Skip to content
You Chose Poorly S01E12 - Ebook Readers episode artwork

Jul 21, 2016 1 hr

You Chose Poorly S01E12 - Ebook Readers

from You Chose Poorly - A Podcast about being wrong Hosted by Mikey Llorin and K Sawyer Paul

In this day and age, what’s the best way to read a book? Sawyer and Mikey try to figure out why “use an ebook reader” isn’t automatically the answer. They also talk about the ebook readers they’ve owned, and if any of them were wrong. Sony Reader PRS300 (2009) Sony Reader T1 (2011) Kobo Aura HD (2013) Kobo Aura (2014) Barnes and Noble Nook Simple Touch Kindle Paperwhite (2012) Joanna Stern's review of the $50 Blu M1 Hurry up the Cakes: I want a Kindle Paperwhite Jason Snell: Which Kindle should you buy? Craig Mod Books in the age of iPad Future reading: Digital books stagnate in closed, dull systems, while printed books are shareable, lovely and enduring. What comes next? Gerty eBook reader app (iTunes link) In this day and age, what’s the best way to read a book? Sawyer and Mikey try to figure out why “use an ebook reader” isn’t automatically the answer. They also talk about the ebook readers they’ve owned, and if any of them were wrong. Sawyer's ebook Readers: Sony Reader PRS300 (2009) Sony Reader T1 (2011) Kobo Aura HD (2013) Kobo Aura (2014) Mikey's ebook readers: Barnes and Noble Nook Simple Touch Kindle Paperwhite (2012) Show notes: Joanna Stern's review of the $50 Blu M1 Hurry up the Cakes: I want a Kindle Paperwhite Jason Snell: Which Kindle should you buy? Craig Mod Books in the age of iPad Future reading: Digital books stagnate in closed, dull systems, while printed books are shareable, lovely and enduring. What comes next? Gerty eBook reader app (iTunes link)

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

You Chose Poorly S01E12 - Ebook Readers

0:00 1:00:30
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Good morning. All right. Good morning to you. It's a little bit better.

The full full moon cursed us for a minute. All right. The phone one's been good to me. Well, that's nice.

So that's harsh to you. Well, you know, phone moons are mysterious. I don't know. I don't have a bit here.

I sympathize. It's the morning we use to do this show. Mine were during my morning, so I get it. I love the what like once you learn the word bit like once that's ingrained in you and you and you say it enough, like you can kind of get out of that situation by saying, well, I was just I was trying to do a bit.

It becomes this like little little magic escape patch out of the awkwardness. It seems a very generational thing, though. I doubt older people won't know what you're talking about. No, older people that will have unless they were like really big, like SNL viewers at the beginning or something.

Right. Right. That would be the only. I would expect them to go out.

You mean like a sketch? Yeah. Like, well, yes, that's a different thing. Kind of like a like a bit is like a it's like an aspect of a sketch.

Like it's one. It's one. Yeah. You're right.

Right. Yeah. Well, we're all in the sketch of the person. Well, now this is a bit.

See, yeah, now we're doing a bit. I'm I'm I'm going to get a new phone within the next 24 hours. Why? What the hell happened?

Nothing happened to my phone. My phone is perfectly fine, except for everything that's bad about the phone itself. You just can't analyze anymore. You need to move over to Blackberry.

Yeah, right before they get sold through SoftBank. I have to go get a blackberry. Well, I think what you always wanted was a SoftBank phone, but they didn't. Was it them?

So your dreams have finally come true. Maybe I should wait, then. Yeah. Much like I've always, you know, I've always wanted like a Fisher price phone, but they don't make phones.

So yeah, they do make phones. Phone to the stickers on them. That's David. David.

They do make that. You're right. So I'm getting a phone and I'm it's the worst time for me to get an iPhone, but it's free. So somebody in the family is getting a phone and they don't want it.

And I said I wanted it. Why do you wanted you have like a six eggs plus or whatever? Don't you know? No, I have a success.

I'm going to get the success plus. I see. There still was a run to upgrade. And it's, you know, I prefer the bigger screen, but it wouldn't be enough to upgrade except for the battery of this is just worse.

So and the battery of that is better. And I think the battery is worth the upgrade. You know, I wonder having been having been a Pokemon Go player for the last couple of days if if a battery upgrade is something that's actually not just like recommended these days, but maybe required for some things. Yeah.

You're you have an iPhone six, right? Yeah. Yeah. I would say I would say even without a game like Pokemon Go, without Pokemon Go, it's already bad enough.

It's all bad enough. It's like it's it's you know, like my lifestyle made it work because the only time it isn't plugged in is when I'm in between places. Yes. It's not like I leave it unplugged all day long.

And I have a battery packs like an external battery pack that I can plug it into on on when I'm out expeditioning or whatever. Like, you know, it's I've made it work, but I agree. It's it's pretty lousy. Yeah.

