Skip to content
Will Google Pull Out of Australia? episode artwork

Feb 4, 2021 29 min

Will Google Pull Out of Australia?

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

How would the news media be affected if Google withdrew its search engine from Australia? Will news companies and the tech giants be able to come to an agreement on the media bargaining code? Which news organisations will be left with the short end of the stick? To discuss we have Josh Taylor, technology reporter at the Guardian and David Swan, Technology Editor at The Australian. Presented by Julia Carr-Catzel.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Will Google Pull Out of Australia?

0:00 29:34
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

A safer Ontario means more police and prosecutors making sure my card doesn't get stolen. It means building new jails to keep criminals behind bars. And it means there's no need to worry when I play at the park. We're making every corner of Ontario safer to make all of Ontario safer.

That's how we protect Ontario. For all of us. Learn how at Ontario.ca slash saferontario. Paid for by the government of Ontario.

Here we go. Someone's already claiming this is our year. Someone else said that last year too. A round of Jameson ginger and lime arrives at the table.

Smooth enough for kickoff, smooth enough for extra time. New friends pulling up a stool. Debates about whether that was a handball. Cheers rising like a roar around the room.

Because match days are about the shared moments. Add Jameson to your match day lineup. Jameson, it's what you bring. Please know your products responsibly.

Hello, you're listening to For the State, the show where journalists talk journalism. Coming to you from 2SER in Sydney on Gaggle Lands of Eeyore Nation, right across Australia on the community radio network, and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. My name's Julia Karkatzel. Well, no doubt you've been acquainted with Google's latest warning signs laid all over the web.

In its most recent act of defiance against a proposed media bargaining code, the tech giant has threatened to leave Australia altogether. The code requesting the tech giant pay for news content is the outcome of three years of work by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission. The ACCC says it aims to even out the playing field for tech giants and media organisations to create a fairer digital ecosystem. Prime Minister Scott Morrison is today meeting with the global boss of Google to discuss.

So, will the media companies and big tech platforms come to an agreement? What would Australia look like without its search engine? And which media companies would suffer most? Well, some journos very familiar with the workings of Google and Facebook are technology reporters Josh Taylor, a reporter for The Guardian based in Melbourne.

He has also worked for BuzzFeed and at Crikey, he's covered politics, technology and freedom of information. And David Swan is the technology editor at The Australian with experience across start-ups, business and tech. Welcome to the panel. Good to be here.

Yeah, thanks, Amy. So, I guess we'll start with maybe in your own words, if one of you could describe what the ACCC is effectively trying to achieve with the media bargaining code. Go for it, Josh. Sure.

So, effectively, you've got a situation where the ACCC has been tasked to develop a code that would, what they call facilitating negotiations between media companies and the digital platforms. At this stage, it only applies to Google and Facebook. But what it would do is basically force Google and Facebook to come to the table with an offer, a reasonable offer, I mean, although they don't think it's particularly reasonable, to pay for media content that appears in search results and on news feeds on Facebook. It's got some other components in there, including having to notify media companies about changes to the algorithms that might affect their business.

So, if they're going to say, we're going to deprioritise video, we're not going to show this many articles, then they have to sort of alert to that. But the main thing that everyone's going to focus on is the payment of money from digital platforms to media outlets. And that's basically how you define these media companies is basically if you have a turnover of $150,000 and the main purpose of your business is for news. So, that's basically where it's at the moment.

And as you mentioned, it's a bit of a standoff. It's currently before the parliament, but the two digital platforms are still very, very opposed to it. So, there's still a bit of a way to go. Sure.

And in recent weeks, Google has hit back pretty hard at the code, threatening to remove its search engine from Australia altogether. And this isn't the first time Google has made such drastic threats. It did so in Spain in 2014 when it removed its news service after a disagreement over payment there. So, this is a pretty big threat.

Should we take it seriously? I've been surprised a little bit, I guess, at how public their threats have been. Having warnings on every Google search you do, for example, they're targeting not just Canberra and politicians with this, but the general public and wanting to lobby Australia to get voters on side with them. I do take their threats seriously.

I think, as you mentioned, they are really serious threats to say, you know, we'll shut down search effectively in Australia and block our users from searching at all. I do take that seriously. Someone I spoke to at Google likened the situation to their stance on China, where Google's not in China, out of principle. And, you know, that's the way they put it, that they're leaving billions of dollars of advertising revenue and a large user base there, obviously, just on the table, out of principle.

