Skip to content
Why Most PT Ads Don’t Work episode artwork

Jul 2, 2026 29 min

Why Most PT Ads Don’t Work

from PT Pintcast - Physical Therapy Hosted by Jimmy McKay, PT, DPT | Physical Therapy Podcast

This week on PT Breakfast Club, Tony Maritato, Dave Kittle, and Jimmy McKay look at a real physical therapy Instagram ad and ask a simple question: Would this actually make someone take action? The answer leads to a bigger conversation about physical therapy marketing, cluttered ads, weak offers, fake scarcity, AI-generated creative, trendjacking, TikTok Shop, LinkedIn recruiting, and how clinics can earn attention without looking like everyone else. The crew talks about why “free physical therapy” may not be the irresistible offer some clinics think it is, why too many visuals and calls-to-action can make an ad feel cheap, and why AI can help create marketing but still needs a human being to check whether the final product makes sense. They also get into Dave’s orange square LinkedIn post, Tony’s AI-generated Home Depot knee replacement image, and whether viral content is worth anything if it does not connect back to revenue. The big takeaway: You cannot interrupt a pattern if you do not have a pattern.  In this episode Why many PT ads feel cluttered or cheap The problem with “free PT” as a marketing hook Why scarcity needs to feel real How AI-generated ads can fail without human review What PTs can learn from trendjacking and meme culture Why attention only matters if it connects to a business goal How TikTok Shop could become an opportunity for PT creators Why Dave’s orange square LinkedIn post worked How clinic owners can create better behind-the-scenes content Why clear beats clever, and clear definitely beats clutter Best quote “You can’t interrupt a pattern if you don’t have a pattern.”

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Why Most PT Ads Don’t Work

0:00 29:24
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Passing way too early from three separate Wi-Fi connections. It's PT Breakfast Club with Tony Maritano, Dave Kittle, and Jimmy McKay. Hot enough for you? I mean, what are you doing this weekend is easily the most asked question in healthcare to a patient. What'd you do about that heat or how's the heat treating you? That's gotta be number two, especially in July, right? That's the cliche. It's the cliche days. You know what I love? I don't know if we talked about it already. I love all the videos on social media from Europeans coming here who are like going crazy about how amazing this country is, how amazing the food is, how amazing the people are. It's such a breath of fresh air. And then of course, like everything is air conditioned and everything is, you know.

You do like absolutely. As much as I try to produce more than I consume on social media, the negativity is outrageous. It's so nice to see the positivity. So funny you mentioned I was driving this morning and I work mostly from home, then travel. The funny part was when I was in radio, I was in the car a lot, which was notoriously one of the places you consume radio. So while I was ever in the car when I was in radio, I always made it a point to like have the radio on and listen to things that were not just ours. And it does put you in that similar mindset of your consumer. People don't we don't notice it because it's now we're blind to it. How wide the aisles are at a grocery store.

or how big a Buc-ee's is, somebody had a comment, like, it's as big as our parliament. Like, it's as big, there is a gas station in America as large as our Capitol building. And we drive past it, we go, oh yeah, that's pretty big. The third time you drive past it, like Seth Godin would say, it's a purple cow, but you don't notice it anymore. Well, do you know the delicacy? You've heard this then, if you're paying attention to the World Cup, the delicacy that people are, even the TSA, Transportation Safety Administration, is giving a heads up. I'm sure you know this one. Let's see if Dave knows. Do you know the delicacy that Europeans are?

infatuated with to the point where they're trying to take it home in their carry-ons but because it's our our crappy food our horrible it's a condiment Ranch dressing, baby. I did hear that. They're surprised. Europeans, you're not missing anything. You're not missing anything with a ranch. Oh, no. I don't know, man. The funny part is it was Italians. And I'm like, you know what I don't want to see in Italy on the menu? Ranch. I like that here. I don't want to see that on the menu in Italy. I love pizza with ranch. Dipping pizza with ranch. Oh, my Lord. Oh, my Lord. Oh, my Lord. I was more of a, if it's two o'clock in the morning, you dip the pizza in blue cheese. That was the thing I didn't see coming that I would enjoy. Yeah.