I can imagine that it would be lousy even without running constantly running an app that uses a camera and GPS and all these things. So, you know, I think I'm upgrading in preparation for Pokemon Go being official here. Yeah. So you will have now had like three iPhones in a year.

Three iPhones in three months, four months. Is this uncommon for you or is this kind of normal? Yes. Very uncommon.

It's the shortest has been a year. So this has been so before this. It's years between two years between phones and then one year in the early years when iPhones were cheaper. So this is unusual, a little exciting.

It's it's it seems silly because the fact behind it is I don't think it's nice to I'd like to be removed from the cycle this year. So this is my way of doing it. You say that. That's what I said last time.

I got this one. So so who knows, right? But yeah, I mean, six plus sevens coming out a month after it's officially the worst. If I were paying for it, this would be the worst decision.

The most you chose poorly decision I've made. But yeah, this is a terrible time to buy iPhone. Right? Unless you're like unless you're buying like an iPhone as he and you're like, no, this is just the size I want.

Yeah, right. Then you're fine. But not so. No.

All right. I'm having a baby. So I'm I'd be nice to not think about phones for a week or a month. I know it's obviously we need to check back in September to see how much you regret this decision.

If I'm even here in September, you're assuming you're assuming I'll be alive by then or able to be on the internet. Sure. I've got to yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. Well, I'll check with you. And if you're not available to cover, I'll check with you in 24 years to see if you were going to fall 2016 phone phone pics. I'm sweating the night of the wedding I can call you afterwards.

That's it. Then you'll be done. That's how parenting works. That's it.

Thanks. So this is you chose poorly. You chose poorly. I'm sorry, Paul.

It's always like you learn. How you doing? Hey, good morning. That was a warm up.

That's what you call an intro topic. And today's main topic, I think we're talking about evil readers because speaking of a horrible time to buy a product, I would say like summer 2016 is is a really is a really bad time to buy an ebook reader. Yeah, I would say so. I the ebook reader as people understand it and I can break it down into what it is.

Because I'm honestly still surprised how many people actually have no idea what the difference is between like a cheap tablet and an ebook reader. The thing that makes it lousy like right now is that it's not like you don't have a lot of choices in the market. But it's really unclear as to as to why you would buy one over another. So we can break that down.

So first let's like let's get into why I'm talking about this. Specifically I I own quite a number of evil readers in my life. I've owned four or five. Surprise.

Right. Yeah, like that I would get one and then I would upgrade. And that's what a lot of them have been. They've been like upgrade purchases.

Let me just open up our professional text file. Here we go. Yeah, I've owned four. I've owned four in my life.

And I've not owned any of these sort of brand leader. And so I got into these pretty early I'd say. And so I'll also preface by saying I think I think it's a whole category to say that you could have chose poorly and very easily. And in fact as a category itself because you will get mocked by some people for saying that you care about this kind of thing.

So it's it has in that regard. This has actually happened to you. Oh yeah, where you were mom. Yeah, because much like a portable video game system like a 3ES or a Vida or something like that where you where you decide you're going to carry around a dedicated piece of kit.

Just to do this one thing and ebook reader is just like that. Any book reader is like a 3DS but just for a different a different thing to do. And these are both things that have been like totally cannibalized by the iPhone, right? It's like a and what's what's funny about the ebook thing is like ebooks like ebook readers weren't really a thing before the iPhone whereas video like poured like the Game Boy and the DS and stuff those those existed pre-iPhone.

There was already a large dedicated fan base of people who carried video game consoles around with them. There weren't really people who had ebook readers pre 2007. I know they existed but it really didn't really didn't break open as a category until 2008-2009. And that's like North America.

I have no idea how how this shook out in the rest of the world. I know the Kindle is sold mostly worldwide. Like for instance, you guys you guys can buy a Kindle there from Amazon directly, right? Well, we we we could but no one does that because customs here are so terrible.

How does it work? How do you how do you buy a Kindle in the Philippines? Technically the gray market, but then it's it's less gray than other gray market things. But yeah, there's a whole whole subset of the market dedicated to ordering stuff from Amazon.

There's services here that you can like you partner with or you become their client so you can order from Amazon and have it shipped to them and then shipped over here. No one actually even if you can, no one actually orders from Amazon here or if they do it's it's a it's an experience and then they never do again. Things by taxes by a lot like more almost twice or thrice the amount of anything you buy. So just a professional curiosity.

Kindles are available there on the gray market. What other ebook readers like what other companies that make ebook readers? Can you buy there? You can our I was gonna say our national bookstore, but the name of the store is National Bookstore.

But the biggest the biggest bookstore chain in the country partnered with I believe it's COBO partnered with COBO. So they sell them retail. Books around this place. The ebook readers around this place.

I don't know. I don't really know how much they've you know how much they've entered the consciousness of the market here, but there was a really big push sometime last year or two years ago. And I still see them occasionally less than before, but there's still like a corner in every national bookstore dedicated to COBOs. That's fascinating.

