A safer Ontario means more police and prosecutors making sure my car doesn't get stolen. It means building new jails to keep criminals behind bars. And it means there's no need to worry when I play at the park. We're making every corner of Ontario safer to make all of Ontario safer.
That's how we protect Ontario for all of us. Learn how at Ontario.ca.ca. Pay for it by the Government of Ontario. Your summer travels deserve an upgrade.
With Select Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, and Cadillac vehicles connected by OnStar, you can stream, game, and more all the go. Whether you're headed to a music festival or a cottage getaway, you can access hundreds of apps on Google Play right from your center display. Explore OnStarTechToday at OnStar.ca and discover how to take your summer to the next level. OnStar, Better Never Stops.
You're listening to Fort The State, the show where journalists talk journalism. Coming to you from 2SCR in Sydney on Gugelands of the ER Nation, right across Australia on the Community Radio Network and directly to your device, across the globe via podcast. Welcome to the program, I'm Tina Quinn. A quick warning, this episode deals with sexual assault and violence.
If you or someone you know is impacted, call 1800-Respect on 1800-737-732, or visit 1800-Respect.org.au. Last week we brought you a discussion which dealt with the stunning allegations from a former Liberal staffer, Brittany Higgins. Brittany was just 24 in 2019 when she was left unconscious and undressed on a couch in the office of her then boss, Defence Minister Linda Reynolds, where she had been allegedly sexually assaulted. The former media advisor to Minister Reynolds went public with her story last month in broiling Canberra and Parliament House in scandal.
In the week since our last episode, more shocking revelations and allegations have abounded. Louise Milligan, the ABC's investigative journalist who had originally broken the story about the toxic work culture that exists within Canberra for women, went public with the letter she had been forwarded, which made an allegation of rape against a federal cabinet minister, relating to his time before entering Parliament. The incident had allegedly taken place in 1988, and the victim in question was now desaased. Within five days of Louise Milligan going public with the letter, and after mounting pressure for the cabinet minister accused to come forward, Attorney General Chris Tramporta addressed the media and the public, tiffly confirming he was the minister named in the letter, but strenuously refuting the allegations against him as simply not true.
However, Mr. Porter is not the only one whose alleged actions are garnering ire. The media and in particular the Canberra Press Gallery are often accused of being too cozy to the politicians who they report on. Many feel that criticism that sections of the media knew of the allegations and didn't go public with it earlier, isn't entirely without its merit.
Others however argue that this criticism is too simplistic, and overlooks many of the red tape and hurdles that journalists often have to overcome. Joining us on the show to discuss, Tory Shepherd, who spent six years in the Canberra Press Gallery for the Adelaide Advertiser, and is now a freelance journalist and writer. You can catch her every morning on ABC Adelaide. However, this week, Tory published a piece in The Guardian, which discussed her own journey with this story.
I highly recommend you read it. Tory Shepherd, welcome to Fourth Estate. Thanks for having me. Also joining us is Wendy Bacon, one of Australia's most highly acclaimed investigative journalists and feminists.
Her much-lauded work has appeared in the National Times on the Nine Networks' esteemed Sunday programme and SBS's Dateline, and that's only naming a few. For 20 years, she was the Professor of Journalism at UTS and has also previously conducted research as a feminist criminologist and into women in the media. Wendy Bacon, a warm welcome to Fourth Estate. Would you be here, Tina?
Tory, I'll start with you. This week, you wrote a piece which was published in The Guardian about the fact that the deceased woman who had accused the Attorney General of sexually assaulting her in 1988 had come forward to you with this allegation back in 2019. But you decided not to proceed with the story. Can you unpack this for us?
Yeah, look, absolutely. And can I say, going in, I'm not sure that this was the right way to proceed. It was more, you know, I was hoping to feed on insight into how journalists worked through situations like this. So I met with her in 2019.
We had done her a copy and she told me everything that had happened to her. She wanted to go public. She wanted justice, but she wasn't quite... She hadn't quite worked through how to do that.
She started talking to the police, the New South Wales Police, and South Australian Police, but in four, she hadn't fully decided to press ahead with anything. So, look, we had a general chat about how it might work, if she did decide that she wanted to put a story in the media. But having met her and talked to her, I could tell that she was still quite distressed. She talked to me a bit about her mental health issues.
And in the end, I say, look, how about you have a think about what you want to do in terms of police, in terms of formal charges. Give me a call and we'll start working it through. So I left it at that. And then I didn't hear from her.
I started thinking, do I call her? And then I was pretty worried that she would say that as pressure, which was certainly something that I didn't want to do. And it went on, and then I heard that she had died. Right.
