Today, you've joined hundreds of established and emerging writers who are discovering ways to reach their writing goals and have fun by being more curious, creative, and productive. You're listening to the Ann Crooker Writing Coach Podcast, and this is episode 287, Whose Voice is on Your Pages, Human vs. AI Writing. I opened a newsletter a few weeks ago touting the glorious age of AI and the advantages it provides. Hmm, I thought. AI is fascinating, I guess. Speedy. Clever in its own way. But glorious? It's been studying us. Wouldn't that suggest anything glorious about AI can be attributed in part to what it's drawn from that which makes us gloriously human?
It did, after all train on our published projects like articles, blog posts, and books, which it's already consumed. I've been thinking a lot about AI lately, as headline after headline offers the dire warnings, job losses or lavish praises, glorious, depending on the source. I know clients and colleagues who are using AI extensively in their operations, including research, drafting, and editing. And I know others who have not even tried it once. To be honest, I've gone back and forth on it myself. When ChatGPT was first making headlines in 2022, I interviewed it because I was curious to see how it worked and what it would say. And I was simultaneously freaked out and fascinated.
the results. Should I avoid it or embrace it? I didn't decide on the spot. Instead, I experimented with it in low stakes ways before drawing any conclusions. And it's continued to evolve so rapidly, it feels like I land on an opinion only to change my mind a week later based on new information. I'm suffering from technological whiplash.
Now that AI is embedded in our writing programs, our email inboxes, and more, I'm revisiting my opinion once more. What is the purpose of infusing everything we touch with it? AI companies say AI is part of these systems to assist us, and it very well may be helpful for a lot of people and applications. I've declined it or turned it off wherever possible because I'm starting to wonder if it's there not only to assist, but also to learn from our unfolding ideas, structure, stories, word choice, sentence structure, and style. As it ostensibly helps us, is it also studying the gloriously human way we think? It supposedly works alongside us. As it does, is it being trained not so much on what we're saying, but on how we write and think and puzzle over life moment by moment? After all, writing is thinking, and thinking is one way to be human. This means embedded AI is aware of our every finger tap, learning the human mind at work.
It sees how we think by watching every choice we make as we type a sentence, click backspace, tweak a little phrase to revise and land on a better phrasing and clearer expression. Are these AI systems scanning our composition in Gmail, Google Docs, Notion, or Microsoft in real times, these ideas that we write to make sense of our world, are they looking at that to figure out how we process that which is formulating deep inside us? Are they doing this so they can write better, or are they taking it a step further to gather intel on the way we think so they can write and interact even more like us? Maybe it's my imagination running wild. Authors have tapped their imagination to write novels about trusting computers and machines too much and too early. Filmmakers made movies about it. These were meant to be warnings, cautionary tales. Instead, some storylines seem as if they're being used as blueprints to follow. As a writer, myself, and a coach helping others find their voice, I feel more and more like we should resist using AI for our creative work. It may be fine, let's say, for professional writing.
producing an executive summary from one's own notes, for example. But I feel more and more like we should find AI-free spaces to write more personal or provocative poetry and prose. In these, we express our deepest truths, tell vulnerable stories, reveal transformative narrative, and other life-changing ideas. Allowing AI into that feels intrusive. As I mentioned, good friends, colleagues, and far more successful coaches and creative advisors will disagree with me. They may argue that we should treat AI like a tool. It's here to stay, obviously, right? So don't be a Luddite. And if I don't encourage you to use it, they might worry that you're going to be left behind.
If we writers let AI help with non-creative tasks, it'll free us to focus on our uniquely human contributions. These people might recommend AI as a research tool, a coach replacement, or a writing buddy to discuss the project and be sure we're not missing out on anything, right? Discussing ideas with other people nearly always enhances our ideas. How different is that from engaging with AI? And all these people may be right, but I keep thinking. While I don't mean to be pessimistic or defeatist, AI is worming its way into where it isn't wanted, and our best efforts to avoid it may fail. I suspect it will continue to find and take all that it needs.
Until then, can't we hold off on inviting AI into the private corners of our minds? Why give away thought? Why welcome AI to be part of our creative and writing process simply to be more productive? When we allow it to contribute to our brainstorming process, we're inviting it to tell us what to think. When we take that a step further and ask it to write on our behalf, it's telling us how to express ourselves. When we do that, who wrote it? Whose voice is on the page? Who do we credit when the piece is published?
Are we giving up our distinctly human voice? I'm remembering the scene in The Little Mermaid when Ursula, the sea witch, commands, Sing! And Ariel begins to do so. Ursula shouts, Keep singing! And as she sings, Ariel's voice rises up from deep within her, and it appears in her throat as this shimmering sphere. This ghastly version of Ursula's claw-like fingers reaches into Ariel's throat, grabs the sphere, and pulls it out, and holds it for a moment there. Shimmering. Shimmering. And then sucks it into a shell, where the voice remains inside, trapped. And then strapped around Ursula's neck.
