With Export Development Canada, Canadian businesses are competing, leading and winning in more international markets, like how agri-food businesses are strengthening global food supply, and critical minerals are powering industries of the future. Their ambition can't be contained, and with EDC behind them, neither can their growing. Export Development Canada is the financial partner for Canadian businesses going global. Visit EDC.ca for more. I'm Aina Garten, and each week on Happy Hour, I invite new and old friends for a drink and a fun conversation at my kitchen table in New York City. On this week's episode, I'm joined
by Julia Louis Dreyfus. We talk all about attending a fashion show in Paris together, throwing dinner parties, and making her Broadway debut in other desert cities. No episodes of Happy Hour are available every Wednesday. You can watch on YouTube or listen wherever you get your podcasts. Cheers!
How far would you go to have a healthy baby? Embryo editing is very much illegal in the United States, is illegal in most countries, but there is growing interest as the technology has gone better. This week on Explain It To Me, the ethics of embryo-maxing. Listen to new episodes, Sundays, wherever you get your podcasts. Hello, and welcome to The Coder. I'm your I-Patel, Editor-in-Chief of The Verge,
and Coder is my show about big ideas and other problems. Today I'm talking of Peter Kafka, who is Chief Correspondent at Business Insider, and host of Channels, a podcast about the media industry. It's a big week for the media industry. Comcast has now split itself up into the Comcast broadband company and the NBCUniversal Entertainment Company. That comes after the media giant spun out its cable assets like CNBC and MSNBC and MSNBC, into a new company called A Versant earlier this year. Quick note before we start by the way,
long time per chance we know we've been disclosing that Comcast NBCUniversal was an investor in our parent company of Vox Media for years now. That's all come to an end. Not only did that investment spin out with Versant, but Vox Media itself is splitting in two. In that Versant stake, now lives inside of a shell company that is part of a joint venture with a Penske Media Corporation called PMX, and PMX technically does not exist yet. It is all very complicated, and I promise I will sort out a simpler disclosure when all of these deals close, but for now the upshot is the same, etc. None of these companies have ever told us what to do or say in our
reporting, and we wouldn't let them fully try. Which is good, because Peter and I have a lot to say about Comcast. He and I have been covering media and telecom as friends, peers, and competitors for years now. And Comcast was the biggest bet on the idea that combining media assets like NBC with access and distribution like Comcast and the broadband network would somehow pay off. This idea which you'll hear us loosely call content plus pipes is irresistible to media and telecom people.
They cannot say away from it. AT&T tried content pipes on about Time Warner, Verizon tried content pipes on about AOL and Yahoo. Hell AOL itself tried content pipes when I bought Time Warner in the early 2000s. You might notice a trend here. All of these deals ended in disaster, but Comcast managed to hold it together with NBC for 15 years, even though it could never quite explain what the value there was in putting the content near the pipes. And as you'll hear Peter say, this big split feels that the
company finally admitting it never really had that answer, and capitulating to Wall Streets demands. Peter and I talked a lot about what comes next for Comcast and NBC. Both companies have existential choices ahead of them and face stiff competition. It's unclear if there are more deals coming to either sell or acquire more assets. We also talked a lot about how we got here and why content plus pipes always crashes and burns. You'll hear us talk a lot about net neutrality in that context.
That's the idea that ISPs like Comcast have to treat all the traffic on their network equally. They can't throttle Netflix and prioritize peacock. The ability to do that might have been the entire economic basis of content plus pipes, but Peter and I disagree on whether it was regulators or the market that kept the internet from turning back into cable TV in that way. This is a good one. As you'll hear, Peter and I really like talking to each other about this stuff. Okay, Peter Kafka on the
Comcast way. Here we go. Peter Kafka, the chief correspondent for Business Insider as well as the host of the excellent media industry podcast channels. Welcome to decoder. Thank you, Neelai. Thank you for having me. I have to say
channels like I was just on it. That's how I know it's good. That was an excellent episode. Yeah. And so we're training it back. But I'm really excited to talk to you
about what's going on with Comcast because it feels like you and I have spent our careers weaving in and out of covering Comcast around each other. You especially. Turns out we were stupid. We should have just slept for the last 15 years and woken up and then nothing would have changed. One of my favorite moments of all the weaving back and forth was it wasn't Comcast specifically, but you had read Hastings on stage at an all things D org code conference and you asked about net neutrality, which we will come to in the course of this conversation. And he
was like, yeah, it's over. We're big enough. It doesn't matter anymore. And that's in many ways, this was a pivotal moment in the history of internet and content. Because what he was saying was that he had reached enough scale so that the distributors, the power now had to come to his terms. And if you look back, I think
you can trace almost everything that's happened to that moment. Netflix announcing to you that they were big enough that everyone had to deal with them. Yeah, I mean, it's funny because I always think of that as a classic like, Oh, nerds or people who care about this thing that we said we cared about. That's fine. We've just moved on because there was a huge part of the internet or internet culture that was just despondent about the fact that Netflix had been their sword carrier for the stuff and that they were done carrying swords.
Shield carrier. Shield. They have a sword in the. Yeah, you're. But you put you've you've nailed it. I mean, we'll get into it. But I think Netflix is the great example
of why this convergence dream that Comcast among many others chased doesn't is not material for 2026. And they're finally acknowledging. Yeah, everyone had to go to Netflix because Netflix had built enough audience. And I think that's where you can begin this conversation about to where you can end it, right? The contest is going to break itself up into a content arm and a broadband arm and maybe those two companies will work together. Maybe they won't. But there's just a
moment that I think you can point to and say, Oh, this was inevitable. It was inevitable that the dream of the giant multinational conglomerate would have to unbundle itself. And we feel I feel like we're in a time of great unbundling right now. Yeah, this is a classic cliche. The media media bundles and re bundles were in the unbundling part of the pendulum shift. I'm sure at some
point we'll move back to hey, would it be great if we bundled? But yeah, I mean, the great thing is the bankers and lawyers remain undefeated because they get paid no matter what for every you do a transaction, it makes no sense. You get paid to undo the transaction. Every time anyone says that to me, I quit being a lawyer to be a judge. I could have been paid on every every one of these deals. Let's
start at the very start. I jumped way into the weeds because it's true. You and I have covered concas together and around each other for so long. But let's just start at the start here. Congas and now it's splitting itself up at a high level.