And I'm guessing when you heard that she had passed away, does the weight of that really hit you and the weight of your own decisions? It really did. And I know that most journalists carry this stuff pretty heavily. I wrote a piece about the two I am waking for rights.
Should I have done more? Should I have done things differently? What else could I have done? That was pretty hard.
And unfortunately, this isn't relevant for my mental state. It came, unfortunately, after I had revealed someone accused of sexual abuse and that person had killed themselves. So yeah, I was thinking pretty heavily about unintended consequences. And also, it's a slightly parallel thing.
As journalists, or pre-journalists at least, I don't know how it works in other organisations, you just kind of work out your own way to do things. And you're quite often working on your own. And there isn't a set process. There isn't a set procedure.
There isn't a clear and easy way to acquire ethical journalism to very complicated situations. And a lot of things are done on instinct. Well, you write quite heart-wrenching, Lee, that I listened to the woman as she told me her story about a horrific attack by a prominent politician. And I did nothing.
Well, except agonise over it from that moment to this. You did such an excellent job of explaining the roadblocks and challenges to publishing a story like this. Do you think this happens more often than the general public are aware? These sorts of hurdles that prevent a story from being published?
Look, I really do. And it's a really fraught area trying to defend journalists to the public sometimes. I think a lot of people probably know about defamation law, but I don't know if they're aware of how much harder, even just in very recent times, it has been to get a story published because of defamation or if there are tighter and tighter budgets within the media. And that means that it's harder to, people will think harder before they engage lawyers, for example.
Sometimes it's easy to say, we just can't take the risk publishing this right now. We've seen some tremendous payouts and I won't comment on whether they were deserved or not. So that's the defamation law itself. And I guess the chilling effect, which is then exacerbated by people not having enough money to pay lawyers.
Wendy, I know you read Tori's piece in the Guardian this week. Now, your career hasn't been one that's been steep so much in Canberra politics, but is one that's been very widely acclaimed for its investigative journalism. Have you had to sit on stories before in which you felt instinctively about the veracity of the information that was being provided, but which you felt would be too difficult to prove? Yes, I certainly have.
Not as far as I can remember right now in relation to a rape allegation, but certainly in other forms of abuse of power very much so. And I actually thought, look at that I was teaching investigative journalism still, as I did for many years. I would have been going into the class this week with Tori's article and getting everyone to read it because I really felt it captured very well the complexities and the sort of multiple decisions that you make. And I've always said that it's a series of myriad of decisions, investigative journalism, and often conflicting ones and concern for victims or people that you're writing about, who've been abused in different ways.
And even look, there's many, another issue I would raise, perhaps in addition to what Tori said, is that stories like a story like this one, that is about a very powerful person and there's a very, very strong public interest in pursuing it because of the issue of you, who is being told office and that sort of thing. So at the same time, of course, I can understand what Tori's saying that she wouldn't want to go ahead if there was any doubt that it was the right thing to do from the victim's point of view. But there's another issue that comes up as well, and that is for just like ordinary people, and I could think of one particular case who suffer injustices, this enormous amount of work in bringing to light any one of those cases. And even now, since I've sort of semi-retired, what I do now is, I still do some journalism, in particular in stories that other people are less likely to be doing.
But there's one story that I had, that involved a fairly prominent person, and I have had to say to people, look, I would have to devote at least six weeks full time to go into all these documents, and I just do not have, like I'm 74 now, so I don't have the capacity to do that. But there's no one I can easily refer people to because these sort of stories require so much energy. And right now, I've been thinking, in fact, this afternoon, I will be emailing back, someone who emailed me from Perth, not a rape story, but certainly a sexual harassment story recently, and I did suggest another journalist to go to because I would have to be someone in Perth I decided. But you know, this weighs on me very heavily, and even now, when I'm coming back through my old papers, as a journalist is quite a bright thing, something that might be more substantial.
There's something that I really hate, and that is coming across letters that people have written to me, even when I was working very full time, but on many stories, and I just was not able to pursue it. So there is this really, contrary in the way, people are very critical of journalists, and I do understand why they're critical of the media. I mean, I am myself in many occasions, but I really do think most investigative journalists, people don't call themselves, they say investigative journalists, but people who really do care about bringing out the truth, it is a pretty onerous job. And of course, that sounds good, but it is tough.
I can imagine. And part of it, of course, the anxiety, like when you publish a story, and particularly what sometimes happens with powerful people, other parts of the media won't take up the story, so it loses momentum. So you can have, and I think actually, it's easy for corner story on the Canva bubble last year, raise hugely significant issues, but there was a lot of pushback on it, and they didn't get properly pursued. And so that can be very, very dispiriting as well.