So COBO, which is the brand of people created that I currently use, but I'm not always used. They grew out of the Indigo chain of bookstores in Canada and they were actually like book owned by them. And then they were sold off to I think it was been sold a couple of times in its history. And so it's interesting to see that it's doing similar things with other bookstores in the world where they co-brand the device to fit the bookstore.

That absolutely happened here. Yeah. Huh. Yeah.

That's interesting. That's an interesting approach they're taking. I don't know if it's working though. I don't see people walking around with COBOs.

I see a lot of people with COBOs here, but I also see a lot of people with Blackberry. So I always figured it might be just a home turf advantage kind of thing. Yeah. Right.

Like it's like taking the Toronto subway, you see a lot of COBOs. You see a lot of kiddos as well. But in no way does it seem like if you were to just walk around Toronto where you would see people reading Ebogreeters, it would seem like COBO and Kindle were like head to head competitors. And I have a feeling that's really not the case in most places in the world.

Especially the US. I would think in the US, Kindle is just number one of the bullet in there might as well not be other Ebogreeters. But the Kindle came out, what, I want to say 2007, 2008, that's kind of when it emerged as a thin. And this was after Sony started making Ebogreeters.

And the Sony reader, which is what the device was called, it was just called a reader. Which was until you get into the product device name, it was one of Sony's most elegantly named things. You think back on Sony naming schemes and you're like, well, the Walker was good. And then everything else was hot garbage naming wise.

But the reader was like, oh, that's, of course you would call it that. Of course then after that it's like they have all these device category subtitles that are very Sony. But I got it, I got into it because of those. I really, really liked the Sony readers.

I really liked their design. And so I bought my first one in 2009. I bought a, it was called a model PRS 300, which is like, why would you, why would you ever name something as supposedly simple as an Ebogreeter with like such a gadgety title? You're pigeonholing yourself by doing that, I feel.

But it was, it was an announcement. Of course they would. Of course they would, because they're something. It was an awesome little device.

It was made of aluminum. This was back when, um, Ebogreeters like when they first emerged on the market were like these really premium devices with premium materials and they would eventually get really, really inexpensive with crappy materials. But this was still back when they would like, you know, they would put their, like, most solid stuff together for these products. And it was made out of like solid aluminum.

It was like, it was, it was like a MacBook Pro of Ebogreeters. It was a gorgeous little thing. And it had so many buttons. It was like, do you remember how the original Kindle had like a full hardware keyboard on it?

Yeah, yeah, yeah. This one, this one seems really spelled by comparison to that. It only had a, it only had a couple of like menu buttons and it had a radial, like a radial button where you would go up, down, left, right. And that's how you would turn pages.

And on the right side. What does it all do? Um, flip the book over. Yeah, I don't know.

I don't remember what up did. I'm thinking, I have a feeling that up and right went back and left and down went forward. And that worked because certain ebooks, um, didn't just go left and right. Some of them did go up and down.

This was really early days. They had not had this figured out yet. Like they were still using a couple of different file formats. One of the reasons I went with the Sony reader instead of the Kindle at first, like at the very beginning when I, when I chose was that I really liked that the Sony reader was something you could just plug into your computer and just drop files onto.

And it would take, it would take everything. It would take ePobs. It would take um, PDFs. It would take Word docs.

It would, there was nothing you couldn't read really. And even Kindle mobile files? Ah, I don't know. Probably not.

Well, it was early. It was early. It was probably not. Well, the kobo can.

The kobo is now kind of in many ways, it's very much the successor to the Sony reader in that pretty much any file you drop into the kobo, it'll work. Like the kobo reads comic book reader files. Like it's, it's crazy compatible. Ah, but yeah, the Sony reader could pretty much read anything.

And I got it partially because I was really interested in this, this new future of like, wait a minute. So instead of having to like get a book deal and like sign a bunch of contracts and hope and pray that some publisher really loves you, I could just like put a book on the internet and people could download and read it on this thing. That's amazing to me. Like that's a huge paradigm shift for a writer.

And oh, I don't even need to like finish a whole book. I could just like publish a short story and they could read it on here. That's phenomenal. That's that's that's all that's all any writer has ever wanted ever.

I think it's too is to shorten that gap between their writing and someone reading it. Right. There's there's still there's still so many steps between one and the other that I saw this product category as a way to really shorten that. And I found it was incredibly easy to get to get books on to ebook stores, right?

Like getting a book into a regular bookstore is is a monumental task. But getting a book onto an ebook store. Yeah, it's still to this day. But getting a book into an ebook store is about is about a half an hour of clicking on a website.

Yeah, it's amazing. And I don't want to undercut like the technological progress that that made and that that created a whole new thing. I created a whole new industry of self published writers. And it's still I don't know how strong it is, but it's definitely still going.

And it's definitely a viable option now. And writers who are emerging today, they think, well, of course we just do it like that. Of course, we just self publish and then if it's a hit a publisher will notice us and we'll get bigger. That's how it works now.