What's happening here? So Congas started splitting itself up earlier this year. It spun out what is now called Versants. That's their collection of cable networks that no one wants. And they split that off. And that was pure financial engineering.
That was, Hey, maybe if we get rid of this thing, this declining asset Wall Street will value us more because their stock really has been sort of mired for for many, many years. That did not move the stock cut to last week. And now it's okay, we'll split ourselves up even more. We are now going to be what we were before we bought NBC Universal going to be a Comcast, the company that sells it to your home and now some other stuff as well. That would be one company.
That'll be another company that is NBC Universal, which is NBC the broadcast network Bravo the cable network for some reason. Peacock the streaming network, the Universal Studios theme park business, big business and the actual film and TV studio by Universal. So there's a big assets and their all entertainment. And for years and years and years, Comcast CEO Brian Roberts would get asked by all two folks, why do you own a media company and infrastructure company? And he would have some answer that didn't really make sense. And the real answer is
now, which is actually we shouldn't have those two companies combined. They should be separate companies. Let's rewind. Just a little bit. Congas buying NBC Universal was a big deal at the time. And a lot of people made the argument that Comcast and VC was the only
company of its kind that actually worked. That every other company that had tried to smash together content and pipes kind of failed from the jump. AT&T time Warner, I think is maybe the classic example of this. Yeah, they didn't even get started. Yeah, they were like, well, this failed instantly.
And AT&T would make crazy arguments about why it would work, but they were going to load clips of Game of Thrones on mid-range Android phones and that would make people pick AT&T. And they were going to have amazing data somehow and under pants now. Yeah, and it literally just like didn't work from the very beginning. There was an argument that Comcast and DC Universal worked for a time. What was that argument? I don't know about that argument, honestly.
Like it never worked in terms of there is a synergy between owning the pipes that distribute content and owning the content. Comcast did own some cable and stuff before they went and bought NBCU. So that made sense to fold into NBCU. You can argue that NBCU performed well as an asset under Comcast. Again, that theme park business is a real business. They've invested a lot in that. Studio has ups and
downs, but it's still a thing that exists and is valuable. But I don't think they've ever proven that there is some benefit from adding the content company to the distribution company, which is what a lot of people thought was going to happen when they merged and freaked out a lot of people. What happens if this big cable distributor now owns these cable networks? And in fact, that was a real concern for the Department of Justice. They had all kinds of remedies and restrictions around that murder to prevent abuse. But in the end, I don't know that anything that
Comcast, the cable, the pipes company was helped at all by owning the content or vice versa. And yet it persisted this long. I mean, this is 10, 15 years into this experiment. Why did it last so long if the thesis never made any sense? Great question. Comcast has a publicly owned company, but it's really a family
owned company. It's the Roberts family. Like a lot of these big media and now tech companies, they are essentially family run companies, even if they're publicly traded as the New York Times, that used to be Viacom. It is now a paramount. We can keep going down the list of Wall Street Journal, the Murdochs, again, publicly traded controlled by one family. So it can be as simple as Brian Roberts saying,
no, this is going to work. And mind you, they were still trying to expand their media business as recently as a few months ago. They were bidding for part of Warner Brothers discovery. They were the third bidder in that deal. They didn't try that aggressively, but they were willing to spend billions of dollars to expand that media company. I think it is probably as simple as after years and years and years
of being told by Wall Street, we don't value this asset. You want it all? We don't care about this giant media company. We only care about your broadband company. They found, okay, we will take you at your word Wall Street. We'll
split it up. And it's that simple. And what the why they stuck it out for 15 years. I mean, that's we sort of we do make fun of AT&T buying Warner media and ditching it a couple years later, at least with AT&T, you can say, they looked around and said, we thought we'd get rewarded by Wall Street for this deal. The real, they had this synergy plan for AT&T and Warner Brothers discovery. But the real answer was, we thought if we owned a media company, we
would get valued like Netflix is valued. And Wall Street again, did not value it, did not reward AT&T at all for that deal. And they turned around and said, all right, let's just get out of here. And so you could argue that AT&T behaved more responsibly than Comcast and Comcast would argue, look, we just, we have behaved responsibly. We've grown this asset. The fact that we're splitting it up
is just a tech accounting. Well, two things are one, it's funny because Netflix is fundamentally valued like a tech company, not a media company. So everyone feels very confused about that just from the jump. And second, AT&T might have been more responsible. Fundamentally, the thing they did was they gave Zack Snyder millions upon millions of dollars to make a grayscale version of Justice League in four, three, which is just one of the all time funniest telecom company investments in history, I think. They had so many great deals. They did that
friends reunion with poor Matt Perry all all drugged up and sorry, that's actually kind of grim story. I shouldn't get into that. They generated a lot of entertainment for us. So that was good. Yeah, give them credit for that. You and I state in
business, but it is funny that AT&T, you know, telecom companies are more like a tech company on its face than a media company. And they chase the tech company evaluation by investing in media. And it feels like maybe Comcast is one of that same thing. And they actually got the benefit of running a media company people liked. Yeah, and they bought it cheap, right? They bought it cheap from from
GE, get conglomerates love media companies. And why did GE own a media company? What did that to do with GE finance or any of the industrial? Nothing. They just wanted a one immediate company. And they concluded that wasn't helping
either. So they spun it off at a fairly cheap price. And again, Comcast can say that deal has worked out well for us, you know, on our P and L. It just has not rewarded with shareholders have not rewarded this work. This kind of brings us to the immediate question. You're going to turn Comcast one big company into two
smaller companies. Is this designed to create value by having those smaller companies get bought themselves further split up? It seems like all the executives are saying that is actually not the plan, but it feels like an obvious next step. It feels like an obvious next step. First of all, like you said, the Comcast folks have been asked about this and said, absolutely not, we're not selling, we're not selling, we're not selling, which can be absolutely what they mean. And it can be absolutely what they mean up until the day to day to
sell one of those assets. There's tax implications that make it difficult for them to go and turn something around right away. So they might end up holding these things for some period of time before they decide to sell them. I think it's worth noting that if you're a Comcast shareholder, you're going to own 20% of this spun out company, but not for very long, they're going to sell that down. So to me, that's a little bit of a tell. But the main reason it flashed in my
mind that this will be an M&A event is when Warner Brothers Discovery was trying to financially engineer its way out of the whole, the message made with its AT&T deal, they were going to split their company up into the good company, which was the HBO and the studio and the cable assets. And the idea was, one, we'll dump the cable assets, maybe that will make our existing stuff look more valuable to investors. Also, there's lots of companies out there that want to buy HBO and or movie studio. There are no companies out there that want to buy HBO Warner Brothers and a bunch of declining cable networks. Turns out they were wrong, there was a paramount. But again, anyways, they were splitting these things up to make them more
sellable, to make them more attractive for sale. So two things can be true at once. They can say they have no intention of selling either of these assets, people think can be charter and Comcast as a combination on the other side, but they have now made them more acquireable if they want to do that. What's about versus one second? That was the first thing that split off. You can
see that they were just trying to cut costs there, maybe most definitively in the rebranding of MS now upon which they spent approximately $0, right? Like the graphics badge for that is straight out of Microsoft thing, like the zero effort was put towards rebranding MS now. This thing is just going to work for it because I cannot tell you I'm familiar with the graphics package. This is the reason they didn't spend any money on it. So you see that a little bit better than Kepi NBC in the name because that's a household brand that might be the biggest piece of that puzzle, is that CNBC is still doing well. What is the future of versus if all the cable
channels that were distributed on Comcast network are declining, all of Paramount's cable channels are declining, it feels like that company has only one direction to go in unless it radically reconfigures itself for the internet. That's what it seems like to me and anyone else from the outside and go, if you bought the stuff was valuable, you would have kept it. Comcast has two responses to that. One is, hey, if we really thought this was a piece of shit, we would have loaded it up with a bunch of debt like AT&T, David Warner Brothers, which then prevented Warner Brothers from ever doing anything else after that. And we have not done that. That is true.