I guess it's interesting to note that Australia's Me Too movement never really got into gear. So as quickly as it started, it got bogged down at least here in legal action, when you compare it to the US, it really came to a halt here. Are we seeing the ramifications now for not properly dealing with this pent up, outrage and injustice? Tori, do you?
Well, I guess you could see a bit of a sliding door moment, really. You know, what if the Me Too movement had continued to build in momentum, what further changes would we have seen? So I think we needed to start seeing a lot of those changes, long, long ago, and as Wendy said, we've had waves of feminism where you sort of think things are going to change, and then you have the next scandal and you think things are going to change then, and sometimes the ongoing failure for the momentum will change really the practice and the exhausting. So yeah, maybe if that had been kept on, you'd have to have a whole other show on why it languished a bit, would we have seen that all happen?
I just don't think that's enough time. I think it's going to take quite some time in an entrenched place, like Parliament House, to turn it around properly. Wendy? Well, I think it is a long process, and I wasn't quite as aware, as you've said, that the Me Too movement actually sort of peed it out.
I see it as a sort of rolling crisis. I sort of met more here in Australia. I feel like we never really had the proper sort of Me Too movement. Oh, no, I totally didn't have the Me Too movement.
That's what's missing, like some sort of very serious acknowledgement by powerful people. And I think it's interesting with the High Court, the fact that there was a woman, the Chief Justice of the Court, which is something that we never had before. So it is a sign of change, and she was able to acknowledge and move forward. But a question I'd like to ask is, I understand that that system for High Court complaints has not actually come into place yet, because in fact, the government somehow tied it up.
But I emailed someone yesterday, a legal academic. It's coming back to that system to be put in place, is somehow been tied into the National Integrity Bill process, which we know is another process. Hacking forever and is very contested. So we need to, and this is a game where we come back to journalism.
And so the task with, and Tory would know more about this scenario, but stretched resources in the media. And I'm constantly sort of realizing in many different spheres that the capacity there to hold, like the crisis comes and the scandal comes, but then you've got to have all the follow up and people whose job it is to make sure that what's promised is actually enacted. And I think we have a crisis in our media as well, actually, just the resources being too stretched. Well, on that as well, sorry to interrupt, Wendy, I did actually want to discuss the Canberra bubble, and particularly the culture within the Canberra Press Gallery.
And Tory, you spent six years covering federal parliament. Do you think the Canberra bubble will be able to move on so quickly this time? Is it different? I'm still not exactly clear what the bubble is.
It's kind of been turned into this derogatory term, particularly by Prime Minister Scott Morrison, to refer to the press galleries, aren't you being interested in things that the public isn't interested in? But put that to one side, I do not do everything, I know what you're asking about. There has been, and a few people have noted that this week, there has actually been a really impressive change in the press gallery, which is the number of women heading up organisations and really leading coverage, particularly leading coverage on issues like this. So you've obviously got Katherine Murphy, a little Taylor, and Samantha Made, and when I first bought there, I feel that those women were there, but it was still a bloke swelled of, you know, lots of swagging around the corridors, and when I first got everyone so confident, they'd come out of a press conference and, you know, pronounce their take on whatever happens to go, oh, look at all these venerable men, they must all be right because they've got so much confidence.
And that certainly shifted in the press gallery. There has also been a bit of a shift in terms of the partying culture. That's certainly a lot quieter than it used to be. It has been gradually getting quieter for a few years.
Incremental changes and nothing has really shifted in terms of it's mostly men in the parliament in Africa. Wendy, you didn't work in the Canberra Press Gallery, but you have a very long story career within journalism, and specifically actually with the newspapers, you worked for Two Fair Facts Papers, The National Times, which was one of the most highly acclaimed papers and milestones for confronting and independent journalism, as well as the Sun Herald. How have you seen the shift over the years in terms of media? Do you think it's still a boys club?
No, I don't think it's still a boys club. That doesn't mean I don't think boys still have quite a lot of power within it, but I think it is really encouraging and to see that, you know, women have, like I remember, actually I was down in Canberra once back in the 1980s and went to a press conference with what I thought was a very important question for Hawk, actually, when he was Prime Minister Bob Hawk. And I wasn't with the pack, and I asked the question that they didn't particularly feel they wanted me to ask, and you really could feel very frozen out. You know, I went down specifically, I got into the Fairfax Press Gallery with everybody's consent and everything, but it was, you know, you really could be very much on the outside.