All right. You shared an ad. I've got it. I can bring it up on screen. You shared the one yesterday and you were saying you had some feelings about it. Dave, why don't you describe the ad while I work my magic to get it up on screen here?

Yeah, this was on Instagram. I think it was, it was like one of those story ads. Like if you're looking at stories and they throw an ad in front of you, so it was not in the newsfeed and you can see it's kind of like the full, the full size of the phone. So this was like a, like a story, a story ad. And again, not to pick on this physical therapist. I think he's in the area, in the New York city area, redefined physical therapy, not a big deal. But, um, I just looked at this and I sent it to you guys. This is what we do. I don't know if the audience, I think the audience knows by now, like we just screenshot stuff or we'll send links to each other. And we're kind of like, like, this is awesome. Or this is horrible. Or like, yeah, what do you guys think or whatever? So I sent this to you guys and.

to me it just it just looks or feels like cheap i don't know if it's the the gold the gold uh circle banner with like the almost like the ribbon or the or like the yeah like the sticker it just looks it looks cheap it looks like it was made probably on chachi bt or gemini or claw or something and well um Yeah. There's nothing wrong with you. You should absolutely use those tools to get in front of your ideal patient. And maybe this resonates with their ideal patient. Maybe this ad is crushing it in the coming weeks and months, especially, you know, let's say in the next six to 12 months, if I keep seeing this ad, then I will send it to you guys again and say, Hey, obviously, obviously I was wrong. Obviously this ad is working because this physical therapy practice is still running it. And you're only going to keep running ads for multiple weeks or months if it's crushing or if it's doing well. My initial response was this looks kind of tacky or something. I don't know. What do you guys think?

Tony, what's your what's your initial gut reaction here with this thing? Yeah, I mean, you got to talk to the person who posted it. What is their idea behind it? What's the intent behind it? Free vouchers is just weird. Anyway, I've always said I could hang I could I could fly a flag like the two crazies who are on the Empire State. And I could say free physical therapy for a month and it wouldn't make any difference. Nobody cares about free physical therapy, at least not in my world. It's not going to be like Chick-fil-A can give you a free sandwich and the line is out the door around the block. Nobody is going to line up for free physical therapy. There's no value in that.

Yeah. Yeah. For me, I would need to know the goals. But now that we're looking at this ad together, there's like four things that's going on here. Like there's too much. I don't know where am I supposed to go? Am I supposed to go to the image? Then there's a bulleted list. Then there's a free voucher thing. Then there's a claim your spot. I get what you're trying to do with scarcity. 50 is not the number. If you're trying to do scarcity, I'm like, I'll take my time. Ironically, as dumb as it sounds, I read stuff like this and they say odd numbers actually perform better for some stupid reason. But 50 ain't it. Because if you've got 50, I'll come back in a week. Let me know what you've got. But they're trying something. They are trying something. Unfortunately, I think in this particular ad, they're trying seven things at once.

Avoid surgery and get back to an active life. That should have been it. But when you're sitting there, I get when you've got Canva and it'll just let me keep adding things. Now, I will give them this thing, although this doesn't look it. Have you heard about the issue with the company REI? And they didn't run an ad, but Meta used AI and ran an ad for them. I think this is Meta's way of pushing out, like, well, we'll have REI do it, and then we can sell it to the Redefined Physical Therapies. The problem was they took content from REI's page, used an AI ad generator, generated it, but REI got crap because they're all about nature. And of course, what's the opposite of nature? Data centers, right? So REI wants to be as clean. I bet you their company that comes out and says we only use real images taken by real photographers. But here's the image.

Can you spot the problem with the REI ad? I don't know if you guys are cycling experts. The pedals? Oh, the handlebars. The handlebars behind the seat. Yes, look, there's two handles. Which way are you supposed to ride that bike? AI put handlebars. It's a mountain bike. So the mountain bike is going from my right to my left if you watch the screen. But the AI put handlebars. It didn't know what to do. It put another set of handlebars going the wrong way, which would be an uncomfortable bike seat. So I was going to give this organization, the PT organization, the benefit of the doubt. But that's what happens when you give all creative control and there's no.