If they really wanted to like really just make that a garbage disposal of a company, they could have done that. And then I had, I had Mark Lazarus, CEO versus not, there he is aware that his cable assets are declining. And his goal is to build them up with something else to take things that are declining, but they still throw off a lot of money, throw off less money each year. But the idea is while that stuff is still making money, can we go and find other things that will generate more revenue for us? You know, you wouldn't have encountered Comcast forever. The main thing I've done forever
is watch old media companies try to struggle with new technology. And even when they can see the future, because some of them can't see the future, but eventually they all can sort of see the future. Okay, we know the future's over there. The existing business we have is over here. We have to keep running that business or we can't get to the new thing. And they usually get screwed. They
usually can't figure out how to go to the new place while staying in the old place, because that would require some kind of time travel, right? Or a foot on each canoe is the easier, the easier metaphor. So that is what person is trying to do. We have this existing declining, but profitable business. What can we turn that into? That's the pitch.
We need to pause here for a quick break. We'll be back. What if we told you that there was one thing you could eat to reduce your risk of death by about a quarter? Interested? And what if we added that this magical substance can dramatically lower your cholesterol, improve your mood, and keep your weight stable? No, it's not protein. It's actually fiber, the least
sexy, most overlooked nutrient of all. But what is fiber? How could one nutrient do all those amazing things? And how can you get enough? Is it powder? You
stir into some water? Are you going to do it for you? All that plus the strange tale of the Gorilla poop obsessed, father of gorn plex in the latest episode of Gastropod, find Gastropod and subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. We're back with Business Insider Peter Kafka discussing the unbundling of Comcast. The reason I asked that is usually a foot in each new is great, but you got to turn down the money from the old canoe in order to go invest in the new money that you might make on the new platforms.
First, it makes a lot of money because people have cable packages and they get paid for CNBC and MSNBC and whatever else, regardless of what they watch us. And this is the greatest business model in history, right? Like we're just doing the podcast. We should know that Peter has a lot of history covering these companies. And it's not obvious by now. This is the
greatest business model history. You get paid no matter what, just because people subscribe to subscription bundle of cable channels. That business is not just in decline for version, it's in decline overall. And you can see it because Comcast pay TV business is essentially in free fall. This is what's called cord cutting and it is just happening. Every single month, it
massive rates. I think there are maybe 50% of their peak in 2008, they're like under 10 million pay TV subs. There's a lot of reporting that YouTube TV is not bigger, which is wild considering how expensive YouTube TV is. If you if YouTube TV is not bigger, now it will be in a year or two, it will be the biggest pay TV company in America. Is there any way out of that beyond just cutting bait? Because it feels like Comcast splitting off its
access division, its broadband and pay TV division is a sign that that business is going away somehow or getting smaller somehow. And then versus tidy the economics of the pay TV business, unless it can reinvent itself. All the cable channels are tidy the economics of the pay TV. Yeah. So what's on the first thing about Comcast, the broadband company?
Well, I'm focused on the fact that this one company that has sort of intertwined economics is splitting itself into three. And the economics are still intertwined. And I don't see how the pay TV business ever recovers. And if the pay TV business never recovers, the cable business at version can't ever recover. And so everyone has to pivot away from their core businesses. Yeah, versus needs to be in it.
Bursa can't be in the words, you're buying a package of MS now and CNBC and the golf channel from us in five years, right? They know that. I mean, they might still have a segment of that, just like AOL still had a dial up business for years. Well, it was like a dirty secret that people, old ladies are still paying for dial up. So that's like an interesting, you know, business school case study, right? How do you know this thing is happening? What can
you do? How can you extract value out of it? Will this thing be a standalone company for X number of years or will it then get combined as something else? Well, some version of bending spoons buy it for the for the digital blue factory that is bending spoons. The Comcast part of it is pretty interesting because for several years now, the Comcast argument has been, we're not really a cable TV company anymore. In fact, we don't actually care
if you buy cable TV from us. We're happy to sell it to you. But we really, all we want is for you to buy our broadband. And that is an awesome business. It is super high margin. We have, they want to use these words, either a
monopoly or a dewopoly and almost every market we're in your, if you want the internet, you're getting it from us. And after that, we don't care what you do. And that looks like an awesome business. And there was a point in which they formally crossed over and had more broadband subscribers and they had video subscribers. And that was a big moment. Like there are no Comcast is not a
cable TV company anymore. And so that, and so if you look at where they are, that all makes sense, because it's shedding media. Their other problem though, is that the broadband business is not as good as it used to be because there actually is competition now. There is fixed wireless from T-Mobile and Verizon. I'm sure folks who listened to Coder have heard you talk about this in the past, but it went from being sort of a fringe idea to its real competition now.