But in 2007, 2008, it was like, wait a minute, we can do what now? Like it felt like Gutenberg, like it felt like it felt like we've been handed a machine from God. So, you know, it's so partially about an ebook reader to dick around with the self publishing stuff. It was great.

It worked wonderfully. And around 2010 is when the iPad came out and iBooks came out and iBooks was an interesting addition to this whole thing because the Apple spin on it was, hey, the Kindle's great, but this is an iPad. We're going to stop messing around now. This is the thing you should be reading on.

And that to me split the conversation. Like before the iPad came out and before iBooks came out, it was, hey, if you want to read digitally, there's these cool devices and they're really great because they're a lot better than a normal computer screen to read on because the normal computer screen is ghastly to read on. For more than like a website length of time. Like if you're, it's, you know, I definitely knew some people who did rebooks on computers, but we're talking like this is serious nerdy at this point.

Like normal people aren't doing that. But normal people did buy ebook readers. Like this was the whole time it was a thing, it was a thing built for people who were not necessarily computer nerd gadget people. It was like, this is serving, this is serving a real need people, people to use, you know.

Like this is a commuter's dream. This is a vacationers dream. Like this is a fantastic product for people who don't want to lug around giant books. Yeah.

But the iPad came out and it was like all of a sudden, oh, so I could just read books on an iPad or on my iPhone. So why do I need an ebook reader? And that conversation absolutely still happens today and probably more so. Probably the arguments against the ebook reader instead of just your iPhone.

I don't know if the ebook reader is winning that argument. Like how do you feel about that? I was going to ask if you remembered not only the, I mean Apple themselves marketed the iPad that way. Yeah.

When it started. I mean, we had dedicated a whole episode about how the iPad didn't know what it was for so long. Yeah. One of the things, yeah.

Exactly. One of the things it was was the Kindle killer. Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. And they thought, or they believed or maybe people believe that the draw of the Kindle was that it was the iPod for books. And not that it's a ink, but that the screen is the draw. Not that you can hold, not just that you can hold 100 or so books in your pocket.

And when the iPad, I remember, this is like the sequel of the episode we had. Yeah. I mentioned this in our chat preparing for this episode that we, the first and the first tech podcast you and I ever did. I can't find it anymore, by the way, but I figured out why.

But yeah, the first podcast we ever did was I was a very happy iPad owner. And but the Kindle Paperwhite was announced and I was super excited for it. Now though, so many years later, how I feel about it is, well, I can, I think I, and maybe many iPad users will agree that the Kindle is a better device for reading books. And that's hands down.

That's, it's, I don't think there's much of an argument. I think what you're, I think the, the tension is not which device is better for reading books, but all the other stuff. It's the problem with the fact that like the Kindle or, and I will defend other ebook readers as a device. Like I don't, I've always been wary of Kindle becoming the Kleenex of this product, or this product ever.

Sorry. Like, oh, it's okay. It's everybody does it. Like, oh, you either have an iPad or a Kindle, not an ebook, right?

I get it. It really, really won in terms of market dominance. But I didn't even notice I was doing it. No, no one does.

Like, like Kindle was so successful at making people think that ebook reader equals Kindle. That it's, it's, it's, it's hard for, and I do it and I've never owned one. So, they, they, they were very good at that. And also, as soon as you try to start correcting people, you sound like the worst kind of nerd.

Like you become an actually kind of person and it's like, oh, I lost, I lost already. I appreciate that you were, you, you kind of did it now without actually doing it. So I, I stand corrected kind of or not corrected here. So exactly.

I think the correction has to be there. I feel to be, to be right, but the correction itself is a bad move. If there's any, if there's any way anyone should do it, it's how you did it. So I think this is honestly awkward for explaining.

That's it. Yeah, it's like explaining to what is a Kleenex. Yeah, I get it. Exactly.

Yeah. So, so ebook readers are, are obviously the best kind of devices for reading ebook. So it's a matter of though. Like mostly of a, like mostly.

I can't, the ways in which they're not are not so much about the ebook reading experience. You know, I mean, I can, I can disagree with that. Okay. Okay.

Okay. Tell me about it. There, how is it not? There is, um, there's a writer online, uh, his name is Craig Mod, and I've been reading his thoughts on digital reading pretty much ever since there's been digital reading.

And he, I think is one of the, is one of the leaders of, of, of this category, like the kind of, like if you're going to write a think piece about, um, about reading in the digital world, like you're reading a Craig Mod essay. And one of the arguments he's made over the years is that, like digital reading is a major shift and it's a majorly important shift and it, and it democratizes reading and publishing to a fantastic degree. But one of the things that failed to do was properly shift the, like the medium of, of reading into the digital age where yes, if, if what you want to mostly be doing is looking at text, that, that cascades literally, or the cascades linearly, sorry, um, then any breeder is, is great for that. It's very good for that.

But if you want to do anything with that text, it's terrible for that. And that is where like the iPhone absolutely crushes an ebook reader, because if you have text on an iPhone, there's a lot you can do with that text. Whereas with a, with a co-worker candle, like even, you can highlight it, but it's awkward. You can leave a note for yourself, but it's awkward because you have to use a software keyboard on an eink display.