There's no checks. Larry Benz has an episode of his podcast, The Operator. I helped produce it. I'm on it. He had a great line for his episode that comes, the article came out yesterday. His podcast will drop today. And he said, autopilot flies the plane. If there's an altitude change, it does that. It does some turns. But human beings take off and land. And when the red light goes off, autopilot says, grab the wheel again. Now you're in charge. So I think it's OK to have AI do some of these things. But you should have someone look at it and go.

Does this pass the smell test? Does this feel good to you? Does this, like the first thing we said, does this accomplish the goal we set out to accomplish? So A for using doing something, I don't know, not an A, C plus for doing something, or a C, I don't know, what's, what's, maybe a B or C, yeah. I was gonna say, so I like the, I do like the headline, I'm fine with the yellow accent on active life. I don't know about get a free, again, that's another thing, like we have, when I have new therapists, by the way, like get ramped up, we'll reach back out to like previous clients, and as goodwill, we'll announce like over text or email to our previous clients.

Like, hey, we have Dr. Andrew. Hey, we have Dr. Ethan now. Basically, it's like to get them busy. We'll offer previous clients a complimentary visit. But I used to say free. I used to say the word free. Words matter. Words are important. So we used to say free visit with Andrew, free visit with Dr. Ethan, and it expires next Friday. Now it's like instead of two weeks, it's like one week. Now all of a sudden, more people grab it. More people do it because words matter. We're big dumb animals. The aesthetic real quick of the ad, another thing that I think distracts is that there's two different images, right? I think it's probably best to do one image per ad. And again,

I could be wrong, but when doing these ads, and by the way, I'm maybe in the future, in the near future, getting back into some meta ads test, but you have to have like a ton of creative. Like every time you run an ad, there's gotta be like dozens of variations. And then you just like, you pick a winner, you see which one's winning, and then you just double down on that. Then you make more new versions that models closer to the ones that already were winning. And then you continue to refine it and refine it. This with two images is distracting, right? It's like one headline, my top to bottom, my eyes go headline, sub headline. Now it's like two images. So it's like, do I look up to right? Then like you said, Jimmy, I got the bulleted list on the left. I got the...

the 50 free voucher sticker and claim your spot you know call to action in like yellow orangish um it's just like a lot going on so again we could we could see like if i keep getting hit with this with this ad like in a month or two i'll share with you guys again i'm like hey let's go run it i recorded radio versions of this it just sounded like you know i'm talking about one thing then another then another you know we call this in radio we call this 10 pounds of shit in a five pound bag it just doesn't fit it ain't accomplishing the goal it looks mushy it's busting out the sides what would you have done with this and this is what was the story that's not late so this was people climbing what yeah a couple climbed to the very extreme tip of the empire state building which is insane i don't know i don't know if you saw this but yesterday on instagram in the evening there was a post from netflix that was i think this couple oh yeah and they did a documentary then and i think that there might be something coming out with them again and i think this uh proposal media i think it's a media stunt probably backed by netflix i don't know for sure i don't know for sure maybe it'll come out this week or today or something but

That's my hunch. And, you know, then I don't know. Well, the city of New York can make Netflix and Netflix will just pay a fine. You guys know me and you might roll your eyes, but of course I see something and I'm like, oh, I have a story for that. So AAA baseball in Scranton, the local team became the AAA Yankees. And when that happened, they changed from the Phillies to the AAA affiliate Yankees in the Scranton. We couldn't get in the stadium the first game because our media competitors had media rights. And the lead singer of Breaking Benjamin, which is a band we played the crap out of, was going to sing the national anthem. We could not be there. So, of course, Jimmy goes, I'm going to figure out a way to do that. The stadium was sort of built in a valley.

And in left field was a mall in an Italian restaurant. I took the vinyl from one of our billboards. Like when they take it down, they ask if you want it or shred it. I go, oh, I want that. And it just had a young woman in a tank top that said, I'm your next ex-girlfriend because the radio station was 97.9X. And when they said, and the home of the brave, we unfurled our banner in left field so the entire stadium could see it. We weren't on the field. So this is hijacking someone else's visibility. What do you think it would cost to get a logo on the top of the NFL? Incalculable.