Now their broadband numbers, which used to go up and up and up every year, are now flat or sometimes down because they are facing real competition. So that's a problem for them. They are trying to sort of engineer their way out of that. But one thing they're doing on top of that is saying, I guess we should be in another business. Okay, why don't we sell wireless? If the wireless guys
are going to sell broadband, we can sell wireless. So they are now building up a wireless business. And there's no obvious synergy there, other than if you're going to buy internet from us, maybe you'll buy a phone connection as well. So it is not, it is not a clear cut sort of business as it used to be even like five years ago. That wireless business has always been a puzzle for me. They've tried it for many
years and the markets are in to bundle wireless. But they're always reselling someone else's network. They haven't built one of their own other big pay TV companies that have tried to build their own wireless networks and pivot their businesses. More or less fallen on their face. I'm thinking of dish network specifically here. They were supposed to be the big winners of the
T-Mobile and Sprint merger where the government literally engineered a deal for them to take over some spectrum and part of Sprint's network. Just not just a clear bankruptcy. This did not work. It is too hard to do at scale. Is Comcast going to try to build its own network and broadband or they can keep reselling Verizon? Do you have a plan to be actually competitive here?
I would assume that it's a reselling and bundling plan. You know, I'm not I'm not a spectrum expert by any means. I'm not sure what's available, what they would need to be competitive in that market. They, you know, again, their messaging is we're a buyer, not a seller. All right. So if you're a
Comcast and you're running a broadband and wireless company, what would you buy that would make you more competitive? I don't know. I'm sure there are listeners right now who are screaming at the dish network. We're going to stand up and network plan was always a sham in order to collect spectrum assets and resell on our profit leader, which is what happened, but still drove that company into bankruptcy. I'm very curious that the Comcast broadband division that's going to get split out has a plan to grow because I'm looking at the numbers. I think they lost 700,000 subscribers last year. That's a huge
number. Their only way to grow is actually to grow outside of the markets they're in. So there's some talk that they'll combine with charter, which doesn't operate in the same markets as Comcast, but that doesn't get you any economy of scale, right? Running a bigger physical network doesn't get cheaper. It actually only gets more expensive.
They're, they're announced strategy to deal with these losses and this overall problem is we're going to operate it better. And it has to be with pricing and, you know, deals and how we've been, how we've been selling and we're going to make the selling easier and all that. Sure. Operate it better. But that's not a, it's, that's a fix the business, not grow the business plan.
Every Comcast subscriber just heard their internet providers say they're going to cut costs and operate leader and thought about their customer service experience. I'm sure. And then thought about those cheaper fixed wireless plans. This is the conundrum they're in. They have to provide a higher quality service for less money. Is this the part of the store we mentioned? Elon Musk?
Actually, yeah, it's literally the next question. You were doing the podcast ago. This is great. SpaceX went public. The only part of that company that makes money is its telecom is it is startling. So much so that there are rumors that
they will buy teamable, which is hilarious to me because SpaceX chasing telecom economics with their fixed costs of launch or anything else they're doing. I don't know if a telecom economics can support it. But why? That's because you're not smart enough. You don't have enough intelligence. You're not creative enough to understand what a galaxy sized
ham is. Yeah, I have no idea. I mean, like, they're already competing with the team, Mobile's of Horizons to sell to sell you internet access and they may well be combining may well be competing with Elon Musk. Again, just because Elon Musk enters a market does not mean he wins. We've now seen evidence of that several different times. But he's certainly a real player that they have to worry
about. The startling premise, at least until now, is I will bring you broadband quality connectivity in places where no cable company would ever dare to spend the infrastructure investment of playing fiber. Comcast has big physical plans in cities, mostly. At least even shout out as a contest customer. It is true. The Comcast was essentially monopoly or duopoly in almost every
apartment building in Chicago. And most people, when you just had Comcast, certainly has to show up and compete there in ways that they can't yet. This is why people think they might buy T mobile. Then the competition looks like, okay, you can get pretty fast access for the same or less money. And then you're in a price war. I would say Comcast is on almost everything it can do in its history
to avoid that kind of competition. Have they shown any signs of being able to meet that? No, I mean, they've been facing real competition from the telcos and losing broadband subs. And what they've said is, okay, the people who are doing that aren't running the business anymore. We have new people running the business is the real answer there. I will say, again, I really know very
a little bit spectrum. I will say there are sober minded people who continue to think that the fixed wireless business has sort of a hard cap in terms of how many customers it can serve. But there's like literal, just sort of physical limits on what you can do with that. And so, and I think that's also probably Comcast hope is these guys can only get so big. And then they can't sort of get into our markets beyond that. But that's also kind of the inverse of whatever cable TV
executive was saying in 2010 to 2015, which is, well, maybe cable TV subscriptions will slow a little bit, but they're not going to go to 50%. Yeah, and they're going to produce the other hope that I hear is that Starlink does require fiber network on the ground. You can connect to satellites all day long, but they got a ground station, then you'd massive bandwidth on the ground, the support of those customers. And maybe just maybe these ISPs will put themselves in the business, supplying the back all. It's just can't believe we're still talking about ISPs and it's 2026. But here we are. It's the whole world
runs and these things. And it was inevitable that you and I would have this conversation. You thought this was boring when I was obsessed with it in like 2011. It was funny. We did. I did a seven part eight part narrative
podcast about Netflix for the Vox Media podcast networks several years ago. And I was like, Oh, I've been following this company forever. And I know the beats of it. And I know what's important. And we're definitely going to spend one episode talking about Netflix's efforts to sort of Netflix is a huge fight with Comcast when you brought up the beginning and how crucial it was for them to figure out how to move bits around the internet more effectively and who is going to control how those bits were gated, etc. And this is nerdy stuff,
but it was core to the company. And I would tell my colleagues about this and they just all just gave me a blank look. And no matter how many times I tried to retell the story, I gave me a blank look. My point is no one wants no one in my world wants to hear about Comcast fighting Netflix over the future of the internet. But it was a big, big deal like you referenced what 2010 to 2015 was a five year and they were angry. They were at each other. Now they're business
partners. But it seemed at the time that this was an existential problem for both of them who was going to control those pipes was there going to be a toll booth for the data that moved through those pipes. And the answer is, Well, all right. So this does interesting. Here we go. This is if you're
listening to this, this has been Peter and I debating whether or not this is important or interesting for over a decade. So here's my argument for why it's important and interesting. If you're to go to listen, you had to know this was coming. The fight was whether Comcast and the other internet providers could turn internet access into cable TV, whether they could recapitulate that business model, which we have both agreed is the greatest business model in the world. AT&T tried to do it. Comcast tried to do it. Literally every ISP tried to do it.