And they said, well, if we do that in China, then we'd probably do the same in Australia, where it's a much smaller market and not meaningful to us compared to other markets. So, I do take it seriously, and I think that it seems to be existential for them in terms of if it did pass in Australia and it was successful, other markets and jurisdictions would likely follow suit. I think we're seeing places like Canada talking about doing a similar thing already. So, for Google, it does seem serious, and I wouldn't be surprised if they did follow through on their threats if it did pass the law here.

Yeah, I take it pretty seriously as well. I've been surprised similarly about how vocal they've been about it and the lengths that they're going to try and stop this. I think the way that the code is structured, they're kind of really back to Google into a corner here, and it's really, in other markets, like in Spain, as you mentioned, they were able to keep a search in place because, you know, they could just turn off the news service because it was only playing for snippets, whereas the way that this is structured, basically, any time a news, anything that could be news is feeding into a search result, the code would apply to them, so there's literally no way for them to get out of it. That's why they're so opposed to it.

So, I do take their threat seriously, but it's going to take a long way to go. I think the interesting thing to watch is that after their hearing where they made the threat that they were going to withdraw from Australia, they've been very, very pointed about saying that it's not a threat. I think that they realised how badly that went down within the public in general, and I think that they've slowly backtracked from that a little bit, but, you know, they could still end up pulling out because it's really hard to say this point. Yeah, and I guess there has been quite a big shock.

The international community has reacted. David, you've been reporting on how Canada is joining a pushback, revealing that it's considering laws very similar to Australia's, and even Australian super funds are being called to drop their investments in Facebook and Google if the tech giants follow through. So, yeah, there has been widespread shock. Just after that, I think, you know, with the superannuation stuff, for example, them calling on the tech giants to be dropped from ethical funds, I think what this has done, this whole process over the last couple of years, has raised really important questions about the role of these tech giants in our lives and are they, you know, quote-unquote good or evil.

Obviously, it's not black and white, but what role do we want them to play? Do we want to use them for news, for example, or should they stick to their meeting and stick to search or, in case of Facebook, you know, play stick-neck with friends? So, yeah, it's raised some really interesting questions as a minimum, whether this passes or not, just to have a conversation about what we want the tech giants to be. Yeah, well, in that same vein, I mean, Google search accounts for more than 90% of search traffic from Australian desktops and 98% from mobile users.

So what would happen if Google was to withdraw? I mean, it would basically mean that we'd have to use Bing or one of the other rivals. Immediately, people's phones would break, although I think that, in particular with Apple, they'd probably find a way to make sure people have an alternative pop-up straight away, and so it wouldn't sort of interrupt their service, but it would be incredibly disruptive. And the other thing that is really confusing for me is that Google has only said that this is limited to their search products, but so many of the other products are tied into search, so it's going to be a little bit concerning, you know, on day one, how Google Maps works and how some of the other applications work if search is no longer there.

So, you know, it is going to have a major impact if they do pull out, and it's one of those things that I don't think anyone's really particularly ready for, and I think that's why they're still paying it as the worst-case scenario, because they've put that on the table now, but, you know, who knows what's going to come out of meetings with the government that might get them to scale back a bit. And Microsoft has put its hand up in support of the code recently, offering to improve its search engine, Bing, as you mentioned, in the event that Google pulls out. How would a service like Bing compare to Google? I think, you know, it's been shown that Bing, although it's not widely used, it is up to scratch as a search engine.

There's no real market difference between using Google for search and using Bing for search. I think Bing's just been the victim of being a bit of a meme for the last few years in terms of just how unpopular it is, and Julia mentioned, obviously, the market dominance that Google has in terms of that sort of 90, 95, 98% market share. So that is a monopoly. No one's really used Bing much in Australia previously, but I think if push came to charge, I think it would hold up in terms of, at least like Josh mentioned, just the search stuff, and there would be question marks of who would fill the other gaps when it comes to Google's other products if they remove those as well.

But in a pure search perspective, I think we could trust Bing to do the job. I mean, I personally want to ask Gives to come back. I don't know if Gives is still alive and kicking, but yeah, there'll be some, even if it's not Bing, I think there'll be alternatives that would pop up. I know the Greens have been pushing for the idea of a government run.

