Retailers are challenging Visa's dominant role in the E&B debit marketplace, claiming that Visa has unlawfully limited or eliminated merchant's abilities to route debit transactions through other networks by forcing them to deploy a certain technology and adhere to certain technical specifications. Mark Orbital, CEO of the Merchant Advisory Group, which represents 108 of the US's largest merchants, says the whole host of Visa's rules and practices are being called into question with some currently under investigation by the Federal Trade Commission. Here, Mark joins me to talk about how Visa's push to quickly get retailers E&B compliant for debit, as violated routing options mandated by the Fed, and why Visa's domination of the debit market, Visa's debit accounts for 52% of all US debit transactions, has given it an unfair advantage over competitors, including MasterCard. Hi, I'm Tracy Kidman, Information Security Media Group.
So, Mark, the Federal Reserve on November 2nd came out with a list of FAQs related to card network rules and routing, and pointed out that no payment network and force retailers to deploy a certain technology or enforce a certain rule that inhibits routing. How has Visa, in your opinion, mark violated the Fed's stance on routing? Well, first let me begin with the caveat that I'm not an attorney. So, this is a layperson, although, hopefully, an informed layperson's view of things.
I take it back to the entire E&B migration, but the bum is rushed, that's infected merchants, whereas Canada had eight years and got a six-month extension on their E&B conversion. We were given four years, and two of those years were used up with even providing the debit specs. We didn't have those till two years in, and so merchants, as a whole, have been rushed into this thing, and not given adequate time to prepare for the E&B migration. Debit has a lot to do with this.
I mean, that's where a lot of issues stem from. Even though it was rushed to begin with, the debit piece was rushed to an even greater extent. I was under the impression in the first E&B migration meetings that I attended, that there wasn't even an acknowledgement by any of the card brands, that they had to develop some means to account for merchant debit routing under RAGII. After talking about this, circling back to the issue and contending, along with other merchant representatives, that this is something that brands needed to address.
They finally did it a couple of years into the four-year plan, and it was not, in our view, addressed in a fashion that was most open to competition from in-depth networks. In many ways, we had a situation where they're really second-class citizens. The merchants who then began the process of developing E&B for the point of sale found themselves having difficulties replicating the free E&B routing of debit transactions that they would not to do under an E&B format, and being faced with, frankly, unclear and inadequate choices by the card brands in particular on how they'd route those transactions to the most cost-effective and safest endpoint. So just to elaborate there, Mark, the way that merchants have been adversely affected is just in the fact that it's costing them more, and they probably are exposed to more fraud?
Absolutely. Many merchants sent many more transactions to pen-debit networks pre-EMV. I mean, I'm not privy to the pricing of each one of these networks to each one of the merchants, but collective wisdom is that there were many more transactions going to the pen-debit networks. I've heard that acknowledged by some of the pen-debit networks as several individual merchants, and then merchants are suffering greatly with the chargebacks associated with this whole E&B conversion.
And most of the chargebacks involve transactions where customers sign or don't do anything. The transactions that have been secured by pens have and remain the most safe transactions out there, and those that result in the fewest chargebacks, and at least amount of fraud. So, Mark, I mentioned during the introduction that the FTC has launched an investigation into Visa's practices. What would you say spurred that investigation?
Or what do you think spurred the investigation? Well, I can only termize that the Fed's clarification of debit routing under RIG-I, you know, had something to do with it. There's been a fair amount of complaint to the Fed from the merchant community about the confused nature of E&B debit routing, and whether or not network rules and somehow overcome the language in the Durbin Amendment or in RIG-I, and I think they just basically came out and stated what the law says that debit routing is entirely up to merchant, and networks and issuers and no one else can impose limitations on that. I know you're not an expert in this area, Mark, but do you have any idea about how long an investigation like this could last, or what some of the possible outcomes could be?
I don't have any. I think that the issue, though, is fairly straightforward. The Fed interpreted the regulation, its regulation. I mean, interpret the law, I guess, is a better way to put it, just exactly the way the merchant community felt that it should be said.
To me, it's fairly straightforward. I don't see any reason why it would take a long time before we could see market changes. Now, I don't know about all the implications of an investigation, and no idea how long that kind of thing may take, or what the potential ramifications are of that. How rare would you say it is, Mark, for the FTC to investigate a card brand for issues such as routing?