AOL maybe did it the best. And that's why they bought Time Warner, right? You bought access from AOL over a phone line. You open the AOL app and it showed you content and the idea that they could put economics around that content and preference their own was the heart of AOL's entire purchase of time where failed disastrously. I think we should note, but that was their argument.
The argument for Comcast, AT&T, whoever else to buy content and put on their pipes was that they would charge everyone else to reach you, the consumer and give you their stuff for free. And then the economics of their stuff would increase in some way. Or in the most hopeful scenario, you would pick Comcast as your ISP because they had NBC and they would keep NBC away from Verizon or make NBC so expensive to access on Verizon that when the Olympics came around, it was cheaper for you to switch to Comcast than to pay the rates on Verizon. Or maybe more simply, they would just say, Netflix, you have this great service. It only works if people can get on the internet. So you're just going to pay us
a little, little, little big for each other. Yeah, and I would get passed on to the consumers. Yes. Right. And so like your rates as a customer of the internet would vary in spectacular ways depending on who your ISP was. And this was the fear.
And I think the reason in 2010, 2011, it was like an outrageous fear was that all that internet platform startups realized that this was an existential threat to them. This is why Alexis Wainan, who's a co-founder of Reddit, styled himself as the mayor of the internet and like toured around the country on a bus being like, we have to have net neutrality because if they can throttle right, I won't be able to pay that big. And it's the ISPs will determine what platforms succeed or fail. The moment I'm talking about when rehasting said to you, we're big enough so that net neutrality doesn't matter anymore. One, and I think we all saw that it was over.
But the reason I'm saying I knew that it was over for the ISPs in their media dreams was that consumers had picked Netflix and they would not tolerate the fee. So Netflix had enough leverage to say, no, our content is going to be on your networks, whether or not you want it to be. And everyone else could just piggyback Netflix and say, no, YouTube has the same arrangement. If you have a AT&T network or a Comcast network, you charge your customers a fee and then you charge them more to access the things they want. That won't work. And this was the argument. It's the argument from all the FCC people,
it's the argument from the Verizon executives that have been on the show, ultimately came to nothing because the market demanded net neutrality. If you would ask a telco person about this during this entire time, they could point out one time where this has happened, where we have successfully extorted someone into paying us more for their access to our pipes. I think honestly, this was much more of a fight with the cable networks, who wanted distribution. This is Bloomberg versus Comcast. This was a long running fight about what kind of carriage Bloomberg could get on Comcast owned pipes. And I think for the
remaining companies that still have cable TV networks, that still was a big deal. cable TV network has zero utility if you can't get it over someone's, if you can't deliver it to someone's TV. And that was a real problem. Otherwise, I'm saying that it's not that matter, it's not because you can just distribute it via a digital service provider. But yeah, that was, I think net neutrality mattered much more to the cable TV nets than it ever did to an internet company.
Well, I think the internet company is all needed. It's matter. They needed it to not be there, so they could preference their own content. This is the argument that I'm making. If Comcast had a peacock and watching peacock was free and watching Netflix incurred some additional charge, I think we all understand how Comcast customers probably watch more peacock today than they do.
But they weren't allowed to do this first because they all insist the market wouldn't let them. But secondly, maybe more importantly, that big complicated Comcast NBC merger agreement, the regulator said you can't do that for some long period of time. So they weren't allowed to achieve their vision. AT&T tried this in weird ways. There was a time when HBO Max didn't hit the data cap for AT&T subscribers and they got real spiky when I asked them about it. And then they
turned it off because they realized that they didn't want that fight and it didn't matter because no one was using AT&T phones to watch AT&T. There's something here where it could have played out differently, right, where the self-preferencing of the networks for their own content might have actually worked. I look back and I look at every attempt from every company to make you watch something you don't want to watch as much as paid for something you don't want to pay for. That's differently. That's the cable bundle. We agree. Best business model ever. But get you to watch
the thing that you don't want to watch on the service you didn't want to watch. The internet says that doesn't work. You can what you can do is say here's some free shit with ads. It's not great but it's free and people watch it. YouTube is that model. But so is what is the Roku channel?
It's a howdy. No, there's actually there's the Roku channel which is free and it's just on your Roku TVs and it has a lot of shit but it's free and that is now a meaningfully sized internet company. You can internet reasonably sized internet video providers. So that can work. But you can't say you must watch Netflix or we're going to make Netflix $5 cheaper and thus you'll have to pay for it we haven't ever seen that play out and it's dumb to get overly optimistic and cheery about the internet in 2026. But we have seen that at least the one thing that overlords
have not been able to pull off is to get us to consume things. Get us to pay for video we don't want to pay for. That's the one little bit of a freedom we still have. They're all moving to add support of one way or another. Actually, you brought a Roku. The question I have is where
where does the vertical integration begin and end? Right? Fox is buying Roku to get access to its distribution and its customers and all of those TVs. That kind of vertical integration seems alive and well. Netflix was in the market to buy Warner. Paramount might still be in the market
to buy NBCU. NBCU might be in the market to buy some other stuff. That kind of integration seems like it's going to keep happening. But you get to the actual pipe, the actual internet connection, whether that's wired or wireless and that's the one that doesn't ever seem to work. Why do you think there's a big difference there? I don't know is the short answer and also I'm
pretty interested to see what happens with Roku and Fox because Roku and Fox in a lot of ways is another one of the isn't one of these content distribution plays that we have seen not work for more than 15 years, 20 years, 30 years, right going back to AOL time Warner. You could argue that this there's just less levered onto this. It's a smaller deal. There's no grand placomations that this is going to connect everyone to everything. This is for a subset of internet TV watchers. Another is just sort of practical. I think one of the reasons that Fox
Roku may be constrained will be the same reasons that all other companies were constrained separate from regulation. It's that if you have this asset, if you have HBO, you want HBO to be distributed as widely as possible to as many people as possible. If you are privileging Roku customers in some way, that is likely to be counterproductive. It's not going to switch. It's not going to convince people to get Roku so they can get HBO. It's going to convince people to go, it's just a pain
to ask to get HBO if I also have to get it through Roku. That's what happens time and time again with all of these content plus pipe deals is that everyone realizes there's just nothing that we can keep that's proprietary that will convince someone to get our broadband through us. Another version of this is Xbox, right? People like playing Halo but not enough to buy an Xbox so they can play that game. Does that make sense? It does. It's funny about Xbox Xbox is the other famous example of
Comcast is you're rating a service and people freaking out until they turn it off. You're rating by the way is when some data doesn't hit your cat and some does. Again, there's a long history of these companies trying it, trying to do the thing that would make the economics of owning the distribution and the content together work and then immediately meeting either market or regular backlash. Yeah, I think market in the end has been more important than regulatory. It's true that people want net neutrality and it's funny that for as boring as it is, whenever you point out that the bad thing is happening, the market does freak out.