So generally, I don't know anyone who's watched the COVIDSafe app or anything along those lines knows that government run technology is not always the best thing in the world, and particularly with something that you need to scale for, I don't know if the government could do it, but there's definitely an opening market there. Actually, I was thinking about the other. I think Atlassian would be one of the ideal ones, but they're opposed to the code, so I don't think that people are going to be doing something like that. Wow, and I guess that Bing wouldn't collect as much data as Google.

That's the main difference, right? Well, I don't know about that. I'm still pretty sure that Bing will be collecting a lot of data. In their statement that they put out to media, they said, everyone searches in groups and searches in, so they are collecting data.

If you want something more private, you just go to DuckDuckGo, which doesn't actually collect anything like that. I'd say, well, too, just like whatever happens, if this was to go through and Bing became the most popular option, it wouldn't be a monopoly in the same way that Google is now. And I think that's one of the key issues Rod Sims in the nature of this tackling is saying that for any company to have a 90 to 95% control on outside of the country, that's just not healthy for any market. So Bing might say get 50 or 60% and then others will pop up, but it wouldn't be at that same monopoly level that Google currently enjoys.

It's funny because in some developing nations, when they buy their phone, it comes with Facebook pre-installed, and for them, the internet is Facebook. And that's a little bit shocking when you think about it, but for a lot of us, Facebook and Google are sort of the gateways that are always to the rest of the internet for us, and I think that that's basically where the code is sort of going towards. They're saying most people are seeing the internet through these two websites, they do have a monopoly. As I was saying, the fact that Google put a big yellow box with its position in search results about the code kind of says that they are backing up like a monopoly.

So it's one of those things that you want technology companies to be free to do what they want to have from government regulation, but at the same time, these companies are huge. Yeah, and speaking of Facebook, it's re-rated its own stance in recent weeks saying that it would no longer allow people to post or view news content within Australia, given the code goes ahead. What would Facebook look like without news? Would Australian users even care?

Well, they said in the hearing that less than 5% of what people see on the news feed is actual news, but I don't know, I think it would just allow misinformation to thrive on Facebook. I can only see anything really bad for them. I think, you know, as I mentioned earlier, I mean, these companies have come so far from their roots in terms of, obviously, Facebook started as a website to rate women, so it's probably good that it has come a long way from that, but these companies are just so big now and so different to how they started, and I don't mind the idea of Facebook, for example, becoming a place where people, instead of trusting it for news or sharing links of fake news, it becomes a more innocent, I don't know if this is too optimistic or naive, but a place where people connect with their friends again and share photos of their food and photos of their pets, and if news wasn't allowed, maybe it would become a bit of a nicer place of genuine connection, so I don't know if that's too optimistic, but I think it's news and Facebook have never made sense to me in terms of being a good fit. I mean, you were talking about making Facebook less political as well.

I think all the problems that Facebook has had has been in dissemination of news and politics in the last few years, so that's, you know, maybe we'll go back to, you know, family connections and things like that rather than everyone just fighting on the platform all the time. But Josh, you were saying it would give life to more misinformation and disinformation on the platform, so your point is that you wouldn't have actual legitimate news media to counteract that on the platform. Yeah, so I still think their threat is a little bit less workable than Google's because the way they've described it to me is basically to say not only would Australians not be able to post links to news articles from any news site in the world, but they wouldn't be able to see what other people posted, but that seems really impressive to me because basically they have to be playing a game of whack-a-mole in terms of blocking out news websites because how do you actually figure out what is a news website and what's not, and if you're not designing, you know, links to certain websites like say Washington Timeline, which is a big misinformation website, if you're not designating that as a news website, then that's being allowed to be posted on Facebook and, you know, no one can point out a link to a debunking article because the debunking news site might be considered a news site. I think it could be really dangerous if they let that sort of stuff happen.