Well, the routing issue, I don't think, ever, has been investigated by any entity before. I could be wrong about that. But the routing issue is a product of the Durbin Amendment and RIG-I specifically. I know that there have been, in the past, some DOJ investigations that resulted in some consent decrees if I'm not mistaken around eight to 10 years ago.
I don't think they involved routing specifically, and I don't recall about my head of previous FTC investigation. And it's interesting because, you know, again, this is something I think that's relatively rare. I know I don't think that I've ever seen an investigation launched by the FTC into routing before. And because this is or seems to be somewhat unique, Mark, are the other current brands reacting any way to this investigation as far as you know?
Yes, I'm sure most of them are quite pleased. Visa has a dominant position in the card market and in the debit market, in particular. And, you know, I'm sure the pandemic networks and perhaps even MasterCard will benefit from this Fed clarification on routing and potentially from the FTC investigation, that one would expect that all of their transaction volumes would increase. That's certainly going to make them all happy with the outcome.
I mean, I know the pandemic networks have seen significant decreases in volume from the merchants that have converted to EMV, at least initially. Some merchants may have gotten around now to addressing that and have mitigated some of those changes, some of those losses, I should say, to the pandemic networks, others. And once they go through this very costly, timely process of moving up to EMV, they never correct it to conform to Fed's clarification. They don't want to go through this change again.
Has Visa been proactive at all as far as you know, Mark, in reaching out to some of the retail groups that are calling Visa out, if you will, for these unfair business practices? Well, not, but I'm aware of. I mean, I'm sure there's some dialogue going on, in fact, we do a party to a letter that was sent to them on this particular matter, but the letter was sent only recently. And I don't believe there's been a response today.
What could this investigation mean for EMV debit deployment in the US? The immediate impact is it could slow things down. There are canned screen prompts from many of the POS hardware and software vendors out there. They're going to deserve a second look.
There was a very large petro chain that, you know, I've heard a remark that, you know, they were simply going to move forward with EMV with whatever they were given by their third-party software and hardware providers in order to escape liability shift or to mitigate the damages associated with liability shift. And without regard to, you know, maximizing their rights under reg-eye-ident routing, this is going to cause some people to stand back and say, okay, should I take the time to change this? Because clearly the merchant community has said, you know, it's more economical and it's safer for merchants to route transactions to then debit networks. But, you know, it may take us more time to put debit in if we have to go back to the drawing board.
It's going to cause some people to stand back, maybe take more time, and it's going to cause others to revise their approach to debit routing at the point of sale. Yeah, and just to clarify their market, because I know you and I have talked about these so-called canned screen prompts, but maybe just for our audience, could you clarify that? I mean, what is it that's actually limiting? And I think it's something that we've only seen with Visa.
I don't know that we've seen this with MasterCard. I don't think it's entirely limited to Visa. I think there are screen prompts that call out, for example, that the transaction may be routed to a specific payment brand or a specific financial institution. And then this other bucket has been called US Common, which no consumer knows what that is, and typically no merchant.
The US clerk knows what that is. And that ambiguity has caused, you know, many people to route transactions to the name, the brand, or the name, the financial institution, rather than this bucket that's called US Common, nobody knows what that is. And is the US Common option the one that would actually offer more perhaps a cheaper way to route a transaction? I mean, what's the different US Common?
Yeah, the US Common refers to an application in the DMV that enables a routing of the debit transaction to one of the ten debit networks, which are, as I mentioned, often most economical and always the safest to route. And then, Mark, before we close one final question for you, what ultimately would Mad and other retail groups like to see happen here? We want to clarify, buy the card brands, Visa in particular, for all of the various constituents of the payment ecosystem, that debit routing is the merchant's choice and the merchant's choice alone, in compliance with their amendment to Bob Frank, as well as Ray Guy. I mean, the Fed has come out and said that.
We've known it all along. I mean, that's always been our interpretation. And given all the cloudiness that's been attended to the space and the usual, I guess, acknowledgement or following of the rules that the US vendors do when it comes to looking at the global brands for clarification, I think there's been a lot of confusion out there that needs to be dealt with. And I think it needs to be very clear.
Again, and Visa in particular needs to say this, it's the merchant's choice and nobody else's choice on how to route debit transactions. Well, Mark, as always, I'd like to thank you for your time again today. Thank you. I can have just heard from Mark Corbinell of the Immersion Advisory Group for Information Security Media Group.
I'm Tracy Gittin.