You'll never get that money back, but it's a stunt. It doesn't have to be a billion dollars. Ours was cute for a moment. I got yelled at by it. Because, of course, you know, the stadium's like, you can't do that. I'm like, that's not your rocks. I can climb on rocks. But, of course, I was never going to do the same gag again anyway. It was the point. But I think you're right, Tony. Like, you could do whatever you want. And for what we provide, is it because it's too abstract? I'm thinking. I don't know.

Tony, I don't know if you saw, but at least the people that I follow on Instagram in the New York City area, people started to hijack that stunt and have their own stuff AI on a banner. And it was like, you know, weight loss, opportunity in New York City, whatever, or, you know, personal training, we're the best, whatever. And like, it's the two, it's the two, the Russian couple that went up to the top of the Empire State Building, they got arrested for it. And they, you know, they just changed the world. And they just changed the world. So like, but that was multiple people. And it's so funny, like, I know we've all seen this where like something happens and then like people pile on and do like an AI version for themselves for like self-promotion. I'm totally fine with self-promotion.

But Tony, you didn't see any of that on your newsfeed yesterday afternoon? Absolutely. I saw that. I'm going to share an image. um i don't know this meme this meme yeah this meme is just filling my feed the wmba girl who's pointing at the other girl who says don't point at me um there are so many like hilarious takes on it like that girl in the physical therapy clinic pointing and then the therapist pointing back and i've been seeing this trend on instagram where it's like gangster gangsta and and their crossfit gyms and the person will walk by the other gym and they'll pull up their shirt and they show a dumbbell you know like a gun and there's just so many of these things that Yeah, totally. Why is it not the massage gun? But it's the yes and. It's the ultimate, what can I take out of this? And I don't have to re-explain the rules. This is why when I used to do radio bar events, I didn't do complicated games. I did musical chairs, but with adults and drunk people. Because I didn't need to explain anything. It was simple, and you already understood the gag. And that's why a play on these is pretty brilliant. And I mean, simple, quick, in and out. I've got a friend, Kay, who runs the Instagram page, DPTsWithAnxiety.

That's the whole strategy. That's the whole strategy. She'll see this, and then she does nine versions of it, puts it out, and everyone's like, oh, this is my favorite. Oh, I like how you spun that. It's yes and. When something popped, like the Empire State Building thing, you knew what our entire radio station was talking about. Mocking, loving, hating. There's no mayonnaise. It's always ranch dressing, baby. It's got to be one way or the other. No mayonnaise. It's got to be a little spice. We were either going to love it and own it, or we were going to trash it and tear it down, and then 48 hours later, we're gone with it.

Just so the viewers and Dave knows, we're wrapping today's episode at nine. So we have about 11 more minutes. But the question is, so now we go back to reality. Now we say, okay, does this turn into money? Does this put dollars in our pocket? Is this just for vanity metrics? I will say though, a couple of weeks or a week or two ago, we shared the Home Depot do-it-yourself total knee replacement image that AI generated. I cannot believe how fast you brought that up. So, but that image put $400 in my bank account, like just from Instagram bonus.

which i didn't even realize was a thing yeah on instagram that image has generated about 400 in bonus income for me um i was on uh paypal i went into paypal this morning because someone was sending me a payment and i've got all of these 30 facebook payments and i don't even know what they're from like facebook is paying me 30 every two weeks i got to figure out why why i'm making that money I found two times in a nickel yesterday. So that's, it's like the same thing. Tony's got money being PayPal to him. He doesn't know where it's coming from. But yeah, we need to understand, like, I don't want to put the effort into making a funny meme with the girl pointing and me pointing back the Donald Trump pointing at the basketball player and her pointing back is freaking hilarious. I don't want to put time into that because I don't know if it's going to make me money. Unless you can directly draw a line to what you're doing. Like this is, this is where like Judy and Judy's pan case come in. She takes a video and whatever it is, she just figures out where do we jam Judy? Judy is the marketing strategy. And if you don't know who we're talking about.

just look up Judy and pancakes and look at their Instagram account. And she has said people now she's in, it begins with a G random ass Illinois. And she sells pancakes. She's a tourist attraction now. And she's the thing because the kids want to do it. And in your brain, you're like, all right, well, if we're anywhere close, the kids get a t-shirt. But now whatever Judy paid for real estate, she didn't do it in downtown Chicago. She did it in a random ass spot, but she went to the people with those things. And she understood it. Tony needs it. I'm a tick. I'm a tick tock famous shirt for sure. Tony needs this thing.