Okay, so if we look at small independent news companies like Junkie Media, they say that 75% of traffic to their site is driven by search and social. If Google removes its search engine and Facebook bans all news content on its platform, will publications like these essentially die? It will force, I guess, the likes of Junkie to better, I guess, just direct traffic directly to their websites, which is really tough. They've, you know, attached their brands for years onto the social media platforms and that's been, you know, basically their entire strategy because that's where millennials are and that's where the eyeballs are so it makes sense to be where their audience is and then without that option, it really leaves Junkie to say, okay, we've got to build an audience for ourselves and I guess then the onus then turns to Junkie to say, we want to make our website one that millennials will go to, you know, without social media and I don't know, we'll have to see how the behavior changes in terms of young people deciding that they're going to, you know, take it upon themselves to go to websites and not just rely on the tech platforms for news.

So, yeah, I think they will really struggle but there's always going to be appetite for news. I mean, that's a human nature and I would be optimistic that, you know, media companies will do well on their own and will be forced to craft strategies that will mean that they survive even without the tech giants. I think a company like Junkie might be okay because it's been around so long but I think Twitter made a submission to the inquiry basically saying that the code in general would probably entrench the existing dominant players both in digital platforms and in publishers and I think the threats also have the effect of potentially entrenching the dominant players in publishing because, you know, if, you know, most sites like The Guardian will probably still do okay not as great if the two sites are gone but it will be so hard for any new company starting up to be able to compete with us because they just might be able to get the eyeballs as I mentioned before but I think it's probably something that's more broadly worth discussing just because it's the same like it's the same argument that media companies have been having for years just in terms of how relied they are on Google and the social media sites to drive traffic because, you know, there was that, you know, when I was at BuzzFeed a few years ago there was, everything was about pivoting to video because Facebook was putting video prominently in the news feed and then all of a sudden within a day like Facebook switched that off and then everyone who were on video teams had to get sacked because there was no traffic going to those videos anymore so the fact that companies are still so beholden to what these companies do is something that, you know, maybe needing to cut the tether a little bit is a good thing. Clicks in general particularly from social media are pretty empty, right?

Like compared to financial support from, you know, in case of the Australian Paywall and you guys like supporters giving your money like that's far more valuable than like an engaged loyal audience is more valuable than an empty click from a Facebook link. Yeah, the problem is just getting them in the first place and I think that's the problem with newer startups as well. Yeah, it's going to be it's really unique browsers are great and that's really good what traffic is driving through but it's all about keeping people on the side and obviously getting them to subscribe that is of most value to us. Okay, so Google has said that withdrawing from Australia would only occur as a last resort, as a worst-case scenario, as Joshi was saying before.

So let's say Google ends up sticking with us. There's still quite a bit of a code to be negotiated between media companies and tech giants. One media consultant, Megan Brownlow, has said it's unlikely the mandated code would actually result in payments from the platforms, and she said instead publishers should focus on other benefits from the code, such as warnings about changes in algorithms and access to news content consumption data. Do you think it's unlikely the platforms will actually pay up in the end?

I think that the payments would, just having watched the hearings over the last couple of weeks, I'd say there's a real chance of talking about some amendments, for example, that would mandate a percentage of payments to go to directly funding newsrooms and journalists. So in the current form of legislation, the publishers could spend any payments, I guess, however they wish, but they're talking about amendments to the journalists, and others, including Rex Patrick, have said this, that maybe we set a certain percentage aside directly to our newsrooms. And from speaking to the tech giants, and basically everybody, it sounds like the payments is a real thing, and I would expect that to be one of the main benefits of this. It does sound like it's on the table, yeah.

I think the thing that, and Rod Sims from the agency has been pointing this out a lot, is that the code is really just, in terms of the negotiations, it's really just a large result. A lot of the companies, like my own company, have been in preliminary discussions with Google about News Showcase and Facebook about other things before, but all the code does is basically put a little bit of a rod on the back of the tech companies to actually come to the table and offer something decent. And I think, and we saw that in France as well, if everyone keeps talking about Google making the deal with the French publishers, they would force into that position because the independent regulator there basically said that they couldn't remove search results, like newsroom search results for companies that didn't demand a payment, so they're paying them. I don't know how much it is, it's not really quite clear, but it means that Google and Facebook will have to offer something a little bit.

I have no idea what they're offering now, but I think from what the public comments have been from the media companies, it's not been particularly generous. So this will kind of force them. The reason why Facebook and Google are so annoyed about it is that they are worried that media companies will hold them to ransom essentially and say, well, this is not really what I want. I want to go to the arbitrator through the code.

