Wrong Door, Tragic Consequence: The Amber Guyger Case (victim: Botham Shem Jean)
from In time crime Hosted by Ear Balls Media
September 6, 2018 — an exhausted off-duty Dallas police officer walks into the wrong apartment and, believing an intruder is inside, fatally shoots her upstairs neighbor. This episode of In Time Crime unfolds the life of Botham Jean, the fateful missteps that led to his death, and the ripple effects that followed: a criminal conviction, a landmark law, a roadside memorial, and a family’s fight for justice. Told with intimate detail and human perspective, this narrative traces sorrow, accountability, and the haunting question of how one mistake can change so many lives. Donate to the Botham Jean Foundation: Botham Jean Foundation For all things In Time Crime and all Ear Balls media podcast join us at: Ear Balls Media Music by- Jeremy Blake Sources: Texas Fifth Court of Appeals — Guyger v. State of Texas This is one of the strongest primary sources. It contains a detailed account of the shooting, apartment numbers, Guyger's testimony, the two gunshots, her 911 call, trial arguments, conviction, and appeal. The court upheld her murder conviction. Read the appellate court opinion The Texas Tribune — Murder conviction Covers the September 2018 shooting, Botham eating ice cream in his apartment, the red doormat evidence, Guyger's defense, prosecution arguments and the October 1, 2019 guilty verdict. Amber Guyger found guilty of murder — Texas Tribune The Texas Tribune — Murder indictment Useful for the early investigation, apartment numbers 1378 and 1478, Guyger's original manslaughter arrest, her firing from the Dallas Police Department and the grand jury's decision to indict her for murder. Amber Guyger murder indictment — Texas Tribune The Texas Tribune — Guyger fired from Dallas Police Department Covers the Dallas Police Department's September 24, 2018 decision to fire Guyger following an internal-affairs review. Amber Guyger fired — Texas Tribune The Texas Tribune — Sentencing Excellent source for the punishment phase. Guyger was sentenced on October 2, 2019 to 10 years in prison after being convicted of murder the previous day. Amber Guyger sentenced to 10 years — Texas Tribune City of Dallas — Botham Jean Boulevard This is an official city-government source. The January 13, 2021 City Council agenda documents the proposal to rename South Lamar Street between Interstate 30 and South Central Expressway Botham Jean Boulevard. City of Dallas — Botham Jean Boulevard record Associated Press — $98.65 million civil verdict Covers the November 2024 federal civil trial in which a jury awarded Botham Jean's family $98.65 million in damages and found that Guyger used excessive force and violated Jean's constitutional rights. Federal civil case / Jean family attorneys — Civil verdict details Provides the breakdown and background of the $98.65 million verdict against Guyger. Botham Jean civil verdict information
Embed this episode
Chapters
- 0:08 Tragic Apartment Shooting
- 4:31 Who Was Botham John?
- 6:59 The Wrong Floor Mistake
- 14:47 Amber’s 911 Call
- 16:53 Questions After the Shooting
- 23:00 Manslaughter Becomes Murder
- 28:02 The Trial Begins
- 33:09 Murder Verdict and Sentence
- 36:23 A Brother’s Forgiveness
- 40:52 Appeals and New Twists
- 45:39 Parole Denied
- 47:11 The Civil Lawsuit
- 53:09 Honoring Botham John
- 55:55 Texas Changes the Law
- 1:01:39 Final Reflections
No transcript yet.