Speaking of TikTok, guys, I have been down the rabbit hole of how much money regular people, 40-year-olds, 50-year-olds, 60-year-olds are making as TikTok shop affiliates. It is absurd. And so this morning before we got on, because I was going to try and bring some numbers, but I didn't have them ready yet. I was looking at like, what are the products? What could I promote that I already use in my clinic?

I think the biggest one that none of us are taking advantage of is BioFreeze. Like Dave, you seem like somebody who would be using something like that. I never use it in the clinic, but I should, I could. I think it's got commercial appeal. It's got the history behind it. It's been around forever. The consumer wasn't able to buy BioFreeze directly from the company. They had to go through the healthcare provider. But now I think that's something that literally could put six figures in your bank account because the general appeal and accessibility for a product like that, if you made one viral video.

that hit several million views, which is totally doable for any of us. I just, I'm trying to better understand how TikTok, I've got like $200 in my TikTok affiliate account that I've earned, but I think this is a really ideal opportunity for people like us. For someone thinking and going, but I don't want to do the tiki-taki, like just talk about it. Yeah, it wouldn't be any of that. No dances, no gimmicks. Here's how Rory Sutherland, I think, would explain it. He would say all TikTok did was two things. They took the distance between someone seeing something and giggling about something or being interested in something.

and owning that and they took that distance down to essentially as close to zero as possible and they aligned the person who has credibility or an audience or the ability to build an audience and they put them on the same team as the bio freeze or the hyper you know the hyper ice gun and they said if you do this thing this much and it gets this much we'll give you a cut and the reach is infinity. Like the reach is potentially, it could be infinity. So simple, but not easy. And Ben's already pilot bio, bio mildly cold is a cheaper alternative. I don't know if that's a, is that a dad joke or is that there actually something called bio mildly? That'd be a smart, like six minute abs. Why not do six minute, five minute abs? Dave, you brought up or you shared an ad that you share or that you created, or I should say a post on LinkedIn. I wanted to ask this about you about it because I wanted to see if it was an error and I'll bring it up on screen here. So you had the ad.

I'll zoom in a little bit. Physical therapists in New York City paid more for treating less. Great hook, because that doesn't make sense. I get paid more. That's why I have to keep reading. How is that possible, he says. And then you go on to a set. You're using hard numbers, which nobody does, which is the way to do it. How is it possible to earn $1.26 to $170K, but only treating 46 patients a day? Details below. What's up with the orange square? I stopped. It got me. So I want to know, where'd you come up with this? I was like, is it not loading? Where's the, is my phone broken? What happened?

This is partly why I did this so that we can talk about it. Neither of you have ever seen this before. No. I don't think so, no. You probably have seen it before because this was what, do you remember the Fyre Festival? The guy that eventually got in trouble. The original promoter, I forget the guy's name. They were paying all of the big, like all the celebrities and the models and the people that were going to be in. They were all posting the orange square. This was on Instagram mostly years ago with Fyre Festival. And it was meant to be exactly what it did to Jimmy, which is it's a pattern interrupt. It's a scroll stopper.

And I could have used a different color. I could have maybe used our own brand color. I could have just done royal blue or something. But I went with the exact same solid orange square image that is meant to cause you to pause or give you intrigue or, yeah, is there an error or, like, what is this? Like, usually it's going to be text on the square, right? So that is literally the point of it is to be unique, different, something that you will not see or haven't seen recently in your feed and probably won't see for a while unless other people start copying it.

