Why Two-Thirds of Sex Crime Allegations in Ireland Are Never Prosecuted

A new investigation by Newstalk has revealed that almost 18,000 sexual offence cases were referred by Gardaí to the Director of Public Prosecutions over the past decade – but nearly two-thirds never resulted in prosecution. In today’s podcast, Ciara Doherty is joined by Newstalk reporter Jessica Woodlock, who has obtained detailed case data through Freedom of Information laws. Together, they examine why so many allegations of rape, sexual assault and other sex-based crimes never make it to court in Ireland. Drawing on newly released figures, the episode explores the DPP’s decision-making process, the role of evidence, and the real-world impact of being told that your case won’t proceed to prosecution. Listeners hear from rape survivor Ciara Mangan, who shares her powerful story of trauma and justice, a decade in the making. Senior Counsel Lorcan Staines also contributes legal insight, including how evidence is weighed in sex crime cases, and why the conviction rate – once a prosecution goes ahead – is actually very high. Executive Director of Rape Crisis Ireland Cliona Sadlier offers reaction from frontline services, as questions grow around whether the criminal justice system is adequately serving survivors of sexual violence. The episode also looks at efforts to improve prosecution rates, what types of cases are reaching the courts, and whether changes in legislation and social attitudes are making a difference. If you’ve been affected by any of the issues discussed, please contact the Rape Crisis Centre National 24-Hour Helpline on 1800 77 88 88, or visit rapecrisishelp.ie.