Once she gave up her voice, Ariel got the legs she wanted, but she could no longer speak or sing. The act of writing helps us learn more about ourselves and the world. It's a way to process ideas and determine what we think and believe about them. It's how we develop our voice and share it with others. Do you ever feel that shimmering power when you write? I don't feel it every time I'm working, but sometimes I sense that shimmering energy when I'm deep in creative flow.
Writing can be one of the most rewarding, satisfying activities that result in authentic and intimate expressions of self. Why outsource that? Offering up our gloriously human self to a machine, it might benefit us in the short run, but it's benefiting the machine in the long run, and those behind the machine most of all. Sing, it's shouting, keep singing. It's hard to resist, though, because it's already everywhere, and at times we have to make an effort not to use it. And it is so darn handy. AI can feel like a near-miraculous tool to help us write faster and edit easier things we could do on our own, but slower and with more effort.
No wonder that newsletter said it was glorious. It seems wild when an article draft can just roll out in seconds on the screen. A draft like that might take a day or more with human effort alone. And when we're stuck, it's so easy to ask for a few ideas to get going. I experimented with having AI create some social media content by pulling from a blog post I had written. That seemed helpful and harmless, as the original source was penned by me, so the excerpts were my own words. And I assumed that LLMs had already gobbled up my original source for training purposes because it was already published in public.
One time I had to draft a newsletter, and I didn't actually hate the final product. I mean, it actually did a decent job writing it, but I hated how it made me feel. Unsettled. Unnerved. I scrapped it and started over on my own.
I thought I wanted a quick solution. But when it arrived so quickly, I realized I prefer to wrestle with words and ideas. I needed to land on a conclusion that felt true to me, that emerged from my own internal struggle and questioning. If AI does all of my thinking, I'm shorting myself. And in shorting myself, I think I would short my readers. So, nope, not doing that again, even if it takes me far longer, even if my ideas draw from fewer sources. I know AI can be trained on our voice to sound like us, but if I do that, it's not me. And I'd know it's not me, that it's something pretending to be me.
Wrestling with our drafts, that's part of the human's writing process. We don't need instant answers. We want to grapple with the ideas ourselves and find our own connections. If AI does the research, what did we ourselves actually discover? If AI connects the dots for us, what have we puzzled out to share? If AI outlines the piece, has it landed on a flow that reflects our own way of thinking? If AI drafts the piece or polishes it, what have we actually written?
Matthew McConaughey recently trademarked himself. According to PC Magazine, he did it because these modern tools can convincingly replicate a person's voice or face or image and then place them in situations they never imagined or consented to. And he wants to control when and how his image or voice is used because it's his distinct, shimmering voice. If I let AI write on my behalf, am I granting it permission to create a version of my writing voice? Am I relinquishing my gloriously human voice when I let it kind of replicate me?
I'm not famous, but why would I so easily forfeit my own voice to gain so little when we have Matthew McConaughey modeling this choice to protect ownership of his voice? Now, I hope I'm not coming off self-righteous because I use AI to help with a few useful tasks that I will now describe. I will say, however, that as my conclusions shift, as I suspect they will because they continue to, I will gladly stop even using it for these. Things like... Transcripts from recorded trainings in YPM, which is my platform building membership. Timestamped summaries of those trainings so we can find the key moments in those videos more easily. Direct quotes pulled from interviews that I can share on social media. Pro-con lists related to ideas that I'm considering for my business. Descriptions of upcoming events in my community. Reasons to choose one to-do app over another. Video captions. These are ways that I have been using AI. Will I continue? We shall see. So far, those have felt like non-creative tasks that I delegated to AI and it...
Doesn't feel like I'm contradicting my increasing resolve to leave AI completely out of my writing process. But what would happen if we switched from, you know, let's say AI-assisted to no AI writing at all? What if we revert to exclusively human writing? What's going to happen? Without AI influencing our thoughts or expression, I think we'd produce words far more authentic and satisfying than anything AI could generate on our behalf. Instead of article or essay drafts spit out in seconds, we'd write forward through resistance and enjoy aha moments that burst into our minds like shimmering balls of light. Without AI, you'll feel something inside your head and heart that whirs and stirs in an only human way.
That said, if you are using AI and you feel like it is in no way taking over your creativity, please keep using it. Don't let my line of thinking make you feel defensive, upset, or shamed. Use it thoughtfully and intentionally if you have discovered how to enhance your work and you feel good about it. Make your choice boldly. I would encourage you to just notice if at any stage of your creative process, AI is throttling your own glorious voice or altering it to the point of being unrecognizable. If so, revisit your reason. Is AI serving you well? If yes, keep going. If not...
