EPISODE · Jun 5, 2025 · 18 MIN
Will Indian Cities Be Beggar-Free? Reviewing Anti-Begging Laws
from Swapnil Karkare Podcast: Economic Insights on India · host Swapnil Karkare
In a surprising move, Indore's administration has decided to fine people for giving alms to beggars. But is this the right way to tackle the problem of begging, or are we ignoring the bigger issue of poverty and homelessness? In this video, we dive deep into: - the new law in Indore and its implications; - anti-begging laws in India and abroad, including Denmark's strict rules; - the historical roots of such laws and their colonial origins; - efforts like Rajasthan’s rehabilitation model and India’s SMILE initiative; - and why criminalizing begging may not be the solution we need. Join the conversation as we explore the social, legal, and moral aspects of begging laws and discuss ways to create a better, more compassionate world for everyone. Share your thoughts in the comments! #begging #beggars #poor #poverty #indore #denmark #smile #SmileInitiative #alms #economicgrowth #compassion #humanity #humanrights #England #vagrancy #homeless #homelessness ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ⏱️ Time Stamps 00:00: Introduction; Indore's Begging Law 01:56: Begging definition of India 03:16: Background of Britain's Vagrancy Act; Colonial Hangover and Adoption of Anti-Begging Law in India 05:44: State of Denmark's Beggars 08:32: Beggar Rehabilitation - Success Story from Rajasthan & SMILE Initiative 12:44: Setting the Right Approach ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Sources and Further Reading Moving Beyond Criminalisation, ISPP - https://tinyurl.com/bdhpncxk Indore's new law, Business Standard - https://tinyurl.com/464krkt3 Anti-Begging Legistlation of India, TISS Dissertation - https://tinyurl.com/3ezdtd4b BEGGING IN INDIA: A CONSTITUTIONAL AND JUDICIAL EXAMINATION OF CRIMINALIZATION VS. REHABILITATION, ILI Law Review - https://tinyurl.com/2sk2zwjr Beggary-concept, implementation and analysis of the law : a case study of Delhi, Ipleaders - https://tinyurl.com/2p8uszk6 In Most Indian States And UTs, You Can Be Arrested For ‘Looking Poor’, IndiaSpend - https://tinyurl.com/mt385r8w SMILE - https://smile-b.dosje.gov.in/ Analysis of the SMILE scheme, IMPRI - https://tinyurl.com/3fuw9bvx Delhi's home for beggars has 70 rooms and 11 staff but no resident beggars, Your Story - https://tinyurl.com/mr3fyd94 Denmark’s tough laws on begging hit Roma women with few other options, Al Jazeera - https://tinyurl.com/xs5z2tyh ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 👉🏼 Follow Me on - LinkedIn - https://www.linkedin.com/in/swapkar Twitter - https://twitter.com/Swap_Kar Instagram - https://www.instagram.com/swap_kar/ Blog - https://econgullyblog.wordpress.com/ Support the channel - https://donate.stripe.com/3cs2aD26u4bB5UYeUUhttps://tinyurl.com/3bav4hks
What this episode covers
In a surprising move, Indore's administration has decided to fine people for giving alms to beggars. But is this the right way to tackle the problem of begging, or are we ignoring the bigger issue of poverty and homelessness? In this video, we dive deep into: - the new law in Indore and its implications; - anti-begging laws in India and abroad, including Denmark's strict rules; - the historical roots of such laws and their colonial origins; - efforts like Rajasthan’s rehabilitation model and India’s SMILE initiative; - and why criminalizing begging may not be the solution we need. Join the conversation as we explore the social, legal, and moral aspects of begging laws and discuss ways to create a better, more compassionate world for everyone. Share your thoughts in the comments! #begging #beggars #poor #poverty #indore #denmark #smile #SmileInitiative #alms #economicgrowth #compassion #humanity #humanrights #England #vagrancy #homeless #homelessness ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ⏱️ Time Stamps 00:00: Introduction; Indore's Begging Law 01:56: Begging definition of India 03:16: Background of Britain's Vagrancy Act; Colonial Hangover and Adoption of Anti-Begging Law in India 05:44: State of Denmark's Beggars 08:32: Beggar Rehabilitation - Success Story from Rajasthan & SMILE Initiative 12:44: Setting the Right Approach ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Sources and Further Reading Moving Beyond Criminalisation, ISPP - https://tinyurl.com/bdhpncxk Indore's new law, Business Standard - https://tinyurl.com/464krkt3 Anti-Begging Legistlation of India, TISS Dissertation - https://tinyurl.com/3ezdtd4b BEGGING IN INDIA: A CONSTITUTIONAL AND JUDICIAL EXAMINATION OF CRIMINALIZATION VS. REHABILITATION, ILI Law Review - https://tinyurl.com/2sk2zwjr Beggary-concept, implementation and analysis of the law : a case study of Delhi, Ipleaders - https://tinyurl.com/2p8uszk6 In Most Indian States And UTs, You Can Be Arrested For ‘Looking Poor’, IndiaSpend - https://tinyurl.com/mt385r8w SMILE - https://smile-b.dosje.gov.in/ Analysis of the SMILE scheme, IMPRI - https://tinyurl.com/3fuw9bvx Delhi's home for beggars has 70 rooms and 11 staff but no resident beggars, Your Story - https://tinyurl.com/mr3fyd94 Denmark’s tough laws on begging hit Roma women with few other options, Al Jazeera - https://tinyurl.com/xs5z2tyh ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 👉🏼 Follow Me on - LinkedIn - https://www.linkedin.com/in/swapkar Twitter - https://twitter.com/Swap_Kar Instagram - https://www.instagram.com/swap_kar/ Blog - https://econgullyblog.wordpress.com/ Support the channel - https://donate.stripe.com/3cs2aD26u4bB5UYeUUhttps://tinyurl.com/3bav4hks
NOW PLAYING
Will Indian Cities Be Beggar-Free? Reviewing Anti-Begging Laws
No transcript for this episode yet
Similar Episodes
Mar 26, 2026 ·1m
Jan 2, 2026 ·47m
Dec 21, 2025 ·46m