You may not need the regulation because everyone's always so mad about it. You were on my podcast recently, you brought this up, right? You can't have an iPhone without access to Instagram. It doesn't matter whether Apple, whether Mark Zuckerberg and Tim Cook, like each other, they have to play nicely or nice enough to make that work. They both lose if it doesn't work.
And again, I guess that's the market working. It's funny. You asked most cable subscribers or broadband subscribers, is this market working? Are you getting faster speeds for less money? And I think most of them would say no, but in very specific ways is competitive. What's also hilarious is every people say this on the
internet, but they say it in real life too. Now, I wish we could go back to the old days where you just got all your stuff from one company and was called CableTee. Wouldn't that be funny? Ha ha ha. I'm like, yes, it'd be funny. And you hated it. Everyone fucking hated that model.
Everyone says we should go back to the model either was not alive or was not paying their bill back when that model existed or just memory wipe themselves. The Comcast, TCI, whoever was your cable company was the most loath company in the world because you hated them because they gave you shitty service and they made you buy things you didn't want. And now we're in a world where they might still give you shitty service, but you don't have to buy things you don't want from them. And every tech company thought they could take the living room by just putting a nicer user interface around your cable box because the cable box interfaces were so bad and so insulated from competition. And all of that failed against the miserable technology stack of cable television.
Yes. And now you've been now, but now you have Roku, which is interesting. And I have a but now you have YouTube TV, which is a cable provider that is growing. And I think it's because it is everywhere. I think it's because it's on your phone and on your TV and all of the other places without that second push to subscribe to some physical connectivity.
It works great on your phone. They are marketing the hell out of it. They are putting money into it. I've always wondered and I ask YouTube and Google this all the time, why don't they don't push it even harder? They are essentially selling you the same cable TV package at the same price as everyone else. Why not sell the same cable TV package at half the price? Your Google, why don't you
just eat the losses for X number of years and just own the entire connected TV market? It's funny that you ask them that. I'm like, why don't you just make the sports in 4K? Why don't you just pay the money and put the 4K cameras in every NFL state? You're Google. You can figure it out.
And then I'll have 4K and I'll pay you as much money as you want. And they just kind of look at me and they say, you know, the local TV market is more complicated than that. And they get a thousand yards stare. And it's the reality of, nope, we got to distribute to a bunch of local broadcasters. And we got to share these feeds and regulators involved and they can't just throw money at the problem. I think the way that they want to. That is a big mess, right? That whole TV ecosystem
is a relic of maybe three different eras. The broadcast era where there were only three networks in the entire country, the cable era, the premium cable era when HBO was now whatever declining era we're in where there's like 45 sub channels on the main NBC broadcast that are all infomercials. I don't know what they're doing. There's something happening there that seems hard to reckon with and maybe everyone's just running away from. But it's still there. It's still
like everyone's lost to deal with it. And it's still the main economics of everybody. Brendan Carr runs around and I can regulate ABC content because of broadcast spectrum. That's a lot of machinery. That's a lot of complexity. It's one of the reasons you would take NBCU and studios away and
apart is to chase cleaner, pure direct to consumer internet distribution instead of that whole mess. Or they still have to deal with that all mess. It's just saying that those businesses are not connected. We're back to where we started. We thought we could connect them in some way. They
remain unconnected. They're in completely separate businesses. And again, the real answer is we think maybe our stock will go up if we get rid of this thing that is dragging our stock down. Or more optimistically, we got no value for this media company right now. If we split it, then we'll have a media company and a broadband company and maybe we'll have some lift by owning two companies instead of one.
We're gonna take on a short break. We'll be back in just a minute. We're some C-Heroes and other C-E-Gos. Bloomberg sees the era of billionaire athletes. A fad to some? The future of money to others. We see crypto's trillion-dollar swings. The end
of jobs or the end of human struggle. We see the endless funds fueling the AI hype. While others follow the noise, we follow the money. Learn more at Bloomberg.com. What does a sunny getaway with Air Canada sound like? Sunny Jamaica moves to its own rhythm. Rio comes alive long after the
sun goes down. Philippines slows everything down. And just when you think you've heard it all, there's Sunny Lima. However you imagine your sunny escape, Air Canada can take you there. Book hot fares and vacation packages today. Nice travels. Welcome back. I'm talking to the channel so it's
Peter Kafka about the media half of Comcast Business and Playa. Okay, we've talked about the broadband company quite a lot. Let's talk about the media company for one second. Let me see you as a player. It has a sparkling brand name as the minions as the pork, as you've mentioned. Taylor
shared it now. He's going to get better or worse at writing women with the power of AI. I feel we're going to find out. We don't need to get it in our TV. Is that the winner of all this? Is that
the company you want to be at? I mean, everyone talked to it first and has a good face. That's a good game face. We can invest in our own future and we don't have to worry about feeding the parent company. They all have the same handbook. I don't know how much they believe it. I think you can make
a pretty strong case that NBCU as a standalone company is interesting. Again, either as a standalone company or as an asset to be acquired by somebody else, you can't replicate that theme park business. Can't really understand how big a deal that is, especially in a world where AI is going to be their future. We're going to want tactile experiences like that is a great thing to own. Studio Supervaluable Peacock has not really worked for them and they've been reluctant to throw the same kind of money that their rivals have. I don't know what becomes of that.