And that's never been a good experience. And even then it's stuck with you. You can't necessarily share it out. Different ebook readers have tried doing different things with this.

Like my co-bow, I can select some text and I can share it to Facebook. But all that will do is share like the first sentence of what I highlight, and then it will link to the co-bow sore. It's, I think it's a terrible implementation of something like this. The second Sony reader I owned, um, had a connection to Evernote actually.

And that was interesting. So I could select some text and hit the Evernote button. And the next time I opened up Evernote, that text would be there in a notebook. Yeah, that makes more sense.

That makes more sense. But it's still kind of siloed to you in a way. Whereas with the, with the iPhone, if you're reading on the iPhone and you select some text, you can do almost anything with that text. Yeah.

So, yeah, I think it's, I don't think that's the fault of the product though. You know, it's not, I mean, the product can only do what its technologies can offer it, you know. But conceptually the product succeeds on what it primarily is. Yeah.

I mean, but you are right. I mean, your reading experience is not only reading, you know. Reading a book is not only about reading a book. That's true.

Yeah. But I, yeah, so something like the iPad can do the other stuff better. Yeah. But just the visceral experience of, well, no, visitors are on word because that's what the iPad addresses the visceral experience of reading.

But the, I suppose, just literal reading with your eyes is what the e-books, e-book readers do better. It's a matter of, I guess, the hardware catching up to do those things better and more efficiently, or the iPad reading experience on a non-e-ink display to be significantly better than it used to be. It might be now that the iPad Pro is smaller one, but I don't actually know. Yeah.

Well, that's, so that's the argument on the other side. The, the pro iPad argument is, you know what, maybe the first iPad was not the best reading, just like, because it wasn't high res, you know, that kind of thing. And maybe, and the argument, so it's just a matter of clarity. Well, I feel like your, your modern iPads have solved that problem, right?

Like modern iPads are incredibly clear with, like, specifically with text. Like it's, it's amazing what it looks like. But that was never the argument on the e-book side of things. Like the, like the Kindle, kobot side of things where you're using an actual specific different kind of display to power this thing.

And for people who believe in that thing, it doesn't matter how high res your screen is, if it's emitting a giant amount of light at you. Yeah. Further undercut though, is that as e-book readers developed over time, they added lights. Yeah.

Well, they would argue that their lights are not, you know, facing you. But facing the game. That's, that's conceptually difficult. Yes, yes, yes, yes.

So it's like, from, from one end, like, from the iPad, and they're like, oh no, our screens are getting better and better and better each year. It's better for reading each year. But yes, it is still a giant, a giant rectangle of light hitting you in the face. And on the Kindle kobot side, it's like, well, no, our screens are purposefully designed for long-term reading because there's, because there's no light.

It's just, it's just black and gray dots that flip to show text. Like it's, it's still kind of insane that that even works. But it's, it pretty much does. And they've made their screens really crisp.

Like, like the, the, the kind of e-book readers you would buy today for 150 bucks from either of these companies, they're incredibly crisp. They have like 300 PPI, e-in displays. They're, they're awesome. But they also have lights, which makes the product confusing to the average customer, right?

Because it's like, well, both of these things have lights now. So what's the advantage of the e-ing thing? And it, and it's thinner and thinner, right? Yeah.

Yeah. But it is still there, I think. It, I think it is still there as a thing. But I totally get why e-book readers sit in drawers while people carry their iPhones everywhere all the time.

I get why that happened. Because not everybody has the mental space in their life for a second device on them. Yeah. Right.

And that's not the fault of this one. It's never automatic. No. Yeah.

It is for my mom. Oh yeah. But then, well, no, no, no. She's given up on her iPad and her Mac.

So she brings around the Kindle. So no, same thing. She just brings around the Kindle. And she refuses to just use the others anymore.

She figures she can just get by without them. But there was a time, no, no, no. You're right. It's never automatic.

I can't think of a person who automatically just brings three devices with them at all times. Or two, and one of them being an e-book reader. Right. Unless it's, unless you're an e-book reader person, you know?

You have to be an e-book reader person to do that. I remember, though, about what you said about the average consumer. I think Amazon did a very good job. Well, not a very good job, but a good enough job.

I think that it got into the mind space of people. I think starting with the paper white. Yeah. The Kindle paper white, which the previous Kindle, I think, had lights also.

Like there was a three tiers of Kindle, one keyboard, one with no lights, one with light. And but when the paper white came out, they differentiated that by saying, this is a better screen. But we also have lights that don't face out. It's not a backlight.

It's on the side that faces down to the screen, which works, which is complimentary to the ambient light around you, etc. And but it never got past a e-book reader people knowing that, you know? No. To the average consumer, it's still just a thing with lights.