I'm surprised that you guys don't remember, but I know it was kind of like a big thing. Yeah, Scott Embry is here live, Pattern Interrupt. Scott probably saw that on LinkedIn. Scott's always on LinkedIn, I think. And Scott agrees with Jimmy. Great hook and got his attention for sure. So that's the point, right? First line, hook on purpose, but the image is also kind of like a visual hook. I'm going to get really nitpicky. The only way to make this better is... Give it to me, give it to me. The disc, don't put the space here.

Don't have the space here. Make this second line here. Here's why. LinkedIn will truncate this and sometimes see more to expand. And I don't want that second subhead to get cut off. That's the only, and that's like a 0.5%. The rest of it I think is fine. What was in the comments though? You tried to share something that didn't work?

Yeah, so then I was like, my intention was actually to add a couple like PDFs, right? So we have like a seven or something, six or seven page FAQ, because I want people to know a bunch of information before we even do an intro call. I don't want to do an intro call where I'm answering the same questions every day. So I try to attach PDFs and I was like, oh crap, I can't do it. And I'm like, ah, whatever, I'm just gonna leave it. And so now I'm getting DMs and emails from this post asking for the FAQ document, which I have to send them. And then I'm also asking for the two pager elite clinician growth opportunity, which is like describes like the base salary, the performance pay weekly, PTO, like that whole thing.

I thought we were trying to do is get people to comment to drive attention to because more people comment shows to more people, more people comment snowball. Overall, that's great. Again, that took you, you know, five minutes, 10 minutes to think about and execute it. If it gets you an interview that leads to a higher feels like it feels like it's a good use of your time. All right. We got we got two minutes left. Let's go party shots. I'm not we're not we're not late to our next our next gig. What do you got for us?

I want to talk about next time. Boom ball. So this is an up and coming competitor for banana ball. You know, I mean, this is what's going to happen. You create something amazing. There are going to be people who make it even better. There are some interesting rule changes in how it works. Yeah, I read about that.

They play with a live hand grenade, one out of nine innings. You never know which one it is. You have to watch. It's called boom ball. So what's going to be the boom ball for the physical therapy profession? How is this going to change and grow and adapt into something new and different? That's my parting shot. Yeah. Yeah. All right. That's a good one. All right. That's a good conversation. I'll come prepared for that one. What do you got, Dave? Parting shot.

I'll go back to that social media post. I'm just trying to do things that are different, unique, try to think outside the box, whether it's posting on social media, making videos. We got a bunch of videos coming out that I was telling Tony about last week where we're having a catch in Central Park with a real baseball and gloves and talking about physical therapy and healthcare in New York City and all that. So we're just trying to continue to, of course, we got to sprinkle in the normal stuff, like sprinkling videos of like treatment, manual therapy, you know, therapy exercise, like strength training, that type of stuff, but also sprinkling in like the... what someone described to me recently, like the, the behind the scenes, like, you know, walking down the street with one of my therapists and we're just, we're just chatting. Right. So, um, that, that, that's my parting shot. Just like, we're continuing to do different things and almost getting closer to the point of Tony's stage advice, which is like, we should be recording everything. We should be posting everything like HEP videos for patients, put that online with, with their, with their permission and therapists talking, like what, like talking between patients and waiting for a patient show up. Are they going to be late? Are they going to be early? Are they going to no show? Like whatever, like all that type of stuff. So that's a, that's my parting shot. Can't interrupt the pattern if you don't have a pattern. So do the normal stuff. Right. And then every once in a while.

Shake it up. That's why there's specials. There's a blue face special. Got to throw him a curveball. Curveball. Curveball. Got to throw him a curveball. All right, guys. We're back next week. And enjoy the heat. Enjoy the heat. That's it. We're out. Boys, what the hell are you doing? Follow Tony Merritt. And hey, just a reminder. None of this was for advice. This was for entertainment only. Our lawyers say that counts. Thanks, Keegan.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of PT Pintcast - Physical Therapy?

This episode is 29 minutes long.

When was this PT Pintcast - Physical Therapy episode published?

This episode was published on July 2, 2026.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this PT Pintcast - Physical Therapy episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.