Maybe find a way to return to human-only writing. A word about publishing and AI writing. Publishing is reacting to changes in AI and how authors are employing it. So what I share right now might be obsolete next month. But if you are pursuing publishing, consider the following. If you're going to submit your writing to an agent or publisher, especially a traditional publisher, consider absolute minimum or zero. It's better to have zero AI input. Even though publishers themselves are using AI in their processes and workflows, they seem to be requesting that writers do not at all.
So certainly, if you use it at all, like for AI assistance, document how you've used it so you can show that to your editor or your agent. I think the primary reason for requesting no AI is to ensure that the copyright is legally yours. As I understand it, AI content cannot be copyrighted. So that seems to be at the root of it. I'm not a legal expert, but that's how I understand it. And then here's another fun filter when you're struggling with this and debating about things. Ask yourself, when it comes to AI, what would so-and-so do? So think of a writer you admire, even somebody who's no longer alive. If they understood what AI is capable of, how would they use it or would they use it at all?
Plug in a name. When it comes to using AI, what would Madeline Lingle do? Emily Dickinson? Ray Bradbury? Wendell Berry? Well, we all know what Wendell Berry would do or would not do. Anyway, swap those names for your own literary heroes and let them kind of offer you guidance, even if you have to imagine their response. If you've been using AI, you may be thrilled at how much faster you complete projects. So if you've been listening and you're kind of rethinking your use, you will find it hard to switch back to 100% human effort.
Writing from start to finish all on your own will take longer, even for speedy writers. Slowing down can, of course, be a problem if you're under a deadline and your draft isn't even started. But if you can take time to tackle it all on your own, I believe gloriously human writing contributes and leads to a more glorious humanity. Some AI optimists are saying that AI's ability to problem solve will definitely benefit humanity. And I don't claim to speak into that at all. And I know I'm even taking a risk weighing in with these thoughts on AI and writing. And maybe this is starting to sound like a manifesto. But I am just concerned that letting AI take over much of our writing process means AI is going to be contributing in some way in that way.
way to humanity as much or more than humans. And we're going to end up with a strange, circular, ever-shrinking experience with fewer fresh ideas emerging as we writers keep drawing from that same well. If we take it from the one that AI is giving us, we're just sloshing it around and pouring it back again, back into that same well. And this is arguable. Feel free to disagree.
In fact, I can think of one way to disagree, which is that you could argue that writers have been caught up in a kind of circular experience as we continue studying the greats. When we learn and apply their techniques, passing along in new packages the same old hero's journey with its tropes and techniques, or we read challenging classic essays and build on their ideas, that's kind of the same thing, right? We're drawing from the well and putting back into the well. But I don't know. Readers engage with the written word in a much more intimate way than AI ever could, even when analyzing it. When we engage with texts preserved over the ages, untouched by AI, we aren't mechanically memorizing it. It becomes part of us.
And what we write next is far more thoughtful than parroted paraphrasing. I prefer to be part of a line of humans, reading, reasoning, and interacting with texts penned by other humans, not a line of AI-generated thoughts. As we write during this glorious era, increasingly infiltrated by AI, I do think it's wise to continue to read about it. Learn AI's rapidly expanding capabilities so you are not left behind or taken by surprise. I subscribe to newsletters focused on AI advancements so I can stay alert, and at times, to be honest, alarmed. But when it comes to your writing, take your own notes. Create your own outline. Write your own draft.
In those early iterations, do all of it without AI assistance, so you'll come to your own conclusions first. Write as yourself, as your gloriously human self. And write from yourself. Bring your messy message, your half-formed truths, and let writing itself be the tool you use to sort it out. Grapple with ideas and sentence structure and word choice to convey your meaningful message. And I'm here for all the misplaced modifiers and overused filler words. Guess how we can fix that? Yes, I know, you can let AI clean up your draft. But you could also read it aloud, self-edit, or...
even hire human editors who bring their gloriously human skills to our pages. So whose voice will be on your pages? I hope it's your gloriously human voice. I don't want to read what you asked AI to write for you. I want to read what you have to say, the way only you can say it. Maybe it'll be a little less organized, a little repetitive, but it'll be your voice singing, shimmering on the page.
As you work through how to insert more of your gloriously human voice onto the page, look for tools that can help you with that. You know that I have some for you. You can check them out at anncroker.com slash everything. And I'm Ann Croker, cheering you on as a writing coach in your ear everywhere we may meet. At my website, here on this podcast, in your inbox, or even in person, I'm always looking for ideas to share with you that will help you achieve your writing goals and have fun by being more curious, creative, and productive. Thanks for being here.