And then they don't think that what Google and Facebook offer to publishers is valued well enough in the code. That means that the arbiter will come to some sort of reasonable payment in Facebook and Google's view and they won't be able to account for that in their forecasting providers and things like that. So that's the main reason that they're really concerned about this. Yeah, so to that point, let's say the tech giants do agree to pay.

How do you put a price on journalism? I guess Rod Sims was talking about a metric whereby you evaluate the platform's value with and then without the media. And Google has run experiments in the past few weeks to test that. Yeah, how do you put a price on journalism?

I think that's just a public debate. It will be interesting to see how they come to the decision and start what it's worth. It might be audience, it might be against your own revenues, it might be against Google's revenues. It's really sort of left up to people to negotiate between themselves and then the arbiter to assess between the two parties if it gets to that.

I think it's an important point too that that was a really big win that the tech giants had following the draft code is that this final legislation has two-way value exchange, meaning that whenever the arbiter decides, it takes into account the value that the tech giants give the publishers as well. And the tech giants argue that they give more value to the publishers than the other way around. So that was one of the big sticking points originally. It just was one way originally.

It was how much is news worth to the tech giants. But the way this legislation is voted now, it takes into account both sides. And they're still unhappy with it. But that was a big win for the tech giants.

Yeah, they still think it's not getting their side enough credit. So that's what I think about. And News Corp and Nine are making quite a lot of noise about all of this. Is there a risk that they will drown out the smaller voices when it comes to working out the details, such as who gets what revenue?

I mean, it's not collective negotiation. You can make your own deals separately. Or we can all team up and do negotiations together, although I do not think that would happen. Actually, that's part of the concern that Facebook and Google have as well, because they say, although the actual thing is something like there's only a couple of hundred publishers in Australia that they have to negotiate with, they're worried that they could get into a situation where News Corp breaks up all its different outlets.

You know, Fox News might be separate from the Australian. You might have a situation where Sydney Morning Herald is negotiating, The Age is negotiating, and Channel 9 is negotiating. So they're worried about having to negotiate with too many people and having too many differing deals and stuff like that. It's less so about that.

But your point is right. The little players will still be able to negotiate. If they haven't turned over $150,000, I think they'll be able to be a part of the code. And they will have the option of teaming up as well in a group to negotiate collectively with Google and Facebook.

I think as well, obviously, this stuff is so new, and we're talking still in hypotheticals, obviously, because it hasn't been passed yet and hasn't been done anywhere else. But I think what we would see is it becomes, you know, if it was to pass, quite standardised in terms of what those agreements are. I think I'd be less concerned about there needing to be hundreds of different agreements and there being more of a standard agreement, I guess, between the companies of, you know, what a snippet is worth and what News effectively is worth. I think that would become standardised if this was to pass.

And if it was to pass, how would that set a global precedent for Google's business model in other countries? I think you'd probably see, I mean, Canada's already sort of looking down that path. I think you'd see other countries follow through. It's kind of interesting because if you think about it, the best way that the government could tackle this is through some sort of digital platform's tax.

But they've gone through the competition, I think in part because it takes it out of the hands of the government collecting taxes and giving it back. But also, it doesn't raise concerns about world trade disputes that Google could potentially launch against Australia for going down this path. Because they've done it down the competition now, it's a little bit harder for them to challenge internationally. So I think you might see a lot of other countries going down the path.

I think this is why the US government was, you know, made a submission thing quite basically saying they don't agree with it as well. Yeah, I'll just add to that. I think just having, you know, the regulators in other countries, you know, they speak very highly of what we're doing here. And, you know, I think Australia tends to, we are a small fish in a big pond globally, but not on this stuff.

This is genuinely, you know, world-first stuff and these are really new issues that we're talking about. But, you know, it's not hyperbole to say that the world is watching this. And yeah, as Josh said, we wouldn't be surprised if I was a politic. Well, that's it from us on The Fourth Estate.

Thanks to my guest, Josh Taylor, a technology reporter for The Guardian, and David Swan, technology editor at The Australian. No worries, thank you. Yeah, thanks, guys. Appreciate it.

Don't forget, you can subscribe to The Fourth Estate Podcast so you'll never miss an episode. And if you're already a subscriber, please leave us a review on your podcast app or on Facebook. See you next time.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 29 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on February 4, 2021.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.