And the broadcast, man, broadcast. Broadcast is hot again. What you keep hearing from the Paramount folks is that yes, they bought all those cable TV assets. They know that's not their future either. They're going to try to milk money out of them just like VersaTiz. But they really think
that broadcast TV is a special thing. I think that mostly comes down to broadcast TV as a thing you can show football on. And that's super valuable. But they seem to think that is a very valuable asset. And again, there are only a handful of broadcast TV networks. They own one of them.
Another way of putting it is there are only a handful of places where you can distribute NFL programming to all of America and they own one of them. Yeah, it's a thing. It's the sports piece that makes broadcast valuable. NFL is the big one. It's the World Cup right now.
And the idea that you need big free distribution of sports that you control seems ascendant. And really the NFL, right? Like, I mean, CBS and Fox in particular kind of only exist. Their primary reason to exist is to distribute football. Like Fox basically doesn't have any other programming. They have some reality shows and then they have football. That's what they do now.
It's funny, I was watching the World Cup on Fox one yesterday, which is their big streaming app. They're very proud of its platform. You have to either pay for it or log into it with a cable provider. And I was watching it. I did what I think everyone does. I opened TikTok on my phone to be
distracted from the thing I was ostensibly watching. And the first thing I got was an official Fox Tik Talk account that was streaming the same game for free. And I thought the economics of this make no sense to me, right? You need to reach the young consumer on this platform for free. And who knows how you're monetizing this? Or you're going to make the old people pay for it to watch it on TV and your app,
which they don't know how to download. And they have to go through some off-flow that is horrible. How does any of that work? Does that ever get reconciled? The kids are all going to watch TikTok for free. A big thesis on the show is we all have to reckon with the fact that there's an army of
teenagers making content for free on Instagram and TikTok every single day. And every media business has to just ignore it, just ignore the elephant in the room that destroys their host structure. That's well put. I don't know that they have an answer every time I hear them talk about it. It's the wrong answer. It is things like, well, if you make this in a format that works for phones,
then people would pay for it, right? I mean, Quibi, but a million other things like that. Yeah. And it's not it's not that no one can watch those on their phone. It's that no one was to pay for on their phone. They don't want to pay for most things. They can get most things for free.
But that is why sports remains sports. Also, Fox paid almost nothing. They get like $500 million for the World Cup deal, essentially, for them, especially the extra water breaks. That sports is the one thing that is immune to this. But even that's not really true because young people don't watch sports. If you find a Zoomer and ask them to sit and watch a two-hour game or a three-hour
football game, no fucking way. So this is one of those things where we keep saying the economics for all of this is not sustainable. It has to collapse. It has to have a reset. Year after year, we say this. And year after year, the rights for sports go up and up and up.
Because it's the only consistently draw audience, right? There's no other one day. One day it will reach a point where an NBC or an ABC or a Paramount. Some of them will cry uncle and say, we can't do this. And you already saw Warner Brothers pass on basketball, which is a much, much smaller sport. And it'll be a big fucking deal when one of those companies
bows out one way or the other. And that will be a giant, giant, giant shift. But we keep saying that and it does not happen. My prediction, by the way, is that eventually YouTube just pays the money to have it all right. They already pay for somebody to get their already the big NFL partner. At some point,
they're just looking at on YouTube. The whole thing. We're just going to take the whole thing. And then the NFL will have to reckon with the fact that there's nothing next to YouTube that can compete the way that CBS can compete with Fox can compete with ABC. Yeah. I mean, the NFL is obviously
religion and politics all wrapped up in one. And so I don't know how you ever get to a place where the United States government allows all of football to be only in one place. I think they want it distributed. So there's already there's already some noise about this. This is a different episode, but the Green Bay Packers are the center of this noise. The economics of the Green Bay Packers are tied up in
sports right? So whether you're talking about it, could NBCU be a buyer? Could they buy a bunch of other stuff that's available? That's the thing that is that is the argument is we are a buyer not a seller. That is there on the record. This is what we want to do. And so you buy a bunch of studios and
content and put it on. I don't know what you buy. I don't really know what you buy. There's a bunch of cable networks available. No one wants to buy those. You know, is this do they go do transformational
things? Do they do little tuck in businesses? Again, if you talk to a person about how they're going to build their business, they talk about their online golf stuff where you can buy tea times, which they've been talking about that for literally a decade. So I'm not sure what these businesses you can tack on to the media business would be. The big argument for all the big studios has long been whether they will be a supplier to platforms like Netflix or build their own distribution.
Thus far, all the big studios have taken a run at building their own distribution, right? Paramount Plus, Disney, Disney Plus, NBCU alone did not build NBCU Plus. They built something called Peacock. Peacock is not as big as the others. As you said, they haven't invested in it as much as the others.
Is there a chance they just give up and they become a supplier to the Netflixes of the world? That is always a possibility. And that is again, a debate internally for them for a long time. And before the all these companies went to buy, went to create their own distribution to build their own Disney Plus, they were very happy to be Netflix suppliers. They thought it was a great business because they were selling all their stuff at huge bar cups and Netflix were a bunch of dummies for buying it. And they realized what they had created. Then Netflix got to roll up and say,
we're so big it doesn't matter. Yeah, I could definitely see a world where some version of NBCU is the broadcast business, the studio, the theme park. And then if you want to buy our programming Netflix or anybody else, go for it. But they sell to when the tech company is an Amazon or an Apple? Yes, they could. The politics of that are very complicated because we don't know who's going to be
an office and what regulatory stance we're going to have. And right there are deals that the Mardox can do in 2026. At the Roberts family, we have a harder time pulling off. I think fundamentally Trump is transactional, not ideological. So there's always a way to make the deal work.
