be less of a media theory as we’ve had in the past and tried to pursue but I realized maybe it’s not the time maybe we don’t have the resources maybe you know just thinking about it wrong. But now there’s much greater clarity all of it is starting to really serve a purpose that creates incentives for it to happen. But of course authorship inside of all of that is really important. And it touches upon again the issue so casual right we’re talking about peer review and attribution in peer review. And then we hear the riff on the students on the topic And yeah it just felt maybe good to talk about because I think we’ve been sort of vibing it The way we have been thinking about authorship up to this point And I thought yeah we could start by actually... I’ll draw out maybe what I think are the two spaces That we’ve being vibing from And we can take it from there Yeah okay so I think the you know whenever we had to author something I was reflecting yesterday there we’ve taken on two instincts and I would call one maybe more American and one more European or you know because I think the first one is let’s say the logic of inclusion and this sort of guilt of the author in the American system at least currently certainly much more intensely a few years ago but this place from which you know I’ll maybe try to sketch out what I think it is that happens in that space it is something like postmodernism dismantles the idea of the originality of the author and makes everything into a sort of process, right? Everyone’s just some sort of actor that’s being moved by the process. Maybe that’s postmodernist, maybe that’s a little bit of systems theory. I’m not sure, but that becomes pervasive culture on the one hand on the other. I think there’s a sort of elite overproduction that starts to create these very... These sort of classes of these members of the laptop class let’s say they start to see themselves as labor. Right? And co-opt the labor movement. There’s some really interesting academics in... The laptop class starts to see itself as labor and read everything through the lens of power That’s another consequence of I think the whole post-modernist thing There’s nothing other than power and raw Some positive or negative exchanges of power Usually negative Or some zero Let’s say And that creates A situation where Well so they start identifying as labor and everything becomes about the recognition of labor. This happens in academia as much as in the professional world right? Everything becomes very transactional maybe this has to do with financialization and globalization of the economy as well and so even you know collaborating on something is just a transaction exchange And so it creates this sort of reading to bring it back to something very simple like who gets attributed on paper or what do we write in the acknowledgement or what did we say before we started lecture as an infinite list of thank yous where the author in the end, let’s say whenever you go give a lecture, there’s always of course an author that is authoring the lecture regardless what they’re talking about and who produced the work but it requires sort of bowing down to this endless infinite list of people that go not only to every single person on the ladder that can be identified that contributed to the work. To even you know systems and institutions and previous owners of the land in the case of America right, the indigenous land on which the work was researched and the whole thing is extremely contorted. But I think it ultimately results in a guilt ridden, very Protestant mentality to authorship that we’re in right now. We can say that this is the reason or not to have the right or wrong description. But what we can say is it’s definitely not functional because when something as simple as putting someone’s name behind some sort of output requires all this architecture then it just tells you there’s something that we’re doing that’s kind of contorted and it’s not really meeting reality. It’s just not operating with the right truth. There’s some confusion there That’s one, right? And then the other one - and I would say that there’s a sort of mimetic reason why to some degree we’ve followed that Not that I disagree with the ways we’ve done attribution in the past but I would said comes from that With not really questioning it for 2 reasons 1 because It made sense, like on a challenge when we read a report to have Of course the leadership team and the whole research as well as our team credited on the report. That just makes sense but I think another is just yeah the mimetic thing it hasn’t really felt very relevant to put into question what we were perceiving in a space in which these things were being received so we’re just focused on saying something else rather than questioning this sort I think premise. The… This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit liminalfutures.substack.com

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Who Should Get Credit?

0:00 1:10:03

No transcript yet.

Requests help us decide what to transcribe next.

A Spooky Action At A Distance David Masters Welcome to 'Spooky Action at a Distance,' a weekly podcast where we chart the mysterious spaces between the mundane and mystical. From ghostly tales to UFO narratives, music phenomena to divine conundrums, our exploration rooted in para-psychology challenges conventional wisdom, ignites thought-provoking dialogues, and illuminates the enigmatic threads of existence. Guided by seasoned hosts, we venture into the labyrinth of the extraordinary, investigating each peculiarity from varied perspectives. Tune in, open your mind, and join us on this captivating quest, traversing the spectral landscapes of the strange and supernatural. A Ground Zero Radio podcast Oliver Bardwell Podcast Oliver Bardwell Welcome to ”The Oliver Bardwell Podcast,” where insightful conversations converge. Join me, Oliver Bardwell, author, speaker, and seeker of wisdom, as I engage in thought-provoking dialogues that span spirituality, unity, and diverse perspectives. Delve into respectful discussions with legislators, doctors, education experts, and guests from every corner of life, as we explore a myriad of intriguing topics. From the heart of Iowa to the world, let’s embark on a journey of discovery and understanding together. Inception Dialogues Bernardo Kastrup Exploring the human imagination through conversations about art, myth, theology, psychology, true philosophy, and direct experience Quintus Curtius Quintus Curtius Quintus Curtius is an attorney, writer, translator, and former Marine officer. His books deal with a variety of ethical, moral, and character topics, using examples in history, biography, literature, and philosophy. The result is both unique and inspiring. His podcasts are his personal dialogues with listeners. He can be found at www.qcurtius.com

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Liminal Dialogues?

This episode is 1 hour and 10 minutes long.

When was this Liminal Dialogues episode published?

This episode was published on August 7, 2026.

Can I download this Liminal Dialogues episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.