So it was more the pack thing, perhaps, than the success thing that was at work there, but still in the media, and while I was at the Stone Centre for Independent Journalism University Technology, I, in those last years, I did quite a big study with students that was published in, I think it was in New England, about women in the media, and still, you know, to this day, when I've recently done some research on climate change in the media, and still women are not quite as nearly as often as men, and still, there's in many rounds in the media, there's still a domination by men. So there's just really, if you're going to have change, gender change, really, and I'm sure everybody, this is not an important, new point, but it does have to happen at every level. And I do think it is significant this week that we do have Laura Tingle, Catherine Murphy. Oh, how could I not have said Laura Tingle when I started listening to that little women in the press gallery?
Yeah, she sort of knew Moona, isn't she? Well, you've got some young ones as well who are coming up very quickly, but the thing is, I think what's really important is not to, like, if you aren't going to get a whole government's accountable, you can't have to government be able to get away with spin and narrative. And I think that's, and so setting up a particular narrative to block accountability, and that's where, you know, I think the politicization, it was always been political, but where you might have, for example, some publications, it'll be very interesting to see it the weekend. You know, Willy Australian, for example, in their columns in the weekend, trying to push back against the historians that people who want to have an independent inquiry or not.
And so, you know, the media is, there's politics of the media as well, that will help define what happens. On the other hand, people have really just say we are not, like, you know, there's also outside the media as well and what will be down there. And I see there is a protest in Canberra next week, and that will attract attention as well. We've come a long way from a minister having to step down over at Paddington Bear, the complete lack of accountability as you referenced there, Wendy.
Not just from recent weeks, but from Robodet to Sportroats. It seems to point to a bigger discussion that needs to take place. Do you think the media is doing its job here or do you think they're just fluffing the big issues? Look, I think one of the problems is the way political journalism is driven in sets by scandals.
And so you get to feeling you're moving, leaching from one big moment to another big moment. And lacking is that sort of follow through that I talked about. And I do think, and also, for example, in legal reporting, that has really fallen way down. And that is to do with the crisis in the media, and that is making it more difficult.
And I also think that, for example, I've just done a study on a big study, which was commissioned by GitHub, which I did independently with Haruun and Jagan and others. And, you know, what this is not on the topic we're talking about, but it is on climate change and how News Corp has covered climate change. And what we found there was there was a very strong bounce. We didn't do the Adelaide Avatar story, so...
I'd like to think they're an outlier. And we were not asserting that every publication or journalist is the same, but what we did find is when you look at a full year of coverage, and this confirmed earlier reports that we've done, that there is a very negative bias against action to address climate change. And there is, and it's not just people like Andrew Bolt, there is a very strong, I think it was all 10 top media commentators were all either climate-scaping or extremely negative about climate change, quite abusive at times. So that is on the biggest issue of our time.
I guess we could debate that, but it's a huge issue. There is an in-ball pushback and bias against action that runs counter to all the known sort of credible science. So that is a massive issue on confronting our media, I think. That's, you know, sorry to raise an additional big issue, but to me, stands out as a failure, a media failure, a market failure, if you like, media failure.
Tori? Yeah, it doesn't bode well, does it? When you're talking about that research. I mean, I had a strange period of optimism earlier in the pandemic when I saw Australia listening to the experts, I saw the government listening to the experts.
There was already that sort of creeping little anti-vaxxer, anti-mask stuff around, but it seemed to be fringe enough to be almost ignoreable. And then of course, the government changing its entire approach and just splashing the casharounds. So I thought, look, this shows us that change is possible and that Australians on the whole do trust the experts in the science. And I wonder whether, although the pandemic has probably, you know, pushed climate change a little bit to one side for now, once we are through this, will we keep those lessons?
But as I said, it was possibly a period of optimism. And now I'm really worried that, you know, depending on how the economic recovery goes, because we had some good figures. Now that everyone's saying, I'll go down again once the government's spending stops. And I just fear that will make people even more against action or climate change because of this false narrative, that it's just spending money for nothing in return, as opposed to, you know, spending money to see the world.
Did, um, moving on a little bit, did either of you happen to catch ABC insiders from last weekend? Tori? I did, yes. And now I feel like that was so long ago, I'm terrified of quizzing on it.
Look, there's no pop quiz. I just wanted to know what your thoughts were. About specific anything specific. Well, the panel, there was sort of criticism that the panel did seem to be the matter as the latest adventures in Canberra, so probably basically, the soap opera called Canberra.
Is the press gallery needing to take a step back and look at how the community views these matters, do you think? I absolutely say that. And then I go, it is insider. It is a show for dedicated to people inside the bubble, talking about what happened in the bubble.