Yeah, it's just a two tablets with lights now. Yeah. But you know, I think I don't know what the ecosystem for kobos are, but I think also Amazon's approach to solving the problem of of e-books being unwieldy for anything else besides reading on an e-book reader is sinking them across devices. But then, no, I mean, what I mean to say is you're on your Kindle.

There's something you want to do on it. You can highlight it, open it on your phone and open your Kindle app on your phone. It'll open exactly where you're reading on your Kindle. And then you can do all those things.

However, that also just means at some point somebody's going to go, well, I'd rather just bring my phone. Yeah. Wait, so I can do it on my phone anyway? Okay, well then forget this device.

Yeah. Yeah. I mean, exactly. Fies whatever benefits you think you get from the Kindle.

I can't speak for, well, I should check out Craig Mod, but I can't speak for many others. But for me, I remember being very excited about the Kindle, finding that getting the Kindle, using it every day for about a month. And then, you know, it's just never stuck as a habit to bring. I mean, occasionally, let's say for masters or for graduate school, I would, there'd be an assignment or a couple books I'd have to read, and I would deliberately choose the Kindle.

I might, yes, the Kindle. And, but after that, it would never be like, I'm just gonna stuff it in my bag every day and put it out when I have time. It's always just the phone in the iPad. Yeah.

And I wonder if the true-tone display of the iPad Pro 9.7 is going to, and I presumably, all the iPhones and Macs coming out later this year, would actually do anything to solve that in terms of moving, in terms of the ebook industry and ebook reading culture that Craig Mod are so interested in. If it actually succeeds in terms of the average consumer mind space as being the best device, I wondered if that's actually possible, since tablets are so established as tablets and not ebook readers exclusively. Yeah. I mean, there's been a whole sector of people that we've completely ignored this episode, and that is traditional book readers who just read on paper, who will argue that- What?

It doesn't matter what these technological dohiggies do. Paper is still the best way to read text. And they have a lot of points that have not denigrated over time. Turns out paper text is a pretty good technology that has not necessarily been wiped out by these pretty good devices.

And I think one of the reasons they haven't been wiped out, like I remember that backlash to the ebook reader, and that happened right away. Like, there was one day there were ebook readers, and the next day there were people who said they would never read that way. And those people are still adamant, and I'm a little surprised that that never really wavered as these devices got better and better, because we've had almost 10 years of year-over-year iteration and improvement on these things. And there are still many, many people who say, if I'm going to read a book, I'm reading a real book on paper.

And the mind space of that being the real book, that's still the case. People still call the paper book the real book, and the digital book is just something else. It's just this other thing that isn't as real. And the Kindle, as good as it was with MarketShare, it could still never beat that.

And the iPad's not going to beat that either, because it's just not the- It's difficult to say the $600 device is going to destroy this $15 device that you buy at a bookstore. It's a bit like crushing the bunny. You know what's emerging now, though? I think similar to comic book readers, I mean, readers like the humans or read comic books, devices that you can read comics in, but similar to those, people are now a lot of people- I find that a lot of people buy actual physical books, but never opened them.

They'd go buy the book, like they would buy a comic book, and then download the book illegally. So they keep the pristine object. Yeah, which makes much less sense to me for books than it does for comic books. But I have to confess that I did that when I couldn't find- I think it was- David Shoemaker's book.

The rest of the article? Sure. Yeah, the rest of the article. Yeah, because I found it online, but I didn't want to not give them my money.

So I bought a book, put it in the bookshelf, and never reopened it. Right. Right on my iPad. But I don't think that's a thing.

That's not- I mean, that's one move in the nerds arsenal, but that's not a thing by itself, no. If anyone would do that, it's specific fans of specific authors. Yeah, and they want their nice pretty collection. Yeah, and that's legitimate, but I wouldn't call that an industry shifter or anything.

Yeah, no. It was for the comic books, though. I mean, that's a thing that people live for comic books still do. I don't know if the Kindle does this.

I'm still not 100% certain on the feature set of the Kindle, like what it can and can't do. It's funny, I should have really bought one at some point in time, just so I could know. I do know that they've more or less- like most people I would think buy kindles now that don't have the whisper sync. Like that always on free somehow 3G connection.

I know you still can buy them, but those are the upper tier kindles now. Those are the more expensive ones, right? If you want to spend 100 bucks on Kindle, you're not getting- you're getting like a Wi-Fi only version of it. And I always say I always have to say quickly, like that was an amazing feature.

I know it's an amazing about this episode, but like the whisper sync thing where like the Kindle is just connected to some internet all the time, no matter where you are in the world. Phenomenal. And only a company is audacious as Amazon. They actually pull something like that off.

But I think most of them are Wi-Fi now. Cobos have always just been Wi-Fi. There's no whisper sync thing on the Cobo. But one of the- Sorry, go ahead.

The kindles have whisper sync. They all have whisper sync, but they just don't have 3G or 4G or something. Sorry, that's what I mean. I'm conflating them too.