I mean, by the way, even as he's like, doing out favors of the Murdochs, he's suing them for 10 billion hours, which is just no cognitive dissonance. So yeah, I think there's I think a lot of folks assume there will be combinations of these assets, no matter what the Comcast executives were saying on their best or call last week. Well, just to make it plain, the Murdoch family owns Fox News and Wall Street Journal, specifically the Wall Street Journal editorial page, which is religiously pro-Trump, the New York Post, which is religiously pro-Trump. I disagree on the journal, but come on. Well, they're they're they're they're they're far to the right. They criticize Trump quite a bit,
but nothing matters. Go on. We could get into it. They don't like terrorists. They don't like screaming with the Fed almost everything else. They're with them. They came out in favor of
birthright citizenship the other day. They noted that several of the soccer players are not born in America. And it's good that they get to play for America. All right, we can agree to disagree in the Wall Street Journal editorial page, but it's the Murdoch family ever and as they're generally politically aligned. The Roberts family ran MSNBC, MSNBC, they're potentially politically aligned in a very different way. Is there a chance that all this split is so that they can do M&A
without the stain of MSNBC or MSNBC? It's definitely something I thought about. I think that is a lot of bending. I think there are easier ways to make Donald Trump happier than splitting your company up. There's something you really want to get accomplished. I have thought about that,
whether or not this makes it cleaner and easier for the Roberts family to maneuver. If they don't have to worry about what Donald Trump says, because they no longer own MSNBC or they no longer own NBC, what are the things he cares about? MSNBC thinks about things that are on broadcast, television and cable television. So there's maybe they're there, but I wonder if we're just doing 5G shows. I think I think of the Comcast was the company best executed strategy that you would have a big ISP and a big content arm and they would work together and that has all come apart. I think
it's come apart because of internet platforms at large. Meta exists, Instagram exists, YouTube exists. People are spending their time in different ways that have nothing to do with the economics of Hollywood. I was just a can. Everyone is talking about creators that can, as they were just invented yesterday because they're the future of marketing in some huge way. They're the future of audiences
in some way. I spent more time listening to creators that can talk about other spending more money making video than ever before. And I thought, oh, we're just doing Hollywood again, right? But it's because the ad dollars are there to be directly integrated into the content they're putting on YouTube. Is this party just over for Hollywood? There's a part of me that says, there's a whole generation
of creators and creatives who came up in a different economic model. That model is ascendant and it is the only model that works. And Sony being a company that made huge IP and then monetized it by selling it to different TV providers around the world and had buildings full of accountants running audits on how many times the video was played on NBC 5 in Chicago. That's all over. Like those economics are over and maybe this just needs to be a clean break. Is there a way out? Is this the way out or is
this where I'll just shuffle and lecture? I mean, it's funny. Sony was supposed to be a synergy company too, right? Because there was never any synergy between Sony, the company that brought you the Walkman and Sony, the brought you Adam Sandler movie. It's just not just happened to be owned by the same company. Hey, they use the Spider-Man font on the PS3. I don't know about the end of Hollywood
stuff. I know about, you know, we like to write narratives. It's a very exciting narrative. People who have a reason to pitch that narrative, a reason to pitch that narrative and, you know, obsessions and backrooms and isn't as exciting. People are also going to see, they're also going to see the Odyssey from NBC Universal this summer. And that's a giant epic movie, right? There's going to be a new
Spider-Man movie from Sony. That's a giant epic movie. Could you in theory finance that thing yourself and do it without making a studio? Sure, I guess. But record labels still exist, right?
So there is something that some combination of capital and talent still allows these companies to create that the individual creator cannot. It seems like consumers want both of those things, not either or. So I would assume they exist in some form. But I do think they could gut in quite a bit, right? It just makes it harder and harder if you are a giant Hollywood studio to justify the way you've been spending money, knowing that your competitors are not people who are spending next to nothing. Is your part on all this? Is there self-awareness from these mean executives that
these big bets didn't work and they need to try something else in different cost structures? Usually you need entirely a new executive to come in and say the old guys, I mean, that's what you're seeing in Xbox right now today this morning is where they put out a memo saying, basically, our predecessors at Xbox got this all wrong. And that's the only way you can sort of acknowledge it. If you bring in a new team and say the people who were here before are the ones who screwed up, which is actually not a new dynamic, right? They rarely say, I mean, the CEO of AT&T was the guy pushing for this for the AT&T Warner Brothers discovery deal when he was not when he was CoO. And then he
became CEO and sold Warner Brothers and said, oh, that was never my deal to begin with. I haven't decided to. That was a polite thing to do with. It's a great world. If you and I spend $83 billion in the wrong way, we have real consequences and other people get raises.
Well, I suspect over the next year or so is all these splits happen across all these companies. You and I will be talking to each other many more times because none of this seems settled. And it also seems like there's a lot of money that's going to fly around without a thesis. And it's our job to figure out what the story actually is. It's great fun to write about, right? I mean, literally the last year or so, I was saying,
I'm kind of getting tired of this beat. I feel like I spent years talking about what would happen if the internet finally showed up and if the internet finally became TV, what would happen? And I'm like, well, it did become TV and it's really fucking boring. It's just peak how it comes in streaming services and I'm about to write about it. And it feels like it is now splitting again. And that is extra fun for us to cover. Yeah, the bundling part of the cycle
is pretty boring. The unbundling cycle seems, seems to be a lot more characters. They're literally having to compete more. And somewhere in there, there's Elon Musk saying he will fund a rock company with telecom margins, which who knows? If you know this is wonderful, I'll have you back to see me and thanks for being on.
Back to you. I'd like to thank Peter for taking the time out of his show to come on to CoO. And thank you for listening. I've enjoyed it. So let's know what you thought about this episode or anything else at all.
Drop us a line. You can email us at decoderreverge.com. We really do read all the emails. Or you can hit me up directly on the threads or blue sky. We're on YouTube, you can watch websites at DecoderPod and we have a TikTok and Instagram. They're also at
DecoderPod. They're a lot of fun. If you'd like to co-derplay share with your friends and subscribe over your podcast, Decoder is a production version part of the Fox and the new podcast. I work. This shows for you by K-Cocks and X-AT. This episode was edited by
Versa Wright, our editorial director is Kevin McShane at the Decoder Music because we break master cylinder. We'll see you next time. The end of jobs or the end of human struggle. We see the endless funds fueling the AI hype. While others follow the noise, we follow the money.
Learn more at Bloomberg.com. Your first Spotify ad is just a few clicks away. Launch a campaign today in minutes with Spotify ads manager.