I guess my name is not yet. I guess the danger is that it is very easy as a journalist to maybe compartmentalise the human factor in a lot of stories. And when you're a political journalist, a lot of the time, that's what you're doing. Quite often, when I was a political editor, there might be somebody over there who's writing the actual crime story about what happened.
This person from social issues is writing about rates of sexual assault and how it impacts people and who people can talk to and do we have enough funding for services. And then my job is the political fallout. So maybe when you're removed from that ecosystem of having people, different people at the same organisation report on things from different dimensions, it does seem a little cold. Well, I have to confess that I don't watch insiders.
And actually I did a tweet last Sunday because I saw, look, I don't watch it because I prefer to do other things on a Sunday morning, but maybe go for a walk. But I don't really like the whole concept. Insights to me stands for being close to power. And I like to see journalism as more detached and more independent than that.
But actually I also understand why people watch it. And if you're really fascinated with one particular story or what's happening, you know, people should watch it. But what I find a bit irritating is that people watch it who hates it. And so I actually did a tweet that they watched.
And they were offended. And they did feel that they were sort of very detached from the victim of this alleged rape. If the woman, obviously a really tragic story anyway. And I just said, well, look, it is about being close to power.
If you don't want to watch it, don't watch it and go and do something else. And actually, if anything really significant is said, it's going to be a news story tomorrow morning. Because often what they're doing is actually trying to break a story by someone saying something really significant that is news. So I didn't have a lot of sympathy for people who just want to slag off at it.
And I think they should just turn it off. Why is words? Good point. Finally, International Women's Day is just a few days away.
What are the conversations that we need to hear in the media on that day? What do you think, Tori? I'm fairly sure about the stories we will actually still be hearing about them, won't I? There are certain ones that come around every year.
And that's not to dismiss them. I guess it's more than it's a frustration. We'll probably have columns about whether we need gender quotas in parliament, things like that. I want to think of what I'd like to hear people talk about.
And I guess I find that too hard. Maybe I'll just say, I just hope that we don't hear Scott Morrison say that he wants women to advance as long as it doesn't disadvantage anyone else. It's odd that he thinks it's really important to listen to women, as he said recently. And in fact then, he seems to have avoided reading these very specific allegations.
So I also think that we should have, as our Prime Minister, a person, and I kind of, you know, while of course he might want to speak to Jenny about the girls, I don't think that we need a Prime Minister. The Prime Minister should be in a position of having to seek advice on something that is as fundamental and serious as this. But another story, apart from things like inequality in wages and all those systemic things that do get raised, I hope that women, you know, it is an opportunity to express anger and frustration because what else are we supposed to feel at this point? But I would also say I feel a story that did not get a lot of attention this week was the really high levels and it has been covered before, but it should not be just dismissed the really high levels of sexual abuse in aged care.
That is really frightening because what could be more power than someone who can't actually get up and walk away, fight back or anything else. And so also I think there have been reports, I think there have been in the last year with the inquiries into the treatment of people with disabilities, also sexual assaults there. So I think there's stories, and really it should be a day, I think when a whole, when really the agenda is set by women. I mean it's tokenistic to some extent have a day anyway.
But on that day it really should be given over to gender issues. Wendy, can I just add to that? So women getting right to nursing homes, people with disabilities getting raped, we heard about all the sexual assaults in schools and yet the chief of the defence force said, oh, I'm going to attract you people. How are we there?
We're not heard at this morning, I was just really appalled. I think that we underestimate because often, like if you're independent, women who are feminist, you tend to mix with people. You're not going to put up with really entrenched attitudes. There's plenty of men actually, and I know plenty of young men and my own age who have really worked on sexism, thanks to women over their lives.
And I don't find it hard to find people who aren't sexist to be with. But then I kind of hear things like that, or I watch Morrison talking to Jenny, and I just think I'm really out of touch with what is going on out there. And I think that I should probably put my head back to like the 1950s to get an understanding about how some of these men who are younger than me actually, younger than me, but how they still think and how their parents obviously inculcate these attitudes and have never shifted. On that note, I'd like to thank you both for being on Fourth Estate.
Thank you so much for having me. Thank you. And thank you for listening to Fourth Estate. This edition was recorded at the studios of Two Azir, and heard across the country on the community radio network.
Fourth Estate is produced with the assistance of the community broadcasting foundation, thanks to the foundation for their continuing support. Make sure you subscribe to Fourth Estate on your favourite podcast app so you can hear us talk media, politics and a lot in between. We'll be back with more next week. But in the meantime, you can stay in touch with us on Twitter.
And I have to listen all the time. Thank you. Many thanks to my executive producer, Anthony Doprel. My name is Tina Quinn.
Thanks for listening.