One of the- I've become that guy for whisper sync, sorry. Actually, I know how it feels. One of the things that Cobo has a sort of a secret feature that- I feel like people who own Cobos don't even know about this is that if you use the read later service pocket, and like if you use it instead of Instapaper or whatever, the Cobo will sync your unread articles from pocket. So if you save an article from the New York Times and it's really, really long and you don't necessarily want to read on your computer screen, that'll sync to your pocket.

And it will only sync the text in some pictures to keep it light. So it gives you that nice clean text only view of the article, but on an e-ink screen. And I use that feature endlessly. Like that's what keeps me reading long before articles on the internet.

Actually, that's how I finish them. I don't know if I would read as many if I didn't have that feature on the Cobo. I used to when I was super excited about the Kindle and Instapaper was still owned by Marco Arment. Right.

You could be a subscriber to Instapaper? Was that the term? Not a member of a subscriber. I think I remember that.

A dollar or two a month. And you could send any article that you send to Instapaper to your Kindle. But if you're not a subscriber, what you can do is send a Kindle Digest that just collects all of your Instapaper articles and puts them in one file. And sends it to your Kindle.

Well, I used to do that with Instapaper as well. They had at- they sort of had an e-pub export. So if you had 10, 12, on read articles, you could hit the export button. And it would package you a nice pretty little e-pub file that actually read really well back on the Sony reader.

But you still have your iPad, right? Or do you not use it anyway? I don't own iPad right now. Oh, OK.

So I think I wonder how this would change for you, actually. I'm curious about this for you. I don't know how we can gauge whether or not we've chosen any of your four readers' porting. If it's not- I can tell you- If it's not- Just quickly, I'll go down the list of the ones I've owned to say whether or not.

I think they were poor choices. The Sony reader 300, I think, was maybe the best reader at the time. But yeah, it just got obliterated by the Kindle. And in 2011, I bought an upgraded version.

It was like a touchscreen Sony reader. It was called the T1. And that's the one that had the Evernote access, which was cool. And I lost it on a bus once.

So it's like- Oh. I didn't even like choose to like not own that one anymore. I just like- I left it on. It's- I just like- just plumb lost it.

And I replaced that with a COBO Aura HD, which is the device my wife still reads on. But it is not the one I owned because the one I owned like bricked and died. Like it just- it just zapped one day and it just stopped working. Which is of course one of the things that the paper book readers would say, well, well my paper book can't run out of battery or can't die.

And they're right. And this happened to me where my ebook reader just like glitched out and stopped working entirely. And then I replaced that with just a regular COBO Aura, not the HD one. It's like a little smaller guy.

It's like the size of a six inch Kindle, basically. It's very much the paper white competitor. And that's what you use now. That's what I use now.

And I use it all the time. Like I'm- a day doesn't go by when I'm not reading something on it. And you're happy with it, right? I'm happy with it.

I do worry that like one day they're just going to stop making them because- because everybody just reads on their phones. I don't even know that the iPad one, I think the iPhone one. You know? Like I think if you buy like a big enough iPhone, that's- that can just be your e-reader for the most part.

I'll tell you that the 5.5 inch iPhone, the plus is a really good e-book read. I bet. Yeah. I mean if you're fine with the light, like if that's- if you're- if you can overcome looking at the light all the time.

And especially now that they have that like- that quiet hours thing or not- not quite hours. What's it called? Night Shift. Night Shift.

Night Shift. Yeah. Now they have that. That does make the screen easier to read over time.

Yeah. It's uh- it's funny about the light thing. That- this is kind of those fault. I don't think- if you're into e-book readers already, you don't- you're already past the argument of, you know, the light hurts my eyes.

Yeah. Because at that point, when- before the paperweight came out, they already had lights. Uh, but the paperweight I think just founded on, uh, their light being different from tablet light or computer light or phone light. That, uh, for me now, whenever I think of reading an e-book, part of me thinks I should be reading this on the Kindle.

This is better for me. Yeah. But if I read literally anything else, and I spend most of the day reading everything else, yeah, I have absolutely no problem. I never think I should put this in my pocket or my insta paper, you know.

It's never a thing. So I would say, uh, Amazon the company and the marketing for the paperweight, especially, is that fault for- for the failure, I think, to just get people to understand that e-book readers are different. Yeah. Uh, in some twisted way, it's kind of backfired on them.

Well, then again, are you mostly reading inside the Kindle app on your iPhone? Yes. Well, then I think they won because that's- Yeah, they don't care. That's the move Amazon made.

It's like, so long as you're using the Amazon service, they don't really don't care what device you're using. They don't, they really don't. I can't resist, but I have to mention the video you see, uh, Joanna Stearns' review of the- the- Blue M1. Sorry.

It's $50 Android. Say that again. $50 phone. That- that's $50 because it's- it has special offers from Amazon.

Oh, good. You should check it out. It's- it's amazing to me that, you know, it's just as a- as a- as a totem for the way Amazon is, it's perfect. Oh, yeah.

Better than the- you know, more so than- I think it's what the fire phone should have been. That's a grouper set and I- No. You know, it's- It's- It's the- It's the other phone with ads on the lock screen. Yeah.

Yeah. And it's a decent phone is what Joanna Stearns' saying. Um, anyway, so the Kindle, it's- yeah, I find myself thinking that I should be reading this on the Kindle, but once I get over that, I really have no problems reading my ebooks on my iPad, on my Mac, or on my phone. Uh, and the other- And the other- The Kindle- Or the Kindle- The thing that's gonna kill it though is I'm guessing that you are not itching to buy a new Kindle anytime soon.

Occasionally when- In mine, this is the first time that they- they have a software update that- that- that's not compatible with my Kindle. Oh, okay. And, uh, yeah, it's- this is crazy. It's- the logic of this is kind of- it's just dumb, but I- this goes back to 2012 me that really wanted a Kindle.

Um, they- they updated all the apps with new fonts and new features. And, uh, this is- this is a font called the Bookerly, which combines, I think, Palatino and the default Kindle blocky one. Um, and it's good. It's decent.

It's, uh, it's easier to read on my phone and my iPad. But since my Kindle can't update to the new one, it doesn't have Bookerly. And now I'm thinking, I think I want the new Kindle, which is the dumbest logic for buying an e-book reader, because the whole point of the e-book reader is that it's not like or not your tablet or your phone. But now I find myself thinking I should update my Kindle, uh, the hardware of the Kindle, so that it matches my phone and iPad, which just makes no sense.

Well, I know it's the argument that it's- that it's an even easier to read fonts, and maybe they fix some other things and it's just generally nicer. That's a good argument to buy a new one. That it matches your iPad is maybe not the best argument. Yeah.

Um, especially since I just admitted that I have no problem reading on my iPad and my phone and not my Kindle. If you were to buy one today, would you buy the, like, the high end, like a $300 like Oasis model? Uh, no. No, absolutely not.

Does that- does that one seem like overkill to you? Uh, the price is overkill. I'd buy it if they're cheaper. Uh, basically, this is what they use it cost.

Like, like, the Sony reader and the original kit, like, like, in 2008, if you wanted to buy an e-book reader, they were $300. And then- Was yours the $100? It was. Wow.

Yeah. Um, now two and a half years later, when I bought my next Sony reader, it was like 150. Like, that's how long- that's how short it took for the market to go from $300 to like $150 readers. Um, and I think 150 is kind of the price still today.

It's kind of the price point for the average one. There's cheaper models that you can buy obviously. You can buy a Kindle for 60 bucks, I think. But like, that's the crappy.

Like, if you want the, like, the good enough model, that's 150 today still. But it's interesting that Amazon went right back to the $300 one for a new entry this time. Yeah. There was one in between the voyage, which you know, they still have it, but it now makes absolutely no sense to get it.

Sure. Something like $200. Right. Like, if you're going to go above the normal price point, like, I think you would still get the Kindle Paperweight is still like the Kindle to buy.

Yeah. Uh, it's the, yeah, exactly. Uh, Jason Snell, obviously putting the show notes, just wrote up something about which Kindle you should buy for summer 2016. There you go.

Yeah. Just listed the whole thing down. Basically, Oasis if you can afford it, but for most people that paper went and avoid the voyage. So, yeah.

Interesting. Yeah. Interesting. Yeah.

Although the one criticism of the Oasis was that it wasn't waterproof. Oh, yeah. And I think new cobos are waterproof. Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. But no, it's interesting that the only time anyone ever mentioned cobos was when they point out that the Kindle's aren't waterproof.

You know, like the new cobos are. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

But never actually about the cobos. I mean, the cobos having been waterproof for a while now never actually got any press. Barely got any press. No.

Well, no, but also it's like, and it's a dumb feature in almost every, like event, like, I'm nowhere near modern water most of the time. Like, but I went on vacation last year and I was on a beach with my ebook reader. And it kind of it would have been nice to have a waterproof book reader. None.

Like, I could have been a little bit less careful, I guess. Yeah. It's a that's that's I think the primary selling point of of ebook readers. I mean, you know, it's Steve Jobs and the iPad.

It was him on a couch, right? That's the vision. Yeah. Yeah.

All ebook reader promotion I see that sells for stores here. Just you want to beach or a lady with a bikini on a beach wearing your shades with Kindle. Yeah. And, uh, because you can't you can't see your phone in that bright of sunlight still.

Yeah. Yeah. Well, that's the thing that's that's, you know, that's a that's marked by time, you know, you know, it's only a matter of time before the phones in the tablets catch up. Are fine in sunlight.

Sure. Yeah. Yeah. So it's what do you think's going to catch up first?

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of You Chose Poorly - A Podcast about being wrong?

This episode is 1 hour and 0 minutes long.

When was this You Chose Poorly - A Podcast about being wrong episode published?

This episode was published on July 21, 2016.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this You Chose Poorly - A Podcast about being wrong episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.